Hilton Cocoa Beach Oceanfront 1550 North Atlantic Ave. Cocoa Beach, FL March 13-14, 2014

Transcription

1 MINUTES FROM THE ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD MEETING Doubletree Cocoa Beach Oceanfront 2080 North Atlantic Avenue Cocoa Beach, FL March 12, 2014 Hilton Cocoa Beach Oceanfront 1550 North Atlantic Ave. Cocoa Beach, FL March 13-14, 2014 The Board meeting was called to order by Chairman Timothy Chinchor at 8:30 a.m. (CST) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE INVOCATION ROLL CALL Members Present Timothy Chinchor (Chairman) Kenneth Hoffmann Noel Thomas Robert Bramlett Brian Flaherty David Botknecht Paul Sandefer Thomas McHaffie John (Jay) Cannava Members Absent Benjamin Smith (Vice-Chairman) - excused Others Present Daniel Biggins, Executive Director Ruthanne Christie, Government Analyst II Deborah Loucks, Esq., Assistant Attorney General Thomas Campbell, Esq., Assistant General Counsel Court Reporter American Court Reporting Ph: Approval of the Agenda MOTION: Mr. Thomas made a motion to approve the agenda

2 Ms. Christie noted for the record that Charles Stokes and Mr. Pinkston attended in compliance with the requirements of their application approval orders. Disciplinary Cases Thomas Campbell, Assistant General Counsel Maxwell, Carl Carl Maxwell Electrical Contractors License #: ER Case #: Mr. Maxwell was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Maxwell was charged with violation of (1)(m)4, F.S. failing to satisfy a civil judgment. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent was properly served and waived his right to hearing. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the violations of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to impose suspension of the license until he provides proof of satisfaction of the civil judgment, fines of $1,000 and costs of $ due within 30 days. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Williams, Ray E. Jr. Ray E. Williams, Inc & GM Signs License #: EC & EC Case #: Mr. Williams was present with Mr. Marinello both were sworn in by the court reporter

3 Mr. Williams was charged with violation of (1)(n), F.S. being disciplined by a municipality. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion to accept the violations of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Botknecht. MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion to dismiss the case. Raia, Salvatore Goliath General Contractors, Inc. License #: ER Case #: Mr. Salvatore was present and sworn in by the court reporter, counsel Carey Blaxberg, Esq. was not present, Mr. Raia agreed to go forward without his attorney. Mr. Salvatore was charged with violation of (1)(m)4, F.S. failing to satisfy a civil judgment and (1)(b), F.S., attempting to procure a license by fraud. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to reject the settlement stipulation. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie Motion passed 5 in favor 2 opposed (Botknecht & Sandefer opposed). MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion for a counter offer with suspension of the license until judgment is satisfied, stay the suspension for 6 months, fines of $ 500 and costs of $ within 90 days. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie Motion passed 5 in favor 2 opposed (Mr. Botknecht & Mr. Sandefer opposed). Ms. Loucks informed Mr. Raia he would receive a written counter offer and he would have 7 days to accept or reject the counter offer and should consult with his attorney. Alonso, Guillermo London General Contractors Inc & Alonso Electric License #: EC Case #:

4 Mr. Alonso was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Alonso was charged with violation of (1)(h), F.S. practicing on a revoked suspended, inactive or delinquent license. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion the respondent was properly served. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to impose revocation of all licenses, fines of $10,000 and costs of $ within 30 days. Gonzalez, Juan Watts Electric, Inc. License #: ER Case #: Mr. Gonzalez was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Gonzalez was charged with violation of (1)(q) F.S. being disciplined by a municipality. MOTION: Mr. McHaffie made a motion the respondent was properly served. SECOND: Mr. Botknecht. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing

5 MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to impose suspension of licensure until compliance with prior final order, satisfaction of the civil judgment and appearance before the Board for reinstatement, fine of $5,000 and costs of $ Motion passed 8 in favor 1 opposed (Mr. McHaffie opposed). Gutierrez, Angel Five D Group License #: ER Case #: Mr. Gutierrez was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Gutierrez was charged with violation of (1)(m)2, F.S. financial misconduct and (1)(p), F.S. abandonment. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion the respondent was properly served. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer

