Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety

Transcription

1 EUROPEAN PARLIAMT Committee on the Environment, Public Health and ood Safety VI_PV(2012)1105_1 MINUTES Meeting of 5 November 2012, from to 18.30, and 6 November 2012, from to BRUSSELS The meeting opened at on Monday 5 November 2012, with Matthias Groote (Chair) presiding. 1. Adoption of agenda The agenda was adopted as shown in these minutes. 2. Chair's announcements 2.1. Interpretation status All languages (plus Croatian) were available with the exception of Estonian and Maltese, which corresponds to the standard linguistic profile of the Committee Announcement of extraordinary meetings 12 November 2012, meeting on the ETS backloading proposal, , JAN4Q2 13 November 2012, hearing of Commissionerdesignate, Mr Borg, Workshop announcement Union Civil Protection Mechanism 15 November from 9.30, in room ASP 5E2. The workshop will be chaired by the rapporteur, Elisabetta Gardini. Commissioner Georgieva will be the keynote speaker. CO 2 emissions passenger cars 26 November 2012, from in room ASP 5G3 The workshop will be chaired by the rapporteur, Thomas Ulmer, MEP PV\ doc PE v0100 United in diversity

2 3. Approval of minutes of meetings of: 6 September 2012 PV PE v September 2012 PV PE v0100 The minutes were approved. 4. Election of a third ViceChair VI/7/10914 Exchange of views and election of the third ViceChair. Speakers: Matthias Groote, Peter Liese Decision: Christa Klaß was elected as a vicechair of the Committee. Since there were no other candidates, the election took place by acclemation. 5. Priority substances in the field of water policy VI/7/08744 ***I 2011/0429(COD) COM(2011)0876 C70026/2012 Rapporteur: Richard Seeber (PPE) Responsible: VI Opinions: ITRE, AGRI, PECH Consideration of draft report PR PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 Speakers: Richard Seeber, Matthias Groote, Kriton Arsenis, Holger Krahmer, Carl Schlyter, Julie Girling, Peter Liese, Christa Klaß, Dagmar RothBehrendt, Corinne Lepage, KarlHeinz lorenz, Linda McAvan, Edite Estrela, Sophie Auconie, Nick Cartwright (UK Environment Agency), Peter Gammeltoft (DG V) 6. Union Civil Protection Mechanism VI/7/08551 ***I 2011/0461(COD) COM(2011)0934 C70519/2011 Rapporteur: Elisabetta Gardini (PPE) Responsible: VI* Opinions: AET, DEVE*, BUDG, REGI Consideration of amendments PR PE v0100 AM PE v0300 AM PE v0300 Speakers: Elisabetta Gardini, Rebecca Taylor, Edite Estrela, Alda Sousa, Anna Rosbach, Alojz Peterle, Richard Seeber, Hans Das (DG ECHO) 7. Amendment of Directive 2005/36/EC on the recognition of professional qualifications and of Regulation [...] on administrative cooperation through the Internal Market Information System VI/7/08657 ***I 2011/0435(COD) COM(2011)0883 C70512/2011 Rapporteur for the opinion: Anja Weisgerber (PPE) PA PE v0100 AM PE v0100 PE v0100 2/84 PV\ doc

3 Responsible: IMCO Bernadette Vergnaud (S&D) PR PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 Opinions: EMPL, VI, CULT Consideration of amendments Speakers: Anja Weisgerber, Mario Pirillo, Antonyia Parvanova, Anna Rosbach, Richard Seeber, Peter Liese, Dagmar RothBehrendt, Edite Estrela, Chris Davies 8. The protection of public health from endocrine disrupters VI/7/ /2066(INI) Rapporteur: Åsa Westlund (S&D) Responsible: VI Consideration of draft report Deadline for tabling amendments: 16 November 2012, PR PE v0100 Speakers: Åsa Westlund, Christa Klaß, Corinne Lepage, Michèle Rivasi, Anna Rosbach, Christel Schaldemose, Carl Schlyter, Jo Leinen, Bjorn Hansen (DG V) * The meeting adjourned at 18:30 *** 9. Coordinators meeting took place in camera on 6 November 2012, (See the results of the meeting in Annex I) * The meeting continued on 6th of November at with Matthias Groote (Chair) presiding. *** 10. Animal health requirements governing intraunion trade in and imports into the Union of dogs, cats and ferrets VI/7/09014 ***I 2012/0040(COD) COM(2012)0090 C70061/2012 Rapporteur: Horst Schnellhardt (PPE) Responsible: VI Opinions: AGRI Decision: no opinion Adoption of draft report PR PE v0100 Decision: The draft report as amended was adopted with 33 in favour, 0 against and 0 abstentions. The draft legislative resolution was adopted with 49 in favour, 0 against and 0 abstentions. (See the results of the vote in Annex II) PV\ doc 3/84 PE v0100

4 11. Noncommercial movement of pet animals VI/7/08994 ***I 2012/0039(COD) COM(2012)0089 C70060/2012 Rapporteur: Horst Schnellhardt (PPE) Responsible: VI Opinions: AGRI Decision: no opinion Adoption of draft report PR PE v0100 AM PE v0100 Decision: The draft report as amended was adopted with 63 in favour, 0 against and 0 abstention. The draft legislative resolution was adopted with 60 in favour, 0 against and 0 abstentions. (See the results of the vote in Annex III) 12. Climate Change Conference in Doha (COP 18) VI/7/ /2722(RSP) Corapporteur(s): Sabine Wils (GUE/NGL) Dan Jørgensen (S&D) Satu Hassi (Verts/ALE) KarlHeinz lorenz (PPE) Corinne Lepage (ALDE) Miroslav Ouzký (ECR) Matthias Groote (S&D) Responsible: VI Opinions: ITRE Marita Ulvskog (S&D) RE PE v0100 QO PE v0200 QO PE v0100 AM PE v0200 Adoption of motion for a resolution further to a question for oral answer Decision: The draft resolution as amended was adopted with 54 in favour, 7 against and 1 abstention. (See the results of the vote in Annex IV) 13. The Microbial Challenge Rising threats from Antimicrobial Resistance VI/7/ /2041(INI) COM(2011)0748 Rapporteur: Anna Rosbach (ECR) PR PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 Responsible: VI Opinions: ITRE AGRI Martin Häusling (Verts/ALE) AD PE v0200 AM PE v0100 Adoption of draft report Decision: The draft report as amended was adopted with 62 in favour, 0 against and 0 abstentions. (See the results of the vote in Annex V) PE v0100 4/84 PV\ doc

