Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 1 of 24 EXHIBIT 1

Transcription

1 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 1 of 24 EXHIBIT 1 DEFENDANTS OBJECTIONS TO QUESADA PLAINTIFFS TRIAL EXHIBITS-2011 CONGRESSIONAL Congress Submission Population Data Congressional Submission 6 RVP for Districts at Issue 10 Baker Botts (Hanna-Davis ) 11 Texas Legislative Council (TIL) Report: C100_2002_General_RED TLC Report: C100_2004_General_RED TLC Report: C100_2006_General_RED TLC Report: C100_2008_General_RED TLC Report: C100_2010_General_RED TLC Report: C185_2002_General_RED TLC Report: C185_2004_General_RED TLC Report: C185_2006_General_RED TLC Report: C185_2008_General_RED TLC Report: C185_2010_General_RED Floor Schedule (Hanna-Davis ) 32 Transcript: House Floor Debate 33 TLC Report: RED350_c TLC Report: RED350_c TLC Report: RED225_c General Election 61 District 9 (C185) Silhouette Map 65 District 12 (C185) Silhouette Map Page 1

2 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 2 of District 18 (C185) Silhouette Map 73 District 26 (C185) Silhouette Map 77 District 29 (C185) Silhouette Map 81 District 30 (C185) Silhouette Map 85 District 33 (C185) Silhouette Map 89 District 23 (C185) Map 96 District 23 (2003 Districts) Map 107 Plan C192 Map and Statistics 108 News Article: Jim Crow lives in the state's redistricting maps 109 News Article: Carl Leubsdorf: 'Overly activist' label applies to Texas Legislature's redistricting decision 110 News Article: Texas redistricting shows judicial activism is in the eye of the beholder 111 Trinity River Vision in Benchmark Plan (C100) 112 Trinity River Vision in Proposed Plan (C185) 113 Memorandum: Commissioner Roy Brooks to Tim Mellett, DOJ 114 Plan C205 District Statistics 115 Plan C205 Elections Dallas County (C205) Map, Black Population by VTD 117 Dallas County (C205) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 118 Dallas County (C205) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 119 Plan C205 Statewide Map 120 Census Report Dallas County, TX 121 Plan Overlap-C205 and H100, RED340 Page 2

3 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 3 of Map Overlap-C205 and H Map Overlap-C185 and H Census Map: Population Change by County, 2000 to Letter from Senator Davis to Senator Kel Seliger (May 10, 2011) 129 Official Statement from Democratic Senators regarding SB Letter from Tarrant County Commissioner Roy Brooks to Senator Kel Seliger(May11,2011) 131 Letter from Tarrant County Constable Sergio L. De Leon to Senator Kel Seliger(May12,2011) 132 Letter from Senators Judith Zaffirini, Mario Gallegos, Juan Hinojosa, Eddie Lucio, Jr. and Carlos Uresti to Senator Kel Seliger (May 13, 2011) 166 News Article: With census numbers in, the redistricting battles begin in Austin 167 News Article: Redistricting plan riles Democrats in DFW 169 News Article: Matt Angle says New District 10 Breaks Minority Bloc Into Quarters 170 News Article: Sen. Davis: I Have Been Shut Out Of Redistricting Process 171 News Article: Tarrant Democrat says Senate redistricting map targets her district 172 News Article: Sen. Davis alleges discrimination against minorities in Senate redistricting plan 173 News Article: Davis recounts humble roots in opposing redistricting plan Page 3

4 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 4 of News Article: Democrats charge Seliger delayed redistricting map to dampen outcry 175 News Article: Senate redistricting map would split Tarrant among four districts 177 News Article: Senate Redistricting Committee Grapples With Map 178 News Article: Davis says redistricting plan an insult to her constituents 179 News Article: Senate redistricting plan demands Justice Department review 180 News Article: Texas Senate redistricting map holds few changes for Houston 181 News Article: Texas Senate approves map of new voting districts 182 News Article: Texas Senate approves redistricting plan after rejecting Fort Worth amendments 183 News Article: Special session for congressional redistricting appears more likely 184 News Article: Dems Plowed Under by GOP Redistricting 185 News Article: Senate map approved over objections from Fort Worth 186 News Article: Repubs and Dems Battle Over Political Landscape Of North Texas 187 News Article: Texas Trib Live- A Preview of Texas Redistricting: Panel with Burt Solomons and Kel Seliger 188 Senate Interim Remedial Plan Hearing Transcripts- Relevance, R. 401, 402 Page 4

