49TH SINGAPORE-MALAYSIA CONGRESS OF MEDICINE (SMCM)
|
|
- Matilda Anderson
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 RODYK & DAVIDSON LLP 49TH SINGAPORE-MALAYSIA CONGRESS OF MEDICINE (SMCM) THE CURRENT LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE LEK SIANG PHENG PARTNER LITIGATION & ARBITRATION PRACTICE GROUP 2 August
2 THE IMPORTANCE OF TAKING CONSENT > Why is consent important? > Patient autonomy and right to self-determination > What constitutes a valid consent? > Sufficient information being given to the Patient (informed consent) > Patient s understanding of the information provided > Consent must be voluntarily given 2
3 THE IMPORTANCE OF TAKING CONSENT > Central theme of presentation: How much information must be provided to the Patient before there is informed consent? > Scope of presentation: Current law of consent in Singapore and potential changes moving forward 3
4 HOW CONSENT FEATURES IN MEDICAL CARE > As a matter of law: > Potential civil liability > Medical negligence (failure to provide proper advice) > Bolam / Bolitho test > Assault / battery (performing medical treatment without the Patient s prior consent) > Potential criminal liability for performing treatment without Patient s consent 4
5 HOW CONSENT FEATURES IN MEDICAL CARE > As a matter of professional ethics: Singapore Medical Council Ethical Code and Ethical Guidelines > Potential professional disciplinary action by the SMC > Overlap? 5
6 COMMONLY ASKED QUESTIONS > Point of contention: How much must you inform the patient in order for his consent to be valid? > What / how much information must a patient be provided? > What if telling the patient too much deters him from treatment? > Does the Bolam test apply to medical advice? 6
7 PRESENT STATE OF LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582 (English High Court) The Bolam test: [A doctor] is not guilty of negligence if he has acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical men skilled in that particular art. Putting in the other way round, a [doctor] is not negligent, if he is acting in accordance with such a practice, merely because there is a body of opinion who would take a contrary view. 7
8 PRESENT STATE OF LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232 (English House of Lords) > Bolam test is supplemented by the Bolitho qualification : Some key points: > Judges are not bound to find a defendant doctor not negligent just because the doctor leads evidence from a number of medical experts who are genuinely of the opinion that the treatment or diagnosis accorded with sound medical practice. > There would have to be a logical basis for the opinion, which would involve a weighing of risks against benefit in order to achieve a defensible conclusion. the threshold test of logic > If the opinion is not capable of withstanding logical analysis, then the judge is entitled to reject the opinion on the basis that it is not reasonable or responsible. 8
9 PRESENT STATE OF LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE Khoo James v Gunapathy d/o Muniandy [2002] 1 SLR(R) 1024 (Singapore Court of Appeal) > Facts: > Plaintiff was diagnosed with brain tumour > D1 performed open brain surgery and removed the tumour > D2 administered post-operative radiotherapy treatment > MRI scan later revealed a small nodule in the brain > D1 advised plaintiff that nodule likely to be a tumour and recommended radiosurgery > Post-radiosurgery: Plaintiff suffered paralysis of right body and severe speech defects > Plaintiff sued D1 and D2 9
10 PRESENT STATE OF LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE > One of the allegations of negligence: D1 did not sufficiently advise on risks of radiosurgery > D1 s advice: > Radiosurgery a simple, half day sort of a job > 5% risk of complications including brain swelling and possible stroke > Did not advise on increased risk of radionecrosis due to previous radiotherapy > Both defence experts agreed that D1 s advice was satisfactory 10
11 PRESENT STATE OF LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE > Court of Appeal s decision in Khoo James: the Bolam test applies to medical advice given to a patient > we found that the defendant doctors disclosure of the relevant percentage risks of radiosurgery was supported by a respectable body of medical opinion. They had not given negligent advice to Gunapathy. > Qualified by Bolitho: The Court can disregard medical opinion if it is not reasonable or responsible. 11
12 PRESENT STATE OF LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE > Caution: Court of Appeal s acceptance in Khoo James of the Bolam test was qualified > We would emphasise that this is not the appropriate place to address a fully argued appeal on the merits of the doctrine of informed consent. The issue did not arise in the submissions before us and we would not pronounce on it as such. 12
13 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK Sidaway v Board of Governors of the Bethlam Royal Hospital and Maudsley Hospital [1985] 1 All ER 643 (English House of Lords) > Majority of House of Lords in Sidaway: Accepted the Bolam test for medical advice > Rationale: Grounded in medical paternalism 13
14 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Minority of House of Lords in Sidaway : Rejected the Bolam test for medical advice > Rationale: Respect for a Patient s right to selfdetermination > Patient autonomy is paramount, patient should have all information necessary in order to meaningfully decide whether to undergo treatment 14
15 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11 (UK Supreme Court) > Facts: > Plaintiff (Patient) was expecting and known to be suffering from insulin dependent diabetes mellitus - likely that the baby will be larger than normal > There was a 9-10% risk of shoulder dystocia; 0.1% risk that the baby s umbilical cord will be occluded, causing hypoxia leading to cerebral palsy or death 15
16 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > O&G doctor s advice: > Baby will be larger than normal > Did not advise on: (1) shoulder dystocia, and (2) associated mechanical problems > During induced labour, shoulder dystocia occurred, doctor attempted forceps delivery but only managed to deliver baby after 12-minutes of baby s shoulder being stuck in mother s pelvis > Baby s umbilical cord was occluded during the process and diagnosed with cerebral palsy due to hypoxia 16
