P&case_id=10CECG00528&begin_date=&end_date=

Transcription

1 P&case_id=10CECG00528&begin_date=&end_date= Report Selection Criteria Case ID: 10CECG00528 Docket Start Date: Docket Ending Date: Case Description Case ID: 10CECG Margaret Mims vs. County of Fresno - -NON JURY- Filing Date: Thursday, February 11th, 2010 Type: 02 - Writ of mandate Status: DEM - Demurrer filed Related Cases No related cases were found. Case Event Schedule Event Date/Time Room Location Judge TRO Order to Show Cause OSC Pre-injunction Status Conference Status Conference Trial Setting Conference Order to Show Cause Order to Show Cause 18-FEB :28 PM 26-MAR :00 AM 14-APR :00 AM 15-APR :00 PM 09-DEC :30 PM 04-MAR :27 PM 18-MAR :00 AM Ex Parte Dept 97D, 2317 Tuolumne Dept 97D, 2317 Tuolumne Dept 97D, 2317 Tuolumne Dept 403, 1130 O Street Dept 403, 1130 O Street Dept 403, 1130 O Street Franson, Donald Franson, Donald Franson, Donald Franson, Donald Franson, Donald Snauffer, Mark W Snauffer, Mark W Status Conference 22-APR-2011 Dept 403, 1130 O Snauffer, Mark W

2 09:00 AM Street Order to Show Cause 29-JUL :00 AM Dept 403, 1130 O Street Snauffer, Mark W Status Conference 23-SEP :00 AM Dept 403, 1130 O Street Snauffer, Mark W Status Conference 20-OCT :30 PM Dept 403, 1130 O Street Snauffer, Mark W Status Conference 17-NOV :27 PM Dept 403, 1130 O Street Snauffer, Mark W Demurrer/Motion Strike 14-DEC :27 PM Dept 403, 1130 O Street Snauffer, Mark W Status Conference 14-DEC :30 PM Dept 403, 1130 O Street Snauffer, Mark W Court Trial 23-MAR :00 AM Dept 403, 1130 O Street Snauffer, Mark W Case Parties Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name 2 23-DEC Address: unavailable Civil Judge For All Purposes DRF Aliases: none Franson, Donald 3 4 Address: unavailable Aliases: Fresno County Sheriff in her official capacity 4 Petitioner/Plaintiff's Atty Mayer, Martin J. Address: 3777 North Harbor Boulevard Jones & Mayer Fullerton CA Aliases: none 5 6 County of Fresno Board of Supervisors

3 Address: unavailable Aliases: none 6 Defendant's Attorney Johnson Jr., Bruce B. Address: 2220 Tulare St., Ste 500 Fresno CA Aliases: none 7 Civil Judge For All Purposes MWS Snauffer, Mark W Address: unavailable Aliases: none Docket Entries Filing Date Description Name Monetary 11-FEB :41 AM 11-FEB :20 PM Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by KFSN TV by Judge Donald Franson filed. le Order filed Order the Court Orders the request to photograph record, or broadcast, signed by Judge D. R. Franson filed. gs 11-FEB :59 PM 11-FEB :59 PM New Civil Case Filed none. Petition Filed 11-FEB :59 PM Petition for writ of mandate and complaint for injunctive relief filed. KEC Government Exemption Claimed Government exemption to payment of filing fees claimed. 11-FEB-2010 Civil case cover sheet

4 04:00 PM 11-FEB :00 PM Civil Case Cover Sheet Summons filed 16-FEB :32 AM 16-FEB :32 AM 16-FEB :33 AM 16-FEB :42 AM 16-FEB :24 PM 16-FEB :15 PM Summons on Petition and Complaint filed. KEC Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by Fresno Bee by Judge Donald Franson filed. le Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by Ksee 24 by Judge Donald Franson filed. le Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by KMPH 26 by Judge Donald Franson filed. le Ex Parte document filed Ex parte application to exceed briefing filed. Hearing Date set on 2/18/2010 at 3:30 p.m. in Dept # 97D. le POS of summons & comp personal Proof of service of summons and complaint filed showing personal service on Bernice E. Seidel on kct Order filed Order Good Cause appearing the Court herrby Grants the Board's application, to file a brief of up to 25 pages in Opposition to Mims ' Ex-Parte Application for Temporary Restraining Order, signed by Judge D. R. Franson filed. gs 16-FEB-2010 Ex Parte document filed

