SCOTTISH AFFAIRS publishes articles of concern to

Transcription

1

2 SCOTTISH AFFAIRS publishes articles of concern to people who are interested in the development of Scotland. This includes articles about similarly placed small nations and regions throughout Europe and beyond. The articles are authoritative and rigorous without being technical and pedantic. No subject area is excluded, but all articles should pay attention to the social and political context of their topics. Thus Scottish Affairs takes up a position between informed journalism and academic analysis, and provides a forum for dialogue between the two. The readers and contributors include journalists, politicians, civil servants, business people, academics, students, and people in general who take an informed interest in current affairs. For information about subscribing to Scottish Affairs, see the inside back cover. To submit an article to Scottish Affairs, send three copies (or an attachment in Word) to: Scottish Affairs, Institute of Governance, The University of Edinburgh, Chisholm House, 1 Surgeon Square, High School Yards, Edinburgh. EH11LZ Tel: Ladams@ed.ac.uk web site: Manuscripts should conform to the style of Scottish Affairs, full details of which are available from the web site. All articles are refereed by being sent to independent experts in the relevant field. The journal has no policy positions of its own (other than to encourage well-informed debate), and articles which disagree with positions taken up by individual members of the editorial team are as welcome as those with which the editors might agree. Books for review should be sent to the book-review editor at the above address.

3 SCOTTISH AFFAIRS Issue no. 60 Summer 2007

4 Published in paperback by Institute of Governance, Edinburgh University, Chisholm House, High School Yards, Edinburgh. EH1 1LZ ISSN the authors, 2007 Successor to The Scottish Government Yearbook Printed by Printing Services The University of Edinburgh

5 Scottish Affairs, no. 60, summer 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE GEORGE DAVIE : AN APPRECIATION Murdo Macdonald 1 SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT ELECTION THE SMOOTH WOOING: THE SNP'S VICTORY IN THE 2007 SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT ELECTIONS Peter Jones 6 PASSPORT TO KELSO : A (MICRO)NATION DECIDES David Stenhouse 24 DIARY OF A CANDIDATE Chris Harvie 43 'A HISTORIC MOMENT'? THE RESULTS OF THE SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT ELECTIONS 2007 David Denver 61 WOMEN'S REPRESENTATION IN THE 2007 SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT: TEMPORARY SETBACK OR RETURN TO THE NORM? Fiona Mackay and Meryl Kenny 80 WHY No BREAK-UP - So FAR? Bob Tait 94 REVIEW ESSAY: ELECTION THE YEAR OF COURAGE? Owen Dudley Edwards 115 i

6 Scottish Affairs, no. 60, summer 200 REVIEW: A BOOK OF LIVES EberhardBort 140 REVIEW: CRIMES OF LOYALTY Steve Bruce 144 REVIEW: RETHINKING NATIONALISM Shanti Sumartojo and Ben Wellings 148 REVIEW: REVITALISING GAELIC Sharon Macdonald 151 REVIEW: SCOTTISH DIASPORAS Tom Hubbard 155 REVIEW: GLOBAL SCOTS Kenny Kemp 158 REVIEW: FROM TROCCHI TO Trainspotting Gavin Miller 161 REFEREES, JUNE 2006 TO MAY ii

7 Essential Reading from Edinburgh University Press { Books > The Government of Scotland Michael Keating February pp Pb Scottish Local Government An Introduction Allan McConnelf October pp Hb X0 Pb Living In Scotland Socio/ ond Economic Change since 1980 Lindsay Peterson, Frank Bechhofer, and David McCrone July pp Pb X Holy rood The Inside Story Susan Bain The fascinating story of the building of the Scottish parliament, told by the assistant producer of controversial documentary series The Gathering Place. April 2005 Pb 320pp The Scottish Labour Party History, Institutions and Ideas Edited by Gerry Hassan March pp Pb I Sectarianism in Scotland Steve Brucejony Glendinning, tain Peterson, Michael Rosie June pp Pb Has Devolution ^lavi Delivered? Edited by Catherine Bromley, John Curtice, David McCrone and Alison Park Draws upon the Scottish Section Studies and the Scottish Social Attitudes surveys to examine in detail how the Scottish public has reacted to devolution. July pp Pb The Transformation of Scotland The Economy since 1100 Edited bytom Devine, Give H. Lee and George Peden February pp Hb X Pb Ç Journals *y Journal of Scottish Philosophy Published on behalf of the Scots Philosophical Cub Publishes work by philosophers and historians of Ideas on all aspects of every period of the Scottish philosophical tradition. 2 issues per year Edinburgh Law Review High-quality, original refereed writing on contemporary substantive law, legal theory and history, and other aspects of the study of law in its social and cultural context 3 issues per year Journal of Scottish Historical Studies A forum for current research and general interest articles on all aspects of Scottish economic and social history including business history, gender, urban history, labour history and cultural history. 2 issues per year Parliamentary History A forum for current research on all aspects of the history of parliaments, including Scottish and Irish parliaments, from the middle ages to the Twentieth Century. 3 Issues per year 0264*2824 Architectural Heritage The Journal of the Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland This illustrated Journal presents a wide variety of scholarship on architectural and conservation topics. / issue per year Scottish Historical Review Covers all periods of Scottish history from the early to the modern, encouraging a variety of historical approaches. 2 issues per year Order online at Tel

8 Established in 1847 "for the promotion of sound learning" The Educational Institute of Scotland The only Scottish teaching union representing teachers and lecturers at all levels and in all sectors. join the EIS today 46 Moray Place Edinburgh EH3 6BH Tel Fax

9 YOUR ONE STOP PRINT SHOP Offering a one-stop shop for all your business printing needs. We can help you promote your business with a wide range of printed materials. We offer a complete service, from consultation and initial design, through to the complete finished product. We are fully equipped to produce a large variety of work including stationery, multi-part forms, envelopes, leaflets and brochures. Some samples be viewed on our website. Contact: Printing Services 13 Infirmary Street Edinburgh EH 1 1LT Tel printlng@ed.ac.uk