Event Date/Time Room Location Judge CITY HALL CITY HALL

Transcription

1 No Items in Cart A $5 Convenience fee will be added to the transaction at checkout. Case Description Case ID: Case Caption: ALEXANDER ETAL VS FRIENDS HOSPITAL ETAL Filing Date: Thursday, November 14th, 2013 Court: MAJOR JURY-COMPLEX Location: City Hall Jury: JURY Case Type: MALPRACTICE - MEDICAL Status: LISTED FOR SETTLEMENT CONF Related Cases No related cases were found. Case Event Schedule Event Date/Time Room Location Judge DISCOVERY HEARING 10-MAR :00 AM CITY HALL COURTROOM 246 DISCOVERY HEARING 24-MAR :00 AM CITY HALL COURTROOM 246 PROJECTED SETTLEMENT CONF DATE 07-SEP :00 AM City Hall Courtroom 246 City Hall BERNSTEIN, MARK I PROJECTED PRE-TRIAL CONF. DATE 02-NOV :00 AM City Hall Courtroom 246 City Hall BERNSTEIN, MARK I PROJECTED TRIAL DATE 07-DEC :00 AM City Hall Courtroom 246 City Hall BERNSTEIN, MARK I Case motions Motion Assign/Date Control No Date/Received Judge PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS pending FEB-2014 BERNSTEIN, MARK I PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS pending MAR-2014 BERNSTEIN, MARK I PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS pending MAR-2014 BERNSTEIN, MARK I Case Parties Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type Name 1 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM

2 2 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM 1 ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF Address: 1600 MARKET STREET 25TH FLOOR (215) CURRIE, JCRAIG 2 1 PLAINTIFF ALEXANDER, EDSHIONA Address: 4309 BROWN STREET PHILADELPHIA PA PLAINTIFF DAVIS, VERNON Address: 4309 BROWN STREET PHILADELPHIA PA FRIENDS HOSPITAL Address: 4641 ROOSEVELT BOULEVARD PHILADELPHIA PA BERGER, D.O., ALEXANDER Address: 4641 ROOSEVELT BOULEVARD PHILADELPHIA PA LEACH, M.D., DAVID M Address: 4641 ROOSEVELT BOULEVARD PHILADELPHIA PA DEC-2013 TEAM LEADER FOX, IDEE C Address: 656 City Hall PHILADELPHIA PA (215) FEB-2014 ATTORNEY FOR Address: 1800 JOHN F. KENNEDY BLVD. SUITE 1900 TURSI, BENJAMIN J

3 3 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM (215) FEB-2014 ATTORNEY FOR Address: MARKS O'NEILL O'BRIEN COURTNEY 1800 JFK BLVD STE 1900 (215) COURTNEY DOHERTY, DAWN 10 ATTORNEY FOR Address: ONE PENN CENTER - 19TH FL 1617 JOHN F. KENNEDY BLVD (215) HARE, KIRSTEN B ATTORNEY FOR Address: ONE PENN CENTER, 19TH FL JOHN F. KENNEDY BLVD (215) WESSEL, RUTH R 12 TEAM LEADER BERNSTEIN, MARK I Address: 530 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA (215) FEB-2014 ATTORNEY FOR Address: MARKS, O NEILL, O'BRIEN DOHERTY & KELLY, P.C JFK BLVD., STE 1900 (215) MERLINI, MARK P 14 ATTORNEY FOR GOLDBERG, JOSEPH

4 4 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM Address: WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLE TON FIRES & NEWBY 2000 MARKET ST 13TH FLOOR (215) ATTORNEY FOR Address: 2000 MARKET STREET 13TH FL (215) GENESIO, C JACQUELINE 16 8 ATTORNEY FOR Address: MARKS, O NEILL, O'BRIEN DOHERTY & KELLY, P.C JFK BLVD., STE 1900 (215) MERLINI, MARK P 17 1 ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF Address: 1800 JOHN F. KENNEDY BLVD. SUITE 1900 (215) TURSI, BENJAMIN J Entries Filing Date/Time 14-NOV :04 AM Type Filing Party Disposition Amount Approval/ Entry Date ACTIVE CASE 14-NOV :06 AM E-Filing Number: NOV :04 AM COMMENCEMENT OF CIVIL ACTION CURRIE, JCRAIG 14-NOV :06 AM Final Cover

