!lepublit of tbe ~bilippines
|
|
- Rolf Short
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 "!lepublit of tbe ~bilippines ~upeme QCout ;fflanila FIRST DIVISION :...,;-'~:... ~. t ~>;.. f :..:. f :.~ i' ; J 1 :.;,.. ; ~ili(ll.t\111.hi ~Hit.; 1 1 ; ~,- ilif~m.c..i \ I I j '' I '!-; 1! 1 I ( ~ l SEP d I 'Jj J''il!J' I.. \ \ Ii: ~~~ :""'!!""' &..-...J..,,,,,.,.:,... I..._ ~ '>:. -,,.:1?> :- 1~11E.,...;.J.:,. NATIONAL TRANSMISSION G.R. No CORPORATION, Petitione, Pesent: - vesus - MISAMIS ORIENTAL I ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC., Respondent. SERENO, CJ, Chaipeson, LEONARDO-DE CASTRO, BERSAMIN, PERLAS-BERNABE, and CAGUIOA,JJ PomAtJGtt:1t 2016 x SERENO, CJ: DECISION This is a Petition 1 fo Review on Cetioai dated 1 Febuay 2011 seeking to set aside the Decision 2 dated 20 Apil 2010 and Resolution 3 dated 3 Janu~y 2011 endeed by the Cout of Appeals (CA), Eighth Division, in CA-G.R. SP No The assailed ulings affimed the Enegy Regulatoy Commission (ERC) Decision 4 dated 30 June 2008 and Ode 5 dated 16 Mach 2009 in ERC Case No THE ANTECEDENT FACTS The facts as summaized by the CA ae as follows: Petitione National Tansmission Copoation (heeafte Tansco) is a govenment-owned and contolled copoation located in Iligan City 1 Rollo, pp Id. at 27-41; penned by Associate Justice Ruben C. Ayson and concued in by Associate Justices Amelita G. Tolentino and Nomandie B. Pizao. 3 Id. at Id. at 45-56; composed of Chaiman Rodolfo B. Albano, J. and Commissiones Rauf A. Tan, Maia Teesa A.R. Castaneda, Alejando Z. Bain and Jose C. Reyes. 5 Id. at ; composed of Chaiman Zenaida G. Cuz-Ducut and Commissiones Rauf A. Tan, Maia Teesa A.R. Castaneda, Alejando Z. Bain and Jose C. Reyes.
2 Decision 2 G.R. No ".,.,I,..; and is engaged in the business of tansmitting electic powe. It tansmits to its consumes electicity geneated by Mindanao Geneation Copoation (heeafte Genco). By vitue of Republic Act No. 9136, 6 Tansco assumed the electical tansmission function, while Genco, the electicity geneation function, of the National Powe Copoation '(heeafte NPC)..'ll ~ ~. Respondent Misamis Oiental I Electic Coopeative, Inc. (peeafte MORESCO I) is an electic coopeative engaged in the business >tf., of distibuting electic powe to its membes-consumes in the westen pat of Misamis Oiental. Sometime in May 2002, NPC and MORESCO I signed a Tansition Contact fo the Supply of Electicity, othewise known as Tansition Supply Contact (heeafte TSC) wheeby the fome obligated itself to supply and sell electicity to the latte. Attached to the TSC as Annex C is a document entitled Chages and Adjustments, Section 25 of which povides: ADJUSTMENT DUE TO INACCURATE METERS AND ERRONEOUS BILLINGS WITHIN A BILLING PERIOD 25. In the event that a billing is found eoneous due to a wong eading, aithmetical mistakes o omissions, SUPPLIER shall send CUSTOMER a debit/cedit memo within ninety (90) days fom the date of bill's eceipt to coect the eo. SUPPLIER shall also be deemed to waive any claim on any billing eo if it fails to send notice fo such billing eo to CUSTOMER within ninety (90) days fom billing date. Povided, that if the eo is due to an inaccuate mete, said eo may be coected anytime. (Emphasis supplied) xx xx Pusuant to the contact, Tansco and Genco began supplying electicity to MORESCO I. Fo billing puposes, Tansco installed a kilowatt hou (kwh) billing mete device at Meteing Point No. 6 in Opol Substation, Misamis Oiental to detemine the amount of electicity used by MORESCO I. The computation of the actual consumption of electicity by the said billing mete device equied the factoing in of a multiplie to the mete eading. The value of the multiplie is the poduct of the values of the intenal multiplie and the extenal multiplie peculia to the billing mete device. The multiplie in the mete device used at the time was 1,000. Accodingly, this value was used in the computation of the bill of MORESCO I. The billing date appeas to be the of each month as this was the cut-off date of each monthly billing peiod. On July 30, 2003, Tansco eplaced the billing mete device of MORESCO I in the pesence of MORESCO I pesonnel, including its Mete Calibato, M. Enie C. Janobas. As the multiplie is inheent in the mete device, the change in the said device bought a coesponding change in the multiplie. The old billing mete device had a multiplie of Q 6 AN ACT ORDAINING REFORMS IN THE ELECTRIC POWER INDUSTRY, AMENDING FOR THE PURPOSE CERTAIN LAWS AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES o the Electic Powe Industy Refom Act of2001.