5 04:14 PM Ex parte application for tro and osc re issuance of preliminary injunction filed. Hearing Date set on at 3:30pm in Dept # 97D. KEC 16-FEB :14 PM Declaration of James R. Touchstone regarding ex parte notice of hearing on tro filed. KEC 16-FEB :15 PM 17-FEB :53 PM 18-FEB :09 AM 18-FEB :09 AM 18-FEB :09 AM 18-FEB :10 AM Declaration of Margaret Mims in support of temporary restraining order and request for scheduling of order to show cause hearing filed. KEC Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by KGPE - TV, Granted, by Judge D. R. Franson filed. gs Opposition filed Opposition to ex parte application for tro filed. KEC Declaration of Bernice E. Seidel in opposition to ex parte application for tro filed. KEC Declaration of Jeannie Figueroa in opposition to ex parte application for tro filed. KEC Declaration of John Navarrette in opposition to ex parte application for tro filed. KEC 18-FEB-2010

6 09:11 AM 18-FEB :11 AM 18-FEB :12 AM Declaration of Kathleen Donawa in opposition to ex parte application for tro filed. KEC Evidentiary Objections to declaration of Margaret Mims in support of tro filed. KEC Proof of service filed Proof of service of opposition to ex parte application and supporting documents filed. Served on Martin J. Mayer by personal service at sheriff's administrative building per attorney on KEC 18-FEB :19 PM Order filed 19-FEB :48 AM 02-MAR :34 AM 02-MAR :35 AM Order it is hereby Ordered that Resp. Fresno County Boad of Supervisors appear before this Court in Dept. #97D, on , at 9:00 a.m., (please refer to Order for more info.) signed by Judge D. R. Franson filed. The parties shall adhere to the following Briefing Schedule: Respondents Shpplemental Opposition of no more than 10 pages due no later than , Petitioner's Reply of more than 25 pages due by gs Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 19-FEB-2010 by MDUARTE2. Declaration Bruce B. Johnson in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC Supplemental document filed Supplemental and amended declaration of Kathleen Donawa in opposition to ex parte application for tro and motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC 02-MAR-2010 Supplemental document filed

7 10:35 AM 02-MAR :37 AM 12-MAR :04 AM Supplemental opposition to motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC Supplemental document filed Supplemental and amended declaration of Jeannie Figueroa in opposition to exparte application for tro and motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC Answer filed Answer to petition and complaint filed. TLC 15-MAR :10 AM Reply filed Reply to opposition to motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC 15-MAR :10 AM Declaration of James R. Touchstone in support of motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC 15-MAR :10 AM Objection to supplemental and amended declaration of Kathleen Donawa in opposition to ex parte application filed. KEC 15-MAR :12 AM Objection to supplemental and amended declaration of Jeannie Figueroa in oppostion to ex parte application for tro and motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC 15-MAR :13 AM 22-MAR :34 AM Declaration of Steve Foerker in support of motion for preliminary injunction filed. KEC Order on media request filed

8 22-MAR :34 AM Order on request for media coverage by KFSN by Judge Donald Franson filed. le Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by KGPE by Judge Donald Franson filed. le 23-MAR :19 AM Notice filed 23-MAR :54 AM Notice of lodging of record of underlying governmental proceedings; Declaration of James R Touchstone filed. TLC Ex Parte document filed Ex parte application for submission of oral testimony filed. Hearing Date set on 3/26/10 at 9:00 am in Dept # 97D. TLC 23-MAR :55 AM Req for judicial notice filed TLC 23-MAR :55 AM Objection to declaration of James Touchstone filed. TLC 23-MAR :56 AM 24-MAR :34 AM Motion in Limine filed Motion in Limine No. 1 TLC Response filed Response to objection to declaration of James R Touchstone filed in support of motion for preliminary injunction filed. TLC 24-MAR :35 AM Opposition filed Opposition to respondent's motion in limine No. 1 and objections to declaration of Steve Forker filed. TLC

