Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety

Transcription

1 EUROPEAN PARLIAMT Committee on the Environment, Public Health and ood Safety VI_PV(2011)0418_1 MINUTES Meeting of 18 April 2011, from to 18.30, and 19 April 2011, from 9.00 to and from to BRUSSELS The meeting opened at on Monday 18 April 2011, with Karl-Heinz lorenz in the chair. In the absence of the chairman and all 4 vice-chairs, Mr lorenz had been asked to chair as "the Member having held office for the longest period" (Rule 12(1) by analogy). 1. Adoption of agenda VI_OJ (2011)0418_1v02 The agenda was in the form shown in these minutes. 2. Chair's announcements 2.1. Interpretation Interpretation was available in all languages except for Estonian and Latvian. Maltese was available for the meeting with National Parliaments on 19 April 2011 up to hrs. 2.2 Welcome to visitors: The chairman drew attention to a meeting with representatives from National Parliaments in the afternoon of 19 April 2011 and announced that the Committee would meet members of the Environment Committee of the German Bundestag on 23 May 2011, hrs. 3. Amendment of Regulation (EC) No 648/2004 as regards the use of phosphates and other phosphorous compounds in household laundry detergents VI/7/04441 ***I 2010/0298(COD) COM(2010)0597 C7-0356/2010 PV\ doc PE v01 United in diversity

2 Rapporteur: Bill Newton Dunn (ALDE) PR PE v01-00 Responsible: VI Opinions: ITRE, IMCO Consideration of draft report Speakers: Bill Newton Dunn, Christa Klaß, Åsa Westlund, Bas Eickhout, Sabine Wils, Vittorio Prodi, Horst Schnellhardt, Kriton Arsenis, Karl-Heinz lorenz, Klaus Behrendt (Commission, DG TR) Deadline for tabling amendments: Wednesday 11 May 2011, in committee: Wednesday 15 June 2011 Adoption in plenary: September Amendment of Council Directive 2001/112/EC relating to fruit juices and certain similar products intended for human consumption VI/7/03880 ***I 2010/0254(COD) COM(2010)0490 C7-0278/2010 Rapporteur: Andres Perello Rodriguez (S&D) PR PE v02-00 Responsible: VI Opinions: AGRI Consideration of draft report Speakers: Andres Perello Rodriguez, Pilar Ayuso, Marina Yannakoudakis, Chris Davies, Christa Klaß, Horst Schnellhardt, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Esther de Lange, Karl-Heinz lorenz, Hermann Vesteylen (Commission, DG AGRI) Deadline for tabling amendments: Wednesday 20 April 2011, in committee: Tuesday 24 May 2011 Adoption in plenary: July Towards a stronger European disaster response: the role of civil protection and humanitarian assistance VI/7/ /2023(INI) COM(2010)0600 Rapporteur: Elisabetta Gardini (PPE) PR PE v01-00 Responsible: VI* Opinions: AET, DEVE*, REGI, LIBE Consideration of draft report Speakers: Elisabetta Gardini, Edite Estrela, Giommaria Uggias, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Vittorio Prodi, Birgit Schnieber-Jastram, rançoise Grossetête, Ian Clark (Commission, DG ECHO) PE v01 2/49 PV\ doc

3 Deadline for tabling amendments: Wednesday 11 May 2011, in committee: Wednesday 13 July 2011 Adoption in plenary: September II 2011 Jo Leinen (Chair) took the chair at Coordinators meeting see Annex I The meeting adjourned at and resumed on Tuesday 19 April 2011 at 9.10 with Jo Leinen (Chair) in the chair. 7. Amendment of Regulation (EC) No 1406/2002 establishing a European Maritime Safety Agency VI/7/04397 ***I 2010/0303(COD) COM(2010)0611 C7-0343/2010 Rapporteur for the Bart Staes (Verts/ALE) PA PE v01-00 opinion: AM PE v03-00 Responsible: TRAN Knut leckenstein (S&D) DT PE v01-00 Adoption of draft opinion Amendments : 26, 27, 28 (orally amended), 29, 9, 30, 11, 31, 32 (orally amended), 33, 13, 34, 37, 35, 36, 16, 18, 19, 20, 3, 4, 22, 21, 5, 25, 23 (orally amended), 24 All other amendments either fell, were rejected or withdrawn. The draft opinion, as amended, was : for: 58; against: 2; abstention(s): ood information to consumers VI/7/04868 ***II 2008/0028(COD) 17602/1/2010 C7-0060/2011 T7-0222/2010 Rapporteur: Renate Sommer (PPE) PR PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 Responsible: VI Adoption of draft recommendation for second reading Speakers: Glenis Willmott, Renate Sommer, Carl Schlyter, Åsa Westlund ollowing the adoption of Consolidated Amendment 4, Ms Glenis Willmott, shadow PV\ doc 3/49 PE v01

4 rapporteur of the S&D Group, made a procedural motion requesting that a separate vote be held on Amendment 214 (as an addition to Consolidated Amendment 4). Ms Renate Sommer, rapporteur, objected to that motion. The chair submitted the question to the committee for decision. The committee rejected Ms Willmott's request with 28 votes in favour, 34 against, without any abstentions. ollowing the rejection of Consolidated Amendment 6 and the subsequent adoption of Consolidated Amendment 7, Ms Sommer made a procedural motion saying that in these circumstances Amendment 291 should - contrary to the voting list - be considered as having fallen. Since Ms Willmott objected to that motion, the chairman submitted the question, whether a separate vote on Amendment 291 should be held or not, to the committee for decision. The committee decided with 30 votes in favour and 31 against, without any abstentions, that such a separate vote should not be held. Amendments : see Annex II The draft recommendation for second reading, as amended, was : for: 57; against: 4; abstention(s): GDP and beyond - Measuring progress in a changing world VI/7/ /2088(INI) COM(2009)0433 Rapporteur: Anna Rosbach (ECR) PR PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 Responsible: VI* Opinions: DEVE Nirj Deva (ECR) AD PE v02-00 AM PE v01-00 ECON* Nikolaos Chountis (GUE/NGL) AD PE v02-00 AM PE v03-00 EMPL Marian Harkin (ALDE) AD PE v02-00 AM PE v01-00 ITRE Marisa Matias (GUE/NGL) AD PE v02-00 AM PE v01-00 REGI Danuta Maria Hübner (PPE) AD PE v02-00 AM PE v01-00 Adoption of draft report Speakers: Jutta Haug, Anna Rosbach The chairman informed the committee that the rapporteur and the shadow rapporteurs had agreed on the following voting procedure: one single vote en bloc to reject all the amendments highlighted in the voting list in grey followed by one on the draft report as a whole. The committee agreed to that procedure by a vote. The committee rejected the highlighted amendments unanimously. Amendments : none PE v01 4/49 PV\ doc

