A Cross-Country Review of Contaminated Land Litigation
|
|
- Meryl Stone
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 A Cross-Country Review of Contaminated Land Litigation Marc McAree Specialist in Environmental Law Certified by the Law Society of Upper Canada Willms & Shier Environmental Lawyers LLP Toronto Maxxam Analytics Inc. Fall Environmental Technical Workshop Burnaby, British Columbia November 4, 2010
2 Roadmap Environmental Class Actions Foreseeability in Negligence Where Historic Contamination Assessment of Damages Involving Contaminated Land Mitigation of Damages: Clean up to Prescribed Standards versus Risk Assessment
3 Environmental Class Actions
4 Class Proceedings Act Avoid multiple proceedings where common issues Define class of plaintiffs a definable number of persons who allegedly suffered harm from the same event Plaintiff is required to seek court certification of the class Certification is not a ruling on the merits Usual litigation process occurs after certification including trial and appeals
5 Environmental Class Actions Environmental class actions Now viable, several have been certified Only two have gone to and through trial o St. Lawrence Cement and Inco Property trumps health Except in Quebec, most successful environmental class action certifications in Canada are limited to claims for property damage Individual plaintiffs are free to pursue health claims in individual lawsuits
6 Class Action Trends Hollick v. City of Toronto Keele Valley Landfill No common issue to justify certification: SCC Smith v. Inco Port Colborne, Ontario Ontario Court of Appeal granted certification (2006) against Inco for longterm emissions from a nickel refinery in Port Colborne for property value claims, not health claims (withdrawn); trial decision is under appeal
7 Class Action Trends Windsor v. CPR Calgary, Alberta Residents class action certified due to groundwater beneath them which was contaminated with trichloroethylene (TCE), a solvent which was used by the defendant Canadian Pacific Railway Limited (CPR) as an engine and railway rolling stock degreaser for years (Certification upheld by Alberta Court of Appeal in 2007) Wambolt v. Northstar Aerospace Cambridge, Ontario Residents within 3 miles of plant claim loss of property value due to TCE contamination of soil and groundwater based on negligence, nuisance and breach of duty (Certified June 2009)
8 St. Lawrence Cement St. Lawrence Cement v. Barrette November 20, 2008 (SCC) SCC upheld Quebec class action brought by neighbours of a St. Lawrence Cement facility for causing odour, noise and dust annoyance to neighbours SCC found a scheme of no-fault civil liability for neighbourhood disturbances in French civil law and Canadian common law
9 Sydney Tar Ponds MacQueen v. Ispat Sidbec Inc. Claim filed May 24, 2004 and subsequently amended Governments had operated steel company before bankruptcy and assured residents that it was safe to continue living in their homes Residents launching class action against Nova Scotia and federal governments and former owner/operator of steel company Residents alleged that governments had a fiduciary duty to residents and breached that duty by failing to warn them about health risks that the government knew about
10 Sydney Tar Ponds Governments challenged allegation of breach of fiduciary duty Court challenge dismissed by Supreme Court Nova Scotia has no class proceedings legislation Nova Scotia Supreme Court will now proceed with certification hearing under common law class action principles How will this case affect the duty of industry and government to warn residents of potential environmental and health risks?
11 Smith v. Inco: Issue The plaintiffs asserted that nickel emissions contaminated the Port Colborne environment, especially a low-income area adjacent to and downwind from the refinery Testing by the Ministry of the Environment confirmed this Initially, the plaintiffs sought damages for Diminution in property value Health impacts
12 Smith v. Inco: Certification In 2003, the Divisional Court found insufficient commonality between members to constitute the proposed class, and dismissed the appeal In 2006, the Ontario Court of Appeal certified the class action when the plaintiff abandoned its claim for health impacts Eliminated much of the uncertainty that the lower courts struggled with. Ultimately, the class was certified for claims relating to diminution in property value only
13 Smith v. Inco: Trial In July 2010, 7,000 property owners were awarded $36 million for reduced property value Trial decision raised issues of Strict liability Nuisance Limitation period and discoverability Standard for civil liability Inco held liable under nuisance and strict liability
14 Smith v. Inco: Trial Strict Liability Rylands v. Fletcher Reasonable use of land for lawful commercial purpose is NOT a defence to strict liability Damage does not need to be the result of an isolated escape Private Nuisance Nuisance can be caused indirectly, but there must be actual damage Physical damage includes diminution in property value due to contamination o in this case the claim is for the physical damage, not inconvenience Claim can be made for decreased property value even though the plaintiff s property was not sold or there was no attempt to sell the property
15 Smith v. Inco: Trial Limitations and Discoverability In Ontario, there is now a 2 year limitation period to bring a claim Begins to run when knew or ought to have known that there is a claim Inco had not operated its refinery for 26 years Plaintiffs claimed that public disclosure in 2000 about the nickel contamination in soil resulted in decreased property value
16 Smith v. Inco: Trial Limitations and Discoverability Court held that o cause of action did not arise until plaintiffs knew or ought to have known that nickel soil contamination caused loss in property value o even using reasonable due diligence, real estate agents would not have known about reduced property value until public disclosure in 2000 o if real estate agents were unaware of the effect of nickel soil contamination on property value, it was unlikely that members of the public would be aware Result: Action not barred by limitation period
17 Smith v. Inco: Trial Standard for Civil Liability MOE sets the standard for property clean ups o based on risk to human health o not based on impacts to property value MOE does NOT set the standard for civil liability o Courts set the standard for civil liability o Court in Inco was concerned about property value not health effects o this begs the question what is the effect of future reliance on MOE Standards as evidence of contamination?
