FILED C28. Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 1 of 27

Transcription

1 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 1 of 27 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS SAN ANTONIO DIVISION FILED C DIS rricr COURT SHANNON PEREZ, ET.AL. v. RICK PERRY, ET.AL. CIVIL NO: SA-1 1 -CV-0360-OLG-JES-XR (CONSOLIDATED LEAD CASE) OEPUT DEFENDANTS' AMENDED COMBINED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST 2011 HOUSE & CONGRESSIONAL PLAN 2014 BENCH TRIALS ***The Court Orally admitted all exhibits offered during the trials, either in open Court or on the flash drives provided to the Court, subject to review and consideration of any objections made by the Plaintiffs.** EXH. ND DESCRIPTIUN DATE 100 Plan H100, county maps for H100, and accompanying RED reports from TLC IDENTIFIED ADMITTED! WITHDRAWN 101 Plan H195 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 102 Plan H196 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 103 Plan H197 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 104 Plan H198 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 105 Plan H199 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 106 Plan Plan H200 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 107 Plan H201 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 108 Plan H205 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 109 Plan H283, county maps under Plan H283, and accompanying RED reports from TLC 110 Plan H288 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 111 Plan H292 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 112 Plan Hi 13 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 113 Plan Hi 53 and accompanying RED reports from TLC Election Data

2 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 2 of Transcripts from Redistricting Committee Hearings held on: June 21, 2010 July 19, 2010 September 1, 2010 September 20, 2010 September 21, 2010 September22, 2010 October 21, 2010 November20, Notice, minutes and witness list for House Committee on Redistricting hearings: April 16, 2009 September 30, 2009 February 10, 2010 June 2, 2010 June 21, 2010 July 19, 2010 July20, 2010 July 21, 2010 August 19, 2010 August 16, 2010 September 20, 2010 September 21, 2010 September 22, 2010 October 18, 2010 October 20, 2010 October 27, 2010 November 17, 2010 November 20, 2010 March 1, 2011 March 15, 2011 March 24, 2011 March 25, 2011 April 1, 2011 (two hearings, no witness lists) April 7, 2011 April 15, 2011 April 17, 2011 April 19, 2011 (no witness list) May 18, 2011 (no witness list) June 2, 2011 June 9, 2011 (no witness list) 117 Notice, minutes and witness list for Senate Select Committee on Redistricting hearings: September 1,2010 September 20, 2010 October 4, 2010 October5, 2010 October 21, 2010 November4, 2010 November 20, 2010 February 16, 2011 April 27, 2011 May4, 2011 May 6, 2011 May 12, 2011 May 13, 2011 (no witness list) June 3, 2011 June 13, 2011 June 20, 2011 (no witness list) U.S. Census information for Texas U.S. Census information for Texas

3 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 3 of Plaintiffs' and Plaintiff-Intervenors' Disclosures 121 Plaintiffs' and Plaintiff-Intervenors' interrogatory responses 122 David Hanna Memo (April 6, 2011) [PX3 from Section 5 trial] 123 David Hanna Memo (April20, 2011) (PX5 from Section 5 trial] 124 March 2011 Hanna County Line Presentation [PX9 exhibit from Section 5 trial] 125 Texas Secretary of State' Office, 2008 County Race Summaries [PX33 from Section 5 trial] 126 Texas Secretary of State's Office, 2010 County Race Summaries [PX33 from Section 5 trial] 127 House Journal Excerpt - CSHB15O Floor Vote (May 7,2001) [PX49 from Section 5 trial] 128 Texas Legislative Council, State and Federal Law Governing Redistricting in Texas (August 19, 2011) EPX5O from Section 5 trial] 129 U.S. Census Bureau Press Release (February 17, 2011 )(PX51 from Section 5 trial] 130 Announcing RedAppl Update (February 21, 2011) [PX52 from Section 5 trial] 131 from D. Davis to Gerardo Interiano re Redist Issues (February 18, 2011 ) [DEFPRIV000126] 132 from Gerardo Interiano to D. Davis re Redist Issues (February 18, 2011 ) [DEFPRIV000127] 133 from Jeff Archer to Gerardo Interiano re Dallas County Map (April 24, 2011 )[DEFPRIV ] 134 from David Hanna to Jeff Archer re Dallas County Map Concur with Archer (April24, 2011) [DEFPRIV ] 135 from David Hanna to Gerardo Interiano re Harris County Discussion (March 7, 2011) [DEFPRIV000242] 136 from David Hanna to Gerardo Interiano re Nueces County (March 22, 2011) [DEFPRIV ] 137 from David Hanna to Gerardo Interiano re retrogression benchmark (April 13, 2011 ) [DEFPRIV ] 138 from David Hanna to Gerardo Interiano re performing districts (April 14, 2011) [DEFPRIV000596] 139 from Gerardo Interiano to Lisa Kaufman re County Splitting vs. Deviation (February 1, 2011) [DEFPRIV000616] 140 from Bonnie Bruce to Jeff Archer re Redistricting Workshop (February 11, 2011)fDEFPRIV000657) 141 RPVA summary information (PX65 from SectionS trial] 142 from Todd Hunter to Gerardo Interiano re RaulTorres redistricting (April 18, 2011) [LP000571] 143 May nd Legislature, Regular Session Calendar [PX67 from Section 5 trial]

