Zephyr Teachout, Parchment Barriers: Why Tillman and Natelson Are Wrong about the Anti- Corruption Principle on Concurring Opinions (2013)
|
|
- Alberta Phelps
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 National University of Ireland, Maynooth From the SelectedWorks of Seth Barrett Tillman June 10, 2014 Zephyr Teachout, Parchment Barriers: Why Tillman and Natelson Are Wrong about the Anti- Corruption Principle on Concurring Opinions (2013) Seth Barrett Tillman Available at:
2 Parchment Barriers: Why Tillman and Natelson Are Wrong about the Anti- Corruption Principle posted by Zephyr Teachout I have argued in several articles and a forthcoming book that the Anti- Corruption Principle was and is a foundational constitutional principle. Larry Lessig has argued the same in a book, several articles, and a brief before the Supreme Court. He also runs a fascinating tumblr of corruption conversations at the convention. We both show how it motivated the Constitutional convention and was the overwhelming topic of the convention. The founding drafters would judge their own success or failure in terms of the Constitution in terms of whether or not it protected against corruption. As George Mason said as the Constitutional Convention got under way: If we do not provide against corruption, our government will soon be at an end. I am not going to recite the argument here its a substantial, text and history based argument. However, it leads to treating the Anti-Corruption Principle like federalism or the separation of powers a fundamental structural part of the Constitution. There are two general disagreements with this view: First, that I, and or Lessig, don t characterize the meaning of corruption at the time properly (we have slight differences), and second, that it was not and is not a Constitutional principle. Seth Tillman, and Rob Natelson citing Seth Tillman, have both recently argued that there is no such principle. Tillman sees a kind of smokinggun flaw with the argument the evidence that the word corruption was taken out of the impeachment clause as a ground for impeachment. Tillman writes: But when the Framers had a chance (actually multiple chances) to give this concept prominence in the Constitution s actual text, the Framers chose not to do so. It is not as if they forgot to use this term or, instead, used some close synonym; rather, they actively took this term out of the
3 Constitution. So why should we today embrace the corruption concept as one having constitutional scope or dimension? I have three responses. First, the absence of the word corruption does no more to the anti-corruption principle than the deliberate choice to exclude separation of powers does to the separation of powers principle. Second, the reason the word was taken out is because corruption is ill-suited to bad-intent criminal law statutes, and well-suited to prophylactic statutes or constitutional provisions that don t reference state of mind. Tillman has a common confusion he treats the scope of the word corruption as that which can be defined in a criminal-law like statute. Third, Tillman s particular argument contrasts with his general support for the anti-corruption principle. (1)First, the founders made a similar choice with regards to separation of powers. When critics objected, Madison skewered them with the argument that they were making parchment barriers be more important than fundamental understandings of power. If Tillman s argument applies to the anti-corruption principle, it applies with even greater force to the separation of powers principle. I could go further for now suffice it to say that I hope Tillman and Natelson are equally willing to dispose of the separation of powers principle. (2) Second, Tillman confuses the legitimate scope of the meaning of corruption with its legitimate use as a tool for individual judgement. This far, Tillman is correct:
4 Corruption appeared in a preliminary draft of the Constitution s Impeachment Clause. But this language was dropped, and superseded by treason, bribery, and maladministration, but the maladministration language appeared too vague. (Meigs, The Growth of the Constitution in the Federal Convention of (1899).) The Convention did not return to the earlier corruption language, and instead, it chose treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. This seems right to me, and not an indication on its face that there was an anticorruption principle, but rather that it was not an appropriate tool for the role of determining who should be impeached. Bribery and extortion were high misdemeanors at the time, so any high crimes and misdemeanors would include bribery and extortion and other crimes related to abuse of office. The choice to take out the particular word, as too vague, doesn t mean the founders didn t believe in corruption (the most cursory review of any writing shows the opposite), but that they saw government s tools for fighting corruption to be better placed in prophylactic rules. The anti-corruption provisions of the constitution, like emoluments clauses or the veto clause or the residency clause are designed to limit corruption but don t reference particular corrupt actors. Assume, for a moment, that corruption was taken out for vagueness that doesn t make it not a founding era principle, it simply makes it a bad candidate for being the grounds of impeachment. Arguably, the vagueness cuts the other way it is such a fundamental concept of enormous foundational import that it would threaten to trivialize it if were litigated in terms of legitimate impeachment. (3) Tillman s initial historical read was more supportive.