5 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 5 of 24 Davis v. Perry (W.D. TX) 195 Block Level Data OA (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-14) 196 Block Level Data OB (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-7) 197 Block Level Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-13) 198 C118 Hispanic Choice Comparison (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-5) 199 C125 Summary (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-11) 200 County Splitting vs Deviation (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-19) 201 CSHB 150 Benchmarks Hanna (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-6) 202 H283 ACS Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-1) 203 H283 Election Analysis (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-2) 204 H283 Hispanic Pop Profile (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-3) 205 H283 RPVA (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-4) 207 HD144 Performance (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-10) 208 Hearing Hanna (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-15) 209 House and Congressional Comments Archer (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-4) 210 Maines (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-6) 211 Nueces Hispanic Democrats (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-9) 212 Republican Performance Summaries (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-12) 213 Retrogression Analysis for H153 (Interiano Dep. Ex. Page 5

6 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 6 of ) 214 Retrogression Analysis H110 (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-2) 215 Retrogression Analysis House (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-1) 216 RPV Summaries Bruce (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-5) 217 Schedule Bruce (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-16) 218 Smith Proposal 1 (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-8) 219 Smith Proposal 2 (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-9) 220 SSVR Elections Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-14) 221 Interiano Comments on Informal Submission (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-4) 222 SSVR Elections Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-14) 223 Section 5 Objection Letters Sent by the Department of Justice Unrelated to Redistricting, Section 5 Objection Letters Sent by the Department of Justice Unrelated to Redistricting, Section 5 Objection Letters Sent by the Department of Justice Unrelated to Redistricting Prior to Crockett Commissioners Districts Dumas ISD Frio Commissioners Districts Page 6

7 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 7 of Nueces State House Districts Subdistricts Uvalde Commissioners Districts Waller Commissioner Districts Caldwell Commissioners Districts Aransas Commissioners Districts Edwards Commissioners Districts Harrison Commissioners Districts Medina Commissioners Districts Nueces Commissioners Districts Port Arthur Residency Districts Beeville City Council Districts Medina Commissioners Districts Atascosa Commissioners Districts Page 7

8 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 8 of Cochran Commissioners Districts Carnal Commissioners Districts Corpus Christi ISD Jim Wells Commissioners Districts Uvalde Commissioners Districts Lynn Constables Districts Trinity CommColl Dist Marshall ISD San Patricio Constable Districts Refugio ISD Victoria Council Districts Dallas Council Districts Houston Page 8

9 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 9 of Bailey Commissioners Districts Calhoun Commissioners Districts Castro Commissioners Districts Cochran Commissioners Districts Commissioners Districts Reconsideration Deaf Smith Commissioners Districts Del Vaile ISD Ellis Commissioners Districts Gaines Commissioners Districts Gregg Commissioners Districts Hale Commissioners Districts Lubbock ISD Monahans ISD Terrell Commissioners Districts Page 9

10 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 10 of Bailey Constable Districts Castro Commissioners Districts McCulloch Commissioners Districts Wharton Commissioners Districts Gonzales Water District Waller Commissioners Districts 276 Galveston Commissioners Districts Congressional Districts State House Districts State Senate Districts State Judicial Districts State House Districts Statewide Hospital Districts Page 10

11 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 11 of Post-Redistricting Elections State Hospital Districts State Senate Districts State House Districts 287 CD23 (Opiela-Interiano) 288 CD23 Effectiveness (Hanna-Davis) 289 CD23 Performance (Downton) 290 CD23 Rumors (Kryer ) 291 HD117 Hispanic Choice (Villareal-Interiano ) 292 HD118 Comparison (Downton-Interiano) 293 Census Reactions (Hanna) 294 CVAP (Interiano-Dyer) 295 Harris 24vs25 (Hanna-Interiano) 296 Hearings Calendar (Bruce ) 297 Hearings Calendar Rule (Bruce) 298 Hearings Calendar Update (Bruce ) 299 Hispanic Choice (Bruce) 300 House and Congressional Hearings 2001 (Bruce- Solomons) 301 House Hearings 1981 (Archer-Interiano) 302 Nueces Issues (Interiano) 303 Nueces Performance (Archer) Page 11