18 Smith v. Inco: Trial Decision has significant implications Environmental class actions are now viable for plaintiffs Industry is on notice that operations cannot be permitted to negatively impact neighbours Decades old pollution may surface as the basis for civil liability in class actions Courts will try to be lenient with limitation expiry, if logically possible Inco filed Notice of Appeal to the Ontario Court of Appeal on August 3, 2010
19 Foreseeability in Negligence Where Historic Contamination
20 Berendsen v. Ontario - Trial Chronology January 18, 2008, Ontario SCJ (Trial) December 1, 2009 Ontario Court of Appeal overturns trial decision October 7, 2010 Friends of the Earth applies for leave to intervene (not yet decided) May 20, 2010 SCC grants leave to appeal At trial, $1.7 million award against Ontario government for negligence for Disposing of waste asphalt from highway construction near water supply on dairy farm Failure and breach of duty to properly exercise its statutory powers of investigation and remediation of impaired farm water
21 Berendsen v. Ontario - Trial Facts MTO buried road reconstruction waste on farm, near watercourse Subsequent purchaser s dairy cows suffered health effects and low milk production Issues Government liability in negligence for o depositing the road bed waste (MTO) o not carrying out its statutory duties to investigate and remediate (MOE)
22 Berendsen v. Ontario Trial Crown s standard of care was taken in context of its statutory powers of Highway repair and maintenance Water protection Environmental protection Court found that even in the 1960s and 1970s Crown employees should have reasonably known about the hazards of burying road bed waste near water on a dairy farm Crown unsuccessfully argued that it had no duty of care where contamination did not exceed the Ontario Drinking Water Objectives
23 Berendsen v. Ontario Appeal Ontario Court of Appeal overturns trial decision [85] I would allow Ontario s appeal, set aside the judgment at trial and dismiss the action. In my view, Ontario was not negligent when it deposited waste materials on the farm in the 1960s. Because the risk of harm was not then reasonably foreseeable, Ontario did not breach the standard of care [86] Nor did Ontario have a duty in the 1980s or 1990s to eliminate the waste material and remediate the Berendsens well water. No duty existed under the Ontario legislative regime protecting our environment. And Ontario was justified in not taking further action when both its investigation and investigation conducted for the Berendsens showed that no chemicals in the Berendsens well water exceeded the allowable provincial drinking water standards
24 Berendsen v. Ontario SCC Supreme Court of Canada has tentatively scheduled the appeal hearing for January 28, 2011 Issue of foreseeability for historic contamination will be at the fore of what the Supreme Court of Canada decides What was the standard of care when the contamination occurred and was it then foreseeable that today s known outcome would be the result? The Supreme Court s dictum about this question in Berendsen will have significant implications for claims involving historic contamination
25 Assessment of Damages Involving Contaminated Land
26 Tridan v. Shell Canada - Trial Tridan sued for $1.6M 9,000 litres of fuel was lost at the service station and some migrated next door Adjacent property was occupied by a profitable Ford dealership Current use for car sales and repair could be lawfully continued without clean-up Before trial, Shell admitted liability and indemnified Tridan for extra financing costs relating to the contamination
27 Tridan v. Shell Canada - Trial The trial judge ordered Shell to pay $550,000 for clean-up costs to pristine (more stringent than the MOE Guideline) $20,000 for business interruption during remediation $25,000 for increased mortgage financing costs (4 months) $85,000 if Shell did not construct a contaminant barrier $350,000 for loss of property value based on stigma even after damages to clean up to pristine (17% - 18%)
28 Tridan v. Shell Canada - Appeal Ontario Court of Appeal January 3, 2002 There is no stigma loss where damages are awarded for clean up to pristine A clean up to MOE Standards would result in an award of 12% to 15% stigma $85,000 should be paid without conditions No order to pay monies into Court In the end, CofA awarded damages for the cost to clean up to pristine plus nil for stigma SCC refused leave to appeal October 3, 2002
29 Cousins v. McColl- Frontenac - Trial Value of property uncontaminated: $100,000 Claim for Clean Up Cost: $1.5M to $2.3M Damages awarded: $125,000, representing one-third of total net investment of $376,000 (including interest) in three parcels of land A plaintiff is entitled to recover reasonable damages for contamination of land Damages may not be the cost of clean up where property value is less than the cost to clean up
30 Cousins v. McColl- Frontenac - Appeal New Brunswick Court of Appeal January 21, 2008 Appeal Court issued a brief and insubstantial 1 ½ page decision Appeal Court agreed that damages should not be awarded on an as is purchase Appeal Court agreed that damages should be assessed by reference to net investment and carrying costs plus interest which is unrelated to the cost to clean and/or diminution in value Supreme Court of Canada granted leave (April 3, 2008) but the case settled before the hearing
31 Lessons from Tridan and Cousins Owners do not have to sell or clean up to successfully sue for damages Damages for diminished property value will be based on the best evidence available to the courts; this may include the estimated costs to clean up the site, and or appraisal evidence of loss of value; the quality of expert appraisal evidence will be a critical factor Owners may also recover related financing and business disturbance losses
32 Lessons from Tridan and Cousins The court accepted evidence that the property value may be reduced by stigma even after the property is cleaned up to Ministry standards, but the court found that there was no evidence of stigma after clean-up to pristine condition If you happen to own lower value property or property in a less highly valued part of the country, you should not expect damages based on the cost to clean up
33 Mitigation of Damages
34 Mitigation of Damages Mitigation: the principle that a plaintiff may not recover losses that could have been avoided by taking reasonable steps Applies to tort and contract law Mitigation is intended to Minimize the total costs of the tort or breach of contract Avoid unduly burdening the defendant Negate a windfall for the plaintiff Failure of the plaintiff to mitigate can result in limiting the plaintiff s damages
35 Mitigation of Damages Can a plaintiff choose a more expensive contaminant remediation method and expect the defendant to pay? How much is too much mitigation? Question of fact plaintiff must take reasonable steps Burden of proof to show plaintiff s failure to mitigate is on the defendant In case of doubt, the plaintiff will usually receive the benefit Reasonable action may not always be the most economical choice available
36 Mitigation of Damages Where the cost to repair the damage exceeds the market price of the property, the owner is expected to follow the most economic path Plaintiffs claim they are entitled to remediation to Ministry standards or pristine Tridan v. Shell Canada
37 Mitigation of Damages Defendants claim that under the duty to mitigate, plaintiffs are entitled to the cost of Risk Assessment plus risk management measures and possibly damages for stigma Why the debate? The difference in cost to remediate to Ministry standards may be orders of magnitude greater than Risk Assessment cost Risk Assessment is becoming more acceptable in the marketplace (slowly but surely) In Ontario, both methods result in a Record of Site Condition filed on the Environmental Site Registry MOE good housekeeping seal of approval No Canadian Court has decided this issue; this will not be the case for long!