5 14. Amendment of Directive 2005/36/EC on the recognition of professional qualifications and of Regulation [...] on administrative cooperation through the Internal Market Information System VI/7/08657 ***I 2011/0435(COD) COM(2011)0883 C70512/2011 Rapporteur for the opinion: Anja Weisgerber (PPE) PA PE v0100 AM PE v0100 Responsible: IMCO Bernadette Vergnaud (S&D) PR PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 AM PE v0100 Adoption of draft opinion Decision: The draft opinion as amended was adopted with 58 in favour, 2 against and 0 abstentions. (See the results of the vote in Annex VI) 15. The European Innovation Partnership on Active and Healthy Ageing VI/7/ /2258(INI) COM(2012)0083 Rapporteur: Kartika Tamara Liotard (GUE/NGL) PR PE v0100 Responsible: VI* Opinions: EMPL* Milan Cabrnoch (ECR) PA PE v0100 ITRE Decision: no opinion REGI LIBE Consideration of draft report Deadline for tabling amendments: 23 November 2012, Speakers: Kartika Tamara Liotard, Elena Oana Antonescu, Mario Pirillo, Julie Girling, rieda Brepoels, Oreste Rossi, rançoise Grossetête, Cristina Gutiérrez Cortines, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Christa Klaß, Alojz Peterle, Sophie Auconie, Maria Iglesia Gomez (DG SANCO) * Christa Klaß (Vice Chair) took the chair at *** 16. Improving the delivery of benefits from EU environment measures: building confidence through better knowledge and responsiveness VI/7/ /2104(INI) COM(2012)0095 Rapporteur: Oreste Rossi (ED) Responsible: VI Opinions: ITRE, TRAN, REGI, JURI, PETI Consideration of draft report Deadline for tabling amendments: 23 November 2012, PR PE v0100 PV\ doc 5/84 PE v0100

6 Speakers: Oreste Rossi, KarlHeinz lorenz, Jo Leinen, Satu Hassi. Due to lack of time it was decided to continue discussion on 28 th of November Dates of the next meeting(s) 12 November 2012, (Brussels) 28 November 2012, and (Brussels) 29 November 2012, and (Brussels) * Meeting closed at *** PE v0100 6/84 PV\ doc

7 EUROPEAN PARLIAMT Annex I COMMITTEE ON THE VIRONMT, PUBLIC HEALTH AND OOD SAETY COORDINATORS' MEETING 6 November 2012, Room Paul Henri Spaak (PHS) 3C050 RESULTS Present Mr Groote, Chairman Mr Liese, Cocoordinator of the EPP Group Mr Seeber, Cocoordinator of the EPP Group Ms McAvan, Coordinator of the S&D Group Mr Davies, Coordinator of the ALDE Group Mr Schlyter, replacing the Coordinator of the Greens/EA Group Ms Rosbach, Coordinator of the ECR Group Ms Liotard, Coordinator of the GUE/NGL Group Mr Rossi, Coordinator of the ED Group Apologies Ms Hassi, Coordinator of the Greens/EA Group 6 November 2012 Reports A.1. [EI] Amendment of Directive 98/70/EC relating to the quality of petrol and diesel fuels and of Directive 2009/28/EC on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources COM(2012)595 VI/7/11007 Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the ALDE Group A.2. Assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment (EIA) COM(2012)0628 [EI] Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the ALDE Group PV\ doc 7/84 PE v0100

8 A.3. Innovating for Sustainable Growth: A Bioeconomy for Europe VI/7/09171 Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the EPP Group A.4. Ecoinnovation Jobs and Growth Through Environmental Policy VI/7/10647 Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the S&D Group Opinions A.5. Harmonisation of the laws of the Member States relating to the making available on the market of radio equipment VI/7/11005 ***I 2012/0283(COD) COM(2012)0584 C70333/2012 Responsible: IMCO Decision: No opinion A discharge: performance, financial management and control of EU agencies VI/7/ /2214(DEC) Responsible: CONT GerbenJan Gerbrandy (ALDE) Decision: Ms Haug was confirmed as standing rapporteur for discharge A.7. System for registration of carriers of radioactive materials VI/7/11001 * 2011/0225(NLE) COM(2011)0518 C70253/2011 Responsible: ITRE [M] Decision: 1. Rapporteur for opinion to be nominated by the EPP Group. 2. It was decided to request the application of Rule 50 (letter to Mr Lehne). PE v0100 8/84 PV\ doc

9 A.8. European Semester for economic policy coordination: Annual Growth Survey 2013 VI/7/ /2256(INI) Responsible: ECON* [M] Elisa erreira (S&D) Decision: No opinion A.9. Current Challenges and Opportunities for Renewable Energy in the European Internal Energy Market VI/7/ /2259(INI) COM(2012)0271 Responsible: ITRE [M] Herbert Reul (PPE) Decision: Rapporteur for opinion to be nominated by the EPP Group A.10. Recommandation to the EEAS and to the Council on the 2013 review of the organisation and the functioning of the EEAS VI/7/ /2253(INI) [I] Responsible: AET Decision: No opinion VI Members who are part of the COP 18 ad hoc delegation are encouraged to table joint amendments on climate and environmental diplomacy directly to AET Documents received for information A.11. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: Safe, effective and innovative medical devices and in vitro diagnostic medical devices for the benefit of patients, consumers and healthcare professionals COM(2012)0540 Responsible: VI [NK] Decision: Opinions: INTA, ITRE, IMCO Already covered by the legislative proposals on medical devices PV\ doc 9/84 PE v0100

10 A.12. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Economic and Social Committee Second Regulatory Review on Nanomaterials COM(2012)0572 Responsible: VI Opinions: EMPL, ITRE, IMCO, JURI [M] Decision: Letter from Chair to Commission to be prepared jointly by representatives to be appointed by the political groups. (The groups were asked to indicate each one person responsible.) A.13. Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council progress towards achieving the Kyoto objectives (required under Article 5 of Decision 280/2004/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council concerning a mechanism for monitoring Community greenhouse gas emissions and for implementing the Kyoto Protocol) COM(2012)0626 Responsible: VI Opinions: ITRE Decision: No specific followup required * * * B. INORMATION ON OTHER ACTIVITIES B.1. Ongoing owninitiative reports (no more than 6 at any given time): 1 Only for information The following ordinary INI reports are currently progressing: On 1 March 2012, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new owninitiative report: "The protection of public health from endocrine disrupters" Rapporteur: Ms WESTLUND, S&D adoption in VI scheduled for 18 December The following INIs were adopted recently: Coordinators decided on 31 January 2012 to draw up an owninitiative report with the title: 'The Microbial Challenge Rising threats from Antimicrobial Resistance', authorised by CoP on 16 ebruary 2012 rapporteur Ms ROSBACH, ECR Group adopted in VI on 6 November 2012 "The environmental impacts of shale gas and shale oil extraction activities": authorisation by CoP 8 December 2011 rapporteur: Mr SONIK, EPP adopted in VI on 19 September 2012 PE v /84 PV\ doc

