MINUTES FROM THE ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD MEETING

Transcription

1 MINUTES FROM THE ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD MEETING Wyndham Baypoint Resort 4114 Jan Cooley Drive Panama City Beach, Florida Ph: November 20-22, 2013 The Board meeting was called to order by Chairman Timothy Chinchor at 8:30 a.m. (CST) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE INVOCATION ROLL CALL Members Present Timothy Chinchor (Chairman) Benjamin Smith (Vice-Chairman) Kenneth Hoffmann Noel Thomas Robert Bramlett Brian Flaherty Paul Sandefer Robert Bramlett Thomas McHaffie John (Jay) Cannava Members Absent David Botknecht (Excused) Robert Bramlett Absent (Excused) 11/22/2013 Others Present Daniel Biggins, Executive Director Ruthanne Christie, Government Analyst II Deborah Loucks, Esq., Assistant Attorney General Thomas Campbell, Esq., Assistant General Counsel Court Reporter - Baytowne Reporting

2 Disciplinary Cases Thomas Campbell, Assistant General Counsel Reynolds, Telford License Number: ER Case Number: Pulled from the agenda by Prosecuting Attorney. Henry, William License#: EF1024, EF , EF , EF , EF Case #: , , , , Mr. Henry was present with counsel Timothy Atkinson, Esq. and sworn in by the court reporter. Mr. Henry was charged with violation of (1)(c)F.S., having a license suspended by another state. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the stipulation imposing a fine of $1,000 and costs of $ as presented. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor. Dasher, William License#: ER Case #: Pulled from the agenda by Prosecuting Attorney. Ellis, Frederick License#: ET Case #: Mr. Ellis was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Ellis was charged with violation of (1)(n), F.S. being disciplined by a municipality. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent was properly served. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board

3 SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to impose suspension of licensure until compliance with the final order and reinstatement by local jurisdiction (minimum 2 years), a fine of $5,000, costs of $220.36, and 5 hours of safety continuing education within 6 months. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor Fiedler, Mary Jane License#: EC Case #: Ms. Fiedler was not present nor represented by counsel. Ms. Fiedler was charged with violation of (1)(j), F.S. aiding and abetting unlicensed activity. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent was properly served. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent waived her right to hearing. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to impose revocation of licensure, a fine of $5,000, costs of $ to be paid within 30 days. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett - 3 -

4 Gonzalez, Juan License#: ER Case #: Pulled from the agenda by Prosecuting Attorney. Roy, Frederick License#: EF & EF Case #: Mr. Roy was not present nor represented by counsel. Mr. Roy was charged with violation of (1)(m)4, F.S. failure to satisfy a civil judgment. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent was properly served. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion the respondent waived his right to hearing. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to impose suspension of licensure until satisfaction of civil judgment, a fine of $3,000, costs of $190.92, to be paid within 60 days. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor Smith, Sam License#: ER Case #: Mr. Smith was present and sworn in by the court reporter. Mr. Smith was charged with violation of (1)(q), F.S. failure to comply with a Final Order

5 MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the findings of facts as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to accept the conclusions of law as stated in the administrative complaint as those of the Board. SECOND: Mr. Braqmlett. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to impose suspension of licensure until compliance with the prior final order and costs of $ SECOND: Mr. Chinchor APPLICATION REVIEW Brian Flaherty, Chairman Additional Business Applications See attachment for a list of applicants that were present during this portion of the meeting: The Court Reporter swore in, as a group, the applicants and those persons providing testimony on behalf of the applicant. During the review each applicant and their respective designees were interviewed in turn and answered general questions concerning the business entity they wished to qualify and direct questions concerning their understanding of their responsibilities and obligations as primary qualifying agent. Mr. Smith asked of the second business applicants collectively as a group: Do you understand that you will be legally responsible for every job undertaken by this business? Do you understand that you will be financially responsible for every job undertaken by this business? Do you understand that you are required to approve the work done on every job undertaken by this business? Do you understand that your license is dependent upon how seriously you take these responsibilities? Each applicant answered affirmatively to each of the preceding questions. Petitions for Declaratory Statement, Deborah Loucks, Esq., Assistant Attorney General Petition for Declaratory Statement 3M The petitioner was not present nor represented by counsel. The Petition seeks the Board s opinion in response to the following questions: - 5 -

