Europe faces unfinished business on the euro

Transcription

1 Sign In Subscribe European Union Europe faces unfinished business on the euro Questions over currency s governance as leaders prepare for anniversary celebrations Pierre Moscovici promised 'ambitious ideas' for 'deepening of the economic and monetary union' Bloomberg 2 HOURS AGO by: Jim Brunsden in Brussels When the European Commission published a white paper this month on the future of Europe, something was missing. Two weeks earlier, Pierre Moscovici, EU economy commissioner, had told an audience in Athens that the blueprint would include ambitious ideas for deepening of the economic and monetary union code for overhauling the system of budget rules and policy co ordination that underpins the single currency. Instead, amid warnings from national capitals that the plans could stoke division ahead of the EU s 60th anniversary summit in Rome, and even heighten tensions in the Dutch election campaign, the commission changed course. It now expects to publish a reflection paper in late May, thereby also leapfrogging France s presidential poll. 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 1/10

2 The move is the latest sign that questions of euro area governance have been driven to the policymaking sidelines by factors ranging from the hammer blow of Brexit ( ww.ft.com/topics/themes/brexit) to an easing of the economic crisis. But Europe s leaders gathering in Rome this week to try to reinvigorate the EU project know reform can only be ducked for so long. Priorities for change vary wildly between capitals but on one point there is agreement: the status quo is not a long term option for the euro. You can t be half pregnant we need to finish the architectural structure of the single currency, says Johan Van Overtveldt ( JlMzgtZGQ3Yy00YmMyLTljZmYtMjZkZjM3OGQ1MTJl UE4=), Belgium s finance minister. If we await another major crisis we will be obliged to do then what we do not succeed in doing now. Manfred Weber, a German centre right MEP who leads the European People s Party group in the EU parliament, concurs, saying Europe will have to come back to fundamental discussions and fundamental decisions on the euro once this year s slalom of major elections culminating in Germany in September is over The reason is clear. The single currency and its perceived iniquities go to the heart of the popular backlash threatening Europe s governments, and a wider sense of disenchantment with the EU. 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 2/10

3 For many, the euro has fomented discord where it was meant to bring harmony. Antiestablishment parties lambast the currency as a cause of economic misery, or complain that it serves as a vehicle for Berlin to maintain its economic dominance. Marine Le Pen, leader of France s Front National, has described it as a corpse that still moves one that shutters businesses and lengthens dole queues. Competing frustrations simmer on the other side of the Rhine: German concerns about the European Central Bank s expansionary monetary policy have mingled with taxpayers resentment at being repeatedly put on the hook for bailing out other countries. Policymakers acknowledge a clear conundrum. How does one solve popular unrest about the euro if doing so requires more integration and more Brussels precisely what the populists are railing against? Related article 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 3/10

4 Spain economy minister urges Europe to focus on trade and banking ( bb ) Comments at odds with call by Brussels for more government spending to spur demand For Luis de Guindos, Spain s economy minister, the first goal of any reform drive should be to have a common view that we should take further steps in integration... We do not have such a consensus now, he told the FT. No one expects such a consensus to materialise before the German election. But officials in Brussels think that, depending on the outcome of this year s votes, the period afterwards leading up to European Parliament elections in mid 2019 could offer potentially fertile policymaking terrain. Ideas are not in short supply. The EU institutions in 2015 published reform options stretching to a 10 year horizon. The blueprint included short term measures, such as more co ordination of economic policies, and completion of a project to centralise oversight of the currency bloc s banks; it also outlined longer term ideas for a euro area treasury and a stimulus fund that could be tapped to deal with macroeconomic shocks. The authors, which included the European Central Bank, said the plans could narrow the gulf in productivity between countries such as Germany and Greece, boost growth and increase resilience to financial crises. 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 4/10