11 Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: Taking forward the Strategic Implementation Plan of the European Innovation Partnership on Active and Healthy Ageing COM(2012)0083 Rapporteur: Ms LIOTARD, GUE/NGL adoption in VI scheduled for 18 December 2012 On 12 September 2012, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new owninitiative report "Ecoinnovation Jobs and Growth through environmental policy" authorisation request pending approved by CCC on 22 October On 12 September 2012, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new owninitiative report "Innovating for Sustainable Growth: A Bioeconomy for Europe" (COM(2012)0060) authorisation request pending approved by CCC on 22 October B.2. Ongoing implementation reports Only for information Implementation report for 2012: "Improving the delivery of benefits from EU environment measures: building confidence through better knowledge and responsiveness" [YG] Rapporteur Mr ROSSI, ED adoption in VI scheduled for 23 January 2013 (tbc) * * * PV\ doc 11/84 PE v0100

12 C. DECISIONS ON OTHER ISSUES C.1. Nomination of experts for hearing on tobacco products [ER] Decision: The coordinators bearing in mind the "Guidelines for implementation of Article 5.3 of the WHO ramework Convention on Tobacco Control on the protection of public health policies with respect to tobacco control from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry" 1 held an exchange of views agreed that 8 speakers should be invited in total decided to invite the following 5 speakers (in alphabetical order) o Ms lorence Berteletti Kemp o Mr David Hammond o Ms Jean King o Mr Brendan Nelson o Ms Martina PötschkeLanger agreed to take a final decision at their next meeting after having received further proposals from the political groups with a view to appointing the remaining 3 speakers." 1 see in particular Conclusion 20: "20. In setting and implementing public health policies with respect to tobacco control, any necessary interaction with the tobacco industry should be carried out by Parties in such a way as to avoid the creation of any perception of a real or potential partnership or cooperation resulting from or on account of such interaction. In the event the tobacco industry engages in any conduct that may create such a perception, Parties should act to prevent or correct this perception. Recommendations 2.1 Parties should interact with the tobacco industry only when and to the extent strictly necessary to enable them to effectively regulate the tobacco industry and tobacco products. 2.2 Where interactions with the tobacco industry are necessary, Parties should ensure that such interactions are conducted transparently. Whenever possible, interactions should be conducted in public, for example through public hearings, public notice of interactions, disclosure of records of such interactions to the public." PE v /84 PV\ doc

13 C.2. Application of Rule 50 The papers for the meeting included a note dated 26 October 2012 with statistics on application of Rule 50. The papers for the meeting also included recent correspondence on Rule 50 issues. Decision: The Coordinators took note of the high number of requests for the application of Rule 50 directed against VI; invited the VI rapporteurs for (a) CO2 emissions from cars and (b) CO2 emissions from vans to examine with the respective ITRE rapporteurs for opinion ways and means of cooperation between the two committees. C.3. Revision of Rule 70 [ZL] The papers for the meeting included the Guerrero Salom report (A70281/2012). Decision: The Coordinators took note of the fact that the Guerrero Salom report was provisionally scheduled for adoption during the November partsession; discussed the potential implications of the proposed revision of Rule 70 for VI's legislative work until the end of the parliamentary term; instructed the chairman to write to the President of the European Parliament (cc to Mr Lehne, Chair of the CCC) so as to draw attention to the potential implications of the proposed changes and to suggest that the implementation of the new framework be postponed until the beginning of the next parliamentary term. PV\ doc 13/84 PE v0100

14 C.4. Request for a workshop on medical devices [NK] Decision: The coordinators agreed in principle to the organisation of a workshop on medical devices, on the understanding that detailed specifications would be decided upon in close cooperation with the rapporteur. C.5. Invitation to VI Members to take part in highlevel visit from Swiss Parliament, 22 November 2012, Strasburg [JV] The papers for the meeting included invitation from Chair of SINEEA, Mr Gallagher, to VI Members to meet with representatives of the Swiss Parliament in Strasburg, 22 November 2012 from 10:30 to 12:00 Decision: The Coordinators invited Mr Seeber and Ms McAvan to represent the committee on that occasion; proposed 'priority substances in the field of water policy' as a subject for an exchange of views with Swiss MPs. C.6. VI Member responsible for Gender Mainstreaming [ER] Decision: The Coordinators appointed Ms Klaß, 3rd vicechair, as the VI Member responsible for gender mainstreaming. C.7. Available ramework contracts for the purpose to provide expertise to the members of the VI Committee [YG] The papers for the meeting included a briefing dated 22 October 2012 by Policy Department A on ramework Contracts for VI. Decision: Coordinators took note of the above document. C.8. Appointment of EP representative in the rench Commission on Indicators for Sustainable Development [YG] The papers for the meeting included letter dated 9 October 2012 three rench Institutions inviting the European Parliament to designate a member of the "Commission nationale de concertation sur les indicateurs du développement durable" PE v /84 PV\ doc

15 Decision: The coordinators proposed Mr Leinen (former rapporteur for the COD report on "European Environmental Accounts") and Ms Rosbach (former rapporteur for the INI report "Beyond GDP") as EP representatives on the rench Commission on Indicators for Sustainable Development; instructed the Chair to inform the President of the European Parliament of their proposal and to ask for clarifications regarding the reimbursement of travel expenses. * * * D. DOCUMTS OR INORMATION None PV\ doc 15/84 PE v0100

16 Annex II VOTING RESULTS on animal health requirements governing intraunion trade in and imports into the Union of dogs, cats and ferrets PR PE v0100 Rapporteur: Horst Schnellhardt Concerned text AM Tabled by Remarks /Comments Vote IN AVOUR AGAINST ABSTTION DRAT REPORT DRAT LEGISLATIVE RESOLUTION PE v /84 PV\ doc

