ANNEX A: FEDERAL SECURITY VOTE DATA Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria
2 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria MDA Ministry 2018 (N) 2018 ($=N365) 2017 (N) Defence Intelligence Agency (DIA) Defence 4,193,886,250 $11,490,099 1,497,955,985 Army Defence 4,147,190,443 $11,362,166 4,147,190,443 State Security Service (SSS) ONSA 1,697,354,538 $4,650,286 2,400,000,000 Ministry of Defence (MOD) Defence 1,520,000,000 $4,164,384 1,055,101,674 Nigerian Air Force (NAF) Defence 1,204,099,768 $3,298,903 204,099,768 Office of the National Security Adviser (ONSA) ONSA 1,144,066,298 $3,134,428 0 Nigerian Navy (NN) Defence 1,079,258,800 $2,956,873 1,079,258,800 Defence Missions (DAs) Defence 920,450,957 $2,521,783 123,840,000 National Intelligence Agency (NIA) ONSA 505,165,343 $1,384,015 1,142,291,000 Nigeria Police Force (NPF) Interior 388,576,329 $1,064,593 489,600,000 Presidential Air Fleet (PAF) ONSA 260,517,160 $713,746 240,001,536 National Drug Law Enforcement Agency (NDLEA) Justice 231,541,038 $634,359 152,541,034 Defence Headquarters (DHQ) Defence 200,000,000 $547,945 0 Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) Presidency 170,000,000 $465,753 150,000,000 Nigeria Prison Service Interior 48,854,046 $133,847 48,854,046 Federal Ministry of Finance Finance 40,000,000 $109,589 0 Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC) Interior 39,261,671 $107,566 39,553,920 Federal University, Lokoja Education 28,417,308 $77,856 0 National Commission for Museum and Monuments National Education Research and Development Council Information and Culture 20,756,240 $56,866 0 Education 20,520,000 $56,219 0 National Hajj Commission of Nigeria SGF 20,172,466 $55,267 0 Nigeria Financial Intelligence Unit (NFIU) Presidency 20,000,000 $54,795 0 National Hospital, Abuja Health 19,556,071 $53,578 0 Ministry of Foreign Affairs Foreign 19,250,000 $52,740 17,500,000
Transparency International Defence & Security 3 2017 ($=N300) 2016 (N) 2016 ($=N200) 2015 (N) 2015 ($=N185) 2014 (N)2014 ($=N160) $4,993,187 336,744,779 $1,683,724 981,054,702 $5,302,998 348,972,503 $2,181,078 $13,823,968 2,076,598,290 $10,382,991 3,002,000,000 $16,227,027 0 $0 $8,000,000 2,266,531,458 $11,332,657 2,540,885,669 $13,734,517 3,367,651,859 $21,047,824 $3,517,006 1,325,044,800 $6,625,224 1,325,044,800 $7,162,404 250,000,000 $1,562,500 $680,333 520,571,426 $2,602,857 901,110,938 $4,870,870 503,239,545 $3,145,247 $0 576,090,299 $2,880,451 645,823,635 $3,490,939 1,166,738,881 $7,292,118 $3,597,529 706,077,016 $3,530,385 1,079,258,800 $5,833,831 1,056,410,554 $6,602,566 $412,800 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $3,807,637 1,216,603,699 $6,083,018 1,363,608,642 $7,370,858 1,748,081,985 $10,925,512 $1,632,000 227,399,880 $1,136,999 295,959,019 $1,599,778 375,959,019 $2,349,744 $800,005 0 $0 0 $0 259,555,635 $1,622,223 $508,470 0 $0 0 $0 134,984,176 $843,651 $500,000 0 $0 0 $0 177,269,346 $1,107,933 $162,847 0 $0 0 $0 23,276,598 $145,479 $0 0 $0 0 $0 24,107,616,635 $150,672,604 $131,846 0 $0 0 $0 106,624,079 $666,400 $58,333 0 $0 0 $0 190,244,748 $1,189,030
4 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria National Board for Technical Education Education 18,328,770 $50,216 0 Centre for Management Development Budget and National Planning 15,270,419 $41,837 0 Federal Polytechnic, Mubi Education 13,000,000 $35,616 0 National Film and Video Censor Board Information and Culture 12,999,040 $35,614 5,999,980 Defence Space Administration (DSA) Defence 11,805,993 $32,345 9,805,993 National Examinations Council Education 11,570,998 $31,701 0 Federal College of Forestry, Jos Environment 11,160,000 $30,575 0 National Oil Spill Detection and Response Agency Environment 10,979,400 $30,081 0 National Identity Management Commission SGF 9,469,965 $25,945 0 National Centre for Women Development Women Affairs 7,496,004 $20,537 0 National Biotechnology Development Agency National Agency for the Prohibition of Traffic in Persons (NAPTIP) 7,401,220 $20,277 0 Justice 7,200,000 $19,726 15,840,000 National Commission for College Education