KIRKLEES COUNCIL STRATEGIC PLANNING COMMITTEE. Councillor Armer substituted for Councillor Ward.

Transcription

1 SPC2 Contact Officer: Richard Dunne Tel KIRKLEES COUNCIL STRATEGIC PLANNING COMMITTEE Thursday 11 December 2014 Present: Councillor S Hall (in the Chair) Councillors Armer, Brice, Kane, A Pinnock and Sokhal Apologies: Councillor Lyons 1 Membership of the Sub Committee Councillor Sokhal substituted for Councillor Preest. Councillor Armer substituted for Councillor Ward. 2 Site Visits The Planning Committee visited the sites of the following proposals: (a) (b) Application 2013/ Use of land as camping centre with erection of 18 camping pods and amenity block, and formation of car park area at Bank House Farm, Broad Carr Lane, New Mill, Holmfirth. Application 2014/ Erection of clubhouse and changing rooms with biomass boiler and alterations including access, car parking and realignment of pitches at Hepworth United Playing Field, Far Lane, Hepworth, Huddersfield. 3 Appointment of Chair for Planning Sub Committee (Huddersfield Area) Councillor Kane was appointed Chair of the Planning Sub Committee (Huddersfield Area). 4 Minutes of Previous Meeting The Minutes of the meeting held on 6 November 2014 were approved as a correct record. 5 Interests and Lobbying In connection with Item 10 Planning Applications, Members identified Planning Applications in which they had been lobbied as follows:- Councillors Brice, S Hall, Kane and Sokhal lobbied on application 2014/

2 Councillors Brice, S Hall, Kane, A Pinnock and Sokhal lobbied on application 2014/ Councillor Sokhal lobbied on application 2013/ Admission of the Public The Planning Committee considered the question of the exclusion of the public and determined that all items be taken in public session. 7 Deputations / Petitions No deputations or petitions were received. 8 Public Question Time No questions were asked. 9 Planning Applications The Planning Committee considered the schedule of the planning applications. Under the provisions of Council Procedural Rule number 37, the Planning Committee heard representations from the members of the public in respect of the following applications;- (a) (b) (c) (d) Application 2014/ Outline application for erection of commercial floor space (B1c, B2, B8) including details of engineering operations to form serviced employment plots and full application for the erection of 166 dwellings at Land at Slipper Lane, Mirfield - Mike Townend, Christine Sykes, Tim Conolly and Cheryl Tyler (objectors), Councillor James Taylor and Councillor David Pinder (Mirfield Town Councillors who objected to the plans), Councillor Kath Taylor and Councillor Vivien Lees-Hamilton (Ward Members), Ian Bath and Mike Dove (speaking on behalf of the applicant) and Neil Rowley (agent) Application 2013/ Use of land as camping centre with erection of 18 camping pods and amenity block, and formation of car park area at Bank House Farm, Broad Carr Lane, New Mill, Holmfirth, HD9 7HU - Andrew Hartley, Liz Bouch, Chris Wilkinson, Gary Taylor and Paul Dixon (objectors) and Jeremy Child (agent) Application 2014/ Erection of clubhouse and changing rooms with biomass boiler and alterations including access, car parking and realignment of pitches at Hepworth United Playing Field, Far Lane, Hepworth, Huddersfield - Jim Osborne, Roger Williamson, Richard Southam and Malcolm Sizer (objectors), Councillor Donald Firth (Ward Member), Charles Battye (supporting the application) and Rob Wilkes (speaking on behalf of the applicant) Application 2014/ Demolition of existing office building and formation of extension to existing engineering facility, new transformer and associated external works at David Brown Gear 2

3 Systems Ltd, Park Road, Lockwood, Huddersfield, HD4 5DD - Jeremy Child (agent) RESOLVED - That the applications under the Planning Acts included in the list submitted for the consideration by the Planning Committee be determined as now indicated and that the schedule of such decisions be circulated to members. 3

4

5 DOC1447A. KIRKLEES COUNCIL LIST OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS DECIDED BY STRATEGIC PLANNING COMMITTEE 11 DECEMBER