5 5 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM none. 14-NOV :04 AM COMPLAINT FILED NOTICE GIVEN CURRIE, JCRAIG 14-NOV :06 AM Compl COMs to be filed.pdf COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE FILED. 14-NOV :04 AM none. SHERIFF'S SURCHARGE 3 DEFTS CURRIE, JCRAIG 14-NOV :06 AM 14-NOV :04 AM none. WAITING TO LIST CASE MGMT CONF CURRIE, JCRAIG 14-NOV :06 AM 08-DEC :14 PM AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED 09-DEC :28 AM Affidavit of Service AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT UPON FRIENDS HOSPITAL BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 12/03/2013 FILED. 08-DEC :17 PM AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED 09-DEC :28 AM Affidavit of Service AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT UPON DAVID M LEACH, M.D. BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 12/03/2013 FILED. 08-DEC :20 PM AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED 09-DEC :29 AM Affidavit of Service

6 6 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT UPON ALEXANDER BERGER, D.O. BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 12/03/2013 FILED. 16-DEC :14 AM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED TURSI, BENJAMIN J 16-DEC :31 PM Entry (PH717544@x9F838).pdf ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF DAWN R COURTNEY AND BENJAMIN J TURSI FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRIENDS HOSPITAL) 19-DEC :40 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED HARE, KIRSTEN B 19-DEC :45 PM Entry_of_Appearance.PDF ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF KIRSTEN B HARE AND RUTH R WESSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF ALEXANDER BERGER, D.O.) 19-DEC :40 PM JURY TRIAL PERFECTED 19-DEC :45 PM 12 JURORS REQUESTED. 19-DEC :45 PM none. TRANSFERRED TO MAJOR JURY 19-DEC :00 AM 19-DEC :45 PM none. WAITING TO LIST CASE MGMT CONF 19-DEC :00 AM 23-DEC :08 AM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS HARE, KIRSTEN B 23-DEC :09 AM PRELIMINARY_OBJECTIONS_-_VERNON_DAVIS_CASE.PDF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' COMPLAINT FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 01/13/2014 (FILED ON BEHALF OF ALEXANDER BERGER, D.O.)

7 7 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM 23-DEC :10 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED TURSI, BENJAMIN J 23-DEC :13 PM EOA- Leach (PH719806@x9F838).pdf ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF DAWN R COURTNEY AND BENJAMIN J TURSI FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAVID M LEACH, M.D.) 23-DEC :36 PM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS COURTNEY DOHERTY, DAWN 23-DEC :43 PM Preliminary_Objections_to_Plaintiffs_Complaint.pdf Memorandum_of_Law_in_Support_of_POs_to_Plaintiffs_Complaint.pdf Exhibit_A_to_Preliminary_Objections_to_Plaintiffs_Complaint.pdf PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' COMPLAINT FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 01/13/2014 (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAVID M LEACH, M.D. AND FRIENDS HOSPITAL) 02-JAN :36 AM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL MERLINI, MARK P 02-JAN :43 AM EOA- MPM (PH721090@x9F838).pdf ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MARK P MERLINI AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAVID M LEACH, M.D. AND FRIENDS HOSPITAL) 09-JAN :29 AM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL GOLDBERG, JOSEPH 09-JAN :29 AM Entry and Jury Demand.pdf ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF C JACQUELINE GENESIO AND JOSEPH GOLDBERG AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAVID M LEACH, M.D.) 09-JAN :29 AM JURY TRIAL PERFECTED 09-JAN :29 AM 12 JURORS REQUESTED. 15-JAN :21 PM PRELIM OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED 15-JAN :21 PM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: BERNSTEIN, MARK I. ON DATE: JANUARY 15, 2014

