FLORIDA ELECTIONS COMMISSION ** AGENDA** (Can be given to the public) Department of Business and Professional Regulations 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399 May 20, 2015 Note: Cases shown on this agenda may be heard in a different order. Cases will not be heard before the stated time, but will be heard as soon as possible; therefore, it is imperative that you arrive promptly and be prepared to be at the meeting for several hours until your case is heard. Untimed items may be heard at any time but will not be heard prior to on May 20, 2015. Lunch will be taken at the appropriate time. SESSION Time Agenda Item Commissioners Roll Call Brian M. Seymour, Vice Chairman Alia Faraj-Johnson Sean S. Hall Patricia Hollarn Dr. Thomas Scott Approval of February 24-25, 2015 Meeting Minutes Ed Tellechea, Commission Counsel Commissioners Present Tim Holladay, Chairman Mack Bernard Alia Faraj-Johnson Patricia Hollarn Barbra A. Stern May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 1 of 17
Appeal of Matching Funds Perry E. Thurston Jr. FEC 15-007 (DM/AMT) May 20, 2015 SESSION Review of Appeal of Denial of Matching Funds (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Perry E. Thurston Jr. Attorney: Mark Herron Attending: Yes Time Automatic Fines Judy Davis FEC 14-301 (BW/SC) FEC 14-302 (BW/SC) FEC 14-303 (BW/SC) Attorney: Adam S. Tanenbaum Attending: Yes ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Judy Davis Local Joseph S. Geller FEC 14-383 (BW/SC) (F) City of Riviera Beach (A) Joseph S. Geller May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 2 of 17
Automatic Fines Floridians for Opportunity FEC 14-439 (CO/SC) SESSION ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Floridians for Opportunity Dipa Shah FEC 14-448 (BW/SC) (A) Dipa Shah Local Geraldine F. Thompson FEC 14-450 (BW/SC) (F) Hillsborough County SOE (A) Geraldine F. Thompson Citizen Coalition PAC FEC 14-452 (CO/SC) FEC 15-036 (CO/SC) FEC 15-037 (CO/SC) (A) Citizen Coalition PAC May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 3 of 17
Automatic Fines Miriam Steinberg FEC 14-455 (BW/SC) SESSION ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Miriam Steinberg Attorney: Michael Steinberg Richard Carroll FEC 14-456 (BW/SC) (A) Richard Carroll Local Kathryn Dukes FEC 14-459 (BW/SC) (F) Pasco County SOE (A) Kathryn Dukes Local Mia L. Jones FEC 14-499 (BW/SC) (F) Hillsborough County SOE (A) Mia L. Jones Yvonne Minus FEC 14-500 (BW/SC) (A) Yvonne Minus Local (F) City of Melbourne May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 4 of 17
Automatic Fines Donna M. Goerner FEC 15-035 (BW/SC) SESSION ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Donna M. Goerner Sunshine Conservatives FEC 15-067 (CO/SC) (A) Sunshine Conservatives Attorney: Richard E. Coates Attending: Yes Palm Beach Gardens Needs Term Limits FEC 15-074 (CO/SC) FEC 15-075 (CO/SC) FEC 15-076 (CO/SC) FEC 15-077 (CO/SC) FEC 15-081 (CO/SC) FEC 15-082 (CO/SC) (A) Palm Beach Gardens Needs Term Limits (F) City of Palm Beach Gardens Local FEC 15-083 (CO/SC) FEC 15-087 (CO/SC) FEC 15-090 (CO/SC) FEC 15-091 (CO/SC) FEC 15-092 (CO/SC) May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 5 of 17
Automatic Fines Dawn S. Pardo FEC 15-146 (BW/SC) SESSION ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Dawn S. Pardo Local Jose Miguel Soto FEC 15-148 (BW/SC) (F) City of Riviera Beach (A) Jose Miguel Soto Local Levoyd L. Williams FEC 15-149 (BW/SC) (F) Miami-Dade County SOE (A) Levoyd L. Williams Florida Nurse Practitioner PAC FEC 15-212 (CO/SC) FEC 15-299 (CO/SC) (A) Florida Nurse Practitioner PAC May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 6 of 17
Automatic Fines Frank Artiles FEC 15-232 (BW/SC) SESSION ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Frank Artiles Carlos Trujillo FEC 15-233 (BW/SC) (A) Carlos Trujillo Vulcan Materials Company Florida Employees Political Action Committee FEC 15-243 (CO/SC) (A) Vulcan Materials Company Florida Employees Political Action Committee Derek Hankerson FEC 15-244 (BW/SC) (A) Derek Hankerson May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 7 of 17
Time Automatic Fines Floridians for Better Government PC FEC 15-293 (CO/SC) Pre-Probable Cause Consent Agreement Virginia M. Gianakos FEC 14-406 (HH/SC) SESSION ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (A) Appellant (F) Filing Officer (A) Floridians for Better Government PC Attorney: Mark Herron Attending: Yes ***Respondent has waived confidentiality. Consent Order (R) Virginia M. Gianakos (C) Gary Scruggs May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 8 of 17
