Please feel free to contact me at (954) or at should you have any questions or need any further information.

Transcription

1 FLORID VITION DEPRTMENT- Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International irort 2200 SW 45 1 h Street, Suite 101 Dania Beach, Florida November 19, 2012 SUBJECT: THE BROWRD COUNTY VITION DEPRTMENT IRPORT NOISE BTEMENT COMMITTEE (NC) MEETING Dear County Commissioners I City Officials I NC Members I irort Community: Enclosed lease find a coy of the meeting minutes for the NC Meeting held on Setember 10, 2012, along with the monthly reorts for ugust through October, lso, enclosed is an genda for the next NC meeting to be held on December 10, 2012, at 6:00.m. in Conference Room "D" located in the BCD Offices at the irort Commerce Park Ravenswood Road, Fort Lauderdale FL, See the attached ma showing the BCD New Office locations. dditionally, enclosed you will find notification regarding the closure of the main runway at the Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International irort beginning on Monday, December 10, The closure wi11 allow work for avement reairs, routine maintenance that includes rubber removal and other airfield work. Please feel free to contact me at (954) or at wcannicle@broward.org should you have any questions or need any further information. Sincerely, Winston B. Cannicle BCD Noise Information Officer WBCimbs Broward County Board of County Commissioners Sue Gunzburger Dale V.C. Holness Kristin Jacobs Martin David Kiar Chi LaMarca Stacy Ritter Tim Ryan Barbara Sharief Lois Wexler

2 B FLORID VITION DEPRTMENT- Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International irort 2200 SW 45 1 h Street, Suite 101 Dania Beach, Florida GEND FORT LUDERDLE- HOLLYWOOD INTERNTIONL IRPORT IRPORT NOISE BTEMENT COMMITTEE December 10, :00.m. BCD Conference Room "D" Suite Ravenswood Road, Fort Lauderdale, FL Welcome BCD Staff 2. roval of Minutes- Setember 10,2012 Meeting NC Chairerson 3. Old Business- NC Chairerson 4. Noise Control Office Udate BCD Staff 5 Noise Presentation- Noise & Oerations Monitoring Systems "1 01" Ted Baldwin, HMMH 6. Committee Member Comments 7. Citizen Comments 8. Next meeting- March 11,2013 at 6:00.m. ***Please Note New Meeting Location bove*** Broward County Board of County Commissioners Sue Gunzburger Dale V.C. Holness Kristin Jacobs Martin David Kiar Chi LaMarca Stacy Ritter Tim Ryan Barbara Sharief Lois Wexler

3 Broward County viation Deartment I Fort Lauderdale- Hollywood International irort irort Noise batement Committee Setember 10, 2012 Meeting Minutes DTE: LOCTION: Monday, Setember 10,2012,6:00 P.M. Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International irort The BCD dministrative Offices irort Commerce Park: Conference Room D 4101 Ravenswood Road, Suite 404 Fort Lauderdale FL, Committee Member (Organization Reresented) Present/ bsent Cumulative ttendance (10/01/ /2012) Present bsent Dr. Michael Richmond (Chair) Ernie Siegrist (RMT#1) Gary Luedtke (RMT#2) Jay Field (RMT#3) Mike McKeever (RMT#4) Rae Sandler (RMT#5) Vacant (RMT#6) Dave Reich (RMT#7) Bud Johnson (RMT#S) Joseh M. Gizzo (RMT#S lt.) George Counts (RMT#S lt.) Duncan Bossie (RMT#9) Leonor Ortiz (RMT#9 lt.) Rudy Herman (RMT# I 0) Debra VanValkenburgh (RMT#IO lt.) Lee Gottlieb (RMT# II) Irwin Oster (City of Hollywood) Samora Emmanuel (Jet Blue) James Vaughn (US irways) John Clark (Sirit irlines) Vacant (FBO Reresentative) Vacant (Southwest irlines) John Higgins (Delta irlines) Robert Berlucchi (F) Theodore Delnegri (F) I I I I I I I RMT =Reresentative for neighborhood containing the identified Remote Monitoring Terminal lt. =lternate RMT reresentative irort/county Staff Winston Cannicle- BCD Noise Officer; llan Siegel- BCD Public Outreach Coordinator coustical Consulting Team Members Ted Baldwin - HMMH Sheryl. Dickey and Carla Hankerson - DCS Visitors Florence Straugh, Noise batement Officer- Fort Lauderdale Executive irort; Richard Reasoner (RMT#10 lt.); Patricia Wright (RMT #3 lt.); Darren Lyle- Hanson Professional Services l.welcome The NC meeting was called to order by Dr. Michael Richmond at 6:00.m. Dr. Richmond welcomed everyone and asked each committee member and visitor to introduce themselves. Page 1 of3