17 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Issues: > Whether the O&G doctor s advice was deficient and negligent? > Does the Bolam test still apply to medical advice? > UK Supreme Court s decision: > Court held that the Bolam test no longer applies to medical advice 17
18 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Reasoning in Montgomery: > Changing nature of patient-doctor relationship no longer justifies medical paternalism > Patients are no longer passive recipients of care and are consumers of medical services with the right of choice > Patients are now better informed and have greater access to medical information > Shift from medical paternalism to doctors working in partnership and in collaboration with the patient 18
19 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Reduction of medical litigation? > If patients are properly advised on the risks of treatment and take responsibility in choosing to undergo treatment Less likely to blame doctor 19
20 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Doctor s duty redefined: The doctor is under a duty to take reasonable care to ensure that the patient is aware of any material risks of treatment and of any reasonable alternative or variant treatments > Material risks? > Whether, in the circumstances of the present case, a reasonable person in the patient s position would likely attach significance to the risk OR > Whether the doctor is or should reasonably be aware that the particular patient would likely attach significance to the risk 20
21 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Factors relevant to determining materiality of risk: > Nature of the risk > Effect which its occurrence may have on the patient s life > Importance to the patient of the benefits sought to be achieved by the treatment > Available alternatives > Risks involved in those alternatives > Characteristics of the patient expressions of concern by the patient and specific questions asked 21
22 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Role of medical expert evidence: Still relevant to determining the character of risk, but the Court has the final say on materiality > Rare risks: Even if a risk is rare but carries significant consequences (e.g. death / paralysis), it should be a material risk requiring disclosure 22
23 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Examples: > Risk of blindness in one eye ought to be highlighted to a patient who is already blind in the other eye > Risk of paralysis may be material where the purpose of the operation was not to save life but only to relieve pain > In the Montgomery case: The percentage risk of shoulder dystocia was substantial for vaginal delivery whereas the risks of elective caesarean section are lesser Therefore, the doctor should advise on the risk of shoulder dystocia and the risk of injury to the baby and mother 23
24 DEVELOPMENTS OF THE LAW OF CONSENT IN UK > Exceptions: > Therapeutic exception: A doctor will be entitled to withhold information of risk if he reasonably considers that its disclosure would be seriously detrimental to the patient s health > A limited exception > Necessity: E.g. where a patient is unconscious and urgently requires treatment 24
25 IMPACT OF MONTGOMERY IN SINGAPORE > Development in English common law mirrors the earlier developments in Canada, Australia, US and Malaysia > Will Singapore follow the same approach? It remains to be seen > Singapore cases have been applying the Bolam test (bound by Gunapathy) but have not discussed the doctrine of informed consent in depth > The Montgomery test has not yet been discussed before the Singapore Court of Appeal (the highest court) > To some extent, Singapore common law tends to mirror the developments in English law > Singapore may strive to achieve consistency with other common law jurisdictions UK, Canada, Australia, US and Malaysia 25
26 IMPACT OF MONTGOMERY IN SINGAPORE > Recent Singapore medical negligence decision: > Chua Thong Jiang Andrew v Yue Wai Mun and another [2015] SGHC 119 (Singapore High Court) The Court mentioned the Montgomery case but did not go into a discussion of the case; accepted the Bolam test > Whether the surgeon ought to have discussed the 2 different surgical approaches when taking consent 26
27 IMPACT OF MONTGOMERY IN SINGAPORE > Note: Doctors are already under an ethical duty to obtain informed consent before commencing treatment > Para of the Singapore Medical Council Ethical Guidelines (on informed consent) states: > It is a doctor s responsibility to ensure that a patient under his care is adequately informed about his medical condition and options for treatment 27
28 IMPACT OF MONTGOMERY IN SINGAPORE > The patient shall be made aware of the: > Benefits of the procedure > Risks of the procedure > Possible complications of the procedure > Any alternatives available to him 28
29 CONCLUSION > Singapore law is in an uncertain state as regards the continued applicability of the Bolam test to the law of consent > As it stands, the Bolam test still applies to consent in Singapore, however, this increasingly appears to be on shaky ground 29
30 THE CURRENT LAW OF CONSENT IN SINGAPORE THANK YOU RODYK & DAVIDSON LLP SINGAPORE 80 Raffles Place LEK SIANG PHENG PARTNER LITIGATION AND ARBITRATION Telephone: This presentation is for general information purposes only. Its contents are not intended to be legal or professional advice and are not a substitute for specific advice relating to particular circumstances. Rodyk & Davidson LLP does not accept responsibility for any loss or damage arising from any reliance on the contents of this presentation. If you require specific advice or have any questions, please contact our presenter or any Rodyk partner. Rodyk & Davidson LLP Limited Liability Partnership Registration No. T07LL0439G #33-00 UOB Plaza 1 Singapore Tel Fax mail@rodyk.com SHANGHAI Unit Ocean Towers No. 550 Yan An East Road Shanghai , China Tel +86 (21) Fax +86 (21) shanghai.mail@rodyk.com 30
Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board: Dr, No
A CONFESSION I represented the defenders in this case. I drafted the Defences in May 2006. After a Procedure Roll, a Proof that lasted 15 days, a Summar Roll that lasted 8 days and 2 days in the Supreme
More informationCourt of Appeal: Lord Woolf M.R. and Roch and Mummery L.JJ.
