2. Room introductions

Transcription

1 ASHRAE MEETING MINUTES New York, New York TC Particulate Contaminants/Removal Equipment Main Committee Meeting Tuesday, January 22, :30 6:00 p.m. (Sheraton Hotel, Liberty 1&2) 2008 ASHRAE. All rights reserved. This is a draft document intended for review only by the cognizant ASHRAE groups and other designated reviewers and is not for distribution to any private interests, individuals, or third parties that are not designated as ASHRAE reviewers for this document. This document may not be distributed in whole or in part in either paper or digital form without the express permission of the chair of the committee originating this document. The appearance of any technical data or editorial material in this draft document does not constitute endorsement, warranty, or guaranty by ASHRAE of any product, service, process, procedure, design, or the like, and ASHRAE expressly disclaims same. SCOPE: TC 2.4 is concerned with the nature of particulate contaminants, both solid and liquid; the measurement of their properties; their effects on living things and materials; both solid and liquid; the means of removing unwanted particulate contaminants from gases; and the evaluation of the effectiveness, energy usage, and the economy of such purification equipment. For both ordinary and extraordinary situations including hostile acts the TC is concerned with the effects of particulate contaminants on the quality of air supplied to and exhausted from enclosed spaces, and with the sources of particulate contaminant pollution within such spaces. The scope of TC 2.4 does not include purely physiological or toxicological aspects of particulate pollution All following votes recorded as for-against-abstain-absent-total 1. Call to order Robert Burkhead, Chair Introduction of guests and members. Particle Party Announcement by Marilyn Listvan (Old Castle Pub and Restaurant, 7:00pm) Chair comments: This will be a paperless meeting. Use TC web site to see minutes and other documents. A request has been made to allow Corresponding Members to have access to TC web site. Link to web site: tab to TC 2.4 minutes is along the top. 2. Room introductions 3. Roll call Jim Hanley Member Pres Abs Member Pres Abs Bob Burkhead X Brian Krafthefer X Phil Winters X Monroe Britt X Jim Hanley X Gemma Kerr X Chuck Schroeter X David Matier X Jeff Siegel X Peter Shipp X Don Thornburg X Al Veeck X Marilyn Listvan X Bob Whitt X Mark Renn X Erik Kuiper Int. X Paolo Tronville Int. X Total total attendance at meeting, 14 voting members (including 2 international member), 13 Corresponding members and 11 visitors/guests. We have a quorum.

2 4. Approval of Long Beach Minutes: Minutes were approved via prior to meeting with vote of: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) 5. Subcommittee Reports: 5a Membership Subcommittee Report.. Tom Justice Rolling off after summer meeting 6/30/2008: E.C. Schroeter, Don Thornburg, Brian Krafthefer, Alan Veeck, Robert Whitt Adding after summer meeting 6/30/2008: Charles Kern, Jim Kubokawa, Bruce McDonald, Tom Kuehn, Charles Seyffer, Eric Brodsky, Barney Burroughs. Motion to approve Membership Report by Bob Burkhead, seconded by Peter Shipp. Vote to approve: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) Chair recognized Mr. John Clark, ASHRAE Handbook Liaison and introduced him to Eric Brodsky, our new TC 2.4 Handbook Subcommittee chair. 5b Research Subcommittee Report Jeff Siegel Research Projects 1281-RP: Identification, Classification and Correlation of Ultrafine Indoor Airborne Particulate Matter with Outdoor Values: Final report now complete. ~180 page report. The researcher were able to do some speciation. Mass to charge ratio to breakout chemical composition I/O ratio for fine particles. Motion to accept final report by Al Veek, second by Jeff Siegel Vote to approve: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) Question on when report will be available? The report is essentially finished and in ASHRAE hands and on ASHRAE s schedule. Discussion on new (new for us) procedure for PMS meetings to be announced and open to all. Jeff intends to have technical details presented/discussed at PMS meetings and keeping the presentations at full TC meeting relatively short. Draft minutes of the research subcommittee meeting were distributed. Deadline for RTARS March 3 rd added. No conflict of interest rules for work statements If you work on the work statement you can still bid on it. RAC members will be on PMS Research Liaison: Iain Walker: prioritizing is internal to committee; not required. There doesn t need to be an official vote on it RP Particle Counter Specifications underway. Send information to Jim Hanley on problem examples. No PMS meeting in NYC RP Energy Implications of Filtration underway. Mark Renn summarized status and noted that there may be some surprising results. More expanded discussion will be presented at the June SLC meeting. PMS met at this meeting, project is well underway and on schedule. Contract ends April 30 th, RP Calibration Reference Device executive session Move discussion to end of meeting. See discussion at end.

