Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 1 of 41 EXHIBIT 1 DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBITS

Transcription

1 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 1 of 41 EXHIBIT 1 DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBITS 1 DX0287 6/11/11 from E. Opiela to G. Interiano re: SA and cd23 reconfigure 2 DX DX DX0304 6/2/11 from D. Hanna to D. Davis re: OK to talk to Heath? 4/22/11 from B. Bruce to R. Downton et al. re: RPVA_Summary_PH /19/10 from E. Opiela to G. Interiano re: useful metric 5 DX0306 4/14/11 from D. Hanna to G. Interiano re: performing districts 6 DX DX0337 4/21/11 from D. Hanna to G. Interiano and R. Downton re: CSHB 150 benchmarks Memo: Possible Retrogression Issues for Black and Hispanic Districts in Proposed Plan H110 8 DX0361 6/4/11 from D. Davis to G. Interiano re: CD 20 Gonzales 1

2 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 2 of 41 9 DX0364 RPV Analysis - CD 23 - C100/C185 (T5) 10 DX0365 RPV Analysis - CD 23 - C100 (T1-T8) 11 DX0642 Map: Overpopulation in benchmark CD DX0654 Chart: Comparison between benchmark plan - HB150 - H DX0655 Election Analysis - Congressional Plan Comparison; C100/C DX0701 Chart/Data: Changes in Total Population ( ) 15 DX DX0705 Map: State's Proposed Congressional District 26 and Citizen Voting Age Population Chart: Changes in Citizen Voting Age Population ( ) (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) 2

3 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 3 of DX0706 Chart: Population, Voter Turnout, and TO Analysis - C General Election (data already contained in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 18 DX0707 Chart: Split VTDs by District - C185 (RED-381) No Objection 19 DX0708 Split Precincts CD26 in State's Adopted Plan C DX0709 Map: State's Proposed Congressional District 26 and Split VTDs 21 DX0748 RED-206, Plan H100, 2002 General Election No Objection 22 DX0749 RED-206, Plan H283, 2002 General Election No Objection 23 DX0750 RED-206, Plan C100, 2002 General Election No Objection 24 DX0751 RED-206, Plan C185, 2002 General Election No Objection 25 DX0753 List of Racially-Contested Elections ( ) 26 DX0764 Map of Eagle Pass and Maverick County Split in C DX0765 RED-206, Plan H100, 2006 General Election No Objection 28 DX0766 RED-206, Plan H283, 2006 General Election No Objection 29 DX0767 RED-206, Plan C185,2006 General Election No Objection 30 DX0768 RED-206, Plan C100, 2006 General Election No Objection 31 DX0769 RED-206, Plan H100, 2004 General Election for Molina No Objection 32 DX0770 RED-206, Plan H283, 2004 General Election for Molina No Objection 33 DX0771 RED-206, Plan C100,2004 General Election for Molina No Objection 34 DX0772 RED-206, Plan C185, General Election for Molina No Objection 3

4 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 4 of DX DX DX DX DX DX DX DX DX /25/10 from L. Habib to G. Interiano re: Memo 5/2/11 from D. Davis to C. Burke et al. re; Redistricting Timeline 5/4/11 from B. Bruce to B. Solomons, et al. re Request for information 5/4/11 from J. Archer to G. Interiano, et al. re 2001 Senate Committee Hearing oh [sic] HB150 (House Redistricting) 5/4/11 from J. Archer to G. Interiano, et al. re 1981 Redistricting bill senate public hearing 5/4/11 from J. Archer to G. Interiano, et al re 1991 Tambien 5/6/11 from B. Bruce to B. Solomons re HB 150 layout 5/17/11 A. Crimmins to A. Pena et al. re: Formal Meeting Announcement 5/28/11 from R. Downton to D. Davis and G. Interiano re: election analysis 44 DX0903 5/28/11 from R. Downton to D. Davis, et al re election analysis 4

5 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 5 of DX /8/10 from G. Interiano to G. Interiano re: FW: census data 46 DX /13/10 from G. Interiano to G. Interiano re: Fw: census data 47 DX DX0913 4/3/11 from L. Kaufman to D. Davis and G. Interiano re: Fwd. 6/6/11 from D. Davis to C. Griesel et al. re: Fwd: house redistricting committee 49 DX0917 3/25/11 from A. Bryant to G. Interiano re [HD117 VTD Analysis] 50 DX DX DX DX0950 6/13/11 R. Downton to G. Interiano re: RPVA_Summary_XO AGC118 6/9/11 from D. Hanna to G. Interiano re: 6/9/11 from D. Hanna to G. Interiano re: Redistricting 4/22/11 from D. Hanna to G. Interiano re: Amendment Retrogression Analysis 54 DX /10/10 from G. Interiano to E. Opiela re: 5

