IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO JACK MORRISON, 4 ) :t^

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO JACK MORRISON, 4 ) :t^"

Merry Gaines
5 years ago
Views:

1 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO TI-IE STATE OF ex rel, JR., LAW DIRECTOR, CITY; FALLS, et al. V. Plainti ffs-appellants BECK ENERGY CORPORA Defendants-Appellees JACK MORRISON, 3-, 4 ) :t^ '01URIfui 0i'^4 No Appeal from the Summit znty Court of Appeals, th Appellate I)istrict, Case 'l'heamericanpetroleum INSTI'I'UTE, THE OHIO CHAlVIBER OF COMMERCE, T I-fE CAN"FON REGIONAL CI-IAMI3ER OF COMMERC:E, THE YOUNGSTOWN/WARREN REGIONAL CHAMBER, AND INTERNATIONAL UNION OF OPERA'I'ING ENGINEERS, LOCAL 18 AS A.MICT CUI4E IN StJPPOR l' OE' APPELLEES NOTICE OF PRO HAC VICE RENEWAL REGISTRa.'I'IONS BENJAMIN NoRRIS (PHV ) AMERICAN PETROLEUM INSTITUTE 1220 L Street, N.W. Washington, DC (202) Cdunsel for Amicus C.'uriaeAmerican Petroleum Tnstitute LINDA WOGGON ( ) TIIE OHIO CIiAMI-3ER OF COMMERCE 230E. Town St. P.O. Box Columbus, OI-I (614) Counsel for.4micus Curiae Ohio Chamber of Co; rrenerce TT^N.IOTHY R. FADEL* ( ) WULIGER FADEL & I3EYER. *CounseZ of Record 'I`he 13rownell Building 1340 Sumner Court C1eveland, Ohio (216) (216) (facsimile) Counsel for Amicus International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 18 ROGER R. MARTELLA, JR.* (PHV ) JOsEaii R. GUERRA (PHV ) SAMUEL B. BOXERMAN (PHV ) L.oWE1,L J. Sc:HILLER (PHV ) SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP 1501 K Street, N. W, Washington, D.C (202) (202) (facsimile) rmartella'@sidley.com Counsel f'or Amici Curiae American Petroteuin Institute, the Ohio Chamber of Commerce, the C.'cznton Regional Claamber of Commerce, and the Youngstotun%Warren Regional Chamber KATHLEEN M. TRAFFORD ( ) PORTER WRICiI-IT MORRIS & ARTHUR LLII 41 S High St Suites Columbus, OH (614) (614) (facsimile) ktrafford <a?porterwright.com Counsel_forAnaici Curiae AmericarzPetroleum Institute, the Ohio C'hamber of Commerce; the Canton Regional Chamber of Coinmerce, and the Youngstown/Warren Regional Chamber

2 JACK MORRtsON JR. ( ) THOMAS M. SAXER ( ) TI-IOMAS R. HOULIHAN* ( ) AMER CUNNII\TGHAM CO., L.P.A, 159 S. Main Street, Suite 1100 Akron, OIf (330) (330) (facsi7nile) houl com Counsel for Plaintiffs-Appellants Munroe Falls JOZ-tN K. KELLER* ( ) VORYS, SA-I'ER, SEYMOR & PEASE LLP 525 F. Gay Street, P.O. Box 1008 Columbus, OH (614) Counsel, for Defendants-Appellees Beek Energy C"orporation and Joseph kyillingham BARBARA A. TAVAGLIONE* ( ) 9191 Paulding Street NW Massillon, OH (330) bal l.com Counselfor Amicus Curiae People'sOil and Cias Collaborative - Ohio TRENT A. DOUGHERTY* ( ) OtIIO ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL 1207 Grandview Avenue Suite 201 Columbus, O1I (614) (614) (facsimile) tdougherty(a7theoec. org Covtnsel for Ohio Local Businesses DAVID C. MORRTSON* ( ) *Counsel of 'Record MORRISON & BINDLEY 987 Professional Parkway Heath, OH (740) dm.morrisonbindley(c3alink.com Counsel for Anaicus Curiae City of Heath RicHARD C. SAtrLA* ( ) 981 Pinewood Lane Coluznbus, OI (614) rsallliucolumbus.rr.com Counsel for An-aici Curiae FleallnProfessionals MELEAH GEERTSMA* (PHV ) KA'rHERiNE, SINDING (1'HV ) PETER PREcAR1o ( ) NATURAL RESOURCES DEPEN.SI-, COUNCIL 20 N. Wacker Dr., Ste Chicago, IL {312) mgeertsmaa,)nrd c. org Counsel for Municipal Arnici Curiae DE$ORAF I GOLDBERG (PHV ) EARTI-IJUSTICE 48 Wall Street, 19lh Floor New York., NY (212) (212) (facsimile) dgolcibergc&eartbjustice.org Counsel for AmiciCuriae IHealth Professionals