Ex Abundante Head Notes Pearce v. United Bristol Healthcare N.H.S. Trust Court of Appeal: Lord Woolf M.R. and Roch and Mummery L.JJ. Mrs Pearce, a mother of five children was pregnant. The baby was due
More informationLDC Officials Day 2015 Bolam to Montgomery
LDC Officials Day 2015 Bolam to Montgomery Richard Birkin National Director: BDA Wales (Head of Regional Services) British Dental Association Informed Consent - definition The voluntary and continuing
More informationConsent. Simon Britten. August 2016
Consent Simon Britten August 2016 Judge Cardozo 1914 every human being of adult years and sound mind has a right to determine what should be done with his body, and a surgeon who performs an operation
More informationTesting the Bolam Test: Consequences of Recent Developments
Singapore Med J 2002 Vol 43(1) : 007-011 S M A L e c t u r e Testing the Bolam Test: Consequences of Recent Developments Mr K Shanmugam, SMA Lecturer 2001 A. INTRODUCTION The Bolam Test is a familiar concept
More informationEdinburgh Research Explorer
Edinburgh Research Explorer Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board and the Rights of the Reasonable Patient Citation for published version: Reid, E 2015, 'Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board and the Rights
More informationINFORMED CONSENT IN THE POST MONTGOMERY WORLD. Rory Anderson QC Robin Cleland, Advocate Compass Chambers 18 November 2016
INFORMED CONSENT IN THE POST MONTGOMERY WORLD Rory Anderson QC Robin Cleland, Advocate Compass Chambers 18 November 2016 Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board 2015 SC (UKSC) 63 Overruled previous House
More informationRole of Medical Experts in Medical Negligence
49 th Singapore-Malaysia Congress of Medicine (SMCM) 2 August 2015 Role of Medical Experts in Medical Negligence Dr Bertha Woon FRCSEd (Gen), JD, FAMS (General Surgery) Honorary Secretary, College of Surgeons,
More informationMedical Negligence. CUHK Med 5 Surgery Refresher Course 28 June Dr. LEE Wai Hung, Danny. MBChB, MD, FRCS, FHKAM(Surgery) LLM(Medical Law), JD
Medical Negligence CUHK Med 5 Surgery Refresher Course 28 June 2013 Dr. LEE Wai Hung, Danny MBChB, MD, FRCS, FHKAM(Surgery) LLM(Medical Law), JD Are You Bothered? Overview of Today s Talk Misconceptions
More informationAmpersand Advocates. Summer Clinical Negligence Conference Case Law update focussing on the Mesh Debate decision. Isla Davie, Advocate
Ampersand Advocates Summer Clinical Negligence Conference 2018 Case Law update focussing on the Mesh Debate decision Isla Davie, Advocate 18 th June 2018 Consideration of AH v Greater Glasgow Health Board
More informationThe decision in Birch marks another step away from the much criticised Sidaway approach to consent.
The decision in Birch marks another step away from the much criticised Sidaway approach to consent. Christopher Stone March 2010 Introduction Obtaining, in broad terms, a patient s consent to treatment
More informationHealth Law. Tracey Tremayne-Lloyd Dr. Gary Srebrolow
Health Law Research ethics approval for human and animal experimentation: Consequences of failing to obtain approval including legal and professional liability Tracey Tremayne-Lloyd* Dr. Gary Srebrolow**
More informationMedical Negligence and Personal Injury Quarterly Newsletter December 2017
Medical Negligence and Personal Injury Quarterly Newsletter December 2017 The key Court decisions during the 4 th quarter of 2017 are summarised below by category. Liability On 23 November 2017 the decision
More informationClinical Trials in Singapore
The Legislative Framework Governing Clinical Trials in Singapore This article discusses the key legislative provisions governing clinical trials in Singapore. Mak Wei Munn(Ms), Partner Litigation & Dispute
More informationStatistical information on complications and injuries associated with forceps delivery
Statistical information on complications and injuries associated with forceps delivery Reference No: 201000575 Decision Date: 12 October 2010 Kevin Dunion Scottish Information Commissioner Kinburn Castle
More informationTHE LEGAL DOCTRINE OF INFORMED CONSENT. Dr Kieran Doran, Solicitor Senior Healthcare Ethics Lecturer School of Medicine University College Cork
INFORMED CONSENT Dr Kieran Doran, Solicitor Senior Healthcare Ethics Lecturer School of Medicine University College Cork THE BASIC PRINCIPLES The Ethical and Professional Principle of Patient Autonomy
More informationProblems of Informed Consent PROFESSOR DAVE ARCHARD QUB
Problems of Informed Consent PROFESSOR DAVE ARCHARD QUB Age of Consent Standard problem of where to fix the age, and also charge of arbitrariness at using age as a marker for competence Recognition that
More informationTom Gibson. Before starting pupillage, Tom was a Judicial Assistant to Arden LJ at the Court of Appeal.