5 Tillman, up to now, has generally supported the argument for an anticorruption principle. In a colloquy between us at Northwestern he wrote: There is a structural anti-corruption principle of constitutional dimension. That principle, the ACP, vindicates substantial congressional control over statutory officers, i.e., officers under the United States. It puts federal statutory officers in a fiduciary relationship under the government, in respect to the officers elected masters and all of the nation s citizens. However, he and I disagree about the scope he thinks it applies only to appointed, not elected officers. Tillman s general interest, for those being introduced to the debate, is the meaning of the word officers his argument is in the prior article, my response on officers is here. We disagree about offices, but I think he has strong and interesting arguments. I hope he returns to this basic principle, and engages the question of what corruption means inside the historical context of the acceptance, instead of rejection of the principle. October 28, 2013 at 11:44 am Posted in: Uncategorized Print This Post 9 Responses Pathfinder - October 29, 2013 Lessig and Teachout are engaged in the worst type of scholarship attempting to conjure up a theory that will turn their policy preferences into a constitutional mandate. In doing so they ignore all other possible readings, including many that have more direct support in the Constitutional text and structure (which they pretty much have to admit).
6 Obviously the Founders were concerned about virtue and preventing corruption in government. (That is essentially their point of agreement with Tillman). But this does not and cannot mean that there is some free-floating anti-corruption principle embedded in the Constitution, a sort of vague legislative intent that overrides the actual language and structure, to be pulled out whenever one needs to support one s favored government policy (for Lessig and Teachout, broad restraints on political speech and participation). It would make as much sense to comb the page of late 18th century political tracts to create a basic liberty principle that trumps the actual language and structure of the Constitution, causing most of the current edifice of government to fall; or to find an equality principle dictating much more redistribution of income. The framers were concerned with many things. They enacted a Constitution to address those concerns. To suggest that one area of concern, one broad principle of government, somehow trumps specific provisions of the Constitution or overrides its structural elements is absurd, particularly when they further interpret that broad principle, rather tendentiously, as being achievable only through the policies they favor. Zephyr Teachout - October 29, 2013 Zephyr - October 30, 2013 Rob thanks for chiming in. As I read your post, you said that Lessig and I asserted that there was an anti-corruption principle, and Tillman s response devastated those assertions. I read that to be a rejection of the ACP. I m glad to know that you are at least open to looking at things through the lens of the ACP.
7 - See more at: tillman-and-natelson-are-wrong-about-the-anti-corruption-principle.html#more
Chapter Three Assignment
Name: Class: Date: ID: A Chapter Three Assignment Multiple Choice Identify the letter of the choice that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1. The Constitution is based on the concept
More information10/6/11. A look at the history and organization of US Constitution
A look at the history and organization of US Constitution During Revolution, the states created a confederation. Loose association of states. Continental Congress responsible to war effort during the Revolution.
More informationFederal Constitution Test Review & Study Guide
Name: AP GOPO 2018-2019 AP United States Government & Politics (AP GOPO) Sumer Work Federal Constitution Test Review & Study Guide AP Government will require you to do a high level of work and to have
More informationCopyright Center for Civic Education. All rights reserved.
THIS LESSON IS PROVIDED FOR REVIEW AND TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY REPRODUCTION IS PROHIBITED WITHOUT PRIOR WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE CENTER FOR CIVIC EDUCATION This sample lesson for middle school students
More informationHOT SEAT QUESTIONS H.FRY 3/2009. We the People. Unit What were some differences between Europe and the American Colonies in the 1770 s?