6 MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to impose suspension until compliance with this final order stayed for 60 days, fines of $5,500 costs of $ and restitution of $600 and appearance before the board for reinstatement of licensure. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor. Motion passed in 4 favor 1 opposed (Mr. McHaffie opposed). MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to reconsider the discipline imposed. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to revoke licensure, impose fines of $5,500 costs of $ and restitution of $600 due within 30 days. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. Hashim, James License #: ES Case #: Mr. Hashim was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Hashim was charged with violation of (1)(d), F.S. being convicted of a crime related to the practice. MOTION: Mr. McHaffie made a motion the respondent was properly served. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board

7 MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to impose revocation of both licenses, fines of $10,000 citing aggravating factor severity of the crime and danger to the public and costs of $ due within 30 days. Law, Martin M A L Electric LLC License #: ER Case #: Mr. Law was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Law was charged with violation of (1)(m)(2), F.S., financial misconduct, (1)(p) abandonment, (1)(h), practicing on a delinquent license, (1)(r), F.S. proceeding without permits, (1)(s), F.S. practicing beyond the scope of a license, (1)(d), F.S. using a delinquent or inactive license and (1)(t) failing to report a crime. Ms. Loucks advised the Board this case was heard in January 2014 and the fines imposed were in excess of the maximum fines for the offenses cited. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to reduce the fines to $24,000. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. Ledford, Joseph Ledford Industries License #: ER Case #: Mr. Ledford was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Ledford was charged with violation of (1)(a), F.S by violating (1)(t), F.S. failing to report a conviction within 30 days. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion the respondent was properly served. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing

8 MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Flaherty MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to impose fines of $1,500 and costs of $ due within 60 days require licensee to attend disciplinary portion of the meeting within 12 months and 2 hours of laws and rules CE in addition to regular requirements within 12 months. Medoff, Seth Medoff Electric Co. License #: ER Case #: Mr. Medoff was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Medoff was charged with violation of (1)(a), F.S. and (1)(q) failing to comply with a final order. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion the respondent was properly served. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing. SECOND: Mr. Cannava MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board

9 MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to impose suspension until compliance with prior final order and satisfaction of civil judgment, fine of $5,000 and costs of $ SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. Wyatt, Dennis Denis Wyatt All phase Electric of Florida, Inc. License #: ER Case #: Mr. Wyatt was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Wyatt was charged with violation of (1)(m)4, F.S. failing to satisfy a civil judgment. MOTION: Mr. McHaffie made a motion the respondent was properly served. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to impose suspension until satisfaction of civil judgment, fine $3,000 and costs of $73.45 APPLICATION REVIEW Additional Business Applications See attachment for a list of applicants that were present during this portion of the meeting: The Court Reporter swore in, as a group, the applicants and those persons providing testimony on behalf of the applicant. During the review each applicant and their respective designees were interviewed in turn and answered general questions concerning the business entity they wished - 9 -

10 to qualify and direct questions concerning their understanding of their responsibilities and obligations as primary qualifying agent. Mr. Smith asked of the second business applicants collectively as a group: Do you understand that you will be legally responsible for every job undertaken by this business? Do you understand that you will be financially responsible for every job undertaken by this business? Do you understand that you are required to approve the work done on every job undertaken by this business? Do you understand that your license is dependent upon how seriously you take these responsibilities? Each applicant answered affirmatively to each of the preceding questions. PETITIONS FOR DECLARATORY STATEMENT, Deborah Loucks, Esq., Assistant Attorney General The petitioner was not present nor represented by counsel. The Petitioner Scout Alarm, Liz Thompson asked if their scope of work considered Alarm Contracting. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion that the scope of work is Alarm Contracting and would be under the Alarm II contractor license. HEARINGS NOT INVOLVING DISPUTED ISSUES OF MATERIAL FACT Deborah Loucks, Assistant Attorney General James Brown Mr. Brown was present with Allison Brown, both were sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Jorge Castillo Mr. Castillo was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application

