ANNEX TO THE REPORT APPENDIX 1: DETAILS OF ASSMBLY MEMBER INTERVIEWEES APPENDIX 2: LOCAL GOVERNMENT SAMPLE AND STATISTICS APPENDIX 3: CONFERENCE PROGRAMMES APPENDIX 4: DISSEMINATION CONFERENCE PROGRAMME APPENDIX 5: MEDIA COVERAGE FO DISSEMINATION CONFERENCE APPENDIX 6: TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR EDITED BOOK
APPENDIX 1: DETAILS OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER INTERVIEWEES Table 1: Assembly Member interviewees Women Men Total Conservative 0 3 3 8 6 14 Liberal Democrat 2 1 3 Plaid Cymru 4 5 9 Independent 1 1 2 Total 15 16 31 Table 2: Number of AMs who had also been MPs Women Men Total Conservative 0 0 0 0 2 2 Liberal Democrat 0 0 0 Plaid Cymru 0 2 2 Independent 0 0 0 Total 0 4 4 Table 3: Number of AMs who had also been local councillors Women Men Total Conservative 0 2 2 6 2 8 Liberal Democrat 1 1 2 Plaid Cymru 3 1 4 Independent 0 0 0 Total 10 6 16 Table 4: Gender and party composition of National Assembly at time of interviewing (2006-7) Women Men Total Conservative 2 9 11 19 10 29 Liberal Democrat 3 3 6 Plaid Cymru 6 6 12 Independent 1 1 2 Total 31 29 60
APPENDIX 2: LOCAL GOVERNMENT SAMPLE AND STATISTICS Table 1: Details of councillor interviewees Carmarthenshire Merthyr Tydfil Swansea All Women Men Women Men Women Men Total Conservative 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 1 2 1 1 8 Liberal Democrat 1 0 0 0 2 1 4 Plaid Cymru 1 0 0 0 1 0 2 Independent 0 1 0 2 0 1 4 Other 0 1 0 2 0 0 3 Total 4 3 1 6 4 3 21
Table 2: Gender breakdown of local government in Wales, 2006 Local authority Men Women Total % women Chief Executive Leader Blaenau Gwent 38 4 42 9.5 M M Bridgend 38 16 54 29.6 M F Lib Dem/Con/Ind coalition Caerphilly 55 17 72 (+ 1 vac) 23.6 M M Cardiff City Council 47 28 75 37.3 M M Lib Dem minority administration Carmarthernshire 62 12 74 16.2 M F Independent/ coalition Ceredigion 38 4 42 9.5 M M Ind/Lib Dem/ coalition Conwy 43 15 58 (+ 1 vac) 25.9 M M No over all control Denbighshire 37 10 47 21.3 M F No over all control Flintshire 57 13 70 18.6 M M Gwynedd 59 15 74 (+ 1 vac) 20.3 M M Plaid Cymru Isle of Anglesey 38 2 40 5 M M No over all control Merthyr Tydfil 32 1 33 3 M M All party coalition Monmouthshire 33 10 43 23.3 M M Conservative Neath Port Talbot 50 13 63 (+ 1 vac) 20.6 M M Newport 41 8 49 (+ 1 vac) 18 M M Pembrokeshire 49 11 60 18.3 M M Independent Powys 53 20 73 27.4 M M Independent Rhondda Cynon Taf 57 18 75 24 M M Swansea 51 21 72 29.2 M M No over all control Torfaen 29 15 44 34.1 F M Vale of Glamorgan 33 14 47 29.8 M M Conservative Wrexham 46 6 52 11.5 F M No over all control Total 986 273 1259 (+5 vac) 21.7% 2F (9%) 3F (14%) Source: Balsom, D. The Wales Yearbook 2006, Aberystwyth: FBA Publications
APPENDIX 3: CONFERENCE PROGRAMMES THE CENTRE FOR THE STUDY OF WOMEN AND GENDER AND WARWICK BUSINESS SCHOOL Engendering Politics and Devolution FEBRUARY 15 2008 Venue: Library LIB 1 (ground floor of the library building) 9.30-10:00 Registration and refreshments 10.00 Introduction, Nickie Charles (University of Warwick) Session 1: Organisational cultures in legislative assemblies 10:15 The organisational culture of the Scottish Parliament, Fiona Mackay (University of Edinburgh) 10.50 Challenging masculinist political cultures? Experiences of devolved government in Wales, Stephanie Jones (Swansea University), Charlotte Davies (Swansea University) and Nickie Charles (University of Warwick) 11:25 Engendering democracy in Northern Ireland, Bronagh Hinds (Queens University Belfast) 12.00 Discussant, Sarah Childs (University of Bristol) 12.30 Questions and discussion 13.00-13:55 Lunch Session 2: Gender Budgeting 14:00 What is gender budgeting? Simona Scarparo and