17 VOTING RESULTS Annex III on noncommercial movement of pet animals PR PE v0100 AM PE v0100 Rapporteur: Horst Schnellhardt Concerned text AM Tabled by Comments/remarks Vote ARTICLES: Article 2 Article 2 point b Article 3 point a Article 3 point a Article 3 point b Article 3 point c Article 3 point c Article 3 point ca Article 3 point e Article 3 point f Article 3 point g Article 3 point ga Article 3 point gb Article 3 point gc Article 3 point gd AM 19 Rapporteur (35/14/0) AM 20 Rapporteur (replaced by oral am 1 W to Art. 39) AM 21 Rapporteur AM 178 Sergio Berlato Possible as an addition AM 22 Rapporteur AM 23 Rapporteur AM 179 Jill Evans Compatible with 23 AM 24 Rapporteur AM 25 Rapporteur (See other ams. on identific. doc.) AM 26 Rapporteur AM 27 Rapporteur AM 28 Rapporteur AM 29 Rapporteur AM 30 Rapporteur AM 31 Rapporteur PV\ doc 17/84 PE v0100

18 Compromise amendment by EPP, S &D, Covering amendments 180 ALDE, Greens/EA, ECR 184, Article 4 a AM 32 Rapporteur W AM 180 Horst identical title Title (relev. part) Schnellhardt AM 182 (relev. part) Jill Evans AM 184 (relev. part) Justas Vincas Paleckis Article 4 a AM 33 Rapporteur W para 1 AM 180 (1) Horst Schnellhardt AM 182 (1) Jill Evans AM 183 (1) Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard identical AM 184 (1) Justas Vincas Paleckis AM 181, Sergio Berlato possible as an addition last sentence Article 4 a AM 34 Rapporteur W para 2, AM 180 (2) Horst Schnellhardt introductory AM 182 (2) Jill Evans sentence AM 183 (2) Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard identical AM 184 (2) Justas Vincas Paleckis Article 4 a Para 2(a) Article 4 a AM 35 AM 182 (2a) AM 183 (2a) AM 184 (2a) AM 180 (2a) AM 182 (2b) Rapporteur Jill Evans Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard Justas Vincas Paleckis Horst Schnellhardt Jill Evans identical: "recreational" = included falls if (2a) are adopted W PE v /84 PV\ doc

19 Para 2(b) Article 4 a Para 3(c) Chapter II subheading Article 5 point a Article 5 point c Article 5 point d Article 5 point d AM 180 Horst compatible (2b) Schnellhardt AM 36 Rapporteur W AM 184 (2b) Justas Vincas Paleckis compatible AM 183 Dan Jørgensen, alls if 184 (2b) is (2b) Nadja Hirsch, adopted Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard AM 180 (3) Horst Schnellhardt AM 37 Rapporteur AM 185 Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Chris Davies (database) (23/30/0) AM 38 Rapporteur AM 39 Rapporteur renumbering am. AM 186 Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard (database) (25/30/0) Article 6 AM 187 Jill Evans deletion of Art.6 Article 6 introductory part AM 40 Rapporteur alls if 187 is adopted Article 6 subpara a Article 6 point b Article 6 a Article 6 a Article 6 AM 41 Rapporteur alls if 187 is adopted AM 42 Rapporteur alls if 187 is adopted AM 189 Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Chris Davies alls if 187 is adopted (32/26/0) AM 43 Rapporteur alls if 187 or 189 is adopted AM 188 Marina alls if 187 is adopted Compatible with 189 PV\ doc 19/84 PE v0100

20 point a (part b)or 43 Article 7 AM 44 Rapporteur Article 7 AM 45 Rapporteur Article 7 AM 46 Rapporteur Deletion paragraph 3 Chapter II AM 47 Rapporteur new subheading (before Article 9) Article 9 point c introductory part AM 190 Sergio Berlato Article 9 point c Chapter III new subheading (before Article 10) Article 10 point d Article 10 point e Article 10 a AM 48 Rapporteur renumbering am. AM 49 Rapporteur AM 50 Rapporteur AM 51 Rapporteur renumbering am. AM 52 Rapporteur Oral am. 2 by rapporteur : shall be moved through a travellers point of entry in a Member State if arriving from a third country or territory other than those in the list established in accordance with Article 13(1 )... AM 53 Rapporteur Article 10 paragraph 1b introductory part Article 10 AM 54 Rapporteur paragraph 1b point a Article 10 AM 55 Rapporteur paragraph 1b point b PE v /84 PV\ doc

21 Article 11 introductory part Article 11 point a Article 11 point b Article 11 a Article 11 a Article 11 Article 12 introductory part Article 12 point a Article 12 point b Article 12 point b AM 56 Rapporteur AM 57 Rapporteur AM 58 Rapporteur AM 191 Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Chris Davies (33/28/0) AM 59 Rapporteur alls if 191 is adopted AM 60 Rapporteur AM 61 Rapporteur ( Oral am.nr 3(by rapporteur) :"Article 13(1)" should read "Article 13") AM 62 Rapporteur AM 63 Rapporteur AM 192 Justas Vincas Paleckis, Daciana Octavia Sârbu Compatible with 63 AM 64 Rapporteur Article 13 title Article 13 AM 65 Rapporteur Article 13 AM 66 Rapporteur introductory part Chapter III AM 67 Rapporteur new subheading (before Article 14) Article 14 AM 68 Rapporteur renumbering am. PV\ doc 21/84 PE v0100

22 point c Article 14a Chapter III new subheading (before Article 15) Article 16 subpara 2 Article 16 subpara 2a AM 69 Rapporteur 3rd country list for Part B species (similar to Art 13(1) am 65 AM 70 Rapporteur AM 71 Rapporteur AM 193 Jill Evans (database) (23/38/0) Article 17 AM 72 Rapporteur W Article 17 AM 194 Horst Schnellhardt W Article 17 AM 196 Jill Evans (training database) Split vote (by S&D) 1)Part 1: the whole text except the last 4 words(for at least 10 years) 2)Part 2: deletion of the words: "for at least 10 years." (27/33/1) Article 17 AM 195 Marina alls if 196 is adopted (31/30/0) Article 20a title AM 74 Rapporteur Article 20a Article 20a Article 22 paragraph 3 Article 20a paragraph 3 AM 75 Rapporteur (= retabled Art.22) AM 76 Rapporteur (= retabled Art.22) AM 211 Justas Vincas Paleckis AM 77 Rapporteur alls if 211 is adopted (= retabled Art.22) Article 22 AM 84 Rapporteur Deletion of Art 22: deemed to be adopted if are adopted, Article 21 AM 198 Marina PE v /84 PV\ doc

