Article 5 Unfair Terms Directive 93/13/EEC Transparency and interpretation in consumer contracts
|
|
- Kory Bradford
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Article 5 Unfair Terms Directive 93/13/EEC Transparency and interpretatin in cnsumer cntracts Jhanna Waelkens PhD Candidate Centre fr Methdlgy f Law Ius Cmmune Cnference Edinburgh 28 Nvember 2014
2 Unfair Terms Directive 93/13/EEC What? facilitate the establishment f the internal market safeguard the citizen in his rle as cnsumer when acquiring gds and services under cntracts Hw? remve unfair terms frm thse cntracts cntract shuld be drafted in plain, intelligible language interpretatin mst favurable t the cnsumer shuld prevail
3 Article 5 Unfair Terms Directive 93/13/EEC In the case f cntracts where all r certain terms ffered t the cnsumer are in writing, these terms must always be drafted in plain, intelligible language. Where there is dubt abut the meaning f a term, the interpretatin mst favurable t the cnsumer shall prevail. This rule n interpretatin shall nt apply in the cntext f the prcedures laid dwn in Article 7 (2).
4 Transparency rule In the case f cntracts where all r certain terms ffered t the cnsumer are in writing, these terms must always be drafted in plain, intelligible language. Reference persn Plain language Intelligible language
5 Reference persn Cnsumer in abstract average cnsumer Unfair Cmmercial Practices Directive ntinal, typical cnsumer reasnably wellinfrmed and reasnably bservant and circumspect, taking int accunt scial, cultural and linguistic factrs naïve and inexperienced cnsumer everyday layman nn-jurist E.g. Pres. Cmm. C. Brussels 16 June Le fait que, seln les circnstances, un acte puisse être cnsidéré u nn cmme clairement téméraire n'implique pas que la clause ne sit pas claire pur le cnsmmateur nnjuriste.
6 Plain language Clarity Frmal clarity easy access t the cntract befre the cnclusin f the agreement frmally easy t read Substantive clarity wrding f the clauses is clear n lng and bscure sentences n legal jargn n cntradictins E.g. The Gvernrs f the Peabdy Trust v Mr Michael Reeve
7 The Gvernrs f the Peabdy Trust v Mr Michael Reeve Altering the Agreement. (a) With the exceptin f any changes in Rent this Agreement may nly be altered by the agreement in writing f bth the Tenant and the Trust. (b) The terms f this Agreement may be varied by the Trust by a ntice f variatin served n the Tenant and the prvisins f sectin 103 f the Husing Act 1985 shall apply t this Agreement as if this tenancy were a secure tenancy prvided that in n case shall the variatins be such as t be prperly regarded as creating a new tenancy. Accrdingly, given that there is 'dubt' as t the meaning f clause 5 as a whle, and, in the light f the cntradictry terms f the subclauses, as t the meaning f the sub-clauses themselves, I am bliged in terms f Regulatin 7(2) t adpt the interpretatin mst favurable t the cnsumer, in ther wrds the tenant in this case.
8 Intelligible language the cnsumer must be able t gather frm the cntract the cntent and the range f his rights and bligatins clse t clearness bligatin t avid jargn cmmn terminlgy nrmal meaning E.g. OFT v Abbey Natinal plc & Others
9 OFT v Abbey Natinal plc & Others Regulatin 6(2), as the OFT submits and as I accept, requires nt nly that the actual wrding f individual clauses r cnditins be cmprehensible t cnsumers, but that the typical cnsumer can understand hw the term affects the rights and bligatins that he and the seller r supplier have under the cntract. This was said abut the plain and intelligible language prvisin in regulatin 6(2), but OFT cnsiders it applies equally t the requirement in regulatin 7.
10 Interpretatin rule Where there is dubt abut the meaning f a term, the interpretatin mst favurable t the cnsumer shall prevail. Tp f the hierarchy Rule in favrem cnsumentis
11 Interpretatin in favrem cnsumentis rights as extensive, bligatins as limited as pssible wh? Judge E.g. Ms G C Cahalane v Lndn Brugh f Wandswrth what? mst favurable fr the cnsumer in cncret limited margin f appreciatin E.g. Cass. fr. (1e civ.) 11 March 2010
12 Ms G C Cahalane v Lndn Brugh f Wandswrth (2) t repair cleanse uphld supprt and maintain the exterir f the Blck and the cmmunal televisin aerials dr entry systems fences walls and the entrance ways paths lifts staircases main walls party walls rf fundatins and all structural parts theref [ ]" and "(3) T repair and maintain the exterir f the windw frames windw sashes and balcny r pati drs and f the frames theref (if any) f the Flat and as ften as may be necessary t replace the whle r part f the windw frames windw sashes windw furniture and balcny r pati drs and frames and furniture theref (if any). Even if there were dubt as t the scpe f paragraph 2 I am by n means sure that case law and the Unfair Cntracts Regulatins wuld require the dubt t be reslved in favur f the lessee in the present case. Paragraph 2 impses bligatins n the landlrd, and in ther circumstances the lessee might be dispsed t cntend that the bligatins extended t the repair and maintenance f the windws f ther flats in the blck. The value f her flat and her enjyment f it culd be adversely affected if lack f repair f these adversely affected the appearance f the blck. It is nly the service charge cnsequences in a situatin where the cuncil have replaced sme windws in the blck but nt hers that causes her t argue fr a limited meaning t be given t the bligatins f the cuncil under paragraph 2. It des nt seem t me that t cnstrue the prvisin cntra prferentem wuld require that the bligatin shuld be cnstrued narrwly r that such narrw interpretatin wuld necessarily be the ne 'mst favurable t' the lessee'.
