SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF MARIN DATE FILED: CASE TYPE: CASE SUBTYPE: DATE OF LAST ACTIVITY: DATE/TIME RUN:

Transcription

1 INVOLVED PERSON/PARTY AND ATTORNEY SUMMARY: REGISTER OF ACTIONS: GROUPP, DOUGLAS is the PLAINTIFF and is represented by: WESTER, BARRY F. VIACOM, INC. is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: AT&T CORPORATION is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: BUTLER SHINE STERN AND PARTNERS is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: KIMBER MANAGEMENT, LLC is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: RECTOR, THOMAS A. CLIPPER YACHT COMPANY is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: MARINSHIP CORPORATION SHIPYARD is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: LAND AND FERRY COMPANY is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: MORGAN, S.L. is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: PEDERSON, C.M. is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: MARTERIE, ANTHONY J. is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: RECTOR, THOMAS A. MARTERIE, ROXANNE is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: RECTOR, THOMAS A. MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED MARCH 15, 2010 is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: RECTOR, THOMAS A. A.G. SCHOONMAKER COMPANY, INC. is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY is the DEFENDANT and is represented by: DONNELLAN, GERARD J TOMLINSON, PAULINE is the GUARDIAN and is represented by: WESTER, BARRY F. AT&T SERVICES, INC. (1) is the CROSS DEFENDANT and is represented by: DONNELLAN, GERARD J MARTERIE, ANTHONY J. (2) is the CROSS DEFENDANT and is represented by: RECTOR, THOMAS A. MARTERIE, ROXANNE (2) is the CROSS DEFENDANT and is represented by: RECTOR, THOMAS A. MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED MARCH 15, 2010 (2) is the CROSS DEFENDANT and is represented by: RECTOR, THOMAS A. 07/02/2013 CASE OPEN / ACTIVE STATUS HON. LYNN DURYEE 07/02/2013 FILING FEE PROCESSED: PLTF, /02/2013 /FIRST PAPER FOR GENERAL NEGLIGENCE AND GROSS NEGLIGENCE 07/03/2013 HEARING CONFIRMED FOR: 09/12/2013 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D03 07/03/2013 HEARING CONFIRMED FOR: 10/11/2013 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D03 07/03/2013 HEARING CONFIRMED FOR: 11/22/2013 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D03 09/12/2013 MINUTE ORDER POSTED JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE LYNN DURYEE, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK S. HENDRYX NO APPEARANCE BY OR FOR THE DEFENDANT THE OSC RE: PROOF OF SERVICE IS CONTINUED TO AT 9:00 A.M. IN DEPT. L THE OSC RE: ANSWER IS MOVED TO AT 9:00 A.M. IN DEPT. L HEARING CONTINUED TO: 11/22/2013 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D03 FROM DATE: 09/12/2013 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH FROM DEPARTMENT: D03 Page 1 of 11

2 10/10/2013 APPEARANCE DROPPED FOR 10/11/2013 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D03 DROP REASON: OSC RE: ANSWER MOVED ON /22/2013 MINUTE ORDER POSTED JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE LYNN DURYEE, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK S. HENDRYX ATTORNEY MATT BREKUS APPEARED FOR SPECIALLY APPEARING FOR PLAINTIFF NO APPEARANCE BY OR FOR THE DEFENDANT THIS MATTER COMES ON CALENDAR ON AN OS RE: PROOF OF SERVICE, AN OSC RE: ANSWER AND FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE. MR, BREKUS REPORTS THE OWNERSHIP OF THE PROPERTY IN THIS MATTER IS IN QUESTION. THIS MATTER SHALL BE CONTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE AND OSC RE: PROOF OF SERVICE TO AT 9:00 A.M. IN DEPT. L HEARING CONTINUED TO: 01/03/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D03 FROM DATE: 11/22/2013 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH FROM DEPARTMENT: D03 HEARING CONTINUED TO: 01/03/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D03 FROM DATE: 11/22/2013 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D03 12/16/2013 JURY FEE DEPOSIT $150 BY PLTF ATTY 12/16/2013 AMENDED FILED (1ST) BY ATTY JOSEPH HOFFMAN OBO PLTF (NO ADDITIONAL PARTIES) 12/16/2013 SUMMONS ISSUED (1ST AMENDED) AND FILED 