Plato I PHIL301 The Task Prof. Oakes updated: 2/27/14 1:44 PM
|
|
- Maud Stevens
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Plat I PHIL301 The Task Prf. Oakes updated: 2/27/14 1:44 PM Republic I-II: The Task pp (327a-367e) - In this sectin, the subject f justice is brached; we see a Scratic-style elenctic exchange with Thrasymachus and thers end in impasse; Glaucn and Adeimantus prevail upn Scrates t advance a psitive accunt f justice. - This sectin is significant fr its presentatin f the traditinal Scratic style and fr a general sense f disappintment with that methd and subsequent intentin t prvide a psitive accunt f justice. Nte, as always, Plat s skill as a dramatist, and in particular the differences in Scrates respnses t his interlcutrs as their attitudes twards him and justice vary. Initial Discussin Cephalus and Plemarchus - Plainly, neither Cephalus nr Plemarchus knws what justice is. Mrever, their ignrance and, we might say, their ignrance f their ignrance makes them vulnerable t mral failing. 1 - Scrates gets Cephalus t say that justice is paying debts and telling the truth. But Cephalus is evidently ignrant f mral truth r indifferent t it. He has little interest in a serius discussin f it, and excuses himself by saying, untruthfully, that he must attend t a religius ceremny. (Anther interpretatin: Cephalus isn t willing t underg a Scratic examinatin, and wisely, plitely, excuses himself. Questin: is Cephalus a sympathetic character, r nt?) - Plemarchus is at least willing t examine his wn beliefs, thugh whether frm a prper understanding f the value f ding s, r frm a sense f filial duty, is unclear. (As usual, Plat is making claims by means f subtle dramatic exchanges: prperly cgnizant f mral truth, ne wuld knw perfectly well that ne shuld investigate such matters. In this, Plat agrees with Scrates.) - Plemarchus accunt f justice is wrth examining fr several reasns: it is relatively cmmn, but trivial and unstable, and cnsequently liable t put ne in the wrng. His first frmulatin (331e): Justice is giving t each what is wed. But this frmulatin is trivial, since what is wed has the same frce as what is just. His secnd frmulatin (332a): Justice is giving what is wed, where the gd is wed t ne s friends, and the bad is wed t ne s enemies. Prblems encuntered by Plemarchus here, include: It s cmpatible with saying that Justice invlves knwledge f larceny (332c-334b); If ne mistakes ne s friends/enemies, then justice entails harming ne s actual enemies and benefiting ne s actual enemies (r, t avid this, benefiting perceived enemies and harming perceived friends 334b-e); it matters, in ther wrds, t be precise. This prmpts the (third) refrmulatin, believed and actual friends r enemies (334e). 1 Cmpare Scrates view f mral risk expressed in Euthyphr and Aplgy. Plat evidently hlds a similar view
2 In ther wrds, Plemarchus knwledge is s weak as t permit his being led by the nse int simple cnfusins. See e.g. 334b, 335d. Once equipped with a relatively cherent definitin (the third), Scrates advances a cunter-argument. He argues as fllws (335b-e): 1. T harm a thing is t make it wrse. 2. Harm t humans is harm in respect f their characteristic excellence mral quality. S, t harm a human is t make him/her less just An actin resulting in greater injustice (less justice) is nt a just act. 4. Hence, it cannt be just t harm a human. Perhaps Plemarchus culd bject that harm t an enemy might mean t reduce the enemy s virtue in respect f being an enemy, rather than in respect f being a human. It s mre likely, hwever, that he wuld have meant harm in respect f being human, Plemarchus nt being ntable fr the precisin f his thinking. Nte, in any case, the failure f Plemarchus t defend his psitin, indicating the instability f his views in the face f his ignrance abut them. If Scrates argues unfairly, Plemarchus is nnetheless culpable fr failure t recgnize and defend prper justice. Part f Scrates traditinal rle, after all, is t demnstrate t his interlcutrs their ignrance. Thrasymachus - Thrasymachus is an imprtant and vivid character in Republic. He is imprtant fr prmting mral skepticism, which prmpts the later call (Bk II) fr Scrates t develp a psitive accunt f justice, ne demnstrating that justice is nt nly finest but als mst beneficial (prudent). Mral skepticism: there are n mral truths (r, in any case, we have n reasn t believe that there are skepticism prper). Prudence: as distinct frm mral gd, that which is f benefit, satisfying sme interest (desire, need, wish, etc.); e.g., it is gd (prudent) t lk bth ways befre crssing the street. Mral skeptics typically maintain that the nly kind f gd is prudential. Mral Realism: there are mral truths i.e., beynd the merely prudential. (Scrates and Plat s psitin.) - Thrasymachus bursts n the scene t denunce Scrates tactics against Cephalus and Plemarchus. (But as abve, Scrates has his reasns fr his tactics. Where Scrates is mre gentle if remnstrating with Cephalus and Plemarchus, he shws little mercy fr thse like Thrasymachus wh disdain mral life.) Thrasymachus was evidently a sphist, smething like a prfessinal philspher fr hire. He will be a mre skilled ppnent fr Scrates than are Cephalus and Plemarchus. - Thrasymachus ffers this definitin f justice: Justice is the advantage f the strnger (338c). He develps this view in several ways. First, Thrasymachus calls attentin t the evident fact that systems f (civil) justice have beneficiaries. Where a state r scial structure has a system f justice, there will be sme plitical pwer benefitting frm the maintenance f that system. See 338d-e, where Thrasymachus refers t different plitical systems. 3 In this sense, justice implies the interest f sme party the plitical 2 Nte again the accrd with Scrates views in Aplgy. 3 Cmpare, e.g., the justice f laws prtecting the rights f crpratins t make unlimited plitical cntributins. What entity r rganizatin des this make strnger? 2