13 Cass. fr. (1e civ.) 11 March 2010 UAP-VIE majrera vtre cmpte de la façn suivante: de la nzième année et jusqu'à la quinzième année incluse. UAP-VIE investit sur vtre cmpte 110 % de vtre prime péridique annuelle. Il y a une cnfusin dans l'interprétatin des clauses du cntrat qui a sa surce dans l'ambiguïté rédactinnelle. 500 eur was nt the mst beneficial utcme
14 Exceptin This rule n interpretatin shall nt apply in the cntext f the prcedures laid dwn in Article 7 (2). cllective actins fr cessatin Cmmissin v Spain The distinctin made in Article 5 f the Directive cncerning the applicable rule f interpretatin, as between actins invlving an individual cnsumer and actins fr cessatin which invlve persns r rganisatins representative f the cllective interest f cnsumers may be accunted fr by the different aims pursued by thse actins. In the frmer case, the curts r cmpetent bdies are required t make an assessment in cncret f the unfair character f a term cntained in a cntract which has already been cncluded, while in the latter case it is their task t assess in abstract the unfair character f a term which may be incrprated int cntracts which have nt yet been cncluded. In the frmer case, an interpretatin favurable t the individual cnsumer cncerned benefits him r her immediately. By cntrast, in the latter case, in rder t btain, by way f preventin, the mst favurable result fr cnsumers as a whle, it is nt necessary, where there is dubt, t interpret the term in a manner favurable t them. Accrdingly, an bjective interpretatin makes it pssible t prhibit mre frequently the use f an unintelligible r ambiguus term, which results in wider cnsumer prtectin.
15 Article 5 Unfair Terms Directive 93/13/EEC: Transparancy and interpretatin in cnsumer cntracts Outline 1. UNFAIR TERMS DIRECTIVE 93/13/EEC Prir t 1993, laws existed relating t unfair terms in cnsumer cntracts in many Eurpean Member States. Hwever, the laws shwed marked divergences, with the result that the natinal markets fr the sale f gds and services t cnsumers differed frm each ther. Cnsequently, distrtins f cmpetitin culd arise amngst the sellers and suppliers. The Cuncil f the Eurpean Cmmunities drawed up Directive 93/13/EEC n unfair terms in cnsumer cntracts in rder t tackle these disparities, with the aim f prgressively establishing the internal market. Tw different systems f implementatin f the Directive can be discerned. In England, the entire Directive was laid dwn almst literally in a seperate law, namely the Unfair Terms in Cnsumer Cntracts Regulatins 1994, which were in 1999 replaced by the Unfair Terms in Cnsumer Cntracts Regulatins In ther cuntries, fr instance Belgium, France and the Netherlands, the Directive was integrated in existing laws. 2. ARTICLE 5 UNFAIR TERMS DIRECTIVE 93/13/EEC Article 5 Directive 93/13/EEC runs as fllws: "In the case f cntracts where all r certain terms ffered t the cnsumer are in writing, these terms must always be drafted in plain, intelligible language. Where there is dubt abut the meaning f a term, the interpretatin mst favurable t the cnsumer shall prevail. This rule n interpretatin shall nt apply in the cntext f the prcedures laid dwn in Article 7 (2)." The rule, adpted in England as Regulatin 7 UTCCR, in France as article L133-2 Cde de la Cnsmmatin, in the Netherlands as article 6:238, 2 NBW and in Belgium as article VI Wb Ecnmisch Recht, cnsists f tw parts: an infrmatin r transparancy requirement and an interpretatin rule. Bth rules are intertwined, since the secnd sentence acts as a sanctin fr nn-cmpliance with the first sentence. Any lack f transparancy suffices t put int effect the interpretatin rule. The rules can be cnsidered tw sides f the same cin: the first ne is preventive, the secnd ne is punitive. 3. FUNCTIONING OF THE RULE IN TWO PHASES In rder t prtect cnsumers, every term f a cntract between the seller f gds r supplier f services, n the ne hand, and the cnsumer f them, n the ther hand, has t be transparent, plain and intelligible. If this is nt the case, the cntract will be interpreted in favur f the cnsumer (interpretatin in favrem cnsumentis). An apprach in tw steps is required. In a first phase, the questin needs t be ascertained whether a cntract, a clause r a term is (1) clear and intelligible, (2) unclear r (3) unintelligible. In rder t d that, it is necessary t interpret the text prvisinally, because 1
16 it is nt pssible t examine whether mre than ne reading f a text can exist withut turning t interpretatin. In a secnd phase, cnsequences need t be attached t the results f the first phase. Three different utcmes can arise. First, the interpretatr might cnclude that the clause is cmpletely clear and intelligible. Only ne meaning is pssible, s n interpretatin is needed. A secnd scenari happens when n meaning can be attached t a clause. It is nt intelligible, s it cannt be interpreted. Such an incmprehensible clause is unfair, s incmprehensibility results in nullity f the clause. A third situatin arises when the clause can have mre than ne meaning: it is unclear. Than it needs t be interpreted in favrem cnsumentis. 4. TRANSPARENCY RULE: PLAIN AND INTELLIGIBLE LANGUAGE The questin if a cnsumer cntract is plain and intelligible is answered by the judge, wh has t prject himself int the rle f the cnsumer. Determining whether r nt the clause at hand is transparent, happens in abstract, by means f a reference persn, namely the "naïve and inexperienced cnsumer". All clauses in a cnsumer cntract have t be plain and clear n the ne hand and intelligible n the ther hand. Clearness means that there are n ambiguities, n dubts abut the meaning f the clauses, because they are accurate, precise, cncrete, transparent and bvius. This ntin has a frmal and a substantive side. Frmal clearness arises when the cnsumer has easy access t the cntract and when the cntract is easy t read (e.g. the fnt is clear, the wrds are nt printed t small ). Substantive clearness cmes int being when the cntent f a clause bears n sectrets fr the average cnsumer, when the sentences are nt lng r bcure, where there is n use f technical jargn, and where there are n cntradictins. Intelligibility means that it must be pssible fr the average cnsumer t understand a clause: at least ne cnstructin f the clause must be plausible. 