3 Work Statements: Four Work Statements and RTARS are in process. Aiming for March 3 rd submission deadline if possible. Dave Pui gave presentation on nanoparticle filtration. Prioritization no vote needed #1 Neutralization broader than just 52.2 Bruce McDonald champion #2 filter loading dust Bob Burkhead champion; Don Thornburg to help. Motion to accept research subcommittee report made by Erik Kuiper, seconded by Don Thornburg. Vote passed cv (Marilyn was out of the room) (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent- Total-CV or CNV) RESEARCH SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES ARE ATTACHED. 5c Standards Subcommittee Report.Don Thornburg If you are a liaison (official or informal) to another committee or group and cannot attend standards subcommittee, please let Don know when you do have a report so he knows you have information for the main TC meeting. New public review system. All online. Not tested yet. Going live mid March. Comments come in instantly, not all at the end. Overall plan is to withdraw 52.1 after SLC meeting. Informational Appendix to 52.2 on conditioning was approved by SSPC 52.2 committee. Addendum to 52.2 on dust holding going forward. GPC 26 going out for public review. Goes fast track. March 2008 Public review. Electronic system. 45 day Public Review. The word Informational is to be added to the conditioning appendix in the sub committee minutes. Motion made by Don Thornburg, seconded Mark Renn to move cognisant committee responsibilities for 185.1P from TC 2.4 to TC 2.9 Vote to approve: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) USTAG changing from IEST to ASHRAE, in process. Next USTAG meeting will be in SLC. TC142: Next meeting is in Philadelphia, with Filtration CD has been approved as a DIS. Vote on approval as an FDIS will likely occur in summer Likely published in 2008 or early 2009, if approved. NAFA meeting April. 4 th edition of NAFA Guide to Air Filtration published. TC 9.6 (Health Care Facilities) wants documentation to justify HEPA use. Motion to approve Standards Report (with minor editorial changes), by Erik Kuiper and 2 nd by Marilyn Listvan. Vote to approve: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) STANDARDS SUBCOMMITTEE MINUTES ARE ATTACHED. 5d Program Subcommittee Report... Charlie Seyffer