Tom Gibson Year of call Email 2010 tom.gibson@outertemple.com Tom specialises in clinical negligence, personal injury, and inquests. He has also been developing a public law practice since his appointment
More informationA doctor s duty of disclosure and the decline of The Bolam Test : A dramatic change in the law on patient consent
Papers Presented to the Society A doctor s duty of disclosure and the decline of The Bolam Test : A dramatic change in the law on patient consent Medico-Legal Journal 2016, Vol. 84(1) 5 17! The Author(s)
More informationClinical negligence by Marc Cornock Senior Lecturer Faculty of Health, Wellbeing and Social Care The Open University
Clinical negligence by Marc Cornock Senior Lecturer Faculty of Health, Wellbeing and Social Care The Open University Address: Faculty of Health, Wellbeing and Social Care The Open University Horlock Building
More informationHSE National Consent Policy Mary Dowling Clinical Risk Manager 28/08/2014
HSE National Consent Policy 2013 Mary Dowling Clinical Risk Manager 28/08/2014 1 HSE National Consent Policy 2013 Applies to all interventions conducted by healthcare professionals on behalf of their employer
More informationHOUSE OF LORDS SIDAWAY (A.P.) (APPELLANT) V BETHLEM ROYAL HOSPITAL AND THE MAUDESLEY HOSPITAL HEALTH AUTHORITY AND OTHERS (RESPONDENTS)
[1985] 1 All ER 643 HOUSE OF LORDS 21 February 1985. SIDAWAY (A.P.) (APPELLANT) V BETHLEM ROYAL HOSPITAL AND THE MAUDESLEY HOSPITAL HEALTH AUTHORITY AND OTHERS (RESPONDENTS) Lord Scarman Lord Diplock Lord
More informationTO LIVE OR LET DIE The Laws of Informed Consent
TO LIVE OR LET DIE The Laws of Informed Consent OBJECTIVES Provide an understanding of the law of informed consent, substitute decision makers and minors rights to accept or refuse treatment. *The information
More information6. BIOMEDICAL LAW AND ETHICS
(2014) 15 SAL Ann Rev Biomedical Law and Ethics 97 6. BIOMEDICAL LAW AND ETHICS Paul TAN LLB (Hons) (National University of Singapore); BCL (Oxon); Advocate and Solicitor (Singapore). Prem Raj PRABAKARAN
More informationLegal Framework: Advance Care Planning Gippsland Region Palliative Consortium and McCabe Centre for Law and Cancer (Cancer Council Victoria)
Legal Framework: Advance Care Planning Gippsland Region Palliative Consortium and McCabe Centre for Law and Cancer (Cancer Council Victoria) Claire McNamara, Legal Officer 1300 309 337 www.publicadvocate.vic.gov.au
More informationLEGAL LIABILITY IN INFORMED CONSENT CASES: WHAT ARE THE RULES OF THE GAME?
McGill Journal of Law and Health ~ Revue de droit et santé de McGill LEGAL LIABILITY IN INFORMED CONSENT CASES: WHAT ARE THE RULES OF THE GAME? Paul McGivern & Natalia Ivolgina* Introduction Informed consent
More informationConsent to treatment
RDN-004 - Resource 4 Consent to treatment (Including the right to withhold consent, not for resuscitation orders, and the right to detain and restrain patients without their consent) Assault and the defence
More informationCan damages be awarded for birth of an unwanted child?
Can damages be awarded for birth of an unwanted child? Case Name: Melchior v Cattanach & Anor Citation: [2001] QCA 246; Supreme Court of Queensland per McMurdo P, Davies and Thomas JJA Date of Judgment:
More informationBusiness intelligence. Medical on i-law. July 2017 highlights the best of i-law.com and picompensation.com
i-law.com Business intelligence Medical on i-law July 2017 highlights the best of i-law.com and picompensation.com Contents Written by experts in medical law and clinical negligence, Medical on i-law.com
More informationIN THE HUMAN RIGHTS REVIEW TRIBUNAL [2012] NZHRRT 9 SECTION 51 OF THE HEALTH AND DISABILITY COMMISSIONER ACT 1994 PLAINTIFF
IN THE HUMAN RIGHTS REVIEW TRIBUNAL [2012] NZHRRT 9 Reference No. HRRT 012/2011 UNDER BETWEEN SECTION 51 OF THE HEALTH AND DISABILITY COMMISSIONER ACT 1994 ERIC RICHARD PILON PLAINTIFF AND VASUDHA IYENGAR
More information: : : : : : FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES. COMES NOW TIANNA SMITH, Plaintiff in the above-captioned action, and hereby INTRODUCTION
IN THE STATE COURT OF DEKALB COUNTY STATE OF GEORGIA TIANNA SMITH, : Plaintiff, : vs. WINDELL C. DAVIS-BOUTTE,M.D., AESTHETIC & LASER BOUTIQUE, INC., BOUTTE CONTOUR SURGERY & DERMATOLOGY, PC, PREMIERE
More informationIN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN AND AND NORTH CENTRAL REGIONAL HEALTH AUTHORITY J U D G M E N T
REPUBLIC OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE Claim No. C.V. 2007-01036 BETWEEN ANNIE KELLMAN Claimant AND DR. ROBERT DOWNES First Defendant AND NORTH CENTRAL REGIONAL HEALTH AUTHORITY Second
More informationHealth Care Consent Act
Briefing Note 2005, 2007 College of Physiotherapists of Ontario 2009 Contents Overview...3 Putting the in Context...3 The HCCA in Brief...4 Key Principles Governing Consent to Treatment...4 Key Aspects