6 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 6 of DX /10/10 E. Opiela to G. Interiano re: 56 DX DX0971 6/6/11 D. Hanna to G. Interiano re: congressional map 4/13/11 from B. Bruce to G. Interiano et al. re: hearing schedule 58 DX0978 4/13/11 from D. Davis to L. Padilla re: Canseco 59 DX /10/2010 from G. Interiano to E. Opiela re: 60 DX0981 2/7/11 D. Hanna to G. Interiano re: Quick Question 61 DX0591 Current Congressional Plan (C100) Dallas Zoom 62 DX0677 RedAppl Screenshot: Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex Showing VTDs 63 DX0680 Red Appl Screenshot: Zoom of Districts 26 and DX0683 RedAppl Screenshot: Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex with Percentage Black and Hispanic Shading 6

7 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 7 of DX0685 RedAppl Election Information List 66 DX0687 RedAppl Screenshot: Shading Dropdown 67 DX0697 Murray Analysis of Enacted Plans Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 68 DX0734 Supplemental Report and Direct Testimony of Rogelio Saenz Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 69 DX Congress Submission Population Data Relevance, R. 401, DX Congressional Submission Relevance, R. 401, DX0006 RPV for Districts at Issue (H100) (already included 72 DX Floor Schedule (Hanna-Davis ) 73 DX0033 TLC Report: RED350_c DX0034 TLC Report: RED350_c DX0047 TX Senate - Congressional Redistricting Video Links in Agreed Map Binder at D-1) (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 7

8 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 8 of DX DX DX DX DX0055 News Article: CONGRESSIONAL MAPS SAIL OUT OF HOUSE REDISTRICTING ON PARTY LINE VOTE News Article: HISPANIC REDISTRICTING TASK FORCE SAYS THREE OF THE NEW CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICTS SHOULD BE HISPANICOPPORTUNITY News Article: HK- IS IT APPROPRIATE FOR HOUSE REDISTRICTING TO MEET OUT OF CAMERAS SIGHT News Article: HOUSE REDISTRICTING COMMITTEE HEARS FROM UNHAPPY CONSTITUENCIES News Article: KING SEEKS TO BYPASS OBAMA DOJ WITH TEXAS REDISTRICTING PLANS 81 DX0056 News Article: SELIGER CHALLENGED ON SOURCE FOR HIS MAP 82 DX0057 News Article: SELIGER- NO SENATOR HAS YET ASKED FOR A CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT 83 DX0058 News Article: THE EYES OF TEXAS COULD BE UPON NEXT HOUSE 84 DX0059 News Article: VEASEY PROPOSES CONGRESSIONAL MAP CREATING THREE NEW MINORITY OPPORTUNITY DISTRICTS 85 DX0060 District 6 (C185) Silhouette Map 86 DX0061 District 9 (C185) Silhouette Map Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R. 802 Hearsay, R

9 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 9 of DX0062 District 9 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD 88 DX0063 District 9 (C185) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 89 DX0064 District 9 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 90 DX0065 District 12 (C185) Silhouette Map 91 DX0066 District 12 (C185) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 92 DX0067 District 12 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD 93 DX0068 District 12 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 9

10 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 10 of DX0069 District 18 (C185) Silhouette Map 95 DX DX0071 District 18 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD District 18 (C185) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 97 DX0072 District 18 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 98 DX0073 District 26 (C185) Silhouette Map 99 DX0074 District 26 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD 100 DX0075 District 26 (C185) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 10

11 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 11 of DX0076 District 23 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 102 DX0077 District 29 (C185) Silhouette Map 103 DX0078 District 29 (C185) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 104 DX0079 District 29 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD 105 DX0080 District 29 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 106 DX0081 District 30 (C185) Silhouette Map 107 DX0082 District 30 (C185) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 11

12 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 12 of DX0083 District 30 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD 109 DX0084 District 30 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 110 DX0085 District 33 (C185) Silhouette Map 111 DX0086 District 33 (C185) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD 112 DX0087 District 33 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD 113 DX0088 District 33 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 114 DX0089 District 23 (C185) Map 12