9 24-MAR :39 AM Objection to respondent's request for judicial notice of Butte county Supervisors' official action of August 6, 1985 filed. TLC 24-MAR :40 AM Opposition filed 25-MAR :36 AM 25-MAR :37 AM 01-APR :43 AM 01-APR :50 AM 01-APR :51 AM Opposition to ex parte application for submission of oral testimony filed. TLC Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by KSEE 24 by Judge Donald Franson filed. le Order on media request filed Order on request for media coverage by KMPH 26 by Judge Donald Franson filed. le Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 01-APR-2010 by MDUARTE2. Minute order Judge Franson Minute Order from Dept.: 97D Clerk: M. Duarte Reporter: Not Reported Nature of Hearing:From Chambers The matter having been under advisment, the Court rules as follows: See attached order dated MMD Order filed Order re Preliminary Injunction- A preliminary injunction shall issue against the Fresno County's Board of Supervisors requiring them to rescind their previous order directing the County Administration Office to lay off 23 correctional officers. The Court also, concludes that the Petitioner has not shown a likelihood of prevailing on the merits of the elimination of the 77 positions within the Sheriff's Department. Based upon the evidence presented, and lack thereof, the additional requests for preliminary injunction are hereby denied. Signed by Judge Donald R. Franson, Jr. filed. MMD

10 09-APR :29 PM 12-APR :30 PM 12-APR :31 PM Order Received for Signature Order: Proposed preliminary injunction Forwarded to: Dept 97D le Declaration of John Navarrette in support of Board of Supervisors' objections to proposed preliminary injunction filed. TLC Objection of Board of Supervisors to Sheriff Mims' proposed preliminary injunction filed. TLC 13-APR :34 AM Response filed 15-APR :38 AM 15-APR :43 PM 26-OCT :09 PM 27-OCT :47 AM Response to objections of board of supervisors sg filed. Preliminary injunction filed The court reserves juridiction to modify this injunction as the ends of justice may require. le Notice sent Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 15-APR-2010 by MDUARTE2. Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 26-OCT-2010 by MDUARTE2. Minute order Judge Franson Minute Order from Dept.: 97D Clerk: M. Duarte Reporter: Not Reported Nature of Hearing: From Chambers Set for 11/18/10 at 3:30 pm in Dept 97D for Trial Setting Conference Other: Court sets the matter for a Trial Setting Conference. Parties may file a short status conference statement five days prior to the hearing mmd

11 10-NOV :32 AM 18-NOV :22 AM 18-NOV :24 AM 18-NOV :25 AM 09-DEC :14 AM 09-DEC :21 PM 14-DEC :25 AM Status conference statement Status conference statement filed. le Minute order Judge Franson Minute Order from Dept.: 97D Clerk: M. Duarte Reporter: Not Reported Nature of Hearing: From Chambers Continued to at 3:30 in Dept 97D for Trial Setting Conference Other: Pursuant to plaintiffs counsel request, the Court continues the Trial Setting Conference set for to See attached letter. mmd Motion for continuance granted none. Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 18-NOV-2010 by MDUARTE2. Minute order Judge Franson Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: K Tobar Reporter: S Davis Nature of Hearing: Trial Setting Conference Set for April 8, 2011 at 8:30 a.m. dept 403 for writ of mandate. The Court sets the matter for a writ of mandate. Parties are limited to a 25 page opening brief due 30 days prior to the hearing. Opposition shall be limited to a 30 page limit due 15 days prior to the hearing. Any reply will be limited to 10 pages and shall be due five days prior. le Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 09-DEC-2010 by KTOBAR. Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 14-DEC-2010 by KTOBAR.

12 23-DEC :24 PM Notice Assignment of Judge Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAPRTY on 23-DEC-2010 by LPETERSON. 14-FEB :53 AM Ex Parte document filed Ex parte application for an order shortening time for hearing of motion to overrule objections to and to compel the depositions of Kathleen Donawa, Jeannie Figueroa and John Navarette; Memorandum of points and authorities filed. Hearing Date set on February 15, 2011at 3:30 in Dept # 403. kct (No RA Copy) 14-FEB :55 AM Declaration of Denise L. Rocawich in support of ex parte application for an order shortening time filed. kct 14-FEB :56 AM Stipulation 14-FEB :47 PM 14-FEB :34 PM 24-FEB :59 PM Stipulation of the parties to shorten time on hearing of motion to overrule objections to and to compel the depositions of Kathleen Donawa, Jeannie Figueroa and John Navarette. kct Off calendar Off calendar for motion for protective order scheduled for 4/6/11 per moving party lp. Off calendar Off calendar for motion to compel scheduled for 2/15/11 by Touchstone lp Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B Danielson Reporter: Not reported Nature of Hearing:From Chambers Set for March 4, 2011 at 3:30 dept 403 for OSC re; why the court should not dissolve the prelim/injunc and dismiss petition for writ of mandate as moot. see attached order. le