23 point a Article 21 point b Article 21 point b Article 21 point b Article 21 point b Article 21 point b Article 21 point (ba) Article 21 point d Article 21 point e point ii Article 21 point ea Article 21 point f Article 21 point f a Article 21 paragraph point f a Article 21 Article 21 AM 201 AM 202 AM 203 Radvile Morkunaite Mikuleniene Justas Vincas Paleckis Chris Davies identical AM 200 Lucas Hartong alls if are adopted AM 199 Marina Compatible with (32/29/0) AM 78 Rapporteur AM 79 Rapporteur AM 80 Rapporteur Deletion AM 81 Rapporteur AM 82 Rapporteur (see am 81) AM 204 AM 205 Dan Jørgensen, Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard Marina (database) (if adopted, will be merged with 81) (27/34/0) (35/26/0) AM 206 Lucas Hartong AM 207 Elisabeth (data base) Jeggle alls if 206 is adopted Article 21 AM 210 Dan Jørgensen, (data base) PV\ doc 23/84 PE v0100

24 Article 21 Article 21 Article 21 Nadja Hirsch, Andrea Zanoni, Kartika Tamara Liotard alls if 206 or 207 is adopted AM 208 Jill Evans (data base) alls if 206,207 or 210 is adopted AM 209 Justas Vincas Paleckis identical to 83 AM 83 Rapporteur Translation error from DE into and R): should read:"...may not be less than 3 years..." no database alls if 206, 207, 210 or 208 are adopted (27/34/0) Article 22a AM 85 Rapporteur (= rewording of Art. title 20) Article 22a AM 86 Rapporteur (= rewording of Art. introductory part 20) Article 22a AM 87 Rapporteur (= rewording of Art. point a 20) Article 22a AM 88 Rapporteur (= rewording of Art.20) point b Article 20 AM 197 Justas Vincas falls if 88 is adopted point b Paleckis Article 22a AM 89 Rapporteur (= retabled Art.20) point c Article 20 AM 73 Rapporteur Deletion of Art.20; Deemed to be adopted if are adopted Article 23 Article 23 introductory part Article 24 a title Article 24a Article 24a AM 90 Rapporteur renumbering am. AM 212 Lucas Hartong AM 92 Rapporteur (=rewording of Art 26) AM 93 Rapporteur (=rewording of Art 26) AM 94 Rapporteur (=rewording of Art 26) PE v /84 PV\ doc

25 Article 26 AM 101 Rapporteur Deletion of Art 26 Deemed to be adopted if are adopted Article 25 AM 95 Rapporteur point b Article 25 point b AM 213 Lucas Hartong alls if 95 is adopted Article 25 point b Article 25 point (ba) Article 25 point e point ii Article 25 point ea Article 25 point f AM 214 Justas Vincas Paleckis (28/34/0) AM 96 Rapporteur AM 97 Rapporteur Deletion of point e(ii) AM 98 Rapporteur AM 99 Rapporteur (See am. 98) Article 25 AM 100 Rapporteur Article 26 a AM 102 Rapporteur (= reworded Art.24) Article 24 AM 91 Rapporteur Deletion of Art.24 Deemed to be adopted if 102 is adopted Article 27 introductory part Article 27 point b introductory part Article 28a title Article 28a Article 28a AM 103 Rapporteur renumbering am AM 104 Rapporteur AM 106 Rapporteur (=Art 30 reworded) AM 107 Rapporteur (=Art 30 reworded) AM 108 Rapporteur (=Art 30 reworded) PV\ doc 25/84 PE v0100

26 Article 30 AM 112 Rapporteur Deletion of Art.30, Deemed to be adopted if adopted Article 29 point b Article 29 point b Article 29 point ba Article 29 point ca Article 29 point d Article 30a title Article 30a introductory part Article 30a point a Article 30a point b AM 216 Justas Vincas Paleckis AM 215 Lucas Hartong falls if 216 is adopted AM 109 Rapporteur AM 110 Rapporteur AM 111 Rapporteur (See am 110) AM 113 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 28) AM 114 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 28) AM 115 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 28) AM 116 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 28) Article 30a AM 117 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 28) point c Article 28 AM 105 Rapporteur Deletion of Art. 28, Deemed to be adopted if are adopted Article 31a title Article 31a Article 31a AM 119 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 33) AM 120 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 33) AM 121 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 33) Article 33 AM 127 Rapporteur Deletion of Art. 33, Deemed to be adopted if are adopted Article 32 point aa AM 122 Rapporteur PE v /84 PV\ doc

27 Article 32 point b Article 32 point b Article 32 point b Article 32 point (ba) Article 32 point d Article 32 Article 32 Article 33a AM 123 Rapporteur AM 217 Lucas Hartong alls if 123 is adopted AM 218 Justas Vincas Paleckis Possible as an addition AM 124 Rapporteur AM 125 Rapporteur (See am 122) AM 126 Rapporteur AM 219 Sergio Berlato (33/29/0) AM 128 Rapporteur (=reworded Art. 31) Article 31 AM 118 Rapporteur Deletion of Art.31, Deemed to be adopted if 128 is adopted Chapter VI section 1 title Article 34 introductory part Article 34 point a Article 35 title Article 35 Article 35 introductory part Article 35 point a AM 129 Rapporteur AM 130 Rapporteur AM 131 Rapporteur AM 132 Rapporteur AM 133 Rapporteur AM 134 Rapporteur AM 135 Rapporteur Article 36 AM 136 Rapporteur PV\ doc 27/84 PE v0100

28 title Article 36 Article 36 introductory part Article 36 point a Article 36 paragraph 4 point b Article 36 paragraph 4 point c Article 37 introductory part Article 37 point a Article 37 point a Article 37 point b Article 37 point c Article 37 point c Article 38 introductory part Article 39 introductory part Article 39 introductory part Article 39 AM 137 Rapporteur AM 138 Rapporteur AM 139 Rapporteur AM 140 Rapporteur Translation error: should read "noncompliance" instead of "complaints" (39/22/0) AM 141 Rapporteur AM 142 Rapporteur AM 143 AM 220 Rapporteur Marina Identical AM 144 Rapporteur AM 221 Marina (38/25/0) AM 145 Rapporteur alls if 221 is adopted AM 146 Rapporteur AM 147 Rapporteur AM 222 Jill Evans Compatible with 147 AM 223 Jill Evans PE v /84 PV\ doc