5. INTERPRETATON RULE: INTERPRETATION IN FAVOREM CONSUMENTIS The sanctin fr nn-cmpliance with the transparancy-duty cnsists f an interpretatin in favur f the cnsumer. This rule prvides the cnsumer with the pssibility t anticipate the utcme f an interpretatin dispute, since it prevails ver all ther interpretatin rules. The precedence f the rule in favrem cnsumentis is t be grunded n its aim t fully prtect the cnsumer. That is als the reasn why a judge is allwed t apply the rule f its wn mtin. But what des this interpretatin rule achtually entails? Which is the interpretatin mst favurable t the cnsumer? It is the interpretatin that burdens the cnsumer the least, the interpretatin that makes his rights as wide as pssible and his bligatins as limited as pssible. It is the judge, nt the cnsumer himself, wh has t find ut which interpretatin is mst expedient, even if that means he has t depart frm the cnsumers claim. He has t investigate in each case in cncret the unclear clause, find ut which pssible meanings it can have, and chse which f these are mst favurable fr this specific cnsumer, at this mment, given these circumstances. His margin f appreciatin is limited. He cannt interpret in a way that is interesting fr the cnsumer, but has t balance the different pssible utcmes in rder t find ut the interpretatin that is mst favurable. This means that in sme cases, he has t interpret a clause in a way that it is makes it unfair, s that it needs t be declared null and 2
17 vid. An interpretatin that leads t nullity can in sme cases indeed be mre favurable fr a cnsumer than an interpretatin that leaves the clause be, since a clause, even when it is interpreted in the cnsumers favur, can still be unappealing t him. Jhanna Waelkens PhD Candidate Centre fr Methdlgy f Law KU Leuven 3
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION. Brussels, 12 July 2000 (28.07) (OR. fr) 10242/00 LIMITE ASILE 30
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Brussels, 12 July 2000 (28.07) (OR. fr) 10242/00 LIMITE ASILE 30 OUTCOME OF PROCEEDINGS frm : Asylum Wrking Party n : 7 July 2000 N. prev. dc.: 9703/00 ASILE 28 Subject: Cnditins
More informationOXON CHURCH OF ENGLAND PRIMARY SCHOOL COMPLAINTS POLICY
OXON CHURCH OF ENGLAND PRIMARY SCHOOL COMPLAINTS POLICY HOW TO RAISE A CONCERN INFORMAL STAGE Class teachers are the usual first pint f cntact fr any cncerns. Mst cncerns are reslved infrmally thrugh cnversatins
More informationAdjourning Licensing Hearings
Adjurning Licensing Hearings Sarah Clver, Barrister and Head f Licensing at N 5 Chambers gives her pinin n a cmmn practical prblem cncerned with adjurning licensing hearings.. An issue which appears t
More informationGuardianship & Conservatorship In Virginia
Guardianship & Cnservatrship In Virginia This bklet is prduced by the Virginia Guardianship Assciatin in cperatin with the Virginia Center n Aging the Virginia Calitin fr the Preventin f Elder Abuse &
More informationWITH RECENT CHANGES ISSUED BY THE CFPB, FINAL REMITTANCE TRANSFER REGULATIONS TO BECOME EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 7, 2013
Financial Institutins Client Service Grup T: Our Clients and Friends September 19, 2012 WITH RECENT CHANGES ISSUED BY THE CFPB, FINAL REMITTANCE TRANSFER REGULATIONS TO BECOME EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 7, 2013
More informationMulti-Agency Guidance (Non Police)
Multi-Agency Guidance (Nn Plice) Dmestic Vilence prtectin Ntices Dmestic Vilence Prtectin Orders Sectins 24-33 crime and security Act 2010 Cntents: Page Intrductin 2 Multi-Agency Engagement 2 Criteria
More informationSubjective intent is too slippery:
Scalia - Cmmn-Law Curts in a Civil Law System Lecture 1: Scalia begins by examining what he calls the cmmn law attitude. Lawyers are trained up in the traditin f cmmn law, distinguishing between cases
More informationBob Simpson: Director of Intergovernmental Relations, Inuvialuit Regional Corp.
Bb Simpsn: Directr f Intergvernmental Relatins, Inuvialuit Reginal Crp. The Inuvialuit Arbitratin Prcess It is very unique the nly example f binding arbitratin in a land claim agreement; ther land claims
More informationJoan DUBAERE Racine & Vergels
LUGANO CONVENTION - Curt Case, initiated n 21 December 2009 by Belgium against Switzerland Belgium vs. Switzerland cncerning the interpretatin and applicatin f the Lugan Cnventin n jurisdictin and the
More informationGUIDELINES FOR GRANT APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY RELOCATION
TOGETHER WITH HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENDERS WORLDWIDE FOR TEMPORARY RELOCATION 1. Eligibility Criteria 1.1. Wh can apply? Applicatins received shuld be made by r n behalf f a specific Human Rights Defender in
More informationMeasuring Public Opinion
Measuring Public Opinin We all d n end f feeling and we mistake it fr thinking. And ut f it we get an aggregatin which we cnsider a bn. Its name is public pinin. It is held in reverence. It settles everything.
More informationAttending the Coroner s Court as a witness and how to give evidence
briefing July 2017 Attending the Crner s Curt as a witness and hw t give evidence Intrductin... 1 Cmmn cncerns f witnesses... 2 The inquest prcess... 2 Preparing fr the inquest... 3 Yur evidence... 3 Refresh
More informationActivities: Teacher lecture (background information and lecture outline provided); class participation activity.
Curts in the Cmmunity Clrad Judicial Branch Office f the State Curt Administratr Lessn: Hw the Appellate Prcess Wrks Objective: Understand what happens t a case when it leaves the trial curts. (Clrad Mdel
More informationCONTRACT LAW IN GENERAL: R
CONTRACT LAW IN GENERAL: R 1. Cntract Defined A cntract is a prmise r a set f prmises fr the breach f which the law gives a remedy, r the perfrmance f which the law in sme way recgnizes as a duty. R 2.