13 25-FEB :59 PM 03-MAR :30 AM Order to show cause filed Order to show cause re: why court should not dissolve prelim/injunc and dismiss petition signed by Judge Mark Snauffer filed. le Order Received for Signature Order: to continue hrg. Forwarded to: Dept. #403 gs 04-MAR :43 AM Stipulation and Order filed Stipulation and order - that the Order to show cause why court should not dissolve preliminary injunction and dismiss petition for Writ of Mandate as Moot previously set for March 4, 2011 shall be continued to March 18, 2011 at 9:00 a.m. in dept 403. signed by Judge Mark Snauffer and filed. le 09-MAR :32 AM Brief filed Petitioners Opening Brief in support of petition for Writ of Mandate csp 09-MAR :33 AM Declaration of Margaret Mims in Support of petitioners Opening brief in Support of Petition for Writ of Mandate csp 09-MAR :33 AM Declaration of James R touchstone in Support of Petitioners Opening Brief in Support of Petition for Writ of Mandate filed. csp 15-MAR :54 PM Response filed 16-MAR :56 PM Response to order to show cause filed. le Notice filed Defendant Board of Supervisors Memorandum concerning Order to Show Cause Re: Mootness Issue Court Date 03/18/2011 9am Dept 403 csp

14 18-MAR :55 AM 18-MAR :45 AM 18-MAR :27 PM 08-APR :16 AM 22-APR :24 AM 22-APR :38 AM Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 18-MAR-2011 by Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 18-MAR-2011 by Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B Danielson Reporter: M Pish Nature of Hearing: Order to show cause Continued to April 22, 2011 at 9:00 a.m. dept 403 for status hearing. The court vacates the briefing schedule and the hearing set for April 8, Further proceedings on the writ of mandate are stayed pending further order by the court. le Off calendar Off calendar for WRTM scheduled for 04/08/2011 continued to 04/22/2011 at 9am dept 403 per minute order of 03/18/2011. csp Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 22-APR-2011 by KARTIS. Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: K Artis Reporter: M Pish Nature of Hearing:Status Conference. Set for OSC on at 9am in Dept 403 skp 22-JUL :50 PM Declaration of Margaret Mims in response to order to show cause filed. ks 25-JUL :04 AM Declaration of James R. Touchstone in response to order to show cause filed. ks

15 25-JUL :54 AM 29-JUL :00 AM 29-JUL :17 AM 29-JUL :48 PM 10-AUG :55 AM 10-AUG :03 PM 10-AUG :03 PM Declaration of Bruce B Johnson in support of Board of Supervisors Reply regarding OSC hearing on Topic of Mootnes filed. Placed in dept 503 basket csp Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 29-JUL-2011 by Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 29-JUL-2011 by Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B. Danielson Reporter: M. Pish Nature of Hearing: Order to Show Cause - Matter argued and submitted. Taken under advisement sg Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 10-AUG-2011 by Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B. Danielson Reporter: none Nature of Hearing: From Chambers Matter having been under advisement, the court rules as follows: see attached order. Matter set for status conference on at 9:00am in dept Court dissolves preliminary injunction & permits petitioner to filean amended pleading within 10 days. gar Order filed Order signed by Judge Snauffer filed. Court finds there is still a justiciable controversy although petition seeking writ of mandate concerning the budget is moot. Court dissolves preliminary injunction entered on

16 concerning the June 30, budget year and permit the petitioner to file an amended petition within 10 days. Court schedules a status conference for at 9am in dept gar 23-AUG :41 AM Amended document filed 14-SEP :39 AM 14-SEP :40 AM 15-SEP :01 AM 15-SEP :02 AM 15-SEP :03 AM 15-SEP :04 AM Amended Petition for Writ of Mandate and Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief filed. gar Motion for continuance granted Status Conference set for 9/16/11 has been continued to 9/23/11 at 9:00 am in D 403 due to Judge's unavailibility. lp Notice of Cal Setting Printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CSAEVNT on 14-SEP-2011 by LPETERSON. Notice of hearing filed Notice of hearing on Demurrer to First Amended Petition and Complaint filed. Hearing set on 10/20/11 at 3:30pm in Dept #403. lmi Demurrer filed Defendant Board of Supervisors' Demurrer to First Amended Petition and Complaint lmi Memorandum of P & A filed Memorandum of points and authorities Supporting Defendant Board of Supervisors Demurrer to First Amended Petition and Complaint lmi Req for judicial notice filed Request for Judicial Notice lmi 15-SEP :04 AM Notice filed