We the People Unit 1 1. What were some differences between Europe and the American Colonies in the 1770 s? Most nations in Europe were much smaller than the colonies. Only the rich could afford to buy
More informationSection 9-1: Understanding the Constitution
Name: Date: Chapter 9 Study Guide Section 9-1: Understanding the Constitution Fill in the blanks: 1. The United States government may be described as a, or one in which people exercise political power
More informationThe John Marshall Institutional Repository. The John Marshall Law School. Walter J. Kendall III John Marshall Law School
The John Marshall Law School The John Marshall Institutional Repository Court Documents and Proposed Legislation 1-1-2011 Statement of Professor Kendall Before Illinois Campaign Finance Reform Task Force,
More informationA More Perfect Union. The Three Branches of the Federal Government. Teacher s Guide. The Presidency The Congress The Supreme Court
A More Perfect Union The Three Branches of the Federal Government The Presidency The Congress The Supreme Court Teacher s Guide Teacher s Guide for A More Perfect Union : The Three Branches of the Federal
More informationLOVE, EQUALITY, AND CORRUPTION
LOVE, EQUALITY, AND CORRUPTION Zephyr Teachout* INTRODUCTION What is corruption? Unless one takes an absolute (and hard to defend) view of words meanings there is a fixed meaning, it cannot differ this
More informationConstitutional Principles
Where Power Comes From The First of Its Kind It may sound dramatic to say the U.S. Constitution revolutionized the world, but that s exactly what it has done. Since the Constitution was adopted in 1791
More informationThe George Washington University Law School
The George Washington University Law School Access to the Media 1967 to 2007 and Beyond: A Symposium Honoring Jerome A. Barron s Path-Breaking Article Introductory Remarks by The Honorable Stephen G. Breyer
More informationUnit 7 Our Current Government
Unit 7 Our Current Government Name Date Period Learning Targets (What I need to know): I can describe the Constitutional Convention and two compromises that took place there. I can describe the structure
More informationSection 9-1: Understanding the Constitution
Name: Date: Chapter 9 Study Guide Section 9-1: Understanding the Constitution Fill in the blanks: 1. The United States government may be described as a representative democracy, or one in which people
More informationChapter 3 The Constitution. Section 1 Structure and Principles
Chapter 3 The Constitution Section 1 Structure and Principles The Constitution The Founders... 1) created the Constitution more than 200 years ago. 2) like Montesquieu, believed in separation of powers.
More informationAn Exchange on the Disqualification Clause
An Exchange on the Disqualification Clause FOREWORD Michael Stern * A few years ago the Chief Justice was quoted as suggesting a disconnect between the typical law review article ( you know, the influence
More informationPOLITICAL SCIENCE 1101 SAMPLE ESSAY ANSWERS BUCKNER F. MELTON, JR.
POLITICAL SCIENCE 1101 SAMPLE ESSAY ANSWERS BUCKNER F. MELTON, JR. Below is a range of answers to the following essay question, ranging from high A to low F. Carefully read and compare each answer and
More informationWho attended the Philadelphia Convention? How was it organized? We the People, Unit 3 Lesson 12
Who attended the Philadelphia Convention? How was it organized? We the People, Unit 3 Lesson 12 A convention has been called to rewrite Redwood school constitution. We need some delegates (representatives).
More informationCitizens Against an Article V Convention I. How would LR35 change the U.S. Constitution?
Citizens Against an Article V Convention judicaler@hotmail.com Points in opposition to NEBRASKA LR35 I. How would LR35 change the U.S. Constitution? LR35 is an application to Congress from Nebraska for
More informationIf the actions constitute a high crime or a misdemeanor, how does the act of the President compare to the original meaning as defined by Blackstone?
nit 4 Individual Activity; Impeachment Decision Making Matrix Directions; Attachh this to back of your cartoon panels for turn-in. Use text sheets, notes, and the information on the back to record information
More informationDEBATE ON RATIFICATION
U.S. I Mr. Lanner 100 Point Project DEBATE ON RATIFICATION Should we ratify the new Constitution? Purpose of Lesson: This lesson describes some conflicting points of view of leading Framers about the Constitution.