5 The draft motion for a resolution was : for: 59; against: 1; abstention(s): 1. Dan Jørgensen (Vice-Chair) took the chair at hrs. 10. Oral question to the Commission on Nuclear safety 25 years after the Chernobyl disaster by Bogusław Sonik VI/7/05834 The oral question was unanimously. 11. Mobility and inclusion of people with disabilities and the European Disability Strategy VI/7/ /2272(INI) COM(2010)0636 Rapporteur for the Oreste Rossi (ED) PA PE v01-00 opinion: Responsible: EMPL Ádám Kósa (PPE) PR PE v01-00 Opinions: VI, CULT, LIBE, EMM, PETI Consideration of draft opinion Speakers: Oreste Rossi, Nessa Childers, Giommaria Uggias, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Vittorio Prodi, rançoise Grossetête, Adina-Ioana Vălean, Peter Liese, Annelisa Cotona (Commission, DG JUST) Deadline for tabling amendments: Tuesday 3 May 2011, in committee: Tuesday 24 May 2011 Adoption in plenary: June Energy infrastructure priorities for 2020 and beyond VI/7/ /2034(INI) COM(2010)0677 Rapporteur for the Rovana Plumb (S&D) opinion: Responsible: ITRE rancisco Sosa Wagner (NI) Opinions: VI, REGI Consideration of draft opinion PA PE v01-00 PR PE v02-00 AM PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 DT PE v01-00 PV\ doc 5/49 PE v01

6 Speakers: Rovana Plumb, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Sabine Wils, Vittorio Prodi, Peter Liese Deadline for tabling amendments: Monday 2 May 2011, in committee: Tuesday 24 May 2011 Adoption in plenary: July Diabetes drug "Médiator" VI/7/05752 Exchange of views Speakers: rançoise Grossetête, Gilles Pargneaux, Antonyia Parvanova, Michèle Rivasi, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Linda McAvan, Paola Testori-Coggi (Commission, Director General DG SANCO), Andreas Pott (EMA, acting Executive Director), Noël Wathion (EMA, Head of Unit), Etienne Marie (IGAS, rance, inspector and co-author of the report on the Médiator case) 14. Date and place of next meeting May 2011 Brussels Jo Leinen (Chair) took the chair at A debate with National Parliaments on Climate Change VI/7/05634 Exchange of views with national parliaments Session I - climate change Speakers: Eva Bulling-Schröter (Bundestag, Germany), Connie Heedegard (Commission), Jaqueline McGlade (EEA), Bruno Lafont (CEO Lafarge), Robert Lugar (Nationalrat, Austria), Leo Brincat (Kamra Tad-Deputati, Malta), Rovana Plumb, Marie Arena (Senat, Belgium), Hans-Josef ell (Bundestag, Germany), Chris Davies, Einārs Cilinskis (Saeima, Latvia), Jens Holm (Riksdagen, Sweden), Peter Liese, José Segura Cavell (Congreso de los Diputados, Spain), Sabine Wils, Roger Tiefensee (Riksdagen, Sweden), Vittorio Prodi Lars Hjälmered (Riksdagen, Sweden), Kriton Arsenis, Tommaso oti (Camera dei Deputati, Italy), ernand Boden (Chambre des deputés, Luxembourg), Satu Hassi, María Amparo errando Sendra (Congreso de los Diputados, Spain) Session II - EU priorities for COP17 in Durban, South Africa PE v01 6/49 PV\ doc

7 Speakers: Benedek Jávor (Országgyülés, Hungary), Christan igueres (UNCCC), Nolundi Dikweni (Deputy Ambassador, South Africa), Konstantinos Kartalis (Vouli ton Ellinon, Greece), Tomas Wyns (Climate Action Network Europe), Silva Črnugelj (Državni Zbor, Slovenia), Hermann Ott (Bundestag, Germany), Vittorio Prodi, Leo Brincat (Kamra Tad-Deputati, Malta), Robert Lugar (Nationalrat, Austria), Sabine Wils, José Segura Cavell (Congreso de los Diputados, Spain), Nick Griffin, Hans- Josef ell (Bundestag, Germany) Einārs Cilinskis (Saeima, Latvia), Kriton Arsenis, Sara Karlsson (Riksdagen, Sweden) The meeting closed at hrs. PV\ doc 7/49 PE v01

8 Annex I EUROPEAN PARLIAMT COMMITTEE ON THE VIRONMT, PUBLIC HEALTH AND OOD SAETY CO-ORDINATORS' MEETING - not to be treated in full committee - Monday 18 April 2011, JAN 2Q2 Brussels RESULTS Present Mr Leinen, Chairman Mr Liese, Co-coordinator of the EPP Group Ms McAvan, Coordinator of the S&D Group Mr Davies, Coordinator of the ALDE Group Ms Girling, representative of the Coordinator of the ECR Group Ms Hassi, Coordinator of the Greens/EA Group Also present Mr Sonik, 3rd vice-chair Apologies Mr Seeber, Co-coordinator of the EPP Group Mr Ouzký, Coordinator of the ECR Group Mr Rossi, Coordinator of the ED Group Ms Liotard, Coordinator of the GUE/NGL Group A. APPOINTMT O RAPPORTEURS AND DRATSPERSONS DECISION ON PROCEDURES Reports A.1. A Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050 VI/7/05827 PE v01 8/49 PV\ doc

9 COM(2011)0112 Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the ALDE Group. Opinions A.2. The European Semester for economic policy coordination VI/7/05779 Responsible: ECON 2011/2071(INI) COM(2011)0011 Decision: Rapporteur for opinion to be nominated by the EPP Group. Documents received for information None * * * B. DECISIONS ON ADDITIONAL REPORTS/OPINIONS/RESOLUTIONS Item B.1 is OR INORMATION ONLY- NO ACTION REQUIRED B.1. Information on non-legislative activities B.1.1. Ongoing own-initiative reports (no more than 6 at any given time)( 1 ): 1 The following INI reports were recently: Commission Green Paper with the title "On orest Protection and Information in the EU: Preparing forests for climate change" (COM(2010)66) - authorised by CoP on ; Rule 50 with AGRI - S&D rapporteur Mr Arsenis; was on 16 March 2011 Solidarity in health: Reducing health inequalities (COM(2009)0567) - authorised by CoP on ; VI rapporteur: Ms ESTRELA, S&D; on 25 January 2011 "Evaluation of the management of H1N1 influenza in in the EU"; authorisation by CoP of ; rapporteur: Ms RIVASI, Greens/EA, on 25 January 2011 Action plan on Organ Donation and Transplantation ( ): Strengthened cooperation between Member States (PERELLO - on 16 March 2010) White Paper: Adapting to climate change: Towards a European framework for action (PRODI - on 16 March 2010) Action against Cancer: European Partnership (PETELE - on 7 April 2010) Management of bio-waste in the European Union (ERNANDES - on 2 June 2010) A Community approach on the prevention of natural and man made disasters (ERREIRA - on 22 June 2010) PV\ doc 9/49 PE v01