11 Antonio Disalvatore Mr. DiSalvatore was present and sworn in by the court reporter with counsel Tim Atkinson, Esq. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Robert Dyer Mr. Dyer was present with Lou Frye both were sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application with probation for the term of the bankruptcy plan with quarterly reports on status of payment plan to the Board. Blaine Frink Mr. Frink was present with Chris Bates, both were sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Cannava made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Botknecht. Jason Kotrady Mr. Kotrady was present with Kenneth Kotrady both were sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. Richard Litland Mr. Litland was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application contingent on proof the IRS tax liens are combined in a payment plan and with probation until IRS is paid off and quarterly reports on the IRS payment plan. Marcelo Martin Mr. Martin was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to continue the application. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor

12 Richard Maxson Mr. Maxson was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to uphold the denial. Rolando Perez Mr. Perez was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Botknecht. Motion passed 7 in favor 1 opposed (Mr. McHaffie). Audley Russell Mr. Russell was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to approve the application contingent on an updated credit report showing the mortgages are no longer past due, Mr. Botknecht is designated to review. SECOND: Mr. Botknecht. Kenneth Wrenn Mr. Wrenn was not present, Mr. Gary Robbins, Esq. was present on his behalf. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Koning Enterprises, Inc. CE Course Digital Project Documentation The provider was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. Israel Markowitz Mr. Markowitz was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application

13 Reconsiderations, Deborah Loucks, Esq., Assistant Attorney General Daniel Insua Application Approved Contingent Mr. Insua was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to approve the application with probation for 1 year or until he satisfies the IRS liability, must be satisfied within 1 year and submit quarterly reports on the status of the payments. William Syx Application Withdrawal Mr. Syx was present and sworn in by the court reporter. Mr. Syx waived his 90 days. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to reverse the withdrawal and rehear the application. SECOND: Mr. Botknecht. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to approve application. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. PROBATION REPORT MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept the probation reports of Raymond Bellefuille, Dennis Guinn, Charles Stokes & Everett Price. Jesse Alexander s report was not accepted, the Board requested he submit the report on the ECLB form. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. LEGISLATIVE REPORT None RULES REPORT Ms. Loucks presented the rules report indicating new rule regarding Public Comment, Rule 61G would be effective March 18, 2014 and the new language in Rule 61G was effective February 19, MOTION: Mr. McHaffie made a motion to accept the report. Motion passed unanimously FINANCIAL BUDGET LIAISON REPORT David Botknecht Mr. Botknecht provided summary of the financial report

14 MOTION: Mr. McHaffie made a motion to accept report. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Motion passed unanimously UNLICENSED ACTIVITY (ULA) REPORT Thomas McHaffie & David Botknecht Mr. McHaffie and Mr. Botknecht gave the report updating the Board on the activities of the Department. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept report. SECOND: Mr. Thomas. EXAMINATION REPORT Thomas McHaffie MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to accept he January & February exam reports. SECOND: Mr. Flaherty Motion passed unanimously ENDORSEMENT REPORT No changes. RATIFICATION OF APPLICATIONS The lists will be attached to the minutes and are hereby incorporated by reference. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to ratify the Continuing Education Committee results. MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion to ratify the Grandfathering Committee and Initial Application Review Committees results. SECOND: Mr. Botknecht. APPROVAL OF MINUTES MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion to approve the January 2014 meeting minutes. SECOND: Mr. Thomas OLD BUSINESS/ NEW BUSINESS The Board disussed the following issues: CEU s Chairman requested staff have 3 hours CE to the Board members for attending the discipline