38 Contact Information Marc McAree (416) Willms & Shier Environmental Lawyers LLP
Environmental Causes of Action
Environmental Causes of Action NEERLS / SEER April 2012, Vancouver, PhD Law 1 Overview n Negligence: Berendsen n Nuisance n Carrier n Smith v. Inco; MacQueen n Heyes n Rylands / Trespass: Inco 2 Berendsen
More informationPolluter Pays Doctrine Underscored: Section 99(2) of the EPA Applied: Some Thoughts on Midwest Properties Ltd. v. Thordarson, 2015 ONCA 819
1 Polluter Pays Doctrine Underscored: Section 99(2) of the EPA Applied: Some Thoughts on Midwest Properties Ltd. v. Thordarson, 2015 ONCA 819 Some Thoughts by the Lawyers at Willms & Shier Environmental
More informationManaging Environmental Liabilities: Case Law Update. SMART Remediation Toronto, ON January 28, 2016
Managing Environmental Liabilities: Case Law Update and Case Studies Jacquelyn Stevens Willms & Shier Environmental Lawyers LLP SMART Remediation Toronto, ON January 28, 2016 SMART is Powered by: www.vertexenvironmental.ca
More informationEnvironmental Case Law Update
Environmental Case Law Update John Georgakopoulos Partner, Certified Specialist in Environmental Law by the Law Society of Ontario Law Firm of the Year for Environmental Law in The Best Lawyers in Canada,
More informationCivil and Regulatory Liability Associated with Spills and Historic Site Contamination
Scotia Plaza 40 King St. West, Suite 5800 P.O. Box 1011 Toronto, ON Canada M5H 3S1 Tel. 416.595.8500 Fax.416.595.8695 www.millerthomson.com TORONTO VANCOUVER WHITEHORSE CALGARY EDMONTON LONDON KITCHENER-WATERLOO
More informationCONTAMINATED SITES AND THE LAW - TODAY AND TOMORROW -
CONTAMINATED SITES AND THE LAW - TODAY AND TOMORROW - LLP Ronald M. Kruhlak, McLennan Ross LLP Remediation Technologies Symposium 2003 October 15-17, 2003, Banff, Alberta Environmental Law Assist clients
More informationCourt of Appeal on Smith v. Inco: Rylands v. Fletcher Revisited By Michael S. Hebert and Cheryl Gerhardt McLuckie*
Court of Appeal on Smith v. Inco: Rylands v. Fletcher Revisited By Michael S. Hebert and Cheryl Gerhardt McLuckie* In October 2011, the Ontario Court of Appeal released its much anticipated decision in
More informationENVIRONMENTAL LAW AND LIABILITY 101: SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY - ENSC 406
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW AND LIABILITY 101: SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY - ENSC 406 EDITED, UPDATED AND PRESENTED BY BOB GILL, P.ENG., FEC Originally Prepared by Catherine A. Hofmann Hofmann@BernardLLP.ca Vancouver
More informationAMENDED STATEMENT OF CLAIM. Proceeding under the Class Proceedings Act, S.N.S 2007, c. 28
FORM 4.02B AMENDED STATEMENT OF CLAIM Proceeding under the Class Proceedings Act, S.N.S 2007, c. 28 1. In this Statement of Claim, the following capitalized terms have the meanings set out below: (a) (b)
More informationEnvironmental Class Actions 1
Environmental Class Actions 1 A. INTRODUCTION Ecojustice made the news on March 31 st of this year for its representation of the Quebec Environmental Law Centre and Friends of the Earth Canada as intervenors
More informationPOLLUTION PREVENTION AND CLEAN-UP BYLAW NO. 8475
CITY OF RICHMOND POLLUTION PREVENTION AND CLEAN-UP BYLAW NO. 8475 EFFECTIVE DATE October 13, 2009 Prepared for publication: November 2, 2009 CITY OF RICHMOND POLLUTION PREVENTION AND CLEAN-UP BYLAW NO.
More informationExploring the Viability of Environmental Class Actions in the Historical Contamination Context: Death of the Historical Contamination Class Action?
