1. COURSE NAME AND NUMBER: Criminal Law, LAWS 1001 2. COURSE INSTRUCTOR Name: Professor Adelina Iftene Office number: 427 Office telephone number: 902-494-1296 E-mail: aiftene@dal.ca Office Hours: Fall Term Monday: 12.30 2.30 pm Tuesday: 1 3pm Winter: TBA OR e-mail for appointment NOTE: I do not answer substantive questions by e-mail please come and see me in person. 3. COURSE INFORMATION a. Class Times and Location: Fall: Monday: 3.00 4.20 pm (Rm 104) Thursday: 11.00 am 12.20 pm (Rm 104) Winter: Tuesday: 1.30 2. 50 pm (Rm 105) Thursday: 9.30 10.50 am (Rm 105) Adelina Iftene, Assistant Professor Weldon Law Building 6061 University Ave. P.O. Box 15000 Halifax NS B3H 4R2 Tel: 902.494.1296 Fax: 902.494.6535 aiftene@dal.ca DAL.CA
b. Materials: Required: Stuart & Coughlan, Learning Canadian Criminal Law, ed 13 th, Carswell, 2015 Pocket Criminal Code, 2018, Carswell Some materials added on Brightspace prior to class You will need the TopHat App for the first term (same one you will be required to get for the Legal Research and Writing course with Prof Jon Shapiro). Recommended: Kent Roach, Criminal Law, 5 th ed, Irwin Law, 2012 (available on reserve in the library) c. Objectives When you have completed this course, you should have: become familiar with, and be able to utilize, the sources of criminal law, the Charter, the Criminal Code, and judicial decisions; acquired knowledge of the general principles of criminal law; be able to apply those principles to specific offences; acquired skills in legal analysis and writing, in the context of criminal law issues; acquired skills in applying law to fact situations; increased capacity to consider the impact of particular rules and practices on a range of groups, such as accused persons, women, and aboriginal people. d. Learning criminal law In this course, we will spend a lot of class time discussing challenging topics such as sexual assault, the over-representation of Indigenous people in the Canadian criminal justice system, and the discrimination against women and racial minorities within the system. Recognising that each of you will have a different experience of these topics, and come equipped with various levels of familiarity with the issues that these topics raise, here are some principles that we will use when discussing difficult issues such as these (these principles are adapted from some originally used by Tracy Lindberg at the University of Alberta): 2
1. We each have the right to make kind mistakes. We will make mistakes and it is each individual s responsibility to be as informed as possible when you get to class in order to ensure that your mistake is kind. 2. It actually does harm to hear stereotypes, generalizations and pejorative understandings about one s race, gender or subject position. While we can all make kind mistakes, let us also be fully informed and gentle as we are talking about people in the room. 3. You have the right to ask any question. If you are shy or uncomfortable, please write it down for me and I will answer it during / as part of a lecture. 4. The goal of these principles is to acknowledge that we have continuing relationships with each other. These relationships must be respectful and reciprocal in order for us to share space and ideas (inside of this classroom and out). e. Evaluation: 100% final open book exam 30% Mid-term exam (December) ONLY IF IT BENEFITS YOU 5. POLICY & ADMINISTRATION a. Special Accommodation Requests for special accommodation for reasons such as illness, injury or family emergency will require an application to the Law School Studies Committee. Such requests (for example, for assignment extensions) must be made to Associate Dean Michael Deturbide or the Director of Student Services as soon as possible, before a scheduled exam or a deadline for an assignment, and will generally require medical documentation. Retroactive accommodation will not be provided. Please note that individual professors cannot entertain accommodation requests. Students may request accommodation for either classroom participation or the writing of tests and exams due to barriers related to disability, religious obligation, or any characteristic under the Nova Scotia Human Rights Act. Students who require such accommodation must make their request to the Advising and Access Services Center (AASC) at the outset of the regular academic year. Please visit www.dal.ca/access for more information and to obtain the Request for Accommodation Form A. Students may also contact the Advising and Access Services Centre directly at 494-2836. 3
b. Plagiarism All students must read the University policies on plagiarism and academic honesty http://academicintegrity.dal.ca/ and the Law School policy on plagiarism http://www.dal.ca/faculty/law/current-students/jd-students/academic-regulations.html. Any paper or assignment submitted by a student at the Schulich School of Law may be checked for originality to confirm that the student has not plagiarized from other sources. Plagiarism is considered a serious academic offence which may lead to loss of credit, suspension or expulsion from the law school, or even revocation of a degree. It is essential that there be correct attribution of authorities from which facts and opinions have been derived. Prior to submitting any paper or other assignment, students should read and familiarize themselves with the policies referred to above and should consult with the instructor if they have any questions. Ignorance of the policies on plagiarism will not excuse any violation of those policies. 6. COURSE OUTLINE Due to the two-week Aboriginal Law course, as well as the fact that I have to cancel the Sept 14 course because I am presenting at a conference, this course starts September 18 th. There will be a make-up class, addressing the issue of criminalization within non-white communities, on a Friday afternoon, TBA. All prescribed readings are from the Stuart & Coughlan (the required book), unless otherwise specified. The criminal justice system 1. Mon, Sept. 18 Introduction to the Criminal Justice System Readings: 108-127. 2. Thu, Sept. 21 Th Criminal Justice & Aboriginality Readings: 211-215; 217-228 from the Report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada ( TRC Executive Summary on Brightspace) Excerpt from Turpel On the Question of Adapting the Canadian Criminal Justice System for Aboriginal Peoples: Don t Fence Me In ( Turpel on Brightspace) NOTE: In preparation for the class, please watch the documentary on the Kikkik case, its context and ramifications (link available on Brightspace). It is essential you watch and understand Kikkik. We will often come back to this case and its lessons through-out the year. This class will not be lecture-based. Come prepared to discus Kikkik and to work on the TRC excerpts. 4
Sources of criminal law 3. Mon, Sept. 25 st Sources: Common Law (Reading a decision and using precedent) Readings: 1-10 4. Thu, Sept 28 Sources: Statutes, Power to Enact Legislation, and Statutory Interpretation Readings: 10-17; 19-21; 32-42. NOTE: Make sure you have your criminal code with you. 5. Mon, Oct 2 The Role of the Charter in Criminal Justice Readings: - Interpretation 43-46 (Hunter) - Limitations on substantive law: 46 47; 56-68 (Bedford) 6. Thu, Oct 5 The Role of the Charter in Criminal Justice (II) Readings: - Limitations (con t): 47 56 (CFCYL) - Overriding protected rights: 68-73 (Oakes) NOTE: you will receive a take-home exercise for the following class, which will be graded by one of your peers. Monday, the 9 th Thanksgiving no class Procedural Aspects 7. Thu, 12 th Peer grading of the take home exercise. Classification of Offences Readings: 74-79. NOTE: You will need the criminal code for the class. 8. Mon, 16 th Presumption of Innocence Readings: 81-98 9. Thu, Oct 19 Presumption of Innocence (con t). Ethical Obligations and Cultural Responsibility Readings: 98 105; 128-130; 156 158; The Wrongful Conviction of Donald Marshall (Excerpt on Brightspace); Excerpt of TRC report in Brightspace: 215 (Educating Lawyers); Rose Voyvodic, Lawyers Meet the Social Context: Understanding Cultural Competence (Excerpts on Brightspace); R v Fraser (Excerpts on Brightspace) NOTE: There is no lecture on Ethical Obligations. Please read the materials and come prepared to engage with them. 5
Elements of offences: Act Requirements NOTE: From now on, you need your criminal code every single class 10. Mon, Oct 23 What is Actus Reus? Commission Readings: 169 184; 188-195. NOTE: There will be a take home exercise that a peer will grade. 11. Thu, Oct 26 Peer grading. Omission & the Legal Duty to Act Readings: 251-258, 266-273 12. Mon, Oct 30 - Further requirements: Voluntariness & Lack of Consent Readings: 291-294; 205-218; 674-689. 13. Thu, Nov 2 Vitiating consent Readings: 227 238. NOTE: In class, we will watch an excerpt from a documentary made by the Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, followed by class discussion on the topic. Nov 6-Nov 10 Reading Week Mon, Nov 13 Remembrance Day no class 14. Thu, Nov 16: Further requirements: Causation Readings: 306-323. 15. Mon, Nov 20 Causation & Revision on Actus Reus Readings: 337 348 Elements of offences: Fault Requirements Subjective Fault-Based Offenses 16. Thu, Nov 23: Fault for Crimes: objective and subjective. Introduction to subjective fault at common law Readings: 349 357; 463 474. 17. Mon, Nov 27: Common Law Subjective Mens Rea 1: Intent and Knowledge Readings: 474-489. 18. Thu, Nov 30: Common Law Subjective Mens Rea 2: Recklessness and Wilful Blindness 6
19. Mon, Dec 4 Revision NOTE: A practice exam will be made available on Brightspace. Please attempt to solve the exam and bring your questions to class. Alternatively, if you are shy, feel free to e-mail the questions ahead, and I will answer them (anonymously) in class. END OF TERM Winter term: 1. Tue, Jan 9: Subjective Mens Rea Required by Charter: Murder I Readings: 421 443. 2. Thu, Jan 11 Subjective Mens Rea Required by Charter: Murder II Readings: 443 462. Objective Fault-Based Offenses 3. Tue, Jan 16 Objective Fault: Criminal Negligence Readings: 499-517. 4. Thu, Jan 18 Objective Fault: Marked departure test Readings: 517 541 5. Tue, Jan 23 Objective fault: Predicated Offences Readings: 542-559 Fault & The Law of Sexual Assault 6. Thu, Jan 25: Rape Laws in Context Readings: 575-580; 583-604 7. Tue, Jan 30: Sexual Assault I: Case Study R v. Barton Readings: R v Barton (excerpts on Brightspace). Also, please watch the 40-minute video of Emma Cunliffe posted online and come prepared to engage with Prof. Cunliffe on the matter, as she will be joining our class as a guest speaker. Guest speaker: Dr. Emma Cunliffe, Associate Professor, Allard School of Law, University of British Columbia 7
8. Thu, Feb 1 Sexual Assault II Readings: 606-612; 651-664, 691-693. Regulatory Offences 9. Tue, Feb 6: Regulatory Offences I Readings: 364 387 10. Thu, Feb 8: Regulatory Offences II Readings: 387 402 Defences 11. Tue, Feb 13 - Introduction to defences & mistake of fact Readings: 897-900, 699-705, 712-721 12. Thu, Feb 15 - Mistake of Law Readings: 724-741; 748-752; R v. Simpson (on Brightspace) Monday 19 Friday 23 Reading Week 13. Tue, Feb 27 Mental Disorder Readings: 769-785 14. Thu, Mar 1 Automatism I Readings: 785-817 15. Tue, Mar 6 Automatism II Readings: 817 847 16. Thu, Mar 8 Intoxication Readings: 851-858; 873-892 17. Tue, Mar 13 Self-defense Readings: 901-918, R v Levy (on Brightspace) 8
18. Thu, Mar 15 Battered Women Syndrome Readings: Defending Battered Women, By Elizabeth Sheehy, Introduction (available on Brightspace and book on reserve in the law library) Guest speaker: TBA 19. Tue, Mar 20 Necessity & Duress Readings: 929-947 20. Thu, Mar 22 Duress Readings: 951-985 21. Tue, Mar 27 - Partial Defences I: Provocation Readings: 987 1016 22. Thu, Mar 29 - Partial Defences II & Revision on Defences Readings: 1016-1022; Look over the two review problems page 1021-1022; we will solve them together in class. Other Issues 23. Tue, Apr 3 Secondary Liability Readings: 1045 1074 24. Thu, Apr 5 Attempts Readings: 1077 1096, 1115 1118 25. Tue Apr 10 Revision Note: You will receive a practice exam in advance on Brightspace. Please attempt to solve it and bring your questions on it, or any other questions to class. Alternatively, you may send your questions to me in advance, and I will answer them anonymously in class. 9