15 Discussed rule change for issuing CE credits to the Board Members and update rule to allow Laws and Rules credit for licensees attending the meeting. Ms. Loucks will bring drafts for discussion to the next meeting. Mr. Biggins will provide suggestions regarding requiring background checks. Ms. Loucks will look into issue of initial license prior to applying for additional business not at same meeting. PROSECUTING ATTORNEY S REPORT Thomas Campbell, Esq., Assistant General Counsel Mr. Campbell directed the Board s attention to the details of the report, which he distributed to the members. The report included case information for all open cases as of March 10, MOTION: Mr. Botknecht made a motion to continue prosecution of all cases over 1 year old. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Motion passed unanimously BOARD COUNSEL S REPORT Deborah Loucks, Esq., Assistant Attorney General None PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL PUBLIC CASES - Reconsiderations Presenting Attorney: Thomas Campbell Members: Noel Thomas, Robert Bramlett & Kenneth Hoffmann Douberly, Chad EC Case # MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to dismiss the case. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett. Raba, Shawn EF Case # MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to dismiss the case. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett. EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR S REPORT Daniel Biggins Mr. Biggins directed the Board s attention to the enforcement report and the proposed meeting dates which were provided for the Board s information. CHAIRPERSON S COMMENTS Timothy Chinchor None Adjournment

16 Continuing Education Agenda March 13, 2014 (Cocoa Beach) A. Comcast University (EC ) 1. App# FLORIDA FASA BASA GREENFIELD CERTIFICATION COURSE (TRAINING) Approved App# FLORIDA FASA BASA GREENFIELD CERTIFICATION COURSE (TRAINING) Approved... B. Continuing Education Academy (EC ) 3. App# BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 1 Approved App# BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 2 Approved... C. Florida Association of Electrical Contractors (EC ) 5. App# HEATHCARE REFORM-THE LONG WINDING & DELAYED ROAD Approved... D. Gray Systems Inc (EC ) 6. App# A REVIEW OF SELECTED 2014 CHANGES TO THE NEC Approved App# CONSTRUCTION BUSINESS MANAGEMENT Approved App# CONTRACTOR LEGAL COMPLIANCE COURSE Approved... E. Independent Electrical Contractors, Inc. (EC ) 9. App# NEC TOPICS - SESSION ONE Approved App# BUSINESS AND GOVERNMENT Approved... F. National Training School (EC ) 11. App# FLORIDA FASA BASA CERTIFICATION COURSE (TRAINING) Approved App# FLORIDA FASA BASA CERTIFICATION COURSE (TRAINING) Approved... G. Redvector.Com, Inc. (EC ) 13. App# NEC CHANGES-ARTICLES 90, 100 & 110 (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-CHAP. 2 WIRING PROTECTION (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-CHAP. 3 WIRING METHODS & MATERIALS (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-CHAP. 4 EQUIPMENT FOR GENERAL USE (ONLINE) Approved... 1

17 17. App# NEC CHANGES-CHAP. 5 SPECIAL OCCUPANCIES (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-CHAP. 6 ELECTRIC SIGNS AND OUTLINE LIGHTING (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-CHAP. 7 SPECIAL CONDITIONS (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-CHAP. 8 COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-A SUMMARY OF CHANGES FOR CHAPTERS 5 & 6 (ONLINE) Approved App# ELECTRIC POWER GENERATION WEBCAST (ONLINE) Approved App# HEPA HIGH EFFICIENCY FILTERS WEBCAST(ONLINE) Approved App# HVAC DESIGN WEBCAST (ONLINE) Approved App# HVAC DISTRIBUTION WEBCAST (ONLINE) Approved 26. App# POWER TRANSMISSION & DISTRIBUTION WEBCAST (ONLINE) Approved App# ELECTRIC POWER SUBSTATIONS WEBCAST (ONLINE) Approved App# COMMERCIAL APPLICATION TRANSFORMERS WEBCAST (ONLINE) Approved App# PROTECTING YOUR COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM FROM TRANSIENTS AND SURGES WEBCAST (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-CONDENSED VERSION (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-A SUMMARY OF CHANGES- CHAPS 1 & 2 (ONLINE) Approved App# NEC CHANGES-A SUMMARY OF CHANGES- CHAPS 3 & 4 (ONLINE) Approved contingent on updated timeline with 25 minutes for chapter 5 Updated timeline received ok to process App# FORMATION EVALUATION BY WIRELINE LOGGING (ONLINE) Approved App# FALL PROTECTION (ONLINE) Approved App# FIRE SAFETY (ONLINE) Approved App# LOCKOUT/TAGOUT (ONLINE) Approved App# SAFETY ORIENTATION (ONLINE) Approved... 2