More informationPENNSYLVANIA TORTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR MICHAEL P. MORELAND VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW
PENNSYLVANIA TORTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR MICHAEL P. MORELAND VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: INTENTIONAL TORTS & NEGLIGENCE A. Intentinal Trts 1. Battery Exam Tip 1: Remember that Pennsylvania
More informationCAPIC Submission on Part 16: Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR)
2017 CAPIC Submissin n Part 16: Immigratin and Refugee Prtectin Regulatins (IRPR) CAPIC SUBMISSION-PART 16: IMMIGRATION AND REFUGEE PROTECTION REGULATIONS (IRPR) Cntents Intrductin... 2 Preamble... 2 Opinin/Input
More informationSupervised Legal Practice Guidelines (Legal Profession Act 2008)
Supervised Legal Practice Guidelines (Legal Prfessin Act 2008) It is a legislative requirement that fllwing admissin and the btaining f a practising certificate, a lcal legal practitiner can nly engage
More informationAlternative Measures for Adult Offenders ALT 1. March 1, 2018 CHA 1 CHI 1 CRI 1 FIR 1 HAT 1 IPV 1 SEX 1
Plicy: Alternative Measures fr Adult Offenders Plicy Cde: Effective Date: Crss-references: ALT 1 March 1, 2018 CHA 1 CHI 1 CRI 1 FIR 1 HAT 1 IPV 1 SEX 1 Sectin 717(1) f the Criminal Cde prvides in part
More informationOpinions on Choice of Law, Forum Selection, Arbitration, and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments or Arbitral Awards in Cross-Border Transactions
Opinins n Chice f Law, Frum Selectin, Arbitratin, and Enfrcement f Freign Judgments r Arbitral Awards in Crss-Brder Transactins With increasing frequency U.S. lawyers are delivering clsing pinins t nn-u.s.
More informationRefugee Council response to the 21 st Century Welfare consultation
Refugee Cuncil respnse t the 21 st Century Welfare cnsultatin Octber 2010 Abut the Refugee Cuncil The Refugee Cuncil is a human rights charity, independent f gvernment, which wrks t ensure that refugees
More informationCONTEMPT. This packet contains forms and information on: How to File a Petition for Citation of Contempt
CONTEMPT This packet cntains frms and infrmatin n: Hw t File a Petitin fr Citatin f Cntempt It is advisable t have an attrney when filing legal papers t be sure that yur rights are prtected and that all
More informationCARL Backgrounder on the New Citizenship Act (formerly Bill C-24) INTRODUCTION
Primary Authr: Aris Daghighian CARL Backgrunder n the New Citizenship Act (frmerly Bill C-24) INTRODUCTION The Stephen Harper Cnservative gvernment s Bill C-24 amending the Citizenship Act is nw law, having
More informationWest Tankers applies, so the Commercial Court points to other options in Nori Holdings Ltd v Bank Otkritie [2018] EWHC 1343 (Comm)
Maritime Bulletin Issue 8 www.4pumpcurt.cm West Tankers applies, s the Cmmercial Curt pints t ther ptins in Nri Hldings Ltd v Bank Otkritie [2018] EWHC 1343 (Cmm) Clarity has been restred fllwing the High
More informationIndigenous Consultation in Environmental Assessment Processes
Ministry f the Envirnment and Climate Change Indigenus Cnsultatin in Envirnmental Assessment Prcesses Ontari Assciatin fr Impact Assessment Octber 17, 2017 Why cnsult with Indigenus cmmunities during an
More informationThe Genuine Temporary Entrant (GTE) Requirement (Recommendations 1 and 2)
The Genuine Temprary Entrant (GTE) Requirement (Recmmendatins 1 and 2) The fllwing infrmatin prvides further detail n the planned Knight Review changes t the student visa prgram. Frequently asked questins
More informationMHA or MCA a more flexible approach?
briefing 18 September 2013 MHA r MCA a mre flexible apprach? Fllwing the judgment in Re A v SLAM, readers shuld cnsider the prcess they fllw fr deciding whether t admit r discharge patients wh lack capacity.
More information1. Humanities-oriented academic essays are typically both analytical and argumentative.
Analysis & Argument 1. Humanities-riented academic essays are typically bth analytical and argumentative. As yu may recall, the pint f an academic paper is nt s much t tell me a bunch f static facts r
More informationIf at all possible, it is strongly recommended that you get advice from a lawyer to help you with this application.
BACKGROUNDER What are my ptins frm here? If yu have been denied Legal Aid and cannt affrd t pay fr a lawyer, there is anther ptin. Yu can apply t the Nva Sctia Prvincial Curt t ask fr a lawyer wh will
More informationSURETYSHIP PROFESSOR KARA BRUCE UNIVERSITY OF TOLEDO COLLEGE OF LAW
SURETYSHIP PROFESSOR KARA BRUCE UNIVERSITY OF TOLEDO COLLEGE OF LAW CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION TO SURETYSHIP A. Suretyship Defined the prmise f a persn t pay the debts (r satisfy the ) f anther. B. Picturing
More informationMASSACHUSETTS WILLS PROFESSOR KENT SCHENKEL NEW ENGLAND SCHOOL OF LAW
MASSACHUSETTS WILLS PROFESSOR KENT SCHENKEL NEW ENGLAND SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION AND INTESTATE SUCCESSION A. Intrductin When yu encunter a wills and estates questin n the bar exam, yu first
More informationPART XIII PRIVATIVE CLAUSES
PART XIII PRIVATIVE CLAUSES I Intrductin A The Privative, Ouster, r Preclusin Clause Privative clauses are prvisins in a statute which preclude the pssibility f certain frms f administrative review. Typically,
More informationLEGAL THEORY / JURISPRUDENCE SUMMARY
LEGAL THEORY / JURISPRUDENCE SUMMARY LAWSKOOL PTY LTD CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 4 POSITIVISM AND THE NATION OF LAW/S 5 What is legal system? 5 Obligatin 5 Law as a System f Rules 6 Legal Obligatins and Mrality
More informationCJS 220. The Court System. Version 2 08/06/07 CJS 220
CJS 220 The Curt System Versin 2 08/06/07 CJS 220 CJS 220 The Curt System Prgram Cuncil The Academic Prgram Cuncils fr each cllege versee the design and develpment f all University f Phenix curricula.