10 GDP and beyond (authorised by CoP on ; Rule 50 with ECON; Rapporteur Ms ROSBACH, ECR, rejected on 25 January 2011; a fresh report was submitted for March 2011, to be on 19 April 2011 Commission communication "Analysis of options to move beyond 20% greenhouse gas emission reductions and assessing the risk of carbon leakage"; Rule 50 with ITRE, approved by CoP on 13 January 2011; rapporteur: Mr EICKHOUT, Greens/EA; adoption scheduled for 24 May 2011 in VI Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: Towards a stronger European disaster response: the role of civil protection and humanitarian assistance (COM(2010)0600) - decision of 30 November 2010 by coordinators to seek authorisation for an own-initiative report; agreement with DEVE to apply Rule 50 in CCC on 19 January rapporteur Ms GARDINI, EPP; adoption tentatively scheduled for 13 July 2011 On 17 ebruary 2011, the coordinators decided to request the authorisation of an owninitiative report with the title "Resource Efficient Europe" - authorised by CCC on 5 April 2011 as a 'strategic report' - rapporteur Mr GERBRANDY, ALDE Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: A Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050 (COM(2011)0112) - Coordinators' decision of 12 April 2011: 1) Decision of principle to request authorisation to draw up an own-initiative report. 2) Given that the Eickhout report deals with stepping up the GHG reduction target beyond 20% by 2020, the new report should focus on the post 2020 perspective. 3) Appointment of the rapporteur at the next coordinators' meeting. B.1.2. Ongoing implementation report (only one per year) 1 implementation report for the year 2010 on "EU legislation on Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathies (TSE) and on related feed and food controls - implementation and outlook" - decisions of the coordinators of 20 September authorised by Conference of Committee Chairs on 19 October rapporteur: Ms ROTH-BEHRDT, S&D; adoption scheduled for 24 May B.2. Short-list of possible candidates for own-initiative reports: - Communications on implementing the biofuel sustainability scheme (coordinators' decision of 14 July 2010) together with the Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council on the feasibility of drawing up lists of areas in third countries with low greenhouse gas emissions from cultivation (COM(2010)0427) - coordinators' decision of 9 September on 20 September 2010, the coordinators agreed that the issue of 'the review of the 6th EAP and the setting of priorities for the 7th EAP' should be short-listed as a candidate for a possible own-initiative report A European initiative on Alzheimer s disease and other dementias (COM(2009)0380) - authorised by CoP on ; VI rapporteur: Ms MATIAS, GUE/NGL, on 30 November The implementation report for 2009 was in VI on 14 July 2010: The DE LANGE report on the Implementation of EU legislation aiming at the conservation of biodiversity PE v01 10/49 PV\ doc

11 - Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: Marine knowledge marine data and observation for smart and sustainable growth COM(2010) coordinators' decision of 5 October Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: Mid-term review of the LIE Regulation (COM(2010)516) - coordinators' decision of 28 October Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: Towards an enhanced market oversight framework for the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (COM(2010)0796) - coordinators' decision of 26 January 2011 B.3. or information: Table on 1st and 2nd reading agreements - possible application of Rule 70 The papers for the meeting included an updated table of 8 April 2011 on the state of negotiations with a view to achieving possible first and second reading agreements. C. DECISIONS ON OTHER ISSUES C.1. Structured dialogue implementation of the Commission Work Programme 2011, VI priorities for CWP 2012 The papers for the meeting include - a letter of 9 March 2011 from Mr Lehne - a draft dated 6 April 2011 with possible contributions, based on input from the political groups. As every year, the parliamentary committees are invited to make their contributions to the 'structured dialogue' exercise which is now taking place on the basis of the new ramework Agreement. Committees have been invited to i. submit their remarks on the implementation of the CWP for 2011 ii. identify a limited number of political or legislative priorities for 2012 iii. propose one item as a possible EP priority for 2012 Proposed action The coordinators examined the draft with the committee's priorities for the Structured Dialogue exercise and to approved it, with the following additions: call for a new Novel ood proposal call for a new Mercury Strategy call for legislative proposals tackling CO2 emissions from maritime transport and non-co2 emissions from aviation The amended draft shall be circulated for information before its being forwarded to the Conference of Committee Chairs. PV\ doc 11/49 PE v01

12 C.2. Delegation to Calabria - proposal to transform the request for an ad hoc delegation into an ordinary VI delegation Proposed action The coordinators decided that the request to send an ad hoc delegation to Calabria should be transformed into a request for an ordinary VI delegation (with the places to be allocated within the annual quota of the committee) and instructed the chairman to inform the Conference of Presidents of that decision. C.3. Delegation to EMA, London - final decision on composition Decision 1) The coordinators agreed that (i) 'local Members' and (ii) Members travelling at their own expenses should be authorised to join the VI delegation to the EMA, London, on June ) The chair was instructed to write to the President in order to reiterate the committee's request that additional Members should be allowed to travel (a) on the basis of the general committee quota and/or (b) on the basis of the Members' 'additional travel expenses allowance' pursuant to Article 22 of the Implementing Measures for the Members' Statute. C.4. irst reading agreements - practical implications of the decision of the Conference of Presidents of 10 March 2011 Decision The coordinators decided to maintain VI's current approach on the application of Rule 70 and to return to the matter when the Committee on Constitutional Affairs would have finalised its review of Rule 70. PE v01 12/49 PV\ doc

13 C.4a. Correlation tables Decision ollowing an exchange of views, the coordinators agreed that all rapporteurs should be encouraged to defend Parliament's institutional position on the matter, that is to insist on the inclusion of mandatory correlation tables in negotiations on first and second reading agreements. C.5. Draft Voluntary Agreement to be concluded under the Ecodesign Directive The papers for the meeting included - a cover note and - a Voluntary Industry Agreement under Directive 2009/125/EC to improve the energy efficiency of Complex Set Top Boxes and the impact assessment thereof Decision The coordinators decided to invite the Commission (a) to present the draft voluntary agreement at a future committee meeting and (b) to submit the most recent version of the draft; decided to invite the Director-General of the responsible Commission DG to a future committee meeting in order to submit evidence as to the application of those provisions of the Ecodesign Directive which allow the conclusion of Voluntary Agreements; reserved their decision on the possible application of Rule 85(2) (preparation of a draft resolution). C.6. Oral Question on Chernobyl (Rule 115) The papers for the meeting include a draft Oral Question submitted by Mr Sonik as well as an amended version circulated by Ms Hassi Decision The coordinators invited Mr Sonik and Ms Hassi to submit a joint proposal for an Oral Question (Rule 115) and decided to put it on the agenda of the Committee meeting of 19 April for adoption, with a view to its inclusion on the agenda of the May part-session. C.7. Bluefin Tuna - ICCAT mandate for the establishment of the annual catch quota - invitation to Commissioner Damanaki - request from the S&D Group PV\ doc 13/49 PE v01