18 38. App# SAFE WORK PERMITS (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-ELEC. APPLIANCES (ONLINE) Approved App# ELECTRIC FIRE ALARM SYSTEMS (ONLINE) Approved App# INT'L BLDG CODE & MORE-FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS (ONLINE) Approved for 1 hour per from Ms. Sakamoto App# INT'L BLDG CODE & MORE-ABOUT THE CODES (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-ELECTRICAL SYSTEMS BASICS (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-HEATING & COOLING SYSTEMS (ONLINE) Approved App# INT'L BLDG CODE & MORE-FIRE & SMOKE RESISTANT ASSEMBLIES (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-PRINCIPLES OF THERMAL COMFORT (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-FIRE SAFETY (ONLINE) Approved App# INT'L BLDG CODE & MORE-ELECTRICAL & COMMUNICATION REQUIREMENTS (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-LIGHTING SYSTEMS (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS (ONLINE) Approved App# BUILDING SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-THE BUILDING AND ITS ENVIRONMENT (ONLINE) Approved App# BLDG SYSTEMS FOR DESIGNERS-INTRO TO ACOUSTIC DESIGN PRINCIPLES (ONLINE) Approved App# INT'L BLDG CODE & MORE-CONSTRUCTION TYPES & BUILDING SIZES (ONLINE) Approved... H. Wayne Lee Beach (EC ) 54. App# EMT CONDUIT FITTINGS, LISTINGS AND APPLICATIONS Approved App# MC FITTINGS, LISTINGS AND APPLICATIONS Approved... 3

19 1 A B C D E App # Last First Present Notes Almaguer Angel yes Requested withdraw BF/TC accepted withdrawal - UNAN.- BF/TC Denied failure to deomstrate financial responsibility, incorrect financial, does not show business liabilities on FS, local fine no proff it is paid and what total amount was Requested withdrawal BF/TM - accept withdrawal. BF/TM - Behhcke Denied for failure to demonstrate financial responsibility James yes Wife "Holly did not complete background questions she is VP. Delinquent accounts on CR (4 accounts). BF/TM - Denied - Personal FS does not list mortgage, cash Benitez surrender valaue?, itemize item 5, updated letter verifying Jose No exam scores from building official. - Unan Dixon Donald No TC/BF - continuance granted Guia Idarraga Mundle Rafael Jorge Jarett yes present with wife Miriam Guia yes No Waived 90 days and requested a continucance - BF/TM - continued unan with request for updated FS and CR, documentation on negative items. Personal credit report shows collections and chargeoffs, debts not accurately reflected on personal FS,need to provide an updated credit report, settlement with mortgage company. BF/JC - Denied - Unan -, BF/TM - reverse denial and allow withdrawal of applocation. Issues were - No proof of vehicles values on business FS, personal FS does not show any debt CR shows liabilities. Provided handout. BF/TC - Denied for outstanding debts not resolved failure to demonstrate financial responsibility - unan Pennella yes with wife Jeanie BF/TC - Approved contingent on proof of satisfaction of the John Penella 2 IRS tax debts within 90 days- unan Peterman Joe yes BF/TM - accepted withdrawal - Unan Quintanilla Provided revised FS and new credit report - TC/BF Approved Benito yes - Unan Rivero BF/JC - denied based on notation from bldg department Joaquin No open cases and expired permits. BF/TC - approved contingent on a Revised personal FS Secker showing student loan and updated assets and positive Charles yes networth. BF/JC - Personal FS does not reflect tax leins or personal Telfort loans listed on the CR, thus personal networth is negative Frantz No Unan BF/TM Denied - failure to demonstrate Financial Delano responsibility, bus fs other assets not documented, James No accounts receivable not documented, chargeoffs,