Exploring the Viability of Environmental Class Actions in the Historical Contamination Context: Death of the Historical Contamination Class Action? By: Mandy Kinzel and Howard Kohn** Forbes Chochla LLP
More informationONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE DAVID CARMICHAEL. -and-
(1fl ~ I CJ~!fl%'1( Court File No. ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE DAVID CARMICHAEL -and- Plaintiff VIA RAIL CANADA INC., CANADIAN NATIONAL RAILWAY COMPANY, and CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY COMPANY Defendants
More informationSMART Remediation Ottawa, ON February 4, 2016
Experts in Environmental Litigation Marc McAree Willms & Shier Environmental Lawyers LLP SMART Remediation Ottawa, ON February 4, 2016 SMART is Powered by: www.vertexenvironmental.ca Experts in Environmental
More informationAfter the Spill: Issues to Consider in Dealing with the Long Term Implications and Liabilities of a Spill
Institute 2010 of Continuing Legal Education Environmental Law The Life Cycle of a Spill: From the Hot Call to Putting the Genie Back in the Bottle and Everything in Between After the Spill: Issues to
More informationContract and Tort Law for Engineers
Contract and Tort Law for Engineers Christian S. Tacit Tel: 613-599-5345 Email: ctacit@tacitlaw.com Canadian Systems of Law There are two systems of law that operate in Canada Common Law and Civil Law
More informationBurges Salmon. The Legal 500 & The In-House Lawyer. Legal Briefing Projects, energy and natural resources. The Legal 500
Burges Salmon The Legal 500 & The In-House Lawyer Legal Briefing Projects, energy and natural resources The Legal 500 Michael Barlow, partner michael.barlow@burges-salmon.com Simon Tilling, associate simon.tilling@burges-salmon.com
More informationIntroductory Guide to Civil Litigation in Ontario
Introductory Guide to Civil Litigation in Ontario Table of Contents INTRODUCTION This guide contains an overview of the Canadian legal system and court structure as well as key procedural and substantive
More informationEnvironmental Causes of Action. Six Minute Environmental Law Dianne Saxe, Ph.D.
Environmental Causes of Action Six Minute Environmental Law, Ph.D. 1 Overview n Nuisance n Negligence n Trespass n Strict Liability (Rylands v. Fletcher) n Riparian Rights n Statutory Causes of Action
More informationOntario Expropriation Association Annual Case Law Update
Ontario Expropriation Association Annual Case Law Update October 25, 2013 Guillaume Lavictoire Introduction To avoid being remembered as the presenter who overlooked Antrim 1 in 2013, I begin by noting
More informationTHE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF INNISFIL. Consolidated Site Alteration By-law BY-LAW As Amended by By-law
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF INNISFIL BY-LAW 050-13 As Amended by By-law 045-14 A By-law of The Corporation of the Town of Innisfil to prohibit and regulate the placing or dumping of fill, the removal
More informationENVIRONMENTAL LIABILITY AND INSURANCE COVERAGE IN BRITISH COLUMBIA:
ENVIRONMENTAL LIABILITY AND INSURANCE COVERAGE IN BRITISH COLUMBIA: A Primer on Contaminated Sites and Clean-Up Cost Recovery Litigation by Neo J. Tuytel and Jonathan L.S. Hodes Environmental and Insurance
More informationPollution (Control) Act 2013
Pollution (Control) Act 2013 REPUBLIC OF VANUATU POLLUTION (CONTROL) ACT NO. 10 OF 2013 Arrangement of Sections REPUBLIC OF VANUATU Assent: 14/10/2013 Commencement: 27/06/2014 POLLUTION (CONTROL) ACT NO.
More informationChecklist XX - Sources of Municipal and Personal Liability and Immunity. Subject matter MA COTA Maintenance of highways and bridges
Checklist XX - Sources of Municipal and Personal Liability and Immunity See also extensive case law in this volume under the sections identified below, and in the introduction to Part XV. A. Public highways
More informationClean Neighbourhoods and Environment Act (Northern Ireland) 2011
Clean Neighbourhoods and Environment 2011 CHAPTER 23 An Act to make provision for the gating of certain minor roads; to make provision in relation to vehicles parked on roads that are exposed for sale
More informationFood Donation and Civil Liability in Canada. placeholder REDUCING WASTE AND RECOVERING FOOD IN CANADA
placeholder REDUCING WASTE AND RECOVERING FOOD IN CANADA Food Donation and Civil Liability in Canada Companion to the Guidelines to Minimize Wasted Food and Facilitate Food Donations The National Zero
More informationA Year in Review: Top Ten Canadian Law Cases of 2010
A Year in Review: Top Ten Canadian Law Cases of 2010 May 05, 2011 Top Ten By Crawford G. Smith, Torys LLP This resource is sponsored by: Authored by Crawford G. Smith, Torys LLP The top cases of 2010 encompass
More informationSubstantial and Unreasonable Injurious Affection after Antrim Truck Centre Ltd. v. Ontario (Transportation)
May 2013 Municipal Law Section Substantial and Unreasonable Injurious Affection after Antrim Truck Centre Ltd. v. Ontario (Transportation) By Scott McAnsh Antrim Truck Stop is located just off Highway
More informationSTATEMENT OF CLAIM. (Court File No. ) FEDERAL COURT. BETWEEN: DAN PELLETIER Plaintiff. and. HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN Defendant.