8 8 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM 15-JAN :21 PM PRELIM OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED 15-JAN :21 PM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: BERNSTEIN, MARK I. ON DATE: JANUARY 15, JAN :35 PM BRIEF-PRELIM. OBJECT. FILED CURRIE, JCRAIG 24-JAN :57 PM FINAL 2 of MOL contra Friends signed.pdf BRIEF IN OPPOSITION OF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF VERNON DAVIS AND EDSHIONA ALEXANDER) 23-JAN :22 AM BRIEF-PRELIM. OBJECT. FILED CURRIE, JCRAIG 24-JAN :57 PM FINAL MOL contra Berger.pdf BRIEF IN OPPOSITION OF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF VERNON DAVIS AND EDSHIONA ALEXANDER) 27-JAN :05 PM PREL OBJECT-ASSIGNMENT UPDATED REASSIGNED TO JUDGE FOGLIETTA, ANGELO ON 27-JAN JAN :05 PM 27-JAN :06 PM PREL OBJECT-ASSIGNMENT UPDATED REASSIGNED TO JUDGE FOGLIETTA, ANGELO ON 27-JAN JAN :06 PM 29-JAN :23 PM ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN FOGLIETTA, ANGELO 29-JAN :23 PM ORDER_26.pdf IT IS ORDERED THAT S' FRIENDS HOSPITAL AND DR. LEACH'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE SUSTAINED. PLAINTIFF SHALL HAVE TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER IN WHICH TO FILE AN AMENDED COMPLAINT. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT 1) ALL CLAIMS FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES AGAINST S FRIENDS HOSPITAL AND DR. LEACH, INCLUDING THE CLAIMS OF "WILLFUL MISCONDUCT" IN PARAGRAPH 53 AND 61 OF PLAINTIFFS' COMPLAITN SHALL BE STRICKEN AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE; AND 2) PARAGRAPHS 54(N), 54(O), 59(M), 59(N) AND 61 OF PLAINTIFFS' COMPLAINT SHALL BE STRICKEN

9 9 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE....BY THE COURT; FOGLIETTA, J JAN :23 PM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE JAN :50 PM NOTICE GIVEN ON 30-JAN-2014 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 29-JAN JAN :41 PM ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN FOGLIETTA, ANGELO 29-JAN :41 PM ORDER_27.pdf IT IS ORDERED THAT: 1. ALL CLAIMS FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES AGAINST DR. BERGER, INCLUDING THE CLAIMS OF "WILLFULL CONDUCT", "GROSS NEGLIGENCE", "WILLFUL MISCONDUCT", "GROSS AND CARELESS LACK OF CONFORMITY WITH THE RECOGNIZED STANDARDS OF THE MENTAL HEALTH PROFESSION" STATED AGAINST DR. BERGER AT PARAGRAPHS 50, 51 AND 59 ARE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. 2. PARAGRAPH 50(C) AND ALL CLAIMS FOR DECEDENT'S LOSS OF LIFE'S PLEASURES ARE STRICKEN WITH PREJUDICE. 3. PLAINTIFF SHALL HAVE TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER IN WHICH TO FILE AN AMENDED COMPLAINT....BY THE COURT; FOGLIETTA, J JAN :41 PM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE JAN :48 PM NOTICE GIVEN ON 30-JAN-2014 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 29-JAN FEB :43 PM none. LISTED FOR CASE MGMT CONF 03-FEB :43 PM 05-FEB :41 AM none. NOTICE GIVEN 05-FEB :41 AM 05-FEB :27 PM WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE TURSI, BENJAMIN J 06-FEB :17 AM Withdrawal (PH731500@x9F838).pdf WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE OF BENJAMIN J. TURSI, DAWN R. COURTNEY, MARK P. MERLINI FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAVID M LEACH, M.D.)

10 10 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM 08-FEB :31 AM none. NOTICE GIVEN 08-FEB :31 AM 14-FEB :47 PM AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED CURRIE, JCRAIG 18-FEB :22 AM 1st Amend. Comp. Sign Verif.pdf AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY(20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF VERNON DAVIS AND EDSHIONA ALEXANDER) none. CASE MGMT CONFERENCE COMPLETED SULLIVAN, JOAN CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ISSUED CMOIS_36.pdf CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER-MEDICAL MALPRACTICE CASE AND NOW,, it is Ordered that: 1. The case management and time standards adopted for Medical Malpractice cases shall be applicable to this case and are hereby incorporated into this Order. 2. All discovery on the above matter shall be completed not later than 01-JUN Plaintiff shall identify and submit curriculum vitae and expert reports of all expert witnesses intended to testify at trial to all other parties not later than 06-JUL Defendant and any additional defendants shall identify and submit curriculum vitae and expert reports of all expert witnesses intended to testify at trial not later than 03-AUG All pre-trial motions shall be filed not later than 03-AUG A settlement conference may be scheduled at any time after 07-SEP Prior to the settlement conference all counsel shall serve all opposing counsel and file a settlement memorandum containing the following:(a) A concise summary of the nature of the case if plaintiff or of the defense if defendant or additional defendant; (b) A statement by the plaintiff or all damages accumulated, including an itemization of injuries and all special damages claimed by categories and amount;(c) Defendant shall identify all applicable insurance carriers, together with applicable limits of liability. 7. A pre-trial conference will be scheduled any time after 02-NOV Fifteen days prior to pre-trial conference, all counsel shall serve all opposing counsel and file a pre-trial memorandum containing the following: (a) A concise summary of the nature of the case if plaintiff or the defense if defendant or additional defendant; (b) A list of all witnesses who may be called to testify at trial by name and address. Counsel should expect witnesses not listed to be precluded from testifying at trial; (c) A list of all exhibits the party intends to offer into evidence. All exhibits shall be pre-numbered and shall be exchanged among counsel prior to the conference. Counsel should expect any exhibit not