20 A B C D E Last First Committee Present Notes ANDREWS MICHAEL Hoffmann & Botknecht yes Approved Residential Specialty - DB/KH deny failure to demonstrate financial responsibility - CASSELE RANDY L Hoffmann & Botknecht no assets on personal FS are credit lines LASCAR JEFFREY B Hoffmann & Botknecht no Requesting Continuance waived 90 days LEBLANC DOUGLAS M Hoffmann & Botknecht no approved LYKE DENNIS J Hoffmann & Botknecht no approved MARTIN DENNIS T Hoffmann & Botknecht yes Sign Specialty - Approved PUGA RUDDY Hoffmann & Botknecht yes Approved UNRUH RALF Hoffmann & Botknecht yes approved Bristoll Matthew Hoffmann & Botknecht yes Wants INACTIVE STATUS KH/DB - approved with condition he appear before the Board for activation of license with a current credit report. Kascht Stephen Hoffmann & Botknecht no approved Rodrigues Davilson Hoffmann & Botknecht yes Approved Reyes Harold Hoffmann & Botknecht yes Approved ROGERS PETER M Hoffmann & Botknecht yes Request for VW - TC/TM - approved - unan License DB/KH - approved BROWN PHILLIP McHaffie & Chinchor no Approved FOWKES JARED T 0 no approved not present Pierre Bellemare on his behalf Approved GRAGG JOSEPH H McHaffie & Chinchor LATCHFORD JUSTIN R McHaffie & Chinchor no approved LINVILLE SCHON T McHaffie & Chinchor no denied bus fs is over 12 months old and experience detail is not sufficient. MARQUIS SHAWN G McHaffie & Chinchor yes approved PAEZ CHRISTIAN D McHaffie & Chinchor yes approved POP-BUIA PAVEL McHaffie & Chinchor no approved ROTELLO LOUIS McHaffie & Chinchor no approved SIMPKINS PATRICK E McHaffie & Chinchor yes approved STAUFFER PAUL McHaffie & Chinchor yes approved WANG YANLING McHaffie & Chinchor yes approved Gard Jamie McHaffie & Chinchor yes approved

21 A B C D E Last First Committee Present Notes Approved with 1 year probation must report status of greentree debt quarterly and contingent on revised FS showing greentree item as a debt. At 1 year comes Hansen Joshua McHaffie & Chinchor yes back to board for further discussion. Received revised FS at meeting ABIN ANTONIO Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no Approved ALVAREZ RODRIGUEZ ALEXIS L Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no approved BF/PS - Approved to Qualify A Greg Orick Marine Construction, Inc. as primary ANDERSON ROBERT J Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava yes license - unan. CAMPBELL SCOTT Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava yes approved CATALANI JOSEPH Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no approved Waived 90 days and requested a continuance - BF/PS/JC granted continuance for 6 months - needs Revised letter of employment from Pomeroy (not residential), Revised Personal financial does not list all liabilities, business fs need itemized lists, job experience does not reflect sufficient 3 phase provid additonal 3phase CORTEZ ALEXANDER Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava yes jobs totaling 5 months. BF/PS/JC - denied failure to demonstrate required experience, job lists overlap DAVIS ERIC D Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no only 37 months out of 48 needed FUDGE BRETON Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no approved GLORIOSO MICHAEL A Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava yes Handout provided - Approved GRAGG MICHAEL R Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no approved HALL JAMES Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no approved HARRELL RICHARD K Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no approved approved contingent on him taking and passing business exam scores are expired HERNANDEZ ALBERTO Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava no must take and pass within 6 months.