6 Can the Owner contract with us to provide a turn-key solution including provision of the equipment and hiring of the licensed electrical contractor to install the equipment and once the equipment is installed, do we need a license to service and maintain the equipment? MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion that Petitioner is required to be licensed by the Board in order to hire the electrical contractor to install the equipment. Petitioner cannot contract with the owner and then subcontract the electrical work without a license. In response to the second question, no license is required to perform incidental electrical work, including removal of the wires, when servicing or maintaining the equipment. Any electrical work beyond the removal of wires must be performed by a licensee. SECOND: Mr. Cannava. Petition for Declaratory Statement Black Hawk Protection Services, Inc. The Petition seeks the Board s opinion in response to the following questions: Is an alarm contractor license required to watch and listen (monitoring) to a CCTV audio and video system? And do the functions described in the petition fall within the ambit of Section (2)(a), F.S.? MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion that Petitioner is required to be licensed by the Board in order to provide the watch and listen (monitoring) functions described in the petition. In response to the second question, if Petitioner's employees are performing only monitoring activities (as monitoring is defined in the statute), then Section (2)(a), Florida Statutes, would apply and those employees would not be required to become Burglar Alarm System Agents. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Petition for Declaratory Statement G4S Technology, LLC The petitioner was not present nor represented by counsel. The Petition seeks the Board s opinion as to whether underground conduit installation is within the scope of licensure for a Certified Alarm System Contractor I. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion that the installation of underground conduit that is part of the installation of an alarm system (provided that the wire and voltage do not exceed 98 volts) falls within the scope of an Alarm System Contractor I licensee. SECOND: Mr. Sandefer. Petition for Declaratory Statement Kleinbard Bell Becker, LLP The petitioner was not present nor represented by counsel. The Petition seeks the Board s opinion as to whether the safety-related video-conferencing application for smartphones requires a license

7 MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion that the Board decline to answer Petitioner's question regarding the application of the definitions of "alarm system" and "monitoring" to Petitioner's circumstances because the Board believes that the statutory definitions set forth in Section , Florida Statutes, and any applicable exemptions are clear. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. Petition for Declaratory Statement National Conductor Constructors The petitioner was not present nor represented by counsel. The Petition seeks the Board s opinion as to what types of licenses would be required for the four divisions listed in the Petition. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion that a Certified Electrical contractor licensee could perform all of the activities described in each division; that a Registered Electrical contractor licensee would likely be able to perform most, if not all, of the described activities; and that some of the described activities could be performed by an utility line electrical specialty contractor. SECOND: Mr. Flaherty. Petition for Declaratory Statement Vergona Bowersox Electric, Inc. The petitioner was not present nor represented by counsel. The Petition seeks the Board s opinion as to scope of authority of a certified electrical contractor when installing solar photovoltaic systems. MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion that an electrical contractor can: bid and be the primary solar contractor on any solar project; do concrete foundations incidental to the installation of the solar photovoltaic system; and can provide structure, support and penetrations that are incidental to the system installation. However, the electrical contractor may have to subcontract for the non-incidental construction work. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor. HEARINGS NOT INVOLVING DISPUTED ISSUES OF MATERIAL FACT Deborah Loucks, Assistant Attorney General Shane Benson Application Denial Mr. Benson was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Smith made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application for downgrade to Alarm II. SECOND: Mr. Thomas

8 Dexter Casanova Application Denial Mr. Casanova was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. Jose Cerro Application Denial Mr. Cerro was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. McHaffie made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Smith. Richard Chafe Application Denial Mr. Chafe was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Smith. Richard Hackeman Application Denial Mr. Hackeman was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Flaherty. Joshua Pagan Application Denial Mr. Pagan was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Sandefer made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Chinchor. Jeffrey Patera Application Denial Mr. Patera was present and sworn in by the court reporter