3 Decision 3 G.R. No ,000 and the new one had a multiplie of 3,500. This necessaily affected the electicity eading inasmuch as the highe multiplie value would esult to a highe electicity consumption eading. Tansco then conducted a Mete Test theeon and M. Enie C. Janobas, as witness to the Mete Test, signed the Mete Test Repot pepaed by Tansco. The mete test showed that the newly installed billing mete device was calibated and found to be accuate. It was Tansco which indicated on the face of the Repot that the multiplie was 5,250, notwithstanding that the actual multiplie was 3,500. M. Janobas did not veify the 5,250 multiplie value of the new billing mete device. Then, Tansco conducted electicity consumption eadings on the new mete and billed MORESCO I evey billing peiod beginning on the. 26th of a given month and ending on the 25th of the next month. It late discoveed that it inadvetently used an incoect multiplie of 3,500 instead of 5,250 fo the billing peiods stating fom August 26, 2003 up to June 25, The use of the incoect multiplie esulted to an undebilling. Hence, Tansco sent MORESCO I on July 13, 2004 an adjustment bill o a debit/cedit memo dated July 9, 2004 in the amount of six million fou hundfed sixty-two thousand seven hunded ninety-nine and eightyone centavos (P6,462,797.81) (sic) coveing the ten (10) billing peiods fom August 26, 2003 up to June 25, On July 23, 2004 Genco, though NPC, sent MORESCO I anothe adjustment bill dated July 20, 2004 in the amount of eleven million fou hunded sixty-thee thousand nine hunded eight pesos and eighty-five centavos (P 11,463,908.85). This sepaate bill coveed the following billing peiods, which wee the same peiods used by Tansco: 1st July 26, nd August 26, d Septembe 26, th Octobe 26, th Novembe 26, th Decembe 26, 2003?1 11 Januay 26, h Febuay 26, th Mach 26, ~ Apil26, th May 26, 2004 August 25, 2003 Septembe 25, 2003 Octobe 25, 2003 Novembe 25, 2003 Decembe 25, 2003 Januay 25, 2004 Febuay 25, 2004 Mach 25, 2004 Apil 25, 2004 May 25, 2004 June 25, 2004 The two adjustment bills o debit/cedit memos eflected the total amount of seventeen million nine hunded twenty-six thousand seven hunded six pesos and sixty-six centavos (Pl 7,926,706.66) allegedly due Tansco and Genco. Howeve, MORESCO I believed that it was liable fo the total amount of only fou million two hunded twenty thousand foty-seven pesos and seventeen centavos (P 4,220,047.17) coveing the 9t\ 10th and 11th billing peiods adveted to above instead of Pl 7,926, pusuant to Section 25 of Annex C to the TSC. On Octobe 11, 2004, MORESCO I fomally offeed to pay Tansco and Genco P4,220,047.l 7. It claimed that since the omission o failue of Tansco and Genco to apply the ight multiplie is consideed a
4 Decision 4 G.R. No Q "wong eading, omission o aithmetical mistake," unde Section 25 of Annex C to the TSC, Tansco and Genco should have sent the adjustment bill, debit/cedit memo o a notice of such billing eo within ninety (90) days fom the bill's eceipt, which is pesumably evey 25th of the month as this was the last day of each billing peiod. Othewise, Tansco and Genco shall be deemed to have waived the payment of the amount theeof. Since Tansco and Genco sent the adjustment bills o debit/cedit memos fo the billing peiods efeed to above only on July 4 and 20, 2004, the ight to collect on the amount on the adjusted bill epesenting the 1st to billing peiods had aleady pescibed because the billings with espect to these peiods wee made beyond the 90-day pesciptive peiod. On the othe hand, the adjustment bills coveing the 9t11, 10 1 h and 11th billing peiods emained due and payable because these wee the bills coveed within the 90-day pesciptive peiod eckoned fom July 4 and 20, 2004, the dates of the adjustment bills. Tansco and Genco ejected MORESCO I's offe to pay. 7 THE RULING OF THE ERC A petition 8 dated 23 Novembe 2004 was filed befoe the ERC by Moesco I against petitione Tansco, along with Mindanao Geneation Copoation (Genco) and National Powe Copoation (NPC). Afte both paties submitted the equied pleadings and paticipated in the heaings, the ERC concluded that Moesco I must not be held liable to pay the amount claimed by the NPC and Tansco. Rathe, it was deemed liable only fo the amount epesenting the coected billings made within the 90-day pesciptive peiod eckoned fom the time the adjustments wee made. 9 The ERC also held that MORESCO I should be allowed to avail itself of the Pompt Payment Discount, consideing that the latte was willing to pay its aeaages, but the NPC and Tansco efused. 1 Finally, the ERC uled that Moesco I was not emiss in the latte's obligations and could not be declaed to be at fault. 11 The ERC endeed its Decision dated 30 June 2008, the dispositive potion of which eads: WHEREFORE, the foegoing pemises consideed, the Commission finds that Misamis Oiental I Electic Coopeative, Inc. (MORESCO I) is liable to pay only the total amount of Fou Million Two Hunded Twenty Thousand Foty-Seven Pesos and Seventeen Centavos (PhP4,220,047.l 7) epesenting the amount equivalent to thee (3) months billing counted fom the time of notice. SO ORDERED Rollo, pp Id. at ; docketed as ERC Case No Id. at Id. at Id. 12 Id.
5 Decision 5 G.R. No A Motion fo Reconsideation dated 1 Septembe 2008 was filed by petitione 13 and anothe one, dated 3 Septembe 2008 by the NPC, 14 both asking that the Decision be set aside. 15 In the Ode dated 16 Mach 2009, howeve, the ERC denied both motions fo lack of meit. 16 THE RULING OF THE CA Of the thee espondents in the ERC case, only petitione filed an appeal 17 befoe the CA to which Moesco I filed a Comment. 18 Unconvinced, the appellate cout denied the Petition fo lack of meit. Tansco filed its Motion fo Reconsideation 19 futhe agumg as follows: Respondent was well awae of the coect multiplie to be applied to thei billing consumptions. Moe impotantly, Respondent was likewise awae that the billings it eceived fo the peiod August 26, 2003 to June 25, 2004 applied an incoect mete multiplie. Howeve, despite knowledge theeof, Respondent did not bothe to infom Petitione and NPC of the eo and enjoyed the benefits of the lowe powe bills fo ten (10) billing peiods. Fo this eason, equity dictates that Respondent should be held liable to Petitione and NPC fo the amount equivalent to what it eceived having been unjustly eniched at the expense of the latte. 20 The motion was denied. Hence, this petition imputing evesible eo to the CA in its affimation of the ERC uling. Respondent filed its Comment 21 dated 13 Febuay THE ISSUE The sole issue to be esolved by this Cout is whethe the CA committed evesible eo in affiming the ERC's uling that Tansco's failue to install the coect device that was eflective of the multiplie used in the billing indeed constituted an omission unde Section 25 of Annex "C" of the Tansition Contact, which should thus be ectified within 90 days fom eceipt of the bill. 13 Id. at Id. 1s Id. 16 Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at