More informationAP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT UNIT 5: GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS FRQ s
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT UNIT 5: GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS FRQ s CONGRESS 1. Article I of the Constitution discusses the powers of Congress. a. Define the EACH of the following powers: Expressed Implied Non
More informationAP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT UNIT 5: GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS FRQ s
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT UNIT 5: GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS FRQ s CONGRESS 1. Article I of the Constitution discusses the powers of Congress. a. Define the EACH of the following powers: Expressed Implied Non-legislative
More informationANSWER KEY EXPLORING CIVIL AND ECONOMIC FREEDOM DBQ: LIBERTY AND THE
ANSWER KEY EXPLORING CIVIL AND ECONOMIC FREEDOM Critical Thinking Questions 1. The Founders understood that property is the natural right of all individuals to create, obtain, and control their possessions,
More informationPoints in opposition to OHIO HJR3
Citizens Against an Article V Convention judicaler@hotmail.com Points in opposition to OHIO HJR3 I. How would HJR3 change the U.S. Constitution? HJR3 is an application to Congress from Ohio for Congress
More information9.1 Introduction When the delegates left Independence Hall in September 1787, they each carried a copy of the Constitution. Their task now was to
9.1 Introduction When the delegates left Independence Hall in September 1787, they each carried a copy of the Constitution. Their task now was to convince their states to approve the document that they
More informationThe Constitution I. Considerations that influenced the formulation and adoption of the Constitution A. Roots 1. Religious Freedom a) Puritan
The Constitution I. Considerations that influenced the formulation and adoption of the Constitution A. Roots 1. Religious Freedom a) Puritan Theocracy (1) 9 of 13 had state church b) Rhode Island (1) Roger
More informationThe Constitution: A More Perfect Union
The Constitution: A More Perfect Union How has the Constitution created a more perfect Union? P R E V I E W Read the quotation and answer the questions that follow. If men were angels, no government would
More informationSupreme Court s Obamacare Decision Renders Federal Tort-Reform Bill Unconstitutional
Supreme Court s Obamacare Decision Renders Federal Tort-Reform Bill Unconstitutional by Robert G. Natelson 1 Congressional schemes to federalize state health care lawsuits always have been constitutionally
More informationThe Constitution: A More Perfect Union
The Constitution: A More Perfect Union How has the Constitution created a more perfect Union? P R E V I E W Read the quotation and answer the questions that follow. If men were angels, no government would
More informationLESSON S OBJECTIVES Explain the powers that the const. Gives to congress Explain the enumerated powers of congress, the necessary and proper and
Lesson 12.2 LESSON S OBJECTIVES Explain the powers that the const. Gives to congress Explain the enumerated powers of congress, the necessary and proper and general welfare clauses, and the reason for
More informationThe Six Basic Principles
The Constitution The Six Basic Principles The Constitution is only about 7000 words One of its strengths is that it does not go into great detail. It is based on six principles that are embodied throughout
More informationSeparation of Powers
Separation of Powers Separation of Powers: The Legislative Branch The legislative branch of government is Congress. Congress consists of the House of Representatives and the Senate Members of the House
More informationCase 8:17-cv PJM Document 123 Filed 07/25/18 Page 1 of 52 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
Case 8:17-cv-01596-PJM Document 123 Filed 07/25/18 Page 1 of 52 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA * and THE STATE OF MARYLAND, * * Plaintiffs, *
More informationWednesday, October 12 th
Wednesday, October 12 th Draft of Essay #1 Due TODAY! Final Essay #1 Due Wednesday, Oct. 26 th Federalism NATIONAL L J E STATE L J E The Founders on Government Government is not reason; it is not eloquent;
More information1 st United States Constitution. A. loose alliance of states. B. Congress lawmaking body. C. 9 states had to vote to pass laws
1 st United States Constitution A. loose alliance of states B. Congress lawmaking body C. 9 states had to vote to pass laws D. each state had 1 vote in Congress Northwest Ordinance / Land Ordinance division
More informationSTAAR OBJECTIVE: 3. Government and Citizenship
STAAR OBJECTIVE: 3 Government and Citizenship 1. What is representative government? A. Government that represents the interests of the king. B. Government in which elected officials represent the interest
More informationConstitutional Principles. Step by Step
Teacher Guide Time Needed: 2 Class Periods Materials: Projector w/powerpoint (optional) Scissors/Glue Blank Paper Pages to Copy: Brain Dump (1/2 page; class set) Reading (4 pages; class set) Barebones
More informationChapter 3: The Constitution Section 1
Chapter 3: The Constitution Section 1 Objectives 1. Understand the basic outline of the Constitution. 2. Understand the six basic principles of the Constitution: popular sovereignty, limited government,
More informationThe Text and History of the Foreign Emoluments Clause
The Text and History of the Foreign Emoluments Clause America s Founders believed that corruption and foreign inf luence were among the gravest threats to our nation. As a result, they included in our
More informationThe House of Representatives shall be composed of Members chosen every second Year by the People of the several States.