9 MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application for licensure in an inactive status and require Mr. Patera to appear before the Board to activate the license and submitting a new personal credit report and new personal financial statement showing a positive networth. SECOND: Mr. Flaherty. MOTION: Mr. Flaherty made a motion to extend Mr. Patera s test scores. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. Robert Sherman Application Denial Mr. Sherman was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application. SECOND: Mr. Flahrty. Anthony Valero Application Denial Mr. Valero was present and sworn in by the court reporter. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to reverse the denial and approve the application contingent on an updated financial statement showing a positive personal net worth. SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. PROBATION REPORT MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to approve the Probation Reports for: Lambert Anglin Glennn Grant Dennis Guinn SECOND: Mr. McHaffie. Robert Smith Mark Uffelman LEGISLATIVE REPORT Mr. Flaherty informed the Board that the bill related to requiring journeymen is back before the legislature this session. RULES REPORT - 9 -

10 Ms. Loucks presented the rules report, she informed the Board that Rule 61G is pending completion of the Statement of Estimated Regulatory Costs. 61G Fees The following fees are prescribed by the Board: (1) No change (2) The initial application fee for licensure by endorsement as a certified unlimited electrical, alarm system or specialty contractor by endorsement or certification of a registered contractor shall be two hundred dollars ($200.00). (3) through (8) No change (9) Delinquent Fee. If licensee becomes delinquent, an applicant must elect for active or inactive status, and a fifty dollar ($50.00) delinquent fee will be charged. (10) through (13) No change (14) The initial application fee for licensure by second entity as certified unlimited electrical contractor or alarm system contractor shall be two hundred fifty dollars ($250.00). (15) Pursuant to Section , F.S., in addition to all other fees collected from each licensee, there shall be a five dollar ($5.00) fee collected at the request of the Department, both upon initial licensure and license renewal for the purpose of combatting unlicensed activity. (16) No change. Rulemaking Authority (2), (1), (3), FS. Law Implemented (2), (1), , (8), , (2) FS. History New , Amended , , , , , , Formerly 21GG-8.01, Amended , , , , , , , Formerly 21GG-8.001, Amended , , , , , , , , , , , ,. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion to notice Rule 61G re: Public Comment for development and approved the language presented with a time frame of 5 minutes. SECOND: Mr. Smith. 61G Public Comment. The Electrical Contractors' Licensing Board invites and encourages all members of the public to provide comment on matters or propositions before the Board or a committee of the Board. The opportunity to provide comment shall be subject to the following: (1) Members of the public will be given an opportunity to provide comment on subject matters before the Board after an agenda item is introduced at a properly noticed board meeting. (2) Members of the public shall be limited five(5)_minutes to provide comment. This time shall not include time spent by the presenter responding to questions posed by Board members, staff or board counsel. The chair of the Board may extend the time to provide comment if time permits. (3) A member of the public shall notify board staff in writing of his or her interest to be heard on a proposition or matter before the Board. The notification shall identify the person or entity,

11 indicate the person or entity's support, opposition, or neutrality, and identify who will speak on behalf of a group or faction of persons consisting of five(5) or more persons. If the person or entity appearing before the Board does not wish to be identified, a pseudonym may be used. Rulemaking Authority: , FS Law Implemented: , FS History-New. MOTION: Mr. Chinchor made a motion there was no adverse financial impact in excess of $200,000 and no Statement of Estimated Regulatory Costs was required. SECOND: Hoffmann FINANCIAL BUDGET LIAISON REPORT David Botknecht Mr. Biggins provided the financial report to the Board for their review. UNLICENSED ACTIVITY (ULA) REPORT Thomas McHaffie & David Botknecht No report. EXAMINATION REPORT Kenneth Hoffmann Alex Bosque and Fanny Fuentes appeared before the Board to discuss the exam. Mr. Bosque advised the Board that consultants in Tallahassee assist with review of the examination. Ms. Fuentes discussed the issue of which version of the National Electrical Code should be used as a reference for the exam. The Board asked that the exam be updated to the most current version of the NEC rather than waiting for the Florida Building Code to be updated. ENDORSEMENT REPORT No changes. RATIFICATION OF APPLICATIONS The lists will be attached to the minutes and are hereby incorporated by reference. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to reconsider the application of Terry Moore. SECOND: Mr. Thomas. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to allow the requested continuance of Terry Moore s application. SECOND: Mr. Thomas. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to ratify the Continuing Education Committee and Initial Application Review results. SECOND: Mr. Thomas. APPROVAL OF MINUTES

