Brighton City Council Meeting

Transcription

1 1. Call to Order 2. Pledge of Allegiance 3. Roll Call 4. Consider Approval of the Agenda Consent Agenda Items Brighton City Council Meeting City Hall Council Chambers 200 N First St. Brighton, Michigan (810) Approval of Minutes: Study Session of April 19, Approval of Minutes: Regular Meeting of April 19, Approval of Zoning Board of Appeals Appointments 8. Approval of Millage Informational Open House Schedule Regular Business Meeting May 3, :30 p.m. AGENDA 9. Approval of Resolution for Liquor License Transfer from Border Cantina-Brighton, Inc, to SBS 1, LLC, dba Single Barrel Social LLC, Located at 8724 W. Grand River Ave, Brighton, MI Correspondence 10. Call to the Public 11. Staff Updates 12. Updates from Councilmember Liaisons to various Boards and Commissions 13. Eagle Scout Presentation (Noah Duneth) Public Hearing 14. Conduct a Public Hearing and Consider Approval of the Fiscal Year 2018/2019 Budget New Business 15. Consider Resolution Establishing the Levy and Authorizing the Collection of Taxes, Penalties and Fees for FY 2018/ Consider Approval of an Extension to the City s Agreement with Waste Management for Trash, Recycling, and Yard Waste Services 17. Discussion of Adding a Sunset Provision (or Term) to the Headlee Override Millage Ballot Language Other Business 18. Call to the Public 19. Adjournment

2 City Council Special Meeting 200 N First St City Hall Council Chambers Brighton, Michigan (810) MINUTES OF THE STUDY SESSION OF THE BRIGHTON CITY COUNCIL HELD ON APRIL 19, 2018 STUDY SESSION Mayor Muzzin called the Study Session to order at 6:30 p.m. Present were Mayor Muzzin, Councilmembers: Bohn, Emaus, Gardner, Pettengill, and Tobbe. Absent was Mayor Pro-Tem Pipoly. Staff: City Manager Nate Geinzer, Attorney Paul Burns, City Clerk Tara Brown, DPW Director Marcel Goch, Police Chief Rob Bradford, and Finance Director Gretchen Gomolka. There were 6 persons in the audience. CALL TO PUBLIC Mayor Muzzin opened the Call to the Public at 6:30 p.m. with no response. Discussion of No Boundaries Play Structure Local mother and advocate Casey Somerville gave a PowerPoint presentation on Inclusive Playgrounds. Council asked about funding and various groups that have been interested in funding. Locations throughout the City were discussed. The closest inclusive play structure is located in Ann Arbor. Council agreed that this is a great idea and supportive of the direction Ms. Somerville is heading, just need logistics to align. Discussion on Upcoming Approved/Budgeted Maintenance Projects Manager Geinzer outlined three possible upcoming projects. Council and staff spoke briefly about the shoreline and plans associated with the engineering. Manager Geinzer also spoke briefly about the possibility for an increase in cost for the roof construction. CALL TO THE PUBLIC Mayor Muzzin opened the Call to the Public at 7:25 p.m. Pat Cole wanted to compliment the Casey Somerville on her presentation and would like to see the project move forward. Ms. Cole would also like to be part of the planning committee for the inclusive park, should one be formed. Jim Vichich of the Brighton Historical Society asked that Millpond Shoreline Restoration also spell out a space for people feeding ducks or signage indicating where ducks may be fed. Mayor Muzzin closed the Call to the Public at 7:32 p.m. ADJOURNMENT Motion by Councilmember Tobbe, seconded by Councilmember Emaus to adjourn the meeting at 7:33p.m. The motion carried unanimously.