4 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 4 of American Community Survey 1-Year Estimates, Sex by Age by Citizenship Status (Total and Hispanic) [PX68 from Section 5 trial] 145 Rep. Solomons Press Releases & Memoranda [PX71 from Section 5 trial] 146 Census 2010 Texas Population Data Tables [PX75 from Section 5 trial] 147 Census 2000 Texas Population Data [PX76 from Section 5 trial] 148 H283 Partisan Shading Slide of HD 41 [PX77 from Section 5 trial] 149 Bexar County Map [PX8O from Section 5 trial] 150 Dallas County Map [PX81 from Section 5 trial] 151 El Paso County Map [PX82 from Section 5 trial] 152 Harris County Map [PX83 from Section 5 trial] 153 Tarrant County Map [PX84 from Section 5 trial] 154 Travis County Map [PX85 from Section 5 trial] 155 Nueces County Districts Maps [PX88 from Section 5 trial] 156 Rate of Growth of Texas Counties Maps [PX93 from Section 5 trial] 157 TX House of Reps, Incumbents Chart (Laminate) [PX96 from Section 5 trial] 158 El Paso House Districts Map [PX12O from Section 5 trial] 159 Dukes Handwritten Notes on Travis County Map [PX122 from Section 5 trial] 160 El Paso & Tarrant Maps [PX123 from Section 5 trial] 161 Texas Legislature Online - Bill Report (1) [PX127 from Section 5 trial] 162 Texas Legislature Online - Bill Report (2) [PX128 from Section 5 trial] 163 Texas Legislature Online - Bill Search Results (3) [PX131 from Section 5 trial] 164 Texas Legislature Online - Bill Search Results (4) [PX132 from Section 5 trial] 165 Tarrant County Map (marked in Court) [PX133 from Section 5 trial] 166 SOS 2008 Democratic Party Primary Election summary for Tarrant County [PX135 from Section 5 trial] 167 Graphs - Population Deviations Minority Districts [PX159 from Section 5 trial] 168 Expert report of Dr. John Alford (March 14, 2014) 169 Table 7: Deviation in Plan H283: All Districts 170 Table 8: Drop-In Districts in Plan H283: Average Deviation from County Ideal 171 Vita of John R. Alford, Ph.D.

5 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 5 of Graph A: Deviation from State Ideal Population: All Non-Majority Anglo CVAP House District 173 Graph B: Deviation from State Ideal Population: All SSVR-Majority House Districts 174 Graph C: Deviation from State Ideal Population: All Anglo CVAP-Majority Districts 175 Graph D: Deviation from County Ideal Population: Non-Anglo Majority- CVAP Drop-In Districts 176 Graph E: Deviation from County Ideal Population: Over 50% SSVR Drop-In Districts 177 Rebuttal report of Dr. John Alford, and all documents included in the appendix to this report (April 14, 2014) 178 Table 1: Reconstituted Election Analysis for House District 90 in Plan H309 and Plan H Table 4: Voting-Age Citizenship in Selected Large Counties 180 Table showing Estimated Hispanic Citizen Voting Age Population (CVAP) for Texas counties, using Census 2000 figures 181 Table showing Estimated Hispanic Citizen Voting Age Population (CVAP) for Texas counties, using American Community Survey Special Tabulation, figures 182 Racially Polarized Voting Analysis for Plan H Racially Polarized Voting Analysis for Plan H Racially Polarized Voting Analysis for Plan H205, dated August 19, Racially Polarized Voting Analysis for Plan H292, dated August 19, District Election Analysis for Plan H District Election Analysis for Plan H District Election Analysis for Plan H District Election Analysis for Plan H House Journal or House Journal Supplements for: April 20, 2011 April 27, 2011 April 28, Senate Journal for: May 21, February 17, from David F-Ianna to Denise Davis [Theodore Arrington Depo. Ex. 7] 193 Memo from Rep. Burt R. Solomons to Members of the 82nd Texas House of Representatives re solicitation of input on redistricting bills (March 14, 2011) [Trey Martinez-Fischer Depo. Ex. 24] 194 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan H283 showing shading of Asian population (marked during deposition of Rogene Calvert) [Rogene Calvert Depo. Ex. 10]

6 Ex. 8] Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 6 of Printout from Google maps showing Alief neighborhood [Rogene Calvert Depo. Ex. 11] 196 Printout from Google maps showing Sharpstown [Rogene Calvert Depo. Ex. 12] 197 Cumulative Report- Official Harris County, Texas Joint Election November 3, 2009 [Rogene Calvert Depo. Ex. 17] 198 Cumulative Report- Official Harris County, Texas Joint Election November 5, 2013 (Rogene Calvert Depo. Ex. 18] 199 Information about population deviation per county and ideal district population based on 2000 U.S. Census [Senfronia Thompson Depo. Ex. 7] population based on 2000 U.S. Census [Senfronia Thompson Depo. Ex. 7] 200 Information about population deviation per county and ideal district population based on 2010 U.S. Census [Senfronia Thompson Depo 201 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan Hi 00 showing shading of Asian population (marked during deposition of Rep. Vo) [Hubert Vo Depo. Ex. 2] 202 Map of House Districts 77 and 78 under Plan H283, with Franklin Mountains shaded [Marisa Marquez Depo. Ex. 3] 203 Map of House Districts 77 and 78 under Plan H283, with shading for 2008 election [Jose Rodriguez Depo. Ex. 13] 204 Partisan shading map for Fort Bend County (Exhibit Deleted per doc. #1218) 205 from Gerardo Interiano to Jeff Archer and David Hanna re Nueces County (March 23, 2011) [TEX 201 1_ TEX2O1 1_ ] 206 Rep. Burt Solomons'statement upon the release of the Committee Substitute for HB 150, Press Advisory on CSHB 150, April 13, 2011 [Hubert Vo Depo. Ex. 8] 207 Declaration of Donald (ee" Margo (Jan. 10, 2012) [Marisa Marquez Depo. Ex. 4] 208 The History of Canutillo ISD, Canutillo ISD website [Joe Moody Depo. Ex. 23] 209 Map of HRC1H215 showing configuration of I-ID 78, signed by Dee Margo [Joe Pickett Depo. Ex. 11] 210 Corpus Christi Area State House Plan H100 [Abel Herrero Depo Ex. 1] 211 Corpus Christi Area State House Plan H283, House districts enacted by the 82nd legislature, 2011 [Abel Herrero Depo. Ex. 3] 212 House districts per county, 2000 [Abel Herrero Depo. Ex. 7] 213 Table consisting of county growth comparisons from 2000 to 2010 [Abel Herrero Depo. Ex. 8] 214 House districts per county, 2010 [Abel Herrero Depo. Ex. 9] 215 Plan H283 Map (Bexar Co) House Districts Enacted by 82 Legislature, 2011 [Jose Menendez Depo. Ex. 3]