22 1 A B C D E Last First Committee Present Notes IZZO DANIEL J Sandefer, Flaherty & Cannava yes approved GREENWAY MARC W Thomas & Bramlett no approved BAKER EDMOND B Thomas & Bramlett yes approved BENNETT ASHLEY E Thomas & Bramlett no approved BOTTERON JARED Thomas & Bramlett no approved LEVENTER JEFFREY Thomas & Bramlett yes approved alarm 2 MASCOLO JOEL S Thomas & Bramlett no approved MONTGOME RY BRANSON D Thomas & Bramlett no approved - IA NORRIS DANIEL W Thomas & Bramlett yes approved NOTARTOM ASO PAUL S Thomas & Bramlett no approved O'NEIL KEVIN M Thomas & Bramlett no approved PATINO VICTOR A Thomas & Bramlett yes approved RODRIGUEZ ALEXIS Thomas & Bramlett yes approved Bussa Robert Thomas & Bramlett no approved - IA Rodriguez Jesus Thomas & Bramlett no Approved Borja Enrique Paper Handout TC/RB no Approved

23 last first present notes Baxter Mason yes BF/TC failure to demonstrate ability to manage, lack of financial responsibility, contracting in a name other than on license, not pulling permits, assets listed on FS are personal not business - unan Bolcavage Paul yes BF/DB approved with 2 years probation quarterly updating board with info. On payments of debts, a new CR to get off probation - unan affirmed on the record his Insalaco Edwin yes authority DB/TC approve - unan Norton Steven yes DB/TC - approved - unan

24 A B C D E App # Last First Present Notes seeking updated FS on our form, qualifier needs to understand items on the FS, some questions. Requested continunce and waived 90 days BF/TC ANDERSON ROBER J present - continued - unan should bring owner Benton Arnold present with Josh Whicker TC/KH approved unan BRACONE JAMES P present KH/TC - approved - unan CALDWELL WILLIAM present with counsel Tim Atkinson, Esq DB/TM - approved - 8 in favor 1 opposed (Chinchor) CALDWELL WILLIAM present with counsel Tim Atkinson, Esq DB/TM - approved - 8 in favor 1 opposed (Chinchor) CALDWELL WILLIAM present with counsel Tim Atkinson, Esq DB/TM - approved - 8 in favor 1 opposed (Chinchor) Cachere Raymond not present withdrawn DETTMANN THOM ALAN Present TC/KH - approved Dixon Donald Not present CKH/DB continued GONZALEZ CARLOS R Present DB/TM Approved - unan GORDILS BENNY ANTHONY JR Present DB/TC - approv ed - unan present with Jorge GRANADILLO JORGE F Saavedra DB/TM - approved - unan HARRINGTONWILLIAM PAUL present w/ Mark Bennett TC/DB - approved - unan KH/RB failure to demonstrate ability to manage additional business and no check writing authority, HIGGINS JOHN PHILLIP not present financial management - unan JAIME JUAN present w/ Luis Llerena DB/TC - approved - unan KENT THOMAS M present KH/RB - approved - unan KNIGHT DAVID present with Kyle Bealey DB/TC - approved - unan LAWRENCE KIMANDY SEON Present TC/DB - approved - unan

25 20 21 A B C D E LOVETT JOHN B JR Present TC/RB -approved unan 4249 MASON STEPHEN W Present with John Seabolt TC/RB - approved - unan MATHEWS STEPHEN WOODROW Present DB/NT - approv ed - unan MCDONALD JOSEPH not present KH/TC failure to demonstrate ability to manage additional business and financial management - unan BF/KH - aiding UL using unlicensed sub and lack of knowledge of FS and failure to demonstrate ability 4228 OAKEY BRANTLEY present to manage OAKEY BRANTLEY present BF/KH - aiding UL using unlicensed sub and lack of knowledge of FS and failure to demonstrate ability to manage Palivoda Daniel not present DB/BF - continuaned - unancontinuance requested present with counsel SASSON ISAAC Tim Atkinson, Esq TC/TM - Approved - unan Stone Lewis present TC/BF - Approved - unan TC/ DB approved contingent on fs showing $10, TEPPER JAMES A present networth for Somos GM THOMAS HENRY present TC/KH - approved - unan THOMAS HENRY present TC/KH - approved - unan VERDECIA ANTHONY JULIUS present TC/RB - approved - unan WEINER STEVEN LEE not present requested to withdraw WRIGHT CHRISTOPHER present PS/RB - approved - unan WRIGHT CHRISTOPHER T present TM/BF approve contingent on CR showing dba with no negative issues