3 pwer and is thus a frm f prudence, cnfirming Thrasymachus mral skeptical view. Secnd, Justice appears t be a kind f zer-sum game, as Thrasymachus understands it. 4 Where human interests are cncerned, they ften invlve the cmpetitin fr resurces fd, materials, mating privileges, etc. And typically the acquisitin by ne f such gds entails their lss by anther either utright r by lss f pprtunity. See 343d-e: the just man gets less than the unjust in cmmercial exchanges, etc. The ptimal state, then, n Thrasymachus view, is that f the tyrant, wh defines justice as that which benefits himself and wh has the advantage f all thers in access t gds. See 344a-c. - It is thus in ne s best-interest (i.e., prudent) t be unjust (if ne can get away with it) in terms f bth f these themes. In plitical terms, it is in ne s interest t be unjust, and a vilatin f ne s interests t be just, fr in being just, ne weakens ne s scial psitin relative t the ruler/s and in being unjust, ne strengthens that psitin. Thrasymachus can thus refer t a cmplete frm f injustice in which ne exerts his/her cntrl ver all thers in the sciety. This is best fr ne s interests; anything less grants authrity ver neself t anther. Of curse, nce ne gains ascendancy ver the whle f sciety, then ne s interests (advantage) re-define justice that set f rules prmting ne s wn benefit. Scrates tries t trip up Thrasymachus ver these different, relative meanings f justice, but Thrasymachus is generally able t avid these traps. And mre generally, justice will be a disadvantage and injustice an advantage in this sense: Being just i.e., fair, hnest, etc. prevents ne frm taking ptimal advantage f thers. I.e., in strict terms f self-interest, the mre ne can get ut f ne s material interactins with thers (business deals, affairs f the heart, etc.) the better. It is better t cheat. Best f all, ntice, is t cheat withut being caught; fr sciety punishes and is in any case wary f the unjust (thse vilating its rules f fairness). If ne can maintain a reputatin fr justice, ne will gain the benefits f gd-scial standing alng with the benefits f cheating thers. - Thrasymachus thus identifies injustice as a virtue, since it imprves ne s life; justice, he calls high-minded flishness (348c). Scrates argument against Thrasymachus - In general, while Thrasymachus falls int varius minr traps laid by Scrates, he is better able t defend his psitin, and cries ful when Scrates miscnstrues his claims. Scrates des trick Thrasymachus, in the end, hwever, much t Thrasymachus chagrin (350d). - Scrates primary argument against Thrasymachus accunt f justice may be understd as fllws: 1. The unjust seek t utd the just and the unjust alike; the just seek t utd the unjust but nt the just. 5 (349b-c) 2. If we think f injustice and justice as kinds f expertise, then (1) implies that the injustice expert seeks t utd bth thse wh are expert at injustice and thse wh are less than expert at injustice, while the justice expert seeks t utd thse wh are nt expert at justice but nt thse wh are expert at justice. (350a-b) 4 A zer-sum game is an interactin between tw r mre parties in which any benefit t ne entails a cst t anther, and vice versa. 5 See plenexia, belw. 3
4 3. But in general, the expert in a given field is ne wh seeks t utd thse wh are inexpert, but nt thse wh are expert in that given field. (See Scrates musician example, 349e.) 4. This implies, fr Scrates, that the expert at injustice is really n expert at all. (This makes a certain sense, given that justice and injustice are cntraries. If injustice is simply the negatin f justice, then it is justice that is the psitive field f knwledge. It wuld thus make sense t speak f experts in respect f justice, but nt in respect f injustice: justice wuld be a field f knwledge, injustice a field f ignrance, s t speak. The expert at injustice will simply be smene wh is ignrant abut justice cmpare being an expert in musical ignrance. 6 As we shall see, hwever, this begs an imprtant questin against Thrasymachus.) 5. T be expert is t be knwledgeable, and t be knwledgeable is t be wise. (350b) 6. T be wise is t be gd. (350b) 7. S, if the unjust seek t utd bth just and unjust alike, then they are nt experts; they are unwise and bad. (350c) - The mistake in Scrates reasning lies in the fact that Thrasymachus cncept f injustice desn t cnfrm t the craft analgy fr knwledge. Typically, a craft can be practiced equally by multiple practitiners, because the practice f the craft by ne craftsman is independent f its practice by anther. The typical craft can admit f cperatin amng practitiners. But Thrasymachus cncept f injustice is precisely the cncept f a practice in which ne practitiner s success entails anther s failure. It s a zer-sum game; cperatin isn t pssible. Of curse, Thrasymachus fails t defend his psitin effectively, allwing Scrates t get away with the misrepresentatin. Scrates argument fr the prudence f mrality - Scrates argument fr the prudence f mrality is characteristic f the histrical Scrates. - His argument: 1. Living is the functin f the sul. (353d) 2. The excellence f the sul is that which enables it t perfrm its functin well. (353d) 3. The bad sul rules (lives) prly; the gd sul lives well. (353e) 4. Justice is the excellence f the sul. (Frm abve: it is the wise and gd, 350bc) 5. Hence, the just live well, the unjust live prly. (353e) - Nte, hwever, that this argument can scarcely be said t be cnvincing. I.e., as an argument t the effect that it is better t be just than unjust, it will hardly cnvince anyne wh shares Thrasymachus views. - Mrever, this accunt fails t identify the nature f justice. It culd equally apply t Thrasymachus definitin f justice (where it wuld be injustice that is the excellence f the sul). Glaucn and Adeimantus - Glaucn revives Thrasymachus argument. This is warranted, given the weakness f Scrates argument against Thrasymachus and f his argument fr the prudence f 6 Cnceiving justice as a frm f knwledge and injustice as a frm f ignrance is a cnsequence f Scrates craft analgy. Craft is a translatin f techne, which has the significance f ur cntemprary term science. See p. 336, n. 6. 4
5 justice. See 358b, 367b, and 367e fr statements f dissatisfactin with Scrates arguments in Bk I. - Glaucn expresses the pint mre elegantly: justice is a necessary evil, a middle grund between the mst desirable (cmplete freedm t act as ne chses) and least desirable (cmplete submissin t the will f thers). It is welcmed, respected, nly fr its capacity t secure us frm the harms f thers. - Glaucn advances the thesis that we are naturally inclined t wrng thers: wrnging thers is naturally gd (prudential); and being wrnged is what is bad (fr us). Since suffering wrng exceeds in badness the lst gd f harming thers, we accept the middle psitin f civil and scietal mral law justice. But, in fact, justice is a sacrifice f ur best interests; injustice is in ur best interests. - Glaucn relates the stry f the Ring f Gyges in rder t substantiate his claim that we are naturally unjust. (359c-360d) - Nte, t, Adeimantus reminders that even the gds seem t admire and reward injustice, as represented by the pets (Hmer, Hesid). Virtue is difficult t achieve (Hesid) and the gds may be swayed t favr the unjust (Hmer; 364d-e, 365e). 7 - Glaucn and Adeimantus s challenge t Scrates: t shw that it is better (mre prudent) t be just than unjust. In rder t make clear that this is s, they ask Scrates t shw that the just man wh appears t be unjust is happier than the unjust man wh appears t be just. Withut these appearances, it will nt be clear that the just man s happiness is nt wing t the scial prfit f a just reputatin, nr the unjust man unhappy because f the scial cst f injustice. (367a-e) - We shuld cnsider, when we have the whle f Plat s accunt befre us, whether it meets this strict cnditin. 7 This f curse is part f the reasn why Plat, like Scrates befre him, is dubius f these tales f the gds. 5
NYS Common Core ELA & Literacy Curriculum D R A F T Grade 12 Module 2 Unit 1 Lesson 7
12.2.1 Lessn 7 Intrductin In this lessn, students cntinue t read and analyze Henry David Threau s Civil Disbedience. Students read part 1, paragraphs 5 6 (frm The mass f men serve the state thus, nt as
More informationCJS 220. The Court System. Version 2 08/06/07 CJS 220
CJS 220 The Curt System Versin 2 08/06/07 CJS 220 CJS 220 The Curt System Prgram Cuncil The Academic Prgram Cuncils fr each cllege versee the design and develpment f all University f Phenix curricula.
More informationSubjective intent is too slippery:
Scalia - Cmmn-Law Curts in a Civil Law System Lecture 1: Scalia begins by examining what he calls the cmmn law attitude. Lawyers are trained up in the traditin f cmmn law, distinguishing between cases
More informationGuardianship & Conservatorship In Virginia
Guardianship & Cnservatrship In Virginia This bklet is prduced by the Virginia Guardianship Assciatin in cperatin with the Virginia Center n Aging the Virginia Calitin fr the Preventin f Elder Abuse &
More informationActivities: Teacher lecture (background information and lecture outline provided); class participation activity.
Curts in the Cmmunity Clrad Judicial Branch Office f the State Curt Administratr Lessn: Hw the Appellate Prcess Wrks Objective: Understand what happens t a case when it leaves the trial curts. (Clrad Mdel
More informationPENNSYLVANIA TORTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR MICHAEL P. MORELAND VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW
PENNSYLVANIA TORTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR MICHAEL P. MORELAND VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: INTENTIONAL TORTS & NEGLIGENCE A. Intentinal Trts 1. Battery Exam Tip 1: Remember that Pennsylvania
More informationIf at all possible, it is strongly recommended that you get advice from a lawyer to help you with this application.
BACKGROUNDER What are my ptins frm here? If yu have been denied Legal Aid and cannt affrd t pay fr a lawyer, there is anther ptin. Yu can apply t the Nva Sctia Prvincial Curt t ask fr a lawyer wh will
More informationMeasuring Public Opinion
Measuring Public Opinin We all d n end f feeling and we mistake it fr thinking. And ut f it we get an aggregatin which we cnsider a bn. Its name is public pinin. It is held in reverence. It settles everything.
More information1. Humanities-oriented academic essays are typically both analytical and argumentative.
Analysis & Argument 1. Humanities-riented academic essays are typically bth analytical and argumentative. As yu may recall, the pint f an academic paper is nt s much t tell me a bunch f static facts r
More information- Problems with e-filing, especially for people from lower-income backgrounds. - Receiving memos / communication from one side and not the other
State Curt Training Mediatin: Beynd the Basics Jhn Lande and Susan M. Yates Nvember 3, 2017 Linked frm Stne Sup: Takeaways Frm New Hampshire Mediatin Training Mediatins frm Hell - Prblems with e-filing,
More informationNYS Common Core ELA & Literacy Curriculum D R A F T Grade 12 Module 2 Unit 1 Lesson 2
12.2.1 Lessn 2 Intrductin In this lessn, students cntinue their analysis f Benazir Bhutt s speech, Ideas Live On, paying particular attentin t hw Bhutt develps a cmplex set f ideas in paragraphs 11 23
More informationGENERAL ORDER PORT WASHINGTON POLICE DEPARTMENT
GENERAL ORDER PORT WASHINGTON POLICE DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: EYEWITNESS IDENTIFICATION NUMBER: 6.3.4 ISSUED: 5/6/09 SCOPE: All Swrn Persnnel EFFECTIVE: 5/6/09 DISTRIBUTION: General Orders Manual RESCINDS 34.1
More informationLEGAL THEORY / JURISPRUDENCE SUMMARY
LEGAL THEORY / JURISPRUDENCE SUMMARY LAWSKOOL PTY LTD CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 4 POSITIVISM AND THE NATION OF LAW/S 5 What is legal system? 5 Obligatin 5 Law as a System f Rules 6 Legal Obligatins and Mrality
More informationCBA Response to Private Prosecuting Association Consultation entitled. Private Prosecutions Consultation. 6 th March 2019
CBA Respnse t Private Prsecuting Assciatin Cnsultatin entitled Private Prsecutins Cnsultatin 6 th March 2019 Intrductin 1. The CBA represents the views and interests f practising members f the criminal
More informationFebruary 6, Interview with WILLIAM J. BAROODY,.JR. William A. Syers Political Scientist and Deputy Director House Republican Policy Committee
B # f c% Interview with WILLIAM J. BARDY,.JR. by William A. Syers Plitical Scientist and Deputy Directr Huse Republican Plicy Cmmittee ~ c;" n February 6, 1985 i TRANSCRIPT F AN INTERVIEW WITH WILLIAM
More informationOXON CHURCH OF ENGLAND PRIMARY SCHOOL COMPLAINTS POLICY
OXON CHURCH OF ENGLAND PRIMARY SCHOOL COMPLAINTS POLICY HOW TO RAISE A CONCERN INFORMAL STAGE Class teachers are the usual first pint f cntact fr any cncerns. Mst cncerns are reslved infrmally thrugh cnversatins
More informationFLORIDA S DEPENDENCY BENCHBOOK BENCHCARD: PSYCHOTROPIC MEDICATION HEARING
FLORIDA S DEPENDENCY BENCHBOOK BENCHCARD: PSYCHOTROPIC MEDICATION HEARING Items in bld fnt are required by Flrida Statutes. If the child cmes int care with psychtrpic medicatin already prescribed. DCF
More informationORGANIZING A LEGAL DISCUSSION (IRAC, CRAC, ETC.)