12 None. OLD BUSINESS/ NEW BUSINESS Mr. Chinchor stated for the record that the 2 week deadline for applications to be complete and in the Board Office to make the agenda stands and he does not plan to make any exceptions. The Board agreed to move some of its business to Wednesday s starting at 1:00 pm in order to reduce the workload on Thursdays. The Board asked Mr. Biggins to determine what would be best on the Wednesday agenda. The Board discussed the issue of certified licensees and grandfather applicants applying to qualify municipalities and what documentation would be required on the municipality. No final determination was reached,. PROSECUTING ATTORNEY S REPORT Erica White, Esq., Assistant General Counsel Mr. Campbell directed the Board s attention to the details of the report which was distributed to the members. The report included case information as of November, BOARD COUNSEL S REPORT Deborah Loucks, Esq., Assistant Attorney General Ms. Loucks stated she would provide the Sunshine Law Training at the January meeting. PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL PUBLIC CASES Blando, Don Case ER Mr. Blando was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to dismiss the administrative complaint with no further action. SECOND: Mr. Bramlett. Motion passed unanimously Brydebell, Richard Case EC Mr. Brydebell was not present nor represented by counsel. MOTION: Mr. Bramlett made a motion to dismiss the administrative complaint with no further action. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. Motion passed unanimously Goya, Freddy Case

13 EC Pulled from agenda. Neel, Nicholas Case ES MOTION: Mr. Bramlett made a motion to dismiss the administrative complaint and incorporate the stipulation in the closing order. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. Motion passed unanimously Taylor, Bobby Case ES Fred Dudley, Esq was present on behalf of the respondent. MOTION: Mr. Hoffmann made a motion to continue with the case. SECOND: Mr. Hoffmann. EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR S REPORT Daniel Biggins Mr. Biggins directed the Board s attention to the enforcement report and the proposed meeting dates which were provided for their information. CHAIRPERSON S COMMENTS Timothy Chinchor Adjournment

14 Continuing Education Agenda November 21, 2013 (Panama City) A. AEMC Instruments (EC ) 1. App# UNDERSTANDING GROUND RESISTANCE TESTING... * B. American Electrical Institute (EC ) 2. App# NEC CODE CHANGE PART 1 (HOME STUDY/CORRESPONDENCE)... * 3. App# NEC CODE CHANGE PART 1 (ONLINE)... * 4. App# NEC CODE CHANGE PART 2 (ONLINE)... * 5. App# WORKERS' COMPENSATION (ONLINE)... * 6. App# FLORIDA STATUTES (ONLINE)... * 7. App# OSHA LADDERS AND STAIRWAY SAFETY... * 8. App# ADVANCED PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEMS... * C. American Trainco (EC ) 9. App# NATIONAL ELECTRICAL CODE... * D. Building Officials & Inspectors Educational Association (EC ) 10. App# BUSINESS PRACTICES FOR FL CONSTRUCTION PROFESSIONALS... * 11. App# WORKERS COMPENSATION... * 12. App# OSHA REQUIREMENTS FOR WORK PLACE SAFETY... * 13. App# SIGNIFICANT CHANGES TO NFPA 70- CHAPS * 14. App# NFPA 70 - CHAPTER 5... * E. College of Business & Technology (EC ) 15. App# FIRE ALARM SYSTEM AGENT TRAINING... * F. Florida Alarm School LLC (EC ) 16. App# BURGLAR ALARM SYSTEM AGENT ONLINE... * 1