12 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 12 of Optimal Hispanic Republican Voting Strength (Opiela-Interiano) 305 Performance vs Pop (Hanna-Interiano) 306 Performing Districts (Hanna) 307 Redistricting History Chart 308 Redistricting History Narrative (Interiano-Davis) 309 Solomons Draft Analysis (Hanna) 310 Section 5 Determinations (Hanna-Archer, Interiano ) 311 Archer Comments on Informal Submission Hanna Comments (v1) on Informal Submission (071511) 313 Hanna Comments (v2) on Informal Submission (071511) 314 Hearing Recordings (Hanna-Davis ) 315 Legislative Council Comments (Bruce-Interiano et al ) 316 Reveal Plan (Hanna-Davis ) 317 Section 5 Fixes (Hanna-Dendav ) 318 SSVR Comparison (Hanna-Interiano, Downton )-- s 321 Benchmark and Proposed Maps 322 Downton Deposition Excerpts Section 5 deposition 323 Floor Debate, April 27, Handley Congress Report Page 12

13 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 13 of Interiano Deposition Excerpts Section 5 deposition 329 Peña Deposition Excerpts Section 5 deposition 331 RPV Analysis for District Solomons Deposition Excerpts Section 5 deposition 333 TLC State & Fed. Law 345 Maps and Data for C March 22, from Hanna to Interiano 357 April 13, from Bonnie Bruce 358 Apri1 21, from Hanna to Interiano and Downton 359 May 11, from Hanna to K Davis and cc to D. Davis 360 June 1, from Interiano (Congressional One Pager) 361 June 4, Denise Davis to Interiano 362 June 9, from Hanna to Interiano 364 RPV Analysis CD23 C100 and C185 T5 Tables 365 RPV Analysis CD23 C Population and Voter Data: RED202a 511 Population and Voter Data: RED202b 515 Section 203 Consent Decree for Ector County 516 Section 203 Consent Decree for Hale County 517 Section 203 Consent Decree for Brazos County Page 13

14 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 14 of Section 203 Consent Decree for Littlefield County 519 Section 203 Consent Decree for Galveston County 520 Section 203 Consent Decree for Earth County 521 Section 203 Consent Decree for Post County 522 Section 203 Consent Decree for Seagraves County 523 Section 203 Consent Decree for Smyer County 524 Section 203 Consent Decree for North Harris Montgomery Community College District 525 Section 203 Consent Decree for Waller County 526 Section 203 Consent Decree for Ft. Bend County 527 Dallas Exhibits 529 Results Shapes Districts 530 Urban Growth in Texas Foundation; Authentication, R. 901; ; Relevance, R. 401, Texas Population Growth Foundation; Authentication, R. 901; Page 14

15 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 15 of 24 ; Relevance, R. 401, Texas Urban Concentrations Split VTDs in C Smith, Lamar Proposal Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, Present Congressional Districts Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, C185 Dallas-FtWorth Graphics 561 C185 Dallas-FtWorth Graphics 562 C185 Harris Graphics 564 C185 Nueces and Travis Graphics 587 Population and Voter Data: RED202c 588 Population and Voter Data: RED202d 589 Current Congressional Plan (C100) Bexar Zoom 590 Current Congressional Plan (ClOO) D23Zoom 591 Current Congressional Plan (C100) Dallas Zoom 592 Current Congressional Plan (C100) Harris Zoom 598 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) Bexar Zoom 599 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) D23 Zoom 600 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) Dallas Zoom 601 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) Harris Zoom Page 15