4 Broward County viation Deartment I Fort Lauderdale - Hollywood International irort irort Noise batement Committee Setember 10, 2012 Meeting Minutes 2. PPROVL OF JUNE 2012 MINUTES Mr. Siegrest made a motion to arove the minutes. Mr. Bossie seconded the motion. The committee aroved the minutes unanimously. 3. OLD BUSINESS Dr. Richmond advised the NC they could not entertain revisions to the Charter because they did not have a quorum. 4. NOISE OFFICE UPDTE Mr. Cannicle noted that Runway 9L/27R will be closed on Setember 17 for aroximately seven days for avement reairs. There will be two 24-hour closures and the remaining days will be nighttime closures. During the closures, Runway 13/31 will be used, excet at night when it may be ossible for the contractors to ull equiment back and ermit use of Runway 9L/27R. Mr. Reasoner asked Mr. Berlucchi how he will direct Runway 31. Mr. Cannicle ointed out that a ilot notice had already been distributed that set out the rocedures calling for aircraft to tum due west as soon as feasible. He said he would send coies of the materials to Mr. Berlucchi. Mr. Berlucchi said he would follow u as indicated. Mr. Reasoner said he areciated Mr. Berlucchi's efforts but his neighborhood would areciate it if he would have the ilots tum earlier to relieve some ofthe noise. Mr. Cannicle said the Oerations Deartment anticiates doing routine maintenance on Runway 9L/27R at night aroximately every three months, but that in most circumstances it would not result in closure ofthe runway, because the contractors would be required to ull their equiment off the runway when it was needed for an oeration. Mr. Berlucchi added that they will try to target Tuesday and Thursday nights in Setember, because they are the slowest days in the slowest month ofthe year. There was additional discussion about use ofthe south runway after Runway 13/31 is closed. Mr. Cannicle reminded the NC that Mr. Siegel is the contact for construction activities. Dr. Richmond asked if the NC members could get a tour ofthe south runway construction area so that they will have a better understanding ofthe roject. Mr. Cannicle said he would investigate this matter with Mr. Siegel and other BCD staff. There was a question about the status of the negotiations to demolish the hotel and marina on the west end. Mr. Cannicle deferred to Mr. Siegel. Mr. Siegel said they are in the acquisition hase and the roject is on schedule. The County is suosed to take ownershi of the roerty late this year or next year. Demolition is scheduled for Mr. Baldwin added that he read an e-newsletter article stating that rogress has been made with the Hilton. Someone asked if the roerty would go into eminent domain. Mr. Siegel said it deends but the County does not anticiate having to do eminent domain. Dr. Richmond asked if there was an udate with the City of Dania Beach renegotiating the settlement. Ms. Sandler said they are still working on it. Mr. Johnson ointed out how loud and low many ofthe oerations were at Site 10 in the July 7 Loud Events Reort. committee member asked if the BCD could track the number of oerations by hour from 10.m. to 6 a.m. for a twomonth eriod. Mr. Berlucchi recommended looking at the last quarter of 2011 to cover off-eak and eak oerations. Richmond requested the information be resented on a grah. The Committee suorted these ideas. Mr. Baldwin and Mr. Cannicle said they would reare the grahics. 5. PRESENTTION Comarison ofstage 3 and 4 Noise Benefits for Takeoffvs. Landing Mr. Baldwin noted the resentation was at Mr. Field's request and that since Mr. Field could not attend the meeting, he would discuss the resentation with him at a later date. The resentation is available on the BCD website. Dr. Richmond asked about noise from reverse thrust on landings. Mr. Baldwin answered that he information in the resentation included reverse thrust. Mr. Counts asked if there is an objective way to measure itch. Mr. Baldwin said Part 36 uses a metric called Effective Perceived Noise Level that takes tones into account. If an engine has a distinct tone, it gets enalized. Mr. Counts asked for clarification regarding the mention of "4" versus "6" in the EPNL certification of aircraft. Mr. Baldwin said he would bring a coy of Part 36 to the next meeting to discuss with Mr. Counts. 6. COMMITTEE COMMENTS ND QUESTIONS Ms. Sandler stated she is concerned about the construction lights on the other side of Greenbelt near the railroad tracks. She believes they are a safety hazard. She sent an to Mr. Siegel who referred her to the Project Manager; however, the roblem has not been resolved. Mr. Siegel said he would contact the Consultant again and follow u with Ms. Sandler. Ms. Sandler also said that since the south runway officially closed on ril 17, the noise readings south of the airort are still surrisingly high and asked if the readings were wrong. Mr. Baldwin noted that the readings are consistent with ast results related to noise from oerations on the north runway. Dr. Richmond agreed and said the variation had not been Page 2 of3