11 11 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM listed to be precluded at trial; (d) Plaintiff shall list an itemization of injuries or damages sustained together with all special damages claimed by category and amount. This list shall include as appropriate, computations of all past lost earnings and future lost earning capacity or medical expenses together with any other Unliquidated damages claimed; and (e) Defendant shall state its position regarding damages and shall identify all applicable insurance carriers, together with applicable limits of liability; (f) Each counsel shall provide an estimate of the anticipated length of trial. 8. It is expected that the case will be ready for trial 07-DEC-2015, and counsel should anticipate trial to begin expeditiously thereafter. 9. All counsel are under a continuing obligation and are hereby ordered to serve a copy of this order upon all unrepresented parties and upon all counsel entering an appearance subsequent to the entry of this order. BY THE COURT: MARK BERNSTEIN, J., TEAM LEADER none. LISTED FOR SETTLEMENT CONF none. LISTED FOR PRE-TRIAL CONF none. LISTED FOR TRIAL NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE FEB :11 PM NOTICE GIVEN ON 24-FEB-2014 OF CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ISSUED ENTERED ON. 25-FEB :18 AM NOTICE OF INTENT/PARCP MERLINI, MARK P 25-FEB :30 AM Notice of Intent (PH737311@x9F838).pdf NOTICE OF INTENT TO ENTER JUDGMENT OF NON PROS FOR FAILURE TO FILE CERTIFICATE OF MERIT TO VERNON DAVIS AND EDSHIONA ALEXANDER. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ATTACHED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRIENDS HOSPITAL) 25-FEB :57 PM DISCOVERY HEARING REQST FILED TURSI, BENJAMIN J 25-FEB :08 PM

12 12 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM MTC Pl Discovery DISCOVERY HEARING REQUEST FILED IN RE: MOTION TO COMPEL ANSWERS AND PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS. HEARING SCHEDULED FOR: MARCH 10, 2014 AT 10:00 IN ROOM 246 CITY HALL. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRIENDS HOSPITAL) 26-FEB :00 PM CERTIFICATION FILED HARE, KIRSTEN B 26-FEB :02 PM Certificate_Prerequisite_To_Service_Of_A_Subpoena.PDF CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF SUBPOENAS PURSUANT TO RULE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF ALEXANDER BERGER, D.O.) 27-FEB :12 AM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS MERLINI, MARK P 27-FEB :14 AM POs to 1st Amended (PH738357@x9F838).pdf PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 03/19/2014 (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRIENDS HOSPITAL) 05-MAR :33 PM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS HARE, KIRSTEN B 05-MAR :35 PM Preliminary Objections.PDF Exhibits_A_to_D (1).PDF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 03/25/2014 (FILED ON BEHALF OF ALEXANDER BERGER, D.O.) 05-MAR :15 PM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS GENESIO, C JACQUELINE 06-MAR :35 AM POs of David Leach M.D. to Amended Complaint.pdf PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 03/26/2014 (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAVID M LEACH, M.D.) 11-MAR :11 PM DISCOVERY HEARING REQST FILED HARE, KIRSTEN B 11-MAR :13 PM Motion_for_QPO.PDF

13 13 of 13 3/19/ :52 PM DISCOVERY HEARING REQUEST FILED IN RE: MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER. HEARING SCHEDULED FOR: MARCH 24, 2014 AT 10:00 IN ROOM 246 CITY HALL. (FILED ON BEHALF OF ALEXANDER BERGER, D.O.) 18-MAR :56 PM AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED CURRIE, JCRAIG 19-MAR :43 AM FINAL 2ND Amend Complt DELETs - WILLFUL GROSS further re Hosp Leach [time stamp removed].pdf AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY(20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF VERNON DAVIS AND EDSHIONA ALEXANDER)