14 Proposed action The coordinators instructed the chairman to request a Legal Opinion from the Legal Service on the legal requirements governing the adoption of EU negotiation mandates under the ICCAT convention and decided to invite Commissioner Damanaki to the VI committee, in order to explain the process which led to the adoption of the catch quota for 2011 and to present the Commission's strategy with a view to setting a sustainable catch quota for C.8. Request by the EPP to organize a hearing on the own initiative report on the European disaster response Decision The coordinators decided that a workshop (to be financed from VI's expertise budget) on European Disaster Response be held outside a committee meeting. Rapporteurs from DEVE, REGI and AET should be involved. The detailed specifications shall be agreed in a follow-up written procedure. C.9. Request by the EPP to prepare an Oral Question with a resolution for plenary (Rule 115) on the "introduction of a comprehensive approach towards the reduction of climate-relevant gases emissions other than CO2" The papers for the meeting include a draft oral question from the EPP Group on the "Introduction of a comprehensive approach towards the reduction of climate-relevant gases emissions other than CO2". Decision The coordinators decided to include the draft Oral Question plus resolution (Rule 115) in the agenda of the next VI meeting for adoption. The text of the Oral Question and of the draft resolution shall be prepared by political group staff with the assistance of the secretariat. PE v01 14/49 PV\ doc

15 C.10. Request by ALDE to prepare an VI Oral Question in plenary (Rule 115) on environmentally harmful subsidies Decision The coordinators decided that the above Oral Question for debate in plenary (Rule 115) be submitted to the committee for adoption at its next meeting. C.11. Information of the EP about international negotiations - report by the Commission on the UNEP Mercury negotiation on a global legally binding instrument on mercury The papers for the meeting included - a cover letter of 21 March 2011 from Mr alkenberg and - a report by the Commission on the participation of the EU in the second session of the intergovernmental negotiating committee on a global legally binding instrument on mercury (INC-2, Chiba (Japan), January 2011) Decision The coordinators took note of the above report, submitted in accordance with Article 218(10) TEU and Annex III of the new ramework Agreement 1. The coordinators expressed the wish to be equally informed about other international negotiations (i) in the form of an overview rolling table and (ii) in the form of detailed reports where this is justified by the particular interest of the matter. The chairman was invited to write a letter in that sense to Mr alkenberg. C.12. Presentation on "how satellite observations can contribute to monitoring, verification and adaptation" Decision The coordinators agreed that a presentation on the possible contributions of satellite observations to MRV be given during a future VI meeting. C.13. European Green Belt - proposal by Mr Weiger from BUND The papers for the meeting included letter dated 9 March 2011 by Mr Weiger, chair of the Bund für Umwelt- und Naturschutz Deutschland (BUND), to give a presentation of the European Green Belt project before the VI committee DOCXMLV0//&language=&navigationBar=YES PV\ doc 15/49 PE v01

16 Decision The coordinators agreed that the European Green Belt project be presented in the VI committee during its July meeting. D. DOCUMTS OR INORMATION * * * 1) Note of 15 April 2011 on the timing of VI hearings and delegations in ) Letter from Mr Nymand-Christensen, Director at the SG of the European Commission, to Mr Leinen, on comitology procedures. PE v01 16/49 PV\ doc

17 Annex II VOTING RESULTS Draft recommendation for second reading on the Council position at first reading with a view to the adoption of a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the proposal for the PROVISION O OOD INORMATION TO CONSUMERS 2008/0028 (COD) PR - PE v01-00 / AM- PE v01-00 Rapporteur: Renate Sommer Concerned text AM Tabled by Remarks/ ARTICLES COMP1 Sommer (EPP), Willmott (S&D), Gerbrandy (ALDE), Schlyter (Greens/EA), Liotard (GUE/NGL), Stevenson (ECR), Rossi (ED) If, AMs 43, 44, 45, 162, 163, 164, 165, 166, 167, 168, 169, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 179, 180, 182, 183, 184, 185, 186 (or parts of them) fall COMP2 COMP3 CONS4 CONS5 CONS6 Sommer (EPP), Willmott (S&D), Gerbrandy (ALDE), Schlyter (Greens/EA), Liotard (GUE/NGL), Stevenson (ECR), Rossi (ED) Sommer (EPP), Willmott (S&D), Gerbrandy (ALDE), Schlyter (Greens/EA), Liotard (GUE/NGL), Stevenson (ECR), Rossi (ED) Willmott (S&D), Schlyter (Greens/EA), Liotard (GUE/NGL), Rossi (ED) Sommer (EPP), Gerbrandy (ALDE), Stevenson (ECR), Willmott (S&D), Gerbrandy (ALDE), Schlyter (Greens/EA), Liotard (GUE/NGL) If AMs 52, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202, 203, 204 (or parts of them) fall If AMs 38, 53, 101, 103 fall If AMs 55, 159, , 398, 399 (or parts of them) fall alls if CONS4 If AMs 55, 159, , , (or parts of them) fall If AMs 70, 291, 293, 294, 295, 296, 297, 298, 299, 300, 301, 302, 304, 307 (or parts of them) fall 36/23/3-29/32/1 CONS7 Sommer (EPP), Stevenson (ECR), Rossi (ED) alls if CONS6 If AMs 72, 284, 72, 302, 304, 306, 307, 308, 309, 310 (or parts of them) fall PV\ doc 17/49 PE v01

18 137 Rapporteur Split vote by the ALDE and GUE/NGL: Article 1 paragraph 3 1st part: rom "3. This Regulation applies... for immediate consumption" 2nd part: rom "Catering services... within Union territory." - 25/36/1 20 Rapporteur alls if AM 137 Article 1 - paragraph 3 a (new) 21 Rapporteur Split vote by the Greens/EA: 1st part: rom "3a. This regulation... of organisation" Article point d Article point e Article 2 point e a (new) 2nd part: rom "Operations such... this Regulation" 22 Rapporteur 23 Rapporteur 138 Rapporteur Split vote by the ED: 1st part: rom "Handcrafted food'... techniques." 2nd part: rom "In order... qualification." Article Oreste Rossi point - g 140 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi Article Andres Perello Rodriguez point k Article 2 24 Rapporteur point k a (new) Article 2 point k b (new) 25 Rapporteur Article Oreste Rossi Deletion 37/25/0 PE v01 18/49 PV\ doc