12/20/2013 PROOF OF SERVICE FILED, AS TO: RESP, BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 12/19/2013 (DEBBIE PAGLIARO, CITY CLERK) 12/20/2013 APPEARANCE DROPPED FOR 01/03/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D03 DROP REASON: POS FILED 01/03/2014 MINUTE ORDER POSTED JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE LYNN DURYEE, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK S. HENDRYX ATTORNEY JOHN ABACI APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT DEFENDANT WAS JUST RECENTLY SERVED WITH THE. DEFENDANT REQUESTS A CONTINUANCE TO ALLOW TIME TO ANSWER OR DEMUR. THIS MATTER SHALL BE CONTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE TO AT 9:00 A.M. IN DEPT. L. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 02/20/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D03 FROM DATE: 01/03/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D03 01/28/2014 AMENDMENT TO FILED, AS TO: TRUE NAME OF DEFTS DOE 1-3 SEE CSTXT OF 1/28/14: COMCAST, INC., (DOE 4); VIACOM, INC., (DOE 5); AT&T CORP, (DOE 6); PACIFIC BELL CORP, (DOE 7); BUTLER SHINE STERN AND PARTNERS, (DOE 8); KIMBER MANAGEMENT, LLC (DOE 9); AND DOES (SEE FILE) 01/28/2014 COMPLETE NAME OF DEFT DOE 1, THE PERSON WHO, AND /OR ENTITY DUG THE TRENCH IN THE MIDDLE OF THE SOUTH SIDE LANE OF LIBERTYSHIP ROAD, ACROSS FROM 10 LIBERTYSHIP, WHERE THE SUBJECT INJURY OCCURRED Page 2 of 11

3 01/28/2014 COMPLETE NAME OF DEFT DOE 2, THE PERSONS WHO, AND /OR ENTITY WHICH WAS / WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR OF THE SUBJECT TRENCH IN THE MIDDLE OF THE SOUTH SIDE LANE OF LIBERTYSHIP ROAD, ACROSS FROM 10 LIBERTYSHIP, WHERE THE SUBJECT INJURY OCCURED 01/28/2014 COMPLETE NAME OF DEFT DOE 3, THE OWNER OF LIBERTYSHIP ROAD, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE PORTION OF LIBERTYSHIP ROAD WHERE THE SUBJECT INJURY OCCURRED, ACROSS FROM 10 LIBERTYSHIP. 02/20/2014 MINUTE ORDER POSTED JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE LYNN DURYEE, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK S. HENDRYX ATTORNEY JOSEPH HOFFMAN APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY JOHN ABACI APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT COUNSEL REPORT THE PARTIES ARE WORKING TO IDENTIFY THE OWNER OF A ROAD IN QUESTION. THIS MATTER SHALL BE OCNTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE TO AT 9:00 A.M. IN DEPT. L. ANSWER/DEMURRER TO BE FILED BY IF THE CASE IS NOT RESOLVED. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 04/22/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 02/20/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D03 03/03/2014 CASE REASSIGNED TO JUDGE HON. MARK A. TALAMANTES 04/22/2014 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 04/22/2014 at 9:00AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE MARK A. TALAMANTES, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK D.THAI ATTORNEY JOSEPH HOFFMAN APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY JOHN ABACI APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT PLAINTIFF STATES THAT THE DOE DEFENDANTS HAVE JUST BEEN ADDED TO THE CASE AND PLAINTIFF IS YET TO SERVE ALL THE PARTIES IT IS ORDERED: OSC RE: PROOF OF SERVICE AND OSC RE: ANSWER SET 06/25/14 AT 9:00 A.M. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 06/25/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 04/22/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 HEARING CONFIRMED FOR: 06/25/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D22 ENTERED BY: D.THAI 04/22/2014 FULL NAME OF DEFT: A.G. SCHOONMAKER COMPANY, INC. AND/OR ITS SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST. 04/22/2014 AMENDMENT TO FILED, AS TO: TRUE NAME OF DEFTS: ANTHONY J. MARTERIE (DOE 15), ROXANNE MARTERIE (DOE 16), MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED 3/15/10, ANTHONY J. MARTERIE AND ROXANNE MARTERIE, TRUSTEES (DOE 17), A.G. SCHOONMAKER CON, INC. AND/OR ITS SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST (DOE 18) 06/09/2014 MINUTE ORDER POSTED JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE MARK A. TALAMANTES, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK P. OKUBO ATTORNEY JOSEPH HOFFMAN APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF CASE FILE NOT IN COURT EX PARTE MINUTE ORDER : APPLICATION FOR ORDER GRANTING LIMITED POWERS OF ATTORNEY EX PARTE REQUEST READ AND CONSIDERED. COURT NOTES DECLARATION DID NOT COMPLY WITH RULES OF COURT AND Page 3 of 11