STATEMENT OF CLAIM (Court File No. ) FEDERAL COURT BETWEEN: DAN PELLETIER Plaintiff and HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN Defendant (Court seal) STATEMENT OF CLAIM TO THE DEFENDANT PROPOSED CLASS PROCEEDING A LEGAL
More informationLICENCE OF OCCUPATION OF A CROWN LAND situated at 580 Booth Street Ottawa, Ontario
LICENCE OF OCCUPATION OF A CROWN LAND situated at 580 Booth Street Ottawa, Ontario HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF CANADA as represented by the Minister of Public Works and Government Services TELUS
More informationTHE SIX-MINUTE Environmental Lawyer
TAB 1 THE SIX-MINUTE Environmental Lawyer The Latest on Damages for Continuing Nuisance Bryan Buttigieg, C.S. Miller Thomson LLP October 20, 2016 Six-Minute Environmental Lawyer 2016 The Law Society of
More informationBY-LAW NUMBER of - THE CORPORATION OF THE COUNTY OF BRANT. To regulate yard maintenance
BY-LAW NUMBER 97-17 - of - THE CORPORATION OF THE COUNTY OF BRANT To regulate yard maintenance WHEREAS the Council of the Corporation of the County of Brant is desirous of enacting a bylaw to regulate
More informationChapter 8 - Common Law
Common Law Environmental Liability What Is Common Law? A set of principles, customs and rules Of conduct Recognized, affirmed and enforced By the courts Through judicial decisions. 11/27/2001 ARE 309-Common
More informationBUSINESS LAW THE ROLE OF LAW IN CANADIAN SOCIETY BUSINESS LAW. Appendix A. Sources of Law. The Court System
Appendix A BUSINESS LAW THE ROLE OF LAW IN CANADIAN SOCIETY Law is the set of rules and standards that a society agrees upon to govern the behaviour of its citizens. Both the British and the French influenced
More informationLICENCE W I N T E R IN THIS ISSUE. Stephanie Lysyk (Vancouver Office)
W I N T E R 2 0 0 6 E N V I R O N M E N TA L L AW N E W S IN THIS ISSUE 1 COURT ORDERS CROWN TO CONSULT FIRST NATION BEFORE REMOVING PRIVATELY OWNED FOREST LAND FROM TREE FARM LICENCE - Stephanie Lysyk
More informationerne Court of Nova Scotia Michael MacKay Plai and Nova Scotia Power Incorporated Defendant Notice of Action
( 20:11 NOV 0 3 Z011 Pic No. PFHrfHONOT AR~u erne Court of Nova Scotia Be ween: Michael MacKay Plai and Nova Scotia Power Incorporated Defendant Notice of Action Proceeding under the Class Proceedings
More informationBERMUDA CLEAN AIR ACT : 38
QUO FA T A F U E R N T BERMUDA CLEAN AIR ACT 1991 1991 : 38 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Short title Interpretation The Environmental Authority
More information2014 ONSC 4841 Ontario Superior Court of Justice. Cruz v. McPherson CarswellOnt 11387, 2014 ONSC 4841, 244 A.C.W.S. (3d) 720
2014 ONSC 4841 Ontario Superior Court of Justice Cruz v. McPherson 2014 CarswellOnt 11387, 2014 ONSC 4841, 244 A.C.W.S. (3d) 720 Terra Cruz and Carmen Cruz, Plaintiffs and Jason Mcpherson, 546291 Ontario
More informationLet the Good Times Roll: Court Allows the Free Flow of Liquor Across Provincial Borders
International Trade Bulletin July 2016 Let the Good Times Roll: Court Allows the Free Flow of Liquor Across Provincial Borders Broad Issues Considered and Resolved in Gerald Comeau v. The Queen Should
More informationClean Neighbourhoods and Environment Act (Northern-Ireland) 2011
Clean Neighbourhoods and Environment Act (Northern-Ireland) CHAPTER 23 1. Gating orders CONTENTS PART 1 GATING ORDERS PART 2 VEHICLES Nuisance parking offences 2. Exposing vehicles for sale on a road 3.
More informationMUNICIPALITY OF JASPER BYLAW #046
Jasper Nuisance Bylaw Page 1 of 6 MUNICIPALITY OF JASPER BYLAW #046 BEING A BYLAW OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF JASPER IN THE PROVINCE OF ALBERTA FOR THE PURPOSE OF PROHIBITING, ELIMINATING OR ABATING OF NUISANCE
More informationBUILDING MAINTENANCE (STRATA MANAGEMENT) REGULATIONS SECOND SCHEDULE PRESCRIBED BY-LAWS
BUILDING MAINTENANCE (STRATA MANAGEMENT) REGULATIONS SECOND SCHEDULE PRESCRIBED BY-LAWS Regulations 20 and 21 Noise 1. A subsidiary proprietor or an occupier of a lot shall not create any noise on a lot
More informationFORM 29. Strata Titles Act Section 69A (f) BUYING AND SELLING A STRATA TITLED LOT
FORM 29 ATTACHMENT NO. 1 Strata Titles Act 1985 Section 69A (f) BUYING AND SELLING A STRATA TITLED LOT This information applies to lots in a strata scheme and a survey-strata scheme. If you are uncertain
More informationToward Better Accountability
Toward Better Accountability Each year, our Annual Report addresses issues of accountability and initiatives to help improve accountability in government and across the broader public sector. This year,
More informationIN THE SUPREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA
NO. VANCOUVER REGISTRY IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA BETWEEN TIGRA WOODS PLAINTIFF AND ON-COURSE GOLF GOODS AND EQUIPMENT INC. NOTICE OF CIVIL CLAIM DEFENDANT This action has been started by
More informationSOLOMON ISLANDS THE ENVIRONMENT ACT 1998 (NO. 8 OF 1998) Passed by the National Parliament this twentieth day of October 1998.