17 15-SEP :04 AM 23-SEP :56 AM 23-SEP :57 AM 23-SEP :20 AM 23-SEP :46 AM 26-SEP :40 AM 26-SEP :40 AM Notice of Defndant Board of Supervisors; Motion to Strike Portions of First Amended Petition and Complaint filed lmi. Memorandum of P & A filed Memorandum of points and authorities supporting Defendant Board of Supervisors Motion to Strike Portions of First Amended Petition & Complaint lmi Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 23-SEP-2011 by Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 23-SEP-2011 by Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B. Danielson Reporter: M. Pish Nature of Hearing: Status Conference - continued to 10/20/11 at 3:30 in Dept 403. Telephonic appearance OK. db Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 23-SEP-2011 by Supplemental document filed Supplemental and Amended Notice of Hearing on Demurrer filed. gs Supplemental document filed Supplemental and Amended Demurrer filed. gs 26-SEP :40 AM Supplemental document filed

18 04-OCT :54 AM 11-OCT :53 PM 14-OCT :12 PM 14-OCT :13 PM Supplemental and Amended Notice of Motion to Strike filed. gs Order Received for Signature Order: to file 2nd amended complaint Forwarded to: Dept. # 403 gs Stipulation and Order filed Stipulation and order permitting filing of second amended petition and complaint, and taking demurrer and motion to strike off calendar signed by Judge Mark W. Snauffer and filed. ks Off calendar Off calendar for demurrer scheduled for 10/20/2011. Per research attorney. le Off calendar Off calendar for motion to strike scheduled for 10/20/2011. Per research attorney. le 17-OCT :09 PM Amended document filed 20-OCT :08 AM 21-OCT :13 PM 24-OCT :18 AM Seond Amended Petition for Writ of Mandate and Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief filed. lmi Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B. Danielson Reporter: M. Pish Nature of Hearing: Status Conference Continued to November 17, 2011 at 3:30 Dept. 403 for Status Conference. Note: The court did not have the file. (gac) Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 21-OCT-2011 by

19 Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 24-OCT-2011 by 14-NOV :50 AM Demurrer filed (gac) 14-NOV :50 AM 14-NOV :50 AM Notice of hearing filed Notice of hearing of Demurrer to 2nd amended petition and complaint filed. Hearing set on at 3:30 in 403. (gac) Memorandum of P & A filed Memorandum of points and authorities in supporting defendant Board of Supervisors' Demurrer to 2nd amended petition and complaint filed. (gac) 14-NOV :50 AM Req for judicial notice filed (gac) 14-NOV :50 AM 17-NOV :58 AM 18-NOV :29 AM 23-NOV :40 AM Notice of motion filed Notice of Defendant Board of Supervisors motion to Strike Portions of 2nd amended Petition and Complaint filed. Hearing set on at 3:30 in 403. (gac) Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B Danielson Reporter: M Pish Nature of Hearing: Status Conference Case is continued to 12/14/11 at 9:30 am in D 403 for Status Conference. lp Minute order printed Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 18-NOV-2011 by Minute order printed

20 23-NOV :15 AM Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 23-NOV-2011 by Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 23-NOV-2011 by 01-DEC :48 PM Opposition filed Opposition to Motion to strike protions of second amended petitioner and complaint filed. ks (no RA copy) 01-DEC :49 PM Opposition filed 09-DEC :41 AM 09-DEC :41 AM 14-DEC :53 PM 19-DEC :27 AM Opposition to Demurrer to second amended petition for writ of mandate and complaint for injuctive and declaratory relief filed. ks Reply filed Reply brief Re: Board of Supervisors' motion to strike portions of the second amended petition and complaint filed. (gac) Reply filed Reply brief Re: Board of Supervisors' Demurrer to the second amended petition and complaint filed. (gac) Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: #403 Clerk: B. Danielson Reporter: M. Pish Nature of Hearing: Demurrer / Motion to Strike Continued to at 10:00 a.m. in Dept. #403 for Hearing on complaint for declaratory relief. Tentative ruling becomes the Order of the Court. No further order is necessary. Parties are instructed to submit an order. The briefing schedule is as follows: Opening breif due , Opposition due reply Partis stipulate to limiting the briefs as follows Opening 25-pages, Oppositon 30-pages, Reply 5- pages. To Overrule the Demurrer and to Deny the Motion to Strike. gs gs Minute order printed