6 2014/90688 Taylor Wimpey Yorkshire and Park Crescent Outline application for erection of commercial floorspace (B1c, B2,B8) including details of engineering operations to form serviced employment plots and full application for the erection of 166 dwellings Land at Slipper Lane, Mirfield GRANT CONDITIONAL OUTLINE PLANNING PERMISSION (BUSINESS AND INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT) AND FULL PLANNING PERMISISON (RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT), SUBJECT TO DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY TO OFFICERS TO IMPOSE: i) ALL NECESSARY AND APPROPRIATE CONDITIONS, WHICH MAY INCLUDE THOSE SET OUT IN THE SUBMITTED REPORT TOGETHER WITH AN ADDITIONAL CONDITION TO INCLUDE THE REQUIREMENT TO CARRY OUT POST SCHEME IMPLEMENTATION AIR QUALITY MONITORING AND SUBSEQUENT MITIGATION MEASURES. ii) SUBJECT TO THE COUNCIL AND THE APPLICANT ENTERING INTO A SECTION 106 AGREEMENT TO SECURE THE HIGHWAY MITIGATION MEASURES SET OUT IN THIS REPORT, DELIVERY OF INFRASTRUCTURE WORKS TO THE EMPLOYMENT PART OF THE SITE (AS SET OUT IN THE REPORT), OFF-SITE DRAINAGE WORKS AND TO SECURE A COMMUTED SUM IN RESPECT OF OTHER POLICY REQUIREMENTS iii) AND TO ISSUE THE DECISION. A recorded vote was taken in accordance with Council Procedural Rules as follows: FOR: Councillors Kane, Sokhal, A Pinnock and S Hall (4 votes) AGAINST: Councillors Brice and Armer (2 votes) 2013/91204 S Hinchliffe Use of Land as camping centre with erection of 18 camping pods and amenity block, and formation of car park area Bank House Farm, Broad Carr Lane, New Mill, Holmfirth HD9 7HU CONDITIONAL FULL PERMISSION SUBJECT TO A REVISED CONDITION RELATING TO HIGHWAY IMPROVEMENTS AND TO ENSURE THAT ANY REQUIREMENT FOR LANDOWNERS PERMISSIONS IS FULLY INVESTIGATED AS PART OF THE SCHEME DETAILING VEHICLE PASSING PLACES WITH A FURTHER CONDITION TO CONTROL AMENITY ASPECTS OF SITE ACTIVITY 2

7 2013/91204 Cont d (1) The development shall be begun not later than the expiration of three years beginning with the date on which permission is granted. (2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans and specifications except as may be required by other conditions. 3) The camping pods hereby approved shall be let and occupied solely for the purposes of holiday accommodation and shall not be occupied as a main or principal place of residence. (4) If the camp site use hereby permitted ceases to operate for a continuous period of 6 months, a scheme for the decommissioning and removal of the camping pods and all ancillary buildings and structures shall be submitted and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority within 3 months of the end of the cessation period. The scheme shall include details for the restoration of the site. The scheme shall be implemented within 3 months of the date of its approval by the Local Planning Authority. (5) Before development commences, the sightlines of 2.4m x 43m shall be cleared of all obstructions to visibility exceeding 1 m in height and these shall be retained free of any such obstruction. (6) Notwithstanding the details shown on plan number , no development shall take place until a scheme detailing vehicle passing places on Meal Hill Lane between the junction with South View and the development site access have been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The details shall include full sections, construction specifications, drainage works, lighting, signage, lining, surface finishes, and all associated highway works, together with an independent safety audit covering all aspects of the works. The scheme so approved shall be implemented before the development is first brought into use and thereafter retained as such for the lifetime of the development. (7) Development shall not commence until actual or potential land contamination at the site has been investigated and a Preliminary Risk Assessment (Phase I Desk Study Report) has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. (8) Where further intrusive investigation is recommended in the Preliminary Risk Assessment approved pursuant to condition 7 development shall not commence until a Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. 3