16 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 16 of 24 SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBITS 607 4/15/11 Minutes of the Texas House Committee on Redistricting 608 4/15/11 Video of the Texas House Committee on Redistricting (excerpt) Authentication, R. 901 Foundation 609 State of Texas Informal House Submission Relevance, R. 401, Nueces House Districts, Anglo Voting Age Population Authentication, R. 901 Foundation /1/10 from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano (LP447) /6/10 from Todd Hunter to Denise Davis et 613 al. (LP449) 12/6/10 from Todd Hunter to Denise Davis et al. (LP451) /7/10 from Todd Hunter to Denise Davis et al. (LP469) /15/10 from Todd Hunter to Denise Davis et 616 al. (LP494) 12/13/10 Letter from U.S. Census Bureau to Todd Hunter (LP496) /15/10 from Gerardo Interiano to Todd 618 Hunter (LP499) 12/15/10 from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano (LP501) Page 16

17 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 17 of /15/10 from Gerardo Interiano to Todd Hunter (LP503) /19/10 from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano (LP505) /21/10 from Todd Hunter to Denise Davis et al. (LP507) 622 2/9/10 from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano 623 (LP517) 2/9/11 from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano (LP519) 624 3/22/11 from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano (LP543) 625 Exhibit 3 to 10/21/11 Todd Hunter Deposition Exhibit marked during Section 5 deposition 626 Texas Legislative Council DistrictViewer Screen Relevance, R. 401, 402 Capture 1 (H283) 627 Texas Legislative Council DistrictViewer Screen Relevance, R. 401, 402 Capture 2 (H283) 628 Texas Legislative Council DistrictViewer Screen Relevance, R. 401, 402 Capture 3 (H283) 629 Documents from January 6, 2012, Production, including Lamar Smith Maps Relevance, R. 401, Tarrant County Maps 631 Notated Tarrant County Map (LP ) Foundation 632 Letter from Rogene Calvert, et al., to Chairman Solomons (042611) Relevance, R. 401, Precinct Shifts (Brunson-Davis, Wayne ) Page 17

18 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 18 of Davis Amendment Notes (Davis-Davis ) 635 Seliger Talking Points on SD10 (DEFPRIV ) 636 Senate Amendments Talking Points (DEFPRIV ) 637 Letter from Senator Nichols to Chairman Seliger (050311) Relevance, R. 401, 402 Relevance, R. 401, 402 Relevance, R. 401, Seat Changes (Interiano-Dendav ) 641 Dallas County Commissioners Districts 642 Changes to District 23 Benchmark 643 Travis County Commissioners Districts 644 State and Federal Cases and Voting Rights Objections Relating to State Redistricting 653 RED-109 Report for H Latino District Plan Comparison: H100, H283, 655 andh292 Latino District Plan Comparison: C100, C Downton Engagement Discussion ( Hanna-Davis ) 657 Map of Key Minority Neighborhoods in Tarrant Foundation County 658 Downton Engagement Letter ( Davis- Hanna 06301) 659 RedAppl Printout: Hidalgo County Districts and Precincts Page 18

19 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 19 of Chairman Solomons' Map 662 District Viewer Screenshots: Nueces and Environs 663 District Viewer Screenshots: District 137 and Environs 664 Hidalgo County by Precincts 666 RedAppl Screenshot 669 Senate Jurisprudence Committee Hearing Transcript Senate Jurisprudence Committee Hearing Transcript list of General Elections in Travis County and Austin from Foundation 672 Legislative Timeline of Actions on Senate Bill 4 (Plan C185) 673 Dawnna Dukes' House Speech Against Senate Bill4 674 Map: Dispersion of Travis County Black Population among Congressional Districts in Plan C Map: Dispersion of Travis County Hispanic Population among Congressional Districts in Plan C Map: Combined Dispersion of Travis County Black and Hispanic Population among Congressional Districts in Plan C RedAppl Screenshot: Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex Showing V'IDs 678 RedAppl Screenshot: Combination of Black and Hispanic 679 RedAppl Screenshot: Districts 26 and 12, with Percentage Black and Hispanic Shading Page 19