4 Charlie: if info in late, TC loses #1 priority in next conference. Too harsh, letter to ASHRAE to change this to be to pull free admission for speaker. Charlie wants permission to write similar letter. Some discussion. Letter circulating to some TCs. Program is trying to solve an ongoing problem with this. So both sides. Al noted that we turned away 59 programs for this meeting. So an absence is felt hard. Committee to allow Charlie to address this and to work on letter: permission given by chair. Two items tomorrow morning 8am. Conflicting time slots. Soon to be computerized to avoid this type of problem. Two Transaction sessions for Chicago: One by Miller and Pui, one by Jeff Siegel. Reviewed program submissions from this meeting for SLC. We have low backlog of topics so new ideas are needed. Contact Charlie if you have ideas. Phil will add this to MBO (management by objective) Motion to approve the Program Subcommittee Report, by Phil Winters and 2 nd by Don Thornburg. Vote to approve: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) PROGRAM SUBCOMMITTEE MINUTES ARE ATTACHED 5e Webmaster Report.. Erik Kuiper Web site is up to date. modified membership. TC 2.4 minutes are posted there. NAFA graciously continuing to host the site. Further improvements coming soon. ASHRAE link is now working! Send Erik information from committee and subcommittees; Bob wants to put as much there as we can. 5f Handbook Subcommittee Report.. Eric Brodsky New chairman, Eric Brodsky Do on incremental basis, sections for CD. Then ready for handbook. Looking for input for handbook. Needs reviewers. If you are interested in participating, contact Eric Brodsky. Currently reviewing what needs updating Chapters 24 of Systems and Equipment needs extensive work to remove dust spot and add MERV Handbook central has been created. Don Thornburg volunteered to assist with handbook Need to add GPC 26 reference. Gemma and Marilyn also volunteer to assist. Motion to accept made by by Peter Shipp, 2 nd by Marilyn Listvan Vote to approve: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) 5g Publications Report.. Marilyn Listvan Biggest project is scanning IAQ proceedings. Nearing completion. IAQ Applications subscriptions have fallen off; publication may be cancelled due to low subscriptions sign up if interested. Also needs articles- please write one if you have an idea.

5 Insights send articles there too goes out to full ASHRAE membership good visibility. Monroe Britt wrote article for 52.1 insights. Advanced IAQ design guide - Barney Burroughs gave brief update part of series from special publications. Usually have high impact. Deals with moisture, mold control, filtration, etc. Likely published on web by end of Will be a very powerful document for setting Standard of Care. Will go out for peer review, but not public review. Motion to accept made by by Gemma Kerr, 2 nd by Jeff Siegel Vote to approve: cv (Yes-No-Abstain-Absent-Total-CV or CNV) PUBLICATIONS SUBCOMMITTEE REPORT ATTACHED. 6. Reports from other TC liaisons Section 2 Liaison Report - Chuck Wilcom: he helps things run smoothly, keep communications open. Roster update forms due tonight. Keep web site clean of personal information ( , phone etc) - agenda, minutes ok; suggests Action Items from minutes. Green Building research funds available. 1M research program. Pre-proposal Jan (see their web site) MBO list Vice Chair should spearhead vision forward where will TC be in 5 years. Vision of where committee is going. 7. Old Business none 8. New Business Al Veek: heads up how to not get turned down by program o Sustainability o Leed o Green o Net Zero carbon footprint, neutral o Follow program themes Phil Winters: 5 year plan. How to put this together. Subcomimtee chairs think about what to include in 5 year plan and do at their subc meetings. Barney: Nanoparticle needs to be in 5 year plan. Executive session 12 voting members remained to discuss a research (Jeff Siegel and Jim Hanley excused from the 14 attending voting membership also two PES committee members and Iain Walker). The PES for 1466 RP has met to select a contractor. (Chair taking minutes) The PES recommended conditional acceptance of one of the proposals. Al Veeck moved to accept the recommendation (seconded by Marilyn Listvan). Motion passed Adjournment at 6:00 Motion to adjourn Made by Gemma Kerr, seconded by Peter Shipp. Motion passed Respectively submitted

6 James T. Hanley TC 2.4 Secretary June 22, 2008

7 Attached TC 2.4 Subcommittee Reports/Minutes Subcommittee Membership Research Standards Program Handbook Publications Subcommittee Report Attached? No; an oral report given Yes Yes Yes No; an oral report given Yes