Guiding Principles of the Constitution (HA) Over the years, the Constitution has acquired an almost sacred status for Americans. Part of the reason for that is its durability: the Constitution has survived,
More informationAP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT Unit Four The President and the Bureaucracy 2 1 Unit 4 Learning Objectives Running for President 4.1 Outline the stages in U.S. presidential elections and the differences in campaigning
More informationBill of Rights. 1. Meet the Source (2:58) Interview with Whitman Ridgway (Professor, University of Maryland, College Park)
Interview with Whitman Ridgway (Professor, University of Maryland, College Park) Bill of Rights 1. Meet the Source (2:58) Well, the Bill of Rights, in my opinion, is a very remarkable document because
More information[ 3.1 ] An Overview of the Constitution
[ 3.1 ] An Overview of the Constitution [ 3.1 ] An Overview of the Constitution Learning Objectives Understand the basic outline of the Constitution. Understand the basic principles of the Constitution:
More informationThe Federal Courts. Chapter 16
The Federal Courts Chapter 16 3 HISTORICAL ERAS OF INFLUENCE 1787-1865 Political Nation building (legitimacy of govt.) Slavery 1865-1937 Economic Govt. roll in economy Great Depression 1937-Present Ideological
More informationWednesday, February 15 th
Anticipating Constitutional Reform 1 Wednesday, February 15 th Midterm #1: February 14-17 in the Testing Center Monday and Tuesday: No late fee Wednesday: $5 late fee Thursday: $7 late fee and test must
More informationCHAPTER 5: CONGRESS: THE LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
CHAPTER 5: CONGRESS: THE LEGISLATIVE BRANCH 1 Section 1: Congress Section 2: The Powers of Congress Section 3: The House of Representative Section 4: The Senate Section 5: Congress At Work SECTION 1: CONGRESS
More informationTHE PRESIDENCY. In this lecture we will cover
THE PRESIDENCY THE PRESIDENCY In this lecture we will cover The Roots of the Office of President of the United States The Constitutional Powers of the President The Development of Presidential Power The
More informationCriminal Procedure. 8 th Edition Joel Samaha. Wadsworth Publishing
Criminal Procedure 8 th Edition Joel Samaha Wadsworth Publishing Crime Control in a Constitutional Democracy Chapter 1 Constitutional Democracy We live in a constitutional democracy, where neither a single
More informationThe Constitution: A More Perfect Union
Unit 3 The Constitution: A More Perfect Union C H A P T E R 9 How has the Constitution created a more perfect Union? P R E V I E W Read the quotation and answer the questions that follow. If men were angels,
More informationUS Government Review 3.1
Class: Date: US Government Review 3.1 True/False Indicate whether the statement is true or false. We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic
More informationIn Elections, Irrelevant Alternatives Provide Relevant Data
1 In Elections, Irrelevant Alternatives Provide Relevant Data Richard B. Darlington Cornell University Abstract The electoral criterion of independence of irrelevant alternatives (IIA) states that a voting
More informationThe Breach Episode 101: Interrogating the Emoluments Clause with Zephyr Teachout
The Breach Episode 101: Interrogating the Emoluments Clause with Zephyr Teachout Welcome to The Breach. Your deep dive into authoritarianism and corruption in the Trump administration. I'm your host Lindsay
More informationThe Constitution: A More Perfect Union
The Constitution: A More Perfect Union How has the Constitution created a more perfect Union? P R E V I E W Read the quotation and answer the questions that follow. If men were angels, no government would
More information9.3. The Legislative Branch Makes Laws For the framers of the Constitution,
9.3. The Legislative Branch Makes Laws For the framers of the Constitution, the first step in building a trusted government was to create a fair way to make laws. Article I of the Constitution gives the
More informationNos and ~n 'Qrbe. ARIZONA FREE ENTERPRISE CLUB'S FREEDOM CLUB PAC, ET AL., Petitioners, v. KEN BENNETT, ET AL., Respondents.