29 point a a Article 39 point d Article 39 point ea Article 39 point eb Article 40 Article 41 Article 44 subparagrap h 2 Article 45 paragraph 2a Article 46 introductory part Article 46 point a Article 46 point b Article 46 introductory part Article 46 point a Article 46 point b AM 148 Rapporteur AM 149 Rapporteur Oral am.1 Oral am 1 Rapporteur Relates to withdrawn am. 20, insertion of the following text: eb) measures taken by Member States to restrict the movement of certain species or breeds of pet animals on the basis of considerations other than those relating to animal health AM 150 Rapporteur Deletion of Art 40(2) AM 151 Rapporteur AM 152 Rapporteur AM 153 Rapporteur AM 154 Rapporteur renumbering am AM 155 Rapporteur AM 156 Rapporteur AM 157 Rapporteur AM 158 Rapporteur AM 159 Rapporteur PV\ doc 29/84 PE v0100

30 Article 46 a Article 47 AM 224 Marina AM 160 Rapporteur Annex 1 part A line 1 Annex 1 part A line 2 Annex 1 part A line 3 AM 225 AM 226 AM 227 ANNEXES: Marina Marina Marina Annex II AM 161 Rapporteur Deletion of Annex II(See am 7 justific.) Annex Va AM 162 Rapporteur Annex Vb AM 163 Rapporteur Annex Vc AM 164 Rapporteur Annex Vd AM 165 Rapporteur RECITALS: Recital 5 AM 1 Rapporteur Recital 8 AM 2 Rapporteur Recital 12 AM 3 Rapporteur Recital 12a AM 4 Rapporteur See ams on Art 4a Recital 13 AM 5 Rapporteur Deletion Recital 14 AM 6 Rapporteur Deletion Recital 16 AM 7 Rapporteur Deletion Recital 17 AM 8 Rapporteur See ams to Art.17 Recital 17 AM 166 Sergio Berlato Recital 17 AM 167 Marina See am 198 PE v /84 PV\ doc

31 Recital 17a AM 9 Rapporteur Recital 17 a Recital 17 a AM 168 AM 169 Jill Evans Jørgensen, Hirsch, Zanoni, Liotard Chris Davies Recital 17 a AM 170 Recital 17 b AM 171 Jill Evans Recital 20 AM 10 Rapporteur Recital 20 a AM 172 Marina Recital 21 AM 11 Rapporteur alls if 168 is adopted Identical Recital 22 AM 12 Rapporteur See ams Recital 22a AM 13 Rapporteur See am 69 Recital 25 AM 173 Jørgensen, Hirsch, Zanoni, Liotard Recital 25 AM 14 Rapporteur alls if 173 is adopted Recital 27 AM 174 Lucas Hartong Recital 27 AM 15 Rapporteur W (37/27/0) Identical (55/7/0) Recital 29 AM 16 Rapporteur Recital 31 AM 175 Jill Evans Recital 34 AM 17 Rapporteur Recital 35 AM 18 Rapporteur Recital 35 AM 176 Marina Recital 35 a AM 177 Marina falls if 18 is adopted IN AVOUR AGAINST ABSTTIONS DRAT REPORT AS AMDED DRAT LEGISLATIVE RESOLUTION PV\ doc 31/84 PE v0100

32 Annex IV VOTING RESULTS on the climate change conference in Doha (COP 18) RE PE v0100 AM PE v0200DEVERE/COP18 Cosponsors: Matthias Groote, KarlHeinz lorenz, Dan Jørgensen, Corinne Lepage, Satu Hassi, Miroslav Ouzký, Sabine Wils Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 1 AM 16 KarlHeinz lorenz Oral AM 1 "also welcomes the process to increase the level of ambition pre 2020 for parties" AM 17 Jolanta Emilia Hibner Linguistic do not vote L 1 a AM 18 Dan Jørgensen AM 19 Sergio Berlato 2 a AM 20 Satu Hassi 2 b AM 21 Satu Hassi 28/32/0 3 AM 22 KarlHeinz lorenz AM 24 Satu Hassi alls if AM 22 adopted 1 Oral amendment tabled by Romana Jordan MEP under Rule 156(6) of the Rules of Procedure. PE v /84 PV\ doc

33 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote AM 23 Jolanta Emilia Hibner alls if AM 22 adopted Compatible with AM 24. AM 26 Jo Leinen, Marita Ulvskog, Kriton Arsenis, Vittorio Prodi Compatible with AMs 22, 24, and 23 32/31/0 AM 25 Andres Perello Rodriguez alls if AM 26 adopted Compatible with AMs 22, 24 and 23 3 a AM 27 Satu Hassi 4 AM 28 KarlHeinz lorenz Split vote (GUE/NGL) Part 1 "Stresses that...take on commitments " Part 2 "and is of the opinion that...mechanism" 4 a AM 29 Vittorio Prodi 5 AM 30 KarlHeinz lorenz 24/38/1 PV\ doc 33/84 PE v0100

34 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote AM 32 EijaRiitta Korhola Compatible with AM 30 Oral AM 1 33/31/0 "...together covering about 15% of global emissions which is why the EU has to intensify its efforts to find solutions for joint measures to bring all the main actors on board..." AM 31 Jolanta Emilia Hibner Compatible with AMs 30 and 32 5 a AM 33 EijaRiitta Korhola 7 AM 34 KarlHeinz lorenz 35/28/1 AM 35 Jolanta Emilia Hibner alls if AM 34 adopted 8 AM 37 Satu Hassi 1 Oral amendment tabled by EijaRiitta Korhola MEP under Rule 156(6) of the Rules of Procedure. PE v /84 PV\ doc

35 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote AM 38 Dan Jørgensen Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "8. Emphasises the need for... integrity of the Kyoto Protocol" Part 1 falls if AM 37 adopted Part 2 "points out that...on climate mitigation" 32/31/1 AM 36 The words: "points out that...on climate mitigation" compatible as an addition to AM 37 KarlHeinz lorenz The words: "within the...need for" and "calls on Annex B parties...in this regard" compatible as additions to AMs 37 and 38 AM 39 Sabine Wils alls if AM 36 adopted Compatible with AMs 37, and 38 PV\ doc 35/84 PE v0100

36 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote AM 40 Corinne Lepage alls if AMs 37 or 38 adopted Compatible with AMs 36 and 39 8 a AM 41 Dan Jørgensen 8 a AM 42 Andres Perello Rodriguez Split vote (Greens/EA) Part 1 The whole text without the words "in order...supply and demand" Part 2 those words 34/28/1 24/38/1 8 a AM 43 Corinne Lepage Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Welcomes the proposal of...surplus of assigned amount units" Part 2 "recalls that the Lisbon Treaty... (Article 218 TEU)" PE v /84 PV\ doc

