PAK: Punjab Irrigation Agriculture Investment Project New Khanki Barrage Project Loan 2841

Transcription

1 Social Monitoring Report March 2016 PAK: Punjab Irrigation Agriculture Investment Project New Khanki Barrage Project Loan 2841 Prepared by the Project Management Office (PMO) for Punjab Barrages, Irrigation Department, Punjab for the Asian Development Bank (ADB). The social monitoring report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB s Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

2 GOVERNMENT OF THE PUNJAB IRRIGATION DEPARTMENT New Khanki Barrage Project (NKBP) ADB Loan No PAK (LCC Lead Channel Component) For Quarter January- March 2016 PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE (PMO) FOR PUNJAB BARRAGES IRRIGATION DEPARTMENT CANAL BANK MUSTAFABAD, Lahore.

3 New Khanki Barrage Project (NKBP) for the Quarter January -March LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT PLAN (LARP) The project is category B for i volu tary resettle e t a d category C for i dige ous people. Draft Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP) for New Khanki Barrage was prepared and submitted to ADB for approval. ADB cleared the draft LARP on July 07, LARP was revised/ updated and cleared by ADB in Feb Land Acquisition is in progress according to requirement of Land Acquisition Act A total of 8.6 acres of land was required for construction of Head Regulator and Head Reach of the new LCC. Section 4 and section 5 of Land Acquisition Act for 8.6 acres of land were notified and published in the Punjab Gazette on August 07, 2012 and January 21, 2013 respectively. Land price was assessed, and the EA released the total amount Rs million to the Revenue Department, Government of the Punjab. However, due to change in engineering design, it was found that only 4.58 acres out of 8.6 acres of land was required along with a new piece of land 1 acre, 6 kanal, 3 marlas, and 4.5 Sarsai. Due to this change, process of land acquisition was re-initiated. The section 4 & 5 of land Acquisition Act 1894 for additional land was notified and published in the Punjab Gazette on July 11, 2014 and July 29, 2015 respectively. Again due to change in engineering design of LCC Lead Channel, the procedure for acquiring 5 kanal, 10 Marla of private land from one landowner (Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema) is still in process. Compensation rates have been re-calculated to reflect current values and procedures. The landowner has received full payment for crop losses, trees and structures. The five affected families which are residing at the Dera of landowner, now they are shifted in their new accommodation built by the landowner on his remaining land. Their livelihoods remain unaffected. These households have received their relocation allowance (Pak Rupees 5,000/household) and cash assistance for vulnerable households (Pak Rupees72, 000/- household). Alternative accommodation for the 15 no. of the affected families of Irrigation staff is also being constructed and out of 15 No. AFs, 13 are shifted in new buildings. Funds for the remaining compensation activities are available. All compensation payment of acres land and relocation of the 02 affected households will be completed by June LARP implementation activities for Tranche-2 relates to LCC Lead Channel (Component) of New Khanki Barrage Project. Internal Resettlement Monitoring of all relevant activities is the responsibility of PMO (Environment and Social Unit (ESU). Internal Monitoring Reports in the shape of QPR are being regularly submitted to the Bank. PMO has selected an

4 independent resettlement monitor (IM) to cover all tranches of the MFF. He has signed the contract agreement with PMO and PMO has sent to the ADB for approval which is still awaited. The IM will be mobilized by May 2016 and is expected to submit his first external resettlement monitoring report by July 01, ESU / PMO for Punjab Barrages is busy in Implementation of LARP since The Implementation Schedule of LARP is given below: Sr. No. Action Time Line Responsibility To date Status 1 Establishment of PMO - PID PMO is already in place at Lahore. 2 Setting-up the ESU. In place PMO ESU is already in place. 3 Setting-up the LIU at Khanki 30 June, 2012 PMO Notified 4 Establish Grievance Redress Cell. 30 Sep, 2012 PMO Notified. 5 Submission of draft LARP to ADB 30 June, 2012 PMO Submitted 6 Approval of LARP 15 June, 2012 ADB Cleared 7 Urdu translation and disclosure of LARP 05 July, 2012 PD/ ESU Also paste at website 8 Formation of DPs Consultation Committees (2 Nos.) 9 Deployment of Supervisory Consultants 30 Jun 2012 LIU Formed and notified. 30 Sep PMO Deployed 10 Deployment of Social & Environment 31 Dec 2012 PMO Deployed 11 Employment to DPs/ locals (age of economic group) June 2013 to March 2017 Contractor/ Consultants/PMO A list of willing and potential DPs/ locals is included in LARP. Also given to DESCON (Contractor) for action. 12 IMR submission before handing over Barrage site for construction 31 Oct, 2012 PMO Done 13 NTP for Barrage - ADB Done