Nos. 10-238 and 10-239 ~n 'Qrbe ~upreme QCourt of tbe Wniteb ~tates ARIZONA FREE ENTERPRISE CLUB'S FREEDOM CLUB PAC, ET AL., Petitioners, v. KEN BENNETT, ET AL., Respondents. JOHN MCCOMISH, ET AL., Petitioners,
More informationChapter 5: Congress: The Legislative Branch
Chapter 5: Congress: The Legislative Branch Section 1: Congress Section 2: The Powers of Congress Section 3: The House of Representatives Section 4: The Senate Section 5: Congress at Work Congress Main
More informationThe Emoluments Clause and the President
The Emoluments Clause and the President Prior to his election in November 2016, President Donald Trump had an extensive private business empire. He was a well-known real estate developer. He became most
More information60 Minutes/Vanity Fair Poll April 18-21, 2013
60 Minutes/Vanity Fair Poll April 18-21, 2013 If you could change it, which of the following songs would you most like to have as our national anthem? 1. God Bless America, 2. America the Beautiful, 3.
More information7a. The Evolution of the Presidency
7a. The Evolution of the Presidency South Dakota's Mt. Rushmore memorializes four of America's greatest Presidents. Washington, Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt, and Lincoln are carved into this spectacular
More informationChanging Constitutional Powers of the American President Feature: Forum: The Evolving Presidency in Eastern Europe
University of Chicago Law School Chicago Unbound Journal Articles Faculty Scholarship 1993 Changing Constitutional Powers of the American President Feature: Forum: The Evolving Presidency in Eastern Europe
More informationMessage from former Colorado Chief Justice Mary Mullarkey to Students
Courts in the Community Colorado Judicial Branch Office of the State Court Administrator Updated January 2013 Lesson: Objective: Activities: Outcomes: Grade Level: 5-8 A Constitutional Treasure Hunt Students
More informationAbsolute Monarchy In an absolute monarchy, the government is totally run by the headof-state, called a monarch, or more commonly king or queen. They a
Absolute Monarchy..79-80 Communism...81-82 Democracy..83-84 Dictatorship...85-86 Fascism.....87-88 Parliamentary System....89-90 Republic...91-92 Theocracy....93-94 Appendix I 78 Absolute Monarchy In an
More informationSeparation of Powers: What s for Lunch? STEP BY STEP
Teacher s Guide Separation of Powers: What s for Lunch? Time Needed: Two class periods Materials Needed: Student worksheets Projector (PowerPoint optional) Copy Instructions: Simulation Activity (4 pages;
More informationBUSINESS TRANSACTIONS AND PRESIDENT TRUMP S EMOLUMENTS PROBLEM
BUSINESS TRANSACTIONS AND PRESIDENT TRUMP S EMOLUMENTS PROBLEM SETH BARRETT TILLMAN* Recently, some have argued 1 that the term emoluments, as used in the Constitution s Foreign Emoluments Clause 2 and
More informationCredit-by-Exam Review US Government
Credit-by-Exam Review US Government Foundations and Ideas of the U.S. Government Characteristics and examples of limited government Characteristics and examples of unlimited government divine right unalienable
More informationThe Evolution of the Presidency
Ushistory.org. The Evolution of the Presidency, American Government Online Textbook. http://www.ushistory.org/gov/7a.asp. Retrieved 9/22/16. Copyright 2008-2016 ushistory.org, owned by the Independence
More informationThe Structure and Functions of the Government
The Structure and Functions of the Government The United States of America is a democratic republic or an indirect government. In definition, it means that when the people vote, they give the power to
More informationAccording to David Barton, in his book Original Intent
JAMES MADISON S DETACHED MEMORANDA 337 The case of navies with insulated crews may be less within the scope of these reflections. But it is not entirely so. The chance of a devout officer, might be of
More informationSOCIAL STUDIES LIFEWORK. The Three Branches of Government 6 th Grade
SOCIAL STUDIES LIFEWORK The Three Branches of Government 6 th Grade Packet due Monday, March 7th! NO LIFEWORK PASSES Call Ms. Seuc for help at 314.724.1056 Monday- classwork Create TEN questions about
More informationColorado and U.S. Constitutions
Courts in the Community Colorado Judicial Branch Office of the State Court Administrator Updated January 2013 Lesson: Objective: Activities: Outcomes: Colorado and U.S. Constitutions Students understand
More informationWhy do you deserve to be at UC Berkeley?