21 19-DEC :20 AM 23-DEC :38 PM 28-DEC :21 PM 03-JAN :27 PM Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 19-DEC-2011 by Docket entry for the letter produced from CDAEVNT on 19-DEC-2011 by Answer filed Answer to 2nd amended petiton and complaint filed. (gac) Order Received for Signature Order: Following Status hearing; Order on Defendants' Demurrer and Motion to Strike Forwarded to: Dept 403 csp Order filed Order followings stays hearing; Order on Defendants; Demurrer and Motion to Strike signed by Judge Mark W. Snauffer filed. The Demurrer is overruled and the motion to strike is denied. The Trial shall commence on March 23, 2012 at 10:00 in Department 403. ks 23-JAN :34 PM Notice filed Notice of Petitioner's Opening Brief in Support of Complaint for Declaratory Relief filed. gs 23-JAN :34 PM Declaration of James R. Touchstone in Support of Opening Brief filed. gs 23-JAN :34 PM Declaration of Margaret Mims in Support of Petitioner's Opening Brief filed. gs 23-JAN :37 PM Req for judicial notice filed

22 23-FEB :05 AM 23-FEB :08 AM 23-FEB :09 AM 23-FEB :11 AM 23-FEB :13 AM 23-FEB :15 AM 23-FEB :16 AM 23-FEB :17 AM gs Opposition filed Defendant Board of superviosors' Opposition Brief Re: Complaint for Declaratory Relief filed. dhouston Proof of service filed Proof of service of Pleadings Supporting Defendant Board of Superviosr's Opposition Brief filed. Served on Martin J. Mayer by mail on 2/23/12. dhouston Declaration of John Navarrette Re: Declaratory Relief Trial filed. dhouston Declaration of Jeannie Figuerroa Re: Declaratory Relief Trial filed. dhouston Declaration of Kathleen Donawa in support of board's opposition brief filed. dhouston Declaration of Bernice E. Seidel in support of board's opposition brief filed. dhouston Declaration of Bruce B. Johnson Re: Declaratory Relief Trial filed. dhouston Declaration of Joseph J. Benbera, Ph.D Re: Declaratory Relief Trial filed. dhouston

23 23-FEB :18 AM 23-FEB :20 AM 23-FEB :22 AM Declaration of Bart Bohn Re: Declaratory Relief Trial filed. dhouston Appendix of Authorities Supporting Defendants Board of Suppervisors Opposition Brief filed. dhouston Defendant's Evidentiary Objections to Declaration of Margaret Mims filed. dhouston 05-MAR :26 PM Reply filed Petitioners Reply to Defendnat Board of Supervisors Opposition Brief Re: Complaint for Declaratory Relief Court Date 03/23/ am Dept 403 csp 05-MAR :26 PM Objections to Declaration of John Navarrette re; Declaratory Relief Trial Court Date 03/23/ am Dept 403 csp 05-MAR :28 PM Objections to Declarationof Jeannie Figueroa re: Declaratory Relief Trial Court Date 03/23/ am Dept 403 csp 05-MAR :29 PM 20-MAR :48 AM Objection to Declaration of Kathleen Donawa Re: Declaraatory Relief Trial filed. Court Date 03/23/ am Dept 403 csp Defendant's Evidentiary Objections to Declaration of James R. Touchstone; Supporting Declaration of Kathleen Donawa filed. (gac)

24 23-MAR :20 AM 27-MAR :44 PM 03-MAY :06 AM 03-MAY :31 PM 03-MAY :31 PM 18-MAY :37 PM Minute order - Judge Snauffer Minute Order from Dept.: 403 Clerk: B. Danielson Reporter: M. Pish Nature of Hearing: Civil Court Trial Minute Order~ 1st Day The above entitled matter comes on regularly before the Honorable Mark W. Snauffer at 10:03 a.m. Martin Mayer and James Touchstone appearing for the plaintiff, and defense counsel, Bruce Johnson, come into open Court, this being the time heretofore set for trial of this action. Court and counsel further address matters of law and procedure as stated fully on the record. Parties are each to submit a proposed judgment and statement of decision dy April 27, The Court will take this matter under submission once it recieves the requested materials from both sides. The Court is adjourned, ks Docket entry for the letter produced from CDADOCT on 27-MAR-2012 by Order Received for Signature Order: statement of decision Forwarded to: 403 (gac) Order Received for Signature Order:proposed statement of decision Forwarded to: 403 sg Judgment Received Forwarded to: dept. 403 sg Objection to Sheriff Mims' Proposed Statement of Decision filed. msm 18-MAY :14 PM Plaintiff's Objections to proposed statement of decision filed. (gac)