More informationMedical Negligence and Personal Injury
Medical Negligence and Personal Injury Quarterly Newsletter July 2017 During the second quarter of 2017 (April-June) there has been a flurry of cases within the field of medical negligence. There have
More information2006 N BERBICE (CIVIL JURISDICTION)
2006 N0. 141 BERBICE IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE (CIVIL JURISDICTION) BETWEEN: 1. CLIFTON AUGUSTUS CRAWFORD, substituted by second named plaintiff by order of Court dated 14 th
More informationConsent in the context of assisted reproduction
FACULTY OF LAW Consent in the context of assisted reproduction Brenda McGivern Deputy Dean of Law, UWA Member, Reproductive Technology Council 5 November 2015 Purpose The purpose of this presentation is
More informationThe Reasonable Person Test An Objective/Subjective Dichotomy
Is it always true that the reasonable person test eliminates the personal equation (Glasgow Corp v Muir, per Lord MacMillan)? In particular, how do you reconcile Philips v William Whiteley with Nettleship
More informationPUBLIC RECORD. Record of Determinations Medical Practitioners Tribunal. Dates: 14/02/2018. Medical practitioner s name: Dr Martin Uylyam MEMBE
PUBLIC RECORD Dates: 14/02/2018 Medical practitioner s name: Dr Martin Uylyam MEMBE GMC reference number: 7114460 Primary medical qualification: Type of case New - Non-compliance with a performance assessment
More informationMEDICAL NEGLIGENCE AND PATIENT AUTONOMY. Bolam Rules in Singapore and Malaysia Revisited
666 Singapore Academy of Law Journal (2015) 27 SAcLJ MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE AND PATIENT AUTONOMY Bolam Rules in Singapore and Malaysia Revisited The classic Bolam test for medical negligence, controversial
More informationBar & Bench (
1 IN THE MATTER OF IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 215 OF 2005 COMMON CAUSE (A REGD. SOCIETY) PETITIONER VERSUS UNION OF INDIA RESPONDENT WRITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
More informationIN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA KWAZULU-NATAL DIVISION, PIETERMARITZBURG. Plaintiff
SAFLII Note: Certain personal/private details of parties or witnesses have been redacted from this document in compliance with the law and SAFLII Policy IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA KWAZULU-NATAL
More informationOpen disclosure - an opportunity lost? Dr John Arranga Victorian State Manager, Avant Law Pty Ltd
Open disclosure - an opportunity lost? Dr John Arranga Victorian State Manager, Avant Law Pty Ltd Disclaimer The information in this presentation is general information relating to legal and/or clinical
More informationIN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE (SUB REGISTRY, SAN FERNANDO) BETWEEN LINDA RAJKUMARSINGH AND GULF VIEW MEDICAL CENTRE LIMITED
REPUBLIC OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE (SUB REGISTRY, SAN FERNANDO) Claim No. CV 2010-01958 BETWEEN LINDA RAJKUMARSINGH Claimant AND GULF VIEW MEDICAL CENTRE LIMITED Defendant BEFORE
More informationSUPREME COURT UPHOLDS PASSIVE EUTHANASIA, ISSUES GUIDELINES ON ADVANCE DIRECTIVES IN LANDMARK JUDGEMENT
NEWSFLASH SUPREME COURT UPHOLDS PASSIVE EUTHANASIA, ISSUES GUIDELINES ON ADVANCE DIRECTIVES IN LANDMARK JUDGEMENT 14 March 2018 A Constitution Bench of the Hon ble Supreme Court of India, comprising of
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS MARILYN CLEMONS, Individually and as Next Friend of MILES HUGHEY, a Minor, UNPUBLISHED September 24, 2009 Plaintiff-Appellant, v No. 282520 Wayne Circuit Court RODERICK
More informationInnovation in medicine through degeneration in law? A critical perspective on the Medical Innovation Bill
Article Innovation in medicine through degeneration in law? A critical perspective on the Medical Innovation Bill Medical Law International 2014, Vol. 14(4) 266 273 ª The Author(s) 2014 Reprints and permission:
More informationDEATH GIVES BIRTH TO THE NEED FOR NEW LAW:
DEATH GIVES BIRTH TO THE NEED FOR NEW LAW: The case for law reform regarding medical end of life decisions. Introduction Many people who oppose the legalisation of euthanasia and/or physician assisted
More informationCapacity to Consent Policy
Capacity to Consent Policy Recommended by Approved by Executive Management Team Quality Committee Approval date October 2015 Version number 2.0 Review date October 2017 Responsible Director Responsible
More informationCOPYRIGHTED MATERIAL. Introduction to the Legal System CHAPTER 1. Ingrid Granne 1 and Lorraine Corfield 2. Case law
CHAPTER 1 Introduction to the Legal System Ingrid Granne 1 and Lorraine Corfield 2 1 Clinical Research Fellow and Specialist Registrar, Nuffield Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of
More informationLoss of a Chance. What is it and what does it mean in medical malpractice cases?