Why do you deserve to be at UC Berkeley? A. I was admitted on my merits because have academic talent, worked hard to succeed, and I met the admissions requirements. B. I know lots of people met the admissions
More informationUnit 8 Review Standard Indicators Which amendments did SC refuse to ratify? 2. What did these two amendments guarantee?
Unit 8 Review Standard Indicators 8-5.1-4 1. Which amendments did SC refuse to ratify? 2. What did these two amendments guarantee? 3. What were the purposes of the Reconstruction plans of the Federal Government?
More informationAmendments THE ERASER ON THE PENCIL: KEEP IT WORKING AND FIX THE PROBLEMS (SOMETIMES DONE IN HASTE, THEN OOPS!)
Amendments 11-27 THE ERASER ON THE PENCIL: KEEP IT WORKING AND FIX THE PROBLEMS (SOMETIMES DONE IN HASTE, THEN OOPS!) 11 th Amendment: Suits Against States Original Text Article 3, Section 2 Amendment
More informationChanging the Constitution STEP BY STEP. the Changing the Constitution reading pages.
Teacher s Guide Time Needed: One to Two Class Periods Materials Needed: Student worksheets Copy Instructions: Reading (2 pages; class set) Activity (3 pages; class set) Changing the Constitution Learning
More informationHEARING QUESTIONS CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT LEVEL. Unit One: What Are the Philosophical and Historical Foundations of the American Political System?
Unit One: What Are the Philosophical and Historical Foundations of the American Political System? 1. How were the Founders' views about government influenced both by classical republicans and the natural
More informationReading Essentials and Study Guide
Lesson 2 The Three Branches of Government ESSENTIAL QUESTION How does the U.S. Constitution structure government and divide power between the national and state governments? Reading HELPDESK Academic Vocabulary
More informationInterpretation of high Crimes and Misdemeanors language in the Utah Constitution, Article VI, Section 19. (2003RR0031)
TO: FROM: RE: Bob Rees, Associate General Counsel Ryan Atkinson, Law Clerk Interpretation of high Crimes and Misdemeanors language in the Utah Constitution, Article VI, Section 19. (2003RR0031) DATE: August
More informationJohn Locke. Source: John Locke, The Second Treatise of Government published 1689
John Locke John Locke was a famous English Enlightenment philosopher that lived from 1632-1704. The following is an excerpt from his Second Treatise on Government. In it, Locke expresses his views on politics
More informationNew Textualism in Constitutional Law
University of Chicago Law School Chicago Unbound Journal Articles Faculty Scholarship 1997 New Textualism in Constitutional Law David A. Strauss Follow this and additional works at: http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/journal_articles
More informationD1 Constitution. Revised. The Constitution (1787) Timeline 2/28/ Declaration of Independence Articles of Confederation (in force 1781)
Revised D1 Constitution Timeline 1776 Declaration of Independence 1777 Articles of Confederation (in force 1781) 1789 United States Constitution (replacing the Articles of Confederation) The Constitution
More informationImpeachment: The Constitution s Fiduciary Meaning of High... Misdemeanors
Impeachment: The Constitution s Fiduciary Meaning of High... Misdemeanors By Robert G. Natelson Note from the Editor: This article explores the meaning of the phrase high... Misdemeanors in the Constitution
More informationName: 2) political party 3) They require large majorities of Congress and of state legislatures.
Name: Directions (1 50): For each statement or question, record on your separate answer sheet the number of the word or expression that, of those given, best completes the statement or answers the question.