5 Broward County viation Deartment I Fort Lauderdale- Hollywood International irort irort Noise batement Committee Setember 10, 2012 Meeting Minutes that great. Mr. Berlucchi added that larger aircraft are tyically the big noise generators even though the roximity is further away. There was a comment addressed to Ms. Sandler that the majority of the incidents she questioned aear to be on Runway 13/31. Mr. Reasoner questioned the low altitude of a Sirit airlane's on one of the monthly reorts. Mr. Baldwin noted that the aircraft's transonder reorts altitude, which is a ressure-based measurement so they are not erfect. Mr. Reasoner asked several questions about how the monitoring system identifies single noise events, which led to a general discussion of the toic. Dr. Richmond suggested that Mr. Baldwin give a resentation at the December meeting about how the system works. Mr. Baldwin agreed to do so, although it might take a coule of meetings. Several committee members asked about why the reorts included the information that they do. Mr. Baldwin noted that the tables were develoed by the NC, but that changes could be made if the Committee thought it would be beneficial. Mr. Reasoner said changes should not be made until airort construction is comleted. Mr. Berlucchi agreed and added that on May 2, 2013, the SR is being commissioned at the new site west ofl-95 in the FedEx arking lot. Ms. Sandler referred to Boeing 73 7 arrival and dearture measurements at sites 4 and 5 within a 10-miunte eriod and if that meant there was a wind and runway change. Mr. Baldwin relied that the sites could have measured an arrival on Runway 27R and a dearture on Runway 27R by two different aircraft, without a runway change. Mr. Reasoner asked how much effect ground noise has on the monitors. In the ast, he observed where a construction crew laced a generator next to one ofthe monitors. Mr. Baldwin noted there is always a chance that kind of situation will occur when monitoring continuously in the community. Ms. Sandler asked if one lane could be tracked by every monitor. Mr. Cannicle said it was unlikely, but that he would look for examles of multile noise events from one oeration. The grou agreed to review the reorts before the meetings and choose secific examles for discussion. 7. CITIZEN COMMENTS ND QUESTIONS Mr. Counts asked what should be the aroximate altitude of large assenger and cargo lanes dearting to the west that follow all of the noise abatement rocedures when they reach 10,000 feet from the end of the runway at the south incinerator near State Road 7. Mr. Baldwin said that it deends on the aircraft model, wind, temerature, etc. Mr. Cannicle added that near the Turnike, for examle, it is 2,500 feet. Mr. Berlucchi said that two miles off the dearture end they can go through feet at 1-95 westbound and 2,000 feet is a good estimate ifthey go down another mile. DJOURNMENT Dr. Richmond called for a motion to adjourn the meeting. Mr. Johnson made the motion and it was assed unanimously. The next meeting will be December 10,2012. Dr. Richmond adjourned the meeting at 7:25.m. Reorted by Dickey Consulting Services, Inc., Sheryl Dickey, Project Manager Reviewed by Ted Baldwin (HMMH) and Winston Cannicle (BCD) Page 3 of3

6 B FLORID VITION DEPRTMENT- Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International irort 2200 SW 45 1 h Street, Suite 101 Dania Beach, Florida November 19, 2012 SUBJECT: TEMPORRY CHNGE IN FLIGHT PTTERNS FOR NORTH RUNWY MINTENNCE WORK T FORT LUDERDLE HOLLYWOOD INTERNTIONL IRPORT Dear County Commissioners I City Officials I NC Members I irort Community: irfield maintenance work at Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International irort will result in the closure of Runway 9L-27R (North Runway) from 12:01 a.m. - 5:30 a.m., Monday, December 10, Monday, December 17, This closure will allow workers to erform routine maintenance which includes rubber removal, safety area work, aroach light reairs, and runway ainting. This temorary change in flight atterns will result in the use of Runway (Crosswind Runway) and lace air traffic over communities to the northwest and southeast of the airort. Please note the following: Runway 9L-27R (North Runway) will be closed each night from 12:01 a.m. until 5:30a.m. Runway (Crosswind Runway) will be used for arrivals and deartures between the hours of 12:01 a.m. and 5:30a.m. If you have any additional questions, lease call the viation Deartment's Noise Information Office at Sincerely, Winston B. Cannicle BCD Noise Information Officer WBCimbs Broward County Board of County Commissioners Sue Gunzburger Dale V.C. Holness Kristin Jacobs Martin David Kiar Chi LaMarca Stacy Ritter Tim Ryan Barbara Sharief Lois Wexler