15 17. App# FIRE ALARM SYSTEM AGENT ONLINE COURSE... * G. Florida Consortium of Community Colleges (EC ) 18. App# CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS & AGREEMENTS... * 19. App# INTRODUCTION TO CHAPTER * H. Gray Systems Inc (EC ) 20. App# HR COMPLIANCE CE COURSE FOR THE ECLB CONTRACTOR... * I. Jade Learning (EC ) 21. App# CONDUCTOR AMPACITY & CALCULATIONS (ONLINE)... * 22. App# DWELLING FEEDER BOX FILL & MOTOR CALCULATIONS-ONLINE... * J. Koning Enterprises, Inc D/B/A Contractors Institute (EC ) 23. App# INTERNET BASICS FOR CONTRACTORS (ONLINE)... for 1 hour * 24. App# DIGITAL PROJECT DOCUMENTATION (ONLINE)... Denied only 40 minutes* K. Lewellyn Technology LLC (EC ) 25. App# ELECTRICAL SAFE WORK PRACTICES contingent on revised timetable L. National Technology Transfer, Inc. (EC ) 26. App# NATIONAL ELECTRICAL CODE... * 27. App# NEC WITH GROUNDING & BONDING... * M. National Training School (EC ) 28. App# CERTIFIED ALARM TECHNICIAN LEVEL I (ONLINE) (BASA)... Denied no verification of student id* 29. App# CERTIFIED ALARM TECHNICIAN LEVEL I (ONLINE) (FASA)... Denied no verification of student id* 30. App# CERTIFIED ALARM TECHNICIAN LEVEL I (ONLINE)... * 31. App# A CONTEMPORARY APPROACH TO PROJECT MANAGEMENT-PART 1... contingent on revised timetable * 32. App# NEW BUSINESS PROSPECT/PIPELINE MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES... contingent on revised timetable 33. App# STRATEGIES FOR BUILDING & MANAGING HIGH PERFORMING SALES TEAMS... contingent on revised timetable * 2

16 34. App# MAXIMIZING THE VALUE OF YOUR ALARM BUSINESS... contingent on revised timetable * 35. App# CREATION OF THE ONE PAGE STRATEGIC PLAN... contingent on revised timetable * 36. App# RESIDENTIAL CYBER SECURITY-A GROWTH OPPORTUNITY?... contingent on revised timetable * 37. App# MAKING THE RIGHT PRODUCT & SOLUTION DECISIONS FOR YOUR BUSINESS... contingent on revised timetable * 38. App# THE DAILY HUDDLE-A KEY COMPONENT IN MASTERIN THE ROCKEFELLER HABITS... contingent on revised timetable * 39. App# THE ABCS OF DRIVING RMR THROUGH A VSAAS MODEL-ITS EASIER THAN YOU THINK! contingent on revised timetable 40. App# CREATING A CHANGE MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR YOUR TEAM... contingent on revised timetable * 41. App# ADAPTING YOUR TEAM FOR GROWTH IN CHANGING TIMES... contingent on revised timetable * 42. App# BUSINESS STREET SMARTS-HOW SALES INTELLIGENCE CAN TRANSFORM... contingent on revised timetable * 43. App# A CONTEMPORARY APPROACH TO PROJECT MANAGEMENT-PART 2... contingent on revised timetable * 44. App# NAT'L SECURITY SINCE 9/11-A PERSONAL PERSPECTIVE... contingent on revised timetable * N. PacePDH.Com D/B/A of The Media Factory (EC ) 45. App# ANALYSIS OF CHANGES 2014 NEC-PART I... * 46. App# ANALYSIS OF CHANGES 2014 NEC-PART II... ** O. Redvector.Com, Inc. (EC ) 47. App# BASIC REPORTING WRITING... ** 48. App# RESIDENTIAL SOLAR POWER SYSTEMS WEBCAST (ONLINE)... ** P. Steven J. Owen Electrical Consultant dba National Code Seminars (EC ) 49. App# INTRODUCTION TO THE 2011 NEC... * RB/BF ok to revise 2 AAF courses to have 2 hours false alarm 3