Education 7,186,264 $19,688 0 Secretariat Yaba College of Education 7,160,897 $19,619 0 Infrastructure Concession Regulatory Commission National Orientation Agency National Theatre ICRC 7,150,000 $19,589 0 Information and Culture Information and Culture 7,104,000 $19,463 0 6,911,841 $18,937 0 Investment and Securities Commission Finance 6,686,811 $18,320 0 Institite for Peace and Conflict Resolution Foreign Affairs 6,000,000 $16,438 0 Federal College of Education, Omuku Education 6,000,000 $16,438 3,600,000 Federal Ministry of Women Affairs Women Affairs 6,000,000 $16,438 0 Legal Aid Council Justice 5,825,243 $15,960 0 Federal School of Medical Laboratory, Jos Health 5,800,000 $15,890 0 National Institute of Hospitality and Tourism Information and Development Studies Culture National Steel Raw Materials Exploration Agency, Kaduna Mines and Steel Development 5,668,635 $15,531 0 5,492,268 $15,047 0
Transparency International Defence & Security 5 $20,000 0 $0 0 $0 26,059,692 $162,873 $32,687 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $52,800 0 $0 0 $0 14,891,253 $93,070 $0 0 $0 0 $0 25,415,567 $158,847 $12,000 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0
6 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria Federal Ministry of Transportation Transportation 5,000,000 $13,699 0 Nigerian Army Institute of and Environmental Studies (NAITES), Biu, Borno Defence 5,000,000 $13,699 0 Auditor General of the Federation (AUGF) AUGF 4,800,000 $13,151 0 Ministry of Budget and National Planning Federal College of Wildlife Management, New Bussa National Rural Electrification Agency Budget and National Planning 4,642,411 $12,719 0 Environment 4,406,219 $12,072 0 Power, Works, Housing 4,328,002 $11,858 0 Federal Polytechnic, Bauchi Education 4,200,500 $11,508 0 National Merit Award SGF 4,050,000 $11,096 0 SMEDAN Industry, Trade and Investment 3,984,000 $10,915 0 Federal Fire Service Interior 3,945,971 $10,811 5,945,971 National Agency for Great Green Wall Environment 3,900,000 $10,685 0 Federal Ministry of Information and Culture Information and Culture 3,707,633 $10,158 0 University of Maiduguri Teaching Hospital Education 3,369,968 $9,233 0 Foreign Mission: Addis Ababa Foreign Affairs 3,209,029 $8,792 0 Foreign Mission: Jakarta Foreign Affairs 2,898,931 $7,942 0 Federal Polytechnic, Bonny Education 2,880,000 $7,890 0 Petroleum Training Institute Federal Neuro-Psychiatric Hospital, Yaba, Lagos Petroleum Resources 2,841,000 $7,784 0 Health 2,782,932 $7,624 0 Accident Investigation Bureau Transport 2,760,000 $7,562 0 Federal Co-operation College, Ibadan Education 2,723,500 $7,462 0 Foreign Mission: Caracas Foreign Affairs 2,627,156 $7,198 0 National Teachers Institute Education 2,611,610 $7,155 0 Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development Agriculture 2,602,651 $7,131 0 Foreign Mission: Bissau Foreign Affairs 2,532,172 $6,937 0 Foreign Mission: Jeddah Foreign Affairs 2,532,172 $6,937 0
Transparency International Defence & Security 7 $0 0 $0 0 $0 4,032,654 $25,204 $19,820 0 $0 0 $0 4,384,412 $27,403
8 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria Foreign Mission: Athens Foreign Affairs 2,522,729 $6,912 0 Foreign Mission: Brasilia Foreign Affairs 2,522,729 $6,912 0 Foreign Mission: Brussels Foreign Affairs 2,522,729 $6,912 0 National Institute of Animal Science Agriculture 2,520,000 $6,904 0 Foreign Mission: Budapest Foreign Affairs 2,445,424 $6,700 0 Command and Staff College, Jaji Defence 2,383,034 $6,529 0 Science Equipment Development Institute, Minna 2,339,052 $6,408 46,635 University of, Owerri Education 2,333,602 $6,393 0 Foreign Mission: Cairo Foreign Affairs 2,319,145 $6,354 0 Foreign Mission: Conakry Foreign Affairs 2,319,145 $6,354 0 Foreign Mission: Dakar Foreign Affairs 2,319,145 $6,354 0 Foreign Mission: Johannesburg Foreign Affairs 2,319,145 $6,354 0 Foreign Mission: Khartoum Foreign Affairs 2,300,258 $6,302 0 Foreign Mission: Brazzaville Foreign Affairs 2,174,857 $5,959 0 Foreign Mission: Algiers Foreign Affairs 2,140,044 $5,863 0 Federal Polytechnic, Ukana Education 2,102,451 $5,760 0 Federal Radio Corporation of Nigeria Information and Culture 2,040,000 $5,589 0 Foreign Mission: Beijing Foreign Affairs 1,973,689 $5,407 0 Foreign Mission: Abidjan Foreign Affairs 1,836,429 $5,031 0 Foreign Mission: Accra Foreign Affairs 1,836,429 $5,031 0 Foreign Mission: Bucharest Foreign Affairs 1,836,429 $5,031 0 Nigeria Police Academy, Wudil, Kano Interior 1,800,000 $4,932 0 Federal Medical Centre, Nasarawa Health 1,676,800 $4,594 0 Nigerian Institute of Medical Research, Yaba, Lagos Health 1,618,574 $4,434 0 Federal Polytechnic, Idah Education 1,599,880 $4,383 2,700,000