6 Decision 6 G.R. No OuRRULING The pesent contovesy calls fo the application of Section 25 of the Tansition Supply Contact, to wit: 25. In the event that a billing is found eoneous due to a wong eading, aithmetical mistakes o omissions, SUPPLIER shall send CUSTOMER a debit/cedit memo within ninety (90) days fom the date of bill's eceipt to coect the eo. SUPPLIER shall also be deemed to waive any claim on any billing eo if it fails to send notice fo such billing eo to CUSTOMER within ninety (90) days fom billing date. Povided, that if ~ the eo is due to an inaccuate mete, said eo may be coected anytime. 22 Two categoies of eo in billing ae evidently envisioned by the povision: (1) eo due to a wong eading, o an aithmetical mistake o omission, which may be coected only within 90 days fom the date of custome's eceipt of the bill, else, the claim shall be deemed waived; and (2) eo due to an inaccuate mete, which may be coected any time. Invoking the second categoy of eo, petitione, along with Genco, sent Debit/Cedit Memos dated 9 and 20 July 2004 to espondent, asking payment of P6,462, and Pl 1,463,908.85, 24 o a total amount of Pl 7,926, Aguing that the situation called instead fo the application of the fist categoy of eo, espondent pomptly offeed to pay P4,220, This 22 Id. at Id. at Id. at 98; the Summay of Revised Powe Bill of MORESCO I M6 & M7, is pesented as follows Billing Peiod AS BILLED AS REVISED TOT AL AMOUNT (Peso) (Peso) DUE A B (Peso) C=B-A Jul 26-Aug 25, ,467, ,219, , Aug 26-Sep 25, ,299, ,320, ,020, Sep 26-0ct 25, ,261, ,283, ,022, Oct 26-Nov 25, ,292, ,425, I, l 33, Nov 26-Dec 25, ,102, ,362, ,260, Dec 26-Jan 25, ,027, ,245, ,217, Jan 26-Feb 25, ,023, , l 59, , 136, Feb 26-Ma 25, ,332, ,4 l l,84 l.23 l.079, Ma 26-Ap 25, ,733, ,910, I, 177, Ap 26-May 25, ,379, l 0, l 56, ,776, May 26-Jun 25, ,262, , 149, ( 112,590.55) TOTAL 11,463, Id. at 189; the Summay is as follows Billin2 Peiod NPC TRANSCO TOTAL Mach 26-Apil 25, 2004 I, 177, , ,858, (eceived July 23, 2004) Apil 26-May 25, ,776, , ,474, (eceived July 13, 2004) May 26-June 25, 2004 ( 112,590.55) (eo aleady (I l 2,590.55) coected) TOTAL 2,841, ,378, ,220,047.17
7 Decision 7 G.R. No amount coesponded to the 9t\ 1 ot\ and 11th billing peiods coveed by the 90 days within which to ectify the eo. 26 The ERC decided in favo of espondent, and the CA affimed the judgment. We find no evesible eo in the CA's affimance of the ERC uling. The ERC concluded that Tansco failed to povide the coect mete multiplie when it installed the new mete - a clea omission that esulted in an eoneous billing. 27 This finding was affimed in the CA uling which we quote in full and with appoval: We hold that the eo in the billing due to an application of an incoect mete is an omission within the ambit of the fist sentence of Section 25, Annex C to the TSC. x x x. xx xx The eo committed by petitione Tansco was an om1ss10n because it failed to use the coect mete device, that is, one with a multiplie of 5,250, notwithstanding its admission in the Mete Test Repot that it used the said multiplie. When Tansco and Genco computed the billings fo espondent MORESCO I fo the months following the installation of the new mete device, they belatedly discoveed that the new device had a multiplie of 3,500 instead of 5,250. This explained the unde-billings. We note that when Tansco installed the new mete device, it believed that the multiplie of which was 5,250 when, in eality, it was 3,500. The eo was caused by Tansco's own act of installing a mete device with a multiplie of 3,500 which was diffeent fom what it was supposed to install, that is, one with a multiplie of 5,250. Stated diffeently, Tansco's omission consists in failing to install a device with a 5,250 multiplie. If thee was any eo in the pesent case, it was only in Tansco's belief that the intenal multiplie of the new mete device was 5,250 instead of 3,500. Consideing that a multiplie is an inheent component of evey mete device, as Tansco expessly so stated, the coect mete device with a multiplie of 5,250 could have been available to it o, if not, within its means to obtain, had it only execised odinay diligence. 28 It is a well-entenched ule that "by eason of the special knowledge and expetise of administative agencies ove mattes falling unde thei juisdiction, they ae in a bette position to pass judgment theeon; thu~ thei findings of fact in that egad ae geneally accoded geat espect, if not finality, by the couts." 29 This ule holds tue especially in this case, in 26 Id. 27 Rollo, p Id. at So/mayo v. Aoyo, 520 Phil. 854, 875 (2006); Bulifan v. COA, 360 Phil. 626 ( 1998); Villaflo v. CA, 345 Phil. 524 ( 1997). ~
8 Decision 8 G.R. No "" which the findings ae suppoted by substantial evidence, 30 and even moe afte these have been affimed by the CA. 31 The conclusion was not without suppoting substantial evidence. Pat of the ecods was the Mete Test Repot, which eadily confimed that thee was no inaccuate mete. That epot shows that the device was calibated in the pesence of epesentatives of both paties to this Petition; that thee tials wee conducted to detemine the accuacy of the new device; and that the aveage accuacy of the device was 100.1%. 32 Also cucial to the ERC's conclusion, which was subsequently affimed by the CA, was the testimony of petitione's witness, M. Edgado Oencia. He expounded on the meaning of "eo due to inaccuate mete"; that is, it is one that cannot be eadily detected, but can only be shown using cetain tools, instuments and/o histoical o statistical data. 33 He hastily pointed, howeve, that the mete-eading eo could eadily be obseved by just looking at the mete-eading epot attached to evey billing funished by petitione to espondent. 34 This fact bolstes the inevitable conclusion that in ode to detect a billing eo, no special instument o tool was necessay - a tool othewise equied when the eo is due to an inaccuate mete. We theefoe see no eason to depat fom the assailed uling. The claim that Moesco I was unjustly eniched at the expense of petitione is equally untenable fo a simple eason. Because a contact exists between the paties, the obligations aising theefom have the foce of law between the paties and must be complied with in good faith. 35 WHEREFORE, pemises consideed, the instant Petition is heeby DENIED. SO ORDERED. MARIA LOURDES P.A. SERENO Chief Justice, Chaipeson 30 Santos v. Manalili, 512 Phil. 324 (2005). 31 Public Estates Authoity v. Uy, 423 Phil. 407 (2001). 32 1d.at Id. 34 Id. 35 Aticle 1159 of the Civil Code.
9 Decision 9 G.R. No WE CONCUR: ~~ft~ TERESITA J. LEONARDO-DE CASTRO Associate Justice ESTELA M~E~BERNABE Associate Justice S. CAGUIOA CERTIFICATION Pusuant to Section 13, Aticle VIII of the Constitution, I cetify that the conclusions in the above Decision had been eached in consultation befoe the case was assigned to the wite of the opinion of the Cout. MARIA LOURDES P.A. SERENO Chief Justice..