3 Brighton City Council Minutes City Hall Council Chambers 200 N First St. Brighton, Michigan (810) MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE BRIGHTON CITY COUNCIL HELD ON APRIL 19, Call to Order Mayor Muzzin called the Regular Meeting to order at 7:33 p.m. 2. The Pledge of Allegiance was recited 3. Roll Call Present were Mayor Muzzin, Councilmembers: Bohn, Emaus, Gardner, Pettengill, and Tobbe. Absent was Mayor Pro-Tem Pipoly. Staff: City Manager Nate Geinzer, Attorney Paul Burns, City Clerk Tara Brown, DPW Director Marcel Goch, Police Chief Rob Bradford, Utilities Director Tim Krugh, Senior Community Development Associate Mike Caruso, Finance Director Gretchen Gomolka, Human Resources Director Michelle Miller. There were 15 persons in the audience. Motion by Councilmember Emaus, seconded by Councilmember Bohn, to excuse Mayor Pro-Tem Pipoly from tonight s meeting for personal reasons. The motion carried unanimously. 4. Consider Approval of the Agenda Motion by Councilmember Bohn, seconded by Councilmember Pettengill, to approve the Agenda as presented. The motion carried unanimously. CONSENT AGENDA Motion by Councilmember Emaus, seconded by Councilmember Bohn, to approve the Consent Agenda as presented. The motion carried unanimously. The following items were approved: 5. Approval of Minutes: Study Session of April 5, Approval of Minutes: Regular Meeting of April 5, Approval of Minutes: Closed Session of April 5, Approval of Amendment to the City Council Approved Agreement with the Charter Township of Brighton to Exclude the Shepherd of the Lakes Parcel from the City s Water Service Area as Outlined in the 2008 Water Service Contract 9. Approval of Agreement with St. Paul s Church for the Construction of the Millpond Band Shell and Amphitheater

4 City Council Regular Meeting April 5, 2018 Page 2 Correspondence 10. Call to the Public Mayor Muzzin opened the Call to the Public was made at 7:37 Ms. Susan Alles stated that Republic Garbage Collectors picks up the morning trash at local business near her home at 4:30 a.m. on Monday and Wednesday, it is very loud. She stated that after Republic was contacted by Tim Corrigan trash was picked up later but has now reverted to the usual 4:30 a.m. She asks that the City look into creating an ordinance to prohibit early pick up. Ms. Alles distributed letters to Council and Staff that she has sent in the past. Ms. Susan Bakhaus stated that she tried to attend the Brighton Veterans Committee but was denied entry because she did not have an agenda item. Ms. Bakhaus further commented that Councilmember Emaus, who is on the Brighton Veterans Committee Director and as a liaison to City Council, cannot make financial decisions. She asks that Councilmember Emaus resign. Jim Vichich of the Brighton Historical Society wanted to let Council and residents know about two upcoming events: The Vintage Jewelry Show Fundraiser on April 28, 2018 from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. at the CoBach Center and the 10 th Annual Village Cemetery cleanup is scheduled for May 5, 2018 from 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. Pat Cole is concerned about the City budget process and learned that there will be an increase in water, sewer, and trash pickup. Ms. Cole asked that residents have a say in the rate increase. She feels that there is no consideration for single homeowners on a fixed income. Ms. Cole also asked if the inclusive play structure would be for all to enjoy. Mayor Muzzin closed the Call to the Public at 7:53 p.m. Manager Geinzer spoke briefly about the early morning trash pickup. He noted that efforts have been taken to remedy the situation, which stopped the early pickup for times but revert back. Councilmember Pettengill clarified that the inclusive play structure would be open to all. Councilmember Emaus noted that the Brighton Veteran Memorial Committee is a private nonprofit with a closed board meeting. Anyone who wishes to address the board can submit an agenda item. The individual trying to attend the last meeting did not have an agenda item. It is a private organization and often speaks about financial aspects of the Committee which are private. Councilmember Emaus clarified that he does not received a pecuniary benefit; he receives a fifty dollar stipend to attend the meeting as a City Council liaison. Mayor Muzzin spoke about the budget process and how it is adopted. The budget booklet is available to all for inspection on the website and at the front counter at City Hall. Mayor Muzzin noted that all Councilmembers are residents of the City and as residents would be affected by a tax or utility increase. 11. Staff Updates Chief Bradford noted that April 24, 2018 is Coffee with a Cop at Starbucks between 9:00 a.m. and 11:00 a.m.