Post-Probable Cause Consent Agreement Citizens for a Reality Check FEC 13-190 (HH/JW) SESSION Consent Order ***Note cases you would like to discuss individually*** (R) Citizens for a Reality Check Attorney: Steven A. Geller Jay Wheeler FEC 14-006 (HH/EL) Richard Charbonneau FEC 14-098 (MW/SC) John Paul Arcia FEC 14-298 (CO/JW) Consent Order Consent Order Consent Order (C) Juan-Carlos Planas (R) Jay Wheeler Attorney: Ben Kuehne and Mark Herron (C) Keith Thompson (R) Richard Charbonneau (C) Terry Tears (R) John Paul Arcia Note: This case is scheduled as an informal hearing in the alternative See also hard copy supplemental materials Note: This case is scheduled as an informal hearing in the alternative Awaiting $$ See also hard copy supplemental materials May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 9 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Rodney W. Williams FEC 13-083 (TA/JW) SESSION (R) Rodney W. Williams Marke Eugene Hall FEC 13-124 (TA/JW) (C) Putnam County SOE (R) Marke Eugene Hall Nina Howard FEC 13-159 (CO/EL) (C) Putnam County SOE (R) Nina Howard James A. Cueva FEC 13-197 (KS/SC) (R) James A. Cueva May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 10 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Alejandro Manuel Walters FEC 13-215 (CO/EL) SESSION (R) Alejandro Manuel Walters Eric L. Haynes FEC 13-232 (HH/EL) (R) Eric L. Haynes Attorney: Gregory Durden Robert F. Small FEC 13-322 (CO/JW) (C) Michael Mee (R) Robert F. Small Cynthia Rena Harris FEC 13-324 (HH/JW) (C) Arthur Penny (R) Cynthia Rena Harris (C) Daisy W. Lynum May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 11 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Joe Wesley Norris FEC 14-004 (TA/SC) SESSION (R) Joe Wesley Norris Jay Wheeler FEC 14-006 (HH/EL) Pamela A. White FEC 14-049 (TA/JW) (C) Justin M. Burnham (R) Jay Wheeler Attorney: Ben Kuehne and Mark Herron (C) Keith Thompson (R) Pamela A. White Note: This case is noticed as a consent order hearing in the alternative. Jean R. Marcellus FEC 14-091 (MW/SC) (R) Jean R. Marcellus (C) Ruth Ogen May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 12 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Benjamin Pollara FEC 14-092 (CO/SC) SESSION (R) Benjamin Pollara Richard Charbonneau FEC 14-098 (MW/SC) Consent Order (R) Richard Charbonneau Note: This case is scheduled as a consent order in the alternative Lisa McDermott FEC 14-101 (KS/EL) FEC 14-102 (KS/EL) FEC 14-105 (KS/EL) (C) Terry Tears (R) Lisa McDermott Michael J. Dreikorn FEC 14-138 (HH/JW) (C) Terry Tears (R) Michael J. Dreikorn (C) Fidel Balan May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 13 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Citizens for Fair Employment Opportunities FEC 14-143 (TA/JW) SESSION (R) Citizens for Fair Employment Opportunities Equal Marriage Florida FEC 14-144 (TA/EL) FEC 14-286 (CO/EL) FEC 14-325 (CO/EL) Failure to Notify (R) Equal Marriage Florida Florida Faith Amendment.com FEC 14-145 (CO/EL) (R) Florida Faith Amendment.com Wenxia Raiti FEC 14-156 (MW/JW) FEC 14-185 (CO/JW) (R) Wenxia Raiti May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 14 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Christopher D. Warnig FEC 14-168 (TA/SC) SESSION (R) Christopher D. Warnig Kyle Alexander Bedran FEC 14-175 (TA/SC) Motion to Dismiss (C) Robert E. Jackson (R) Kyle Alexander Bedran Beth Reindl Madrigal FEC 14-184 (CO/SC) (R) Beth Reindl Madrigal Pets Voice FEC 14-238 (KS/SC) (R) Pets Voice (C) Juan-Carlos Planas May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 15 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Kathy Foster FEC 14-253 (KS/SC) SESSION (R) Kathy Foster Travis W. Pitts FEC 14-254 (CO/EL) FEC 14-328 (CO/SC) (C) Lisa Goldman (R) Travis W. Pitts Florida Society of Health- System Pharmacists PAC FEC 14-266 (CO/EL) FEC 14-287 (CO/EL) FEC 14-329 (CO/EL) (R) Florida Society of Health-System Pharmacists PAC Attorney: Lawrence A. Gonzalez Cedon Saintil Jr. FEC 14-273 (TA/JW) (R) Cedon Saintil Jr. (C) Norma Gordon May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 16 of 17
Informal 120.57(2), F.S. Ryan Jack Singleton FEC 14-322 (KS/SC) SESSION (R) Ryan Jack Singleton Clarence Riley FEC 14-324 (TA/EL) (R) Clarence Riley Untimed Lunch SESSION May 20, 2015 Public Agenda: 5/12/2015 4:45 PM Page 17 of 17