3 Amici Curiae 'I'he American Petroleurn Instihrte, The Ohio Chamber Of Commexce, The Canton Regional Chamber Of Commerce, The Youngstownr'Warren Regional Chamber, and International Union Of Operating Engineers, Local 18 respectfully give notice that the pro hac vice registrations for attorneys Roger R. Martella, Jr., Joseph R. Guerra, Samuel B. Boxerman, Lowell J. Schiller and Benjamin Norris have been renewed for Copies of the 2014 Certificates of,pro I-Jac Vice Registration furnished by the SLrprerne Court of Ohio Office of Attorney Services and a certificate attesting to service of this notice on all known parties and attorneys of record are attached. Respectfully submitted,,.. ^ ^ z: ROGER R. MARTELLA, JR.* (PHV ) JOSEYEi R. GUERRA (PHV ) SAMUEL B. BOXERMAN (PHV ) LowELl, J. SCHILLER (PHV ) *Counsel of RecoYd SIDLEY AUSTI1v' LLP 1501 K St-reet, N.W. Washington, D.C (202) (202) (facsimile) rmartella@sidley.com KATI-ILF:E'v M. TRAFFORD ( ) PORTER WRIGxT'MORRIS & ARTHUR LLP 41 S 1-ligh St Suites Columbus, OH (614) (614) (facsimile) ktrafford,cyiporterwright.com Counsel for Amici Curiae American Petroleurn Institute, the Ohio Chamber o,f'commerce, the Canton Regional Chamber of Commerce, and the Youngstown/Warren Regional Chamber

4 BENJAMIN NORRIS (PHU ) AMERICAN PETROLEUM INS'I'ITUTE? 1220 L Street, N.W. Washington, DC (202) Counsel for Amicus Curiae flinerican,petyoleun2 Ifzstitute LINDA WOGGON ( ) THE; OHIO CHAMBER OF COMMERCE_, 230 E. Town St. P.O. Box Columbus, OH (614) Counsel for Amicus Curiae Ohio Chantber of Comrnet ce TIIvtO'rI-rY R. I ADEI, ( ) WULIGER 1~ADEL, & BEYER *C'ounsEl of Record `The Brownell Buildiilg 1340 Sumner Court (:levetand, Ohio (216) (216) (facsimile) tfadel (a, wfblaw.com Counsel for Amicus International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 18 2

5 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned counsel certifies that a copy of the foregoing Notice of Pro Hac Vice Renewal Registrations was served by First-Class U.S. Mail, postage pre-paid on the following counsel of record this 18th day of February 2014: Jack Morrison Jr. 'I'homas M. Saxer Thomas R. Houlihan* *Counsel of'record AMER CU-N-NINGI-IAM CO., L.P.A. 159 S. Main Street, Suite 1100 Akron, OH Trent A. Dougherty* *C'ounsel of Record OHIO ENVIRONMENTAL COtTI^^CIL 1207 Grandview Avenue Suite 201 Columbus, OH Counsel for Ohio Local Businesses Counsel, for Plaintiff.v-Appellants Munroe Falls Johii K. Keller* David C. Morrison* *Counsel of'record VORYS, SATER, SEYMOR & PEASE LLP MORRISON & BINDLEYY 525 E. Gay Street, P.O. Box Professional Parkway Columbus, OH Heath, OH Counsel for Defendants-Appellees Beck Energy Courasel for Amicus Curiae C"rty of Fleath Corporation and Joseph Willingharn Meleah Geertsma* *Counsel of'record Katherine Sinding Peter Precario ( ) NATURAI, RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCII, 20 N. Wacker Dr., Ste Chicago, IL Barbara A. Tavaglione* 9191 Paulding Street NW Massillon, OH Counsel for AniicusCut iae People's Oil and Gas Collaborative - Ohio Cnunsel fot 2vlunicipal Anaici Curiae

6 DEE3ORAH C^aOLDBE:RG EART'HJUSTICE 48 Wall Street, 19th Floor New York, NY 1(I0(15 RICHARD C. SAHLI* *Counsel ofrecorcl 981 Pinewood Lane Columbus, OH Counsel for Amici Curiae HealthPf ofessionals Counsel for Amici C'uriaeHeallh Professionals Eric E. Murphy* State Solicitor Peter K. Crlenn-Applegate Deputy Solicitor Ohio Attorney General's Office 30 E. Broad Street, 17th Floor Columbus, OH Coirnsel for Atnicus Curiae State of Ohio Counsel for Amici Ci iae Id ^

7 THE SUPREME COURT of OHIO OFFICE of, A`I'7YJRNEI' SERVICES IN TIiE MATTEI2 ofti-ie APPLICATION OF Roger Martella FOR PRO II,4C N'ICE RE:GIST`RATION Certificate of FRQ fiac VICE REGI STRATT()N 2014 per Gov. Bar R. XII. Section 2`(,A)(3 ) Registration Number: P1-fv Roger Martella having Inet the requirements of, andfouncfto be in flill cornpiiance with, Section 2(A)(3) of Ralle XII of the Rules 1'or the Government of the Bar of Oliio, is hereby isslted this certificate of prc^ hac vice registration in the state of Ohio. I'o receive permission to appear pro hac vice in an C)liio proceeding, a niotion reyuesting such permissiort must be filed with the trihtknal in accordance with Sectioii `( A)(6) of Rule XII of the Rules for the Eiovernrnent of ri;e. E3ar ofohio: Susan B. Christoff Director, Attorsiey Services Expires Decemlier 31, 2014