5 14 Construction of Link LCC 30 Jun Contractor/ PMO To be completed up to 30 Jun, Land Acquisition 15 Section-4 Notification Dec LAC Due to new / revised drawing of LCC in September Section-5 Notification January-2016 LAC Section 5 is cleared form LAC and will be published before April 15, Land Acquisition Process through Private Negotiation Not Applicable 18 LARP Updation Oct Consultant LARP discussed with the ADB representatives on October 07, Payment to DPs (Partial Payment) July 2015 Land owner/ PMO 20 Relocation of Farming labourers Dec., 2015 Land owner/agri. Labourers PMO 100% payment has released to land owner, laborers are shifted in alternate location at nearby place. Farming laborers are shifted in newly constructed accommodation by the land owner. 21 Final payment to land owner after confirmation by IM that labourers have been relocated and paid as in LARP. May 2016 PMO Final payment of the land will be made before June, 2016 to the land owner after confirmation by the IM. 22 Possession/ Transfer of Land May 2016 LAC/ PMO Expected in the month of May, Relocation/ Construction of Staff Colony Dec PMO Thirteen quarters are completed and staff shifted while two quarters are under constructions. After construction remaining will be shifted. 24 Relocation/ shifting of PID staff Dec Residents/ PMO Thirteen shifted in new accommodations while two will be shifted

6 after completion of residences. 25 Construction of Community Lined Watercourses 26 Construction of Lined Public Watercourse 30 Jun 2016 Contractor/ PMO After completion of high level channel W/C will be lined and connected. 30 Jun 2016 Contractor/ PMO Construction will be completed before June, Construction of High Level Channel 30 June 2016 Contractor/ PMO - 28 Date of contract award (expected) 30 Sept., 2012 PMO - 29 Full Implementation of LARP Dec PMO - 30 IMR confirming LARP implementation Dec IM Specialist/ PMO - 31 Commencement of civil works Subject to ADB approval for NTP. 32 Redress of Community Complaints Continuous activity ADB GRC/ PMO Subject to ADB approval on the satisfactory implementation of LARP. Ongoing activity till project completion. Total amount under LARP is Rs Million. Out of which, Rs is payable to Project Affected Persons (PAPs) for their compensation and assistance. Rs Million has already been paid to the Revenue Department for land Acquisition. Rupees million have been paid to the 21 No. of affected families as compensation amount for their structures, crop compensation, Tubewell, hand pumps and trees. The vulnerability allowance & shifting allowance is also paid. The detail is given in Annex-A & A-I. 2. ADJUSTMENT MADE IN THE COMPENSATION RATE DURING UPDATING OF LARP The LARP of New Khanki Barrage was approved in Again, it was updated and approved in The adjustment was made in compensation rates of the land after certification by the Revenue Department, Government of Punjab. The rates are still applicable up till now. The adjustment made in the compensation is given in Annex-B.