Transparency International Defence & Security 9 $155 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 265,915 $1,662 $9,000 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0
10 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria National Mathematical Centre, Sheda Education 1,577,702 $4,322 0 Federal Government Girls College, Lejja Education 1,500,000 $4,110 0 Federal College of Education, Akoka Education 1,500,000 $4,110 0 National Cereals Research Institute, Badeggi Agriculture 1,464,982 $4,014 0 Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka Education 1,379,812 $3,780 0 University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital Education 1,312,019 $3,595 0 Federal Polytechnic, Ile-Oluji Education 1,300,000 $3,562 0 Michael Imodu Institute of Labour Studies Labour and Employment 1,280,000 $3,507 0 Federal University, Dutse Education 1,250,000 $3,425 0 Federal College of Education, Obudu Education 1,200,000 $3,288 0 Nigerian Institute of Transport Transport 1,200,000 $3,288 0 Foreign Mission: Cotonou Foreign Affairs 1,179,956 $3,233 0 Foreign Mission: Islamabad Foreign Affairs 1,159,572 $3,177 0 Federal College of Fresh Water Fisheries, New Bussa Agriculture 1,148,082 $3,145 0 Federal Government College, Okigwe Education 1,120,706 $3,070 0 Maritime Academy, Oron Transport 1,090,909 $2,989 1,200,000 Bioresource Development Centre, Owode, Ogun 1,061,100 $2,907 0 University of Jos Education 1,059,000 $2,901 0 Federal University, Gashua Education 1,036,288 $2,839 0 Federal Medical Centre, Bida, Niger Health 1,028,144 $2,817 0 Federal College of Agriculture, Akure Agriculture 1,000,000 $2,740 0 Federal Polytechnic, Ede Education 1,000,000 $2,740 0 Federal School of Dental and Therapy, Enugu Bioresource Development Centre, Ogbomoso Health 1,000,000 $2,740 0 1,000,000 $2,740 0 Foreign Mission: Damascus Foreign Affairs 978,389 $2,681 0
Transparency International Defence & Security 11 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2,108,965 $13,181 $4,000 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0
12 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria Foreign Mission: Kigali Foreign Affairs 927,658 $2,542 0 National Broadcasting Corporation Information and Culture 876,420 $2,401 0 West Africa Examination Council (WAEC) Education 803,411 $2,201 0 Foreign Mission: Kampala Foreign Affairs 801,598 $2,196 0 Federal School of Occupational Therapy, Yaba, Lagos Health 704,521 $1,930 0 Federal University, Oye-Ekiti Education 701,625 $1,922 2,675,609 Federal College of Education, Gombe Education 699,778 $1,917 0 Power Equipment and Electrical Machinery Development Centre, Okene, Kogi Bioresource Development Centre, Abuja National Centre for Petroleum Research and Development, Bauchi 600,000 $1,644 0 598,798 $1,641 0 577,484 $1,582 0 Federal Government Girls College, Bwari Education 575,700 $1,577 0 Federal Government Girls College, Jalingo Education 566,273 $1,551 0 Federal Specialist Hospital, Irrua Health 560,000 $1,534 1,200,000 Centre for Energy Research and Development, Nsukka 559,983 $1,534 0 Federal Technical College, Lassa Education 519,401 $1,423 0 Federal College of Education, Asaba Education 500,000 $1,370 0 National Biosafety Management Agency (NBMA) Environment 500,000 $1,370 0 Foreign Mission: Kuala Lumpur Foreign Affairs 499,020 $1,367 0 Federal Government College, Maiduguri Education 493,467 $1,352 0 Federal College of Animal Health and Production, Vom Agriculture 477,000 $1,307 0 Foreign Mission: Kuwait Foreign Affairs 463,829 $1,271 0 Federal Government Girls College, Abuloma Education 460,025 $1,260 0 Federal Training Centre, Kaduna Education 457,712 $1,254 0 Federal Training Centre, Lagos Education 457,712 $1,254 0 Federal Government College, Azare Education 450,000 $1,233 0