More informationDATA REQUEST GUIDELINES
DATA REQUEST GUIDELINES This dcument describes prcedures law enfrcement authrities and individuals invlved in civil litigatin shuld fllw t request data frm LinkedIn and its affiliated service prviders.
More informationCBA Response to Private Prosecuting Association Consultation entitled. Private Prosecutions Consultation. 6 th March 2019
CBA Respnse t Private Prsecuting Assciatin Cnsultatin entitled Private Prsecutins Cnsultatin 6 th March 2019 Intrductin 1. The CBA represents the views and interests f practising members f the criminal
More informationPrinted copies are for reference only. Please refer to the electronic copy in Scouts.ca for the latest version.
Prcedure Title: Temprary Suspensin and Discipline Prcedure Number: 13020.1 Dcument Owner: Directr f Child and Yuth Safety Apprval Date: Nvember 13, 2013 Apprver: Natinal Leadership Team Related Plicy:
More informationSUBSTITUTED JUDGMENT AND EXTRAORDINARY TREATMENT. Substituted Judgment--Overview
SUBSTITUTED JUDGMENT AND EXTRAORDINARY TREATMENT Substituted Judgment--Overview An exceptin t the general apprach t judicially-rdered alternative decisin making cncerns medical prcedures and treatment
More informationRole Play Magistrate Court Hearings Teacher information
Rle Play Magistrate Curt Hearings Teacher infrmatin These ntes are prvided s that teachers can guide students thrugh preparatry activities befre presenting a rle play at the Law Curts Cnnecting t the curriculum
More informationMICHIGAN CONTRACTS & SALES DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR ANNE LAWTON MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF LAW
MICHIGAN CONTRACTS & SALES DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR ANNE LAWTON MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF LAW CHAPTER 1: CONTRACT FORMATION AND MODIFICATION A. OFFER General rule: Time perid fr a cntract is a
More information- Problems with e-filing, especially for people from lower-income backgrounds. - Receiving memos / communication from one side and not the other
State Curt Training Mediatin: Beynd the Basics Jhn Lande and Susan M. Yates Nvember 3, 2017 Linked frm Stne Sup: Takeaways Frm New Hampshire Mediatin Training Mediatins frm Hell - Prblems with e-filing,
More informationTORTS FULL COURSE SUMMARY AND READINGS. Breach of duty
TORTS FULL COURSE SUMMARY AND READINGS Breach f duty 1. General principles fr establishing breach f duty Did the defendant fall belw a standard duty f care which a reasnable persn wuld hld? A breach f
More informationSocial Media and the First Amendment
Scial Media and the First Amendment Benjamin J. Yder Frst Brwn Tdd, LLC Margaret W. Cmey Lcke Lrd LLP Thurs. Feb. 1 & Fri. Feb. 2, 2018 Presentatin Overview Backgrund and develping case law Implementing
More informationInternational Model United Nations Conference (IMUNC) 2018 Middle East Summit (MES) 2018
Internatinal Mdel United Natins Cnference (IMUNC) 2018 Middle East Summit (MES) 2018 Rules f Prcedure 1 Table f Cntents General Rules... 3 Decrum... 3 Pwers f the Dias... 3 Yielding... 3 Cmmittee Dynamics...
More informationPENNSYLVANIA CONFLICT OF LAWS PROFESSOR KEVIN P. OATES DREXEL UNIVERSITY THOMAS R. KLINE SCHOOL OF LAW
PENNSYLVANIA CONFLICT OF LAWS PROFESSOR KEVIN P. OATES DREXEL UNIVERSITY THOMAS R. KLINE SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: FULL FAITH AND CREDIT FOR JUDGMENTS Three Main Tpics in Cnflict f Laws: Full faith and
More informationFLORIDA S DEPENDENCY BENCHBOOK BENCHCARD: PSYCHOTROPIC MEDICATION HEARING
FLORIDA S DEPENDENCY BENCHBOOK BENCHCARD: PSYCHOTROPIC MEDICATION HEARING Items in bld fnt are required by Flrida Statutes. If the child cmes int care with psychtrpic medicatin already prescribed. DCF
More informationImpact of Proffer Legislation Changes
Impact f Prffer Legislatin Changes General Infrmatin n New Statute VA Cde Sectin 5.2-2303.4 Senate Bill (SB) 549 206 Sessin Reprt Senate Bill (SB) 549 New Prffer Legislatin (Handut) Slide 9 & 0 frm Schl
More informationThe Judicial Branch. I. The Structure of the Judicial Branch: *U.S. Supreme Court
I. The Structure f the Judicial Branch: The judicial pwer f the United States, shall be vested in ne Supreme Curt, and in such inferir curts as the Cngress may frm time t time rdain and establish. The
More informationORGANIZING A LEGAL DISCUSSION (IRAC, CRAC, ETC.)