19 point 143 Marianne Thyssen o 144 Andres Perello Rodriguez Article 2 point o a (new) Article 2 point p a (new) Article 2 point q a (new) Article 3 - paragraph 1 Article 3 - paragraph 1 a (new) 26 Rapporteur 27 Rapporteur 145 Kartika Tamara Liotard 33/27/1 28 Rapporteur - 29 Rapporteur Split vote by the S&D: 1st part: whole AM without the word "average" Article 3 paragraph 3 Article 4 - paragraph 1 - point b subpoint ii Article 4 paragraph 1 point b subpoint iii Article 4 Article 7 - paragraph 1 Article 7 paragraph 1 point b a (new) Article 7 paragraph 1 point b a (new) Article 7 paragraph 1 point b b (new) 2nd part: this word Struan Stevenson 30a Rapporteur 147 Theodoros Skylakakis 30b Rapporteur Deletion - 25/36/1 31 Rapporteur Theodoros Skylakakis alls if AM Rapporteur 34/28/0 149 Kartika Tamara Liotard Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi alls if AM /28/0 150 Kartika Tamara Liotard PV\ doc 19/49 PE v01

20 Article 7 paragraph 1 point 151 Kartika Tamara Liotard b c (new) - Article 7 paragraph 1 point b b (new) 153 Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi Article rancesco Enrico Speroni* Inadmissible, Rule 63 (4) paragraph 1 point d Article 8 - paragraph 1 33 Rapporteur Withdrawn W Article 8 - Article 8 - paragraph 3 Article 8 - paragraph 4 Article 8 - paragraph 5 34 Rapporteur Withdrawn W 35 Rapporteur - 36 Rapporteur Withdrawn W Deletion 37 Rapporteur Deletion - Article 8 paragraph 6 Article 9 paragraph 1 point e Article 9 paragraph 1 point f a (new) Article 9 paragraph 1 point h Article 9 paragraph 1 point k Article 9 - Article 9 - paragraph 3 Article Rapporteur Article Rapporteur Deletion PE v01 20/49 PV\ doc 155 Åsa Westlund, Christel Schaldemose*, Dan Jørgensen 157 Oreste Rossi, Giancarlo Scottà 38 Rapporteur 158 Mario Pirillo, Licia Ronzulli, Elisabetta Gardini, Oreste Rossi, Rosario Crocetta, Sergio Berlato 160 Kartika Tamara Liotard alls if COMP3 Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) 39 Rapporteur 40/19/2 40 Rapporteur Deletion - 27/35/0 Article 9 a (new) 156 Marianne Thyssen - -

21 paragraph 3 Article Rapporteur paragraph Oreste Rossi alls if COMP1 Article 13 Article 13 a (new) Article 13 paragraph Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, rédérique Ries alls if COMP1 alls if AM Thomas Ulmer alls if COMP1 alls if AM 163 or Elisabetta Gardini, Sergio alls if COMP1 Berlato, Salvatore Tatarella, Split vote by the S&D and Paolo Bartolozzi, Licia the ECR: Ronzulli, Crescenzio Rivellini, Cristiana alls if AM 163 or 166 or Muscardini, Anna Záborská, 165 Mario Pirillo, Vittorio Prodi, 1st part: rom "Without Oreste Rossi, Pilar Ayuso, prejudice to specific Union Rosario Crocetta, Cristina provisions... greater that 1 Gutiérrez-Cortines mm. " 164 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Elzbieta Katarzyna alls if AM 163 or 166 or Lukacijewska, Boguslaw 165 Sonik, Jaroslaw Kalinowski 2nd part: rom "Criteria other 167 Holger Krahmer... also be considered." 168 János Áder 169 rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries alls if COMP1 alls if AM 163 or 166 or 165 or 162/164/167/ 168 (1 st or 2 nd ) 43 Rapporteur alls if COMP1 alls if AM 163 or 166 or 165 or 162/164/167/ 168 (1 st or 2 nd ) or rançoise Grossetête, alls if COMP1 rédérique Ries 181 Horst Schnellhardt Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) 170 Holger Krahmer Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) 172 Oreste Rossi alls if COMP1 Deletion PV\ doc 21/49 PE v01

22 173 Elisabetta Gardini, Sergio Berlato, Salvatore Tatarella, Paolo Bartolozzi, Licia Ronzulli, Crescenzio Rivellini, Cristiana alls if COMP1 Muscardini, Anna Záborská, Vittorio Prodi, Mario Pirillo, Oreste Rossi, Pilar Ayuso, all if AM 172 Rosario Crocetta, Cristina Gutiérrez-Cortines 174 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Elzbieta Katarzyna Lukacijewska, Jaroslaw Kalinowski, Boguslaw Sonik 175 Holger Krahmer Article 13 paragraph János Áder alls if COMP1 all if AM 172 or 173/174/ rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries 177 Thomas Ulmer alls if COMP1 alls if AM 172 or 173/174/175 or 176/ Miroslav Ouzký, Jan alls if COMP1 Brezina* alls if AM 172 or 173/174/175 or 176/179 or Riikka Manner alls if COMP1 alls if AM 172 or 173/174/175 or 176/179 or 177 or Oreste Rossi alls if COMP1 183 Deletion Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, rédérique Ries 44 Rapporteur alls if COMP1 alls if AM 182/ Oreste Rossi alls if COMP1 Article 13 paragraph 5 subparagraph 1 45a Rapporteur alls if COMP1 Deletion Part a: the deletion of the first point of Art. 13(5) 185 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, rédérique Ries alls if COMP1 alls if AM 44 PE v01 22/49 PV\ doc

23 Article 13 paragraph 5 sub b Oreste Rossi Rapporteur alls if COMP1 Deletion alls if COMP1 alls if AM 186 Part b: from the "or the purpose of... of foods." 187 Kartika Tamara Liotard - Article 13 paragraph 6 46 Rapporteur Article 13 paragraph 7 47 Rapporteur Article Jill Evans Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) Article Rapporteur a (new) Article Oreste Rossi paragraph Boguslaw Sonik Article 16 Article 16 paragraph 4 subparagraph 1 Article 16 paragraph 4 sub 49 Rapporteur - 25/35/2 191 Holger Krahmer Complementary to AM 49 as addition 50 Rapporteur 34/26/1 193 Struan Stevenson Oral AM by the ECR: Text change: rom " beverages should be exempted, " to " beverages should in future be included, " 194a except footnote 192a except footnote Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi Glenis Willmott, Antonyia Parvanova, Åsa Westlund alls if AM 193 (or with OA) in substance - PV\ doc 23/49 PE v01