Transparency International Defence & Security 13 $8,919 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $4,000 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0
14 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria Federal Government College, Minna Education 446,179 $1,222 0 University of Nigeria, Nsukka Education 423,652 $1,161 0 Bioresource Development Centre, Abagana, Anambra 411,600 $1,128 0 Federal Technical College, Otukpo Education 407,563 $1,117 0 Federal Training Centre, Enugu Education 400,000 $1,096 0 Bioresource Development Centre, Effraya, Cross River Regional Centre for International Commercial Arbitration 393,129 $1,077 0 Justice 380,824 $1,043 0 Ahmadu Bello University Teaching Hospital Health 371,400 $1,018 0 Federal Technical College, Jalingo Education 350,000 $959 0 Council for the Regulation of Freight Forwarding in Nigeria Transport 328,000 $899 0 Federal Government College, Daura Education 308,015 $844 0 Federal College of Education, Katsina Education 300,000 $822 0 Council for the Regulation of Engineering in Power, Works, Nigeria (COREN) Housing 300,000 $822 0 FSTC Dayi Education 295,118 $809 0 Bioresource Development Centre, Chibok, Borno Federal Government College, Iket Vandekya 292,795 $802 0 Education 291,514 $799 0 Federal Government College, Kano Education 291,514 $799 0 National Obstetric Fistula Centre, Bauchi Health 270,000 $740 0 Federal Government College, Ugwolawo Education 262,962 $720 0 Federal Government Girls College, Gusau Education 229,464 $629 0 Nigeria Natural Medicine Development Agency Business Incubator Centre, Agege, Lagos Civil Defence, Immigration, and Prison Service Boards (CIPB) Business Incubator Centre, Ado-Ekiti Business Incubator Centre, Warri, Delta 221,519 $607 0 217,246 $595 0 Interior 200,000 $548 1,200,000 186,797 $512 0 155,243 $425 0
Transparency International Defence & Security 15 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1,063,661 $6,648 $4,000 0 $0 0 $0 532,159 $3,326
16 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria Nursing and Midwifery Council Health 133,164 $365 0 Business Incubator Centre, Minna, Niger 131,378 $360 0 Federal University, Gusau Education 125,171 $343 723,117 Federal Technical College, Uyo Education 120,000 $329 0 Presidential Advisory Committee on Corruption Community Health Practitioners Registration Board Business Incubator Centre, Gusau, Zamfara Business Incubator Centre, Bauchi Business Incubator Centre, Ilorin, Kwara Business Incubator Centre, Taraba PHC Tutors Programme, Kaduna Polytechnic SGF 120,000 $329 0 Health 111,454 $305 0 111,292 $305 0 100,000 $274 0 100,000 $274 0 100,000 $274 0 Health 75,681 $207 0 FSTC Awka Education 12,182 $33 0 Federal Government Girls College, Langtang Education 3,600 $10 0 Nigeria Immigration Service (NIS) Interior 0 $0 0 Office of the Head of Service of the Federation OHSF 0 $0 0 Nigerian Copyright Commission Justice 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Moscow Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 Ministry of Labour and Productivity Labour 0 $0 0 Federal Ministry of Environment Environment 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: London Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 Federal Ministry of Mines and Steel Development Mines and Steel 0 $0 0 Federal Ministry of Works Works 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: New York (NMUN) Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 NIPSS Presidency 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Bern Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0
