MEETING CALLED TO ORDER: 7:05 PM RECOGNITIONS/PRESENTATIONS:

Transcription

1 82 MINUTES OF TOWN BOARD MEETING OF THE TOWN OF BRIGHTON, COUNTY OF MONROE, NEW YORK HELD AT THE BRIGHTON TOWN HALL, 2300 ELMWOOD AVENUE, ROCHESTER, NEW YORK July28, 2010 PRESENT: Councilmember Sheila Gaddis Councilmember Louise Novros Councilmember Ray Tierney William Moehle, Attorney for the Town Councilmember James Vogel Susan Kramarsky, Town Clerk Sandra Frankel MEETING CALLED TO ORDER: 7:05 PM RECOGNITIONS/PRESENTATIONS: Presentation by Michael A. Fallace of Brown & Brown of NY Re: COG Health Insurance Consortium. Presentation to Paula Parker OPEN FORUM: Swearing Th of newly appointed Captain Robert Cline to the Brighton Police Department Paul Horowitz APPROVAL OF AGENDA: Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel to approve the agenda with the addition of an Executive Session to discuss matters of litigation APPROVE AND FILE TOWN BOARD MEETING MINUTES FOR: Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel to receive and file the minutes for the meeting of July 14, 2010 PUBLIC HEARINGS: MATTER RE: Proposed Car Wash at 2875 Monroe Ave., Continuation of Public Hearing from July 14, Owner requesting Town Board to review completed Traffic Study (corner of Monroe Ave. and Clover St.) and approve Incentive Zoning application for same. communications received from Brighton residents Mallory Moyer & Bill Egert, Richard A. Kroll, Jim LeChase, Mr. & Mrs. Kenneth Warzocha, Juan A. Nevarez, Esq. Richard Gielow Jr. and Arthur and Ann Kolko concerning Car Wash to be entered into Public Hearing record. (Complete transcript under separate cover)

2 83 PETITIONS: MATTER RE: Proposed Car Wash at 2875 Monroe Avenue, various Town of Brighton signatures collected of those citizens opposed to the building and operation of said Car Wash (see copy of signed Citizen Petition generated by Ms. Ruth Baker). Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel to receive and file the aforementioned petition BIDS: MATTER RE: Approval to solicit requests for proposals for alarm system evaluation and design for the Brighton Town Hall and the Brighton Public Works Operations Center (shared service) (see Resolution #1 and request letter dated July 21, 2010 from Timothy Keef, Dir. Public Works & Highway Dept., Town of Brighton. Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel that the Town Board adopt the resolution as prepared by the Attorney for the Town as set forth in Exhibit No. 1 attached. COMMUNICATIONS: FROM Gary E. Bonarski, Environmental Engineer, NYS Dept, of Environmental Conservation. Div. of Environmental Remediation, Region 8 to Mr. & Mrs. Gregory Meyer; cc to Sandra Frankel, regarding Town & Country Cleaners and the Brownfield Cleanup Program Site work plan. FROM Thomas Goodwin, Planning Mgr., Monroe County Planning & Dev. Dept. to all Municipal s. Receipt of complimentary copy of the 2009 Land Use Report for Monroe County. Actual report is available for viewing with the Town of Brighton Planning Office. FROM George Smith to Frankel thanking the Town Board for allowing him to present the Buckland Creek presentation at the July 14, 2010 Town Board FROM Robert Freeman, Executive Director, NY State Dept. on Open Government to Susan Kramarsky, Brighton Town Clerk dated July 14, 2010 with Advisory Opinion in the matter of Town of Brighton s request for a certain list maintained by the Dept. of Environmental Conservation (D EC). FROM Liza Mortimer, Registrar from the Child Care Council to Rebecca Cotter, Town of Brighton Parks, & Recreation Dept. dated July 6, Approval of application to conduct Child Afterschool Program through the Town of Brighton Parks and Recreation Dept. with additional approval for Rebecca Cotter to assume responsibilities as Director of same. FROM State of New York Public Service Commission Procedural Ruling dated July 16, 2010 regarding Application of National Grid Co. for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public need for the reconstruction of Transmission Line 111 from Lockport to Mortimer, NY FROM David J. Swarts, Chair & Commissioner of State of NY Motor Vehicles Dept. Governor s Traffic Safety Committee dated July 16, 2010 to Captain Robert Cline, Town of Brighton Police Dept. notifying us that the Town of Brighton has been awarded $7,946 to participate in the statewide BUCKLE UP NEW YORK campaign.

