IN YOUR COMMUNITY: JOBS AUTOS REAL ESTATE RENTALS CLASSIFIEDS OBITUARIES FIND N SAVE PLACE AN AD LOCAL BUSINESSES. 5-day Satellite

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "IN YOUR COMMUNITY: JOBS AUTOS REAL ESTATE RENTALS CLASSIFIEDS OBITUARIES FIND N SAVE PLACE AN AD LOCAL BUSINESSES. 5-day Satellite"

Janice Jennings
6 years ago
Views:

Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com http://www.nj.com/hudson/voices/golden_gun_owners... (http://ads.nj.com/realmedia/ads/click_lx.ads/www.nj.com/hudson/voices /golden_gun_ownership_and_we_di.

jpg/687449334f3036304a77554141545a32) IN YOUR COMMUNITY: JOBS AUTOS REAL ESTATE RENTALS CLASSIFIEDS OBITUARIES FIND N SAVE PLACE AN AD LOCAL BUSINESSES Search 5-day Satellite N.J. NEWS LOCAL NEWS N.J. POLITICS SPORTS H.

1 Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com ( /golden_gun_ownership_and_we_di.html/l24/ /leaderboard/njonline /AVE05_NJ_RoS_Multi_02/AVE_Union_728x jpg/ f a a32) IN YOUR COMMUNITY: JOBS AUTOS REAL ESTATE RENTALS CLASSIFIEDS OBITUARIES FIND N SAVE PLACE AN AD LOCAL BUSINESSES Search 5-day Satellite N.J. NEWS LOCAL NEWS N.J. POLITICS SPORTS H.S. SPORTS ENTERTAINMENT All Newspapers Business Education Forums Lottery National Opinion/NJ Voices Photos Videos World Sign in Join ( By Jersey Journal Guest Columnist ( on January 18, 2013 at 5:01 AM, updated January 18, 2013 at 5:04 AM Print ( /golden_gun_ownership_and_we_di.html) View full size ( d5c01850f.jpg) In this June 26, 2008 file photo, a chrome plated revolver rests on top of a glass display case at John Jovino Co. in New York. A New York county clerk on Thursday, Jan. 3, 2013 justified his refusal to release the names and addresses of handgun permit holders to a newspaper, saying it would give stalkers and thieves a convenient roadmap to target potential victims â and determine whether they have a gun. By CARL GOLDEN I began my career in the newspaper business in the mid-1950s on the daily paper in my hometown in Pennsylvania and, as the new kid in the newsroom, my assignments often required unearthing information that others wished to remain secret. I was instructed by my city editor to be vigilant in dealing with government officials and AP photo law enforcement, for instance, two groups he warned were more likely than most to be less than forthcoming with information that might prove embarrassing if brought to light in print. Sponsored By: /ads/click_lx.ads/ww /golden_gun_owne /L24/ /Se /MassageEnvy06_N / f ( / /golden_gun_owne /L24/ /Re /BayonneMC07_NJ /BMC_RADONC_re / f303630

2 Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com We were a newspaper, he said, and we had an obligation to print all relevant information and, if it resulted in embarrassment, then so be it. He drilled into me his conviction that the public's right to know was absolute and it was our responsibility to protect that right. As a result, I was threatened, screamed at and warned of dire consequences if I persisted in my quest for information others felt should remain unknown. Tensions between the news media and those with responsibility for determining what constitutes public information have existed since the invention of the printing press. The most recent and controversial illustration was the decision by The Journal News in White Plains, N.Y., to print 33,614 names and addresses of Westchester and Rockland counties residents who hold a gun permit. The reaction was swift and savage. Death threats were sent to the paper's publisher, editors and news staff, including the "we know where your children go to school" warning, a particularly disturbing threat given the massacre at Sandy Hook elementary school in Newtown, Conn., a few weeks earlier. Home addresses of reporters were posted on the Internet and some received s warning they'd be shot on their way to work. Armed guards were posted at the paper's office and assigned to individuals. Gun ownership information is public record, clearly spelled out in local regulations. Whether the paper had a right or obligation to print the names and addresses of the permit holders is problematic. Those identified argued their homes would be targeted by burglars and their families put at risk, although a would-be thief might be deterred by the knowledge that his intended victim was armed, a point made by gun rights advocates in opposing firearms control legislation. The controversy does, though, focus on the mountains of personal information available and where the invasion of privacy line should be drawn. Massive data banks didn't exist back when I spent hours ferreting out details that others wanted to remain uncovered. Today, a few moments at a keyboard can produce all manner of information once considered nobody's business. Armed with a name, inquiring minds can learn a person's home address, the amount of a mortgage on a home and who holds it, property taxes paid, employment history, place and date of birth, circumstances of divorce or criminal history (if any). Hudson Cou Se Jo ( /4505/gal Se H ( w /results SearchKey SearchReg SearchCate SearchDat A Po co ( w /voices/in /political_ Most Com m N.J. voters 557 measures, /politics/ind /politics /nj_voters_ /nj_voters_fa N.J. men s com 196 m ents) shorted on ( /business /nj_men_su /nj_m en_sue Cory Booke com 111m ents) Newark ho /essex/inde /essex /cory_book /cory_booker