17 Applicant 's Name Profess ion Code AGUILA, MANUEL A JR 0801 BROWN, Richard BERMUDEZ, DANA 0801 BINDSCHADLER, DAVID E 0801 BOCAS, ERROL 0801 Reason for Board Review SEE ENF PUBLIC CASE STATUS 50 DATED 08/08/2013 AND YES ANSWER TO QUESTION #1 BACKGROUND QUESTIONS. CRIMINAL CHARGE NOT ON LIST. Type of Application Present Notes grandfathering Not Present Present TC/KH - Denied criminal history still on probation related to practice and financial responsibility - unan KH/BF - contingent on passing EC technical exam before 11/1/2015 and we accept ES business exam -KH/BF - waived $200 exam application fee only to pay $ exam fee VR DOES NOT REFLECT 5 YRS EXPERIENCE & YES ANSWER TO BACKGROUND QUESTION #1 grandfathering Present PS/TC - Unan ISSUES ON PERSONAL CREDIT REPORT W/LETTER OF EXPLANATION grandfathering Present TM/BF in favor/1 opposed RB COLLECTION ITEM ON CREDIT REPORT OVER $500.00; EXPLANATION & DOCUMENTATION PROVIDED YES ANSWER TO BACKGROUND QUESTIONS 1, 2 & 4 AND PERSONAL/ BUSINESS CREDIT ITEMS grandfathering Not Present Not Present TC/TM - - unan DITARANTO, GERALD MART 0801 grandfathering KH/TM - - unan (TC - recused) YES ANSWER TO QUESTION 2 ON BACKGROUND AND PERSONAL CREDIT REPORT ISSUES 7 COLLECTION AND 1 FORECLOSURE; WILL SUBMIT EXPLANATION AND PROOF OF STATUS AT BOARD MEETING. ALSO QUALIFYING DIXON, DONALD 0801 ADDITIONAL BUSINESS ENTITY. grandfathering Continued Continued FIORINI, JUSTIN M 0801 YES ANSWER TO QUESTION 1 grandfathering Present TC/KH - - unan MALO, GREGORY GEORGE 0801 Nov-13 YES ANSWER TO QUESTION 2 ON BACKGROUND grandfathering Present TC/BS - - Unan

18 MARKOWITZ, ISRAEL 0804 MATHES, KEVIN L 0801 MCGROTTY, DAVID M 0801 MOSS, KEITH L 0801 OSSORIO, ALEXANDER 0804 PIANESI, DAVID 0801 SAGESSE, JEAN 0801 WEATHERBY, DAVID EARL 0801 ZUNIGA, LAZARO 0801 GILES, LORENZO AMADEUS 0808 O CULL, ALAN D 0801 FREDERICK, JEROME P 0802 HODGES, PERRY JOE 0801 GARCIA, JORGE MOORE, TERRY PARASCO, JAMES YES ANSWER TO QUESTION 2 ON BACKGROUND grandfathering Not Present KH/TM - Denied personal financial statement not accurate per CR - lack of financial responsibility - unan CAN'T DETERMINE 5 YRS EXPERIENCE grandfathering Present Requested Withdrawl - BF/RB - Grant Withdrawl APPLICANT DOES NOT HAVE 5 ACTIVE YRS grandfathering BF/TM - denied lacks 5 years active BF - KH - DeniedFailure to demonstrate financial DEFAULT ON LOAN; SEE LETTER responsibility - personal FS does not list mortgage of FROM ATTY grandfathering $136,000, collections and judgment ET LICENSE INACTIVE STATUS; CAN LICENSEE QUALIFY USING BC LIMITED LICENSE grandfathering BF/KH - approved - unan HAS COLLECTION ON CREDIT Request Withdrawal - KH/TM - grant withdrawl - REPORT grandfathering Present unan HAS COLLECTION ON CREDIT KH/BS contingent on proof of $10,000 cash REPORT AND FORECLOSURE grandfathering Present in bank within 30 days - Unan Present YES ANSWER TO BACKGROUND QUESTION PERSONAL #1 CREDIT REPORT grandfathering w/atty Tim Atkinson KH/BS 8 in favor - 1 opposed TC REFLECTS COLLECTION ITEMS RB/BS - Denied failure to demonstrate financial (MULTIPLE & GREATER THAN grandfathering Present responsibility SEE ENF STATUS 20 UNDER INVESTIGATION INITIAL Present RB/BF - - Unan YES ANSWER TO QUESTION 2 ON BACKGROUND reactivation Present Present with atty BUSINESS FINANCIAL STATEMENT Tim <$10,000 reactivation Atkinson YES ANSWER TO QUESTION #2 FOR TAX LIEN(S) Transfer Present with Mr. DiBenned etto RB - recused Waived 90 days, suggesting he get $10,000 cash in bank and clear up judgment show satisfaction, BF/JC - Continuance - Unan BF/ RB - with 5 years probation with annual report of financial statement and bond renewal $50,000 PS/BS - - Unan Pulled RB/BF - denied failure to demonstrate financial resp. (1 opposed TM) BS/TM - denied failure to demonstrate financial responsibility.