8 ASHRAE RESEARCH SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES - DRAFT NY, NY TC Particulate Contaminants/Removal Equipment Sunday January 20, :00-5:00 p.m. New York Hilton Petite Trianon I. Call to Order 3:05pm II. III. Introductions 33 signed-in attendees Review of Agenda Mark Renn, TC2.4 Research Subcommittee Vice-Chair, will take over meeting and report at main TC2.4 meeting on topics where Jeff Siegel is a bidder or contractor (i.e. V.c. & VI). IV. Announcements 3 Awards from RAC that would like more participation: New Investigator Award Beginning Career Homer Addams Award Student who is participating or has participated in ASHRAE research Graduate Student Grant-In-Aid Graduate Student Additional announcement from Research Subcommittee Chairs Breakfast: New deadline for WS/RTAR submission March 3 rd (existing My 15 th, August 15 th, December 15 th ) No conflict of interest rules anymore, but other checks/balances (need 3 qualified bidders on WS, 2 members of PES from RAC, etc.) Schedule rooms for PMS meetings (they are public) V. Current Projects (35 minutes) a RP Identification, Classification and Correlation of Ultrafine Indoor Airborne Particulate Matter with Outdoor Values Principal Investigator, Shelly L. Miller PMS Chair, Charlie Kern Final report now complete Wealth of data. Contract is complete, but data could benefit from further analysis. Requires TC2.4 vote approval to accept final report. PMS chair to notify MORTS. Form to notify MORTS that project is complete and Disposition of Research Form both need completion. b RP Particle Counter Specification for Use with Filter Performance Test Standard ANSI/ASHRAE 52.2 Principal Investigator, Jim Hanley PMS Chair, Erik Kuiper Project underway Looking for examples where two different OPCs give different results. c RP Energy Implications of Filtration in Residential and Light Commercial Applications Principal Investigator, Jeffrey Siegel

9 PMS Chair, Erik Kuiper Project underway VI. Project out for bid (1 minute, not much that can be said outside of executive session) a RP Development of a Calibration Reference for Use with Test Standard ANSI/ASHRAE PMS met and have a decision. Need TC 2.4 vote in executive session. Written note in MORTS box (PES chair). VII. Chronologically-gifted (i.e. old) Research Plans (20 minutes) Procedure: Jeff and champion polish and respond to existing RAC comments, submit to Iain Walker (RAC Liaison) for review, respond to comments, submit to TC 2.4 for review (address minor comments), TC 2.4 Vote, submit to RAC by March 3 rd, May 15 th, August 15 th, December 15 th. a (Priority 1) 1360-WS: How do filters change through their life: pressure drop, efficiency, weight gain and dust composition. Authored by KJ Choi Aim for March 3 rd deadline. b Priority 2 What are the factors that cause variation in 52.2? Championed by Monroe Britt Have RTAR, some discussion required. Aim for March 3 rd deadline c Priority 1 Effectiveness of filtration/ventilation on ultrafine particles. Championed by Charlie Kern Need RTAR. Aim for August 15 th deadline. d Priority 2 Shedding/reentrainment MOT, field results. Championed by Erik Kuiper and Bob Burkhead Have RTAR, some discussion required. Aim for March 3 rd deadline. VIII. Presentation by David Pui on nano-particle filtration (10 minutes) Presentation on interactions between nano-technology and filtration. IX. Prioritization of research ideas (30 minutes) What are the cost/benefits of filter test methods 5 Emissions from filters and influence of filter emissions on IAQ 2 Aerosol/particle neutralization and its impact on 52.2 (Priority 1) 16 Characterization of viable bioaerosols as they exist in indoor air and surrogates for testing 1 Particle size of biological agents 1 What is the impact of UV on particles and standard test method for determination of 2 suitable? Filter loading dust ASHRAE vs. ISO fine (Priority 2) 10 MOT microbiological particles 2

10 Effects of filters on coil loading 2 Field testing of high efficiency filters for ultrafine particles 8 Ultrafine particle transport in buildings 0 Comparison of 5 and 1 filters in residential market 2 Combining gas-phase and particle filtration 6 Evaluation of filtration for commercial cooking applications 4 Comparison between central and non-central air cleaning systems 0 Need TC 2.4 vote to accept prioritization for Need champions for both priorities. X. Group Work Statement/RTAR Writing (20 minutes) No time. XI. Other Business XII. Liaison Report (whenever Iain Walker arrives) XIII. Adjournment 5:10