ORGANIZING A LEGAL DISCUSSION (IRAC, CRAC, ETC.) Intrductin The rganizatin f yur writing will determine whether r nt a reader will understand and be persuaded by yur argument. Brilliant rhetric will nly
More informationBRIEFING NOTE. Both these cases involved appeals from judgments of Charles J in the Upper Tribunal, where the Court of Appeal considered:
Skiptn Huse Learning Disability Prgramme 6 th Flr 80 Lndn Rad Lndn SE1 6LH Publicatins Gateway Reference 07333 BRIEFING NOTE Abut this briefing nte At the end f March 2017, the Curt f Appeal handed dwn
More informationFebruary 6, Interview with WILLIAM J. BAROODY,.JR. William A. Syers Political Scientist and Deputy Director House Republican Policy Committee
B # f c% Interview with WILLIAM J. BARDY,.JR. by William A. Syers Plitical Scientist and Deputy Directr Huse Republican Plicy Cmmittee ~ c;" n February 6, 1985 i TRANSCRIPT F AN INTERVIEW WITH WILLIAM
More informationCALIFORNIA REMEDIES ESSAY WORKSHOP PROFESSOR CHRISTOPHER IDE-DON UC DAVIS SCHOOL OF LAW
CALIFORNIA REMEDIES ESSAY WORKSHOP PROFESSOR CHRISTOPHER IDE-DON UC DAVIS SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: APPROACH; ISSUES TESTED A. Apprach t Essays 1) Determine and analyze the cause(s) f actin in the questin
More informationMost Frequently Asked Questions
Mst Frequently Asked Questins f receive a full pardn can have a NO On June 10, 1999 the Gvernr and recrd sealed r expunged? criminal histry recrd. Cabinet determined that the granting f a full pardn des
More informationEyewitness Identification. Professor Nancy K. Steblay Augsburg College Minneapolis
Eyewitness Identificatin Prfessr Nancy K. Steblay Augsburg Cllege Minneaplis The 2016 Criminal Justice Institute August 22 & 23, 2016 The Science f Eyewitness Memry and Identificatin Evidence (Prfessr)
More informationDispute Resolution Around the World. Venezuela
Dispute Reslutin Arund the Wrld Venezuela Dispute Reslutin Arund the Wrld Venezuela 2009 Dispute Reslutin Arund the Wrld Venezuela Table f Cntents 1. Natinal Cnstitutin... 1 2. Internatinal Treaties:
More informationbriefing Case law to clarify the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards
briefing Case law t clarify the Deprivatin f Liberty Safeguards Intrductin...2 Case law in detail...4 DCC v KH and thers...4...4 Issue befre the curt...4 Outcme...4 W Primary Care Trust v TB...5...5 Issue
More informationCOMPILATION OF SECRETARY-GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS ON WOMEN, PEACE AND SECURITY RELEVANT TO PEACE OPERATIONS ( )
Inputs fr the High-Level Independent Panel n Peace Operatins SG recmmendatins n wmen, peace and security relevant t peace peratins (2002-2014) - UN Wmen 2015 COMPILATION OF SECRETARY-GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS
More informationSTALKING PROTECTION BILL EXPLANATORY NOTES
STALKING PROTECTION BILL EXPLANATORY NOTES What these ntes d These Explanatry Ntes relate t the Stalking Prtectin Bill as intrduced in the Huse f Cmmns n 19 July. These Explanatry Ntes have been prvided
More informationNYS Common Core ELA & Literacy Curriculum D R A F T Grade 12 Module 2 Unit 1 Lesson 7
12.2.1 Lessn 7 Intrductin In this lessn, students cntinue t read and analyze Henry David Threau s Civil Disbedience. Students read part 1, paragraphs 5 6 (frm The mass f men serve the state thus, nt as
More informationUnit #2: American Political Ideologies and Beliefs AP US Government & Politics Mr. Coia
Unit #2: American Plitical Idelgies and Beliefs AP US Gvernment & Plitics Mr. Cia Name: Date: Perid: Thurs 10/18 Learning bjective: MPA-A: Explain the relatinship between cre beliefs f U.S. citizens and
More informationCOURT FACILITY EQUAL ACCESS POLICY
COURT FACILITY EQUAL ACCESS POLICY Gvernment Cde 7284.8(a ALEX CALVO COURT EXECUTIVE OFFICER CLERK OF THE COURT Superir Curt f Califrnia Cunty f Santa Cruz 701 Ocean Street Santa Cruz, Califrnia 95060
More informationSenate Bill 549 New Proffer Legislation
Senate Bill 549 New Prffer Legislatin Effect: Created Virginia Cde 15.2-2303.4, which limits the ability f lcal gvernments t request/accept prffers fr residential reznings/prffer amendments. 1 Applicability:
More informationINFORMATION ON THE SELECTION PROCESS OF JUDGES AT THE UNIFIED PATENT COURT
INFORMATION ON THE SELECTION PROCESS OF JUDGES AT THE UNIFIED PATENT COURT Please read carefully the infrmatin n the selectin prcess f Unified Patent Curt (UPC) judges, the eligibility criteria, as well
More informationGENERAL ORDER PORT WASHINGTON POLICE DEPARTMENT
GENERAL ORDER PORT WASHINGTON POLICE DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: EYEWITNESS IDENTIFICATION NUMBER: 6.3.4 ISSUED: 5/6/09 SCOPE: All Swrn Persnnel EFFECTIVE: 5/6/09 DISTRIBUTION: General Orders Manual RESCINDS 34.1
More informationFindings from the Federal, State, and Tribal Response to Violence Against Women in Indian Country Studies
Findings frm the Federal, State, and Tribal Respnse t Vilence Against Wmen in Indian Cuntry Studies Alisn Brks Martin Pstdctral Research Assciate Natinal Institute f Justice 14 th Indian Natins Cnference
More informationLEGAL BRIEF SMALL CLAIMS COURT JANUARY 2016
LEGAL BRIEF SMALL CLAIMS COURT JANUARY 2016 PREPARED BY NELLIS LAW CENTER, 4428 England Ave (Bldg 18), Nellis AFB, Nevada 89191-6505 702-652-5407, Appt. Line 702-652-7531 SMALL CLAIMS COURT This handut
More informationAnswer: The issue in this question is whether Donny acted in reliance of Ann s offer to get the reward of $1000.