ORGANIZING A LEGAL DISCUSSION (IRAC, CRAC, ETC.) Intrductin The rganizatin f yur writing will determine whether r nt a reader will understand and be persuaded by yur argument. Brilliant rhetric will nly
More informationAGENCY PROFESSOR WILLIAM BIRDTHISTLE CHICAGO KENT COLLEGE OF LAW
AGENCY PROFESSOR WILLIAM BIRDTHISTLE CHICAGO KENT COLLEGE OF LAW CREATING THE AGENCY RELATIONSHIP Every agency relatinship must have a principal and an agent. Generally, an des things n behalf f the and
More informationSocial Media and the First Amendment
Scial Media and the First Amendment Benjamin J. Yder Frst Brwn Tdd, LLC Margaret W. Cmey Lcke Lrd LLP Thurs. Feb. 1 & Fri. Feb. 2, 2018 Presentatin Overview Backgrund and develping case law Implementing
More informationTEXAS AGENCY PROFESSOR WILLIAM BIRDTHISTLE CHICAGO KENT COLLEGE OF LAW
TEXAS AGENCY PROFESSOR WILLIAM BIRDTHISTLE CHICAGO KENT COLLEGE OF LAW CHAPTER 1: CREATING THE AGENCY RELATIONSHIP Every agency relatinship must have the principal and the agent. d things n behalf f the
More informationAdjourning Licensing Hearings
Adjurning Licensing Hearings Sarah Clver, Barrister and Head f Licensing at N 5 Chambers gives her pinin n a cmmn practical prblem cncerned with adjurning licensing hearings.. An issue which appears t
More informationThe Genuine Temporary Entrant (GTE) Requirement (Recommendations 1 and 2)
The Genuine Temprary Entrant (GTE) Requirement (Recmmendatins 1 and 2) The fllwing infrmatin prvides further detail n the planned Knight Review changes t the student visa prgram. Frequently asked questins
More informationSocial Studies 30-1 Related Issue Review. Related Issue 1: To what extent should ideology be the foundation of identity?
Scial Studies 30-1 Related Issue Review Related Issue 1: T what extent shuld idelgy be the fundatin f identity? General Outcme: Specific Outcmes: Students will explre the relatinship between identity and
More informationEUROPEAN REFUGEE CRISIS
EUROPEAN REFUGEE CRISIS DATA, TECHNOLOGY & COORDINATION BRIEFING NOTE On Nvember 4, 2015, the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative (HHI) brught tgether representatives f a range f rganizatins wrking t address
More informationCARL Backgrounder on the New Citizenship Act (formerly Bill C-24) INTRODUCTION
Primary Authr: Aris Daghighian CARL Backgrunder n the New Citizenship Act (frmerly Bill C-24) INTRODUCTION The Stephen Harper Cnservative gvernment s Bill C-24 amending the Citizenship Act is nw law, having
More information! EQUITY! LAWS%2015%!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1!