3 84 FROM Art Lentilucci, A.I.C.P. Director of Planning and Zoning for the City of Rochester to Ramsey Boehner, Town of Brighton dated July 19, 2010 regarding City of Rochester Response to Town of Brighton s comments on the Citygate draft Final GElS. FROM Douglas Elfner, Director of Consumer Policy, NY State Dept. of Public Service to dated July 19, 2010 regarding Update on the filing of Joint Proposal and Public Statement Hearings, concerning RG&E rate cases. FROM Beth Sciumeca, Executive Dir. National Park Service Erie Canalway, National Heritage Corridor, dated July 8, 2010 to regarding Erie Canalway Map & Guide (located for viewing in s office), 2010 Erie Canalway Heritage Award of Excellence winner information and a copy of the Economic Impact Survey Results for the Erie Canalway region. Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel to receive and file the aforementioned communications COMMITTEE REPORTS: Community Services--Next meeting August 17, 2010 Finance and Administrative Services--Next meeting August 3, 2010 Public Safety Services Next meeting September 14, 2010 Public Works Services Next meeting August 2, 2010 NEW BUSINESS: MATTER RE: Reading and approval of Claims Motion by Councilm ember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel that the read and approve payment of claims as set forth Exhibit No. 2 attached. MATTER RE: Approval of provisional promotion of Town of Brighton Police Lieutenant Robert Cline to rank of Captain. (See Resolution #5 and request letter from Chief of Police Mark T. Henderson dated July 21, 2010). Motion by Councilmember Ray Tierney seconded by Councilmember James Vogel that the Town Board adopt the resolution as prepared by the Attorney for the Town as set forth in Exhibit No. 3 attached. MATTER RE: Approval to adopt Standard Work Day and Reporting Resolution for elected and appointed personnel used for retirement benefit calculations. (See Reporting Resolution) Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember Louise Novros that the Town Board adopt the resolution as prepared by the Finance Director for the Town as set forth in Exhibit No. 4 attached. MATTER RE: Authorize appointment of Marcia Birken as a member of the Brighton Art s Council (See Resolution #3).

4 85 Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember Louise Novros that the Town Board the resolution by the Attorney for Town forth in Exhibit No. 5 adopt attached. as prepared the as set MATTER RE: Approve Agreement between the Town of Brighton to provide consulting; training to the Acting Director, Town Town Board by the Town for period August 1,2010 to November 30, Resolution #2 copy of Agreement). and assistance and Motion by Councilmember Louise Novros the Town Board the resolution Exhibit No. 6 that adopt attached. as prepared seconded and Paula Parker Finance Department, as directed 2010 (See and Finance by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis by the Attorney for Town forth in the as set MATTER RE: Approval for provisional of Evert Garcia to full-time for Town of Brighton Highway Department effective August 2, Resolution #6 letter from Timothy Keef, Director of Public Works & Highway Dept, Town of Brighton Assistant (See the the and request appointment Motion by Councilmember Louise Novros the Town Board the resolution Exhibit No. 7 that adopt attached. as prepared seconded Engineering by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis by the Attorney for Town forth in the as set MATTER RE: Approval for to tariff for the Resolution #7 Dept., Town of Brighton current rates and request execute agreement with RG&E for modifications to Penfield Lighting District letter from Timothy Keef, Dir. Public Works & Highway July 16, Second dated Road Street Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel the Town Board the resolution by Attorney for the Town forth in Exhibit No. 8 adopt attached. as prepared the as set (see that MATTER RE: Approve (90 Town of Brighton Financial Dept. letter from Brandt, certain request temporary reorganization Gary days) and extension personnel. (See dated 7/28/2010) of working Resolution #10 hours Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel the Town Board the resolution by the Attorney for the Town forth in Exhibit No. 9 adopt attached. as prepared as set and of that MATTER RE: Approval for Police Labor for labor negotiation Resolution #9 Henderson). to Relations Specialist Mr. services and request execute Agreement between to letter be the Town of Brighton M. Girvin, J. Martin Inc. provided to the Town of Brighton July 21, from Chief of Police Mark T. dated John 2010 d.b.a. Solutions (see and