11 ASHRAE STANDARDS SUBCOMMITTEE TC 2.4 Monday, January 21, 2008, 4:15 p.m. 6:00 p.m. Sheraton, Madison 4 (5 th fl) New York, NY Meeting convened at 4:15pm with 23 present. Sign in sheet attached (Attachment 1) 1) Update on standards within scope of TC 2.4: a) SPC 52.1 Gravimetric & Dust Spot M.o.T Air Cleaners Monroe Britt i) No meeting in NYC ii) With the finalization of Addendum B to 52.2 there was no need for a Public Review iii) It is expected that the paperwork to withdraw 52.1 will be submitted after SLC. b) SSPC 52.2 M.o.T. Air Cleaners for Particle Size Efficiency Jim Hanley i) Informational Appendix with KCl conditioning was approved for release. ii) Addendum B moving 52.1 into 52.2 Committee responses to the PR comments are completed and will be finalized to ASHRAE ASAP. c) SPC 180P Inspection & Maintenance of HVAC Systems Charlie Seyffer i) Draft sent to publication. d) GPC 17 Sampling of Airborne Particle Concentrations Erik Kuiper i) Did not plan to have a meeting. ii) Updating roster and will have a meeting at SLC. iii) Public Review draft after Chicago. e) GPC 26 In-Situ Test Method Don Thornburg i) Public Review draft was approved and has been given to ASHRAE for the March 2008 Public Review. 2) Official Liaisons: a) TC 2.3 Karin Foarde (Erik Kuiper) i) Research ongoing for investigation of by products from of photo catalytic oxidation b) TC 2.9 UV Air & Surface Treatment Karin Foarde (Derald Welles) i) TC 2.9 voted to take over as the cognizant committee for SPC 185P from TC 2.4. c) TC 5.4 Industrial Air Cleaners Bruce McDonald i) Research going on for pulse cleaner test method. About 1 yr away. ii) TPS for a pulse cleaner test method standard is underway for SLC. d) TC 9.3 Transportation Air Conditioning Paolo Tronville i) RTAR behavior of cabin air filters ii) General consensus to work on filters e) TC 9.5 Residential & Sm. Bldg. Applications Marilyn Listvan i) No report f) TC 9.6 Health Care Facilities Derald Welles i) Met last night and the hospital handbook has been approved to be written. Contact Rick Hermans for information. On Wednesday there is a seminar on infectious control and includes filters. g) TC 9.11 Clean Rooms Phil Winters i) Nothing for standards h) SSPC 62.1 Commercial Ventilation Charlie Seyffer i) Seminar on IAQ method in SLC and they are looking for co sponsors ii) Areas of nonattainment for PM 2.5 now require MERV 11 filters iii) Areas of nonattainment they wanted to change the Ozone level required, but it did not change. i) SSPC 62.2 Residential Ventilation Barney Burroughs i) No report j) SPC 161 Air Quality in Commercial Aircraft Erik Kuiper i) Std out for publication, 2 appeals, hearing done ii) Should be published after this meeting iii) Guideline 28 will be produced by SPC 161 (1) 2 nd PR after SLC