Loss of a Chance What is it and what does it mean in medical malpractice cases? Walter C. Morrison IV Gainsburgh, Benjamin, David, Meunier & Warshauer, LLC I. Introduction Kramer walks in to your office
More informationOPINIONS OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL
HOUSE OF LORDS SESSION 2003 04 [2004] UKHL 41 on appeal from:[2002] EWCA Civ 724 OPINIONS OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL FOR JUDGMENT IN THE CAUSE Chester (Respondent) v. Afshar (Appellant) ON THURSDAY 14 OCTOBER
More informationMEDICAL NEGLIGENCE AND CRIMINAL LAW
MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE AND CRIMINAL LAW Ayushi Dubey 3 rd year student, BA. LL.B(Hons.) Symbiosis Law School, Pune ABSTRACT This paper is being written down as to bring out the matter of criminal medical negligence
More informationDates: 02/10/ /10/2017, 09/10/2017 and 03/01/2018 to 12/01/2018 Medical Practitioner s name: Dr Francesco MOLLO GMC reference number:
PUBLIC RECORD Dates: 02/10/2017 06/10/2017, 09/10/2017 and 03/01/2018 to 12/01/2018 Medical Practitioner s name: Dr Francesco MOLLO GMC reference number: 6043403 Primary medical qualification: Type of
More informationADR INSTITUTE OF CANADA, INC. ADRIC ARBITRATION RULES I. MODEL DISPUTE RESOLUTION CLAUSE
ADR INSTITUTE OF CANADA, INC. ADRIC ARBITRATION RULES I. MODEL DISPUTE RESOLUTION CLAUSE Parties who agree to arbitrate under the Rules may use the following clause in their agreement: ADRIC Arbitration
More informationApplication of foreign common law and statute by Australian court in medical negligence claim: O Reilly v Western Sussex Hospitals NHS Trust (No 6)
This article was first published in Australian Health Law Bulletin Volume 23 No. 2 (HLB 23.2) Application of foreign common law and statute by Australian court in medical negligence claim: O Reilly v Western
More informationEnglish law for the surgeon II: Clinical negligence
REVIEW Open Access English law for the surgeon II: Clinical negligence Waseem Jerjes 1,2*, Jaspal Mahil 3 and Tahwinder Upile 3,4 Abstract Traditionally, in the United Kingdom and Europe, the surgeon was
More informationIN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA EASTERN CAPE LOCAL DIVISION : MTHATHA CASE NO. 2930/13 N. S. PLAINTIFF
1 SAFLII Note: Certain personal/private details of parties or witnesses have been redacted from this document in compliance with the law and SAFLII Policy IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA EASTERN CAPE
More informationThe Mental Health of Children and Young People in Northern Ireland
The Mental Health of Children and Young People in Northern Ireland In Northern Ireland over 20% of children under 18 years of age suffer significant mental health problems 2012/13 7.9% of the mental health
More informationA Conversation between Medicine and Law
A Conversation between Medicine and Law PROF DR PUTERI NEMIE JAHN KASSIM CIVIL LAW DEPARTMENT, AHMAD IBRAHIM KULLIYYAH OF LAWS, INTERNATIONAL ISLAMIC UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA! Intervention of Law into Medical
More informationLegal aspects of consent
BJU International (2000), 86, 275±279 Legal aspects of consent B. JONES Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda, Louth, Ireland Introduction Consent, as developed through the common law over the last 3±4
More informationMENTAL HEALTH (JERSEY) LAW Revised Edition Showing the law as at 1 January 2017 This is a revised edition of the law
MENTAL HEALTH (JERSEY) LAW 1969 Revised Edition Showing the law as at 1 January 2017 This is a revised edition of the law Mental Health (Jersey) Law 1969 Arrangement MENTAL HEALTH (JERSEY) LAW 1969 Arrangement
More informationCase Comment: Ontario Inc. et al v. Tutor Time Learning Centres, LLC, et al. [2006] O.J. No (S.C.J.), confirmed on appeal April 12, 2007
Scotia Plaza 40 King St. West, Suite 5800 P.O. Box 1011 Toronto, ON Canada M5H 3S1 Tel. 416.595.8500 Fax.416.595.8695 www.millerthomson.com TORONTO VANCOUVER WHITEHORSE CALGARY EDMONTON LONDON KITCHENER-WATERLOO
More informationSupersedes: Version 1 Description of Amendment(s): Amendments to Stage Test of Capacity. Originated By: The Mental Capacity Act Working Group
Review Circulation Application Ratification Originator or modifier Supersedes Title Document Control Template DOCUMENT CONTROL PAGE Title: Mental Capacity Policy Version: 1.1 Reference Number: MCA001 Supersedes:
More informationCONSOLIDATION OF MEDICAL PROFESSION ACT. R.S.N.W.T. 1988,c.M-9. (Current to: February 6, 2006)
CONSOLIDATION OF MEDICAL PROFESSION ACT (Current to: February 6, 2006) AS AMENDED BY NORTHWEST TERRITORIES STATUTES: R.S.N.W.T. 1988,c.105(Supp.) S.N.W.T. 1995,c.11 S.N.W.T. 1997,c.8 S.N.W.T. 1998,c.5
More informationREPUBLIC OF KENYA. High Court at Nairobi (Nairobi Law Courts) Civil Case 788 of 2000 E. R. O...PLAINTIFF V E R S U S
REPUBLIC OF KENYA High Court at Nairobi (Nairobi Law Courts) Civil Case 788 of 2000 E. R. O...PLAINTIFF V E R S U S BOARD OF TRUSTEES, FAMILY PLANNING ASSOCIATION OF KENYA...DEFENDANTS J U D G M E N T
More informationSUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY NO. I. JURISDICTION
SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY MATTHEW HIPPS and SARAH HIPPS, husband and wife, v. Plaintiffs, VIRGINIA MASON MEDICAL CENTER and CHONG CHOE, MD, Defendants. NO. COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES Plaintiffs
More informationNRPSI INDICATIVE SANCTIONS GUIDANCE
NRPSI INDICATIVE SANCTIONS GUIDANCE Introduction Purpose of sanctions Warnings What sanctions are available Questions for the Panel to consider Mitigation and aggravating factors Guidance on considering
More informationSingapore Court Enforces China Ruling in Landmark Judgment
Singapore Court Enforces China Ruling in Landmark Judgment Introduction The Singapore High Court has issued a landmark judgment in what is believed to be the first instance of enforcement of a judgment
More informationDISCIPLINE COMMITTEE OF THE COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS AND SURGEONS OF ONTARIO COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS AND SURGEONS OF ONTARIO. - and - MARTIN JUGENBURG
DISCIPLINE COMMITTEE OF THE COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS AND SURGEONS OF ONTARIO B E T W E E N: COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS AND SURGEONS OF ONTARIO - and - MARTIN JUGENBURG NOTICE OF HEARING THE INQUIRIES, COMPLAINTS
More informationClient Privilege in Intellectual Property Advice
Client Privilege in Intellectual Property Advice Prepared by the Commission on Intellectual Property I The WIPO/AIPPI Conference on 22-23 May 2008 1. Client privilege in intellectual property advice was
More informationProtocol for Special Medical Procedures (Sterilisation)
Protocol for Special Medical Procedures (Sterilisation) Made pursuant to the approval of the Australian Guardianship and Administration Council (AGAC) 6 May 2009 2 Table of Contents 1. Background... 3
More information*582 Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee
Page 1 Status: Mixed or Mildly Negative Judicial Treatment *582 Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee 1956 B. No. 507 Queen's Bench Division 26 February 1957 [1957] 1 W.L.R. 582 McNair J. and a
More informationPUBLIC RECORD. Record of Determinations. Medical Practitioner: Dates: 10/12/ /12/2018. GMC reference number: Summary of outcome Erasure
PUBLIC RECORD Dates: 10/12/2018-20/12/2018 Medical Practitioner s name: Dr David NZEGBULEM GMC reference number: 4340881 Primary medical qualification: Type of case New - Misconduct MB BS 1991 University
More informationHUMAN TISSUE DONATION ACT
c t HUMAN TISSUE DONATION ACT PLEASE NOTE This document, prepared by the Legislative Counsel Office, is an office consolidation of this Act, current to May 13, 2011. It is intended for information and
More informationCanada, the Netherlands, Switzerland and the states of Colorado, Vermont, Montana, California, Oregon and Washington DC in the United States of Americ
IN THE HON BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL ORIGINAL WRIT JURISDICTION Writ Petition (C) 215 of 2005 IN THE MATTER OF: COMMON CAUSE...PETITIONERS VERSUS UNION OF INDIA...RESPONDENTS Note on Arguments of
More information~ Ohio ~ Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care Christian Version NOTICE TO ADULT EXECUTING THIS DOCUMENT
~ Ohio ~ Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care Christian Version NOTICE TO ADULT EXECUTING THIS DOCUMENT This is an important legal document. Before executing this document, you should know these facts:
More informationSAMPLE Examination for Torts
Federation of Law Societies of Canada National Committee on Accreditation SAMPLE Examination for Torts Candidate No.: (To ensure your anonymity, please do not print or sign your name) For educational purposes
More informationCase 8:12-cr JLS Document 87 Filed 09/14/17 Page 1 of 9 Page ID #:288
Case :-cr-000-jls Document Filed 0// Page of Page ID #: SANDRA R. BROWN Acting United States Attorney LAWRENCE S. MIDDLETON Assistant United States Attorney Chief, Criminal Division JOSEPH T. MCNALLY (Cal.
More informationSpeaking Out in Public
Have Your Say Speaking Out in Public Last updated: 2008 These Fact Sheets are a guide only and are no substitute for legal advice. To request free initial legal advice on an environmental or planning law
More informationAgreement to an investigation, procedure or treatment by a patient with mental capacity
D CONSENT FORM ONE (1) Addressograph Patient s surname / family name: Patient s first name(s): Date of birth: Hospital number: NHS number: Agreement to an investigation, procedure or treatment by a patient
More informationProfiting from your own mistakes: Common law liability and working directors
Profiting from your own mistakes: Common law liability and working directors Author: Tim Wardell Special Counsel Edwards Michael Lawyers Profiting from your own mistakes: Common law liability and working
More informationMaggie Fitzgerald Principal Pharmacist, Medicines Information Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust September 2013
Maggie Fitzgerald Principal Pharmacist, Medicines Information Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust September 2013 Aim of the Session Consider how to identify and deal with legal and ethical problems that
More informationConsent to Medical Treatment: The Legal Status of an Adult Patient in Malaysia.