7 3. EMPLOYMENT FOR THE AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS IN PROJECT RELATED JOBS Two types of affected families are residing at LCC Lead Channel. First are Irrigation Department Employees and they are already serving in Irrigation Department. Second are the land owner and his agriculture laborers, those are cultivating crops. They shifted in newly built houses. The Contractor is ready to accommodate the affected families for jobs as and when they demand. ESU, PMO Punjab Barrages requested to the Consultants to ask the Contractor to provide jobs under the project. As per recommendation of the Engineer, the Contractor trace each of the person included in the list, (The list of the potential persons of affected families requiring jobs under the project). The Contractor offered them an appropriate employment. Out of 16 affected persons, only 3 residents of Irrigation Colony were willing for jobs with the Contractor and the Contractor hired their services. The Contractor also offered jobs to the family members of employees of Irrigation Department of Khanki Division. Out of 26 applications, 20 family members of Irrigation staff were offered jobs and the Contractor hired their services under the Project. Regarding employment to the unskilled labor of the local area, the status of skilled and un-skilled labor employment for the month of January, February and March, 2016 is given in Annex-C, D & E, which is 62%, 61% and 62 % respectively. 4. RELOCATION OF AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS AND THEIR CURRENT LIVING CONDITION Total Twenty One (21) affected families (AFs) are to be dislocated from LCC Lead Channel Component of New Khanki Barrage Project. In first phase, land owner and his five (05) Agri-laborers are relocated and an amount of Pak Rupees 4.10 million has been paid to the six (06) no. of affected families as the compensation amount for their structure and other assets. During the quarter, the shifting allowance amounting to PKR.075 million has been paid to 15 No of irrigation staff. Crop compensation for acre (remaining land) and private trees (100%) paid to Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema vide cheque No dated Out of Fifteen (15) No. of affected families of Irrigation Department Employees 13 No. of families have been shifted to the newly constructed residences. The remaining 02 No. of families shall be shifted in the month of May, The owner of the land has built a new Dera along with the residences for the laborers. 05 No. of Agri. Laborers have been shifted in their new residences. Before and after comparison of residences shall be presented in next quarterly report.

8 Case No.1 Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema is the only land owner fall in category of affected household. His land, trees and residential structures were affected due to NKBP. A compensation payment of amounting Pak Rs million was paid for crops, tube well, hand pumps, trees (fruit and timber trees) and structures. Old status of land and structure can be viewed as under: The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report. Case No.2 Mr. Anwar is the farm laborer of Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema. He has been shifted to the new constructed house by the land owner. He has collected an amount of Rs. 77,000/- as compensation /poverty allowance and relocation allowance Mr. Anwar is standing in front of his house

9 Case No.3 Mr. Amanat Ali is the farm laborer of Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema. He has been shifted in the newly constructed house by the land owner. He has obtained an amount of Rs. 77,000/- as compensation /poverty allowance and relocation allowance. Case No.4 Mr. Manzoor Hussain is the farm laborer of the Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema. He built the residential structure at the land of land owner. He has been shifted in newly constructed house and he has obtained amount of Rs. 986,100/- as compensation for his structure, 1 No. hand pump, poverty allowance and relocation allowance.

10 Mr. Manzoor Hussainis standing near his dismantled house Case No.5 Mr. Anayat is the farm laborer of Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema. He has been shifted in the newly constructed house by the land owner. He has obtained an amount of Rs. 77,000/- as compensation /poverty allowance and relocation allowance.

11 Mr. Anayat is standing near his dismantled house Case No.6 Mr. Ramzan is the farm laborer of Mr. Farooq Akbar Cheema. He has been shifted to the newly constructed house by the land owner. He has obtained an amount of Rs. 77,000/- as compensation /poverty allowance and relocation allowance. Mr. Ramzanis standing near his dismantled house

12 Irrigation Employees Out of fifteen Irrigation Employees, 13 No. have been shifted to their new residences constructed under New Khanki Barrage Project. The remaining 2 No. of Irrigation employees shall be shifted to their new residences in the month of May Case No.7 Mr. Abdul Hameed (Guage Reader) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at RoW of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance. Case No. 7. Mr. Abdul Hameed (Guage Reader) with his family at current residence. Case No.8 Mr. Mansha (Beldar) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at RoW of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance.

13 Case No.9 Mr. Ghulam Abbas (Chowkidar) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at RoW of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance. Case No.10 Mr. Faisal Mehmood (NaibQasid) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at RoW of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance.

14 Case No.11 Mr. Akram (Regulation Beldar) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at Row of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance. Case No.12 Mr. Riaz (Boatman) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at RoW of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance.