Rihab Khalifa (Warwick Business School, University of Warwick) 14:15 Gender Budgeting in Wales - the difference devolution has made Adele Baumgardt (Gender Budgeting Group Wales) 14:45 Using Political Change to Promote Gender Sensitive Budgeting in Scotland: The Experience of the Scottish Women s Budget Group Ailsa McKay (Gender Budgeting Group Scotland) 15:15 'A different approach to influencing: promoting gender budgeting at national level, Louise Tilbury and Clare Cochrane (Gender Budgeting Group,Westminster) 15:45 Tea 16:00 17.00 Questions and discussion
9.30-10:00 Registration and refreshments 10.00 Introduction ENGENDERING POLICY & DEVOLUTION DAY CONFERENCE FRIDAY 21st NOVEMBER 2008 Session 1: 10:15 13:00 Engendering Policy: an Overview 10:15 Alexandra Dobrowolsky (St Mary s University, Nova Scotia) Federalism, Devolution & Women: Democratic Debates and Dilemmas 10.50 Paul Chaney (Cardiff University, Wales) The Welsh Assembly Government and Legislative Duty in the Promotion of Equal Opportunities 11:25 Margaret Ward (Director of the Women s Resource and Development Agency, Belfast) Gender neutrality or gender equality? Working for a gender equality strategy in Northern Ireland 12.00 Discussant: Shirin Rai (University of Warwick) 12.30 Questions and discussion 13.00-13:55 LUNCH Session 2: 14:00 16:30 Policy Case Study: Domestic Violence 14:00 Nickie Charles (University of Warwick) and Fiona Mackay (University of Edinburgh) Developing domestic abuse strategies in devolved legislatures: Scotland and Wales compared 14:30 Marsha Scott (European Women s Lobby Observatory on Violence Against Women) "Yours, mine and ours": EU and UK violence against women work since devolution 15:00 Brita Fernandez- Schmidt (Women s National Commission) The Women s National Commission women s voices to government 15:30 Discussant: Chris Harrison (SWELL, University of Warwick) 16:00 TEA 16:15 Questions and discussion 17.00 CLOSE
APPENDIX 4: DISSEMINATION CONFERENCE PROGRAMME Beth mae r Cynulliad Cenedlaethol yn ei wneud dros fenywod? What is the National Assembly doing for women? Cyrhaeddodd cynrychiolaeth menywod lefelau hanesyddol yng Nghynulliad Cenedlaethol Cymru. Holodd ymchwil sydd newydd ei chwblhau i r effeithiau gafodd hyn ynghyd â datganoli ar fywydau menywod ac mae r gynhadledd hon yn cyflwyno ei chanlyniadau. Mae n ystyried cwestiynau megis: Sut brofiad yw hi i fod yn fenyw mewn gwleidyddiaeth? Pa gamau a gafwyd tuag at gyflogau cyfartal i fenywod? Beth a wneir yngl n â thrais yn erbyn menywod? Sut mae Cymru n cymharu â r Alban a Gogledd Iwerddon? Daw siaradwyr o r llywodraeth, y trydydd sector a phrifysgolion ac maent yn rhannu eu profiadau wrth ystyried dyfodol menywod yng Nghymru. Women have achieved historic levels of political representation in the National Assembly for Wales. Recently completed research has investigated the effects of this and of devolution on women s lives and this conference presents its findings. It addresses questions such as: What is it like to be a woman in politics? What progress has been made towards equal pay for women? What is being done about violence against women? How does Wales compare with Scotland and Northern Ireland? Speakers are drawn from government, the third sector and the university sector and pool their experiences to explore the future for women in Wales. RHAGLEN Y GYNHADLEDD CONFERENCE PROGRAMME Stadiwm Liberty, Abertawe 30/01/2009 Liberty Stadium, Swansea 09.30 10.00 Te a choffi, Cofrestru / Tea and coffee, Registration 10.00 10.40 Croeso / Welcome: Charlotte Davies (Prifysgol Abertawe / Swansea University) Menywod mewn Gwleidyddiaeth Women in Politics Panelwyr / Panelists: Siân James AS / MP Helen