Available online at www.globalilluminators.org GlobalIlluminators Full Paper Proceeding ITMAR -2014, Vol. 1, 550-557 FULL PAPER PROCEEDING Multidisciplinary Studies ISBN: 978-969-9948-24-4 ITMAR-14 Consent
More informationCANCER AGENCY c.c CHAPTER C-1.1
1 2006 c.c-1.1 2006 CHAPTER C-1.1 An Act respecting the Provision of Cancer Care Services and the Cancer Agency and to make consequential amendments to other Acts TABLE OF CONTENTS PART I Short Title and
More informationAlexander Line. Year of call
Alexander Line Year of call Email 2009 alex.line@outertemple.com Alexander Line is a civil practitioner, whose practice is focused particularly on the areas of education, social welfare, court of protection,
More information(Use for claims arising on or after 1 October For claims arising before 1 October 2011, use N.C.P.I. Civil )
PAGE 1 OF 11 (Use for claims arising on or after 1 October 2011. For claims arising before 1 October 2011, use N.C.P.I. Civil 809.03.) NOTE WELL: Res Ipsa Loquitur has been approved as an option for liability
More information2 Travel Group plc v Cardiff City Transport Services Ltd
competition LAW 2 Travel Group plc v Cardiff City Transport Services Ltd [2012] CAT19 LIGIA OSEPCIU July 2012 In this rare decision on the appropriate quantum of follow-on damages, the Competition Appeal
More informationLAWS1100 Final Exam Notes
LAWS1100 Final Exam Notes Topic 4&5: Tort Law and Business (*very important) Relevant chapter: Ch.3 Applicable law: - Law of torts law of negligence (p.74) Torts (p.70) - The word tort meaning twisted
More informationPUBLIC RECORD. Record of Determinations Medical Practitioners Tribunal. Date: 29/06/2017. Medical practitioner s name: Dr Dariusz Stanislaw FAFERA
PUBLIC RECORD Date: 29/06/2017 Medical practitioner s name: Dr Dariusz Stanislaw FAFERA GMC reference number: 7396655 Primary medical qualification: Type of case New - Non-compliance with an English language
More informationBERMUDA MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS ACT : 38
QUO FA T A F U E R N T BERMUDA MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS ACT 1950 1950 : 38 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 2 3 4 5 5AA 5AB 5A 5B 6 7 7A 7B 8 9 10 11 12 12AA 12A 13 13A 14 15 16 17 PRELIMINARY Interpretation Unqualified
More informationSabah Shipyard (Pakistan) Ltd v Government of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan
184 SINGAPORE LAW REPORTS (REISSUE) [2004] 3 SLR(R) Sabah Shipyard (Pakistan) Ltd v Government of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan [2004] SGHC 109 High Court Originating Motion No 31 of 2003 Judith Prakash
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS JANET TIPTON, Plaintiff-Appellant, FOR PUBLICATION April 19, 2005 9:05 a.m. v No. 252117 Oakland Circuit Court WILLIAM BEAUMONT HOSPITAL and LC No. 2003-046552-CP ANDREW
More informationCase number: 17077/2012
REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA GAUTENG LOCAL DIVISION, JOHANNESBURG Case number: 17077/2012 (1) REPORTABLE: No (2) OF INTEREST TO OTHER JUDGES: No (3) REVISED. 11 DECEMBER 2014
More informationForfeiture Clause In Incentive Award Plan Did Not Constitute Restraint In Trade
Forfeiture Clause In Incentive Award Plan Did Not Constitute Restraint In Trade Introduction It is common today for employers to incorporate an incentive award plan into their employment contracts, or
More informationSTATE OF LOUISIANA COURT OF APPEAL, THIRD CIRCUIT
STATE OF LOUISIANA COURT OF APPEAL, THIRD CIRCUIT CLYDE SNIDER, JR. ET UX VERSUS 12-1068 LOUISIANA MEDICAL MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, ET AL. ********** APPEAL FROM THE THIRTY-SIXTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
More informationClinical Negligence and Personal Injury
Clinical Negligence and Personal Injury Quarterly Newsletter April 2017 The first quarter of 2017 has been a busy one within clinical negligence circles. There is a Ministry of Justice consultation on
More informationArbitration CAS 2008/A/1488 P. v. International Tennis Federation (ITF), award of 22 August 2008
Tribunal Arbitral du Sport Court of Arbitration for Sport Arbitration P. v. International Tennis Federation (ITF), award of 22 August 2008 Panel: Mr Hans Nater (Switzerland), President; Prof. Richard H.
More informationACT 290 MEDICINES (ADVERTISEMENT AND SALE) ACT 1956 (REVISED ) Incorporating latest amendment - Act A778/1990
ACT 290 MEDICINES (ADVERTISEMENT AND SALE) ACT 1956 (REVISED - 1983) Incorporating latest amendment - Act A778/1990 First enacted : 1956 (Ordinance No. 10 of 1956) Date of coming into operation : West
More informationTHE RIGHTS OF PEOPLE WHO HAVE BEEN ARRESTED
THE RIGHTS OF PEOPLE WHO HAVE BEEN ARRESTED A REVIEW OF THE LAW IN NORTHERN IRELAND November 2004 ISBN 1 903681 50 2 Copyright Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission Temple Court, 39 North Street Belfast
More information2. "Artificially administered" means providing food or fluid through a medically invasive procedure.
36-3201. Definitions In this chapter, unless the context otherwise requires: 1. "Agent" means an adult who has the authority to make health care treatment decisions for another person, referred to as the
More information