7 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 7 of MALC Membership Directory [Joe Moody Depo. Ex. 3] 217 Texas Legislative Online List of House Redistricting Meetings [Joe Moody Depo. Ex. 4] 218 American Community Survey Special Tabulation Estimated Hispanic Citizen Voting Age Population [Jose Rodriguez Depo. Ex. 9] 219 Harris County House Districts Plan H100 (2011) List of Members and districts [Senfronia Thompson Depo. Ex. 6] 220 House Districts Per County actual 2000 reflecting ideal population of Texas Counties [Senfronia Thompson Depo. Ex. 7] 221 House Districts Per County actual 2010 reflecting ideal population of Texas Counties [Senfronia Thompson Depo. Ex. 8] 222 Table 2 Exhibit from Baker-Gonzales tate and Selected County Latino Population Distribution by Voting Age and Citizenship (2000 and 2010) [Chris Turner Depo. Ex. 17] 223 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan H283 showing shading of Asian population (marked during the deposition of Rep. Vo) [Hubert Vo Depo. Ex. 10] 224 Memo from Clare Dyer reflecting Incumbent Locations for Redistricting Project. Sent to Members of the Texas Senate. (January 11, 2011) [Royce West Depo. Ex. 12] 225 from Raul Torres to Rep. Todd Hunter and Connie Scott Subject Redistricting (April 18, 2011) [PX66 from Section 5 trial] 226 from Bonnie Bruce to David Hanna, et al. re Schedule (Apr.8, 2011) [DYER ] 227 from Bonnie Bruce to Denise Davis, et al. re Schedule (March 18, 2011) [TEX2O ] 228 from Bonnie Bruce to Burt Solomons re Schedule & Issues (Apr. 3,2011) [TEX_ ] 229 Signed Maps from Legislators 230 Map of Estimated Percent Hispanic CVAP by County (2000 Census) 231 Map of Estimated Percent Hispanic CVAP by County ( ACS) 232 Signed Travis County Delegation Map 233 Signed Tarrant County Delegation Map 234 Signed Harris County Delegation Map 235 from Eric Opiela to Gerardo Interiano re why (June 13,2011) [PX163 from Section 5 trial] 236 s from/to Eric Opiela, Jennifer Brown, Lamar Smith, Gerardo Interiano re okay...this has to stop (June 13, 2011) [PX164 from Section 5 trial] 237 Shapefile PENA H100 from Representative Aaron Pena' RedAppl Account 238 Shapefile PENA HiOl from Representative Aaron Pena' RedAppl Account

8 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 8 of Shapefile BEX1 H104 from Speaker Straus' RedAppi Account 240 Shapefile STRJ H240 from Speaker Straus' RedAppl Account 241 Shapefile STRJ H243 from Speaker Straus' RedAppl Account 242 Shapefile SOLO from Representative Solomons' RedAppl Account 243 Shapefile SOLO H139 from Representative Solomons' RedAppl Account 244 Shapefile HRC1 H169 from the House Redistricting Committee RedAppl Account 245 Shapefile HRC from the House Redistricting Committee RedAppi Account 246 Shapeflle HRCI H226 from the House Redistricting Committee RedAppl Account 247 Shapefile HRC1 H224 from the House Redistricting Committee RedAppi Account 248 Census 2000-Estimated HCVAP by County 249 RED 201 for Plan H RED 235 for Plan H RED 200 for Plan H s from/to Gordon Johnson, Denise Davis, Speaker Straus, Gerardo Interiano (April 20-April ) [J.M. Lozano Depo. Ex. 8] 253 Map-District 41 Anglo Shading at Block Level PLANH283, Enacted by 82nd Legislature [PX149 from Section 5 trial] 254 from Erick Erickson to Gerardo Interiano re Morning Briefing: Liars and Lies (April25, 2011) p ] 255 Side-by-Side Analysis: Texas House of Representatives Redistricting Current Map vs Proposed Plan H113 Mapprepared by The Election Group, LLC (April 13, 2011) [D ] 256 from Ryan Downton to Bryan Eppstein, Gerardo Interiano, Denise Davis re URGENT: Need Perry/McCain Comparison data (April25, 2011) [D D ] 257 Keats Norfleet, Bryan Eppstein, Draft-Press Release Former State House Rep Joe Nixon and Former Phil King State House Aid Being Dishonest About House Redistricting Map (April 26, 2011 )[D ] 258 s and attachment from/to Kim Thole and Gerardo Interiano re List (January 6, 2011) [D D ] 259 s from/to Gerardo Interiano and Gordon Johnson (April 11, 2011) [D ] 260 s from/to David Hanna, Bonnie Bruce, Gerardo Interiano, Burt Solomons, Ryan Downton, Denise Davis, Lisa Kaufman re hearing schedule (April 13, 2011) [TEX_201 1_ TEX_2011_ ] 261 from David Harina to Denise Davis re HB 150 (April17, 2011) [TEX_2011_ ]

9 Ex. 6] Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 9 of s to/from Gerardo Interiano, Eric Opiela, Clare Dyer, Sam Davenport re Census Data (December 7, 2010-December 13, 2010) [Gerardo Interiano Depo. Ex. 6 (confidential)] 263 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan H283 showing shading of Asian population 264 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan HI 00 showing shading of Asian population 265 from Rep. Michael Villarrealto Bexar County House delegation re: Bexar County redistricting (February 24, 2011) [TEX_201 1_ ] 266 Precinct map of Nueces County under Plan H Letter from Marisa Marquez, Naomi Gonzalez, Dee Margo and Joe Pickett to Hon. Orlando Garcia (February 27, 2012) [R0D ] 268 Plan H308 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 269 RedAppl account report for Rep. Dee Margo 270 RedAppl account report for House Redistricting Committee 271 RedAppl account report for Rep. Solomons 272 RedAppl account report for Rep. Pickett 07/I 9/ RedAppl account report for Rep. Garza 274 Shapefiles from Rep. Margo's RedAppl account, and maps created /10/08/2014 from these shapefiles (WITHDRAWN) 275 Shapefiles from House Redistricting Committee' RedAppl account, /10/08/2014 and maps created from these shapefiles (WITHDRAWN) 276 Shapefiles from Rep. Solomons'RedAppl account, and maps created /10/0/2014 from these shapefiles (WITHDRAWN) 277 Shapefiles from Rep. Pickett' RedAppl account, and maps created /10/08/2014 from these shapefiles (WITHDRAWN) 278 Shapefiles from Rep. Garza' RedAppl account, and maps created /10/08/2014 from these shapefiles (WITHDRAWN) 279 RED reports from TLC for shapefiles from RedAppl accounts 280 Spreadsheet showing requests to TLC from Rep. Pickett [TEX_201 1 _ ] 281 Excerpts from Senate Journal for May 17, Text of County Line Rule, Texas Const. art. III, 26 [Hubert Vo Depo 283 Letter from Rep. Ruth Jones McClendon to Rep. Trey Martinez 07/I 9/2014 Fischer, et al. re Bexar County Redistricting (Mar. 11, 2011) [TEX_201 1_ ] 284 Map of HD 117 under Plans H100 and H Texas Legislature Online, Legislative History re HB 150, 72 Legislature (marked during deposition of Gonzalo Barrientos [Gonzalo Barrientos Depo. Ex. 4]