24 51a Rapporteur Split vote by the S&D: 1st part: rom "The Commission shall produce a report... alcopops" Article 16 paragraph 4 subparagraph 3 Article 18 paragraph 1 a (new) Article 19 Article 21 paragraph 1 - sub Article 21 paragraph 1 subparagraph 3 2nd part: rom "concerning the... containing alcohol" alls if AM 193 (or with OA) or 194a/192a 192b Glenis Willmott, Antonyia Withdrawn W footnote Parvanova, Åsa Westlund 194b Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi footnote 30/29/2 195 Glenis Willmott, Antonyia Parvanova, Michèle Rivasi, 36/25/0 Åsa Westlund, Carl Schlyter 51b Rapporteur alls if AM 195 rom The Commission may Articles 50 and Åsa Westlund, Christel - Schaldemose*, Dan Jørgensen 197 Rapporteur 52a Rapporteur alls if COMP2 rom "In any event,... listed in Annex II" 198 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy 199 Struan Stevenson 200 Esther de Lange 201 Oreste Rossi, Giancarlo Scottà alls if COMP2 Deletion Article 21 paragraph 1 - subparagraph 4 52b Rapporteur alls if COMP2 Withdrawn rom "Where the possibility of... outlined in Annex II" W Article Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy paragraph 1 subparagraph Struan Stevenson alls if COMP2 alls if AM 52b PE v01 24/49 PV\ doc

25 204 Esther de Lange Article 21 Article 23 paragraph 1 point b a (new) 205 Rapporteur 206 Horst Schnellhardt 207 Thomas Ulmer, Holger Krahmer 208 Esther de Lange Inadmissible, Rule 66 (2) Article Rapporteur Article 24 - title 53 Rapporteur alls if COMP3 Article 24 paragraph 3 introductory part Article 9 paragraph 1 point i (relevant to Art. 25) 210 Rapporteur 213 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi 159a Dan Jørgensen, Christel Schaldemose*, Sirpa Pietikäinen alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 213 rom "The country... following:" 212 Oreste Rossi alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 213 or 159a point b Article 9 paragraph 1 point i (relevant to Art. 25) point b a (new) point a 223a 159b 225, , 235 & 236 Dagmar Roth-Behrendt Dan Jørgensen, Christel Schaldemose*, Sirpa Pietikäinen Kartika Tamara Liotard alls if CONS4 or CONS5 in substance rom "- meat... processed foods" en block 218a Oreste Rossi alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 223a/159b/ 225/233/234/235/236 rom "- meat... processed foods" PV\ doc 25/49 PE v01

26 211a Mario Pirillo, Rosario alls if CONS4 or CONS5 point Crocetta b b (new) 229,230 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, alls if AM 231 & Michèle Rivasi 223a/159b/225/233/234/ /236 or 218a AMs order from "(ba) for dairy products... processed Article 9 paragraph 1 point i (relevant to Art. 25) subparagraph b a 222 Glenis Willmott, Åsa Westlund 227 Glenis Willmott, Åsa Westlund, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi, Carl Schlyter 159c Dan Jørgensen, Christel Schaldemose*, Sirpa Pietikäinen Kartika Tamara Liotard Dagmar Roth-Behrendt Oreste Rossi 216a 223b 218b (new) 215 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi 214 Glenis Willmott, Åsa Westlund, Kartika Tamara indent 1 (new) Liotard foods" alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 223a/159b/ 225/233/234/235/236 or 218a Complementary to AM 211a/229/230/231/232 as addition alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 223a/159b/ 225/233/234/235/236 or 218a or 211a/229/230/231/232 Complementary to AM 222 as addition alls if CONS4 or CONS5 AMs from "rom meat and poultry,... shall be given" alls if CONS4 or CONS5 indent 1 (new) 217 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 214 Article 9 paragraph 1 point i (relevant to Art. 25) 159d 211b Dan Jørgensen, Christel Schaldemose*, Sirpa Pietikäinen Mario Pirillo, Rosario Crocetta alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 214 or 217 PE v01 26/49 PV\ doc

27 216b Kartika Tamara Liotard AMs text from "Where there 223c Dagmar Roth-Behrendt are reasons... unspecified origin" Article 9 159e Dan Jørgensen, Christel alls if CONS4 or CONS5 paragraph 1 point i Schaldemose*, Sirpa (relevant to Art. 25) Pietikäinen rom "or all other foods,... point a Article 35(5);" 218c Oreste Rossi alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 159e 219 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi Oral AM by the ED: Text change: "or all other foods,... in accordance with the rules laid down in Article 49 and subject to the conditions laid down in Articles 50 and 51." alls if CONS4 or CONS5 point b subparagraph b a (new) subparagraph b a (new) paragraph Oreste Rossi 221 Marianne Thyssen 224 rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries 226 Mario Pirillo, Rosario Crocetta 228 rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries 237 James Nicholson 238 Oreste Rossi 239 Marianne Thyssen alls if AM 159e or 218c alls if CONS4 or CONS5 Deletion alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 220/221 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AM 220/221 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if CONS4 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 Deletion PV\ doc 27/49 PE v01

28 240 Andres Perello Rodriguez 241 Thomas Ulmer paragraph 3 subparagraph 1 introductory part Esther de Lange Holger Krahmer paragraph 3 subparagraph 1 introductory part paragraph 3 subparagraph 1 point a paragraph 3 subparagraph 1 point b paragraph 3 subparagraph 1 point a bis (new) 244 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi 245 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi 247 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi 246 rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries, Elisabetta Gardini alls if CONS4 or CONS5 all if AM 238/239/240 Deletion alls if CONS4 or CONS5 en block, same concept alls if AMs 238/239/240 or 241/242/243 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 paragraph 3 sub 248 Mario Pirillo, Rosario Crocetta alls if CONS4 or CONS5 paragraph Oreste Rossi 250 Marianne Thyssen 54 Rapporteur alls if CONS4 or CONS5 Deletion alls if CONS4 or CONS5 paragraph Oreste Rossi 252 Marianne Thyssen alls if AMs 249/250 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 253 Mario Pirillo, Rosario Crocetta Deletion PE v01 28/49 PV\ doc