13 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 13 of DX0090 District 23 (C185) Map, Black Population by VTD 116 DX0091 District 23 (C185) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 117 DX0092 District 23 (C185) Bexar County Map, Black Population by VTD 118 DX0093 District 23 (C185) Bexar County Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 119 DX0094 District 23 (C185) El Paso County Map, Black Population by VTD 120 DX0095 District 23 (C185) El Paso County Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 121 DX0096 District 23 (C185) El Paso County Map, Hispanic Population by VTD 13

14 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 14 of DX DX DX0105 News Article: The GOP s big Texas gerrymander - The Fix The Washington Post News Article: Bad plan_ Congressional redistricting plan packs and splinters minorities to benefit GOP _ Editorial _ Chron News Article: GOP redistrict map hijacks Latino voters _ Corpus Christi Caller Times 125 DX0106 News Article: The Dallas Morning News 126 DX0108 News Article: Jim Crow lives in the state's redistricting maps 14

15 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 15 of DX DX0110 News Article: Carl Leubsdorf: Overly activist label applies to Texas Legislature s redistricting decision News Article: Texas redistricting shows judicial activism is in the eye of the beholder 129 DX0111 Trinity River Vision in Benchmark Plan (C100) 130 DX0112 Trinity River Vision in Proposed Plan (C185) 131 DX0114 Plan C205 District Statistics Relevance, R. 401, DX0115 Plan C205 Elections Relevance, R. 401, DX0116 Dallas County (C205) Map, Black Population by VTD Relevance, R. 401, DX0117 Dallas County (C205) Map, Black and Hispanic Population by VTD Relevance, R. 401, DX0118 Dallas County (C205) Map, Hispanic Population by VTD Relevance, R. 401, DX0119 Plan C205 Statewide Map Relevance, R. 401, DX0120 Census Report 138 DX0121 Plan Overlap - C205 and H100, RED340 Relevance, R. 401, DX0122 Map Overlap - C205 and H100 Relevance, R. 401, DX0123 Map Overlap C185 and H100 15

16 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 16 of DX0124 Census Map: Population Change by County, 2000 to DX0128 Letter from Senator Davis to Senator Kel Seliger (May 10, 2011) 143 DX0129 Official Statement from Democratic Senators regarding SB DX DX0166 Letter from Senators Judith Zaffirini, Mario Gallegos, Juan Hinojosa, Eddie Lucio, Jr. and Carlos Uresti to Senator Kel Seliger (May 13, 2011) News Article: With census numbers in, the redistricting battles begin in Austin 146 DX0167 News Article: Redistricting plan riles Democrats in D-FW 147 DX0168 News Article: MALDEF SAYS SELIGER FAILED TO DRAW LATINO OPPORTUNITY DISTRICT IN METROPLEX 16

17 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 17 of DX DX DX DX0172 News Article: MATT ANGLE SAYS NEW DISTRICT 10 BREAKS MINORITY BLOC INTO QUARTERS News Article: SEN. DAVIS: I HAVE BEEN SHUT OUT OF REDISTRICTING PROCESS News Article: Tarrant Democrat says Senate redistricting map targets her district News Article: Sen. Davis alleges discrimination against minorities in Senate redistricting plan 152 DX0173 News Article: Davis recounts humble roots in opposing redistricting plan 17

18 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 18 of DX DX DX DX0177 News Article: Democrats charge Seliger delayed redistricting map to dampen outcry News Article: Senate redistricting map would split Tarrant among four districts News Article: MALDEF RELEASES ALTERNATE TEXAS SENATE MAP CREATES TWO NEW LATINO MAJORITY DISTRICTS News Article: SENATOR REDISTRICTING COMMITTEE GRAPPLES WITH MAP 157 DX0178 News Article: Davis says redistricting plan an insult to her constituents 18

19 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 19 of DX DX0180 News Article: Senate redistricting plan demands Justice Department review News Article: Texas Senate redistricting map holds few changes for Houston 160 DX0181 News Article: Texas Senate approves map of new voting districts 161 DX DX0183 News Article: Texas Senate approves redistricting plan after rejecting Fort Worth amendments News Article: Special session for congressional redistricting appears more likely 19