8 2013/91204 Cont d (9) Where site remediation is recommended in the Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report approved pursuant to condition 8 development shall not commence until a Remediation Strategy has been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. The Remediation Strategy shall include a timetable for the implementation and completion of the approved remediation measures. (10) Remediation of the site shall be carried out and completed in accordance with the Remediation Strategy approved pursuant to condition 9. In the event that remediation is unable to proceed in accordance with the approved Remediation Strategy or contamination not previously considered [in either the Preliminary Risk Assessment or the Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report] is identified or encountered on site, all works on site (save for site investigation works) shall cease immediately and the local planning authority shall be notified in writing within 2 working days. Unless otherwise agreed in writing with the local planning authority, works shall not recommence until proposed revisions to the Remediation Strategy have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. Remediation of the site shall thereafter be carried out in accordance with the approved revised Remediation Strategy. Following completion of any measures identified in the approved Remediation Strategy or any approved revised Remediation Strategy a Validation Report shall be submitted to the local planning authority. Unless otherwise agreed in writing with the local planning authority, no part of the site shall be brought into use until such time as the remediation measures for the whole site have been completed in accordance with the approved Remediation Strategy or the approved revised Remediation Strategy and a Validation Report in respect of those remediation measures has been approved in writing by the local planning authority. (11) Before development commences details of the packaged sewage treatment plant to be installed shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The details shall include: Location of the tank The capacity of the tank and number of persons using the tank. Adequate means of vehicular access should be provided to allow the tank to be emptied. Thereafter the approved installation shall be installed and maintained in accordance with the agreed details. 4

9 2013/91204 Cont d (12) The development shall be undertaken in accordance with the Ecological Survey by Keystone Environmental Limited dated February (13) The development shall be undertaken in accordance with the Crime Prevention Strategy by Acumen. (14) The development shall be undertaken in accordance with the Coal Mining Risk Assessment by Avie Consulting Limited Ref P1058 dated May (15) Prior to development commencing protective fencing in accordance with British Standard BS 5837 shall be erected around all protected trees and trees to be retained on the site. (16) Any tree work and pruning required to facilitate the development shall be submitted to and approved in writing before any works to trees are undertaken. Thereafter the works shall then be undertaken in accordance with the approved details. NOTE: All contamination reports shall be prepared in accordance with CLR11, PPS23 and the Council s Advice for Development documents or any subsequent revisions of those documents. NOTE: The granting of planning permission does not authorise the carrying out of works within the highway, for which the written permission of the Council as Highway Authority is required. You are required to consult the Design Engineer, Flint Street, Fartown, Huddersfield (Kirklees Street Care: ) with regard to obtaining this permission and approval of the construction specification. Please also note that the construction of vehicle crossings within the highway is deemed to be major works for the purposes of the New Roads and Street Works Act 1991 (Section 84 and 85). Interference with the highway without such permission is an offence which could lead to prosecution. NOTE: It is the applicant's responsibility to find out whether the work approved by this planning permission requires written approval from the Highways Structures section for works near or abutting highway and any retaining structures. Contact Highways Structures Section on Tel No who can advise further on this matter. A recorded vote was taken in accordance with Council Procedural Rules as follows: 1. A motion to refuse the Officer Recommendation. 5

10 2013/91204 Cont d FOR: Councillors Brice, A Pinnock and Armer (3 votes) AGAINST: Councillors Kane, Sokhal and S Hall (3 votes) Councillor S Hall used the Chairs casting vote to defeat the motion. 2. A vote to accept the officer recommendation FOR: Councillors Kane, Sokhal and S Hall (3 votes) AGAINST: Councillors Brice, A Pinnock and Armer (3 votes) Councillor S Hall used the Chair s casting vote to accept the Officer Recommendation. 2014/91665 Hepworth United FC Erection of clubhouse and changing rooms with biomass boiler and alterations including access, car parking and realignment of pitches Hepworth United Playing Field, Far Lane, Hepworth, Huddersfield DEFERRED TO ALLOW THE APPLICANTS AN OPPORTUNITY TO RECONSIDER THE PROPOSAL IN LIGHT OF THE COMMENTS MADE BY THE COMMITTEE TO CONSIDER AN ALTERNATIVE SITING AND/OR TO REDUCE THE SCALE OF THE DEVELOPMENT A recorded vote was taken in accordance with Council Procedural Rules as follows: FOR: Councillors Kane, Sokhal, Brice, A Pinnock, Armer and S Hall (6 votes) AGAINST: (0 votes) 2014/92662 Ken Savage, Perry s Motor Sales Ltd Change of use from builders merchant (Sui Generis) to warehouse (B8), vehicle workshop (B2) and external vehicle storage Builder Centre, Willow Lane, Fartown, Huddersfield HD1 6EB CONDITIONAL FULL PERMISSION SUBJECT TO AN ADDITIONAL CONDITION FOR THE INCLUSION OF A TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT PLAN 6