5 City Council Regular Meeting April 5, 2018 Page 3 Utilities Director Tim Krugh stated that hydrant flushing will begin May 7, 2018 and finish May 10, DPW Director Goch stated that CSX will be out during the spring and will update Council as soon as information is available. He also noted that there will be some closures this summer on Brighton Lake Road. Director Goch will update Council as soon as information is available. Manager Geinzer stated that the second annual Millpond Cleanup is scheduled for April 21, 2018 and will begin at 9:00 a.m. followed with an Arbor Day tree planting and special dedication at 2:30 p.m. 12. Updates from Councilmember Liaisons to various Boards and Commissions Councilmember Pettengill stated that during the Zoning Board of Appeals meeting there were several variance requests for 765 S 3 rd Street, none were granted due to lack of hardship. She also noted that the annual Imagination Station Spring Kickoff is on May 12, Councilmember Emaus noted that the Brighton Veterans Memorial Committee met on April 11 th during which the Brighton Garden Club presented their spring planting intentions. During some of the upcoming events the Committee will showcase era specific battle field crosses. There will be a Committee member present to educate the public on those battle field crosses. Mayor Muzzin attended the April 12, 2018 BAFA meeting and received updates on benefits summary and tuition reimbursement to full time firefighters. BAFA awarded a one-year lawn care contract to Clear Water Properties on the five stations. Mayor Muzzin also attended the DDA meeting on April 17, 2018 where the DDA portion of the Budget was adopted. Arbor Day is on Saturday, April 21, 2018 with activities at City Hall and a special tree planting dedication to Darian Locklear. Public Hearing 13. Conduct a Public Hearing and Consider Approval for the Vacation of St. Paul Street Right of Way as Described Senior Community Development Associate Mike Caruso gave a brief overview of the vacation history. Mayor Muzzin opened the Call to the Public at 8:09 p.m. Hearing and seeing none, the Call to the Public was closed. Councilmember Tobbe asked Utilities Director Krugh if there was any potential use for utilities, storm water, electric, or any other utility that could be affected by this right away. Director Krugh stated that there is absolutely no use for that property for a utility easement. Councilmember Tobbe asked that it be noted that there would be no future use for that property based on Utility Director Krugh s assessment. Motion by Councilmember Emaus, seconded by Councilmember Gardner to approve Resolution to Approve the Vacation of St. Paul Street Right of Way as Described. The motion carried by roll call vote. New Business

6 City Council Regular Meeting April 5, 2018 Page Consider Approval of Contribution to the Brighton Community Center in the Amount of $7,000 Finance Director Gretchen Gomolka introduced Nancy Blumenthal, Director of the Brighton Senior Center. Ms. Blumenthal gave a brief overview of the Senior Center and budget. She is proud to report that there were over 7,600 visits to the center. Currently there is no member fee but she has asked for a donation of twenty dollars. Nearly 40% of the members reside in the in the City. The Center provides a free flu shot clinic, blood pressure and skin cancer screening, as well as foot care. Hot lunch is provided Monday through Thursday. Transportation is provided to its members. Ms. Blumenthal reported that Busch s donates every day and Panera donates once a week. The Director is visiting other municipalities to ask for similar donations. Motion by Councilmember Bohn, seconded by Councilmember Emaus to approve the contribution to the Brighton Community Center in the amount of $7, The motion carried unanimously. 15. Consider Approval of Tetra Tech Proposal for North Second Street Road and Utility Improvements Construction Phase Engineering in the Amount of $183,000 Manager Geinzer gave a brief overview of the project. The project is funded by Utilities and General Fund and is in the current budget. Councilmember Tobbe expressed concern over the timing of the project considering all of the current projects. Gary Markstrom from Tetra Tech noted that the project will be completed in three phases. Councilmember Tobbe stated that traffic on Main Street is very thick especially with the Challis Road closure. Mr. Markstrom stated that every effort will be taken for construction to be the least intrusive as possible, noting that some utilities will be interrupted intermittently. Motion by Councilmember Emaus, seconded by Councilmember Bohn to Approve the Tetra Tech Proposal for North Second Street Road and Utility Improvements Construction Phase Engineering in the Amount of $183,000. The motion passed unanimously. 16. Consider Staff Direction on Upcoming Approved/Budgeted Maintenance Projects a. City Hall Roof Manager Geinzer presented a brief picture narrative on the difficulties flashing that the roofing company would needs to address and is asking for Councils approval for an additional $17, Council discussed color, loss of light, and potential problems that could arise during the project. DPW Director Goch stated that he believes that staff and the contractor have done their due diligence to anticipate additional issues but were confident with the roofers assessment. Motion by Councilmember Bohn, seconded by Emaus, to make the necessary changes to the City Hall Roof altering the look of the building and windows around the atrium for needed weatherproofing and roof flashing. The motion passed unanimously.