20 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 20 of DX0184 News Article: Dems Plowed Under by GOP Redistricting 164 DX0185 News Article: Senate map approved over objections from Fort Worth 165 DX DX0187 News Article: Repubs and Dems Battle Over Political Landscape Of North Texas News Article: Texas Trib Live A Preview of Texas Redistricting: Panel with Burt Solomons and Kel Seliger 167 DX0195 Block Level Data A (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-14) 168 DX0196 Block Level Data B (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-7) 20

21 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 21 of DX0197 Block Level Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-13) 170 DX0198 C118 Hispanic Choice Comparison (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-5) 171 DX0199 C125 Summary (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-11) 172 DX0200 County Splitting vs Deviation (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-19) 173 DX0201 CSHB 150 Benchmarks Hanna (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-6) 174 DX0202 H283 ACS Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-1) 175 DX0208 Hearing Hanna (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-15) 176 DX0209 House and Congressional Comments Archer (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-4) 177 DX0210 Maines (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-6) 178 DX0211 Nueces Hispanic Democrats (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-9) 179 DX0212 Republican Performance Summaries (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-12) (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-2) 21

22 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 22 of DX0216 RPV Summaries Bruce (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-5) 181 DX0217 Schedule Bruce (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-16) 182 DX0218 Smith Proposal 1 (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-8) 183 DX0219 Smith Proposal 2 (Interiano Dep. Ex. 1-9) 184 DX0220 SSVR Elections Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-14) 185 DX0221 Interiano Comments on Informal Submission (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-4) 186 DX0222 SSVR Elections Data (Interiano Dep. Ex. 2-14) 187 DX0223 Section 5 Objection Letters Sent by the Department of Justice Unrelated to Redistricting, Relevance, R. 401, DX0224 Section 5 Objection Letters Sent by the Department of Justice Unrelated to Redistricting, Relevance, R. 401, DX0225 Section 5 Objection Letters Sent by the Department of Justice Unrelated to Redistricting Prior to 1980 Relevance, R. 401, DX Crockett Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Dumas ISD Relevance, R. 401, DX Frio Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401,

23 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 23 of DX Nueces State House Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Subdistricts Relevance, R. 401, DX Uvalde Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Waller Commissioner Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Caldwell Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Aransas Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Edwards Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Harrison Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Medina Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Nueces Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Port Arthur Residency Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Beeville City Council Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Medina Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Atascosa Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Cochran Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Comal Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Corpus Christi ISD Relevance, R. 401, DX Jim Wells Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Uvalde Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Lynn Constables Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Trinity CommColl Dist Relevance, R. 401, DX Marshall ISD Relevance, R. 401, DX San Patricio Constable Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Refugio ISD Relevance, R. 401, DX Victoria Council Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Dallas Council Districts Relevance, R. 401,

24 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 24 of DX Houston Relevance, R. 401, DX Bailey Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Calhoun Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Castro Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Cochran Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Commissioners Districts Reconsideration Relevance, R. 401, DX Deaf Smith Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Del Valle ISD Relevance, R. 401, DX Ellis Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Gaines Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Gregg Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Hale Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Lubbock ISD Relevance, R. 401, DX Monahans ISD Relevance, R. 401, DX Terrell Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Bailey Constable Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Castro Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX McCulloch Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Wharton Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Gonzales Water District Relevance, R. 401, DX Waller Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX0276 Galveston Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401,

25 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 25 of DX Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX State House Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX State Senate Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX State Judicial Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX State House Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Statewide Hospital Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Post-Redistricting Elections Relevance, R. 401, DX State Hospital Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX State Senate Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX State House Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX0289 CD23 Performance (Downton ) 252 DX0290 CD23 Rumors (Kryer ) 253 DX0294 CVAP (Interiano-Dyer ) 254 DX0300 House and Congressional Hearings 2001 (Bruce-Solomons ) 255 DX0302 Nueces Issues (Interiano ) 256 DX0303 Nueces Performance (Archer ) 25

26 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 26 of DX0305 Performance vs Pop (Hanna- Interiano ) 258 DX0307 Redistricting History Chart 259 DX DX DX0314 Redistricting History Narrative (Interiano-Davis ) Hanna Comments (v2) on Informal Submission (071511) Hearing Recordings (Hanna-Davis ) 262 DX0320 Arrington Report 263 DX0321 Benchmark and Proposed Maps Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 26