15 Case No.13 Mr. Liaqat Ali (Regulation Beldar) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at RoW of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance. Case No.14 Mr. WalayatHussain (Head Boatman) is employee of the Irrigation Department and he was residing at RoW of LCC Lead Chanel of NKBP. He has been relocated to newly allotted building in Canal Colony Khanki and he has obtained Rs. 5,000/- as relocation / shifting allowance.

16 Case No.15 Mr. Shabbir is Irrigation Beldar and he is shifted in newly allotted building. He has

17 obtained relocation allowance of Rs. 5,000/-. Mr. Shabbir (Beldar) is standing in front of his old residence. The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report. Case No.16 Mr. Mushtaq (Beldar) is living in Government residence that needs to be relocated at the earliest. He will be relocated to new allotted building and he has obtained relocation allowance of Rs. 5,000/-.Mr. Mushtaq (Beldar) is standing in front of his old residence. The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report. Case No.17 Mr. Ashraf Masih (Sweeper) has been relocated to the new residence and he has obtained relocation allowance of Rs. 5,000/-. He is standing in front of his old residence. The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report.

18 Case No.18 Mr. Amanat Ali (Painter) has been shifted to newly constructed residence and he has obtained relocation allowance of Rs. 5,000/-.) He is standing in front of his old residence. The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report. Case No.19 Mr. SibtUl Hassan (Sub Engineer) has been shifted to the newly constructed residence and he has obtained relocation allowance of Rs. 5,000/-.) He is standing in front of his old residence. The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report.

19 Case No.20 Mr. Rana Ayub ((Sub Engineer)) is living in Govt. residence although his residence has been completed. Rana will be shifted to newly constructed house next month due to the examinations of his childrens.) RanaAyub is standing in front of his old residence. The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report. Case No.21 Mr. Shabir (Sub Engineer) has been shifted to newly constructed residence and he has obtained relocation allowance of Rs. 5,000/-.) Shabbir is standing in front of his old residence. The comparison of old and new structures will be presented in next quarterly report.

20 5. GRIEVENCE REDRESSAL MECHANISM Tranche-2 also has an operational Grievance Redressal Mechanism that covers all types of grievances of NKBP, including resettlement. Complaint register is also being maintained by the Consultants to record community concerns and their solutions. Out of 29 complaints, 25 complaints have been resolved while 4 complaints are yet to be resolved. The detail of complaints is given in Annex-F. 6. COMMUNITY WORKS A high school is constructed under the New Khanki Barrage Project. The construction work was started on February 10, 2014 and work was completed on September 15, Total cost of the project is Rs million. The school is handed over to the Education Department, Gujranwala. Basic Health Unit (BHU) is constructed under the New Khanki Barrage Project. The construction work was started on February 23, 2014 and work was completed on December 10, Total cost of the project is Rs million. The Basic Health Unit is handed over to the Health Department, Gujranwala.

21 Implementation of LARP for New Khanki Barrage as of March 2016 Sr. N o Contract No PAK LARP for LCC Lead Channel Component (under NKBP) Status of Preparatio n, vetting and approval of RP Draft LARP of LCC Lead Channel was prepared and approved in Later on LARP was revised, updated and cleared by ADB in Feb, 2014 No. of AF s Paymen t Due (PKR in millions) Contract No PAK Tota l AFs paid Amount Paid (PKR in millions) % Impleme ntation % Amount Paid Annex A Remarks % Cost of ,200,000 is amounting to Rs. 7,950,000 while PMO has deposited Rs (million) to the Revenue Department for further payment to the land owner. Whole the payment of land will be paid before June, 2016

22 Annex (A-I) New Khanki Barrage Construction Project (NKBP) Compensation and Allowances paid as of March 31, 2016 Sr. # Registration Name Residential Crop Coversation T/Well Hand Pump Relocation Assistance Trees Vulnerability Allowance Total 1 NKBP/LCC-1 FAROOQ AKBER CHEEMA 1,678, , ,000 20,000 5, ,600 2,805,824 2 NKBP/LCC-2 MUHAMMAD ANWER 5,000 72,000 77,000 3 NKBP/LCC-3 AMANAT ALI 5,000 72,000 77,000 4 NKBP/LCC-4 MANZOOR HUSSAIN 899,100 10,000 5,000 72, ,100 5 NKBP/LCC-5 ANAYAT MUHAMMAD 5,000 72,000 77,000 6 NKBP/LCC-6 M.RAMZAN 5,000 72,000 77,000 7 NKBP/LCC-7 SHABIR AHMED 5,000 5,000 8 NKBP/LCC-8 SIBTUL HASSAN CHEEMA 5,000 5,000 9 NKBP/LCC-9 MUHAMMAD MANSHA 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-10 LIAQAT ALI 5,000 5,000