Environment Act 1998 (Commenced 1 September 2003 as per LN No.77 2003) SOLOMON ISLANDS THE ENVIRONMENT ACT 1998 (NO. 8 OF 1998) Passed by the National Parliament this twentieth day of October 1998. Assented
More informationInvestigative Negligence. Hill v. Hamilton-Wentworth Regional Police Services Board (2007)
Investigative Negligence Hill v. Hamilton-Wentworth Regional Police Services Board (2007) By Gino Arcaro M.Ed., B.Sc. Niagara College Coordinator Police Foundations Program I. Commentary Part 1 Every police
More informationCP Motors Storage Terms & Conditions (2014)
CP Motors Storage Terms & Conditions (2014) You may have other rights granted by law in addition to those set out in these terms and conditions which We may not exclude. These terms and conditions do not
More informationCompensating Claims for Reduced Access a Safari through the impenetrable jungle of nuisance law and injurious affection in Ontario
February 2013 Public Sector Lawyers' Section Compensating Claims for Reduced Access a Safari through the impenetrable jungle of nuisance law and injurious affection in Ontario Graham Rempe and Matthew
More informationSOIL REMOVAL AND DEPOSITION BYLAW
City of Vernon SOIL REMOVAL AND DEPOSITION BYLAW #5259 BYLAW NO. THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF VERNON ADOPTION BYLAW NUMBER 5259 AMENDMENTS AMENDMENT 5670 February 26, 2018 Regulatory Updates as follows:
More information1.2. "the Deposit" means any of the sums paid to BSL in accordance with clause 4.4.
BURNHAM STORAGE Terms and Conditions 1. Interpretation In this Contract: 1.1. "BSL" means Burnham Storage Ltd and "The Customer" means the individual, company, firm or other person with whom BSL contracts,
More informationInternational Invasive Weed Conference: Risk, Roots & Research. Some Legal Considerations by Leo Charalambides 1
Property Care Association, London, 22 nd November, 2016 International Invasive Weed Conference: Risk, Roots & Research Some Legal Considerations by Leo Charalambides 1 Session 1, Risk: an examination of
More informationTHE LAW OF NUISANCE IN CANADA
THE LAW OF NUISANCE IN CANADA Gregory S. Pun, B.A., LL.B. Of the Ontario Bar, Of the British Columbia Bar Margaret I. Hall, LL.B., LL.M. Of the British Columbia Bar LexisNexis* TABLE OF CONTENTS Dedication
More informationProtection of Environment Act 2053 B.S. (1997)
Protection of Environment Act 2053 B.S. (1997) The Following Act issued by His Majesty the King Birendra Bir Bikram Shah Dev has been published for the information of the public general. Act No. 24 of
More informationGuidelines for Part 17.2 of the Dutch Environmental Management Act: measures in the event of environmental damage or its imminent threat (English
Guidelines for Part 17.2 of the Dutch Environmental Management Act: measures in the event of environmental damage or its imminent threat (English translation of original version dated 8 January 2008) Introduction
More informationThe Mineral Resources Act
The Mineral Resources Act UNEDITED being Chapter 50 of The Revised Statutes of Saskatchewan, 1965 (effective February 7, 1966). NOTE: This consolidation is not official. Amendments have been incorporated
More informationCORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF INGERSOLL BY-LAW NO A by-law to provide for the regulation of Open Air Burning in the Town of Ingersoll.
CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF INGERSOLL BY-LAW NO. 13-4726 A by-law to provide for the regulation of Open Air Burning in the Town of Ingersoll. WHEREAS Div. B article 2.6.3.4.of the Ontario Fire Code regulates
More informationEnvironmental Law for Facilities Managers. Mr James Pong Mr Francis Yeung
Environmental Law for Facilities Managers Mr James Pong Mr Francis Yeung Environmental law civil or criminal in nature Nuisance is always a balancing exercise One man s meat may be another man s poison
More information310 CMR: DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
40.1003: General Provisions for Permanent and Temporary Solutions (1) All necessary and required response actions under 310 CMR 40.0000 shall not have been conducted at a site or disposal site unless and
More informationBY LAW. Number ROAD OCCUPANCY PERMIT BY LAW. within the Town of New Tecumseth
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF NEW TECUMSETH BY LAW Number 2013 161 ROAD OCCUPANCY PERMIT BY LAW A By Law to regulate Road Occupancy on Municipal Highways within the Town of New Tecumseth WHEREAS Section
More informationTHE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF SHELBURNE NUMBER
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF SHELBURNE NUMBER 26-2015 BEING A BYLAW TO REGULATE SITE ALTERATIONS, PLACEMENT OF FILL AND REMOVAL OF TOPSOIL WITHIN THE TOWN OF SHELBURNE WHEREAS Section 142 of the Municipal
More informationWhen New Data Give Way to Claims Over Old Contamination
When New Data Give Way to Claims Over Old Contamination By Steven C. Russo & Ashley S. Miller April 17, 2009 One of the most significant hazardous waste issues in New York and elsewhere over the past few
More informationInjurious Affection Claims where No Land is Taken after Antrim: Charting a New Course?