10 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 10 of Senate Journal Excerpt NB 150 Floor Vote (May 24, 1991) [Gonzalo Barrientos Depo. Ex. 5] 287 Texas Legislature Online, Legislative History re NB 1, 72nd Legislature [Gonzalo Barrientos Depo. Ex. 6] 288 Legislative Reference Library of Texas, Legislative History re HB 960, 67th Legislature [Gonzalo Barrientos Depo. Ex. 7] 289 House Study Group bill analysis re HB 960 (May 27, 1981) [Gonzalo Barrientos Depo. Ex. 8] 290 Plan Hill and accompanying RED reports from TLC 291 Plan H112 and accompanying RED reports from TLC 292 Legislative Reference Library of Texas, 82nd Legislature, Regular Session Snapshot 293 Map of HD 77 and HD 78 under Plan H283, marked during deposition of Senator Rodriguez [Jose Rodriguez Depo. Ex. 4] 294 Map of HD 77 and HD 78 under Plan Hl00, with Franklin Mountains shaded (Jose Rodriguez Depo. Ex Map of ND 41 showing partisan shading, split VTD5 under Plan H Map of HD 41 showing Anglo shading under Plan H Shapefile PICK H120 from Representative Pickett' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative map 298 Map of ND 77 and ND 78 under plan PICK H120 showing SSVR shading 299 Map of ND 77 and ND 78 under Plan H283 showing SSVR shading 300 Shapeflle SOLO H108 from Rep. Solomon' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative maps 301 Shapefile SOLO H109 from Rep. Solomon' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative maps 302 Shapeflle SOLO Hi 10 from Rep. Solomon' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative maps 303 Shapefile MARG H104 from Rep. Mar90' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative map 304 Shapeflle PICK N113 from Rep. Pickett' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative map 305 Shapefile PICK N118 from Rep. Pickett' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative map 306 Shapefile MARG H103 from Rep. Mar90' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative map 307 Shapefile PICK HIll from Rep. Pickett' RedAppl Account, and 07/I 9/2014 demonstrative map 308 Shapefile HRC1 H267 from the House Redistricting Committee' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative map 309 Shapefile PICK H121 from Rep. Pickett' RedAppl Account, and demonstrative map 10

11 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 11 of Shapefile MARG Hi05 from Rep. Margo' RedAppi Account, and demonstrative map 311 Shapeflle PICK Hi 10 from Rep. Pickett' RedAppi Account, and demonstrative map 312 Shapefile PICK Hii4 from Rep. Pickett' RedAppl Account, and 313 RedAppl account report for Rep. Joe Straus 314 RedAppl account report for BEX1 315 Rules and Precedents of the Texas House, 82nd Legislature, Rules of the Texas Senate, 82nd Legislature, RedAppl account report for PLAN Texas Secretary of State Election Advisory no [PX152 from Section 5 trial] 319 Map of HD 105 under H283 showing VTD5 and population 320 Map of HD 77 and HD 78 under PICK H120 showing VTD5 and population 321 Map of HD 77 and RD 78 under Plan H283 showing VTDs and population 07/i 9/ RED 119 for Plan Census Bureau Guidance 324 RED 116 for Plan H RedAppl account report for David Hanna 326 DOJ Objection Letter Nov. 16, David Hanna memo for Plan HliO 328 from Hanna to Downton and Interiano re: House Committee substitute benchmarks (April 21, 2011) 07/i 9/ from David Hanna to Jennifer Welch re: calendar rule 07/i 9/ from David Hanna to Denise Davis re: need input (April 13, 2011) LTEX_20i 1_ ] 331 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan H100 showing shading of other population 332 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan H100 showing shading of other population 333 Map of a portion of Harris County under Plan H283 showing shading of other population 07/i 9/ Map of HD 40 showing partisan shading, split VTD's under Plan Hi53 07/i 9/ Map of HD 41 showing partisan shading, split VTDs under Plan Hii3 336 Map of HD 105 under H283 showing partisan shading 337 Map of RD 105 under H283 with total population 338 Map of HD 104 under H283 with partisan shading 07/i 9/

12 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 12 of Map of HD 104 under H283 with total population 340 Map of HD 54 under Plan H Map of HD 54 under Plan H Friends of Texas Public Schools press release 343 Map of Hidalgo County under HRC1 H287 and Plan H Map of Hidalgo County under HRC1 H287 and Plan H Map of HD 77 and HD 78 under HRC1 H RED report for HCRI H RED report for SOLO H RED report for HRC1 H Map of HRC1 H RED reportfor HRCI H Map of El Paso County under HRC1 H265 08/18/ RED il9forhrcl H265 08/18/ Exhibit number not used 365 Transcript of April 15, 2011 House Redistricting Committee hearing 08/18/ Map of El Paso County under HRC1 H258 08/18/ RED ii9forhrci H258 08/18/ Map of El Paso County under Plan Hi 10 08/18/ REDli9forPlanHliO 08/18/ from Elizabeth Coburn to Gerardo lnteriano (April 11,2011) [TEX_201i_ ] 08/i 8/ RedAppl account report for Rep. Aaron Pena 08/i 8/ RedAppl account report for Rep. Ryan Guillen 08/i 8/ Overlay map of HD 40 under Plan H283 and Plan Hi53 08/i 8/ Overlay map of HD 40 under Plan Hi 53 and GUILH /i 8/ Overlay map of HD 40 under Plan H283 and GUILH127 08/i 8/ Map of Hidalgo County under GUILH1O8 08/i 8/ Map of Hidalgo County under GUILHi 10 08/i 8/ Map of Hidalgo County under GUILH /i 8/20i4 379 Map of Hidalgo County under GUILH /i 8/ Map of Hidalgo County under GUILH /i 8/20i4 381 Map of Hidalgo County under GUILHI 16 08/i 8/20i4 382 Map of Hidalgo County under GUILHi 17 08/i 8/