12 k) SPC 170 Ventilation of Healthcare Facilities Zied Driss i) No meeting in NYC ii) Draft out for 4 th PR iii) TC 9.6 is questioning SPC 170 on why there should be filters downstream of coils and why HEPA s need to be in operating suites. l) SPC 185.1P Elimination of Microbial Contaminants in Air Karin Foarde (Derald Welles) i) We need to move this to TC 2.9 as the cognizant committee. Will require a vote in TC 2.4. TC 2.9 has already accepted this. 3) Information Exchange: a) AFS KJ Choi i) Annual Technical Conference, Valley Forge, PA, May 19-22, 2008 ii) 10 th World Filtration Congress, Leipzig, Germany, April 15-18, 2008 b) ARI Terri Wytko i) No report c) ASTM-AG-1 Section FC Bill Cambo i) No report d) CEN Committee for European Normalization Paolo Tronville i) TC 195 (1) Met in Paris in September 2007 with new secretariat (2) WG 1 EN-779 HVAC Filters (a) Meeting in Paris Feb 7, 2008 on EN-779 revision (b) They will decide on keeping EN-779 as a test method or only a classification system (c) If CEN adopts the Vienne agreement, they will use the ISO standard and drop EN-779. This has not happened, yet. (3) WG 2 EN-1822 HEPA Filters (a) Revised and been submitted for Public Review (all parts) (b) New group of classes have been added between F and H E10, E11, E12 (i) i.e. They no longer call a 85% filter a H10 filter (ii) It has been proposed to make these classes F10, F11 & F12 (4) WG 4 Face Dimensions of Filters (a) Submitted for Public Review (5) WG 5 Gas Phase (a) This group did adopt the Vienne Agreement and will use the ISO TC 142 document as the European Standard. e) Eurovent Paolo Tronville i) Meeting Feb 6, 2008, Discussion to be on Energy Rating of Filters (1) Germany wants to use ISO fine loading (2) They are looking for a compromise f) IEST Institute of Environmental Sciences and Technology Phil Winters i) 1, 7, 21 & 34 all gearing up for revisions ii) Fan filter draft plagued by low attendance and constant turnover (1) Hopefully a draft at fall meeting iii) Nano-particles and Ultrafines are on the IEST agenda g) INDA Bob Burkhead i) Filtration 08 in Philadelphia December 11-13, 2008 ii) Will host the plenary meeting of ISO TC 142 h) ISO TC 142 Cleaning Equipment for Air and Other Gases i) US TAG Phil Winters (1) Admin of the US TAG is changing to ASHRAE from IEST (2) Selecting officers now and the next meeting will be at ASHRAE in SLC ii) TC 142 Paolo Tronville (1) Next meeting in Philadelphia at Filtration 08 (2) TG Formed to look at performance testing of dust collectors (3) WG 3 HVAC Filter Testing Jan Gustavsson, Sweden (Co-Convener, Don Thornburg, US) (a) Draft DIS approved for issue as a FDIS

13 (i) Formal vote in next few months to be published in 2008 (b) In-Situ work approved and will use GPC-26 as the base document (4) WG 4 HEPA/ULPA Testing Vijay, US (a) There was no meeting, but they will now be using EN-1822 as the base document and modify accordingly. (5) WG 1 Terminology John Dyment, UK (a) First draft due end of April 2008 (6) WG 9 Air Intake for Stationary Rotating Machinery Ulf Johansson, Sweden (a) Two new work items started: Barrier filters, Pulse Jet filters (will follow the ASHRAE work) (7) New preliminary work item started for Life Cycle Cost, Life Cycle Assessment, Safety of Materials in Filtration and Quality Factor (a) Jan Gustavsson is putting together a technical report and is looking for input i) ISO TC 23 Environmental Air quality for Agricultural Cabs Paolo Tronville i) Final version has been circulated and is being modified now j) NAFA Al Veeck i) The NAFA Guide to Air Filtration (4 th edition) is out for sale (1) Added 2 new chapters and updated most of the rest ii) Next meeting is April Memphis, TN iii) Annual Conference is in San Francisco, September 17-19, 2008 k) SAE Bruce McDonald i) ISO TS Cabin Air Filter (1) New work item to make it more performance orientated ii) ISO CD Engine Inlet Filters (1) Split 2 documents (a) um KCl neutralized (b) um using ISO not neutralized 4) Old Business 5) New Business Respectfully submitted Don Thornburg TC 2.4 Subcommittee Chair January 21, 2008