11 2014/92662 Cont d (1) The development hereby permitted shall be begun within three years of the date of this permission. (2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in complete accordance with the plans and specifications listed in this decision notice, except as may be specified in the conditions attached to this permission, which shall in all cases take precedence. (3) The Delivery Management Plan contained within the supplementary acoustic report (part 4) submitted by Jonathan Rigg of ENS Ltd submitted shall be adopted and implemented at all times when deliveries to or dispatches from the site are taking place between the hours of 18:00 and 07:00. During these hours, the use of vehicle reversing alarms shall not be permitted and there shall be no external use of tannoys or speaker/bells to telephone systems on the site. Vehicles undertaking deliveries to or dispatches from the site within these hours shall be unloaded in the warehouse not in the yard area. (4) The numbers of supplier delivery vehicles to the site between 22:00 and 07:00 hours on weekday nights shall not exceed 3 per night, with no deliveries on Saturdays or Sundays. (5) No activities shall take place on site except during the following hours: Monday to Friday day shift 0700 to 1800, night shift 2200 to 0700; Saturday 0700 to 1300 only; with no working at or dispatches from the site on Sundays or Bank Holidays. There shall be no dispatches from the site between the hours of 1800 and 0600 on any day. (6) Notwithstanding the above condition, the PDI centre shall only be operational during the following hours: Monday to Friday 0700 to 1800; Saturday 0700 to 1300; with no working on Sundays or Bank Holidays. (7) Before the jet wash is first brought into use, a 2 metre high acoustic screen fence with a minimum mass of 10kg/m 2 shall be installed in the position shown on plan 1204-PRH and thereafter retained. (8) The development shall not be brought into use until all areas indicated to be used for parking and for the loading, unloading and turning of vehicles on the submitted/listed plan(s) have been marked out. Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 as amended (or any Order revoking or re-enacting that Order) these areas shall be so retained, free of obstructions and available for the use(s) specified on the submitted/listed plan(s) for the lifetime of the development. 7

12 2014/92662 A recorded vote was taken in accordance with Council Procedural Rules as follows: FOR: Councillors Kane, Sokhal, Brice, A Pinnock, Armer and S Hall (6 votes) AGAINST: (0 Votes) 2014/91283 G Wilson (Fibres) Ltd) Erection of extensions to warehouse Ravenswharfe Mills, Ravenswharf Road, Scout Hill, Dewsbury CONDITIONAL FULL PERMISSION (1) The development shall be begun not later than the expiration of three years beginning with the date on which permission is granted (2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans and specifications except as may be required by other conditions. (3) No development shall take place until a sample facing and roofing materials have been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority, and the development shall be constructed of the approved materials. (4) Development shall not commence until actual or potential land contamination at the site has been investigated and a Preliminary Risk Assessment (Phase I Desk Study Report) has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. (5) Where further intrusive investigation is recommended in the Preliminary Risk Assessment approved pursuant to condition 4 development shall not commence until a Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report has been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. (6) Where site remediation is recommended in the Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report approved pursuant to condition 5 development shall not commence until a Remediation Strategy has been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. The Remediation Strategy shall include a timetable for the implementation and completion of the approved remediation measures. (7) Remediation of the site shall be carried out and completed in accordance with the Remediation Strategy approved pursuant to condition 6. In the event that remediation is unable to proceed in accordance with the approved Remediation Strategy or 8