19 Dyer, Robert Draga, Artur Not Present RB/BF - - Unan KH/BF -

20 Last Name First Name Profession Code Initial or EndorsemeCommittee Comments contingent on passing Florida Examination Tech & Business within 6 Armstong Nicholas Chinchor months - $ exam fee only Present BOLING TIMOTHY J 0801 ENDORSEMENT Chinchor CAYMARES JOSE L 0801 INITIAL Chinchor Present COTNER ROBERT 0801 INITIAL Chinchor Present DELARIONDA CHAD 0801 INITIAL Chinchor Present GABEL DAVID A 801 INITIAL Chinchor Withdrawn Present GARCIA DIONISIO 0801 INITIAL Chinchor GILKEY JOHN R 0801 INITIAL Chinchor GREENUP RAFAEL E 0801 INITIAL Chinchor HINSON TIMOTHY R 0801 INITIAL Chinchor Rymal Philip Chinchor Present TRUNDY CHRISTOPHER N 0801 ENDORSEMENT Chinchor WILBERT THOMAS 0801 ENDORSEMENT Chinchor WILKINS DAVID F 0801 ENDORSEMENT Chinchor

21 Last Name First Name Profession Code Initial or EndorsemeCommittee Comments HUSTY DANIEL 0801 INITIAL Sandefer JORDAN MATTHEW W 0801 INITIAL Sandefer Present JOYCE PATRICK J 0801 INITIAL Sandefer LAUDERDALE WILLIAM R 0801 INITIAL Sandefer BF/PS Denied - Financial responsibility - Personal net worth appears to be negative - values are inflated not current values, business assets itemization appear inflated - business accounts recivable need explanation LLOYD WILLIAM H 0801 INITIAL Sandefer LOERZEL JEFFREY P 0801 INITIAL Sandefer LUKER CHAD F 0801 ENDORSEMENT Sandefer MACHUAT PEDRO 0801 INITIAL Sandefer Denied - lack of experience W2's do not demonstrate fuull time income Denied - lack of work experience, details not MACKAY WILLIAM T 0801 INITIAL MARTIN MARCELO G 0801 INITIAL MAXSON RICHARD C 0801 ENDORSEMENT PEREZ ROLANDO M 0801 INITIAL-INACTIVE PETREE KENNETH W 0801 ENDORSEMENT PRITCHETT RAYMOND 0801 INITIAL Sandefer Sandefer Sandefer Sandefer Sandefer Sandefer sufficent Denied - Unlicensed Activity, lack of experience in the trade Denied - did not take similar exam (C-10 waiver per California) experience is not sufficient - questioned expereince with business info is accurate Denied - experience not acceptable - paid on 1099

22 Last Name First Name BRISTOLL MATTHEW 0802 INITIAL COX DONALD R 0802 INITIAL MORENO RENE R 0802 INITIAL NIXON JOHN 0802 INITIAL Profession Code Initial or EndorsemeCommittee Comments Hoffmann & Thomas Hoffmann & Thomas Waived 90 days - requested continuance, officer answers, and clear smaller items off CR report Denied - finacials do not match business name, fire alarm work not verified by anyone else Denied - employment verification form from Thomas Brand is incrrect no alarm work indicated Present Hoffmann & Thomas Hoffmann & Thomas Present POLIGNAN MIGUEL L 0802 INITIAL WILLIAMS ANDREW 0802 INITIAL Hoffmann & Thomas Hoffmann & Thomas Denied - Vehicles not depreciated - makes personal networth negative, business financial does not breakout the subsidiary unclear if business is a seprate compnay