5 But even progress on the short term goals has been mixed. One priority was a common scheme to guarantee bank deposits in the the euro area. The plan was championed by France and southern Europe but encountered strong opposition from Berlin, which feared a safety net would lead to irresponsible risk taking by banks. Olli Rehn, a board member at the Bank of Finland and the EU s economy commissioner until 2014, says this is one example of a north south intellectual cleavage that has persisted since the earliest days of the euro, and that has often slowed down the development of economic and monetary union. When it comes to economic and fiscal policy, many in France see the Germans as too rigid, while many in Germany see the French as insufficiently credible Pierre Moscovici When it comes to economic and fiscal policy, many in France see the Germans as too rigid, while many in Germany see the French as insufficiently credible, Mr Moscovici notes. If we are to build the trust we need to move forward with reforming the eurozone, we will need to see credibility from France, and openness from Germany. The current political climate means that now in the eurozone we are in the middle of nowhere, Mr de Guindos says. We do not know if we should go further or take some steps backwards. 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 5/10

6 It is a situation, he says, that will only partly be resolved by pro EU election outcomes, as populism is going to mark the agenda. I think the only way forward is to have more integration to share more risks, to have more instruments... to avoid leaders and laggards in the eurozone. For some, the solution lies in a gradual approach, with moves towards economic risksharing in the euro area balanced by greater risk reduction measures promoting market discipline. Germany has advocated such an approach in the area of financial services saying a deposit guarantee scheme could only come after steps to make sure losses can be imposed on failed banks creditors. Reform has practical as well as political constraints. Many of the more ambitious ideas in circulation would require EU treaty change, something which is firmly off the political agenda. Full blown monetary union demands full blown political union I m not sure that s realistic, Mr Van Overtveldt says. But we can make a valuable positive contribution by developing a second best solution, and we can do that better than we have done so far. Reform plans One of the main challenges for Brussels will be to balance different and often competing national priorities for change. Proposals have ranged from an Italian push for a euro area unemployment insurance scheme, to long term ideas in Berlin for a European Monetary Fund that would police budgetary discipline. Here are some current and former policymakers priorities: Luis de Guindos, Spain s economy minister, says the focus should be on pushing countries to undertake labour market reforms and other measures to boost competitiveness. Brussels should have much more capacity and capability to force countries to implement structural reforms, he says. The macro economic procedures should be much more enforceable. For Johan Van Overtveldt, Belgium s finance minister, the number one priority should be to boost the financial system s resilience to crises by 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 6/10

7 completing the banking union a centralised system of financial oversight. The banking union is a complex project that mixes extra powers for the European Central Bank with the setting up of a new crisis fighting agency and common fund. Work on the final pillar of the project a centralised scheme for centralising bank deposits, is at an early stage. Luc Frieden, chairman of the board at Banque Internationale à Luxembourg and the duchy s finance minister until 2013, cites a chronic need to simplify the EU s rules on national budgets. Multiple revisions during the crisis years of the so called stability and growth pact have left it much too complicated he says. All the text that we have added has made it so complex that even for experts it becomes difficult. Olli Rehn, board member at the Bank of Finland, highlights two big issues, which are linked, which are not solved. One is how the euro area can pursue an aggregate fiscal stance so as to move as a co ordinated, single economic area boosting demand or deflating bubbles. The other is to adapt the budget rules to focus more on growth enhancing reforms and productive investment. The first rule that each and every member state should follow is that [it] pursues an economic policy that supports growth and employment, he says. Print a single copy of this article for personal use. Contact us if you wish to print more to distribute to others. The Financial Times Ltd. Latest on European Union Scottish Independence Sturgeon leaves two important questions unanswered SNP conference told they will soon be fighting another independence referendum 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 7/10

8 Europe Kremlin-backed media adds to western fears in Balkans Alarm in European capitals at breadth of Moscow s influence Global Trade Fresh impetus for Europe-S America trade pact Negotiators gather for talks between EU and Mercosur Special Report Boldness in Business Boldness in Business Person of the Year: Helena Morrissey This City maverick won over sceptics about women on boards; now let s see about Brexit Latest in Europe French presidential election French election: policies of the runners and riders The main contestants offer radically different visions for France 2 HOURS AGO 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 8/10

9 EU defence UK and Germany to sign defence co-operation deal Theresa May hopes European security contribution will win Brexit goodwill France terrorism Security forces shoot man dead at Paris airport Orly flights suspended after man on terror watch list killed by security Follow the topics mentioned in this article Europe Europe World Global Economy EU Economy Follow the authors of this article Jim Brunsden Take a tour of myft 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 9/10

10 0a3d 11e7 97d1 5e720a26771b 10/10