7 City Council Regular Meeting April 5, 2018 Page 5 b. City Hall Shoreline Restoration Manager Genizer presented a power point photo presentation on the erosion of the shoreline necessitating the restoration along with a plan drawn by the City s landscape engineers. A request for proposals by the end of April would be the target. There was a discussion by Council about the coir logs recommended by Manager Geinzer and a landscape architect with Giffles Webster. Manager Geinzer asked if Council is comfortable with the direction of this project and would like feedback. Council asked about an alternate seawall but looking at budget, the coir logs were most economical and are an encouraged treatment by the MDEQ and the Huron River Watershed Council. Councilmember Pettengill asked if the decomposing coir logs would emit a bad odor. Landscape Design & Associates owner/operator, Karleen Shafer present in the audience, noted there is no smell as the coir logs deteriorate. Mr. Geinzer thanked Council for the feedback and noted he would be back to Council on this project once proposals are received and a recommendation is ready for Council action. Other Business 17. Call to the Public Mayor Muzzin opened the Call to the Public was made at 9:12 p.m. Karleen Shafer, Landscape Design & Associates, reminded Council and Staff that if the intention is to deter geese and other water fowl, it would be best not to plant blueberries and strawberries as outlined in the presentation. She recommends a taller grass as a deterrent. Pat Cole asked if the Veterans Memorial Committee is private, should it be meeting privately on City property paid for by tax dollars. She further asked if the Committee is a 501c3. Mayor Muzzin closed the Call to the Public at 9:16 p.m. Councilmember Bohn stated that the Veterans Memorial Committee meeting on City property is not an issue for him since no tax dollars are going to fund the maintenance of the Memorial. The Committee has enhanced the Millpond area with the Memorial. 18. Adjournment Motion by Councilmember Tobbe, seconded by Councilmember Emaus to adjourn the meeting at 9:19 p.m. The motion carried unanimously. Tara Brown, City Clerk James Muzzin, Mayor

8 City of Brighton REPORT FROM THE CITY MANAGER TO CITY COUNCIL May 3, 2018 SUBJECT: REAPPOINTMENTS TO THE CITY OF BRIGHTON ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS ADMINISTRATIVE SUMMARY David Chaundy and Russ Gottschalk are seeking reappointment to the Brighton Zoning board of Appeals. Barbara Curtis is seeking reappointment to the Brighton Zoning Board of Appeals as an alternate board member. All three have shown dedication and exemplary service as board members and look forward to continuing their service with the Zoning Board of Appeals. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends the reappointment of David Chaundy, Russ Gottschalk, and Barbara Curtis to the City of Brighton Zoning Board of Appeals for 3-year terms ending on May 1, Prepared by: Michael Caruso, Senior Community Development Associate Approved by: Nate Geinzer, City Manager brightoncity.org 200 North First St. Brighton, MI (810)

9 City of Brighton REPORT FROM THE CITY MANAGER TO CITY COUNCIL April 19, 2018 SUBJECT: APPROVAL OF MILLAGE INFORMATIONAL OPEN HOUSE SCHEDULE BACKGROUND Staff has been working on the development of additional information and educational materials regarding the City s Headlee Override Millage request. Staff has identified four (4) dates for informational open houses to be held within four (4) different residential areas in the City (see map attached). o June 13, Fairway Park o June 27, 1010 State Street o July 11, TBD o July 25, Woodlake Park All open houses would run from 6:00 pm 8:00 pm RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that City Council approve the millage open house schedule as outlined. Prepared by: Reviewed & Approved by: Nate Geinzer, City Manager Nate Geinzer, City Manager brightoncity.org 200 North First St. Brighton, MI (810)

10 4/26/2018 Brighton - Google Maps June 27 Corner of Chestnut and N. 5th June 13 Fairway Park July 25 Woodlake Park

11 CITY OF BRIGHTON REPORT FROM THE CITY MANAGER TO CITY COUNCIL April 26, 2018 SUBJECT: REQUEST TO APPROVE LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER FROM BORDER CANTINA- BRIGHTON, INC, TO SBS 1, LLC, DBA SINGLE BARREL SOCIAL LLC, LOCATED AT 8724 W. GRAND RIVER AVE BRIGHTON MI ADMINISTRATIVE SUMMARY Single Barrel Social has obtained a proper liquor license transfer with the State of Michigan Liquor License Control Commission. The current application is for a transfer of the Class C on premises liquor with the addition of Sunday Sales (AM and PM), SDM License with sale of beer and wine to go, including growlers, Outdoor Service Area Permit, which allows for the sale of alcohol on a patio and a Dance Permit. The City of Brighton application was submitted and the proper liquor license application fee has been paid to the City of Brighton. The Brighton City Police department has conducted an investigation of the applicant business including all stockholders and trustees above 10% ownership. A criminal record check reveals the stockholder (s) and trustee (s) have no violations in the State of Michigan. Single Barrel Social will be the first liquor controlled establishment owned and operated by this applicant. The applicant meets the minimum requirements for consideration by the MLCC. The applicant meets the requirement for consideration by City Council. RECOMMENDATION The Police Department has determined that the applicant meets the requirements of the City s liquor ordinances (6-31 to 6-41) and therefore recommends approval of the request. If Council approves, the following resolution is suggested: A resolution approving the sale of alcoholic liquor. Prepared by: Craig C Flood, Deputy Chief of Police Reviewed by: Rob Bradford, Chief of Police Approved by: Nate Geinzer, City Manager