8 THE SUPREME COURT 0f OHIO OFFI('E OF ATT'()RNI;Y Sr,,RVICI;s IN TIIE MATTER OF TIiE APPLICATION OF Joseph Guerra FOR PRO E1,aC: 1'LC[i, REGISTRATION Certificate of PRO HAC VICE REGISTRIITION 2014 per Gov. Bar R. XII, Section -`("A)( 3) IZq istz'ation Number: PHV Joseph Guerra having met the requirements of, and found to be in full compliance wit17, Section 2(A)(3) of Rule XII of the Rules for the Governinent of the 13ar of Uhiv. ishereby issued this certificate of pro hac vice registration in the state of Qhio. To receive permission to appear pro hac vice in an Ohio proceeding, a motion requesting such pernlissio., must be filed ^^ ith dhe triblinal in aecordance,^ith Secti, l: 2(I;{.){6) of Rule XII of the Rules for the Gove:r>>rncrlf, of the laar of i)i1ic0, Susan B. Christoff Director, Attot ney Services Expires December 31, 2014

9 THE SUPREME COURT Of OHIO OFI'IC..E: oi' ATTORNEY SERVICES IN'rz-r.:F MaT'rER OF THE APPr, CATioN OF Samuel Boxerman F'oR PRO ti,^c VICE Rr cts'ruatto,^v Certificate of PRO I-IAC VICE RL;GISTRATIO-N 2014 pej' Cso`>. Bar R. XII, Section 2(A)(3) Registration Number: P1-IV Samtzel Boxerman having rnetthe requiremerits of, and found to be in full compliance with, Section 2(A)(3)af Rule XII of the Rules for the G«vernment of the Bar of Ohio, is herreby issucd this certificate of pro hac vice rebistration in the state of ()hio. To receive permission to appear pro hac vice in an Ohio proceeding, amc,tion requestingsuch permission n.liist be filed with the trib unal in accordanee with Section 2(A)(6) of Rule XII of the Rules for the Governrnent of the Bar of Ohio. ^:^^ Susan B. Christoff Director, Attorney Services ` Expires Decem>`ier 31, 2014

10 THE SUPREME COURT of OHIO C7FF1CE OF ATTORNEY SERVICES IN THE M:AT1'ER OF TFIEAPPL-ICATION OF Lowell Schiller FOR PRO i-iac VICE kiegistra'r.i4\ per Gov. Bar R. XII, Section 2(A)(')) C;eIilficatf; of PRO I-IAC VICE REGISTRATION 2014 Registration Numbei. PI-Iv Loweli Schiller having rnet the requirements of, and found to be in full compliance with; Section 2(A)(3) of Rule XIT of the Rules for the Government of the Bar of Ohio, is hei-eby issued this certificate ofpro hac 's icc registration in the state of Oliio. 'I'cj receive permission to appear pro hac vice in an Oliio proceeding, a motion requesting such permission must be filed wittl the tribunal in accordanc.e wit1'i Section 2(A)(6) of Rule XII of the Rules for the Government of the Bar of Ohio. Susan L. Christoff Director, Attorney Services Expires December 31, 2014

11 THE SUPREME COURT Of OHIO OFFICE OF ATTC?RNI,Y S[=RVic:ES IN 'fhl ' iy1at'i'eti OF 1'Iir APPLICATION OF Benjamin Norris FOR PRO IIAC VICE REGISTRATION per Gov. Bar R. XIT. S< cti:_}1-i -'(:1)(3) Certificate of PRO HAC VICE REGIS'I'RATION 2014 Registi'ation Number: PI-iV Benjamin Norris having met the rcquirements of, atld found to be in fult compliance with, Section 2(A)(3) of Rule XII of the Rules for the Government of the Bar of Ohio, is hereby issued this cir.rtificate ot'pro hac vice registration in the state of Ohio. `C'o receive permission to appear pro hac vice in an Ohio proceedirig, a nlotion recluesting such permisslor inust be filed `vith t'ie tribunal in accordanee with Sectioi: 2(.A)(6) ofruie XII of the Rules for the (3o^crnmi)e12 t of the Bir oi'nhio. Susan B. Christoff Director, Attorney Services Expires December 31, 2014

IN THE SUPREME COIIRT OF OHIO

IN THE SUPREME COIIRT OF OHIO THE STATE OF OHIO ex rel. JACK MOR.ItISON; JR., LAW DIRECTOR, CITY OF MUNROE FALLS, OHIO, V. Plaintiff-Appellant BECK ENERGY CORP., et al. Case No. 2013-0465 ON APPEAL FROM