Mary Jones AC / AM Meryl Gravell Arweinydd Cyngor Sir Gaerfyrddin / Leader of Carmarthenshire County Council Cadeirydd / Chair: Stephanie Jones (Prifysgol Abertawe / Swansea University) 10.40 11.00 Te a choffi / Tea and coffee 11.00 12.00 Pa wahaniaeth ydy cynrychiolwyr gwleidyddol benywaidd yn ei wneud? What difference do women political representatives make? Panelwyr / Panelists: Nickie Charles (Prifysgol Warwick / University of Warwick) Bronagh Hinds (Gogledd Iwerddon / Northern Ireland) Ailsa McKay (Prifysgol Glasgow Caledonian University) Cadeirydd / Chair: Vivienne Walters (Prifysgol Abertawe / Swansea University)
12.00 13.00 Cinio / Lunch 13.00 14.00 Y trydydd sector a Chynulliad Cenedlaethol Cymru The third sector and the National Assembly for Wales Panelwyr / Panelists: Liz Morgan Stonewall Cymru Cathy Owens Amnest Rhyngwladol Cymru / Amnesty International Wales Lynne Sanders Cymorth i Fenywod / Welsh Women s Aid Cadeirydd / Chair: Sara Reid Swyddfa Comisiynydd Plant Cymru / Office of the Children s Commissioner Wales 14.00 14.30 Tê a choffi / Tea and coffee 14.30 15.30 Datganoli a chyfiawnder cymdeithasol i fenywod Equality and social justice for women Panelwyr / Panelists: Kate Bennett Y Comisiwn Cydraddoldeb a Hawliau Dynol yng Nghymru / The Equality and Human Rights Commission in Wales Bev Pold Chwarae Teg Siân Wiblin TUC Cymru / Wales TUC Cadeirydd / Chair: Terry Rees (Prifysgol Caerdydd / Cardiff University) RHYWEDD A PHROSESAU GWLEIDYDDOL YNG NGHYD-DESTUN DATGANOLI Gender and Political Processes in the Context of Devolution SWANSEA UNIVERSITY PRIFYSGOL ABERTAWE
Conference Delegates (total 75) Academic 30% Political/Governmental 15% Third Sector 49% Ninety three per cent of those returning evaluation forms rated the event as very interesting or interesting, with nearly all comments very positive ( A very informative, educative and empowering session. )
APPENDIX 5: MEDIA COVERAGE OF DISSEMINATION CONFERENCE Interview with one of the grant holders on BBC Radio Wales, 30/1/09 BBC News 30/1/09, Women transform Welsh politics http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/7859373.stm South Wales Argus News 29/1/09, Assembly helped by gender balance http://www.southwalesargus.co.uk/news/4086678.assembly_helped_by_gender_ balance/ Evening Leader (Flintshire) 2/2/09 Women AMs have transformed the political scene in Wales by Michael Youds and Matt Sims South Wales Evening Post 19/2/09 Women at the heart of change by Alex Brown
APPENDIX 6: TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR EDITED BOOK GENDER AND SOCIAL JUSTICE IN WALES Editors Nickie Charles (University of Warwick) Charlotte Aull Davies (Swansea University) Contents Part I: Gender, political representation and social justice 1. Setting the scene: devolution, gender politics and social justice Nickie Charles 2. Gender mainstreaming and public policy in post-devolution Wales Paul Chaney 3. Gender and political representation: views from the grassroots Sandra Betts Part II: Social justice for women? 4. Devolution, gender and childcare: a distinctive agenda for Wales? Wendy Ball 5. Developing a domestic abuse strategy Nickie Charles and Stephanie Jones 6. Mainstreaming Across the Equality Dimensions: Policy on Sexual Orientation in Wales Alison Parken 7. Making the world new for them: an exploration of women in power in the post-devolution Welsh education system Sue Sanders 8. Gendering housing policy Susan Hutson 9 The material resources of older women in Wales and WAG policy responses Vanessa Burholt 10. Devolution and Welsh language policy: a gender dimension? Charlotte Aull Davies Concluding comments 11. The future Nickie Charles and Charlotte Aull Davies