4 EX PARTE RETURNED TO MR. HOFFMAN. ***** LATER **** EX PARTE RESUBMITTED BY MR. HOFFMAN. IT IS ORDERED: EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER GRANTING LIMITED POWERS OF ATTORNEY IS GRANTED. ORDER GRANTING LIMITED POWERS OF ATTORNEY SIGNED AND IS GIVEN TO MR. HOFFMAN FOR FILING IN ROOM 113. ENTERED BY: P. OKUBO 06/09/2014 IT IS ORDERED: ORDER GRANTING LIMITED POWERS OF ATTORNEY. JOSEPH HOFFMAN IS GRANTED LIMITED POWERS OF ATTORNEY, THE PURPOSE OF WHICH IS TO ASSIST MR. GROUPP WITH THIS LITIGATION. JUDGE MARK A. TALAMANTES. 06/25/2014 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 06/25/2014 at 9:00AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE MARK A. TALAMANTES, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK P. OKUBO ATTORNEY JOSEPH HOFFMAN AND BARRY WESTER APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY JOHN ABACI APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT MR. ABACI GIVES STATUS. MR. HOFFMAN GIVES STATUS. CONTINUANCE REQUESTED TO GET PROPER DEFENDANTS IN THE CASE. WAITING ON SURVEY. IT IS ORDERED: FUTURE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE DATE: 9/24/14 TIME: 9:00 A.M. HAVE PLEADINGS SET IN 90 DAYS. HAVE MOTION FOR AMENDED ON FILE BY 9/24/14. ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE: PROOF OF SERVICE AND ANSWER ARE CONTINUED TO 9/24/14. IF CITY IS GOING TO BE DISMISSED, HAVE ON FILE BY THEN - 9/24/14. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 09/24/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 06/25/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 HEARING CONTINUED TO: 09/24/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 06/25/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 ENTERED BY: P. OKUBO 07/10/2014 SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED, AS TO: PLTFS ; FORMER ATTY JOSEPH HOFFMAN; PRESENT ALLY BARRY WESTER 09/16/2014 SUMMONS ISSUED AND FILED 09/24/2014 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 09/24/2014 at 9:00AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE MARK A. TALAMANTES, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK P. OKUBO ATTORNEY JOHN ABACI APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT STATUS OF CASE IS GIVEN BY MR. WESTER. NEED TO IDENTIFY DEFENDANTS AND SERVE. COURT REMINDS COUNSEL TO FILE A CMC STATEMENT. IT IS ORDERED: FUTURE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERNCE DATE: 11/20/14 TIME: 9:00 A.M. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 11/20/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 09/24/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 HEARING CONTINUED TO: 11/20/2014 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 09/24/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: OSCH FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 Page 4 of 11

5 ENTERED BY: P. OKUBO 09/30/2014 PROOF OF SERVICE FILED, AS TO: DEFT, ANTHONY MARTERIE BY SUBSTITUTED SERVICE OF JANE DOE ON 9/27/2014. DOM: 9/30/2014. DECLARATION OF MAILING ATTACHED. 10/01/2014 PROOF OF SERVICE FILED, AS TO: DEFT, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED MARCH 15, 2010 BY SUBSTITUTED SERVICE OF JANE DOE ON 9/27/2014. DOM: 9/29/2014. DECLARATION OF DILIGENCE. 10/01/2014 PROOF OF SERVICE FILED, AS TO: DEFT, ROXANNE MARTERIE, SUB SVC TO JANE DOE, DOM 9/29/14 10/10/2014 ANSWER DEFT, ANTHONY MARTERIE 10/10/2014 FILING FEE PROCESSED: DEFT, ANTHONY MARTERIE /10/2014 ANSWER DEFT, ROXANNE MARTERIE 10/10/2014 FILING FEE PROCESSED: DEFT, ROXANNE MARTERIE /10/2014 ANSWER DEFT, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED MARCH 15, /10/2014 FILING FEE PROCESSED: DEFT, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED MARCH 15, /10/2014 JURY FEE DEPOSIT DEFT, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED MARCH 15, /07/2014 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: DEFT, WITHOUT PREJUDICE. 