13 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 13 of Map of Hidalgo County under GUILHI 18 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under GUILHI 19 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under GUILH121 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under GUILH122 08/18/ Map of 1-lidalgo County under GUILH128 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under HRC1H265 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under HRCI H277 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under HRC1H286 08/18/ Map of 1-lidalgo County under HRC1H287 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under PENAH100 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under PENAH1OI 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under PENAH1O2 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under STRJHI27 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under STRJH /18/ Map of Hidalgo County under STRJH158 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under STRJH243 08/18/ Map of Hidalgo County under plan GUILH127 08/18/ Plan C100, county maps under C100, and accompanying RED reports from the Texas Legislative Council (TLC") 401 Plan C185, county maps under Plan C185, and accompanying RED reports from TLC 402 Exhibit deleted 403 RED 340- Plan Overlap Analysis Comparing Plans C185 and C Two-Plan Comparison by Incumbent-Comparing Plans C185 and Cl SOS 2008 Democratic Party Primary Election summary for Tarrant County [PX 135 from Section 5 trial] Democratic Primary -Travis County [PX 138 from Section 5 trial] General Election Results - Travis County [PX 139 from Section 5 trial] Democratic Primary -Travis County [PX 140 from Section 5 trial] General Election Results - Travis County [PX 141 from Section 5 trial] Democratic Primary -Travis County [PX 142 from Section 5 trial] General Election Results - Travis County [PX 143 from Section 5 trial] Democratic Primary - Travis County [PX 144 from Section 5 trial] 13

14 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 14 of General Election Results - Travis County [PX 145 from Section 5 trial] Democratic Primary - Travis County [PX 146 from Section 5 trial] General Election Results - Travis County [PX 147 from Section 5 trial] 416 Map - TX U.S. Congressional Districts PLANO1 151 C [PX 154 from Section 5 trial] 417 Map - TX U.S. Congressional Districts PLANOI374C [PX 155 from Section 5 trial] 418 Texas RPVA Index Elections (PX169 from Section 5 trial] 419 Board marked in Court as exhibit [PX 170 from Section 5 trial] 420 Travis County Election Sample Ballots [PX 171 from Section 5 trial] 421 Office of SOS Race Summary Report, Special Runoff Election US Rep District 23 [PX 184 from Section 5 trial] 422 Office of SOS Race Summary Report, 2006 Special November Elections IPX 186 from Section 5 trial] 423 Charts of Hispanic Population in Texas & DOJ 500,000 [PX 192 from Section 5 trial] 424 Expert report of Dr. John Alford (March 14, 2014) 425 Table 1: Estimated 2010 Election Under Plan C Table 2: Estimated 2010 Election Under Plan C Table 3: 2012 Election Under Plan C Table 4: Estimated 2012 Election Under Plan C TableS: Estimated 2012 Election Under Plan C Table 6: District Election Analysis Results for CD 23 in Plans C100, C185 and C Table A: Areas Moved In/Out of Congressional District 23 in Plan C185 (Whole VTD5 Only) 432 Table B: Analysis of Areas Moved In/Out of Congressional District 23 in Plan C185 (With Split VTD5) 433 DEA Plan C185-CD General Election 434 DEA Plan C235 CD Gen Election 435 El Voting Analysis C235-CD Dem Primary and Runoff 436 Map 1: VTD Overlay C Map 2: VTD Overlay C Table 2: Estimated HCVAP Increase in Benchmark Congressional Districts, Table 3: Estimated HCVAP Increase in Benchmark Congressional Districts: Highest to Lowest 14

15 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 15 of Table 5: Citizenship Percentages for Dallas/Fort Worth Districts in Plans C235, C220, C238, and C Google map showing location of Rangers Ballpark, Cowboys Stadium, Arlington Convention Center, and UT-Arlington, and map showing overlay of Plan C100 and Plan C Google map showing location of Texas Wesleyan University, and map showing location of Texas Wesleyan University under Plans C100, C185, C Map of Dallas County under Plan C185, marked during deposition of Sharon Barbosa Cram 444 Map of Dallas County under Plan C235, marked during deposition of Sharon Barbosa-Crain 445 Printout showing address of UlSouthwestern Medical Center, maps showing location of UTSouthwestern Medical Center under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of Margaret Hunt Hill Bridge, maps showing same location under Plans C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of AT&T Stadium and Rangers Ballpark, maps showing same locations under Plans C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of Texas Instruments Corporate Headquarters, maps showing same location under Plans C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of American Airlines Center, maps showing same location under Plans C100, C185, and C235 (with handwritten notes from deposition of Eddie Bernice Johnson) 450 Google map showing location of Dallas Love Field, maps showing same location under Plans C100, C185, and C Google map focused on of Uptown, Oak Lawn, and Turtle Creek, maps showing same areas under Plans C100, C185, and C Printout of webpage of Congressman Barton 453 Google map showing location of district office of Congresswoman Johnson, maps showing same location under Plans C100, C185, and C Printout from TLC District Viewer showing location of Congresswoman Johnson's district office under Plan C Legislative history of Senate Bill 4 during 2011 special session 456 DistrictViewer screenshot showing location of Congresswoman Johnson's home under Plan Cl Printout from the FCI Seagoville website from the Federal Bureau of Prisons 458 Map showing VTD's at least 50% Hispanic or African-American for Plan C Map of Dallas County under Plan C100, marked during deposition of Michael McPhail 460 Map of Dallas County under Plan C185, marked during deposition of Michael McPhail 15