23 Annex (A-I) New Khanki Barrage Construction Project (NKBP) Compensation and Allowances paid as of March 31, 2016 Sr. # Registration Name Residential Crop Coversation T/Well Hand Pump Relocation Assistance Trees Vulnerability Allowance Total 11 NKBP/LCC-11 MUHAMMAD AKRAM 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-12 MUHAMMAD SHABIR 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-13 MUSHTAQ AHMAD 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-14 MUHAMMAD WILLAYAT 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-15 MUHAMMAD RIAZ 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-16 MUHAMMAD AYUB 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-17 ABDUL HAMEED 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-18 GHULAM ABBAS 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-19 FAISAL MEHMOOD 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-20 AMANAT ALI 5,000 5, NKBP/LCC-21 ASHRAF MASEEH 5,000 5,000 4,174,924

24 Adjustment made in Compensation Rates in LARP July, 2014 Sr. No. Description Unit A) Mouza -Wise Acquisition of Private Land Unit Rate of LARP 2012 I) Khanki Acres 0.474(Rs.Million) Land Acquisition B) Compulsory Surcharge (15%) C) Crop Compensation Residential Structures D) Unit Rate of updated LARP (Rs. Million) Rabi Acres 32,236 42,000 Kharif Acres 54,373 82,000 Sq. ft. Rs.675/sqft Rs.675/sqft (Houses) - i) Pacca structure Sq. ft ii) Semi-Pacca structures - Sq. ft iii) Katcha/ thatched shed - Sq. ft. - - E) Others i) Cattle Yard Sq. ft. Rs.675/sqft Rs.675/sqft ii) Borehole of a tube well / F) drilling No / bore / bore iii) Hand pump No Cost of W/C 1 community,private Meters 1445/m 1445/m Fruit Trees Tree No Compensation Timber wood trees No G) Livelihood Assistance - - Livelihood assistance to - vulnerable families a) impassion cash assistance /allowance equivalent to 6 months OPL adjustment amount, i.e.(rs ) DFs b) Relocation assistance Rs. 5000/- to be paid all the DPs requiring to move out of the ROW or Land acquired for the Project DFs Annex - B Remarks The rates of 2012 were not applicable in 2014 so, after Consultation with Revenue and Agriculture Department, rate for land and crop compensation were updated, while rates for structures and, other i.e. Tree compensation and livelihood assistance are still applicable in Therefore, there is no much changes recognized for D, E, F and G up till now.

25 Annex-C 1- List of Potential Persons of Displaced Families (DFs) Requiring Jobs under the Project Sr. No Name Father's Name 1 2 Father's Designation Age (Years) Education Remarks Mr. Nadeem Abdul Hameed Gurge Reader 21 Middle Out of Country Mr. Sufian Mansha Baildar 21 Middle Out of Country 3 Mr. Akhtar Ali Mansha Baildar 21 Matric Out of Country 4 Mr. Paris Ali WalayatHussain Head Boat Man 24 Middle Not Willing 5 Mr. Rahat Ali WalayatHussain Head Boat Man 27 Middle Hired in year Ms. Rizwana (female) 7 Mr. WaseemAkram 8 Mr. HusnanAkram W/O Pans Ali Head Boat Man 26 Intermedia te Akram Baildar 28 Middle Akram Baildar 23 Middle Not Required Hired in year Hired in year Mr. AhsanUllah Liaqat Ali Baildar 24 Middle Out of Country 10 Mr. ShafkatMushtaq Mustaq Ahmad 11 Head Boat Man 21 Matric Not Willing Mr. MubasherSarfraz Malik Sarfraz Sub Engineer 22 M.Com Not Willing 2- Potential Persons available for Job from 5 Vulnerable DFs at DeraFarooq Akbar Cheema, Village Khanki Sr. No Name Father's Name 1 2 Mr. Mustafa Mr. Sarwar 3 Mr. Ali Raza 4 Mr. Ramzan MuanzoorHussa in Anayat Akram Anayat 5 Mr. GhulamMurtaza Amanat Ali Father's Designation Age (Years) Education Remarks Agricultural- Labourer 25 Illiterate Agricultural- Labourer 25 Illiterate Called for joining but not joined yet Called for joining but not joined yet Agricultural- Labourer 23 Illiterate Migrate Agricultural- Labourer 35 Illiterate Migrate Agricultural- Labourer 21 Illiterate Migrate