11/07/2014 REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE FILED BY ATTY BARRY WESTER OBO PLTF, AS TO AGAINST ONLY, AND PER TERMS OF PARTIES' DISMISSAL AGREEMENT; EACH PARTY TO BEAR THEIR OWN FEES AND COSTS. 11/18/2014 CROSS- FILED (1) BY ATTY PATRICK TORSNEY OBO CROSS-COMPLAINANTS ANTHONY MARTERIE, ROXANNE MARTERIE, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED 3/15/10, AGAINST CROSS-DEFTS COMCAST BUSINESS COMMUNICATIONS, INC., AT&T SERVICES, INC., PG&E CORP., AND ROES 1 THROUGH 20 11/18/2014 SUMMONS ISSUED ON CROSS- (1) AND FILED. 11/20/2014 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 11/20/2014 at 9:00AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE MARK A. TALAMANTES, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK P. OKUBO COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY PATRICK TORSNEY FOR DEFENDANTS MARTERIE, DISMISSED. CROSS- RECENTLY SERVED. NEED TO DETERMINE WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE TRENCH. COURT DID NOT RECEIVE CMC STATEMENT FROM DEFENDANTS. IT IS ORDERED: FUTURE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE DATE: 1/22/15 TIME: 9:00 A.M. ADR OPTIONS. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 01/22/2015 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 11/20/2014 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 COUNSEL MR. WESTER MUST PROVIDE NOTICE OF THIS ORDER TO MR. TORSNEY ENTERED BY: P. OKUBO 12/12/2014 PROOF OF SERVICE FILED, AS TO: CRDF, AT&T SERVICES, INC. (1), PER SVC TO PROCESS SPEC., CT CORP, 12/2/14 12/24/2014 ANSWER (1) CRDF, AT&T SERVICES, INC. (ANSWERING AS PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY, ERRONEOUSLY NAMED AS AT&T SERVICES, INC.) 12/24/2014 FILING FEE PROCESSED: CRDF, AT&T SERVICES, INC. (1) /24/2014 CROSS- FILED (2) BY ATTY GERARD DONNELLAN OBO CROSS-COMPLAINANT PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY, AGAINST CROSS-DEFTS ANTHONY MARTERIE, ROXANNE MARTERIE, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED 3/15/10, AND ROES 1 TO 100, ET AL. Page 5 of 11

6 12/26/2014 ANSWER DEFT, KIMBER MANAGEMENT, LLC 12/26/2014 FILING FEE PROCESSED: DEFT, KIMBER MANAGEMENT, LLC /02/2015 SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED, AS TO: DEFTS ANTHONY MARTERIE; FORMER ATTY LAW OFFICES OF BAKER & ASSOCIATES; PRESENT ATTY THOMAS RECTOR. 01/02/2015 SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED, AS TO: DEFT KIMBER MANAGEMENT, LLC; FORMER ATTY LAW OFFICE OF BAKER & ASSOCIATES; PRESENT ATTY THOMAS RECTOR. 01/02/2015 SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED, AS TO: DEFT MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST; FORMER ATTY LAW OFFICES OF BAKER & ASSOCIATES; PRESENT ATTY THOMAS RECTOR. 01/02/2015 SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED, AS TO: DEFT ROXANNE MARTERIE; FORMER ATTY LAW OFFICES OF BAKER & ASSOCIATES; PRESENT ATTY THOMAS RECTOR. 01/22/2015 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 01/22/2015 at 9:00AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE MARK A. TALAMANTES, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK P. OKUBO COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY GREGORY CHIN FOR DEFENDANTS MARTERIE ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR CROSS-COMPLAINANT PACIFIC BELL AT & T INCORRECTLY NAMED. WILL BE IDENTIFYING RESPONSIBLE PARTY SOON, THEN OTHERS MAY BE DISMISSED. IT IS ORDERED: FUTURE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE DATE: 3/4/15 TIME: 9:00 A.M. FINALIZE PLEADING. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 03/04/2015 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D22 FROM DATE: 01/22/2015 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 ENTERED BY: P. OKUBO 01/23/2015 PROOF OF SERVICE FILED, AS TO: CRDF, COMCAST BUSINESS COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (1) BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 12/3/ /23/2015 PROOF OF SERVICE FILED, AS TO: CRDF, PG&E CORPORATION (1) BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 12/3/ /10/2015 FILING FEE PROCESSED: CRDF, COMCAST BUSINESS COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (1) /10/2015 ANSWER (1) CRDF, COMCAST BUSINESS COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (ANSWERING AS COMCAST OF CALIFORNIA III, INC., ERRONEOUSLY SUED AS