EQUITY LAWS%2015% 1 TheHistryandNaturefEquity WhatisEquity?HistryandNaturefEquity Equityreferstthebdyfcases,maxims,dctrines,rules,principlesandremediesthatderive frmthespecificjurisdictinestablishedbythecurtfchancery.itremainsakeypillarfthe
More informationSUBSTITUTED JUDGMENT AND EXTRAORDINARY TREATMENT. Substituted Judgment--Overview
SUBSTITUTED JUDGMENT AND EXTRAORDINARY TREATMENT Substituted Judgment--Overview An exceptin t the general apprach t judicially-rdered alternative decisin making cncerns medical prcedures and treatment
More informationMulti-Agency Guidance (Non Police)
Multi-Agency Guidance (Nn Plice) Dmestic Vilence prtectin Ntices Dmestic Vilence Prtectin Orders Sectins 24-33 crime and security Act 2010 Cntents: Page Intrductin 2 Multi-Agency Engagement 2 Criteria
More informationImpact of Proffer Legislation Changes
Impact f Prffer Legislatin Changes General Infrmatin n New Statute VA Cde Sectin 5.2-2303.4 Senate Bill (SB) 549 206 Sessin Reprt Senate Bill (SB) 549 New Prffer Legislatin (Handut) Slide 9 & 0 frm Schl
More informationCommon Evidentiary Predicates to Authenticate Evidence
Cmmn Evidentiary Predicates t Authenticate Evidence 1. Phtgraphs Rule 901. Identify and cnfirm that phtgraph is fair and accurate representatin f what is depicted. See Huffman v. State, 746 S.W.2d 212,
More informationCAR. Message. efforts to. is carried. It provides. Fifth Tradition. o o. out the group. o o o o. or to make a
2012 CAR 57 The Grup Supprt Unit Carrying the Message Grup fcused: The grup supprt unit (GSU)) fcuses n effrts t carry ur message. aiding the grups in their The primary purpse f an NA grup is t carry the
More informationRecording Secretary Participant Workbook Facilitators: Colin Treanor (UConn 2014) Jake Lueck (Kansas 2017)
The Fraternity f Phi Gamma Delta Internatinal Headquarters P. O. Bx 4599 1201 Red Mile Rad Lexingtn, KY 40544 www.phigam.rg Recrding Secretary Participant Wrkbk Facilitatrs: Clin Treanr (UCnn 2014) ctreanr@phigam.rg
More informationSupervised Legal Practice Guidelines (Legal Profession Act 2008)
Supervised Legal Practice Guidelines (Legal Prfessin Act 2008) It is a legislative requirement that fllwing admissin and the btaining f a practising certificate, a lcal legal practitiner can nly engage
More informationWest Tankers applies, so the Commercial Court points to other options in Nori Holdings Ltd v Bank Otkritie [2018] EWHC 1343 (Comm)
Maritime Bulletin Issue 8 www.4pumpcurt.cm West Tankers applies, s the Cmmercial Curt pints t ther ptins in Nri Hldings Ltd v Bank Otkritie [2018] EWHC 1343 (Cmm) Clarity has been restred fllwing the High
More informationUnit #2: American Political Ideologies and Beliefs AP US Government & Politics Mr. Coia
Unit #2: American Plitical Idelgies and Beliefs AP US Gvernment & Plitics Mr. Cia Name: Date: Perid: Thurs 10/18 Learning bjective: MPA-A: Explain the relatinship between cre beliefs f U.S. citizens and
More informationDATA REQUEST GUIDELINES
DATA REQUEST GUIDELINES This dcument describes prcedures law enfrcement authrities and individuals invlved in civil litigatin shuld fllw t request data frm LinkedIn and its affiliated service prviders.
More informationBob Simpson: Director of Intergovernmental Relations, Inuvialuit Regional Corp.
Bb Simpsn: Directr f Intergvernmental Relatins, Inuvialuit Reginal Crp. The Inuvialuit Arbitratin Prcess It is very unique the nly example f binding arbitratin in a land claim agreement; ther land claims
More informationFACULTY OF HEALTH SCIENCES A QUICK AND UNDERSTANDABLE GUIDE TO COPYRIGHT AND PLAGIARISM POLICIES
FACULTY OF HEALTH SCIENCES A QUICK AND UNDERSTANDABLE GUIDE TO COPYRIGHT AND PLAGIARISM POLICIES Cmpiled by Dr G Myers Witwatersrand Health Sciences Library Nvember 2007 WHAT IS COPYRIGHT? Cpyright is
More informationREGISTERED STUDENT ORGANIZATION LEADERSHIP TEAM Drafted on: April 25, 2013
Cnstitutin Guide G E O R G E M A S O N U N I V E R S I T Y Student Invlvement The fllwing is an example f an RSO Cnstitutin. Nt all infrmatin in the belw dcument is representative f the RSO Leadership
More informationEstablishing the standard of care against which the D will be assessed;
Breach f Duty The task f determining whether a duty f care has been breached invlves a cmparisn f the defendant s cnduct with the standard f care required by the duty. Whenever the defendant s cnduct falls
More informationCALIFORNIA REMEDIES ESSAY WORKSHOP PROFESSOR CHRISTOPHER IDE-DON UC DAVIS SCHOOL OF LAW
CALIFORNIA REMEDIES ESSAY WORKSHOP PROFESSOR CHRISTOPHER IDE-DON UC DAVIS SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: APPROACH; ISSUES TESTED A. Apprach t Essays 1) Determine and analyze the cause(s) f actin in the questin
More informationCommunicating with Mainers on Climate Change
Cmmunicating with Mainers n Climate Change Tyler Kidder Cmmunity Outreach Directr, GrwSmart Maine & Lcal Trainer Based n Research Cnducted by Gdwin Simn Strategic Research n behalf f the Maine Climate
More informationDEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY I $5,461 - $7,410/Month
and a Drug-Free Wrkplace The Cunty f Mnterey Invites yur interest fr the psitin f DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY I $5,461 - $7,410/Mnth OPEN UNTIL FILLED PRIORITY SCREENING DATE: Friday, Octber 13, 2017 Exam
More information45-47 Part 1: General & Specified Prohibited Conduct Lecture 11: Consumer Protection Law
Sectin Page Lecture 1: The Australian Legal System 1-4 Lecture 2: Intrductin t Cntracts 5-9 Lecture 3: Cnsideratin 10-14 Lecture 4: Capacity, Legality & Frm 15-20 Lecture 5: Term in a Cntract 21-28 Lecture
More informationCOUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION. Brussels, 12 July 2000 (28.07) (OR. fr) 10242/00 LIMITE ASILE 30
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Brussels, 12 July 2000 (28.07) (OR. fr) 10242/00 LIMITE ASILE 30 OUTCOME OF PROCEEDINGS frm : Asylum Wrking Party n : 7 July 2000 N. prev. dc.: 9703/00 ASILE 28 Subject: Cnditins
More informationRole Play Magistrate Court Hearings Teacher information
Rle Play Magistrate Curt Hearings Teacher infrmatin These ntes are prvided s that teachers can guide students thrugh preparatry activities befre presenting a rle play at the Law Curts Cnnecting t the curriculum
More informationPEER INTERVIEW. Conduct a 15-minute face-to-face interview with a colleague
PEER INTERVIEW PART I- The Interview Cnduct a 15-minute face-t-face interview with a clleague This will be cmpleted during class n 11/7 and 11/8 Select questins frm the list belw. Yu can als ask 1 questin
More informationOpinions on Choice of Law, Forum Selection, Arbitration, and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments or Arbitral Awards in Cross-Border Transactions
Opinins n Chice f Law, Frum Selectin, Arbitratin, and Enfrcement f Freign Judgments r Arbitral Awards in Crss-Brder Transactins With increasing frequency U.S. lawyers are delivering clsing pinins t nn-u.s.