26 Application of employees sons of khanki division Irrigation Department for Employment in DESCON Annex-D Sr. No Name of Applicant Father's Name Father's Designation Post Applied For Remarks 1 WaseemAkram Akram Signaler Helper Hired 2 Salman Niaz Niaz Security Guard Safty Helper 3 Afzaal Riaz Boatman Helper Hired 4 Faisal Iqbal Ashraf Regulation Jamadar Helper Hired 5 Muqarrab Ali Ashraf Guage Reader Helper Hired 6 Rehan GhulamRabbani Oil Man Helper Hired 7 AtifRaza Abbas Baildar Helper Hired 8 Shah Nawaz ManzoorHussain Baildar Helper Hired 9 Zaman Ali Nasrullah Khan Regulation Baildar Helper Hired 10 ZubairHussain Anwar NaibQasid Helper Hired 11 Waqar Ali Late Aslam Regulation Baildar Helper Hired 12 Asim Inayat Regulation Baildar Messon 13 QasirShahzad ManzoorHussain Baildar Driver Hired

27 Sr. No Name of Applicant Father's Name Father's Designation Post Applied For Remarks 14 Saeed Anwar Anwar Junior Clerk Office Boy Hired 15 Rahat Ali WalayatHussain Head Boat Man Helper Hired 16 Umar Farooq Azam Regulation Baildar Helper Hired 17 AmjadFarooq ManzoorHussain Baildar Helper Hired 18 Shahzad Ali ManzoorHussain Baildar Helper Hired 19 Shawal Ali Liaqat Ali Regulation Baildar Generator Mechanic 20 KaleemUllah Irshad Ahmad Butt Boatman Office Boy 21 Bilal Younas Regulation Baildar Helper Hired 22 IrshadMasih Ashraf Masih Sweeper Sweeper 23 HusnainAkram Akram Regulation Baildar Safty helper Hired 24 Jazib Ali Irshad Ahmad Butt Boatman Survey Helper Hired 25 Javed Khan Bulock Man Helper Hired 26 Bilal Ahmad Fazal NaibQasid Helper

28 Annex - E New Khanki Barrage Project (NKBP) District Wise Skilled / Unskilled Labour for the Month of January 2016 Sr # Districts DESCON Sub Contractor TOTAL Total Skilled Unskilled Skilled Unskilled Skilled Unskilled Total Remarks 1 GUJRANWALA HAFIZABAD CHINIOT SHEIKHUPURA NANKANA FAISALABAD JHANG TOBA TEK SINGH Gujrat (Barrage Adjoining Villages Total %age 64.88% 60.93% 63.54% 45.89% 61.00% *62.00% 62% Other Districts Total Districts *62% unskilled labouris used during the month of January 2016 Three number of employees from affected families are working with the contractors

29 Annex - F New Khanki Barrage Project (NKBP) District Wise Skilled / Unskilled Labour for the Month of February 2016 Sr # Districts DESCON Sub Contractor TOTAL Total Skilled Unskilled Skilled Unskilled Skilled Unskilled Total Remarks 1 GUJRANWALA 2 HAFIZABAD 3 CHINIOT 4 SHEIKHUPURA 5 NANKANA 6 FAISALABAD 7 JHANG 8 9 TOBA TEK SINGH Gujrat (Barrage Adjoining Villages Total %age Other Districts Total Districts % 62.42% % % 58% *61.00% 57% Three number of employees from affected families are working with the contractors * 61.00% unskilled labour is used in the month of February, 2016.