MLC101 OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE Questin: It is the week befre ANZAC day and Ann s huse is rbbed. The thieves steal many items, including her Great grandfather s Wrld War 1 medals. Ann is distraught and puts
More informationSTALKING PROTECTION BILL EXPLANATORY NOTES
STALKING PROTECTION BILL EXPLANATORY NOTES What these ntes d These Explanatry Ntes relate t the Stalking Prtectin Bill as brught frm the Huse f Cmmns n 26 Nvember 2018 (HL Bill 145). These Explanatry Ntes
More informationINSTRUCTIONS FOR VACATING MISDEMEANOR AND GROSS MISDEMEANOR CONVICTIONS
INSTRUCTIONS FOR VACATING MISDEMEANOR AND GROSS MISDEMEANOR CONVICTIONS Washingtn law permits the vacatin f sme misdemeanr r grss misdemeanr cnvictins. Vacatin f a cnvictin releases yu frm all penalties
More informationAlex Castles, The Reception and Status of English law in Australia (1963) pg
4A The Path t Federatin, The Acquisitin f Legal Independence and Ppular Svereignty The Clnial Laws Validity Act 1865 (Imp) pg. 98-102 The Clnial Legislatures The bicameral legislatures (tw huses) were
More informationPART X ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW
PART X ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW I Intrductin A Types f Review 1 Merits review Merits review may be available under the fllwing avenues: 1 Avenue f review (a) (b) Cmmnwealth decisin-makers: Administrative
More informationMASSACHUSETTS CRIMINAL PROCEDURE DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR ISAAC BORENSTEIN SUFFOLK UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL
MASSACHUSETTS CRIMINAL PROCEDURE DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR ISAAC BORENSTEIN SUFFOLK UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL CHAPTER 1: THE FOURTH AMENDMENT AND MASSACHUSETTS LAW A. General Principles In rder fr the Furth Amendment
More informationEUROPEAN REFUGEE CRISIS
EUROPEAN REFUGEE CRISIS DATA, TECHNOLOGY & COORDINATION BRIEFING NOTE On Nvember 4, 2015, the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative (HHI) brught tgether representatives f a range f rganizatins wrking t address
More informationNUTS AND BOLTS OF PERFORMING NOTARIAL ACTS. Kathleen Butler, Executive Director American Society of Notaries Austin, TX August 30, 2017
NUTS AND BOLTS OF PERFORMING NOTARIAL ACTS Kathleen Butler, Executive Directr American Sciety f Ntaries Austin, TX August 30, 2017 TODAY S DISCUSSION WHY are dcuments ntarized? WHAT are a Ntary s fundamental
More informationMigrant children: what rights at 18?
Prvisinal versin Migrant children: what rights at 18? Reprt 1 Cmmittee n Migratin, Refugees and Displaced Persns Rapprteur: Ms Mailis Reps, Estnia, ALDE 1 Reference t Cmmittee: Dc. 12678, Reference 3800
More informationCommon Evidentiary Predicates to Authenticate Evidence
Cmmn Evidentiary Predicates t Authenticate Evidence 1. Phtgraphs Rule 901. Identify and cnfirm that phtgraph is fair and accurate representatin f what is depicted. See Huffman v. State, 746 S.W.2d 212,
More informationCalifornia Common Core Content Standards: Writing Grade 11/12
Califrnia Cmmn Cre Cntent Standards: Writing Grade 11/12 11-12.W Writing 11-12. Text Types and Purpses 11-12.W.1 Write arguments t supprt claims in an analysis f substantive tpics r texts, using valid
More informationCAUSE NO CITY OF FORT WORTH'S ORIGINAL ANSWER. COMES NOW Defendant City of Fort Worth, Texas ("the City") and files this its
CAUSE NO. 48-270181-14 FORT WORTH PROFESSIONAL IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF FIREFIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, Plaintiff V. TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS CITY OF FORT WORTH, TEXAS, Defendant 48 TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COMES NOW
More informationItem No Halifax Regional Council August 14, 2012
Item N. 11.1.12 Halifax Reginal Cuncil August 14, 2012 TO: Mayr Kelly and Members f Halifax Reginal Cuncil SUBMITTED BY: Richard Butts, Chief Administrative Officer DATE: July 24, 2012 Original signed
More informationSOLOMON ISLANDS LAW REFORM COMMISSION
SOLOMON ISLANDS LAW REFORM COMMISSION MENTAL IMPAIRMENT, CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY AND FITNESS TO PLEAD CONSULTATION PAPER THE SOLOMON ISLANDS LAW REFORM COMMISSION HONIARA, SOLOMON ISLANDS MENTAL IMPAIRMENT,
More informationReview of Ofcom list of major political parties for elections taking place on 7 May 2015 Statement
Review f Ofcm list f majr plitical parties fr electins taking place n 7 May 215 Statement Statement Publicatin date: 16 March 215 Review f Ofcm list f majr plitical parties fr electins taking place n 7
More informationCONSTITUTION OF INDIA
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA Sample : Amendments t Cnstitutin Delhi Law Academy India s Finest Law Caching Judicial Services, LLM Entrance www.delhilawacademy.cm All materials, cpyrights and trademarks are rights
More informationAssessment of Refugees Qualifications:
Assessment f Refugees Qualificatins: Nrwegian Apprach Marina Malgina Head f Sectin NOKUT (Nrwegian Agency fr Quality Assurance in Educatin), Nrwegian ENIC-NARIC NOKUT Nrwegian Agency fr Quality Assurance
More informationti' ; ~ ~djj 2 December 2016 Excellency,
ti' ; ~ ~djj ~ THE PRESIDENT OFTHE GENERAL ASSEMBLY 2 December 2016 Excellency, I have the hnur t transmit herewith a letter, dated 2 December, 2016 frm the Advisers f the cnsultatin prcess cncerning the
More informationIEEE Tellers Committee Operations Manual