Injurious Affection Claims where No Land is Taken after Antrim: Charting a New Course? In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court of Canada overturned the Ontario Court of Appeal s decision and restored
More informationQuestion Farmer Jones? Discuss. 3. Big Food? Discuss. -36-
Question 4 Grain Co. purchases grain from farmers each fall to resell as seed grain to other farmers for spring planting. Because of problems presented by parasites which attack and eat seed grain that
More informationSUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, CENTRAL DISTRICT
1 1 1 1 1 1 RUTAN & TUCKER, LLP Richard Montevideo (BAR NO. ) Eric Dunn (BAR NO. ) Anton Boulevard, Fourteenth Floor Costa Mesa, California - Telephone: 1-1-0 Facsimile: 1--0 Attorneys for Plaintiff LITTLE
More information.,;:(.~. * VANCOUVER REGISTRY IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA PHIL BEEDLE
OF ~UPREME COURT VAN~ll~PRCROELUMB IA GIST RY S- 17 5315.::~,~ JUN 05 2017.. ::::~ :. No.. '.,;:(.~. * VANCOUVER REGISTRY IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA BETWEEN: PHIL BEEDLE PLAINTIFF AND: GENERAL
More informationProduct Recalls: Crisis Management and Class Action Prevention
Product Recalls: Crisis Management and Class Action Prevention Gord McKee, Jill Lawrie, Nicole Henderson, Robin Linley & Marc-André Landry September 12, 2013 Recall Effectiveness An effective recall An
More informationEnvironmental Questionnaire
BUSINESS/BORROWER INFORMATION 1. List all locations of the applicant's business. (State whether the applicant is the owner or lessee of any premises.) 2. Describe briefly the nature of the applicant's
More informationCanada: Electronic Commerce Law Overview
Canada: Electronic Commerce Law Overview Stikeman Elliott LLP Canada: Electronic Commerce Law Overview... 2 Jurisdiction... 2... 2 Dealing with the Uncertainty... 4 Electronic Commerce Legislation... 4...
More informationCONSULTATION AND NOTIFICATION REGULATION
Oil and Gas Activities Act CONSULTATION AND NOTIFICATION REGULATION B.C. Reg. 279/2010 Deposited September 24, 2010 and effective October 4, 2010 Last amended November 30, 2017 by B.C. Reg. 217/2017 Consolidated
More informationMUNICIPAL LIABILITY FOR BY-LAW ENFORCEMENT CEMENTING THE ANALYTICAL FRAMEWORK
MUNICIPAL LIABILITY FOR BY-LAW ENFORCEMENT CEMENTING THE ANALYTICAL FRAMEWORK By Cesare Plastina Cesare Plastina 416.748.5125 cplastina@loonix.com Loopstra Nixon is a full-service Canadian business and
More informationThis document is available at WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT ACT NO. 9 OF 2002
Water Resources Management Act 2002 Commencement: 10 March 2003 This document is available at www.ielrc.org/content/e0217.pdf REPUBLIC OF VANUATU WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT ACT NO. 9 OF 2002 Arrangement
More informationORDINANCE NO GAS FRANCHISE
ORDINANCE NO. 1161 GAS FRANCHISE AN ORDINANCE GRANTING TO NEW MEXICO GAS COMPANY, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION, ITS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES, SUCCESSORS, LESSEES AND ASSIGNS, GRANTEE HEREIN, CERTAIN POWERS,
More informationPage: 1 PROVINCE OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND COURT OF APPEAL. JOHN McGOWAN and CAROLYN McGOWAN THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA
Page: 1 PROVINCE OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND COURT OF APPEAL Citation: McGowan v. Bank of Nova Scotia 2011 PECA 20 Date: 20111214 Docket: S1-CA-1202 Registry: Charlottetown BETWEEN: AND:
More information74th OREGON LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Regular Session. Enrolled. Senate Bill 149
74th OREGON LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY--2007 Regular Session Enrolled Senate Bill 149 Printed pursuant to Senate Interim Rule 213.28 by order of the President of the Senate in conformance with presession filing
More informationStudy of Civil Liability Systems for Remedying Environmental Damage FINAL REPORT. (as at 31st December 1995)
Study of Civil Liability Systems for Remedying Damage FINAL REPORT (as at 31st December 1995) This report was originally prepared by McKenna & Co McKenna & Co is now known as CMS Cameron McKenna For further
More informationFREEPORT (WATER PRESERVATION) BYE-LAWS
FREEPORT BYE-LAWS [CH.29 11 FREEPORT (WATER PRESERVATION) BYE-LAWS (SECTION 5) [Commencement 5th October, 1967] 1. These Bye-laws may be cited as the Freeport (Water Preservation) Bye-laws. 2. In these
More informationPart 1 Interpretation
The New Limitation Act Explained Page 1 Part 1 Interpretation This Part defines terms and provides some general principles of interpretation for the new Limitation Act ( new Act ). Division 1 Definitions
More informationA summary of Injurious Affection
A summary of Injurious Affection Where no land of the claimant is expropriated By Devesh Gupta 30 March 2011 For the Ontario Expropriation Association Introduction The Ontario Expropriations Act 1 ( OEA
More informationBAREKI & ANOTHER V GENCOR LTD & OTHERS 2006 (1) SA 432 (T)
BAREKI & ANOTHER V GENCOR LTD & OTHERS 2006 (1) SA 432 (T) Importance This case is notorious in environmental circles for being the judgment that failed to confirm the retrospective application of s 28
More informationCambridge International Examinations Cambridge International Advanced Subsidiary and Advanced Level. Published
Cambridge International Examinations Cambridge International Advanced Subsidiary and Advanced Level LAW 9084/43 Paper 4 MARK SCHEME Maximum Mark: 75 Published This mark scheme is published as an aid to
More informationMUNICIPALITY OF EAST HANTS BYLAW NUMBER P-100
MUNICIPALITY OF EAST HANTS BYLAW NUMBER P-100 WHEREAS Part III, Section 172(1) of the Municipal Government Act, R.S.N.S. 1998, c. 18 enables the council of a Municipality to control nuisance in the Municipality,
More informationSUPREME COURT OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND. Citation: Lank v. Government of PEI 2010 PESC 09 Date: Docket: S1-GS Registry: Charlottetown
SUPREME COURT OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND Citation: Lank v. Government of PEI 2010 PESC 09 Date: 20100218 Docket: S1-GS-16828 Registry: Charlottetown Between: Stephen Lank and Stephen Lank Enterprises Inc.