37 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 9 AM 46 Satu Hassi Split vote (EPP) Part 1 Whole text without the words "in particular calls on Parties... from international aviation and maritime transport" Part 2 those words 32/31/0 AM 45 Jolanta Emilia Hibner Compatible with AM 46 AM 44 KarlHeinz lorenz Compatible with AMs 46 and 45 9 a AM 47 Dan Jørgensen 9 a AM 48 Satu Hassi 9 a AM 49 Sabine Wils 30/30/0 9 a AM 50 Jo Leinen, Marita Ulvskog, Kriton Arsenis, Vittorio Prodi 56/7/0 9 b AM 51 Dan Jørgensen 32/29/1 10 AM 54 Sabine Wils AM 52 KarlHeinz lorenz Compatible with AM 54 PV\ doc 37/84 PE v0100

38 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote AM 53 Satu Hassi Compatible with AMs 54 and a AM 55 KarlHeinz lorenz 10 a AM 56 Jo Leinen, Marita Ulvskog, Kriton Arsenis, Vittorio Prodi 32/31/0 11 AM 59 Satu Hassi AM 60 Jo Leinen, Marita Ulvskog, Kriton Arsenis, Vittorio Prodi Compatible with AM 59 AM 57 KarlHeinz lorenz Compatible with AMs 59, 60 and 57 AM 58 Jolanta Emilia Hibner Compatible with AMs 59, 60, 57 and 58 34/30/0 DEVE 4 DEVE DEVE 5 DEVE 11 a AM 61 KarlHeinz lorenz 11 a AM 62 Satu Hassi 11 a AM 63 Sabine Wils PE v /84 PV\ doc

39 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 11 a AM 64 Jo Leinen, Marita Ulvskog, Kriton Arsenis, Vittorio Prodi Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Calls on the Commission.. innovative financing sources" Part 2 "like the TT or a carbon tax" 30/33/1 DEVE 3 DEVE 11 a AM 65 Corinne Lepage, GerbenJan Gerbrandy 12 AM 66 KarlHeinz lorenz AM 67 Jolanta Emilia Hibner Linguistic do note vote L AM 68 Dan Jørgensen The following words are compatible as an addition to AM 66: "recognises that...of utmost importance;" AM 69 Andres Perello Rodriguez Compatible with AMs 66 and 68 PV\ doc 39/84 PE v0100

40 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote DEVE 6 DEVE Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Stresses that the Cancun agreements... existing development aid" Part 2 "believes that the Green Climate und... sustained funding" 30/34/0 DEVE 1 DEVE DEVE 11 DEVE 10 DEVE DEVE 33/30/0 12 a AM 70 Sabine Wils 12 b AM 71 Sabine Wils 12 c AM 72 Sabine Wils DEVE 2 DEVE DEVE 12 DEVE 13 DEVE 14 DEVE 15 DEVE 33/29/1 DEVE DEVE DEVE PE v /84 PV\ doc

41 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 14 AM 73 Kriton Arsenis Oral AM (Greens/EA) with oral AM "REDD activities" witout oral AM 14 a AM 74 Sabine Wils 14 a AM 75 Kriton Arsenis Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Stresses that according to the UNCCC framework... financing solutions" Part 2 "which go beyond the monetisation of carbon" 31/32/0 14 a AM 76 Corinne Lepage 14 b AM 77 Sabine Wils 14 b AM 78 Kriton Arsenis Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Emphasises that... monitoring systems" Part 2 "Notes in this respect... readily available" 31/32/1 DEVE 7 DEVE PV\ doc 41/84 PE v0100

42 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 14 c AM 79 Sabine Wils 15 AM 80 Jolanta Emilia Hibner Linguistic do note vote L 15 a AM 82 KarlHeinz lorenz 15 b AM 83 KarlHeinz lorenz Subheading 7 a AM 81 KarlHeinz lorenz AM 81 (title) deemed adopted if AMs 82 or 83 adopted Deemed rejected if AMs 82 and 83 both rejected 15 a AM 84 Satu Hassi Split vote (EPP) Part 1 Whole text without the words "all eventual" Part 2 those words 15 a AM 85 Sergio Berlato Split vote (Greens/EA) Part 1 29/36/0 "Continues... scheme" Part 2 "but expresses... (ICAO)" 15 c AM 87 KarlHeinz lorenz 15 d AM 88 KarlHeinz lorenz PE v /84 PV\ doc

43 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 15 e AM 89 KarlHeinz lorenz Subheading 7 b AM 86 KarlHeinz lorenz AM 86 (Title) deemed adopted if AM 87, 88 or 89 adopted Deemed rejected if AMs 87, 88, and 89 all rejected X a AM 91 (ITRE) X b AM 92 (ITRE) X c AM 93 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela PV\ doc 43/84 PE v0100

44 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote X d AM 94 (ITRE) X d a AM 95 (ITRE) X e AM 96 (ITRE) X f AM 97 (ITRE) X g AM 98 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela PE v /84 PV\ doc

45 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote X h AM 99 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Split vote (GUE/NGL) Part 1 "Recalls that... technology transfer" Part 2 "Recalls that the CDM...Least Developed Countries" Split vote to be taken only if AM 42 (p.5) rejected Compatible as the following addition to AM 42 (p.5): "considers that...least Developed Countries" X i AM 100 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela PV\ doc 45/84 PE v0100

46 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote Title AM 90 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela AM 90 (Title) deemed adopted if AMs 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99 or 100 adopted. Deemed rejected if AMs 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99 and 100 all rejected. X j AM 102 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela X k AM 103 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela X l AM 104 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela PE v /84 PV\ doc

47 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote X m AM 105 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Title AM 101 ITRE AM 101 (Title) deemed adopted if AMs 102, 103, 104, or 105 adopted Deemed rejected if AMs 102, 103, 104 and 105 all rejected X n AM 107 (ITRE) X o AM 108 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela PV\ doc 47/84 PE v0100

48 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote X p AM 109 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela alls if AM 51 (p.7) or 65 (p.8) adopted Split vote (ALDE) Part 1 whole text without the word "inefficient" Part 2 that word X q AM 110 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Title AM 106 ITRE AM 106 (Title) deemed adopted if AMs 107, 108, 109 or 110 adopted. Deemed rejected if AMs 106, 107, 108, 109 and 110 all rejected DEVE 8 DEVE 33/31/0 DEVE 9 DEVE PE v /84 PV\ doc