More informationWHY THE INCOMPATIBILITY CLAUSE APPLIES TO THE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
WHY THE INCOMPATIBILITY CLAUSE APPLIES TO THE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT SAIKRISHNA BANGALORE PRAKASH* In Why Our Next President May Keep His or Her Senate Seat: A Conjecture on the Constitution s Incompatibility
More informationSeparation of Powers. Introduction to Roles
Introduction to Roles Our government has three separate branches: a legislative branch, an executive branch, and a judicial branch. But how do these three branches work together? This activity will show
More informationAmendment 1 Lawsuit Explained By David Fowler, FACT President
Amendment 1 Lawsuit Explained By David Fowler, FACT President If you have not heard, a lawsuit has been filed in federal court to have the vote on Amendment 1 declared invalid as a violation of the state
More informationGuiding Principles of the Constitution (HAA)
Guiding Principles of the Constitution (HAA) Over the years, the Constitution has acquired an almost sacred status for Americans. Part of the reason for that is its durability: the Constitution has survived,
More informationThe Presidency. AP Government Mr. Zach
The Presidency AP Government Mr. Zach Myth v. Reality: How powerful is the President? What powers does he have? How does his power compare to other world leaders? Are there limits on his powers? What is
More informationThe Constitution. Name: The Law of the Land. What Does Our Constitution Look Like?
The Law of the Land A constitution is a document that gives the rules for how a government should run. The Framers wrote our Constitution to create a government for the new United States of America. Creating
More informationWAR POWERS AND THE CONSTITUTION: 15 YEARS AFTER 9/11
WAR POWERS AND THE CONSTITUTION: 15 YEARS AFTER 9/11 SYMPOSIUM DISCUSSION: PRAKASH APRIL 9, 2016 DRAKE UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL Mariah Zeisberg: I think your defense of congressional supremacy in war is even
More informationChapter 2 Content Statement
Content Statement 6 Chapter 2 Content Statement Cite arguments from the Federalist Papers and/or the Anti- Federalist Papers that supported their position on the issue of how well the Constitution upheld
More informationConstitution Scavenger Hunt Anagram
Constitution Scavenger Hunt Anagram Directions: Using the Constitution, find the correct answer to the clue. Then, indicate by Article, section, and clause the location of the answer. (Not all answers
More informationThat s An Order. Lesson Overview. Procedures
Lesson Overview Overview: This lesson will explore s as used by presidents of the past and present. Students will evaluate the concept of s and establish a position on the constitutionality of executive
More informationAn Introduction to Documents of Freedom
An Introduction to Documents of Freedom In 1781, after the Americans won the Battle of Yorktown, the British General Charles Cornwallis surrendered, effectively ending the Revolutionary War. Tradition
More informationConstitution Day Lesson STEP BY STEP
Teacher s Guide Time Needed: One Class Period Materials Needed: Student worksheets Scissors and glue or tape (optional) Transparency or Projector (optional) Copy Instructions: Reading (4 pages; class set)
More informationConstitution Day Play: The Tinker Case Study
Source: University of Northern Iowa Constitution Day Play: The Tinker Case Study This play could be used in the following way: You could do it as a readers theater, radio theater, or a regular play with
More informationArticle V: Congress, Conventions, and Constitutional Amendments
February 10, 2011 Constitutional Guidance for Lawmakers Article V: Congress, Conventions, and Constitutional Amendments Advocates of a living Constitution argue that the Founders Constitution is hopelessly
More informationInterview with Victor Pickard Author, America s Battle for Media Democracy. For podcast release Monday, December 15, 2014
Interview with Victor Pickard Author, America s Battle for Media Democracy For podcast release Monday, December 15, 2014 KENNEALLY: Under the United States Constitution, the First Amendment protects free
More informationWhy We Should Abolish the Electoral College And How to Do It Script to Accompany Slide Presentation (shorter version)
Why We Should Abolish the Electoral College And How to Do It Script to Accompany Slide Presentation (shorter version) 1 [No script here, just have this up while people are getting seated.] 2 The League
More information2/4/2016. Structure. Structure (cont.) Constitution Amendments and Concepts
Constitution Amendments and Concepts Structure The U.S. Constitution is divided into three parts: the preamble, seven divisions called articles, and the amendments. The Preamble explains why the constitution
More informationChapter 9 - The Constitution: A More Perfect Union
Chapter 9 - The Constitution: A More Perfect Union 9.1 - Introduction When the delegates left Independence Hall in September 1787, they each carried a copy of the Constitution. Their task now was to convince
More information