16 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 16 of Map of Tarrant and Dallas County under Plan C Exhibit deleted 463 Excerpts from the State's interrogatory responses to the Department of Justice 464 Map of Arlington showing overlay of Plan C100 and Plan C Maps showing overlay of Plan C100, Plan C185, and location of Las Colinas Medical Center, and the Exxon Mobil Corporate headquarters 466 Map of Tarrant and Dallas County under Plan C Google map showing the location of the MD Anderson Center and the U.T. Health and Science Center, and maps showing these locations in C100, C185, C Google map of the 90 and 610 area in Houston, and maps of the same area in C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of Baylor College of Medicine, maps showing location of Baylor College of Medicine in Cl 00, Cl 85, and C Google map showing location of Memorial Hermann Texas Medical Center, maps showing location of Memorial Hermann Texas Medical Center in C100, C185, and C Printout from Congressman Culberson's website showing Congressman Culberson's office locations, maps showing location of Congressman Culberson's Houston office under Plans C100 and C Exhibit deleted 473 Google map showing downtown Houston, and maps showing downtown Houston under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map showing parts of the Third Ward of Houston, Texas Southern University, Houston University, and maps showing these locations under Plan C100, C185, and C gle map showing location of Rice University, and maps showing location of Rice University under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of Memorial Hermann Texas Medical Center, and maps showing location of Memorial Hermann Texas Medical Center under Plan C100, C185, and C gle map showing location of University of Texas Health and Science Center and MD Anderson Cancer Center, and maps showing these locations under Plan C100, C185, and C Printout from Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee's website showing her office locations 479 Google map showing location of Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee's Houston offices, and maps showing these office locations in under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map of central part of Houston, and maps of central part of Houston under Plan C100, C185, and C235 If1

17 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 17 of Google map showing location of William P. Hobby Airport, maps showing location of William P. Hobby Airport in C100, C185, and C List of minority candidates who won their general elections in Travis County from Exhibit deleted 484 Katherine Haenschen, Round-Up of Endorsements in 2012 Travis County Democratic Primaly, Burnt Orange Report, May 20, Sworn Statement of Dawnna Dukes (September 14, 2011) 486 Table of elected minority candidates for Travis County (Post-2000) 487 Google map showing location of BNSF Railway Corporate Headquarters, maps showing location of BNSF Corporate Headquarters under Plans C100, C185, and C Map showing location of AT&T Stadium and Ranger Ballpark under Plan C Maps showing district office of Rep. Lamar Smith under Plan C185 and Plan C Maps showing district office of Rep. Kevin Brady under Plan C185 and Plan C Maps showing district office of Rep. John Culberson under Plan C185 and Plan C Maps showing district offices of Rep. Michael McCaul under Plan C185 and Plan C Maps showing district offices of Rep. Joe Barton under Plan C185 and Plan C Exhibit deleted 495 Exhibit deleted 496 RedAppl screenshot of District 30 under Plan C185 showing residence of Congresswoman Johnson 497 Map showing location of Congresswoman Johnson' home under Plan Cl Google map showing location of Dallas Baptist University, maps showing location of Dallas Baptist University under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of University of Dallas, maps showing location of University of Dallas under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of ExxonMobil Corporate Headquarters, maps showing location of ExxonMobil Corporate Headquarters under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of Houston Baptist University, maps showing location of Houston Baptist University under Plan C100, C185, and C Google map showing location of Sienna Plantation, maps showing location of Sienna Plantation under Plan C100, C185, and C235 17

18 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 18 of Memorandum from Clare Dyer to Texas Congressional Delegation, Texas Senate, Texas House of Representatives, and Texas State Board of Education (January 11, 2011), and documents related to incumbents' residences 504 Dallas Central Appraisal District printout for 2323 N. Houston Street, Dallas, TX, residence of Congresswoman Johnson Street, Dallas, TX, residence of Congresswoman Johnson 505 and attachment from Debbie Irvine to Blame Brunson, Denise Davis, Julia Rathgeber, Frank Battle, Jesse Ancira, Lisa Kaufman re: redistricting issue paper (November 15, 2010) 506 RedAppl account report for PLAN-Congress 507 Maps and reports for plans C124 through C185 listed on the RedAppl /08/26/2014 account report for PLAN-Congress (WITHDRAWN) 508 RedAppl account report for House Redistricting Committee-Congress 509 Maps and reports for plans HRC1 C100 through HRC1 198 listed on /08/26/2014 the RedAppl account report for House Redistricting (WITHDRAWN) Committee-Congress 510 Shapefile HRCI C104 from the House Redistricting Committee's 511 Shapefile HRC1 C129 from the House Redistricting Committee's RedAppi Account, demonstrative maps, and Red reports 512 Shapefile HRCI C136 from the House Redistricting Committee's 513 Shapefile HRC1 C138 from the House Redistricting Committee's 514 Shapefile HRC1 C140 from the House Redistricting Committee's 515 Shapefile HRC1 C141 from the House Redistricting Committee's 516 Shapefile HRCI C142 from the House Redistricting Committee's 517 Shapefile HRC1 C147 from the House Redistricting Committee's 518 Shapefile HRC1 C148 from the House Redistricting Committee's 519 Shapefile HRC1 C149 from the House Redistricting Committee's 520 Shapefile HRC1 C166 from the House Redistricting Committee's 521 Shapefile HRCI C178 from the House Redistricting Committee's 522 Shapefile HRC1 C179 from the House Redistricting Committee's 523 Shapefile HRC1 C180 from the House Redistricting Committee's 18