14 ASHRAE Technical Committee 2.04 Program Sub-Committee Report (Jan. 22 nd, 2008) Submitted by Charlie Seyffer - Call, to order, 11:30 AM - Introductions and sign in (attached) - Discussed scheduling situation of forums, seminars and Transactions - Direct conflict with 2.03 Seminar offering, Seyffer will communicate frustration with scheduling to ASHRAE - Reviewed program priorities and ASHRAE themes for future meetings - Reviewed two planned Transaction offerings for January 2009 in Chicago (automatic placement) - Speakers for Bypass Session include: o Jeffrey Siegel o Paul Nigro o David Chojnowski o Doug Kosar o John Vershaw - Speakers for Ultrafine Particles Session include: o Shelly Miller o David Pui Session suggestions and voting on priorities To be submitted, in order of voting priority: - Forum: Costs associated with PM 2.5/Ozone Compliance (Muller) - Seminar: IAQ & LEED, Contrary or Complimentary (Seyffer) - Seminar: Global Implications of air Filtration Standards (Tronville) - Forum: Implementing and Reporting of the ASHRAE Standard 52.2 Optional Conditioning Step (Hanley) - Forum: Are Ionic Air Cleaners Beneficial (Siegel or Listvan) Discussed low backlog of subjects, same in 2.03 meeting that followed Meeting adjourned

15 TC 2.4 Publication Subcommittee Minutes Publications Report for 1/21/08 (Marilyn Listvan, Chair, reporting) Publications Minutes of 1/21/08 (New York City)... submitted by Marilyn Listvan The joint TC 2.03 and 2.04 Publications Meeting was held on Jan. 21, 2008 in NYC, NY and had 15 members present. ( s at the end) A.) IAQ Proceedings CD: ASHRAE publications is still expecting our document for Special Pubs. The remaining efforts include:scanning of IAQ proceedings is almost complete (?) Design, Construction & Operation of Healthy Buildings; Solutions to Global --- we need the book (from Barney Burroughs)!! C. Seyffer to scan (not started!!) ****ASAP deadline for scanned files back to Marilyn so she can bookmark, etc. **** Action item : Detailed scanning instructions to all: PDF format, Scan from within Acrobat (open New..). They need to be scanned with optical character recognition OCR (with 600 dpi) use Acrobat 7.0 OCR settings. We can use bookmarks to identify papers. ASHRAE wants each paper a separate file, then bookmarks **Action Item: Marilyn: finished/repaired scans DUE to ASHRAE by 8/08. B.) **IAQ Applications: danger of cancellation per ASHRAE Publications Comm. SUBSCRIBE!** C.) Article topics and Authors were asked for (continued from past meetings) : 1.) Fyi: Several ASHRAE News releases relevant to 2.3 & 2.4 have been sent out lately ASHRAE news releases. (Contact: Jodi Dunlop Phone: a) Action item for 62.1 Press release: perhaps wait for Press Release after public review period. 1b) Who is MERV? Al Veeck provided information. Marilyn & Jim Hanley & Eric Kuiper will help review information. (ML note got from AV, status??) Action Item for Marilyn: joint News release or IAQ Appls: Who is MERV anyway?? (ML note: I spoke to Fred Turner, will send info). 2) K. Foarde will attempt to convert an ARTI report into an ASHRAE Journal article on UV light effects o Action: (Karin/Doug draft in process, submitting 7/08) 3) G. Kerr (1) may produce a second (and third) manuscript for ASHRAE TRANSACTIONS based on work for RP-961, (Contaminants, and Barrier effects) (7/08) and 4) Gemma (2) may work on an ASHRAE (IAQ Applications)Journal article on How to investigate Odor Problems in Real Buildings. (12/08) 5) Nick Agopian & Tom Justice Insights how to article. outline by? 6) Action: Phil Winters keep notes on working with the ISO process and write an article on that experience. (next ISO mtg is? (was 6/07).checked with Phil W...he will write an article on the ISO process / experience.or what not to do ) -- Charlie Kern could help with this (?) 7) Paulo will put together a small summary for the ISO standard (ISO TC 142.?). Maybe we can put something into Insights. (Note ML: GPC 27P wants this ISO info as reference material -- is Bill Lull still interested in this info?) 8) Action: Use of Filtration in Process Applications. Nick Agopian has info for two applications (Outdoor air for Semiconductors; Pulp & paper). Nick is moving forward with a P&P field studies paper Cu coupons (corrosion measures) has lab data now 1/08 paper? ARCHIVAL interest, too? Deadline 7/08?. 9) Need status: Jim Hanley has a paper drafted on 52.2 round robin (tech paper). **Waiting for a Symposium slot.** Action for 2.4 Program! 52.2 Round Robin results waiting for a Symposium slot.*** 9a) Action Item: See if there is an interest in Jim H. (and/or Jim Kubokawa as PMC chair?) to prepare a paper on this 52.2 RR for Insights. Jim H. does have an executive summary already prepared. This executive summary can be used for ASHRAE Insights. 10) MVOC Res. Project Exec Summ. ( Karin Foarde to write/ ML to help edit)