12 A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR WHEREAS, pertinent sections of the Brighton Municipal Code require that the Brighton City Council expressly approve the sale of alcoholic liquor by any person or persons within the City of Brighton; and WHEREAS, the applicants have applied to the Michigan Liquor Control Commission for the transfer of a state issued liquor license to be used within the City of Brighton; and WHEREAS, the Brighton Police Department has conducted an investigation of the applicant and found said applicant to be in compliance with the Brighton Municipal Code; and NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that a transfer of the current license, Border Cantina Brighton, Inc. located at 8724 W. Grand River Ave, dba, Border Cantina to SBS1, LLC dba Single Barrel Social, is approved to sell alcoholic liquor at 8724 W. Grand River Ave. in the City of Brighton in accordance with the Brighton Municipal Code. AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: RESOLUTION DECLARED ADOPTED. Dated: TARA BROWN, City Clerk CERTIFICATION I, Tara Brown, City Clerk of the City of Brighton, do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and correct copy of a Resolution adopted by the City Council of the City of Brighton at a regular meeting held on May 3, TARA BROWN, City Clerk

13 CITY OF BRIGHTON REPORT FROM THE CITY MANAGER TO CITY COUNCIL May 3, 2018 SUBJECT: WASTE MANAGEMENT ONE YEAR REFUSE/RECYCLE CONTRACT EXTENSION ADMINISTRATIVE SUMMARY As of June 30, 2018 the current refuse collection and recycling contract with Waste Management will come to an end. This contract runs concurrently with the City s fiscal year starting July 1 through June 30 and provides an option of two, one-year extensions while keeping services status quo if both parties agree to the increases listed in the contract. A list of services has been provided with this document. While reviewing this option with Waste Management we were informed that the increase listed in the contract would not be adequate to cover their costs due to more restrictive changes in the recycling market. Waste Management therefore offered a new rate with the one-year extension while still maintaining the same services (see below). This was forwarded to the city attorney for review. After looking at current rates of other municipalities and service providers we discovered that this is a problem that the market has been dealing with since the latter part of With this in mind we feel moving forward with a new Request for Proposal would likely increase our service costs over the current extension option. While this extension is only one year, we believe that recycling costs could level off over this period, which could allow the market time to adjust to new standards that are causing these increases. At that point we would review the last one-year extension with Waste Management or create a new Request for Proposal for refuse services. The pricing below represents the monthly increase to each residential unit provided service. Contract Pricing Curbside Leaf Recycle increase Total Monthly Increase Current year $14.70 $ /2018 Year 2018/2019 $14.99 $0.52 $0.50 $0.80 Year 2019/2020 $15.14 $.052 $0.52 TBD RECOMMENDATION Approve the one-year contract extension with Waste Management as outlined above subject to City Attorney review. Prepared by: Reviewed & Approved by: Marcel Goch, DPW Director Nate Geinzer, City Manager