COMCAST BUSINESS COMMUNICATIONS, INC.) 02/12/2015 CASE REASSIGNED TO JUDGE HON GEOFFREY HOWARD 02/12/2015 APPEARANCE MOVED TO: 03/04/2015 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D24 MOVE REASON: RE-ASSIGNMENT FROM DATE: 03/04/2015 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D22 02/18/2015 ANSWER (2) CRDF, ANTHONY MARTERIE 02/18/2015 ANSWER (2) CRDF, ROXANNE MARTERIE 02/18/2015 ANSWER (2) CRDF, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED MARCH 15, /04/2015 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 03/04/2015 at 9:00AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE GEOFFREY M. HOWARD, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK S. HENDRYX ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY ATTORNEY GREG CHIN APPEARED FOR DEFENDANTS ANTHONY MARTERIE, ROXANNE MARTERIE AND THE MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST Page 6 of 11

7 COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY JASON DINEROS FOR CROSS-DEFENDANT COMCAST BUSINESS COMMUNICATIONS BEFORE THE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE BEGINS, THE COURT DISCLOSES A DISQUALIFYING INTEREST IN AT&T CORP. AND ASKS COUNSEL IF AT&T CORP. IS THE SAME ENTITY AS AT&T INC. MR. DONNELLAN RESPONDS AND INFORMS THE COURT PACIFIC BELL TELPHONE COMPANY IS A WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARY OF AT&T INC. IT IS ORDERED: THIS MATTER SHALL BE REVIEWED BY THE COURT FOR POSSIBLE RECUSAL. A NEW CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE DATE WILL BE ASSIGNED AND THE PARTIES WILL RECEIVE NOTICE. 03/04/2015 MINUTE ORDER POSTED JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE GEOFFREY M. HOWARD, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK S. HENDRYX NO APPEARANCE BY OR FOR THE PARTIES EX PARTE MINUTE ORDER *******************IN CHAMBERS MINUTE ORDER******************* JUDGE/COMMISSIONER GEOFFREY M. HOWARD RECUSES HIM/HERSELF FROM HEARING THE CASE PURSUANT TO CCP 170.1/ THE CASE FILE IS FORWARDED FOR REASSIGNMENT. THE NEWLY ASSIGNED DEPARTMENT SHALL SET A CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE IN APPROXIMATELY 30 DAYS. 03/04/2015 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: (1) CRDF, PG&E CORPORATION WITHOUT PREJUDICE 03/04/2015 (1) REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE FILED BY ATTY THOMAS RECTOR OBO CROSS- COMPLAINANTS, AS TO CROSS- AGAINST CROSS-DEFT PG&E CORPORATION ONLY. 03/04/2015 JUDGE/COMMISSIONER RECUSES HIM/HERSELF FROM HEARING THE CASE PURSUANT TO CCP 170.1/ /04/2015 CASE REASSIGNED TO JUDGE HON ROY O CHERNUS 03/04/2015 NOTICE OF CASE REASSIGNMENT AND NOTICE OF HEARING MAILED TO THE PARTIES 03/04/2015 HEARING CONTINUED TO: 04/03/2015 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 03/04/2015 FROM TIME: 09:00 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D24 03/24/2015 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: DEFT, PACIFIC BELL CORPORATION ( PER 3/24 15 AMENDMENT TO ) 03/24/2015 AMENDMENT TO FILED, AS TO: TRUE NAME OF DEFT PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY, (DOE 7), (ERRONEOUSLY NAMED AS PACIFIC BELL CORPORATION), FILED BY ATTY OBO PLTF. 03/30/2015 ANSWER DEFT, COMCAST, INC. (ANSWERING AS COMCAST OF CALIFORNIA III, INC., ERRONEOUSLY SUED AS COMCAST, INC.) (FIRST AMENDED ) 03/30/2015 FILING FEE PROCESSED: DEFT, COMCAST, INC /03/2015 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 04/03/2015 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER MATTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK J. LANGFORD COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY JASON DINEROS FOR DEFENDANT, COMCASE, INC COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY GREGORY CHIN FOR DEFENDANTS AND CROSS COMPLAINANT, KIMBER MANAGEMENT, LLC AND ANTHONY AND ROXANNE MARTERIE ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT, PACIFIC BELL DISCUSSION HELD BETWEEN COURT AND COUNSEL Page 7 of 11