30 Annex - G New Khanki Barrage Project (NKBP) District Wise Skilled / Unskilled Labour for the Month of March 2016 Sr # Districts DESCON Sub Contractor Total Unskill Skilled Unskilled Skilled ed Skilled TOTAL Unskilled Total Remarks 1 GUJRANWALA HAFIZABAD CHINIOT SHEIKHUPURA NANKANA FAISALABAD JHANG TOBA TEK SINGH Gujrat (Barrage Adjoining Villages Total %age 65.82% 66.37% 66.01% 52.94% 42.48% 64.00% 62.00% 63% Other Districts Total Districts % is used during the month of October 2015 Three number of employees from affected families are working with the contractors

31 Status of Settlement of Complaints Annex H Sr# Date Complainant Location Sort of Complain Status Lundpur Demand for Culverts at 1 10/2/14 Imtiaz Ahmed /complete Chanawan Road address 2 1/1/15 Zubair Ahmad BurjCheema 3 10/1/15 MansoorWarraich ThatthiBaloch 4 5/1/14 Khizar Hayat ThatthiBaloch 5 10/12/14 NaseemHussain ThatthiBaloch 6 15/12/14 Master Shafqat Ali Faqiranwali Demand for Culverts/ and /Chanawan Road Demand for Culverts134+71/Chanawan Road Demand for Culverts/115+70Chanawan Road Demand for Culverts/84+93/Chanawan Road Demand for Culverts/56+37/Chanawana Road 7 14/10/14 Farooq Akbar Cheema LCC 8 26/12/14 Dr. AzharIqbalCheema KotJaffar 9 1/12/14 Rana Khan BurjDhalla Increase the rate of land /LCC Small Bridge /Gunayanwala to KotJaffar Road Demand for Culverts/19+200/ Chanawan Road In Process 10 Repeated App Dr. AzharIqbalCheema KotJaffar No 8 Applicaton Repeated /4/15 GhulamSarwarCheema BurjCheema Demand for Culverts/Chanawan Road 12 21/05/15 Head Mistress Girls School Khanki Play Ground/ Khanki 13 16/5/15 GhulamRasool Ratowali /Jamil Town Cemented Ramp & Soling /LMB Road In Process 14 21/5/15 Farooq Akbar Cheema Kot Imam Bux Drainage of flood water/chanawan Road In Process

32 Status of Settlement of Complaints Annex H Sr# Date Complainant Location Sort of Complain Status 15 14/5/15 Umer Hayat BurjDhalla Demand for Culverts/Chanawan Road 16 8/6/15 Hafiz SaifUllahChatta KotRatta Speed Breaker/ Footpath /Chanawan Road In Process 17 9/6/15 AslamRandhawa KorRatta Outlet /Chanawan Road 18 8/6/15 Haji AmjadPervaizRandhawa KorRatta Repair the old bridge /Chanawan Road 19 7/6/15 PervaizIqbalBhatti KotRatta Repair the old bridge/chanawan Road 20 9/6/15 XEN Irrigation Khanki Boundary wall / Play Ground/Irrigation Colony 21 6/4/15 Master NasirMahmood KotRatta Change the location of culvert/chanawan Road 22 11/4/15 WaqasChatta Advocate Lundpur Court Case /Chanawan Road 23 9/7/15 SDO Headworks Khanki Breakage of High Level Channel 24 7/7/15 Umer Hayat BurjDhalla Hurdle on Chanawan Road 25 14/7/15 Farooq Akbar Cheema Khanki Drainage of Rain water from crops 26 22/7/15 Amanat Ali Khanki Standing Rain Water in Colony 27 28/7/15 SDO Headworks Khanki Breakage of High Level Channel 28 19/11/2015 Sibt-Ul-Hassan Khanki Boundary Wall of New Irrigation Colony 29 22/03/2016 HameedSalemi Khanki Leveling of Road at Khanki In Process Note : Out of 29 Complaints 24 are settled.