49 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 16 AM 111 Jolanta Emilia Hibner Linguistic do note vote L AM 112 EijaRiitta Korhola AM 113 Andres Perello Rodriguez Compatible with AM a AM 114 Dan Jørgensen Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Regrets that...2ºc objective" Part 2 "and is concerned that... climate talks" 30/33/0 16 a AM 115 Andres Perello Rodriguez 17 a AM 116 KarlHeinz lorenz 17 a AM 117 Satu Hassi, Chris Davies, Jo Leinen, Bas Eickhout, GerbenJan Gerbrandy, Sabine Wils 17 a AM 118 Sabine Wils 17 a AM 119 Vittorio Prodi 30/33/0 PV\ doc 49/84 PE v0100

50 Articles/ s Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote 17 b AM 120 Satu Hassi irst part (the words "Is concerned that...2 C objective) covered by AM 114 (p.19) Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Is concerned that...ghg reduction goal" If AM 114 Part 1 (p.19) adopted, split vote Part 1 concerns the words "and a costeffective path to the 2050 GHG reduction goal" Part 2 "calls for...eu climate policy" 31/33/0 17 b AM 121 Vittorio Prodi 33/31/0 19 AM 122 Jolanta Emilia Hibner 29/33/1 PE v /84 PV\ doc

51 Recitals and Citations Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote Citations DEVE CIT 1 DEVE CIT 2 DEVE CIT 3 DEVE CIT 4 Recital A a AM 1 Sergio Berlato Recital A a AM 2 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Split vote (EPP) Part 1 "Whereas...and 2035" Part 2 "and meeting... CO2 emissions" 25/37/0 2nd part falls if 1st part falls Part 3 "whereas the major part... emerging economies " Part 4 "whereas there are...fossil fuels" 34/28/1 PV\ doc 51/84 PE v0100

52 Recitals and Citations Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote Recital A b AM 3 (ITRE) Recital A c AM 4 (ITRE) Recital A d AM 5 (ITRE) Recital A e AM 6 (ITRE) Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Marita Ulvskog, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Jens Rohde, Yannick Jadot, Evžen Tošenovský, Marisa Matias, Niki Tzavela Recital C a AM 7 Sabine Wils Recital D AM 8 KarlHeinz lorenz AM 9 Satu Hassi Compatible with AM 8 AM 10 Dan Jørgensen Compatible with AMs 8 and 9 Recital E AM 12 Jolanta Emilia Hibner 55/8/0 PE v /84 PV\ doc

53 Recitals and Citations Am No Tabled by Remarks Vote AM 11 KarlHeinz lorenz Compatible with AM 12 Recital AM 13 EijaRiitta Korhola Recital a AM 14 Satu Hassi Recital a AM 15 Sabine Wils 31/32/0 Recitals (DEVE) DEVE A 29/28/0 DEVE B DEVE C DEVE D DEVE E 31/31/0 DEVE 33/29/0 DEVE G VOTE ON THE DRAT RESOLUTION AS AMDED IN AVOUR AGAINST ABST PV\ doc 53/84 PE v0100

54 Annex V VOTING RESULTS on the Microbial Challenge Rising threats from Antimicrobial Resistance PR PE AM PE AD PE Rapporteur: Anna Rosbach Concerned text 1 a footnote 1 2 a 3 AM Tabled by Remarks AM 32 AGRI 1 PARAGRAPHS Anna Rosbach, Karin Kadenbach AGRI AM 30 Bart Staes alls if AGRI 1 adopted Vote 37/22/0 AM 31 Anna Rosbach, Karin Kadenbach, Theodoros Skylakakis AM 34 Christel Schaldemose, Karin Kadenbach AM 35 Anna Rosbach, Karin Compatible with AM34 Kadenbach AM 33 Mairead McGuinness alls if AM35 adopted AM 36 AM 37 Zofija Mazej Kukovic, rançoise Grossetête, Anna Rosbach, Peter Liese, Georgios Koumoutsakos, Esther de Lange Compatible with AM34, 35 Split vote request by S&D: 1st part: "we need to enhance... clinical treatment" 2nd part: rest of the AM 39/21/0 Anna Rosbach, Karin Kadenbach AM 38 Bart Staes 28/32/0 COMP 3 EPP, S&D, ALDE, If adopted, the following AM will Greens, ECR, GUE, fall:39, 40, 41, 44, 45, 46, 52, 80, ED AGRI3, AGRI17, AM 39 Mairead McGuinness alls if COMP3 adopted 3 AM 45 Anna Rosbach, Karin alls if COMP3 adopted 3 Kadenbach, Theodoros Compatible with AM39 Skylakakis AM 40 Peter Liese alls if COMP3 adopted 3 Compatible with AM39 PE v /84 PV\ doc

55 3 3 AM 41 Zofija Mazej Kukovic, rançoise Grossetête, Anna Rosbach, Peter Liese, Esther de Lange alls if AM45 adopted alls if COMP3 adopted Compatible with AM39, 45, 40 AM 44 Daciana Octavia Sârbu alls if COMP3 adopted Compatible with AM39, 45, 40, 41, 42, 43 3 a 3 c 9 a 3 3a AM 46 Horst Schnellhardt alls if COMP3 adopted AM 52 Bart Staes alls if COMP3 adopted AM 80 Linda McAvan, Kriton alls if COMP3 adopted Arsenis AM 43 Bart Staes Vote in addition to COMP3 COMP 4 EPP, S&D, ALDE, Greens, ECR, GUE, ED Anna Maria Corazza Bildt If adopted, the following AM will fall:47,48, 49, 51 AM 47 alls if COMP4 adopted 3 a AM 48 Bart Staes alls if COMP4 adopted 3 a AM 49 Peter Liese alls if COMP4 adopted 3 a AM 51 Peter Liese alls if COMP4 adopted 3 b COMP 5 EPP, S&D, ALDE, If adopted, the following AM will 4a Greens, ECR, GUE, fall:50, 55, 64, 11(2nd part) ED AM 50 Bart Staes alls if COMP5 adopted 3 b AM 55 Christel Schaldemose, alls if COMP5 adopted 4 a Karin Kadenbach AM 64 Christel Schaldemose, alls if COMP5 adopted 6 b Karin Kadenbach AM 54 Bart Staes 4 AM 53 Anna Rosbach, Karin alls if AM54 adopted 4 Kadenbach AM 56 Christel Schaldemose, 5 Karin Kadenbach AM 57 Esther de Lange Compatible with AM56 5 AM 58 Christel Schaldemose, 6 Karin Kadenbach AM 59 Peter Liese Compatible with AM58 6 AM 60 Christel Schaldemose, PV\ doc 55/84 PE v0100