5 86 Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel that the Town Board adopt the resolution as prepared by the Attorney for the Town as set forth in Exhibit No. 10 attached. MATTERS OF THE SUPERVISOR: MATTER RE: Revenue and Expense Report for period ended June 30, Motion by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis seconded by Councilmember James Vogel to receive and file aforementioned report MATTER RE: Confirm appointment of Suzanne Zaso as temporary Finance Director for the Town of Brighton. Currently Suzanne holds the position with the Town of Brighton of Deputy Finance director. Motion by Councilmember Louise Novros seconded by Councilmember Sheila Gaddis that the Town Board confirm the appointment of Suzanne Zaso. MOTION TO GO INTO EXECUTIVE SESSION: Motion by Councilmember James Vogel seconded by Councilmember Louise Novros to go into executive session to discuss a matter of litigation and Councilmember Sheila Gaddis excused from Executive Session. Motion by Councilmember James Vogel seconded by Councilmember Louise Novros to come out of executive session at 10:55 PM MEETING ADJOURNED: Motion by Councilmember Louise Novros seconded by Councilm ember James Vogel to adjourn at 11:00 PM CERTIFICATION: I, Susan Kramarsky, 79 Monteroy Road, Rochester, NY do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and accurate record of the proceedings of the Town of Brighton County of Monroe, State of New York meeting held on the 28 th of July 2010 and that I recorded said minutes of the aforesaid meeting of the Town Board of the Town of Brighton, New York.

6 EXI-IIBIT NO. I Ata Town Board Meeting of the Town of Brighton, Monroe County New York held at the Brighton Town Hail, 2300 EImwood Avenue, in said Town of Brighton on the 28th day of July PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAMES R. VOGEL RAYMOND J. TIERNEY III LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS Councilpersons RESOLVED, that correspondence dated July 19, 2010, from Timothy E. Keef, P.E., Commissioner of Public Works, concerning a request for proposals for alarm system evaluation and design for Town Hall and the Highway Department Operations Center, be received and filed; and be it further RESOLVED, that the Commissioner of Public Works is hereby authorized to solicit requests for proposals for alarm system evaluation and design at the Town Hall and the Highway Department Operations Center. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres

7 - AGENCY EXIIIBH NO. 2 CLAIMS FOR APPROVAL AT TOWN BOARD MEETING July 28, 2010 THAT THE CLAIMS AS SUMMARIZED BELOW HAVING BEEN APPROVED BY THE RESPECTIVE DEPARTMENT HEADS AND AUDITED BY THE TOWN BOARD AUDIT COMMITTEE ARE HEREBY APPROVED FOR PAYMENT. A-GENERAL $ D - HIGHWAY H - CAPITAL 5, L - LIBRARY SA-AMBULANCE DIST 1, SB - BUSINESS IMPROVM SK - SIDEWALK DIST SS - SEWER DIST 27, TA TRUST24, TOTAL $ 530, UPON ROLL CALL MOTION CARRIED APPROVED BY: SUPERVISOR COUNCIL MEMBER COUNCIL MEMBER TO THE SUPERVISOR: I CERTIFY THAT THE VOUCHERS LISTED ABOVE WERE AUDITED BY THE TOWN BOARD ON THE ABOVE DATE AND ALLOWED IN THE AMOUNTS SHOWN. YOU ARE HEREBY AUTHORIZED AND DIRECTED TO PAY TO EACH OF THE CLAIMANTS THE AMOUNT OPPOSITE HIS NAME. DATE TOWN CLERK

8 EXHIBIT NO. 3 At a Town Board Meeting of the Town of Brighton, Monroe County, New York, held at the Brighton Town Hall, 2300 Elmwood Avenue, in said Town of Brighton on the 28th day of July PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAMES R. VOGEL RAYMOND J. TIERNEY III LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS Councilpersons RESOLVED, that correspondence dated July 21, 2010, from Mark T. Henderson, Chief of Police, concerning the appointment of a Police Captain, be received and filed; and be it further RESOLVED, that the Town Board hereby approves the provisional appointment of Lieutenant Robert Cline to the rank of Police Captain, effective July 31, 2010, at an annual salary of $105,144, on a probationary basis with a 26 week probationary period. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres

9 F.XHIBI I NO. 4 Standard Work Day and Reporting Resolution BE IT RESOLVED, that the Town of Brighton hereby establishes the following as standard work days for elected and appointed officials and will report the following days worked to the New York State and Local Employees Retirement System based on the record of activities maintained and submitted by these officials to the clerk of this body: Elected Officials Title Name Social Registration Standard Term Participates Days! Security Number Work Beins/Ends in Month Number Day Employers Period Time (Last (Hrs/day) Keeping (based on 4 digits) System Record of (YIN) Activities) Frankel, Sandra L. 6 1/1/10 12/31/11 N CouncilMember Vogel,James 6 1/1/10 12/31/13 N Council Member Tierney Ill, Raymond 6 1/1/09 12/31/1 1 N Council Member Novros, Louise 6 1/1/10 12/31/13 N Council Member Gaddis, Sheila 6 1/1/09 12/31/11 N Justice Morris, Karen 6 1/1/08 12/31/11 N Justice Falk, John 6 1/1/ /31/12 N Clerk/ Receiver of Taxes Kramarsky, Susan 8 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Appointed Officials Directorof Finance Parker, Paula A. 8 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Assist. Director of Finance Zaso, Suzanne 7 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Assessor Ainsworth, Elaine 8 10/1/07 9/30/13 Y Commissioner of Public Works/Highway Keef, Timothy 8 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Deputy Highway Superintendent Anderson, Timothy 8 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Executive Library Director Ries-Taggart, Jennifer 7.5 1/1/07 Deputy Clerk /Receiver of 12/31/12 Y Taxes O Brien, John Patrick 7 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Secretary to Hussar, MaryAnn 7 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Communications Director Clapp, Douglas 7.5 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Historian Lanphear, Mary Jo 6 1/1/10 12/31/10 N 3.25 Police Chief Henderson, Mark 8 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Police Captain Principe, William 8 1/1/10 12/31/11 Y Police Captain Vacant 8 On this of 20 (Signalure of clerk) Date enacted: I, clerk of the governing hoard of the rfown of Brighton, (Name of Employer) the State of New York, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing with the original resolution passed by such board, at a legally convened meeting held on the day of 20_ of

10 EXHIBIT NO. 5 At a Town Board Meeting of the Town of Brighton, Monroe County, New York, held at the Brighton Town Hall, 2300 Elmwood Avenue, in said Town of Brighton on the 28th day of July PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAMES R. VOGEL RAYMOND J. TIERNEY III LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS Councilpersons RESOLVED, that the Town Board hereby appoints Marcia Birken as a member of the Brighton Art Council. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres

11 EXHIBIT NO. 6 At a Town Board Meeting of the Town of Brighton, Monroe County, New York, held at the Brighton Town Hall, 2300 Elmwood Avenue, in said Town of Brighton on the 28th day of July PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAMES R. VOGEL RAYMOND J. TIERNEY III LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS Counci lpersons RESOLVED, that the is hereby authorized to execute and deliver an agreement by and between the Town and Paula A. Parker for consulting services, at a cost not to exceed $4,875 in the aggregate, which agreement shall be in form and substance as may be approved by the Attorney for the Town. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres

12 EXHJBITNO. 7 At a Town Board Meeting of the Town of Brighton, Monroe County New York held at the Brighton Town Hail, 2300 Elmwood Avenue, in said Town of Brighton on the 28th day of July PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAI 1ES R. VOGEL RAYMOND J. TIERNEY III LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS Counci ipersons RESOLVED, that correspondence dated July 16, 2010 from Timothy E. Keef, P.E., Commissioner of Public Works and Highway Superintendant, concerning the appointment of an Engineering Assistant in the Highway Department, be received and filed; and be it further RESOLVED, that the Town Board hereby confirms the appointment by the Highway Superintendent of Evert Garcia as Engineering Assistant in the Highway Department, at an annual salary of $44,304, on a probationary basis with a 52 week probationary period, initially on a provisional basis, to become permanent upon successful completion of the Civil Service examination. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres

13 EXHIBIT NO.8 At a Town Board Meeting of the Town of Brighton, Monroe County, New York, held at the Brighton Town Hall, 2300 Elmwood Avenue, in said Town of Brighton on the 28th day of July PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAMES R. VOGEL RAYMOND J. TIERNEY III LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS Councilpersons RESOLVED, that correspondence dated July 16, 2010 from Timothy E. Keef, P.E., Commissioner of Public Works, together with correspondence attached thereto, be received and filed; and be it further RESOLVED, that the Town Board hereby authorizes the to execute and deliver an agreement by and between the Town, on behalf of the Second Penfield Road Lighting District, and Rochester Gas and Electric to reflect the new Rochester Gas and Electric tariffs, under which the District will save approximately $ per month, which agreement shall be in form and substance that may be approved by the Attorney for the Town. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres

14 Town of Brighton MDNRDE UNTY, NEW Yt3IK DEPARTMENT CF PUBLIC WDRKS 230D ELMW000 AVENUE ROCHESTER, NEW YORK 14G1 B PHONE: (555)7$4-525C FAX: (R5) 7B4-S86 July 16, 2010 The Honorable Finance and Administrative Services Committee Town of Brighton 2300 Elmwood Avenue Rochester, New York re: RG&E Street Lighting Proposal Second Penfield Road Lighting District Revised Tariff Rates Dear Councilperson Gaddis and Committee Members: Per the attached correspondence from RG&E, the tariff governing rates for street lighting was modified to allow for changes in the charges billed as outlined therein. These actions and charges better reflect the actual equipment presently in place in the Second Penfield Road Lighting District, which will result in a savings of $ per month to the district. Therefore, I recommend that the Finance and Administrative Services Committee approve the to execute this document, so that this proposal may take effect upon receipt by RG&E. As always, thank you for your consideration. I will be in attendance at your regularly scheduled July 21, 2010 meeting in the event that you have any questions regarding this matter. Sincerely, Timothy E. eef, Commissi ner o ublic Works TEKIwpd attachment cc: R. Cortina S. Zaso FASC.RGE.PENFILED.[JGHT.DTSTRIC.RENEWALJULY

15 EXHIBIT NO. 9 Ata Town Board Monroe Town Avenue, Town day Brighton, at the Brighton 28th in said of July Meeting of the County, Hall, Town New York, 2300 Elmwood on of Brighton of held the PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAMES R. VOGEL RAYMOND TIERNEY LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS J. III Councilpersons RESOLVED, Brandt, Director of reorganization of the and be it further that Human Town a memorandum dated July Resources, concerning Finance Department, a be 28, 2010 from Gary temporary received and filed; assignment of Public to step hour Amy 3 Works, RESOLVED, Amy Banker, at of the that the Town Board hereby approves the temporary Banker, currently Accountant in the Department of to the position of Acting Assistant Director of Finance 2010 an work week; and be annual salary of $58,219.20, under Non-Represented it further Employee Group Salary Schedule for VII, a 40 RESOLVED, that the Town Board hereby approves the assignment of Jose Rosario, currently Senior Account Clerk in the Finance Department, to the to the position of Acting Accountant in the Department of Public Group VI for a 40 step hour 1 of the Works, at work week; and be an annual salary of $49,940.80, under 2010 Non Represented Employee it further Salary Schedule RESOLVED, that the hours Clerk in the Finance Department, hours per week to 30 hours per be worked for Anna Bowles, temporarily increased week; and be it further Payroll from 25 RESOLVED, that each of the foregoing changes not to exceed ninety days, without enhanced benefits, except that be for a period any Brigtres7.281O-1 0

16 holidays observed during this temporary period for the Acting Assistant Director of Finance and the Acting Accountant would be paid at a rate of eight hours per day. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres O1 0

17 holidays observed during this temporary period for the Acting Assistant Director of Finance and the Acting Accountant would be paid at a rate of eight hours per day. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres

18 EXHIBIT NO. 10 At a Town Board Meeting of the Town of Brighton, Monroe County New York, held at the Brighton Town HaIl, 2300 Elmwood Avenue, in said Town of Brighton on the 28th day of July PRESENT: SANDRA L. FRANKEL, JAMES R. VOGEL RAYMOND J. TIERNEY III LOUISE NOVROS SHEILA A. GADDIS Counci lpersons RESOLVED, that correspondence dated July 21, 2010 from Mark T. Henderson, Chief of Police, recommending that the Town enter into an agreement with J. Martin Solutions, Inc. for police collective bargaining negotiations, be received and filed; and be it further RESOLVED, that the is hereby authorized to execute and deliver an agreement by and between the Town and J. Martin Solutions, Inc., under which John N. Girvin, the principal of J. Martin Solutions, Inc., would conduct collective bargaining negotiations with the Brighton Police Patrolmens Association for a new contract, at an hourly rate of $90 per hour, which agreement shall be in form and substance as may be approved by the Attorney to the Town. Dated: July 28, 2010 Sandra L. Frankel, Voting James R. Vogel, Councilman Voting Raymond J. Tierney III, Councilman Voting Louise Novros, Councilperson Voting Sheila A. Gaddis, Councilperson Voting Brigtres