13 2014/91283 Cont d contamination not previously considered [in either the Preliminary Risk Assessment or the Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report] is identified or encountered on site, all works on site (save for site investigation works) shall cease immediately and the local planning authority shall be notified in writing within 2 working days. Unless otherwise agreed in writing with the local planning authority, works shall not recommence until proposed revisions to the Remediation Strategy have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. Remediation of the site shall thereafter be carried out in accordance with the approved revised Remediation Strategy. (8) Following completion of any measures identified in the approved Remediation Strategy or any approved revised Remediation Strategy a Validation Report shall be submitted to the local planning authority. Unless otherwise agreed in writing with the local planning authority, no part of the site shall be brought into use until such time as the remediation measures for the whole site have been completed in accordance with the approved Remediation Strategy or the approved revised Remediation Strategy and a Validation Report in respect of those remediation measures has been approved in writing by the local planning authority. (9) Prior to the development being brought into use, all areas to be used by vehicles and/ or pedestrians shall be surfaced and rained in accordance with details that have previously been approved in writing by the local planning authority (10) Before the development is brought into use, turning facilities (including the 25m diameter internal turning circle) and a widened access shall be provided in accordance with the details shown on the approved plan. The turning facilities shall thereafter be made available for use at all times by vehicles and shall be kept free from obstruction to such use. A recorded vote was taken in accordance with Council Procedural Rules as follows: FOR: Councillors Kane, Sokhal, Brice, A Pinnock, Armer, and S Hall (6 votes) AGAINST: (0 votes) (THE DECISION WAS MADE IN LINE WITH THE REASONS GIVEN IN THE OFFICERS REPORT) 9

14 2014/92973 D Scott Demolition of existing office building and formation of extension to existing engineering facility, new transformer and associated external works David Brown Gear Systems Limited, Park Road, Lockwood, Huddersfield HD4 5DD CONDITIONAL FULL PERMISSION (1) The development shall be begun not later than the expiration of three years beginning with the date on which permission is granted. (2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans and specifications except as may be required by other conditions. (3) No development shall take place until a sample facing and roofing materials have been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority, and the development shall be constructed of the approved materials. (4) Development shall not commence until a Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report has been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. (5) Where site remediation is recommended in the Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report approved pursuant to condition 4, development shall not commence until a Remediation Strategy has been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. The Remediation Strategy shall include a timetable for the implementation and completion of the approved remediation measures. (6) Remediation of the site shall be carried out and completed in accordance with the Remediation Strategy approved pursuant to condition 5. In the event that remediation is unable to proceed in accordance with the approved Remediation Strategy or contamination not previously considered [in either the Preliminary Risk Assessment or the Phase II Intrusive Site Investigation Report] is identified or encountered on site, all works on site (save for site investigation works) shall cease immediately and the local planning authority shall be notified in writing within 2 working days. Unless otherwise agreed in writing with the local planning authority, works shall not recommence until proposed revisions to the Remediation Strategy have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. Remediation of the site shall thereafter be carried out in accordance with the approved revised Remediation Strategy. (7) Following completion of any measures identified in the approved Remediation Strategy or any approved revised Remediation Strategy a Validation Report shall be submitted to 10