3 Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com If the subject is a current or retired public employee, the salary is available along with any pension received. As someone who had a career in government, I accepted the public's right to know my compensation; the public, after all, paid it. The uproar over the release of gun permit holders is another indication of the passions that surround discussions of gun rights or efforts to limit them. It has always been a debate dominated by extreme elements, which, in turn, has crowded out efforts to reach common ground or develop sensible and reasonable steps to address gun violence and its causes. The paper's position smacks of a "we did it because we could" defense, ignoring the point that simply because some information IS public, should it be MADE public. At the same time, the reaction of gun owners -- thinly veiled threats against children, in particular -- will only serve to reinforce arguments that they are typical of rabid "gun nuts" consumed by a belief that their rights trump all else. The paper might have better served its readers by first publishing a story about the number of gun permits issued in the county, seeking input from law enforcement, academics, social scientists and others involved in the debate. The decision to publish the names and address should have been explained in detail, along with those arguments management felt persuaded it to proceed and publish. After all, informing readers their neighbor owns a gun isn't calculated to send him next door to borrow it like it's a new pair of electric hedge clippers. While the young reporter I was in the '50s was tasked with the often distasteful chore of tracking down embarrassing details about someone's personal life, today's media has become infinitely more intrusive and needs, perhaps, to step back and reassess its role in serving the public interest and its right to know. If that happens, something worthwhile may come from the uproar in Westchester County. EDITOR'S NOTE: Carl Golden is a senior contributing analyst with the William J. Hughes Center for Public Policy at the Richard Stockton College of New Jersey. You can reach him at cgolden1937@gmail.com. com m ents) N.J. Democ 84 monitors fo /politics/ind /politics /anticipatin /anticipating_ Jury award com 67 m ents) State Polic /2 /politics /jury_award /jury_aw ards See more com m ents) /jump/n /B ;sz=1 /golden_gun_own /L24/ /SaffarOrtho01_N /saffar_031912_b / f3036 /golden_gun_own /L24/ /B /HCIA03_NJLT_S FREEWebAds120 / f3036 Tweet 4 Like 1 0 Foursquare /golden_gun_own /L24/ /LibertyH05_NJLT /197502_LH_NJc / f3036 Add Your Com m ent

Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com http://www.nj.

com/sign %2Fwww.nj.com%2Fhudson%2Fvoices%2Findex.ssf%2F2013%2F01%2Fgolden_gun Type your comment here.

this story yet. (http://w w w.nj.com /new s /feds_disabled_students_m ust_ge.

4 Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com Sign in with your NJ.com or Facebook account ( %2Fwww.nj.com%2Fhudson%2Fvoices%2Findex.ssf%2F2013%2F01%2Fgolden_gun Type your comment here... POST Pause Live Updates» Sort By: Most Recent ( / /golden_gun_owne /L24/ /R /BayonneMC07_NJ /INTWOMHEALTH_ / f There are no on this story yet. ( w w.nj.com /new s /feds_disabled_students_m ust_ge.htm Feds:Disabled students m ust get chance to play sports. ( w w.nj.com /new s ( w w.nj.com /essex /2_young_children_found_safe_af.htm rpt-1#incart_hbx#incart_best-of)2 kids taken for a ride by carjacker ( w w.nj.com /essex ( /snow _w ill_arr rpt-1#incart_hb Snow to hit NJ a hom e ( w /new s/index.ss

Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com http://www.nj.com/hudson/voices/golden_gun_owners... /feds_disabled_students_m ust_ge.htm /2_young_children_found_safe_af.