More informationProtecting Access to Reproductive Health Care and Abortion As An Electoral Priority
Nvember 11, 2014 Prtecting Access t Reprductive Health Care and Abrtin As An Electral Pririty New NARAL Pr-Chice America and Planned Parenthd Actin Fund Pll Results T: Interested Parties Frm: Greenberg
More informationEyewitness Identification. Professor Nancy K. Steblay Augsburg College Minneapolis
Eyewitness Identificatin Prfessr Nancy K. Steblay Augsburg Cllege Minneaplis The 2016 Criminal Justice Institute August 22 & 23, 2016 The Science f Eyewitness Memry and Identificatin Evidence (Prfessr)
More informationDESCRIPTIVE CLASSIFICATIONS OF MIGRATION. Fabio Baggio
1 DESCRIPTIVE CLASSIFICATIONS OF MIGRATION Fabi Baggi The understanding f the migratin phenmenn and the develpment f migratin classificatins shuld be always based n the cnsideratin f bth bjective criteria
More informationCONTEMPT. This packet contains forms and information on: How to File a Petition for Citation of Contempt
CONTEMPT This packet cntains frms and infrmatin n: Hw t File a Petitin fr Citatin f Cntempt It is advisable t have an attrney when filing legal papers t be sure that yur rights are prtected and that all
More informationWATERLOO REGION LOCAL IMMIGRATION PARTNERSHIP COUNCIL (LIPC)
WATERLOO REGION LOCAL IMMIGRATION PARTNERSHIP COUNCIL (LIPC) FINAL REPORT (April 2010) LIPC Lead Cmmunity Partners LIPC Funder 1 WATERLOO REGION LOCAL IMMIGRATION PARTNERSHIP COUNCIL FINAL REPORT APRIL
More informationCAMPAIGN REGISTRATION STATEMENT STATE OF WISCONSIN ETHCF-1
CAMPAIGN REGISTRATION STATEMENT STATE OF WISCONSIN ETHCF-1 FOR OFFICE USE ONLY IF A CANDIDATE DOES NOT FILE THIS STATEMENT BY THE DEADLINE FOR FILING NOMINATION PAPERS, THE CANDIDATE S NAME WILL NOT BE
More informationDear Mr./Ms. President... Stephen Arbogast, The National Cathedral School, Washington, DC
Religius Wrlds f New Yrk Curriculum Develpment Prject Dear Mr./Ms. President... Stephen Arbgast, The Natinal Cathedral Schl, Washingtn, DC Abstract This assignment is the cumulative written assessment
More informationINSTRUCTIONS FOR FILING A COMPLAINT FOR DIVORCE WITHOUT MINOR CHILDREN
INSTRUCTIONS FOR FILING A COMPLAINT FOR DIVORCE WITHOUT MINOR CHILDREN GENERAL COMMENTS This is the packet fr peple wh want t file their wn divrce in Cbb Cunty, and wh d nt have any minr children tgether
More informationIndigenous Consultation in Environmental Assessment Processes
Ministry f the Envirnment and Climate Change Indigenus Cnsultatin in Envirnmental Assessment Prcesses Ontari Assciatin fr Impact Assessment Octber 17, 2017 Why cnsult with Indigenus cmmunities during an
More informationINFORMATION ON THE SELECTION PROCESS OF JUDGES AT THE UNIFIED PATENT COURT
INFORMATION ON THE SELECTION PROCESS OF JUDGES AT THE UNIFIED PATENT COURT Please read carefully the infrmatin n the selectin prcess f Unified Patent Curt (UPC) judges, the eligibility criteria, as well
More informationMEMBER PROTECTION POLICY
Martial Arts Industry Assciatin Inc. August 2004 MEMBER PROTECTION POLICY POLICY STATEMENT The Martial Arts Industry Assciatin Inc (MAIA) member rganisatins and affiliated clubs, branches and states, is
More informationKey YWCA USA. What Women Want 2012: A YWCA USA National Survey of Priorities and Concerns. Summary of Findings from a Survey among Adult Women
Key YWCA USA What Wmen Want 2012: A YWCA USA Natinal Survey f Pririties and Cncerns Summary f Findings frm a Survey amng Adult Wmen September 2012 YWCA 2 Key Findings While cnventinal wisdm suggests that
More informationCAUSE NO CITY OF FORT WORTH'S ORIGINAL ANSWER. COMES NOW Defendant City of Fort Worth, Texas ("the City") and files this its
CAUSE NO. 48-270181-14 FORT WORTH PROFESSIONAL IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF FIREFIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, Plaintiff V. TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS CITY OF FORT WORTH, TEXAS, Defendant 48 TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COMES NOW
More informationMedia & Democracy. Course Introduction Week 1
Media & Demcracy Curse Intrductin Week 1 Cmm 110 Disclaimer I knw that I WILL encunter ideas, perspectives, and language in this curse I may nt agree with r that may even ffend me. I als understand that
More informationGetting in Front on Data Quality
Getting in Frnt n Data Quality Thmas C. Redman, Ph.D. the Data Dc, in Ciudad Real, Espana, July, 2016 Data Quality Slutins tmredman@dataqualityslutins.cm /Redman-ICIQ-June2016 DQS 2000-2016 T.C. Redman,
More informationThe Judicial Branch. I. The Structure of the Judicial Branch: *U.S. Supreme Court
I. The Structure f the Judicial Branch: The judicial pwer f the United States, shall be vested in ne Supreme Curt, and in such inferir curts as the Cngress may frm time t time rdain and establish. The
More informationAttending the Coroner s Court as a witness and how to give evidence
briefing July 2017 Attending the Crner s Curt as a witness and hw t give evidence Intrductin... 1 Cmmn cncerns f witnesses... 2 The inquest prcess... 2 Preparing fr the inquest... 3 Yur evidence... 3 Refresh
More informationWITH RECENT CHANGES ISSUED BY THE CFPB, FINAL REMITTANCE TRANSFER REGULATIONS TO BECOME EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 7, 2013