23 Last Name First Name Profession Code Initial or EndorsemeCommittee Comments CHRISTOPHER Smith & AMODEO M 0804 INITIAL McHaffie Present CARMICHAEL KEVIN STUART 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie Present DISALVATORE ANTONIO J JR 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie Denied - failure to demonstrate experience in the trade DUNN BEN S 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie Present FULMER DANIEL E II 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie Present HOFF GERALD K 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie JONES TAYLOR P 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie KIRKMAN JEFFREY 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie Present MANEV ERIC B 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie STEWART EZEKIEL D 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie MULERO STEVEN 0804 INITIAL Smith & McHaffie Present Alarcon Percy 0801 Initial Bramlett, Cannava RB/BF/JC -Denied failure to demonstrate financial responsibility, lack of networth Present

24 Last Name FIRST NAME Business Present Notes ALTVATER PATRICK MEP ELECTRIC INC Not Present with condition he attend discipline within 6 months TC/BS - unan ANDERSON DENNIS DWANE HERON PEST CONTROL INC dba HERON LAWN AND PEST CONTROL Present Did not have comp cards for Seminole, Osceola or Polk. Deny - BF/RB Deny for Failure to demonstrate ability to supervise and financial responsibility - Unan BEHLMER JAMES K BEHL ELECTRIC LLC Present PS/RB - - Unan CACHERE RAYMOND EXP SERVICES INC Not Present Continued - waived 90 days DIMENNO JERROLD R VORTEX SECURITY SOLUTIONS LLC DBA VORTEX 1 SECURITY Present KH/BS - approved - unan DIXON DONALD QUALITY ELECTRICAL SERVICE OF SO FLORIDA, INC. Not Present BF/KH - Continued - Unan DOWDY OREN K LAPORTE INVESTMENT HOLDINGS, INC. dba SIGN EFFEX Present TM/RB - - Unan DOYLE JAMES LIGHTSCAPE LANDSCAPE LIGHTING, INC Present TM - Recused KH/RB - - Unan EHRENKRANTZ LEE LOUD SECURITY SYSTEMS INC. Present KH/TC - approved - Unan FLORES JOSE TECHADDICT, INC Present TM/PS HERZEK JOHN DELL RESPONSELINK, LLC Present KH/TM in favor, 1 oppssed BF HIMES CHARLES A A&H SYSTEMS, INC. Present TC/PS - - Unan JOHNSON JAMES BRIANQ SOUND INSIGHTS, INC. Not Present Denied - Failure to Demonstrate ability to supervise JOHNSON ADAM D HYPOWER, INC. Present TC/RB - - Unan MERZACCO MICHAEL L A1 QUALITY CONTROLS INC Not Present KH/NT Continued - Unan MINCEY JOHNNY M ALARM FUNDING ASSOCIATES, LLC Present with Pierre Bellemare PS/RB - - Unan NIETO ANTONIO M5 CONSTRUCTION & MANAGEMENT, INC. Present BF/BS - approved - Unan Palivoda DANIEL Secure Technologies Integration, Inc Not Present KH/RB - Continued DUNCAN SEAWALL, DOCK AND BOAT LIFT,LLC PALMER LEE DARRELL Present TM/RB - - Unan Sasson Issac POGO SECURITY, LLC Present PS/RB - approved - Unan VERDECIA ANTHONY JULIUS MATRIX COMMUNICATION SERVICES, INC. PULLED PULLED WEISBERG PETER HYPOWER, INC. Present PS/RB - approved - unan WIXSON DOUGLAS Showtime Audio & Video, Inc. Present BF/RB - - Unan WONG ORESTES MASTER INVESTIGATION & SECURITY, INC. Present KH/RB - - Unan