16 11) Energy Conservation using IAQ procedure article (IAQ in Schools issue?) received several detailed/ critical comments back to Fred Turner possible response needed (Chris Muller/ Brad Stanley will do talks were given in Long Beach..paper status??) 12) Jerry Lampin s talk on San Antonio schools 6/07 should be written up (with emphasis on specifics of HOW they achieved the improvments!! Action Chris Muller / Brad Stanley (?)in the ASHRAE Journal. 13) Examples of using the NEW online calculator for IAQ method.? Charlie Seyffer (out to 6/08) 14) FTC needs to crack down on false claims by filter devices should this be a FORUM? seminar? Action: Would Jeff Seigel &/or Richard Corsi and/or Don Thornberg do an article? ) note Calif. has legated twice the snake Ions vendor(s). 15) 52.1 how/ if to retire it was discussed: ask Monroe Britt to write (for Insights?). 16) Emerging Technologies papers: PCO: Catherine Jacquiod.(/ Dean T.) has an abstract for a paper for PCO applications. For PCO Symposium / TC 2.9 interested also(?) 17) Emerging Technologies papers: PCO: Jeff Roseberry-- a paper for PCO applications, based on Quebec talk? 18) Emerging Technologies papers: Plasma: Ron D. (?) a paper for Plasma applications. (ML find Ron info ofr Al V.) 19) Indoor/Outdoor Ultrafines Shelly Miller, et. al. 2.4 s RP-? Transactions paper (C. Seyffer said it was in prep). 20) How to apply the IAQ method? Action: Barney Burroughs 15-building project. And/or Chris Muller/Brad Stanley??? 21) Jean Tetreaute: Users view How to protect Museum collections with Gas & Particle Filtration 22) T. Justice. Importance of Dust Holding Capacity (DHC) Real Life Usage. 23) C. Seyffer (an Engineered Sytems article is coming out Aug or Sept. '08 LEED & Air Filtration 24) C. Seyffer write an Insights summary of previous LEED & Air Filtration 25) Nick Agopian/+ Chris Mueller + C. Seyffer) How can we apply filtration to reduce Outdoor air with IAQ method (also see #13?) 26) Al Vatine (& David Matier) Coalescence of of Rain water for Fractional Efficiency using particles(?)...is submitting for Power Industry summer '08. A request for volunteer reviewers of articles made so that good information is provided by TC. Attendees of 0108 meeting: Name Phone . Marilyn Listvan Charles Seyffer Mark Stutman Nick Agopian Christine Sun David Matier Tom Justice Thad Ptak Al Vatine Mick Flom Karin Foarde Gemma Kerr Rien van Benthem Jook Geboer (?) Jean Tetreault