Transparency International Defence & Security 17 $2,410 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 404,683 $2,529 $0 0 $0 207,974,994 $1,124,189 114,244,839 $714,030 $0 0 $0 0 $0 73,000,000 $456,250 $0 0 $0 0 $0 69,655,016 $435,344 $0 0 $0 0 $0 42,107,000 $263,169 $0 0 $0 0 $0 16,733,755 $104,586 $0 0 $0 0 $0 16,642,277 $104,014 $0 0 $0 0 $0 15,903,984 $99,400 $0 0 $0 0 $0 15,000,000 $93,750 $0 0 $0 0 $0 11,436,795 $71,480 $0 0 $0 0 $0 8,222,245 $51,389 $0 0 $0 0 $0 7,977,457 $49,859 $0 0 $0 0 $0 7,588,000 $47,425
18 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria Benin/Owena River Basin Development Authority Water Resources 0 $0 5,535,010 Nigerian Meteorological Agency Aviation 0 $0 0 Federal College of Complementary and Alternative Medicine Health 0 $0 0 National Animal Product Research Institute, Agriculture 0 $0 0 Zaria Foreign Mission: Buea Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Seoul Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 Police Service Commission 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Dubai Trade Mission Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 Nigeria Institute of Leather and Science (NILEST) 0 $0 0 Rubber Research Institute, Benin Agriculture 0 $0 0 Ministry of Lands, Housing, and Urban Development National Agriculture Extension Research Liaison Services, Zaria 0 $0 0 Agriculture 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Madrid Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 Customs, Immigration, Prisons Pension Office (CIPPO) Interior 0 $0 0 Federal Ministry of Aviation Aviation 0 $0 0 National Council of Arts and Culture Culture and Tourism 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Bamako Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 National Ear Care Centre, Kaduna Health 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Pyongyang Foreign Affairs 0 $0 0 Border Commmunities Development Agency Presidency 0 $0 0 NAFDAC Health 0 $0 0 Federal College of Agriculture, Ishiagu Agriculture 0 $0 0 Nurse Tutor Training, Enugu Health 0 $0 0 Foreign Mission: Sao Paolo Foreign Affairs 0 $0 768,000 Federal Technical College, Otobi Education 0 $0 60,000
Transparency International Defence & Security 19 $18,450 0 $0 0 $0 6,300,000 $39,375 $0 0 $0 0 $0 5,318,305 $33,239 $0 0 $0 0 $0 3,190,983 $19,944 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2,853,378 $17,834 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2,699,304 $16,871 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2,458,905 $15,368 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2,438,375 $15,240 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2,353,250 $14,708 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2,306,203 $14,414 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1,595,491 $9,972 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1,449,178 $9,057 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1,331,434 $8,321 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1,234,564 $7,716 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1,048,661 $6,554 $0 0 $0 0 $0 927,729 $5,798 $0 0 $0 0 $0 850,929 $5,318 $0 0 $0 0 $0 473,068 $2,957 $0 0 $0 0 $0 266,223 $1,664 $0 0 $0 0 $0 254,822 $1,593 $0 0 $0 0 $0 189,009 $1,181 $0 0 $0 0 $0 123,480 $772 $0 0 $0 0 $0 106,366 $665 $0 0 $0 0 $0 16,311 $102 $2,560 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $200 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0
20 Camouflaged Cash: How Security Votes Fuel Corruption in Nigeria University of Uyo Education 0 $0 4,000,000 Independent Corrupt Practices and Related Offences Commission (ICPC) Justice 0 $0 24,660,600 Ministry of Petroleum Resources Petroleum 0 $0 591,190 Business Incubator Centre, Maiduguri, Borno 0 $0 0 TOTAL 18,354,336,602 $50,285,854 12,874,340,311
Transparency International Defence & Security 21 $13,333 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $82,202 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $1,971 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 $42,914,468 9,251,661,647 $46,258,308 12,342,721,199 $66,717,412 34,334,081,860 $214,588,012
Transparency International Defence & Security ti-defence.org twitter.com/ti_defence Civil Society Legislative Advocacy Centre (CISLAC) cislacnigeria.net twitter.com/cislacnigeria