More informationHUU-AY-AHT FIRST NATIONS
HUU-AY-AHT FIRST NATIONS COMMUNITY PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT OFFICIAL CONSOLIDATION Current to December 18, 2014 The Huu-ay-aht Legislature enacts this law to provide a fair and effective system for
More informationBYLAW NUMBER
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF MONO BYLAW NUMBER 2014-31 BEING A BYLAW TO REGULATE SITE ALTERATIONS, PLACEMENT OF FILL AND REMOVAL OF TOPSOIL WITHIN THE TOWN OF MONO WHEREAS Section 142 of the Municipal
More information2ND SESSION, 41ST LEGISLATURE, ONTARIO 66 ELIZABETH II, Bill 68. (Chapter 10 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2017)
2ND SESSION, 41ST LEGISLATURE, ONTARIO 66 ELIZABETH II, 2017 Bill 68 (Chapter 10 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2017) An Act to amend various Acts in relation to municipalities The Hon. B. Mauro Minister
More informationTHE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF GODERICH BY-LAW NO. 124 OF 2016
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF GODERICH BY-LAW NO. 124 OF 2016 BEING A BY-LAW TO REGULATE THE SETTING OF OPEN FIRES AND TO REPEAL BY-LAW 112 OF 2007 WHEREAS the Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997,
More informationPEl Government Introduces Long-Awaited Lobbying Law - Strong Enforcement, but Many Gaps. Includes rare exemption for lawyers who lobby
..f:!:lsk~~,m~f(lne~~id~mtj'i~ii~ LLP I?arrlst.erlf and Sqlicitdrs. P~terit and tradii.~fii:
More informationDISPUTE RESOLUTION & LITIGATION
W: DISPUTE RESOLUTION & LITIGATION LIBRARY OF PARLIAMENT The Library of Parliament originated in the legislative libraries of Upper and Lower Canada, which were amalgamated in 1841. It is the main information
More informationSITE C PROJECT TRIPARTITE LAND AGREEMENT
Execution Version SITE C PROJECT TRIPARTITE LAND AGREEMENT This Agreement is dated, 2017 BETWEEN: AND: AND: WHEREAS: DOIG RIVER FIRST NATION, a band within the meaning of the Indian Act, R.S.C. 1985, c.
More informationROAD CROSSING AGREEMENT FOR SUB-SURFACE FACILITIES
B-12-09 ROAD CROSSING AGREEMENT FOR SUB-SURFACE FACILITIES THIS AGREEMENT made the day of 20 BETWEEN: COUNTY OF FORTY MILE NO. 8 a municipal corporation established and existing under the laws of the Province
More informationSOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIET NAM CONSTRUCTION. Independence - Freedom Happiness
THE MINISTRY OF SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIET NAM CONSTRUCTION Independence - Freedom Happiness -------- ---------------- No.: 13/2013/TT-BXD Hanoi, August 15, 2013 CIRCULAR PRESCRIBING VERIFICATION, APPRAISAL
More informationDemographics. Chapter 2 - Table of contents. Environmental Scan 2008
Environmental Scan 2008 2 Ontario s population, and consequently its labour force, is aging rapidly. The province faces many challenges related to a falling birth rate, an aging population and a large
More informationBYLAWS OF ENERGY SAFETY CANADA
BYLAWS OF ENERGY SAFETY CANADA Part 1 - Interpretation 1.1 Definitions In these By-laws, unless the context otherwise requires: Act means the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act, S.C. 2009, c. 23, including
More informationExpropriation Act CHAPTER 156 OF THE REVISED STATUTES, as amended by
Expropriation Act CHAPTER 156 OF THE REVISED STATUTES, 1989 as amended by 1992, c. 11, s. 36; 1995-96, c. 19; 2001, c. 6, s. 106; 2006, c. 16, s. 7; 2017, c. 4, ss. 80-82 2018 Her Majesty the Queen in
More informationDISTRICT OF CHETWYND BYLAW NO. 874, A bylaw to regulate or prohibit the making or causing of noises or sound in the municipality
DISTRICT OF CHETWYND BYLAW NO. 874, 2008 A bylaw to regulate or prohibit the making or causing of noises or sound in the municipality WHEREAS pursuant to the Community Charter, Council may, by bylaw, regulate,
More informationSMALL CLAIMS COURT RULES SUMMARY OF CONTENTS RULE 1 INTERPRETATION
SMALL CLAIMS COURT RULES SUMMARY OF CONTENTS Rule 1. Interpretation Rule 2. Non-Compliance with the Rules Rule 3. Time Rule 4. Parties Under Disability Rule 5. Partners and Sole Proprietorships Rule 6.
More informationSUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: R. v. Pike, 2018 NSSC 38. Jeremy Pike. v. Her Majesty the Queen
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: R. v. Pike, 2018 NSSC 38 Date: 20180214 Docket: CRPH. No. 470108 Registry: Port Hawkesbury Between: Jeremy Pike v. Her Majesty the Queen Applicant Respondent Judge:
More informationConstruction Warranties
Construction Warranties Jon W. Gilchrist Payne & Jones, Chartered Sealant, Waterproofing & Restoration Institute Fall Technical Meeting September 2006 Montreal Definition: What is a warranty? warranty?
More informationCOURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO. HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN in right of the Province of Ontario as represented by the Minister of the Environment.
Court of Appeal File No. C53611 COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO B E T W E E N: HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN in right of the Province of Ontario as represented by the Minister of the Environment (Respondent) - and
More information