29 254 Dagmar Roth-Behrendt alls if CONS4 or CONS5 paragraph 5 subparagraph 1 introductory part alls if AMs 251/252/253 paragraph 5 subparagraph 1 introductory part paragraph 5 subparagraph 1 a (new) paragraph 5 subparagraph 1 point f paragraph 5 subparagraph 1 point g Article 25 - paragraph 5 sub 255 Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans, Michèle Rivasi Deletion alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AMs 251/252/253 or AM Struan Stevenson alls if CONS4 257 rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries 258 rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries 259 Giancarlo Scottà 260 Esther de Lange paragraph 5 subparagraph 3 a (new) rédérique Ries, rançoise Grossetête, Elisabetta Gardini János Áder alls if AMs 251/252/253 or AM 254 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AMs 251/252/253 or AM 254 Deletion alls if CONS4 or CONS5 alls if AMs 251/252/253 or AM 254 Deletion alls if CONS4 or CONS5 all if AMs 251/252/253 alls if CONS4 or CONS5 PV\ doc 29/49 PE v01

30 267 Elisabetta Gardini, Sergio Berlato, Salvatore Tatarella, Paolo Bartolozzi, Licia Ronzulli, Crescenzio Rivellini, Cristiana Muscardini, Anna Záborská, Mario Pirillo, Vittorio Prodi, Oreste Rossi, Pilar Ayuso, rançoise Grossetête, rédérique Ries, Rosario Crocetta, Cristina Gutiérrez- Cortines 268 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Elzbieta Katarzyna Lukacijewska, Jaroslaw Kalinowski, Boguslaw Sonik 263 Oreste Rossi alls if CONS4 or CONS5 264 Marianne Thyssen Deletion 55 Rapporteur alls if CONS4 or CONS5 paragraph 6 Article 26 - paragraph 1 Article 26 Article 29 paragraph 1 subparagraph 1 point b alls if AMs 263/ rançoise Grossetête, alls if CONS4 or CONS5 rédérique Ries alls if AMs 263/ Mario Pirillo, Rosario alls if CONS4 or CONS5 Crocetta alls if AMs 263/ Rapporteur 269 Rapporteur 270 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Antonyia Parvanova, Corinne Lepage 274 Andres Perello Rodriguez in substance - 29/30/1 276 Glenis Willmott, Daciana Octavia Sârbu, Michèle Rivasi, Åsa Westlund, Carl Schlyter, Kartika Tamara Liotard en block -same concept Complementary to AM 270/274 as addition 32/28/2 PE v01 30/49 PV\ doc

31 271 Glenis Willmott, Carl Schlyter, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Michèle Rivasi, Jill Evans 272 Åsa Westlund, Christel alls if AMs 270/274 or Schaldemose*, Dan 271/276 Jørgensen 273 rédérique Ries in substance Article 29 Article 29 point a 275 Giommaria Uggias, Sergio Paolo rancesco Silvestris* Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) 57b Rapporteur "(fb) novel sugars" 34/29/0 277 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Antonyia Parvanova, Corinne 36/24/0 Lepage 278 Glenis Willmott, Daciana Deletion Octavia Sârbu, Michèle Rivasi, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Carl Schlyter 279 rédérique Ries 57a Rapporteur "(fa) cholesterol" Article 29 point d a (new) 280 Esther de Lange Article 29 point f a (new) Esther de Lange rançoise Grossetête, Pilar Ayuso, Cristina Gutiérrez- Cortines Article 29 paragraph 3 58 Rapporteur Deletion Kartika Tamara Liotard Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) Article 29 paragraph 4 Article 29 paragraph 5 Article 29 paragraph 6 Article 30 Article 30 paragraph 4 sub 59 Rapporteur Deletion - 26/34/1 285 Kartika Tamara Liotard alls if AM Rapporteur Deletion - 61 Rapporteur Deletion Rapporteur 287 Rapporteur PV\ doc 31/49 PE v01

32 Article Rapporteur paragraph 3 Article Rapporteur en block, same concept paragraph 1 Article Rapporteur Article Rapporteur paragraph 4 Article Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Glenis Willmott 35/27/0 Article 31 paragraph 4 Article 31 paragraph 4 a (new) Article 32 - paragraph 1 Article 32 - Article 32 paragraph Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy - 66 Rapporteur 67 Rapporteur 68 Rapporteur Deletion 290 Rapporteur Split vote by the ED: 1 st part: whole AM except replacement of "may" with "shall" 69 Rapporteur 2 nd part: this replacement Article 33 paragraph Glenis Willmott, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi, Jill Evans alls if CONS6 292 Kartika Tamara Liotard alls if CONS6 alls if AM 58 - Article Glenis Willmott, Carl Schlyter, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Michèle Rivasi, Jill Evans alls if AM 291 alls if CONS6 alls if AM /27/0 Article 33 a (new) Article Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Antonyia Parvanova, Corinne Lepage alls if CONS6 alls if AM /32/1 PE v01 32/49 PV\ doc

33 paragraph 294 Elisabetta Gardini, Sergio Berlato, Salvatore Tatarella, Paolo Bartolozzi, Licia Ronzulli, Crescenzio Rivellini, Cristiana Muscardini, Anna Záborská, Vittorio Prodi, Mario Pirillo, Oreste Rossi, Rosario alls if CONS6 Crocetta 295 Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Elzbieta Katarzyna alls if AM 291 or 297 Lukacijewska, Jaroslaw Kalinowski, Boguslaw Sonik 298 Pavel Poc János Áder Article 33 - b (new) Article 33 paragraph 3 introductory part 301 Horst Schnellhardt alls if CONS6 alls if AM 291 or 297 or 294/295/298/ Rapporteur alls if CONS6 alls if AM 291 or 297 or 294/295/298/300 or Thomas Ulmer alls if CONS6 alls if AM 291 or 297 or 294/295/298/300 or 301 or Miroslav Ouzký, Jan Brezina* alls if CONS6 alls if AM 291 or 297 or 294/295/298/300 or 301 or 70 or Rapporteur 35/27/0 304 Elisabetta Gardini, Sergio alls if CONS6 or CONS7 Berlato, Salvatore Tatarella, Paolo Bartolozzi, Licia Ronzulli, Crescenzio Split vote by the EPP: Rivellini, Anna Záborská, Oreste Rossi, Vittorio Prodi, 1st part: "Where the labelling Mario Pirillo, Rosario... per 100g/ml and per Crocetta portion." nd part: "In addition,... maybe repeated thereon:" PV\ doc 33/49 PE v01