19 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 19 of Shapefile HRCI C182 from the House Redistricting Committee's RedAppi Account, demonstrative maps, and Red reports 525 Shapefile HRC1 C187 from the House Redistricting Committee's RedAppi Account, demonstrative maps, and Red reports 526 Shapefile HRC1 C191 from the House Redistricting Committee's 527 Shapefile HRC1 C192 from the House Redistricting Committee's 528 Shapefile HRCI C194 from the House Redistricting Committee's 529 Shapefile HRC1 C197 from the House Redistricting Committee's 530 Shapefile HRC1 C198 from the House Redistricting Committee's 531 RedAppl account report for Senator Seliger-Congress 532 Maps and reports for plans SELl C100 through SELl C104 listed on /08/26/2014 the RedAppl account report for Senator Seliger-Congress (WITHDRAWN) 533 RedAppi account report for Senate Redistricting Committee-Congress 534 Maps and reports for plans SRC1 C102 through SRC1 C157 listed on /08/26/2014 the RedAppl account report for Senate Redistricting Committee-Congress (WITHDRAWN) 535 Shapefile SRC1 C128 from the Senate Redistricting Committee's 536 Shapefile SRC1 C153 from the Senate Redistricting Committee's 537 RedAppl account report for Rep. Solomons-Congress 538 Maps and reports for plans SOLO C100 through SOLO C102 listed /08/26/2014 on the RedAppl account report for Rep. Solomons-Congress (WITHDRAWN) 539 RedAppl account report for Speaker Straus-Congress 540 Maps and reports for plans STRJ C100 through STRJ C121 listed on /08/26/2014 the RedAppl account report for Speaker Straus-Congress (WITHDRAWN) 541 Shapefile STRJ Cl 16 from Speaker Straus's RedAppl Account, demonstrative maps, and Red reports 542 Shapefile STRJ Cl 17 from Speaker Straus's RedAppl Account, demonstrative maps, and Red reports 543 Shapefile STRJ C120 from Speaker Straus's RedAppl Account, demonstrative maps, and Red reports 544 Shapefile STRJC12O attached to previously produced at Congress3l 1, and demonstrative map 545 Plan C121 (Rep. Veasey (Senator West S2-F2) ST SB (H2-F10) Plan C149), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 19

20 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 20 of Plan C122 (MALDEF Congressional proposal A), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 547 Plan C123 (MALDEF Congressional proposal B), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 548 Plan C125 (Rep. Solomons-Senator Seliger Congressional proposal), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 549 Plan C130 (Senator Seliger statewide substitute), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 550 Plan C134 (Senator Williams Districts 8, 10 amendment Plan C130), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 551 Plan C136 (C.S.S.B. 4, Senate committee report), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 552 Plan C137 (Senator Seliger Districts 5, 32 amendment (S2-Fl) Plan C136), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 553 Plan C140 (Senator Patrick Districts 8, 10 Amendment (S2-F4) Plan C136), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 554 Plan C141 (SB. 4, Senate engrossment), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 555 Plan C144 (Rep. Solomons statewide substitute), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 556 Plan C146 (Rep. Hunter District 10, 27 amendment Plan C144), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 557 Plan C147 (Rep. Madden districts 3, 4, 24, 26, 32,amendment Plan C144), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 558 Plan C148 (Rep. Madden districts 3, 4, 24, 26, 32, amendment Plan C147), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 559 Plan C149 (C.S.S.B. 4, House committee report), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 560 Plan C152 (Rep. Hughes districts 1, 5 amendments (H2-F4) Plan C149), and accompanying REDreports from TLC 561 Plan C154 (Rep. Turner and Rep.Davis statewide substitute 1 Plan C149), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 562 Plan C163 (Rep. Martinez Fischer statewide substitute 2 (H2-F13) Plan C149), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 563 Plan C164 (Rep. Martinez Fischer statewide substitute 1 (H2-F15) Plan C149), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 564 Plan C165 (Rep. Martinez Fischer statewide substitute 3 (H2-F16) Plan C149), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 565 Plan C166 (Rep. Dukes statewide substitute (H2-F17) Plan C149), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 566 Plan C169 (Rep. Geren Districts 12, 26 amendment (l-l2-f2) Plan C149), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 567 Plan C170 (Rep. Solomons' West Texas amendment (H2-F1) Plan C149), and accompanying REDreports from TLC 20

21 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 21 of Plan C178 (Rep. Johnson Districts 30, 32 amendment (H2-F14) Plan C157), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 569 Plan C179 (Rep. Pen Districts 11, 21, 23 amendment Plan C170), and accompanying REDreports from TLC 570 Plan C182 (S.B. 4, second reading House amendments), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 571 Plan C193 (Texas NAACP plan), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 572 Press release and advisory regarding Plan C125 (May 31, 2011) (TEX_201 I _ ] 573 Congressional Republican delegation proposal documents 574 Transcript of June hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence 575 Transcript of July 19, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence hearing 576 Transcript of August 16, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence 577 Transcript of August 18, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence 578 Transcript of September 1, 2010 hearing of Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 579 Transcript of September 20, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, House Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence, and Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 580 Transcript of September 21, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence 581 Transcript of September 22, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence 582 Transcript of October 4, 2010 hearing of Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 583 Transcript of October 5, 2010 hearing of Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 584 Transcript of October 18, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence 585 Transcript of October 20, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, and Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence 586 Transcript of October21, 2010 hearing of Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 587 Transcript of November 4, 2010 hearing of Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 588 Transcript of November 20, 2010 hearing of House Subcommittee on Redistricting, House Subcommittee on Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence, and Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 589 Transcript of February 16, 2011 hearing of Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 21