15 2014/92973 Cont d the local planning authority. Unless otherwise agreed in writing with the local planning authority, no part of the site shall be brought into use until such time as the remediation measures for the whole site have been completed in accordance with the approved Remediation Strategy or the approved revised Remediation Strategy and a Validation Report in respect of those remediation measures has been approved in writing by the local planning authority. (8) Before development commences a report specifying the measures to be taken to protect the occupants of nearby noise sensitive premises on Nabcroft Lane, Sunningdale Road and de Trafford Street from noise from the proposed development shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The report shall include: An assessment of noise emissions from the proposed development Details of background and predicted noise levels at the boundary of Nabcroft Lane, Ruddings Street, Ellison Street and de Trafford Street A written scheme of how the occupants of Nabcroft Lane, Ruddings Street, Ellison Street and de Trafford Street will be protected from noise from the proposed development with noise attenuation measures as appropriate. This shall include the level and hours of use of any deliveries off Nabcroft Lane The development shall not be brought into use until all works comprised within the measures specified in the approved report have been carried out in full and such works shall be thereafter retained. (9) Unless otherwise agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority, noise emitted from the premises shall not exceed 61dB LAeq 5 min when measured at any point one metre from the façade. (10) Development shall not commence until a scheme restricting the rate of surface water discharge from the site to a maximum of 70% of the existing pre-development flow rate to the same outfall, has been submitted to and approved in writing by Local Planning Authority. The drainage scheme shall be designed to attenuate flows generated by the critical 1 in 30 year storm event as a minimum requirement. Volumes generated by storms in excess of the critical1 in 30 year storm event, up to and including the critical 1 in 100 year storm event with an appropriate allowance for climate change, shall be stored on site in areas to be approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The scheme shall include a detailed maintenance and management 11

16 2014/92973 Cont d regime for the storage facility including the flow restriction. There shall be no piped discharge of surface water from the development and no part of the development shall be brought into use until the flow restriction and attenuation works comprising the approved scheme have been completed. The approved maintenance and management scheme shall be implemented and thereafter retained. (11) Surface water draining from areas of hard standing shall be passed through an oil interceptor or series of oil interceptors, prior to the discharge into ant watercourse, soakaway or surface water sewer. The interceptor(s) shall be designed and constructed to have a capacity compatible with the area being drained, shall be installed prior to the occupation of the development and shall thereafter be maintained throughout the lifetime of the development. Clean roof water shall not pass through the interceptor(s). Vehicle wash downs and detergents shall not be passed through the interceptor. (12) All down pipes carrying rain water from areas of roof shall be sealed at ground level prior to the occupation of the development. All sealed construction shall thereafter be retained throughout the lifetime of the development. (13) Inspection manholes shall be provided on all foul and surface water drainage runs such that discharges from individual units can be inspected/sampled if necessary. All manhole covers shall be marked to enable easy recognition. Foul will be marked in red Surface water will be marked in blue. Directions of flow will be denoted. Where more than one discharge point is proposed, manholes will also be numbered accordingly to correspond with their respective discharge point. (14) The areas to be used by vehicles including parking, loading and unloading areas shall be surfaced and drained before the development is occupied/brought into use and thereafter retained. (15) No part of the development shall be brought into use until a Travel Plan for the site (Park Gear Works) has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The Travel Plan shall include: Measures, objectives and targets for reduced car usage and increased non-car transport usage, including modal split targets; The provision of Travel Plan Co-ordinator including roles, responsibilities and annual monitoring The provision of travel information Implantation and review timescale; and 12

17 2014/92973 Cont d enforcement, sanctions and corrective/review mechanisms. The measures contained within the Travel Plan shall be implemented in accordance with the approved timescale, except where the monitoring evidence demonstrates that a revised timescale/measures to achieve trip targets are necessary, in which case the revised details would be implemented. (16) A traffic management plan to minimise the use of public roads to move goods by site plant from the application site to other areas of the Park Gear Works shall be submitted to, approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority and brought into operation before the building is first brought into use. Thereafter the movement of goods by site plant shall be undertaken in accordance with the traffic management plan so approved. (17) No development shall take place including works of any demolition until a construction management plan or construction method statement has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The approved plan/ statement shall be adhered to throughout the construction period. The statement shall provide for Parking of vehicles of site operatives and visitors Routes for demolition and construction traffic and deliveries Hours of operation Method of prevention of mud being carries onto the highway Arrangements for the turning of vehicles A recorded vote was taken in accordance with Council Procedural Rules as follows: FOR: Councillors Kane, Sokhal, Brice, A Pinnock, Armer and S Hall (6 votes) AGAINST: (0 votes) (THE DECISION WAS MADE IN LINE WITH THE REASONS GIVEN IN THE OFFICERS REPORT) 13