Financial Institutins Client Service Grup T: Our Clients and Friends September 19, 2012 WITH RECENT CHANGES ISSUED BY THE CFPB, FINAL REMITTANCE TRANSFER REGULATIONS TO BECOME EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 7, 2013
More informationAlex Castles, The Reception and Status of English law in Australia (1963) pg
4A The Path t Federatin, The Acquisitin f Legal Independence and Ppular Svereignty The Clnial Laws Validity Act 1865 (Imp) pg. 98-102 The Clnial Legislatures The bicameral legislatures (tw huses) were
More informationCalifornia Common Core Content Standards: Writing Grade 11/12
Califrnia Cmmn Cre Cntent Standards: Writing Grade 11/12 11-12.W Writing 11-12. Text Types and Purpses 11-12.W.1 Write arguments t supprt claims in an analysis f substantive tpics r texts, using valid
More informationThis tort protects the interests of plaintiffs in maintaining their land free from physical intrusion
Trespass t Land Definitin: Intentinally r negligently entering r remaining n, r directly causing any physical matter t cme int cntract with, land in the pssessin f anther is a trespass. This trt prtects
More informationNUTS AND BOLTS OF PERFORMING NOTARIAL ACTS. Kathleen Butler, Executive Director American Society of Notaries Austin, TX August 30, 2017
NUTS AND BOLTS OF PERFORMING NOTARIAL ACTS Kathleen Butler, Executive Directr American Sciety f Ntaries Austin, TX August 30, 2017 TODAY S DISCUSSION WHY are dcuments ntarized? WHAT are a Ntary s fundamental
More informationDual Court System Chapter 3
Dual Curt System Chapter 3 Dual Curt System In the United States the justice system has tw parts: 1. The Federal Curt System 2. The State Curt System Federal curts hear cases invlving federal matters
More informationCONTRACT LAW IN GENERAL: R
CONTRACT LAW IN GENERAL: R 1. Cntract Defined A cntract is a prmise r a set f prmises fr the breach f which the law gives a remedy, r the perfrmance f which the law in sme way recgnizes as a duty. R 2.
More informationThe impact of branding an educational institution Methodist. Final report. October School of Business and Social Sciences Roehampton University
The impact f branding an educatinal institutin Methdist Final reprt Octber 2008 Schl f Business and Scial Sciences Rehamptn University Cmmissined by the Educatin Office f the Methdist Church and funded
More information7.0 Eagle/Cloverdale Alignment
Final Reprt September 2009 Suthwest Bise Transprtatin Study Page 39 7.0 Eagle/Clverdale Alignment CIM calls fr a cntinuus nrth suth rute between Kuna Mra Rad and the Eagle Rad/I 84 interchange. While CIM
More informationLogging in. Once logged in, go to the My AAMVA link in the top right of the screen.
Belw are sme general FAQs and answers fr navigating the new AAMVA Awards nline platfrm. If yu have additinal questins, please submit them t awards@aamva.rg and we will be happy t address them. Lgging in
More informationAnswer: The issue in this question is whether Donny acted in reliance of Ann s offer to get the reward of $1000.
MLC101 OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE Questin: It is the week befre ANZAC day and Ann s huse is rbbed. The thieves steal many items, including her Great grandfather s Wrld War 1 medals. Ann is distraught and puts
More informationSenate Bill 549 New Proffer Legislation
Senate Bill 549 New Prffer Legislatin Effect: Created Virginia Cde 15.2-2303.4, which limits the ability f lcal gvernments t request/accept prffers fr residential reznings/prffer amendments. 1 Applicability:
More information2018 APPLICATION FOR APPOINTMENT TO NEW ALBANY CITY COUNCIL
2018 APPLICATION FOR APPOINTMENT TO NEW ALBANY CITY COUNCIL APPLICANT INFORMATION Applicant Name: Residential Address: Cell Phne Number: Wrk Phne Number: E-Mail: CITY BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS/PUBLIC SERVICE
More informationBecome a Successful Bureaucrat / Judiciary
Becme a Successful Bureaucrat / Judiciary Civil Services ffer the mst challenging career and wrking fr public welfare is the mst demanding ne. Anyne with the right aptitude, perseverance, tenacity, cmmitment
More informationRefugee Council response to the 21 st Century Welfare consultation
Refugee Cuncil respnse t the 21 st Century Welfare cnsultatin Octber 2010 Abut the Refugee Cuncil The Refugee Cuncil is a human rights charity, independent f gvernment, which wrks t ensure that refugees
More informationPART XIII PRIVATIVE CLAUSES
PART XIII PRIVATIVE CLAUSES I Intrductin A The Privative, Ouster, r Preclusin Clause Privative clauses are prvisins in a statute which preclude the pssibility f certain frms f administrative review. Typically,
More informationMr. Professor Lyubomir T. GRUYITCH* Dipl. M. Eng., M. Sc. El. Eng., D. Sc., D. H. C. Belfort, December 20, 1998
Mr. Prfessr Lyubmir T. GRUYITCH* Dipl. M. Eng., M. Sc. El. Eng., D. Sc., D. H. C. Belfrt, December 20, 1998 Mr. William CLINTON, Hnrable President f the U. S. A. White Huse Washingtn D. C. U. S. A. Dear
More informationLLB#170#!Law$of$Contract$B"
LLB#170# Law$f$Cntract$B" Chapter"12" "identifying"the"express"terms" Inidentifyingthetermsfacntractthecurtstrytgiveeffectttheintentinsfthe parties. Hwever,thecurtsuseanbjectiveapprachinassessingtheparties
More informationMASSACHUSETTS WILLS PROFESSOR KENT SCHENKEL NEW ENGLAND SCHOOL OF LAW
MASSACHUSETTS WILLS PROFESSOR KENT SCHENKEL NEW ENGLAND SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION AND INTESTATE SUCCESSION A. Intrductin When yu encunter a wills and estates questin n the bar exam, yu first
More informationPENNSYLVANIA CONFLICT OF LAWS PROFESSOR KEVIN P. OATES DREXEL UNIVERSITY THOMAS R. KLINE SCHOOL OF LAW
PENNSYLVANIA CONFLICT OF LAWS PROFESSOR KEVIN P. OATES DREXEL UNIVERSITY THOMAS R. KLINE SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: FULL FAITH AND CREDIT FOR JUDGMENTS Three Main Tpics in Cnflict f Laws: Full faith and
More informationCh nook Aboriginal Management Certificate Program (AMP) 2015 Application Form
Ch nk Abriginal Management Certificate Prgram (AMP) 2015 Applicatin Frm Abriginal entrepreneurs are the key t building a healthy ecnmy bth n and ff reserve. The Abriginal Management Certificate Prgram
More informationAlternative Measures for Adult Offenders ALT 1. March 1, 2018 CHA 1 CHI 1 CRI 1 FIR 1 HAT 1 IPV 1 SEX 1
Plicy: Alternative Measures fr Adult Offenders Plicy Cde: Effective Date: Crss-references: ALT 1 March 1, 2018 CHA 1 CHI 1 CRI 1 FIR 1 HAT 1 IPV 1 SEX 1 Sectin 717(1) f the Criminal Cde prvides in part
More informationMARYLAND CONTRACTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR BRENDAN HURSON UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND CAREY SCHOOL OF LAW
MARYLAND CONTRACTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR BRENDAN HURSON UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND CAREY SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: MARYLAND CONTRACTS DISTINCTIONS A. Frmatin f Cntracts 1. Mutual Assent Mutual assent: Offer
More informationWhat are the tools and techniques introduced to the company and the order of implementation?
CHAPTER 5 Results and Discussin 5.1 Discussin in Relatin t Research Questins Fr hw lng Lean Manufacturing is being implemented in Sri Lankan apparel industry? It is clear that almst every apparel rganizatin
More informationThe Elementary Guide to 'Moot Court'
Frm the SelectedWrks f Lucky Michael Mgimba March, 2012 The Elementary Guide t 'Mt Curt' Lucky Michael Mgimba, Mr. Available at: https://wrks.bepress.cm/lucky_mgimba/4/ THE ELEMENTARY GUIDE TO MOOT COURT
More informationThe Informal Employment in the Arab Countries
The Infrmal Emplyment in the Arab Cuntries Realities and Rights Launching the Reginal Reprt Beirut, Cair May 8 and 9, 2017 Samir AITA President, Cercle des Ecnmistes Arabes What des this reprt target?
More informationOHIO TORTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR RIC SIMMONS THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY MORITZ COLLEGE OF LAW
A. Intentinal Trts - Defenses 1. Self-Defense OHIO TORTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR RIC SIMMONS THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY MORITZ COLLEGE OF LAW INTENTIONAL TORTS, NEGLIGENCE, DEFENSES General law frce used
More informationWeek 1 Lecture. Nature of Tort Law
Trts Week 1 Lecture Nature f Trt Law The Law f Trts Law f civil wrngs. Trt = crked r twisted Trtfeasr is liable t the victim Cmpensatin fr persnal injury & prperty damage caused by the cnduct f thers Varius
More informationThe Best of You and the Rest of You: Making the Most of Strengths-Based Leadership. By Joelle K. Jay, PhD. Leadership Research Institute
The Best f Yu and the Rest f Yu: Making the Mst f Strengths-Based Leadership By Jelle K. Jay, PhD. Leadership Research Institute The Best f Yu and the Rest f Yu: Jay, 2009 Making the Mst f Strengths-Based
More informationdue date: Monday, August 31 (first day of school) estimated time: 3 hours (for planning purposes only; work until you finish)
AP Gvernment Summer Wrk 2015 due date: Mnday, August 31 (first day f schl) estimated time: 3 hurs (fr planning purpses nly; wrk until yu finish) Yur assignment is t read the U. S. Cnstitutin and answer
More informationSURETYSHIP PROFESSOR KARA BRUCE UNIVERSITY OF TOLEDO COLLEGE OF LAW
SURETYSHIP PROFESSOR KARA BRUCE UNIVERSITY OF TOLEDO COLLEGE OF LAW CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION TO SURETYSHIP A. Suretyship Defined the prmise f a persn t pay the debts (r satisfy the ) f anther. B. Picturing
More informationDeferred Action for Parental Accountability (DAPA) Frequently Asked Questions December 4, 2014
Deferred Actin fr Parental Accuntability (DAPA) Frequently Asked Questins December 4, 2014 On Nvember 20, 2014, President Obama annunced executive actins t change immigratin plicy. One f these refrms,
More informationThe British Computer Society. Open Source Specialist Group Constitution
The British Cmputer Sciety Open Surce Specialist Grup Cnstitutin Date Apprved Date Issued 21 December 2004 Amended Patrick Tarpey Versin Final THE BRITISH COMPUTER SOCIETY THE BRITISH COMPUTER SOCIETY
More informationOrder on Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment (ING USA ANNUITY AND LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY)
Gergia State University Cllege f Law Reading Rm Gergia Business Curt Opinins 8-11-2010 Order n Defendants' Mtin fr Summary Judgment (ING USA ANNUITY AND LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY) Alice D. Bnner Superir Curt
More information