14 Service Container Information Frequency Service Notes Included in Contract Per Unit Rate Curbside Refuse Collection & Disposal 96 Gallon WM Provided Cart (+2 bags/32 Gal cans also allowed) Once/Week WM FEL Dumpsters Provided Brighton Valley & Hidden Harbour Condos X Curbside Recycle Collection & Processing 18 Gal WM Provided Bin or Resident 32 Gal Can Once/Week X Curbside Yardwaste Collection & Processing Resident Paper YW Bags/32 Gal Cans (10 bag/can limit) EOW 4/1 to 9/30 & Once/Week 10/1 to 11/30 X Unlimited Leaf Collection Resident Bags/Cans Once/Week Oct. 1 Nov. 30 X Curbside Bulk Collection & Disposal None One Bulk Item/Year Additional items w/charge to resident & schedule w WM X Freon Bulk Item Collection & Disposal None Upon Request Pre Paid Sticker from City and City scheduled PU w WM Spring Cleanup (dropoff at DPW) None One/Year May Includes packer truck, crew and RO WM postcard notice provided to residents X Brighton Downtown Refuse Cans Qty, 8, 32 Gal City Owned Decorative Containers Downtown M, T, Th X Brighton Downtown Recycle Cans Qty, 6, 96 Gal Recycle Carts Once/ Week Empty Reycle Carts Located at DPW for Downtown Recycle Material X FEL Compactor Refuse Qty 1, 6 Yd WM Provided Compactor M, W, F, S Service Location 200 Main Street N FEL Compactor Cardboard Qty 1, 6 Yd WM Provided Compactor M, W, F Service Location 200 Main Street N X Brighton Parsons Plaza Refuse Qty 2, 4 Yd WM Provided FEL Containrs M, T, W, Th, F Service Locaion 401 Main Street W Brighton Cemetary Refuse Qty 1, 8 Yd WM Provided FEL Container On Call Service Location Flint Road Brighton Water Plant Refuse Qty 1, 8 Yd WM Provided FEL Container W Service Location 7377 Challis Road X Brighton Fire Hall Refuse Qty 1, 6 Yd WM Provided FEL Container W Service Location 615 Grand River W X Brighton Community Center Refuse Qty 1, 4 Yd WM Provided FEL Container W Service Location 555 Brighton Street X Brighton WWTP Refuse Qty 1, 6 Yd WM Provided FEL Container T Service Location 6570 Hamburg Road X Brighton WWTP Grit Qty 1, 10 Yd RO Container On Call Service Location 6570 Hamburg Road X Brighton DPW Refuse Qty 1, 20 YD RO Container On Call Service Location 420 Third Street Brighton Cemetary Refuse Qty, 1 30 Yd RO Container On Call Service Location Flint Road City Facility Recycle Collection & Processing Bins/Carts Once/Week City Hall, PD, Fire, DPW X Downtown Events Refuse Qty, 8, 20 Yd RO Containers, 1 6 Yd FEL (Ash), Cardboard Event Boxes On Call Downtown Events June through November X

15 AMENDMENT TO REFUSE COLLECTION CONTRACT This Amendment ( Amendment ) is made and entered into this day of, 2018 by and between the CITY OF BRIGHTON, a Michigan municipal corporation ( City ) and WASTE MANAGEMENT OF MICHIGAN, INC., a Michigan corporation ( WMM ). WHEREAS, the City and WMM executed a Refuse Collection Contract on July 18, 1991; a First Amendment dated April 15, 1993; a Second Amendment dated January 2, 1994; a Third Amendment dated August 1, 1996; a Fourth Amendment dated December 18, 2000; and three further amendments dated June 21, 2007, November 12, 2010 and May 21, 2015 respectively (collectively the Contract ). WHEREAS, the current term of the Contract, as amended, extends through June 30, 2018; THEREFORE, the parties agree to extend the term of the Contract through June 30, 2019 and to further amend the Contract as follows: Term of Contract Extension: The new term of the Contract will be extended by one (1) year through June 30, This contract may be further extended for (1) year until June 30, 2020 upon mutual written consent of the City and WMM as outlined below under Optional Extension Year Fees. Annual Fee Adjustment: All Core Service Fees, as well as the Unlimited Leaf Collection Fee, the Spring Clean-Up Fee and the Household Hazardous Waste Collection Fee shall be adjusted according to the following table: Contract Pricing Yearly Existing Service Additional Recycle Cost July 1 to June 30 Curbside Leaf Increase (Option Year) $ $ % $ (Option Year) $ $ % TBD Note: One annual Spring Cleanup is included in the above pricing.

16 Other Provisions: The provisions related to Fuel Surcharge, Governmentally Imposed Charges, Additional Services and Vertical Compactor shall continue as part of the Contract as enumerated and described in the Amendment dated November 12, Unless otherwise amended herein, the terms and conditions of the Contract shall remain in full force and effect. In Witness Whereof, the parties have executed this Amendment on the date and year first above written. WITNESSES: CITY OF BRIGHTON By: By: WITNESS: WASTE MANAGEMENT OF MICHIGAN, INC. By: