Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Similar documents
Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, September 9, 2014

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, August 26, 2014

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, January 13, 2014

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, June 9, 2015

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Monday, April 20, 2015

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, August 12, 2014

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday May 26, 2015

Vestal Central School District Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. Tuesday, February 26, 2019

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. Tuesday, September 26, 2017

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Monday, April 22, 2013

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. TUESDAY, May 24, 2016

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. Tuesday, December 5, 2017

Vestal Central School District Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. Tuesday, May 22, 2018

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. Tuesday, FEBRUARY 13, 2018

Vestal Central School District Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, August 14, 2018

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING. Tuesday November 15, 2016

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, January 10, 2006

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REORGANIZATION MEETING TUESDAY, JULY 11, 2017

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Vestal Central School District Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION SPECIAL MEETING Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Vestal Central School District Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REORGANIZATION MEETING TUESDAY, JULY 10, 2018

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, January 13, 2009

2. Approve the administrator tenure--secondary Assistant Principal

BETHLEHEM CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT Board of Education Meeting. A G E N D A Glenmont Auditorium

MONDAY, OCTOBER 17, :00 p.m. AGENDA

REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION FEBRUARY 9, 2016

David Weyand; Paul McAnany; Richard Dunning; Pasquale Picco Carol Berry

WELCOME Vice President Matyas and Superintendent Roland welcomed the visitors in attendance.

9. CONSENT AGENDA Recommended Motion: That the consent agenda consisting of the following

BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING Regular Meeting Board Room November 14, 2018

BOARD OF EDUCATION VESTAL CENTRAL SCHOOLS Vestal, New York Senior High School Tuesday, October 10, 2017 Auditorium 6:00PM REGULAR MEETING AGENDA

BOARD OF EDUCATION WORKSHOP MEETING MINUTES October 15, :45 P.M.

WASHINGTONVILLE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York. BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Mohonasen Central School District

AGENDA Regular Business Meeting

RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS Norwalk City School District Board of Education Regular Meeting

I. Opening of the Meeting

ALEXANDER CENTRAL SCHOOL Board of Education Meeting

Board of Education LANCASTER CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT Lancaster, New York

RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS MINUTES OF KEYSTONE BOARD OF EDUCATION

BOARD OF EDUCATION BAYPORT BLUE POINT UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT. REGULAR BOARD MEETING April 9 TH, 2013

REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION AT 6:00 p.m. BAYPORT-BLUE POINT UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT April 9, 2013

The Frewsburg Central School Board of Education met on Thursday, February 8, 2018 in the MS/HS Multi-Purpose Room at 6:30 p.m.

Cold Spring School District Board of Trustees

Mohonasen Central School District

Board of Education Mr. Colin Smith, President Mrs. Lisa Aspinall-Kellawon, Vice President Mr. Douglas Glickert Mrs. Maria Pereira

WEST ALLEGHENY SCHOOL DISTRICT MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF SCHOOL DIRECTORS. August 16, 2017

Shannon M. Edmondson, Vice President Nicholas J. Matyas, District Clerk Jeannette Farr, Trustee Heather Gaughan, Trustee Matthew Jablonowski, Trustee

OFFICIAL POSTING: BULLETIN BOARD OUTSIDE BOARDROOM DATE POSTED: JUNE 28, 2017 TIME POSTED: 4:00 P.M.

Administrators in attendance were Tim Ryan, William Zakrajsek, Jenn Henderson, Linda Maynard and Scott Graham.

SHERBURNE-EARLVILLE CENTRAL SCHOOL BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING 3/23/15 Board Meeting 6:30 p.m. Elementary Library Classroom

Student Liaison Chuck Stiver: numerous students received certificates in recognition of their achievements in FCCLA, Power of the Pen and Wrestling.

BOARD OF EDUCATION WILLIAM FLOYD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT of the Mastics-Moriches-Shirley. REGULAR MEETING December 9, 2014 AGENDA

Fayetteville-Manlius School District Board of Education Meeting Monday, October 5, Enders Road

Mount Morris Central School

ORLEANS COMMUNITY SCHOOLS 173 W Marley St.; Orleans, IN

HOPEWELL AREA SCHOOL BOARD REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING SEPTEMBER 23, 2014

APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE OCTOBER 8, 2016 REGULAR MEETING RECOGNITION OF VISITORS AND READING OF CORRESPONDENCE

I. Opening of the Meeting

GANANDA CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT District Office/Middle School Board Room WALWORTH, NEW YORK September 10, 2014

Attendance Central Office Administrators Mr. Bodziak X Mr. Petrus N/A Dr. Costello X Ms. Pinker X

INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 624 WHITE BEAR LAKE, MN 55110

BOARD OF EDUCATION ISLAND PARK UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT ISLAND PARK, NEW YORK

Present: Gary Kepley, Robert Miller, Rodney Morris, Bill Standerfer,

To challenge and inspire students to achieve at the highest level and become responsible citizens.

FRANKLIN SQUARE SCHOOL DISTRICT FRANKLIN SQUARE, NEW YORK

I. Opening of the Meeting

Minutes School Board Business Meeting Fridley Independent School District 14 December 17, 2013

A motion was made by Droste, seconded by Kary to approve the following consent agenda as amended:

CENTER GROVE COMMUNITY SCHOOL CORPORATION BOARD OF SCHOOL TRUSTEES June 16, 2015 MINUTES

CAIRO-DURHAM CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT Board of Education Agenda

VALLEY CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT 944 State Route 17K Montgomery, New York. October 13, 2015

Regular Meeting. February 18, The Buckeye Valley Local Board of Education met in Regular Session at 6:30 p.m. at the High School, Baron Hall.

OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION Chickasha Public Schools Chickasha, Okla. Regular Meeting March 13, 2018

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION RE-ORGANIZATIONAL MEETING MONDAY, JULY 9, 2007

The Portsmouth City School Board Portsmouth, Virginia

HOPEWELL AREA SCHOOL BOARD REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING AUGUST 22, The meeting was called to order at 7:09 p.m. by Lesia Dobo, Board Vice President.

ORCHARD PARK CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT

AGENDA 873 1, 2018, 7:00 PM

Regular Meeting of the School Board November 19, :00 P.M. District Office Board Room th Street East Inver Grove Heights, Minnesota

MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION SANDY CREEK CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT SALISBURY STREET SANDY CREEK, NEW YORK

The Board of Education, Piqua City School District, met on October 28, 2010, 4:00 P.M. at the Municipal Government Complex, Commission Chambers.

ALBANY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION 1051 Monroe Street Albany, CA 94706

FRANKLIN CENTRAL SCHOOL REGULAR BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING April 21, 2014 Room 206 7:00 p.m. Executive Session, 7:30 p.m.

FINANCIAL OCTOBER APPROVED STATEMENTS MOTION: Trustee Martinez SECOND: Trustee Jablonowski CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY

Regular Board of Education Meeting Tri-County School District 2358 June 21, 2017, 8:00 p.m. Staff Work Room

CHRISTIAN COUNTY FISCAL COURT

OPEN REGULAR SESSION

WALTON CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION

Joanna Hughes, Superintendent/Principal Christine Werner, Interim Business Administrator/Board Secretary

BOARD OF EDUCATION AGENDA April 9, 2019 Elementary School LGR

RED LION AREA BOARD OF SCHOOL DIRECTORS DECEMBER 15, 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS

MOUNT SINAI UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION AGENDA THE AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO MODIFICATION UP TO THE START OF THE MEETING

CRESTWOOD SCHOOL DISTRICT JANUARY 21, 2010 AGENDA E. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF REORGANIZATION AND REGULAR BOARD MEETING OF DECEMBER 3, 2009.

BOARD OF EDUCATION ROSELLE PARK, NEW JERSEY OPEN MINUTES of the May 20, 2014 Board Meeting 7:00 P.M.

RED LION AREA BOARD OF SCHOOL DIRECTORS MARCH 17, 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS

BUCKEYE VALLEY LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICT REGULAR BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING

Ken Orwoll, Scott Johnson, Dave Ertl, Andrea Uhl, Greg Crowe, Sarah Schmidt, Lori Nelson, Brenda Schell and Bob Meyer

Transcription:

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION REGULAR MEETING Tuesday, April 7, 2015 PRESENT: Michon Stuart, President Jerry Etingoff, Vice President Linda Daino David Hanson Joan Miller Kim Myers Mario Nunes Sylvia Place Tony Turnbull ALSO PRESENT: Superintendent Mark LaRoach School Business Administrator Jeffrey Ahearn Director of Instruction Laura Lamash District Negotiator Keith Olivet Attorney Michael Sherwood District Clerk Kay Ellis Student Government Representative Rachel Kosty About 60 Visitors The Board meeting was called to order at 7:00 PM by Board President Michon Stuart in the Board Conference Room at the Administration Building. The Pledge of Allegiance was recited. On motion by Sylvia Place, second by David Hanson, the Board voted 9 to 0 to adjourn immediately into Executive Session to discuss recommendations from the Committee on Special Education and the Committee on Preschool Special Education and a legal issue. #344-15 Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance #345-15 Executive Session The Board returned to open session at 7:40 PM. On motion by Sylvia Place, second by Linda Daino, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the minutes of the March 24, 2015 meeting as written. #346-15 Approval of Minutes None. #347-15 Public Comments on Agenda Items Student Government Representative Rachel Kosty: --The student exchange with Binghamton went well. --ID cards for students are being processed. --The Swing Into Spring Dance for senior citizens will be held this Friday. --Booths can be rented for the music festival (Vestival). --The interim principal, Al Penna, has an open door policy. #348-15 Reports Board President Michon Stuart reported: Liaisons: the Chemistry Magic Show was performed for 4 th graders. African Road held an assembly prior to spring break. Clayton Avenue will have a book fair and ice cream social on May 19. Glenwood will have a carnival on May 19, the Barnes & Noble fundraiser will be 4/19, and a spring musical is being planned. --Odyssey of the Mind state competition will be 4/11; we have 4 teams participating at that level. --NYSSBA spotlighted the collaborative efforts between UE and Vestal regarding shared teachers. Superintendent Mark LaRoach reported: --The proposed NYS budget included some additional state aid, along with changes to tenure and APPR. On motion by Mario Nunes, second by Sylvia Place, the Board voted 9 to 0 to accept Schedule E (Enrollment Report), Schedule F (Travel/Conference Requests) and Schedule I (Budget Transfers); and approve Schedule P (Personnel). Under Schedule P, the following changes in personnel were made: #349-15 Acceptance of Schedules E, F and I; Approval of Schedule P SCHEDULE IP 4A TEMPORARY APPOINTMENTS: INSTRUCTIONAL SUBSTITUTES The Superintendent of Schools hereby recommends the APPROVAL of the following INSTRUCTIONAL TEMPORARY APPOINTMENTS (SUBSTITUTES): NAME INSTRUCTIONAL LEVEL CERTIF DEGREE EFFECTIVE DATE REMARKS

Moore, Amelia Music Initial BM 4/8/15 Pipher, Diane Social Studies None MA 4/8/15 Ryan, Daniel Art Initial BS 4/8/15 SCHEDULE IP 6 TENURE APPOINTMENTS: INSTRUCTIONAL The Superintendent of Schools hereby recommends the APPROVAL of the following INSTRUCTIONAL TENURE APPOINTMENTS: NAME POSITION TENURE AREA CERIF PROBATION EFFECTIVE REMARKS PERIOD DATE Kelly, Christie Special Education Special Subject Area: Initial 9/1/12-6/30/15 9/1/15 Teacher General Special Education Kinsley, Special Education Special Subject Area: Initial 9/1/12-6/30/15 9/1/15 Jacqueline Teacher General Special Education Klimas, Peter Science Teacher Academic Area: Science Professional 9/1/13-6/30/15 9/1/15 Previous NYS tenure Mignerey, Sandra Science Teacher Academic Area: Science Permanent 9/1/13-6/30/15 9/1/15 Previous NYS tenure Murphy, Benjamin Science Teacher Academic Area: Science Initial 9/1/13-6/30/15 9/1/15 Jarema credit 9/1/12-6/30/13 Russell, Pamela Foreign Language Academic Area: Foreign Initial 9/1/11-6/30/15 9/1/15 Teacher Language Skinner, Sonya Science Teacher Academic Area: Science Professional 9/1/12-6/30/15 9/1/15 SCHEDULE IP 8 CHANGE IN STATUS: INSTRUCTIONAL The Superintendent of Schools hereby recommends the APPROVAL of the following NON-INSTRUCTIONAL CHANGE IN STATUS: NAME POSITION TENURE AREA CHANGE EFFECTIVE Zappia, Annamary Director of Special Services Administrative Area: Director of Special Services Withdrew resignation 4/8/15 SCHEDULE NIP 8A TEMPORARY APPOINTMENT/SUBSTITUTE: NON-INSTRUCTIONAL The Superintendent of Schools hereby recommends the APPROVAL of the following NON-INSTRUCTIONAL TEMPORARY APPOINTMENT/SUBSTITUTE: NAME POSITION EFFECTIVE DATE REMARKS Carey, Cody-James Bus Driver PT/S 3/26/15 Remains a bus attendant SCHEDULE NIP 9B PART TIME NON-COMPETITIVE APPOINTMENTS: NON-INSTRUCTIONAL The Superintendent of Schools hereby recommends the APPROVAL of the following NON-INSTRUCTIONAL PART-TIME NON- COMPETITIVE APPOINTMENTS: NAME POSITION SHIFT/BLDG PROBATION PERIOD SALARY REMARKS Haight, Anna Food Service Helper (3.5 hrs/day) ARE 4/8/15-6/29/16 $5,519 52 wk probationary period Lainhart, Kimberly Food Service Helper (3.0 hrs/day) District 4/8/15-6/29/16 $4,730 52 wk probationary period SCHEDULE NIP 11 CHANGES IN STATUS: NON-INSTRUCTIONAL The Superintendent of Schools hereby recommends the APPROVAL of the following NON-INSTRUCTIONAL CHANGES IN STATUS: NAME POSITION SHIFT/BLDG CHANGE EFFECTIVE Peterson, Debra Food Service Helper (3.5 hrs/day) High School To Food Service Helper (4 hrs/day) 4/8/15 Sherwood, Charles Bus Driver PT/S Transportation To Bus Driver 4/6/15 Tom, Rhonda Bus Attendant PT/S Transportation To Bus Attendant (DIT) 4/6/15 On motion by Tony Turnbull, second by Linda Daino, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED, that the Board of Education pursuant to its authority under Section 1709(12) of the Education Law hereby accepts the following gifts: Description Approx. Value Donor Recipient Cash Donation for Hall of $100.00 Home Central Vestal Central 2 #350-15 Acceptance of Gifts

Fame Inductions Cash Donation for Hall of $100.00 National Pipe & Vestal Central Fame Inductions Plastics, Inc. Cash Donation for Hall of $100.00 Patrick Giannetto Vestal Central Fame Inductions Cash Donation for Vestal $308.66 Target Take Charge Vestal Central Middle School of Education Cash Donation for Clayton $2200.00 Excellus Health Plan, Vestal Central Avenue Elementary School Inc. Several Kawasaki Power $1474.72 Tractor Supply Co. Vestal Central Tools On motion by Jerry Etingoff, second by Joan Miller, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED, that the President or Vice-President of the Board of Education be authorized to sign an agreement with the Union Endicott Central to provide Health and Welfare Services to approximately 35 students residing in the Vestal Central attending non-public schools in the Union Endicott Central during the 2014-15 school year at a cost of $334.05 per student. On motion by Mario Nunes, second by Kim Myers, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED that the Board of Education authorizes the following textbooks for use, as detailed in the attached memorandum: Oxford Press Co.: Chemistry: IB Study for the Diploma; by Geoffrey Neuss, Copyright 2014 List Price: $36.00 each Pearson Education Limited: Higher Level Chemistry, 2 nd Edition; by C. Brown & M. Ford, Copyright 2014 List Price: $99.97 each On motion by Linda Daino, second by David Hanson, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED, that the Board of Education authorizes the President or Vice-President to sign an agreement with Movie Licensing USA to provide a single event licensing to show the movie Temple Grandin, in accordance with the attached contract. On motion by Jerry Etingoff, second by Sylvia Place, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED, that the 2011-2017 Agreement between the Superintendent of Schools and the Association of Vestal Schools Paraprofessionals is hereby implemented and the additional funds are provided in accordance with Civil Service Law 204A, effective from July 1, 2011 to June 30, 2017. On motion by David Hanson, second by Sylvia Place, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED, upon the recommendation of the Superintendent of Schools, that the proposed tentative school budget for the 2015-16 school year be and is hereby adopted in the amount of $75,086,114 and said amount will be the spending plan upon which the eligible voters of the Vestal Central will consider on May 19, 2015; and BE IT ALSO RESOLVED upon the recommendation of the Superintendent of Schools that the Board of Education approves the submission of the 2015-16 Property Tax Report Card to the New York State Department of Education as required by NYS regulations. On motion by Joan Miller, second by Sylvia Place, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED that the Board of Education authorizes the President or Vice-President to sign an agreement with NYSDEC Division of Fish Wildlife and Marine Resources, National Archery in the Schools Program to provide a loan of archery equipment, in accordance with the attached contract. On motion by Kim Myers, second by Tony Turnbull, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED, that the President or Vice-President of the Board of Education be authorized to sign the agreement with Excellus BlueCross BlueShield for the continuation of medical and prescription benefits (BlueCross 3 #351-15 Health and Welfare Service Charges; Union Endicott Central School District #352-15 Adoption of Textbooks #353-15 Contract with Movie Licensing USA #354-15 Implementation of Agreement with AVSP #355-15 Adoption of 2015-16 Budget #356-15 Agreement with NYS Department of Environmental Conservation #357-15 Blue Cross-Blue Shield Renewal of

BlueShield Classic Blue Regionwide/PPO H/Simply Prescription) from April 1, 2015 through March 31, 2016. On motion by Jerry Etingoff, second by Mario Nunes, the Board voted 9 to 0 to approve the following resolution: RESOLVED, that the President or Vice-President of the Board of Education be authorized to sign an agreement with Four Winds Katonah for tutoring services for a Vestal student residing in that facility for the 2014-15 academic year at a cost of $54.00 per hour. Ruth Fitzgerald, 2209 Hemlock, Vestal, thanked the District s negotiation team and spoke to the Board about the vital part paraprofessionals play in the support of staff and students. MONDAY, April 20, 2015 7:00 PM Regular Meeting Board Conference Room Administration Building Tuesday, May 12, 2015 6:00 PM Public Hearing on Budget; 7:00 PM Regular Meeting Auditorium Clayton Avenue Elementary School The Board discussed the appropriateness of holding public meetings in a religious facility. On motion by Tony Turnbull, second by Linda Daino, the Board voted 6 to 3 to allow the procedures committee to meet at the United Methodist Church April 9, 2015. Benefits #358-15 Contract with Four Winds Katonah #359-15 Voice of the Public #360-15 Future Meetings #361-15 Public Meeting in Religious Facility Future Board Sub-Committee Meetings Procedure Committee April 9, 2015; 11:00AM, United Methodist Church library Policy Committee April 21, 2015; 1:00 PM; Small Conference Room On motion by David Hanson, second by Linda Daino, the Board voted 9 to 0 to adjourn the meeting immediately. #362-15 Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 8:27 PM. Kay Ellis, District Clerk 4

Vestal Central Schools Vestal, New York BOARD OF EDUCATION EXECUTIVE SESSION #1 Tuesday, April 7, 2015 PRESENT: Michon Stuart, President Jerry Etingoff, Vice President Linda Daino David Hanson Kim Myers Joan Miller Mario Nunes Sylvia Place Tony Turnbull ALSO PRESENT: Superintendent Mark LaRoach School Business Administrator Jeffrey Ahearn Director of Instruction Laura Lamash District Negotiator Keith Olivet Attorney Michael Sherwood District Clerk Kay Ellis Anne Tristan, Director of Special Education Executive Session commenced at 7:02 PM in the small conference room of the Administration Building. Recommendations and annual reviews of the Committee on Special Education and the Committee on Preschool Special Education were on the agenda. Board members had copies of the IEPs for each student made available to them prior to the meeting and had reviewed them. Board members gave due consideration to each case before voting. On motion by Jerry Etingoff, second by Tony Turnbull, the Board voted 9 to 0 to accept the recommendations and annual reviews of the Committee on Special Education and the Committee on Preschool Special Education for all students considered. The Board discussed a legal issue. The session was adjourned at 7:38PM. Kay Ellis, District Clerk 2015 4-7 MIN 5