8 PARTIES TO PROVIDE NEW CMC STATEMENTS THIS MATTER IS CONTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE TO 8:30AM IN DEPT. B HEARING CONTINUED TO: 06/05/2015 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 04/03/2015 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 ENTERED BY: J. LANGFORD 04/03/2015 IT IS ORDERED: APPLICATION AND ORDER FOR APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIAN AD LITEM. PAULINE TOMLINSON IS APPOINTED AS GUARDIAN AD LITEM FOR, AND HAS NO GUARDIAN OR CONSERVATOR OF HIS ESTATE. JUDGE ROY O. CHERNUS, 04/06/2015 ANSWER DEFT, PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY 06/05/2015 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 06/05/2015 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER MATTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK J. LANGFORD ATTORNEY GERARD J. DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT, PACIFIC BELL COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY JASON DINEROS FOR CROSS-DEFENDANT, COMCAST OF CALIFORNIA COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY GRGEORY B. CHIN FOR DEFENDANT AND CROSS-COMPLAINANT, KIMBER MANAGEMENTM, LLC AND MARTERIE DEFENDANTS APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY FRED HERSEYFIELD DISCUSSION HELD BETWEEN COURT AND COUNSEL PARTIES TO MEET AND CONFERN RE: DISCOVERY PLANS PARTIES TO PROVIDE NEW CMC STATEMENTS THIS MATTER IS CONTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE TO 8:30AM IN DEPT. B HEARING CONTINUED TO: 09/04/2015 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 06/05/2015 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 ENTERED BY: J. LANGFORD 06/23/2015 NOTICE OF HCANGE OF ATTORNEY'S ADDRESS AND CONTACT INFORMATION FOR DEFENDANT/CROSS- DEFENDANT PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPNAY ATTORNEY GERALD DONNELLAN 09/04/2015 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 09/04/2015 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER MATTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK J. LANGFORD ATTORNEY FREDERIC L. HIRSCHFIELD APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT, PACIFIC BELL CORPORATION COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY JASON DINEROS FOR CROSS-DEFENDANT, COMCAST OF CALIFORNIA III, INC COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY GREGORY B. CHIN FOR DEFENDANT/CROSS-COMPLAINANT, KIMBER MANAGEMENT LLC AND MARTERIE NO APPEARANCE BY OR FOR THE OTHER PARTIES DISCUSSION HELD BETWEEN COURT AND COUNSEL THIS MATTER IS CONTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE TO 8:30AM IN DEPT. B HEARING CONTINUED TO: 12/04/2015 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 09/04/2015 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 Page 8 of 11

9 ENTERED BY: J. LANGFORD 09/30/2015 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: CRDF, COMCAST BUSINESS COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (1) WITHOUT PREJUDICE. EACH SIDE TO BEAR OWN FEES AND COSTS 12/03/2015 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: DEFT, COMCAST, INC., WITHOUT PREJUDICE 12/04/2015 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 12/04/2015 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER MATTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK J. LANGFORD ATTORNEY FREDERIC L. HIRSCHFIELD APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT, PACIFIC BELL CORPORATION COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY JASON DIEROS FOR CROSS-DEFENDANT, COMCAST OF CALIFORNIA III, INC. COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY GREGORY CHIN FOR DEFENDANT, DEFENDANT/CROSS-COMPLAINANT, KIMBER MANAGEMENT LLC AND MARTERIE DISCUSSION HELD BETWEEN COURT AND COUNSEL COUNSEL INFORMS THE COURT, PARTIES HAVE AGREED ON A MEDIATOR THIS MATTER IS CONTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE TO 8:30AM IN DEPT. B FOR RESULTS OF MEDIATION HEARING CONTINUED TO: 03/04/2016 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 12/04/2015 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 ENTERED BY: J. LANGFORD 03/04/2016 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 03/04/2016 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O. CHERNUS, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK S. DIENER ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR PAC BELL DEFENDANTS COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY GREGORY CHIN FOR DEFENDANTS MARTERIE 3/26 PLAINTIFF TO BE EVALUATED; MEDIATION SET FOR MAY 9TH. THIS MATTER SHALL BE SET ON 5/20/16 FOR RESULTS OF MEDIATION AND TRIAL SETTING. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 05/20/2016 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 03/04/2016 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 ENTERED BY: S.D. 05/20/2016 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 05/20/2016 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER MATTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK J. LANGFORD ATTORNEY FRED HIRCHFIELD APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF COURT CALL APPEARANCE BY THOMAS RECTOR FOR DEFENDANT/CROSS-COMPLAINANT, KIMBER MANAGEMENT LLC AND MARTERIE NO APPEARANCE BY OR FOR THE OTHER DEFENDANTS DISCUSSION HELD BETWEEN COURT AND COUNSEL THIS MATTER IS CONTINUED FOR FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE TO 8:30AM IN DEPT. B Page 9 of 11

10 HEARING CONTINUED TO: 08/24/2016 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 05/20/2016 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 ENTERED BY: J. LANGFORD 08/24/2016 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 08/24/2016 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK C. ASLESON NO APPEARANCE BY OR FOR THE DEFENDANT MATTER ON CALENDAR FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RE RESULTS OF MEDIATION. COUNSEL STATES THE CASE HAS SETTLED. IT IS ORDERED: FUTURE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE 10/26/16 AT 8:30AM IN DEPARTMENT B. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 10/26/2016 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 08/24/2016 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 ENTERED BY: C. ASLESON 10/26/2016 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 10/26/2016 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK C. ASLESON ATTORNEY FRED HIRSCHFIELD APPEARED FOR PLAINTIFF MATTER ON CALENDAR FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RE: RESULTS OF MEDIATION. IT IS ORDERED: FUTURE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE 01/05/2017 AT 8:30AM IN DEPARTMENT B. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 01/05/2017 AT: 08:30 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 10/26/2016 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 ENTERED BY: C. ASLESON 12/23/2016 ORDER APPROVING COMPROMISE 01/05/2017 MINUTE ORDER POSTED - Appearance: 01/05/2017 at 8:30AM for CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JUDGE/PROTEM/REFEREE ROY O CHERNUS, REPORTER NOT REPORTED, DEP CLK C. ASLESON ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN APPEARED FOR DEFENDANT PACIFIC BELL THIS MATTER COMES BEFORE THE COURT FOR A CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RE: STATUS IT IS ORDERED: FUTURE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE 04/07/2017 AT 9:00 A.M. IN DEPARTMENT B. HEARING CONTINUED TO: 04/07/2017 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 FROM DATE: 01/05/2017 FROM TIME: 08:30 AM FROM APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT FROM DEPARTMENT: D06 NO APPEARANCE NECESSARY BY PARTIES IF DISMISSAL ON FILE WITH THE COURT. ENTERED BY: C. ASLESON 01/18/2017 ORDER APPROVING COMPROMISE Page 10 of 11

11 01/18/2017 IT IS ORDERED: AMENDED COMPROMISE OF DISPUTED CLAIM, COMPROMISE OF PENDING ACTION JUDGE ROY O. CHERNUS 02/23/2017 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: CRCO, ANTHONY MARTERIE, WITH PREJUDICE 02/23/2017 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: CRCO, ROXANNE MARTERIE, WITH PREJUDICE 02/23/2017 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: CRCO, MARTERIE FAMILY TRUST DATED 3/15/10 (1), WITH PREJUDICE 02/23/2017 PARTIAL DISMISSAL AS TO: CRCO, PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY (2), WITH PREJUDICE 02/23/2017 CASE DISPOSED BEFORE TRIAL; DISMISSED - OTHER REASONS ENTIRE ACTION WITH PREJUDICE 02/23/2017 CASE DISPOSED IN ENTIRETY 02/24/2017 APPEARANCE DROPPED FOR 04/07/2017 AT: 09:00 AM FOR APPEARANCE TYPE: CMGT IN DEPARTMENT: D06 DROP REASON: SISMISSAL FILED 2/23/17 0 NOTICE OF ENTRY OF DISMISSAL AND PROOF OF SERVICE PERSONAL INJURY BY ATTORNEY GERARD DONNELLAN ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT AND CROSS-COMPLAINANT PACIFIC BELL AND TELEPHONE Page 11 of 11