ANNOUNCEMENTS COLORADO COURT OF APPEALS November 16, 2006 Slip opinions are the opinions as filed by the judges with the clerk. Slip opinions are subject to modification, rehearing, withdrawal, or clerical corrections. A link to any modifications to previously posted opinions will appear in the Petition for Rehearing section of the announcement document the day the changes are announced. Click on the case number to view published opinion. P U B L I S H E D O P I N I O N S Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1794 City and County of Denver District Court No. 03CR1499 Honorable Sheila A. Rappaport, Judge William Hoover, JUDGMENT AND SENTENCES AFFIRMED Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE LOEB Román and Plank*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1939 Pueblo County District Court No. 03CV621 Honorable Scott B. Epstein, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (1 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Connie Espinosa and Michael Miranda, Plaintiffs-Appellants, Wilmer Perez, M.D. and Parkview Medical Center, Inc., a Colorado nonprofit corporation, d/b/a Parkview Medical Center, Defendants-Appellees. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Rothenberg and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2424 City and County of Denver District Court No. 86CR2049 Honorable Larry J. Naves, Judge John P. Sherman, ORDER AFFIRMED Division I Opinion by: JUDGE BERNARD Márquez and Rothenberg, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2539 Arapahoe County District Court No. 95CV1854 Honorable J. Mark Hannen, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (2 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Michele R. Pearson and Denise L. Fahy, Plaintiffs-Appellants, William E. Kancilia, Defendant-Appellee. ORDER REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Rothenberg and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0015 Adams County District Court No. 03CR3049 Honorable C. Scott Crabtree, Judge Joseph L. Whaley, Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0145 JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division V Opinion by: JUDGE FURMAN Dailey and Hawthorne, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (3 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Adams County District Court No. 02CV2889 Honorable Thomas R. Ensor, Judge Colorado Korean Association, Korean Senior Association of Colorado, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Rothenberg and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0443 Eagle County District Court No. 03CV71 Honorable R. Thomas Moorhead, Judge Town of Avon, a municipal corporation, Defendant-Appellant, Weststar Bank and County of Eagle, Defendants-Appellees. JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division II Opinion by: JUDGE CRISWELL* Rothenberg and Roy, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (4 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0535 Adams County District Court No. 98DR1801 Honorable John E. Popovich, Jr., Judge In re the Marriage of Veronica Sanchez-Vigil, f/k/a Veronica Rael, Appellant, and Eril T. Rael, Appellee. ORDER REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROTHENBERG Roy and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0587 Gunnison County District Court No.: 04CV10 Honorable J. Steven Patrick, Judge Larry Darien, Dana Darien, Tom Williams, and Dan Brumbaugh, Plaintiffs-Appellants and Cross-Appellees, Town of Marble Colorado, a body corporate; Town Council of the Town of Marble; and Hal Sidelinger and Robert Pettijohn, in their official capacities as members of the Town Council, Defendants-Appellees and Cross-Appellants. file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (5 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE CARPARELLI J. Jones, J., concurs Casebolt, J., dissents Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0936 Washington County District Court No. 00CR15 Honorable Douglas R. Vannoy, Judge Tilford H. Gash, Jr., ORDER AFFIRMED Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE ROMÁN Davidson, C.J., and Loeb, J., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0982 Pueblo County District Court No. 05CV29 Honorable David A. Cole, Judge GMAC Mortgage Corporation, a Pennsylvania corporation; et al., Plaintiffs-Appellants, PWI Group, a California limited partnership, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (6 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Defendant-Appellee. JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Casebolt and Russel, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1568 City and County of Denver Probate Court No. 05PR446 Honorable C. Jean Stewart, Judge In the Matter of the Estate of Sophia H. Scott & William C. Scott, Deceased. Samuel C. Scott, Petitioner-Appellant, John S. Holt, Trustee of the Sophia H. Scott and William C. Scott Trust, Respondent-Appellee. APPEAL DISMISSED Division II Opinion by: JUDGE TERRY Taubman, J., concurs Vogt, J., dissents Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1797 Jefferson County District Court No. 05CV940 Honorable Jane A. Tidball, Judge Lane R. Evans, Plaintiff-Appellant, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (7 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Department of Revenue, State of Colorado Motor Vehicle Division, Defendant-Appellee. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE ROMÁN Loeb and Plank*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1955 Jefferson County District Court No. 03JD1018 Honorable James D. Zimmerman, Judge Petitioner-Appellee, In the Interest of J.C.P., Juvenile-Appellant. SENTENCE AFFIRMED Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Rothenberg and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2131 City and County of Denver District Court No. 04CV7177 Honorable Lawrence A. Manzanares, Judge David K. Jenner, Plaintiff-Appellant, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (8 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Joseph Ortiz, Christine Moschetti, and the Attorney General of the State of Colorado, Defendants-Appellees. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division II Opinion by: JUDGE TERRY Taubman and Vogt, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2214 Arapahoe County District Court No. 05JV349 Honorable Gerald J. Rafferty, Judge In the Interest of K.L.O-V., a Child, and Concerning K.A.V., Petitioner-Appellee, and M.F.O., Grandparent, Intervenor-Appellant. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED IN PART AND APPEAL DISMISSED IN PART Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE ROMÁN Roy and Loeb, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 06CA0606 El Paso County District Court No. 04JV2020 Honorable Theresa M. Cisneros, Judge In the Interest of K.A., a Child, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (9 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Upon the Petition of the El Paso County Department of Human Services, Petitioner-Appellee, and Concerning A.A., Respondent-Appellant. ORDER AFFIRMED Division I Opinion by: JUDGE BERNARD Márquez and Rothenberg, JJ., concur U N P U B L I S H E D O P I N I O N S Court of Appeals No.: 03CA2409 Larimer County District Court No. 03CR1669 Honorable Daniel J. Kaup, Judge Dariel I. Hough, Jr., JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE LOEB Roy and Román, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (10 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0779 Arapahoe County District Court No. 03CR1025 Honorable Thomas C. Levi, Judge Hector M. Sanchez, JUDGMENT AND SENTENCES AFFIRMED Division III Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Casebolt and Russel, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1305 & 05CA0939 Boulder County District Court No. 03DR309 Honorable D.D. Mallard, Judge Honorable Lael E. Montgomery, Judge Honorable Morris W. Sandstead, Jr., Judge In re the Marriage of Kelly M. Hesse, Appellee, and Carl J. Hesse, III, Appellant. file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (11 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
ORDERS AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE FURMAN Dailey and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1840 Jefferson County District Court No. 03CR322 Honorable Frank Plaut, Judge Penny A. McHugh, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED, SENTENCE AFFIRMED IN PART, AND VACATED IN PART, AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE CASEBOLT Graham and Russel, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1848 Jefferson County District Court No. 03CR2473 Honorable Jack W. Berryhill, Judge Honorable R. Brooke Jackson, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (12 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Gregorio L. Bonifacio, JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division V Opinion by: JUDGE DAILEY Hawthorne and Furman, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2355 Adams County District Court No. 01CR1357 Honorable C. Scott Crabtree, Judge Mark F. Shifter, ORDER AFFIRMED Division III Opinion by: JUDGE RUSSEL Casebolt and Graham, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2590 Mesa County District Court No. 04CR322 Honorable Amanda D. Bailey, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (13 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Nicholas E. Shilling, ORDER REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division VI Opinion by: JUDGE PLANK* Loeb and Nieto*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2641 Larimer County District Court No. 96CR1186 Honorable Daniel J. Kaup, Judge James D. Taylor, ORDER AFFIRMED Division III Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Casebolt and Kapelke*, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (14 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0044 Adams County District Court No. 03CR3575 Honorable C. Scott Crabtree, Judge William D. Chrysler, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division V Opinion by: JUDGE FURMAN Dailey and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0166 Mesa County District Court No. 98CV787 Honorable Charles A. Buss, Judge Great Homes, Ltd., Plaintiff, John Giancanelli and Linda Giancanelli, Defendants-Appellees, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (15 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Stanley L. Seligman and DACASTA, Inc., Third-Party Defendants-Appellants. ORDER REVERSED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE FURMAN Dailey and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0377 Mesa County District Court No. 04CR476 Honorable David A. Bottger, Judge Dwain T. Jackson, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE HAWTHORNE Dailey and Furman, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0527 City and County of Denver District Court No. 04CV6919 Honorable Shelley I. Gilman, Judge Lois Leder, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (16 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Plaintiff-Appellee and Cross-Appellant, Thomas R. Giles, Defendant-Appellant and Cross-Appellee. JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division VI Opinion by: JUDGE PLANK* Loeb and Nieto*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0573 Adams County District Court No. 03CR39 Honorable C. Scott Crabtree, Judge Luis Adrian Lovejoy, ORDER AND SENTENCE AFFIRMED Division II Opinion by: JUDGE VOGT Taubman and Terry, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (17 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0721 City and County of Denver District Court Nos. 00CR4602, 00CR4603, & 01CR1697 Honorable R. Michael Mullins, Judge Valerie Giorella, ORDER AFFIRMED Division III Opinion by: JUDGE CASEBOLT Graham and Russel, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0833 Adams County District Court Nos. 98CR342 & 98CR612 Honorable Katherine R. Delgado, Judge Eldon K. Horton, ORDER AFFIRMED Division VI file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (18 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Opinion by: JUDGE NEY* Davidson, C.J., and Sternberg*, J., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0907 Routt County District Court No. 02DR74 Honorable Michael A. O Hara, III, Judge In re the Marriage of Susan K. Waldron, Appellee and Cross-Appellant, and Martin J. Waldron, Appellant and Cross-Appellee. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE KAPELKE* Davidson, C.J., and Criswell*, J., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0972 Adams County District Court No. 00CR306 Honorable Harlan R. Bockman, Judge Honorable Katherine R. Delgado, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (19 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Frank Churchill, Jr., ORDER AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: CHIEF JUDGE DAVIDSON Criswell* and Ney*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1040 Adams County District Court No. 03CV3915 Honorable Thomas R. Ensor, Judge Rocky Mountain Recycling, Inc., Don s Scrap Iron & Metal Co., Inc., JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division I Opinion by: JUDGE BERNARD Márquez and Rothenberg, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1147 El Paso County District Court No. 94CR2345 Honorable Larry E. Schwartz, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (20 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Shannon R. Gray, ORDER AFFIRMED Division VI Opinion by: JUDGE STERNBERG* Davidson, C.J., and Ney*, J., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1206 Weld County District Court No. 04CR1136 Honorable James Hartmann, Judge Joshua James Richardson, SENTENCE AFFIRMED Division II Opinion by: JUDGE TAUBMAN Vogt and Terry, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1343 City and County of Denver District Court No. 04CR3175 file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (21 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Honorable Larry J. Naves, Judge Carlys Doucett, a/k/a Carlos M. Doycett, ORDER AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE CRISWELL* Davidson, C.J., and Ney*, J., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1688 Arapahoe County District Court No. 04CV5245 Honorable Cheryl L. Post, Judge Armor Buildings, Inc., Mid-American Gunite, Inc., order reversed and case remanded with directions Division III Opinion by: JUDGE CASEBOLT Graham and Russel, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (22 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2267 Jefferson County District Court No. 04DR137 Honorable Peter A. Weir, Judge In re the Marriage of Suzanne Scohy, Appellee, and Russell E. Scohy, II, Appellant. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division VI Opinion by: CHIEF JUDGE DAVIDSON Sternberg* and Ney*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2275 Jefferson County District Court No. 00CR924 Honorable Margie L. Enquist, Judge Ron E. Edgmon, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (23 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
ORDER AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE NEY* Davidson, C.J., and Criswell*, J., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2354 Routt County District Court No. 02DR74 Honorable Michael A. O Hara, III, Judge In re the Marriage of Susan Kathleen Waldron, Appellee, and Martin J. Waldron, Appellant. ORDER AFFIRMED Division IV Opinion by: CHIEF JUDGE DAVIDSON Criswell* and Kapelke*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2390 Montezuma County District Court No. 04CR341 Honorable Sharon L. Hansen, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (24 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Destin D. Yazzie, SENTENCE AFFIRMED Division I Opinion by: JUDGE ROTHENBERG Márquez and Bernard, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2586 Jefferson County District Court No. 05DR1078 Honorable Margie L. Enquist, Judge In re the Parental Responsibility of J.S., a Child, and Concerning James B. Sulzbach, Petitioner-Appellee, and Allison A. Fulton, Respondent-Appellant. JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division I Opinion by: JUDGE BERNARD Márquez and Rothenberg, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (25 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2674 City and County of Denver District Court No. 05CV584 Honorable Martin F. Egelhoff, Judge Michael D. Barry, Plaintiff-Appellant, Joe Ortiz and Bill Owens, Defendants-Appellees. APPEAL DISMISSED IN PART, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART, AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Casebolt and Russel, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 06CA0719 Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado DD No. 167-2006 Pete A. Balzer, Petitioner, Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado and CSK Auto, Inc., Checker Auto Parts 1131, Respondents. ORDER AFFIRMED file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (26 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Division I Opinion by: JUDGE BERNARD Márquez and Rothenberg, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 06CA1505 Mesa County District Court No. 05JV323 Honorable Thomas Deister, Judge Petitioner-Appellee, In the Interest of J.D. and G.D., Children, and Concerning S.D., Respondent-Appellant. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1300 Division III Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Casebolt and Russel, JJ., concur P E T I T I O N S F O R R E H E A R I N G file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (27 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]
Mike Kirkpatrick, Petition for Rehearing DENIED *Sitting by assignment of the Chief Justice under provisions of Colo. Const. art. VI, 5(3), and 24-51-1105, C.R.S. 2006. file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q4/11-16-06.htm (28 of 28) [8/19/2008 5:59:14 PM]