5 Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com /feds_disabled_students_m ust_ge.htm /2_young_children_found_safe_af.htm rpt-1#incart_hbx#incart_best-of) /snow _w ill_arr rpt-1#incart_hb About Us About NJ.com /aboutus/) Advertise with us /advertise/) Contact Us /contactus/) More on NJ.com Jobs at NJ.com ( /careers/company /detail/id/134004) Newsletters ( /adv_nj/newsletters /nj/subscribe.htm) RSS feeds /rss/) Interact Search ( /interact/) Place an ad Weather /placead/) /weather/) Sell your car Blogs /placead/) /blogs/) Sell/rent your home Premium Blogs /placead/) /blogs/premium/) Post a job Site map /jobs/products /siteindex/) ) Claim your free Post a free business listing classified ad ( /registration /classifieds/free/) /default.aspx?_act=display& Apartments & _con=claim%20your%20listing.html& rentals mp=800101& ( bl=&src=categories) /for-rent) NJ.com Sections N.J. News Shore /news/) /shore/) Local News Obituaries /local/) /obituaries/) N.J. Politics Jobs /politics/) /jobs/) Sports Autos ( /sports/) Real Estate High School Sports ( ( Rentals Entertainment /entertainment/) Living /living/) Business /business/) Opinion /opinion/) Inside Jersey /inside-jersey) Contribute to NJ.com Become a blogger /contribute/forums/) /2010/03 Register for free /be_a_blogger_on_njcom_1.html) with NJ.com /////ProxyLink/NJONLINE/CLICK_NJ10 /SubTimesClick.html/) The Jersey Journal ( Subscribe /for-rent/) ( Classifieds /ads/click_lx.ads/ ( /////ProxyLink/NJONLINE/CLICK_NJ10 Shopping Good /SubJournalClick.html/) Deals South Jersey Times ( /southjerseytimes/) Subscribe Local Businesses /sjtsubscribe) ( Hunterdon County Democrat Special Sections ( /SS/Tiles2.aspx) Forums Submit your photos ( ( /photogallery Submit an event Newspaper stories and photos The Star-Ledger /starledger/) Subscribe ( /ads/click_lx.ads/ /////ProxyLink/NJONLINE/CLICK_NJ10 /SubLedgeClick.html/) The Times of Trenton /times/) Subscribe ( /ads/click_lx.ads/ /hunterdon-countydemocrat/) The Messenger-Gazette /messengergazette/) The Warren Reporter /warrenreporter/) Independent Press /independentpress/) Suburban News /suburbannews/) Cranford Chronicle /cranford/) Learn more about our newspapers /newspapers/)

Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com http://www.nj.com/hudson/voices/golden_gun_owners... /upload.html) Submit your videos /myevent/) (http://videos.nj.com /upload.

6 Golden: Gun ownership and 'we did it because we could' journalism NJ.com /upload.html) Submit your videos /myevent/) ( /upload.html) Follow Us Twitter ( /njdotcom) M obile Mobile site ( iphone, Android apps /mobile-device/) Tablet apps /mobiledevice/) Facebook ( Google+ ( /u/0/b/ / /posts) foursquare ( /njdotcom) ( Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement /useragreement/) and Privacy Policy /privacypolicy/) (Revised November 1, 2011) 2013 New Jersey On-Line LLC. All rights reserved (About Us /aboutus/)). The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of New Jersey On-Line LLC. Community Rules /forums?rules.html) apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Contact interactivity management. /contactus /interactivity.ssf) Ad Choices (

IN YOUR COMMUNITY: JOBS AUTOS REAL ESTATE RENTALS CLASSIFIEDS OBITUARIES FIND N SAVE PLACE AN AD LOCAL BUSINESSES. 5-day Satellite

http://blog.nj.com/njv_carl_golden/rivera_interest_in_senate_ad... 1 of 7 2/12/2013 12:42 PM IN YOUR COMMUNITY: JOBS AUTOS REAL ESTATE RENTALS CLASSIFIEDS OBITUARIES FIND N SAVE PLACE AN AD LOCAL BUSINESSES