27 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 27 of DX0327 Handley Congress Report Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 265 DX0331 RPV Analysis for District 23 (data already contained in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 266 DX0333 TLC State & Fed. Law No Objection 267 DX0349 NAACP Congressional Reports 268 DX0357 Hearing Schedule - April 13, DX0359 Pre-doing committee report. No bueno - May 11, DX0360 Solomons-Seliger Congressional Map - June 1, DX0362 Starting point for objected to map -June 9, DX0515 Section 203 Consent Decree for Ector County Relevance, R. 401, DX0516 Section 203 Consent Decree for Hale County Relevance, R. 401, DX0517 Section 203 Consent Decree for Brazos County Relevance, R. 401, DX0518 Section 203 Consent Decree for Littlefield County Relevance, R. 401, DX0519 Section 203 Consent Decree for Galveston County Relevance, R. 401,

28 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 28 of DX0520 Section 203 Consent Decree for Earth County Relevance, R. 401, DX0521 Section 203 Consent Decree for Post County Relevance, R. 401, DX0522 Section 203 Consent Decree for Seagraves County Relevance, R. 401, DX0523 Section 203 Consent Decree for Smyer County Relevance, R. 401, DX0524 Section 203 Consent Decree for North Harris Montgomery Community College District Relevance, R. 401, DX0525 Section 203 Consent Decree for Waller County Relevance, R. 401, DX0526 Section 203 Consent Decree for Ft. Bend County Relevance, R. 401, DX0527 Dallas Exhibits 285 DX0529 Results Shapes Districts 286 DX0530 Urban Growth in Texas 287 DX0532 Texas Urban Concentrations DX0533 Split VTDs in C185 No Objection 289 DX Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Present Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401,

29 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 29 of DX Congressional Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX0560 C185 Dallas-Ft. Worth Graphics 296 DX0561 C185 Dallas-Ft. Worth Graphics 297 DX0562 C185 Harris Graphics 298 DX0564 C185 Nueces and Travis Graphics 299 DX0587 Population and Voter Data: RED202 (already included (C100) in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) 300 DX0588 Population and Voter Data: RED202 (already included (C185) in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 301 DX0589 Current Congressional Plan (C100) Bexar Zoom 302 DX0590 Current Congressional Plan (C100) D23Zoom 303 DX0592 Current Congressional Plan (C100) Harris Zoom 29

30 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 30 of DX0598 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) Bexar Zoom 305 DX0599 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) D23 Zoom 306 DX0600 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) Dallas Zoom 307 DX0601 Proposed Congressional Plan (C185) Harris Zoom 308 DX from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano (LP447) 309 DX from Todd Hunter to Denise Davis et al. (LP469) 310 DX from Gerardo Interiano to Todd Hunter (LP503) 311 DX0629 Documents from January 6, 2012, Production, including Lamar Smith Maps 312 DX0630 Tarrant County Maps 30

31 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 31 of DX0631 Notated Tarrant County Map (LP ) 314 DX0633 Precinct Shifts (Brunson-Davis, Wayne ) 315 DX0640 Lichtman Supplemental Report (011612) on Senate District 10 Relevance, R. 401, 402, 402; Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 316 DX0641 Dallas County Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX0643 Travis County Commissioners Districts Relevance, R. 401, DX0644 State and Federal Cases and Voting Rights Objections Relating to State Redistricting 319 DX0656 Downton Engagement Discussion ( Hanna-Davis ) 320 DX0657 Map of Key Minority Neighborhoods in Tarrant Count 321 DX0658 Downton Engagement Letter ( Davis-Hanna 06301) (initially marked 657) 322 DX0669 Senate Jurisprudence Committee Hearing Transcript Hearsay, R

32 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 32 of DX0670 Senate Jurisprudence Committee Hearing Transcript DX0671 List of General Elections in Travis County and Austin from DX0673 Dawnna Dukes' House Speech Against Senate Bill DX DX DX0676 Map: Dispersion of Travis County Black Population among Congressional Districts in Plan C185 Map: Dispersion of Travis County Hispanic Population among Congressional Districts in Plan C185 Map: Combined Dispersion of Travis County Black and Hispanic Population among Congressional Districts in Plan C DX0678 RedAppl Screenshot: Combination of Black and Hispanic 330 DX0679 RedAppl Screenshot: Districts 26 and 12, with Percentage Black and Hispanic Shading 331 DX0681 RedAppl Screenshot: Demonstrating Moving a Precinct into District 1 Hearsay, R