20 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 20 of RedAppl Screenshot: Zoom of Districts 26 and RedAppl Screenshot: Demonstrating Moving a Precinct into District RedAppl Screenshot: Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex with Percentage Black and Hispanic Shading 684 RedAppl Screenshot: Congressional District 26 (on submission) Shaded Only by Hispanic Population 685 RedAppl Election Information list 686 RedAppl Screenshot: Political Dropdown of Republican Performance, El Paso Foundation 693 District Viewer Screenshot: Bexar County C District Viewer Screenshot: Bexar County C RED-100 Report: C District Viewer Screenshot: I35 Corridor, C Chairman Solomons' Summary Judgment Declaration 701 Chart, Change in Texas total population ( ) and supporting data 702 State's Proposed Congressional District 26 and Citizen Voting Age Population Chart, Change in Citizen Voting Age Population ( ) 706 RED-236 Report, Plan C RED-381 Report, Plan C Split Precincts CD26 in State's Adopted Plan C State's Proposed Congressional District 26 and Split VTDs Page 20

21 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 21 of House Journal, Tuesday, June 14, Corrected Population Growth Graph Foundation; Authentication, R. 901; ; Relevance, R. 401, Dallas-Tarrant Senate Districts Relevance, R. 401, Details for Congressional Districts in Dallas, Tarrant, Harris, and Travis Counties 714 Attachments to Congressman Smith's (CLP00474-CLP0478 and CLP0173) 716 Dallas and Tarrant Counties Congressional Districts 717 Nueces and Harris Counties Congressional Districts Foundation 720 Texas Urban Concentrations, 2010 Census 741 Nueces County Partisan Performance (Interiano-Archer, Hanna ) 742 Deposition of David Hanna ( ) Section 5 deposition 743 C131 South Texas Congressional Districts with SSVR 744 C185 South Texas Congressional 745 Congressional District 27 in C100 and Congressional District 34 in C Hispanic Citizen Voting Age Population as a Percentage of Total CVAP by County Page 21

22 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 22 of B Department of Justice Special Tabulation: CVAP Data 750 RED Report 206, Plan C100, 2002 General Election 751 RED Report 206, Plan C185, 2002 General Election 752 Congressional Plan Comparison, District 23 Foundation; Authentication, R. 901; ; 753 list of Racially Contested Elections ( ) Foundation; Authentication, R. 901; ; 754 Table: Retrogression Using 14 Elections Foundation; Authentication, R. 901; ; 788 Amendments (Hanna-Interiano ) 789 RED-381 Report for H283 Enacted House Plan 792 RED-100 Report for H Bexar County H100 Precincts Map 796 Bexar County H283 Precincts Map 797 Bexar County Cities Map Opiela-Interiano RED-375 Report Page 22

23 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 23 of 24 Part Two 71 Trial transcripts and transcripts of evidentiary hearings in Davis v. Perry, Civil Action No (W.D. TX) (three-judge court) 72 Collection of s in 2011 produced by Defendants during discovery in Maps of the Dallas-Fort Worth area showing racial/ethnic shading of population under Plans C100 and C185 (with neighborhoods) 74 February 28, 2014 Report of Dr. Allan J. Lichtman 75 Decision of District of Columbia three-judge court denying preclearance in State of Texas v. Holder, No (D.D.C.)(three-judge court) Section 5 opinion 76 Francisco Canseco Deposition Excerpts-2014 See Defendants objections and counterdesignations (ECF No. 1188) 77 Bonnie Bruce deposition Excerpts-2014 See Defendants objections and counterdesignations (ECF No. 1188) 78 Gerardo Interiano Deposition Excerpts-2014 See Defendants objections and counterdesignations (ECF No. 1188) 79 Ryan Downton Deposition Excerpts-2014 See Defendants objections and counterdesignations (ECF No. 1188) Page 23

24 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/01/14 Page 24 of Rep. Oliveira Deposition Excerpts-2014 See Defendants objections and counterdesignations (ECF No. 1188) 81 Rep. Anchia Deposition Excerpts-2014 See Defendants objections and counterdesignations (ECF No. 1188) 82 Rep. Solomons Deposition Excerpts-2014 See Defendants objections and counterdesignations (ECF No. 1188) Page 24