34 302 Anna Záborská alls if CONS6 or CONS7 Split vote by the EPP: alls if AM st part 1st part: "Where the labelling... per 100g/ml and per portion." alls if AM 304 2nd part 2nd part: "In addition,... maybe repeated thereon:" 284 Thomas Ulmer alls if CONS7 alls if AM 304 (1 st or 2 nd ) or 302 (1 st or 2 nd ) AM tabled in Article 29 paragraph 3, but it is related to Article 33 paragraph 3 72 Rapporteur alls if CONS7 alls if AM 304 (1 st or 2 nd ) or 302 (1 st or 2 nd ) or Kartika Tamara Liotard Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) Article 33 paragraph 3 subparagraph 1 (new) 305 Kartika Tamara Liotard Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) 306 Kartika Tamara Liotard alls if CONS7 Article 33 Deletion paragraph 3 point 307 Anja Weisgerber alls if CONS6 or CONS7 a alls if AM 306 Article 33 paragraph 3 point b Kartika Tamara Liotard Anja Weisgerber alls if CONS7 Deletion alls if CONS7 alls if AM 308 Article Anja Weisgerber paragraph 3 point b a (new) alls if CONS7 Article Rapporteur - paragraph 4 Article Rapporteur PE v01 34/49 PV\ doc

35 paragraph 5 74 Rapporteur alls if AM 311 sub Article Rapporteur Deletion - paragraph 6 Article 34 - paragraph 5 footnote Oreste Rossi Oral AM by the ED: Deletion of the whole Article 34 - Article 34 - paragraph 1 point a,b Article 34 paragraph 1 introductory part Article 34 paragraph 1 point a Article 34 paragraph 1 point a a (new) Article 34 paragraph 1 point c Article 34 paragraph 1 point d Article 34 paragraph 1 point Original AM 312 is withdrawn (mistake caused by the AT4AM software) 76a Rapporteur alls if OA in AM 312 rom "1. In addition... a diet;" 313 Kartika Tamara Liotard alls if OA in AM Antonyia Parvanova, Michèle Rivasi, Corinne Lepage, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Glenis Willmott, Carl Schlyter 316 Glenis Willmott, Corinne Lepage, Antonyia Parvanova, Michèle Rivasi, Åsa Westlund, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Carl Schlyter 317 Glenis Willmott, Corinne Lepage, Antonyia Parvanova, Michèle Rivasi, Åsa Westlund,Kartika Tamara Liotard, Carl Schlyter alls if AM 76a alls if OA in AM 312 Complementary to AM 76a as addition alls if OA in AM 312 alls if OA in AM b Rapporteur alls if OA in AM 312 alls if AM 317 rom "(c) they are supported... consumer; and" 76c Rapporteur alls if OA in AM 312 rom "(d) in the case... or nutrients." 318 Andres Perello Rodriguez alls if OA in AM 312 W 33/29/0 PV\ doc 35/49 PE v01

36 d a (new) Article Andres Perello Rodriguez alls if OA in AM 312 paragraph 1 point d b (new) Article 34 paragraph 1 a (new) Article 34 - Article 34 a (new) Article 34 paragraph 3 sub Article 34 paragraph 5 footnote 44 Article 34 paragraph 6 Article 35 a (new) 314 Glenis Willmott, Antonyia Parvanova, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Carl Schlyter Inadmissible, Rule 66(2) 77 Rapporteur alls if OA in AM 312 Deletion 320 Thomas Ulmer, Holger Krahmer 321 Glenis Willmott,Corinne Lepage, Antonyia Parvanova, Michèle Rivasi, Carl Schlyter, Kartika Tamara Liotard 322 Glenis Willmott, Carl Schlyter, Kartika Tamara Liotard, Antonyia Parvanova, Corinne Lepage, Michèle Rivasi, Åsa Westlund alls if OA in AM 312 alls if OA in AM 312 alls if OA in AM Rapporteur alls if OA in AM Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi 325 Holger Krahmer - 29/34/0 Article 35 - paragraph 3 Article 35 - paragraph 4 Article 37 - paragraph 1 Article 37 Article Rapporteur Deletion - 79 Rapporteur Deletion - 80 Rapporteur 81 Rapporteur Deletion - 30/30/0 326 Holger Krahmer alls if AM 81-27/35/0 82 Rapporteur Deletion 327 Oreste Rossi alls if AM Giommaria Uggias alls if AMs 82 or 327 Article 42 - title 83 Rapporteur - 30/33/0 Article 42 paragraph 1 point a 330 Andres Perello Rodriguez alls if AMs 83 - PE v01 36/49 PV\ doc

37 Article Rapporteur - paragraph 1 point b Article Theodoros Skylakakis rom "The provision in - paragraph 1 point b a (new) and measurable." Article Rapporteur - paragraph 3 Article Struan Stevenson Article Oreste Rossi - paragraph 3 Article 43 paragraph Oreste Rossi Rapporteur Complementary to AM 333 as addition Article Struan Stevenson Deletion - paragraph 5 Article Rapporteur paragraph 1 Article Rapporteur paragraph 1 introductory part Article Rapporteur paragraph 1 Article Rapporteur subparagraph 1 Article Rapporteur Deletion sub Article Rapporteur paragraph 1 Article Rapporteur paragraph 3 Article Rapporteur Deletion paragraph 4 Article Rapporteur Deletion Article Rapporteur Deletion Article 52 paragraph 1 Article 52 Article 54 paragraph 1 sub 346 Rapporteur 347 Rapporteur Text correction: "...Article 49(3)... instead of... Article 49(5)..." 348 Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi Deletion - PV\ doc 37/49 PE v01

38 Article Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi Deletion - Article Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi - 25/37/0 Annex I point Chris Davies Text correction: "...'nutrition labelling'... instead of...'nutrition labelling3..." Annex I - point 8 86 Rapporteur - Annex I - point Rapporteur Struan Stevenson Withdrawn W Annex III table point 1 a (new) Annex III table point righthand-column 353 Dan Jørgensen, Christel Schaldemose*, Sirpa Pietikäinen 359 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy 355 Corinne Lepage, Antonyia Parvanova "Ritual Slaughter" AM co-signed by Struan Stevenson Split vote by the ALDE: 1st part: "'contains aspartame (a source of phenylalanine)" 34/28/0 2nd part: "might be unsuitable for pregnant women)'" 88 Rapporteur all if AM 355 Annex III table point 3 a (new) 89 Rapporteur 356 Carl Schlyter, Michèle Rivasi - Annex III table point righthand column Annex III table point 4.2 Annex III table point 4.2 left-hand column 352 Åsa Westlund, Christel Schaldemose*, Dan Jørgensen alls if AM Rapporteur 357 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Boguslaw Sonik 358 Struan Stevenson Complementary to AM 357 as addition Annex IV 360 Oreste Rossi Deletion - Annex V - point 2 91 Rapporteur PE v01 38/49 PV\ doc