22 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 22 of Transcript of March 1, 2011 hearing of House Committee on Redistricting 591 Transcript of March 15, 2011 hearing of House Committee on Redistricting 592 Transcript of March 24, 2011 hearing of House Committee on Redistricting 593 Transcript of March 25, 2011 hearing of House Committee on Redistricting 594 Transcript of April 7, 2011 hearing of House Committee on Redistricting 595 Transcript of April 15, 2ollhearing of House Committee on Redistricting 596 Transcript of April27, 2011Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 597 Transcript of May 4, 2011 Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 598 Transcript of May 6, 2011 Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 599 Transcript of May 12, 2011 Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 600 Transcript of May 13, 2011 Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 601 Transcript of June 2, 2011 hearing of House Committee on Redistricting 602 Transcript of June 3, 2011 Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 603 House Journal for June 14, House Journal for June 15, Senate Journal for June 6, Senate Journal for June 20, from Eric Opiela to Congressman Smith, Gerardo Interiano, and Doug Davis re:cameron County legislators vie for new congressional seat (January 9, 2011) (Congresso6l] 608 from/to Eric Opiela and Ryan Downton (April 6, 2011) [Congress434 - Congress435] 609 from Eric Opiela to Denise Davis, Lamar Smith re congressional redistricting (May 14, 2011) [TEX_201 1_ TEX_201 1_ ] 610 from Eric Opiela to Denise Davis, Lamar Smith re congressional redistricting (May 16, 2011) [DAVIS ] 611 from Eric Opiela to Gerardo Interiano re redistricting update (May 17,2011) [D D ] 612 from Eric Opiela to Lamar Smith, Gerardo Interiano (May 30, 2011) [Congress208] 613 from Gerardo Interiano to Eric Opiela, Lamar Smith (May 30, 2011) [INTERIAN ] 614 from Eric Opiela to Ryan Downton re CD 10/25 precinct changes in Travis (June 1, 2011) [Congress438] 22

23 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 23 of from/to Eric Opiela, Gerardo Interiano, Ryan Downton, Doug Davis re CD 21 Blanco (June 2, 2011 )[Congress439] 616 from Gerardo Interiano to Eric Opiela re CD 20 (June 2, 2011) [D ] 617 from Gerardo Interiano to Eric Opiela re C1301C136 regression analysis (June 4,2011) [INTERIAN ] 618 from Eric Opiela to Ryan Downton re CD 20 (June 6,2011) (Congress445] 619 from Eric Opiela to Ryan Downton re Blanco County (June 7, 2011) [Congress447] 620 from Eric Opiela to Ryan Downton, Gerardo Interiano re CD 20 at benchmark (June 7, 2011) [Congress268] 621 from/to Eric Opiela, Ryan Downton, Gerardo Interiano, Lamar Smith (June 8, 2011) [Congress274] 622 from Eric Opiela to Ryan Downton, Gerardo Interiano, Lamar Smith re changes to CD 12 (June 8,2011) (Congress276] 623 from Ryan Downton to Eric Opiela, Gerardo Interiano re proposed El Paso changes (June 10, 2011) (TEX_ ] 624 from Eric Opiela to Ryan Downton, Gerardo Interiano re proposed El Paso changes (June10, 2011) [TEX_2011_ ] 625 from Eric Opiela to Gerardo Interiano re couple of options (June 10, 2011)[TEX_2011_ ] 626 from Eric Opiela to Gerardo Interiano re SA and CD 23 reconfigure (June 11, 2011)[D ] 627 from Gerardo Interiano to Eric Opiela re SA and CD 23 reconfigure (June 11, 2011 )[INTERIAN000000I 14 -INTERIAN ] 628 from Eric Opiela to Gerardo Interiano, Ryan Downton re optimized Friday's plan (June 13, 2011) [TEX_2011_ ] 629 from Gerardo Interiano to Eric Opiela re optimized Friday's plan (June 13, 2011) (Congress3o9] 630 from Gerardo Interiano to Eric Opiela re map (June 13, 2011) [Congress3l 1] 631 from/to Eric Opiela, Jennifer Brown, Lamar Smith, Gerardo Interiano re okay...this has to stop (June 13-June 14,2011) [Cong ress42o] 632 from/to Eric Opiela, Gerardo Interiano re why (June 13-June 14, 201 1)[TEX_201 1_ ] 633 from Eric Opiela to Gerardo Interiano, Bonnie Bruce, Lamar Smith re Penaamendment (June 15, 2011) [Congress323] 634 C149-El Paso attached to previously produced at TEX_201 1_ , and demonstrative map 634 C149-El Paso attached to previously produced at TEX_ , and demonstrative map 635 C149-CD23modEctor attached to previously produced at TEX_201 1_ , and demonstrative map 23

24 Case 5:11-cv OLG-JES-XR Document 1270 Filed 10/28/14 Page 24 of C149-CD23mod attached to previously produced at TEX2O1 1_ , and demonstrative map 637 C149-CD23modoptoep-nomav attached to previously produced at TEX_201 1_ , and demonstrative map 638 Color copy of El Paso map previously produced at TEX_201 1_ Color copy of CD 23 map previously produced at D Map of Tarrant County under plan C185, with partisan shading 641 Map of Tarrant County under plan C185, with shading for Democratic 642 Map of Congressional Plan C166, Rep. Dukes Statewide Substitute 2 PlanCl District Viewer screen shot of Plan C122, MALDEF Congressional Proposal A 644 May 29, 2012 Joint Primary Election-Travis County-Democrat Cumulative Results 645 from Joe Hamill to Rep. Eddie Rodriguez re: Updated talking points and data (June 13, 2011) 646 Plan C191 (Task Force CD 23 overlap analysis), and accompanying RED reports from TLC 647 TLRTF exhibit 385 from September 2011 trial - "Cl 91: Changes made to C100 CD 23 in C185 CD 23" 648 Map of Cl 00/PLANO1 438C, as ordered by the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, August 4, Memorandum from Rep. Burt Solomons to Members of the 82nd Texas House of Representatives re: Hearing on H.B. 4 (June 1,2011) 650 from Joe Hamill to Rep. Eddie Rodriguez re: Talking points and info on Dukes Plan (June11, 2011) 651 Map of Texas Congressional Districts: Elections 652 Map of Texas Congressional Districts: Elections and 1996 Primary Elections 653 Map of Texas Congressional Districts: 1996 Special and General Elections, Elections, as ordered by the U.S.District Court for the Southern District of Texas, August 6, Map of Texas Congressional Districts: 2002 Elections, as ordered by the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, November 14, Screenshots of Google Earth in RedAppi 656 Map of Houston area VTD5 under plan C185, with shading for HCVAP or BCVAP of at least 50% 657 Map of Dallas/Fort Worth area VTD5 under plan C185, with shading for Hispanic or African-American CVAP of at least 50% 658 Texas Legislative Online List of Senate Redistricting Committee Meetings (September 1, November 20,