33 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 33 of DX0684 RedAppl Screenshot: Congressional District 26 (on submission) Shaded Only by Hispanic Population 333 DX0688 District Viewer Screenshot: C166 Relevance, R. 401, DX0689 District Viewer Screenshot: Travis County, District 25, C166 Relevance, R. 401, DX0690 C185 Congressional Statistics 336 DX0691 C166 Dukes Substitute Relevance, R. 401, DX0692 District Viewer Screenshot: Hidalgo County, District 15, C166 Relevance, R. 401, DX0693 District Viewer Screenshot: Bexar County C122 Relevance, R. 401, DX0694 District Viewer Screenshot: Bexar County C DX0695 RED-100 Report: C100 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) 341 DX0696 District Viewer Screenshot: I35 Corridor, C DX0703 Texas Election Code Section No Objection 343 DX0704 Texas Election Code Section No Objection 344 DX0711 Corrected Population Growth Graph 345 DX0713 Details for Congressional Districts in Dallas, Tarrant, Harris, and Travis Counties 33

34 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 34 of DX DX DX DX DX0719 Attachments to Congressman Smith s (CLP00474-CLP0478 and CLP0173) Expert Report of George Korbel (102111) Dallas and Tarrant Counties Congressional Districts Nueces and Harris Counties Congressional Districts Expert Report of George Korbel, State Senate Plan (101911) 351 DX0720 Texas Urban Concentrations, 2010 Census Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 34

35 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 35 of DX0722 Supplemental Report of Allan J. Lichtman 353 DX0723 Declaration of J. Morgan Kousser 354 DX0724 Expert Reports of Stephen Ansolabehere 355 DX0725 Pre-Filed Direct Testimony of Richard Engstrom (Dated October 21, 2011) 356 DX0726 Supplemental Expert Report of Richard Engstrom (Dated October 23, 2011) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 35

36 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 36 of DX0727 Curriculum Vitae of Richard Engstrom 358 DX0728 Rebuttal report of Richard Engstrom 359 DX0729 Curriculum Vita of Henry Flores 360 DX0730 Expert Report of Henry Flores and Attachments 361 DX0739 Supplemental Declaration of Theodore S. Arrington 362 DX0740 Addendum to the Expert Report of J. Morgan Kousser Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 36

37 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 37 of DX0743 C131 South Texas Congressional Districts with SSVR 364 DX0744 C185 South Texas Congressional 365 DX0745 Congressional District 27 in C100 and Congressional District 34 in C DX0746 Hispanic Citizen Voting Age Population as a Percentage of Total CVAP by County 367 DX0746 Department of Justice Special ulation: CVAP Data 368 DX0747 Rebuttal Report of Richard Engstrom, January 20, DX0752 Congressional Plan Comparison, District 23 Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 37

38 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 38 of DX0754 le: Retrogression Using 14 Elections 371 DX0786 Department of Justice Internal Memorandum of December 12, DX0794 Rebuttal Report of Lisa Handley 373 DX Opiela-Interiano DX0811 from Bonnie Bruce on Scheduling (DEFPRIV ) 375 DX0818 C100 Plan Packet 376 DX0819 C185 Plan Packet 377 DX0820 Selected State s Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 38

39 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 39 of DX0831 Expert Report and Exhibits of Dr. Flores (filed at Dkt to ) 379 DX0832 Burton Report 380 DX0835 Texas Senate Committee Hearing Excerpt DX0836 Obama Boot Image 382 DX0837 Statement of Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee DX0840 from Dendav DX0844 NAACP and Congressional Intervenors Plan Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) Opinions Not Properly Disclosed Pursuant to R. 26(a)(2) 39

40 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 40 of DX0846 from Ashlee Vinyard DX0855 Texas Population Growth by Race 387 DX0856 RED-100 Report for Plan C100 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) 388 DX0857 RED-100 Report for Plan C185 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 389 DX0858 RED-202 Report for Plan C100 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) 390 DX0859 RED-202 Report for Plan C185 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 391 DX0874 TLC Data for 2011 Redistricting No Objection 392 DX0875 RED381 for C185 (VTD Splits by District) No Objection 393 DX0877 RED101 for C185 (Pop with County Subtotals) No Objection 394 DX0880 RED106 for C100 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) 395 DX0881 RED106 for C185 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 396 DX0884 RED109 for C100 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-3) 397 DX0885 RED109 for C185 (already included in Agreed Map Binder at D-4) 398 DX0887 RED110 for C185 No Objection 399 DX0889 RED334 for C185 No Objection 400 DX1010 News Article: Texas Gains the Most in Population Since the Census Hearsay, R

41 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document Filed 08/05/13 Page 41 of DX1014 Attachments from Opposition to Summary Judgment Motion by TLBC, NAACP, and LULAC 41