IEEE Tellers Cmmittee Operatins Manual IEEE 445 Hes Lane Piscataway, NJ 08854 USA Apprved by the IEEE Bard f Directrs Updated in June 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTION I - RESPONSIBILITIES... 3 FUNCTIONS
More informationPRE-ELECTION NATIONAL SURVEY KEY FINDINGS, INDONESIA
PRE-ELECTION NATIONAL SURVEY KEY FINDINGS, INDONESIA March 2014 Funding fr this survey was prvided by the United States Agency fr Internatinal Develpment. I F E S 2 5 Y E A R S LECTORAL SYSTEMS EINTERNATIONAL
More information1. adopt the principles of the Firearms Protocol to strengthen their controls over the import, export and transit movement of firearms;
RECOMMENDATION OF THE CUSTOMS CO-OPERATION COUNCIL * CONCERNING THE PROTOCOL AGAINST THE ILLICIT MANUFACTURING OF AND TRAFFICKING IN FIREARMS, THEIR PARTS AND COMPONENTS AND AMMUNITION, SUPPLEMENTING THE
More informationSteps to Organize a CNU Chapter Congress for the New Urbanism
Steps t Organize a CNU Chapter Cngress fr the New Urbanism 140 S. Dearbrn St., Ste. 404 Chicag, IL 60603 Phne: 312.551.7300 Fax: 312.346.3323 Email: chapters@cnu.rg Intrductin The Cngress fr the New Urbanism
More informationAIPPI Special Committee Q94 WTO/TRIPS
AIPPI Special Cmmittee Q94 WTO/TRIPS Annual reprt f Special Cmmittee Q94 prepared fr the AIPPI Paris Cngress Octber 3-6, 2010 1. Cmpsitin f Special Cmmittee Q94 Chair: Ivan Hjertman Sweden C-Chair: Esmé
More informationINTERNATIONAL TRADE AND CLIMATE CHANGE
INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND CLIMATE CHANGE POLICY STATEMENT Key messages: The trade and climate change plicy regimes must be aligned and integrated t achieve the gals f the Paris Agreement and t advance internatinal
More information45-47 Part 1: General & Specified Prohibited Conduct Lecture 11: Consumer Protection Law
Sectin Page Lecture 1: The Australian Legal System 1-4 Lecture 2: Intrductin t Cntracts 5-9 Lecture 3: Cnsideratin 10-14 Lecture 4: Capacity, Legality & Frm 15-20 Lecture 5: Term in a Cntract 21-28 Lecture
More informationMARYLAND PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT PROFESSOR RUSSELL MCCLAIN UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND SCHOOL OF LAW
MARYLAND PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT PROFESSOR RUSSELL MCCLAIN UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND SCHOOL OF LAW Exam Tip 1: The Maryland Bar Exam tests n the Maryland Lawyers Rules f Prfessinal Cnduct, nt the ABA Mdel Rules.
More informationMARYLAND CONTRACTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR BRENDAN HURSON UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND CAREY SCHOOL OF LAW
MARYLAND CONTRACTS DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR BRENDAN HURSON UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND CAREY SCHOOL OF LAW CHAPTER 1: MARYLAND CONTRACTS DISTINCTIONS A. Frmatin f Cntracts 1. Mutual Assent Mutual assent: Offer
More informationOHIO CRIMINAL PROCEDURE DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR RIC SIMMONS THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY MORITZ COLLEGE OF LAW
A. Furth Amendment OHIO CRIMINAL PROCEDURE DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR RIC SIMMONS THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY MORITZ COLLEGE OF LAW PRE-TRIAL: SEARCHES, WARRANTS, ARRAIGNMENT, GRAND JURY, DISCOVERY Under OHIO
More informationMEMBER PROTECTION POLICY
Martial Arts Industry Assciatin Inc. August 2004 MEMBER PROTECTION POLICY POLICY STATEMENT The Martial Arts Industry Assciatin Inc (MAIA) member rganisatins and affiliated clubs, branches and states, is
More informationOFFICIAL MINUTES OF THE PALM BEACH COUNTY COMMISSION ON ETHICS PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA AUGUST 3, 2017
OFFICIAL MINUTES OF THE PALM BEACH COUNTY COMMISSION ON ETHICS PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA AUGUST 3, 2017 THURSDAY COMMISSION CHAMBERS 1:36 P.M. GOVERNMENTAL CENTER I. SWEARING IN NEW COMMISSIONER BY CHIEF
More informationCommunity Protection Notices and Public Space Protection Orders. County Policing Command. Superintendent David Buckley
POLICY Cmmunity Prtectin Ntices and Public Space Prtectin Orders Plicy wners Plicy hlder Authr Cunty Plicing Cmmand Superintendent David Buckley Sgt Operatinal Partnership Team Plicy N. 208 Apprved by
More informationEUCases end-user applications: EuroCases, ConsumerCases and EULinksChecker
EUCases end-user applicatins: EurCases, CnsumerCases and EULinksChecker Sfia, 24 June 2015 FP7-ICT-2013-SME-DCA EUCases end-user applicatins verview One applicatin > tw services CnsumerCases Online legal
More informationThe Terrorism Act 2000 came into force on 20 July
The Terrrism Act 2000: an analysis --* by Dr C Chatterjee The Terrrism Act 2000 cmpletely refrms the law cncerning preventin f terrrism in the United Kingdm, albeit with sme exceptins; furthermre, it applies
More informationHatch Act: Who is Covered?
Frm the fllwing Hatch Act infrmatin are excerpts frm the fllwing surce: U.S. OFFICE OF SPECIAL COUNSEL 1730 M Street N.W., Suite 218, Washingtn D.C. 20036-4505 www.sc.gv http://www.sc.gv/hatchact.htm April
More informationExhibit 1 : Terms and conditions for domain name registrations under the ".ie" domain operated by IEDR
Exhibit 1 : Terms and cnditins fr dmain name registratins under the ".ie" dmain perated by IEDR Versin - April 2013 1.1 Definitins Acceptable Use Plicy means the plicy f same name as published n the Site
More information