Raycom Program Ventures, Inc. v Reliable Fast Cash, LLC 2018 NY Slip Op 32945(U) November 20, 2018 Supreme Court, Kings County Docket Number:
Raycom Pogam Ventues, nc. v Reliable Fast Cash, LLC 2018 NY Slip Op 32945(U) Novembe 20, 2018 Supeme Cout, Kings County Docket Numbe: 501246/18 Judge: Leon Ruchelsman Cases posted with a "30000" identifie,
More information~epublic of tbe llbilippines. ~upreme ~ourt. ;JMnniln FIRST DIVISION. and. Petitioners, INSURANCE. Petitioner, DECISION.
~epublic of tbe llbilippines ~upeme ~out ;JMnniln FIRST DIVISION ~.. " ;....~ :.>:1.J,.~ ;,,: ; t.i ::. ;!'-;:.... ~: :,_.. 1:.tli :;1t~. t_ "'\ ~~;~ i 1;:- 1"1..::-',\~c ; '14:. 1--:::.....!. i \ i..;;.;..._
More informationThe Chief Executives further recommended that said
WHEREAS, The Chief Executives of the Five Civilized Tibes in Convention at Eufaula, Indian Teitoy, May 21, 1903, ecommended that the Geneal Council of each Nation authoize the Chief Executive to issue
More informationPLANNING DEPARTMENT TRANSMITTAL TO THE CITY CLERK S OFFICE
PLANNING DEPARTMENT TRANSMITTAL TO THE CITY CLERK S OFFICE CITY PLANNING CASE: ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENT: COUNCIL DISTRICTS: CPC-2018-2657-CA ENV-2018-2658-CE All PROJECT LOCATION: Citywide APPLICANT TELEPHONE
More informationpullig&co Solicitors CHABITYCOMMISSION RECEIVED IN 22 JAN 2003 DECLARATION OF TRUST DATED constituting THE GUILD OF OUR LADY OF GOOD COUNSEL
1 RECEIVED IN REGcTP&T!0fS3(T) 22 JAN 2003 CHABITYCOMMISSION DATED 2003 DECLARATION OF TRUST constituting THE GUILD OF OUR LADY OF GOOD COUNSEL pullig&co Solicitos B K I D - W t I. HOUSE 9 BRIDEWELL PLACE
More informationORDINANCE NO BK: 1384 PG: 85
I. I R ** OFFICIOL RECORDS ** ORDINANCE NO. 99-2 5 BK: 1384 PG: 85 AN ORDINANCE CREATING A MUNICIPAL SERVICE BENEFIT UNlT TO BE KNOWN AS THE "HERNANDO BEACH UNITS 9, 10, & I I FlRE HYDRANT MUNICIPAL SERVICE
More informationThe Constitutional Convention
The Public Good "To secue the public good and pivate ights against a dange of such faction, and at the same ~,- time to peseve the spiit and the fom of popula govenment, is then the geat object to which
More informationMESSAGE FROM THE CHAIRMAN
MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIRMAN You have been selected to pefom one of the most impotant civic duties. As a polling office fo the upcoming Paliamentay and Pesidential Elections, you will facilitate the pocess
More information~epublic of tbe ~bilippines ~upreme ~ourt ;!ffilanila FIRST DIVISION. x
epublic of tbe ~bilippines ~upreme ~ourt ;!ffilanila FIRST DIVISION PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, - versus - ARIELLAYAG Accused-Appellants. G.R. No. 214875 Present: SERENO, C.J., Chairperson,
More informationCongressional Research Service The Library of Congress
Congessional Reseach Sevice The Libay of Congess t! Tbis coutesy ot Tbe Vacation Lane GoUP Washington, D.C. 20540 Febuay 7, 1989 TO FROM SUBJECT Hon. Edwad J. Makey Attention: Cathy Huwit Ameican Law Division
More informationCITY OF ROCKWALL, TEXAS ORDINANCE NO SUP NO. 122
CITY OF ROCKWALL, TEXAS ORDIACE O. 14-27 SUP O. 122 A ORDIACE OF THE CITY COUCIL OF THE CITY OF ROCKWALL, TEXAS, AMEDIG THE UIFIED DEVELOPMET CODE OF THE CITY OF ROCKWALL, TEXAS, AS PREVIOUSLY AMEDED,
More information3Repuhlic of tbe ~bilippineg. ~upreme (!Court ;ffianila EN BANC DECISION
= 3Repuhlic of tbe bilippineg upreme (!Court ;ffianila EN BANC NATIONAL TRANSMISSION CORPORATION, Petitioner, - versus - G.R. No. 223625 Present: SERENO, C.J, CARPIO, VELASCO, JR., LEONARDO-DE CASTRO,
More informationDiscussion Paper No. 2003/27 Efficiency Gains from the Elimination of Global Restrictions on Labour Mobility. Ana María Iregui *
Discussion Pape No. 2003/27 Efficiency Gains fom the Elimination of Global Restictions on Labou Mobility An Analysis using a Multiegional CGE Model Ana Maía Iegui * Mach 2003 Abstact This pape computes
More information:., :.~v1 r:.j :J;: -,;::. tr..1'j',r... ~i 1 ~- 1 -r.\
,., 3aepublic of tbe Jlbilippines ~upreme Qeourt ;fffilanila FIRST DIVISION SPOUSES AUGUSTO and NORA NAVARRO, Petitioners, :.,,~r.,.t: :--.:..:.:r, ~.. ~:,:.: t..a...i. : 1,LJ t':a:.11; ~,;,,..-,l* e fe~
More information1U<-o,,,,.r+,.\ ('. :! ~ 'f. -M,.1,, ,~;;~,,~~ 3Repuhlic of tlje tlbilippineg. ~upreme QI:ourt. ;Mnniln FIRST DIVISION
1U
More informationStrategic Timing of Ballot Initiatives: Evidence from Wisconsin School Referenda
Stategic Timing of Ballot Initiatives: vidence fom Wisconsin School Refeenda Mac Meedith Stanfod Gaduate School of Business Political conomics Field Pape Last Updated: 11/15/04 ABSTRACT: One impotant consideation
More informationBRAMPTON bromplon.(q Flower City
BRAMPTON bomplon.(q Flowe City Copoate Sevices Legal Sevices Decembe 14 2011 By couie and fax to 416-585-6882 Ministy of Municipal Affais and Housing Municipai Sevices Office - Cental Ontaio 777 Bay Steet
More informationMINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30P.M. MARCH 25, 1997
,--- --- ----- --------- ----- ------- ---- ---------~--! ~ ------ - - - - - [ MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30P.M. MARCH 25, 1997 CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL CITY CLERK'S
More informationCITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 5:00 p.m. CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING 6:00p.m. MINUTES OCTOBER 9, 2001
!-- - --------------------------------------------- - -- ------ CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 5:00 p.m. CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING 6:00p.m. MINUTES OCTOBER 9, 2001 CALL TO ORDER
More information3aepubHc of tbe flbilippines
3aepubHc of tbe flbilippines ~upreme Qtourt :!Manila FIRST DIVISION SPOUSES VICTOR P. DULNUAN and JACQUELINE P. DULNUAN,. Petitioners, - versus - G.R. No. 196864 Present: SERENO, C.J., Chairperson, LEONARDO
More informationWar, Uncertainty, and Leader Tenure
Wa, Uncetainty, and Leade Tenue Badley C. Smith William Spaniel June 1, 2016 Abstact How do new leades impact cisis negotiations? We ague that opposing states know less about such a leade s esolve ove
More informationx ~-x
l\cpublic of tijc IJilippincg upre111e QCourt ;fflfln n iln FIRST DIVISION SUPREME COURT OF THE PHILIPPINES 0)1fil 1..1uL 2 s 2017 r t -. av:...?tr TIME:.. d1 au SUMIFRU (PHILIPPINES) CORP. (surviving
More information3L\epublic of tbe!lbilippine~ ~upreme ([ourt :fflanila THIRD DIVISION. Respondent. January 15, 2014 ' DECISION
3L\epublic of tbe!lbilippine~ ~upreme ([ourt :fflanila THIRD DIVISION PHILIPPINE NATIONAL BANK, Petitioner, - versus- G.R. No. 186063 Present: VELASCO, JR., J., Chairperson, PERALTA, ABAD, MENDOZA, and
More informationWar, Uncertainty, and Leader Tenure
Wa, Uncetainty, and Leade Tenue Badley C. Smith William Spaniel Octobe 7, 2016 Abstact How do new leades impact cisis negotiations? We ague that opposing states know less about such a leade s esolve ove
More information,,.,:.J,-.;..i>iC'1::oe-+... :: LA :I. ~ -~l/ ~;(' ~ --:.J>,,,~ Q~,!.~~N~--- Republic of the Philippines SUPREME COURT Manila EN BANC DECISION
,,.,:.J,-.;..i>iC'1::oe-+... '. :: LA :I ~ -~l/ ~;(' ~ --:.J>,,,~ Q~,!.~~N~--- Republic of the Philippines SUPREME COURT Manila EN BANC TERESITA P. DE GUZMAN, in her capacity as former General Manager;
More information3Repuhlic of tbe ~bilippines ~upreme <!Court. ;fffilanila EN BANC. Respondent. March 8, 2016 ~~~-~
3Repuhlic of tbe ~bilippines ~upreme
More informationl\epnblic of tlje tlljilippines ~upren1e QCourt ;fffilanila THIRD DIVISION RESOLUTION
l\epnblic of tlje tlljilippines ~upren1e QCourt ;fffilanila c:ic:rtl~rue COPY ~~~.~~. Third Otvision JUN 2 7 2016. THIRD DIVISION STRONGHOLD INSURANCE CO., INC., Petitioner, - versus - G.R. No. 174838
More information10 E. Chicago St. - Coldwater, MI BRANCH DISTRICT LIBRARY SYSTEM BOARD MINUTES Central Library Meeting Room. July 16, :00 P.M.
10 E. Chicago St. - Coldwate, MI 49036 BRANCH DISTRICT LIBRARY SYSTEM BOARD MINUTES Cental Libay Meeting Room % v* July 16, 2002 6:00 P.M. PRESENT FOR ROLL CALL Mailyn Ashdown, Caol Bown, Doothy Chey,
More informationl\epublic of tbe tlbilippine~ ~upren1e QCourt ;Jfllln n iln FIRST DIVISION
l\epublic of tbe tlbilippine~ ~upren1e QCourt ;Jfllln n iln FIRST DIVISION RADIO MINDANAO NETWORK, INC., Petitioner, - versus - G.R. No. 167225 Present: SERENO, CJ., LEONARDO-DE CASTRO, BERSAMIN, PEREZ,
More information(/ ~;:,,\ A~... ~%~ ...,e,.~ r w... #:( . ~ ~'"-!!!~ l\epublic of tbe llbilippines $>upreme (!Court.ff[anila FIRST DIVISION DECISION
A~... ~%~ (/ ~;:,,\...,e,.~ r w... #:(. ~ ~'"-!!!~ l\epublic of tbe llbilippines $>upreme (!Court.ff[anila.--...: ~,..... ;,. ~..-:.,... ~-=--, ~-~,.~ "".::.,.~;~!,' ~':4: ~~:r.:~.-~~~~ ~ i...;:. :. ;.:.~.
More informationMINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30P.M. JUNE 25, 1996
CALL TO ORDER CITY CLERK'S ANNOUNCEMENT EXECUTIVE SESSION PUBLIC PARTICIPATION INVOCATION PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE APPROVAL OF AGENDA MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30P.M.
More information,.!-'<.:*'""'"" /~~,,.'.. ""V.;; \l' ' ~; .. :M::- \."- l! ~"..!!!':.~~~/ l\epublic of tlje ~bilippine~ $>upreme <!Court. ~nnila FIRST DIVISION
,.!-'upreme
More informationl\epttblic of tbe tlbilippineti
l\epttblic of tbe tlbilippineti ~ttpreme ~ourt TJjaguio ~itp THIRD DIVISION HEIRS OF DANILO ARRIENDA, ROSA G ARRIENDA, MA. CHARINA ROSE ARRIENDA-ROMANO, MA. CARMELLIE ARRIENDA-MARA, DANILO MARIA ALVIN
More informationMINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30P.M. DECEMBER 14, 1993
------- ----------------- ----------------- - -~-- ------ 1 MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30P.M. DECEMBER 14, 1993 EXECUTIVE SESSION The Executive potion of the City Council
More informationWar, Uncertainty, and Leader Tenure
Wa, Uncetainty, and Leade Tenue Badley C. Smith William Spaniel Decembe 5, 2016 Abstact How do new leades impact cisis negotiations? We ague that opposing states know less about such a leade s esolve ove
More informationl.epublit of tfellbilipptne~,upreme Court ;flanila
-l l.epublit of tfellbilipptne~,upreme Court ;flanila FIRST DIVISION EXPRESS PADALA (ITALIA) S.P.A., now BDO REMITTANCE (ITALIA) S.P.A., Petitioner, -versus- HELEN M. OCAMPO, Respondent. G.R. No. 202505
More informationANNUAL REPORT OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL 279
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL 279 the statute, constitutes a quoum. Section 25.62, F. S. The vacancies have now been filled; ho\veve, 25.63, id., povides that a chate commission shall pesent a
More informationCITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OF SPECIAL MEETING 4:30P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING 6:00P.M. MARCH 13, 2001
CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OF SPECIAL MEETING 4:30P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING 6:00P.M. MARCH 13, 2001 CALL TO ORDER Mayo Weste called to ode the special meeting of the City Council
More informationMINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING. CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30 p.m. NOVEMBER 12, Councilmember Heidt read the invocation.
MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:30 p.m. NOVEMBER 12, 1991 CITY CLERK ANNOUNCEMENT INVOCATION CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL FLAG SALUTE,,_ PRESENTATIONS PROCLAMATIONS APPROVAL
More information,lt\.epubltt Of tbe f}btltpptuesthird Division
. CERTIFIED TRUE CO.Pi I. LAP- ]1),,, Divisio Clerk of Court,lt\.epubltt Of tbe f}btltpptuesthird Division upreme Qtourt JUL 26 2011 Jmanila THIRD DIVISION. ALEJANDRO D.C. ROQUE, G.R. No. 211108 Petitioner,
More informationMilitarized Disputes, Uncertainty, and Leader Tenure
Militaized Disputes, Uncetainty, and Leade Tenue Badley C. Smith William Spaniel June 28, 2018 Abstact How do new leades impact cisis negotiations? We ague that opposing states know less about such a leade
More information~;i.. r I,., ~~ 3&epublic of tbe i)bilippineit &upreme Court jffilanila EN BANC RESOLUTION
@" ~;i.. r I,., (ll ~~ 3&epublic of tbe i)bilippineit &upreme Court jffilanila EN BANC NORMA M. GUTIERREZ, Complainant, A.C. No. 10944 Present: - versus - ATTY. ELEANOR A. MARAVILLA ONA. SERENO, C.J.,
More informationx~t~&~~ <~, ". ht. w / , ;..,!:i' \"'(...,,.<!...,. -~/ ~~h4t!!~' 3Rcpublir of tbc l)ijiltpptnc% ~upreme QCourt jflfln n iln FIRST DIVISION
x~t~&~~
More information~epublit of tbe J)bilippines $upreme <!Court. ~anila EN BANC DECISION
~epublit of tbe J)bilippines $upreme
More informationl\epublic of tbe ~bilippineg i>uprmtt lourt :ffianila
fm l\epublic of tbe ~bilippineg i>uprmtt lourt :ffianila SECOND DIVISION CE CASECNAN WATER and ENERGY COMPANY, INC., Petitioner, -versus - THE PROVINCE OF NUEV A ECIJA, THEOFFICEOFTHEPROVINCIAL ASSESSOR
More informationThe Virtual Watercooler: Influences of Political Comedy on Social Media Discussion
Easten Michigan Univesity DigitalCommons@EMU Senio Honos Theses Honos College 2013 The Vitual Watecoole: Influences of Political Comedy on Social Media Discussion Andew Abad Follow this and additional
More information~epublic of tbe llbilippines $>upreme <!Court :fflanila SECOND DIVISION
F., ~epublic of tbe llbilippines $>upreme
More information[! l l l l U JOURNALS YUKON LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY FIRST SESSION. 32nd LEGISLATURE. (EGISCAIlYE 08RAR'l. E.[EASE REt.URN. March 20, May 15, 2008
(EGSCAYE 08RAR'. E.EASE REt.URN JOURNAS YUKON EGSATVE ASSEMBY! U FRST SESSON 32nd EGSATURE Mach 20, 2008 - May 15, 2008 Speake: The Hon. Ted Saffen --; ; JOURNAS YUKON EGSATVE ASSEMBY " (, --, FRST SESSON
More informationtheir political agenda. ln addition, the paper within their party structure according to
SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF WOMEN'S REPRESENTATION IN NATIONAL POLITICS Bangladesh has made emakable pogess afte the 2008 elections in inceasing epesentation of women in Paliament to sixty-nine membes. lnceasing
More information2 Ideology and the nature of the state
2 Ideology and the natue of the state Timeline Key questions 1914 Jun Red Week Aug Fasci di Azione Rivoluzionaia set up Nov founding of Il Popolo d Italia What ole did ideology play in Mussolini s ise
More informationGOVERNOR ABBOTT SIGNS OIL AND NATURAL GAS
THE TIPRO TARGET VOLUME 18, NO. 10 May 21, 2015 Texas Independent Poduces and Royalty Ownes Association GOVERNOR ABBOTT SIGNS OIL AND NATURAL GAS PRE-EMPTION BILL INTO LAW Texas Goveno Geg Abbott officially
More information3aepubltc of tbe ~btltpptne~
r~ 3aepubltc of tbe ~btltpptne~ ~upreme ~ourt ;fftilantla SECOND DIVISION RADIOWEALTH COMPANY, INC., FINANCE Petitioner, G.R. No. 227147 Present: - versus - ALFONSO 0. PINEDA, JR., and JOSEPHINE C. PINEDA,
More information3aepublic of tbe flbilippines. ~upreme Qeourt jffilanila FIRST DIVISION
3aepublic of tbe flbilippines ~upreme Qeourt jffilanila FIRST DIVISION SPOUSES BYRON and MARIA LUISA SAUNDERS, Complainants, A.C. No. 8708 (CBD Case No. 08-2192) Present: - versus - ATTY. LYSSA GRACE S.
More informationFIRST DIVISION. x ~ ~ RESOLUTION
FIRST DIVISION PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, - versus - ANTONIO BALCUEV A y BONDOCOY, Accused-Appellant. G.R. No. 214466 Present: SERENO, CJ, Chairperson, LEONARDO-DE CASTRO, BERSAMIN,
More informationLimited Horizons and the Persistence of Collective Farms in Post-Soviet Agriculture
Limited Hoizons and the Pesistence of Collective Fams in Post-Soviet Agicultue Matin Petick Leibniz Institute of Agicultual Development in Cental and Easten Euope (IAMO), Halle (Saale), Gemany and Michael
More informationCITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 15:00 P.M. CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING 6:00P.M. MINUTES OCTOBER 23, 2001
CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 15:00 P.M. CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING 6:00P.M. MINUTES OCTOBER 23, 2001 CALL TO ORDER. Mayo Weste called to ode the special meeting of the City Council
More information~epuhlic of tbe llbilippines!~~: :~ j,~,~~.~,~.,; ~upreme qf;ourt l ~!( i\ OEC o , JI J. ;fflanila FIRST DIVISION DECISION
~epuhlic of tbe llbilippines!~~: :~ j,~,~~.~,~.,; 1 ~,:\ ' I \,..wi,,._.._.. # I. ~upreme qf;ourt l ~!( i\ OEC o 9 2016, JI J ;fflanila J~\.V!:.~~- FIRST DIVISION r-,,. - :~~ -- 7;1t;E:_ --- - JINKY S.
More information1.;.~t;,i.),.'r.e t>+ . " 1. M. ~;,_. E;: ~ '..{': 'c ',~/ <-~.~~1~.~~,/' ~epublic of tfje thjilippinen. ~upreme QCourt. ;!
1.;.~t;,i.),.'r.e t>+ 1. M.. " ~;,_. E;: ~ '..{': 'c-... 11... ',~/
More informationW ha e conduct dar ie\ of the appr ed ROP 8 in refi r nc to our Ii nt and maintain our original concem with ap 1- Regional tructur ttached as ).
O'CONNOR MACLEOD HANNA LLP DEC "'oisle:' & Solicilos Thomas C. Hays Bian J. Hanna Kenneth W. WaHs Javis G. Shendan Tanya A. Leedale Megan M. Bown James McAskili Chanlel Goldsmith Melanie Petes Caolyn M.
More informationlllj. ~. i;_l ~ I I '. ~~. ' : ; ) : j jhlt \6 I. '. i : i
lllj. ~. ~ -... ::.- ~i~.. ~~o.j.~1 ltit ~ 1 rt:.....,. ~ " I... t't,... f '.~j'. ' 0.._,;..,....., ~i.\ i..!,,..,, f".. t.i..1.~- ""''1;'. '.....!.;~n...,,~,-{ ". II ' I \ :.~......,,..-~. ' I I ; i i;_l
More informationCritical Masses in the Decollectivisation of Post-Soviet Agriculture
Citical Masses in the Decollectivisation of Post-Soviet Agicultue Matin Petick Leibniz Institute of Agicultual Development in Cental and Easten Euope (IAMO), Halle (Saale), Gemany and Michael R. Cate Depatment
More informationUsing Conflict Analysis Method to Analyze Crimea Crisis Between Russia and Ukraine
Intenational Confeence on Engineeing Management, Engineeing Edcation and Infomation Techlogy (EMEEIT ) Using Conflict Analysis Method to Analyze Cimea Cisis Between Rssia and Ukaine iaojia Jiang*, Lei
More informationCITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 15:30 P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:00P.M.
,------ --- - --. ----- -- ----- - - - - - CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 15:30 P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:00P.M. JUNE 26, 2001 CALL TO ORDER
More informationGOVERNOR ABBOTT S VISION FOR TEXAS
THE TIPRO TARGET VOLUME 18, NO. 4 Febuay 19, 2015 Texas Independent Poduces and Royalty Ownes Association STATE OF THE STATE ADDRESS UNDERSCORES GOVERNOR ABBOTT S VISION FOR TEXAS Speaking befoe a joint
More informationTHE TIPRO TARGET TEXAS SECRETARY OF STATE RESIGNS OPEC ANNOUNCES CUTS FOR JANUARY TIPRO Calendar of Events
THE TIPRO TARGET VOLUME 21, NO. 24 DECEMBER 13, 2018 Texas Independent Poduces and Royalty Ownes Association TEXAS SECRETARY OF STATE RESIGNS Secetay of State Rolando Pablos will step down fom his position
More information~upreme <!Court ;ffianila EN BANC DECISION. The Case
~epublit of tbe ~bilippineg ~upreme
More information3aepublic of tbe ~bilippines 10i-'1{bW\i.: COURT OF THE?IHU?PINES. ~upreme, <!Court FIRST DIVISION. Present: DECISION
3aepublic of tbe bilippines 10i-'1{bW\i.: COURT OF THE?IHU?PINES PUBLIC llll'ormation O>FICE upreme,
More information3Republic of tbe flbilippine%
pt{) 3Republic of tbe flbilippine% ~upre1ne QCourt jflffanila SECOND DIVISION NATIONAL TRANSMISSION CORPORATION, Petitioner, - versus - MA. MAGDALENA LOURDES LACSON-DE LEON, MA. ELIZABETH JOSEPHINE L.
More informationAn Garda Síochána. Monthly Report to the Policing Authority. In accordance with Section 41A of the Garda Síochána Act 2005 (as amended)
An Gada Síochána Monthly Repot to the Policing Authoity In accodance with Section 41A of the Gada Síochána Act 2005 (as amended) Febuay 2018 An Gada Síochána Oifig an Choimisinéaa Gnóthaí Copaáideacha
More informationCITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OF SPECIAL MEETING 5:30P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING 6:00P.M. JUNE 28, 2005
CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OF SPECIAL MEETING 5:30P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING 6:00P.M. JUNE 28, 2005 CALL TO ORDER Mayo Smyth called to ode the special meeting of the City Council at
More information.l\epublic of tbe ~bilippine~ ~upreme (!Court ;fffilanila THIRD DIVISION. January 15, 2018 DECISION
.l\epublic of tbe ~bilippine~ ~upreme (!Court ;fffilanila L \. :. -. ic;:--;--- ;, :. ~..._ :. ', : ~ ~ ii. ~.. _ ~ ' _-,, _A\ < :;: \.. ::.-\ ~ ~._:, f c.:.. ~ f.' {.. _).,,.,, g ' ~ '1 ;,,.; / : ;. "-,,_;'
More informationl\rpublic of tbr Jlbiltppinrs ~upreme (!Court ;Manila EN BANC
l\rpublic of tbr Jlbiltppinrs ~upreme (!Court ;Manila EN BANC ALELI C. ALMADOV AR, GENERAL MANAGER ISAWAD, ISABELA CITY, BASILAN PROVINCE, Petitioner, - versus - CHAIRPERSON MA. GRACIA M. PULIDO-TAN, COMMISSION
More informationTHE TIPRO TARGET PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, TAKES EXECUTIVE ACTION TO BOOST AMERICAN ENERGY SECTOR DONALD TRUMP TAKES OFFICE AS 45 TH
THE TIPRO TARGET VOLUME 20, NO. 3 Febuay 2, 2017 Texas Independent Poduces and Royalty Ownes Association DONALD TRUMP TAKES OFFICE AS 45 TH PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, TAKES EXECUTIVE ACTION TO BOOST
More informationVol. 6, No. 1, 2007 Journal of Global Positioning Systems
Vol. 6, No., 7 Jounal of Global Positioning Systems ISSN 446-356 (Pint Vesion) ISSN 446-364 (CD-ROM Vesion) Intenational Association of Chinese Pofessionals in Global Positioning Systems (CPGPS) Jounal
More informationSUPREME COURT FIRST DIVISION. -versus- G.R. No November 24, 1999 D E C I S I O N
SUPREME COURT FIRST DIVISION ALLIED INVESTIGATION BUREAU, INC., Petitioner, -versus- G.R. No. 122006 November 24, 1999 HON. SECRETARY OF LABOR & EMPLOYMENT, acting through Undersecretary CRESENCIANO B.
More informationNon-Immigrant Mobility Responses to Immigrant Inflows in Canada: a Panel-Data Analysis
Non-Immigant Mobility Responses to Immigant Inflows in Canada: a Panel-Data Analysis (DRAFT Pepaed fo the 44 th Annual Confeence of the CEA) Athe H. Akbai & Yigit Aydede 1 Abstact: Population plannes in
More informationRepublic of the Philippines ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION San Miguel Avenue, Pasig City RULES FOR CONTESTABILITY
Republic of the Philippines ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION San Miguel Avenue, Pasig City DRAFT RULES FOR CONTESTABILITY ERC CASE NO. Pursuant to Section 43 of Republic Act No. 9136, its Implementing Rules
More informations r! PAk drew to a close (19). But we must face mentals and applications. This movement the possibility that it may well decline in the 1980's. In any
s! PAk dew to a close (19) But we must face mentals and applications This movement the possibility that it may well decline in the 1980's n any event, thee will be inceased emphasis on selecting eseach
More informationNo. R January 2015 RULES BOARD FOR COURTS OF LAW ACT, 1985 (ACT NO. 107 OF 1985) MAGISTRATES' COURTS: AMENDMENT OF THE RULES OF COURT SCHEDULE
50 No. 38399 GOVENMENT GAZETTE, 23 JANUAY 2015 No.. 33 23 January 2015 ULES BOAD FO COUTS OF LAW ACT, 1985 (ACT NO. 107 OF 1985) MAGISTATES' COUTS: AMENDMENT OF THE ULES OF COUT The ules Board for Courts
More informationSUPREME COURT SECOND DIVISION
SUPREME COURT SECOND DIVISION CITYTRUST BANKING CORPORATION, Petitioner, -versus- G.R. No. 104860 July 11, 1996 NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, and MARIA ANITA RUIZ, Respondents. x----------------------------------------------------x
More informationCITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 4:80 P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY COUNCIL 6:00 P.M. JUNE 12, 2001
CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 4:80 P.M. MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING CITY OF SANTA CLARITA CITY COUNCIL 6:00 P.M. JUNE 12, 2001 CALL TO ORDER Mayo Weste called to ode the special meeting
More informationl\epublit of tbe ~bilippines $>upreme <!Court ;.1Wlanila THIRD DIVISION Respondent.
I ~.TiFlED TRUE COPY '.~ 1 cl~- r k of Court ; :.~ t:t. ~'\ i: ;~;;11 \ t ts U ~! 201 B l\epublit of tbe ~bilippines $>upreme
More information3aepublit of tbe ~bilippines. ;frmanila '; ! f-'{l: 1. NOV i I ; J. x x
3aepublit of tbe ~bilippines!... ;..;. : :.;;: ; ~/ ~.:,~v.t;~:~~ : :; $>upreme Qeourt..:... ~:...,,ri,. ~ ;.c ; r... :: ;:1.-z.. ;11.,.a: ' -~--~ It i \,...;.11..l'-~:.L-,.. U.J.Wf.i.~ 1,. I I I, ;frmanila
More information~ """"'...-. '~~,,.~:,~'~
~ """"'...-. 1\'."~' MIJe' --~ '~~,,.~:,~'~ ' --- 3Republic of tlje flbilippines $>upreme (!Court :fflnniln FIRST DIVISION TERELA Y INVESTMENT AND DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, Petitioner, - versus - G.R. No.
More informationTHE TIPRO TARGET TEXAS SENATE, HOUSE ANNOUNCE COMMITTEES TIPRO HOSTS FRESHMEN LEGISLATOR RECEPTION, EDUCATIONAL BRIEFING AT CAPITOL
THE TIPRO TARGET VOLUME 22, NO. 2 Januay 24, 2019 Texas Independent Poduces and Royalty Ownes Association TEXAS SENATE, HOUSE ANNOUNCE COMMITTEES The 86th legislative session is up and unning, and leadeship
More informationl\epublic of tbe flbilippine9' ~upreme QCourt JManila FIRST DIVISION x x DECISION
l\epublic of tbe flbilippine9' ~upreme QCourt JManila FIRST DIVISION ENRICO S. EULOGIO and NATIVIDAD V. EULOGIO, Petitioners, - versus - PATERNO C. BELL, SR., ROG ELIA CALINGASAN-BELL, PATERNO WILLIAM
More information.. '.!i~:r'1hrr.::, =.:..J!1:.t
i\epubhc of tbe bilippine upreme Ql:ourt ; lllanila CATHAY PACIFIC AIRWAYS, LTD., Petitioner,.. r :-... '.. { :-1.'t, :/. lt.; r;.t..,;, :. ti.:> t'\a...: H!-.0.,l'iJN C'ifl..: "'.'- ;:i,;.;..r::.1,0 1=---\
More information.. ~i)ll:co /:.~ t... :. ~~ ' t, r ;r ' {".~1 ~ ~ -<-I. ' h t. 31\epublic of tlj ~bilippine% ..!~'~" ~ ~upreme (!Court. :!
.. ~i)ll:co /:.~ t... l't \ :. ~~ ' ' {".~1 t, r ;r ~ ~ -
More information=:~~~-~~;~~~~~t: _ -_
~hlic of tlfc Wlftlippines ~uprcnrc OO:our± ~n:girio OiitJJ THIRD DIVISION REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by HONORABLE LOURDES M. TRASMONTE in her capacity as UNDERSECRETARY OF THE DEPARTMENT
More informationx
3R.epublir of tbe flbilipptneg ~upreme Q:Court jflllanila EN BANC NATIONAL TRANSMISSION CORPORATION Petitioner, G.R. No. 204800 Present: SERENO, C. J., CARPIO, VELASCO, JR.,* LEONARDO-DE CASTRO, BRION,**
More information