Employment in the tourism industries from the perspective of the ILO Valeria Nesterenko, International Labour Organisation
Overview Labour-intensive and fast growing sector not influenced by the crisis A source of employment for youth, women and migrants (as very often little or no formal training needed) Can considerablycontributeto social and economicdevelopmentand to poverty reduction Stimulatethe creationand growthof new enterprisesand developmentof the infrastructure and quality of services Politically a very important industry, but the working conditions very often are precariousand shouldbeimproved(seasonality, long workinghours, low wages, low union density, no training provided, etc)
ILO measures(ilostat database): Employment (paid employment + self-employment) from LFS Data from establishment surveys are very limited (mainly wages and hours of work) Other topics covered by LFS include hours of work, unemployment, underemployment, etc) Proxy for tourism industries is considered to be hotels and restaurants sector Employed persons with single jobs in hotels and restaurants sector + multiple job-holders with main jobs in hotels and restaurants sector (IRTS 2008 Figure 7.1. ) Data availability quarterly and monthly (updated the third week of each month) and annually (latest data available for 2012)
Y2008_Q01 Y2008_Q02 Y2008_Q03 Y2008_Q04 Y2009_Q01 Y2009_Q02 Y2009_Q03 Y2009_Q04 Y2010_Q01 Y2010_Q02 Y2010_Q03 Y2010_Q04 Y2011_Q01 Y2011_Q02 Y2011_Q03 Y2011_Q04 Y2012_Q01 Y2012_Q02 Y2012_Q03 Y2012_Q04 Y2013_Q01 Y2013_Q02 10.5 10 9.5 9 8.5 8 7.5 7 6.5 6 5.5 5 % 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 Seasonalityisone of the characteristics of employmentin tourismsector, selectedcountries AVG Americas AVG Asia and the Pacific AVG Western and Central Europe AVG Eastern Europe and Central Asia Source: ILO calculations based on the data from National Statistical Offices
Sectorwasnot affected by the crisis, selectedcountries 10 9 8 7 6 % 5 4 3 2 1 AVG Americas AVG Asia and the Pacific AVG Western and Central Europe AVG Eastern Europe and Central Asia 0 Y2008_Q04 Y2009_Q04 Y2010_Q04 Y2011_Q04 Y2012_Q04 Source: ILO calculations based on the data from National Statistical Offices
Europe Shareof paidemploymentin total employmentin tourism sector in 2012, selected coutries % 100.0 90.0 80.0 70.0 60.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 100.0 90.0 80.0 70.0 60.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 Benin Guatemala Thailand Guinea Azerbaijan Ethiopia Peru El Salvador Mexico Malaysia Korea, Republic of Mongolia Argentina Panama Costa Rica Kazakhstan Egypt Singapore New Zealand Mauritius Kyrgyzstan Cuba Armenia Seychelles Hong Kong, China Greece Belgium Italy Portugal Turkey Serbia Spain Czech Republic Switzerland Austria France Croatia Slovenia Germany Cyprus Poland Hungary Sweden Netherlands Denmark Finland Ireland Macedonia, The Bulgaria United Kingdom Latvia Iceland Luxembourg Slovakia Estonia Malta Lithuania Liechtenstein Romania Norway Other countries % Source: ILO calculations based on the data from National Statistical Offices
Educational attainment, Europe Accommodation and Food Service Activities 2012 All industries 2012 13% 33% 0-2 3-4 5-6 31% 20% 0-2 3-4 5-6 54% 49% Is there an existing underemployment (or over-qualification)? NEED FOR SKILLS MISMATCH ANALYSIS Educational levels: 0-2 = Pre-primary, primary and lower secondary education; 3-4 = Upper secondary and post-secondary non-tertiary education; 5-6 = First and second stage of tertiary education. Source: ILO calculations based on the data from Eurostat
Issue of high hoursof workand lowwagesin the hotelsand restaurants sector in selected countries, latest data available Hotels and restaurants AVG in the economy Higher hours of work in hotels and restaurants, % Lower wages in hotels and restaurants, % Macau 48 47 2.1-21.3 Paraguay 51.3 45.2 13.5-5.5 Egypt 52.3 45.8 14.2-47.6 Greece 47.4 41.2 15.0-26.3 Indonesia 46.9 40.1 17.0-17.0 Philippines 48.5 40.6 19.5-41.8 Turkey 59.4 48.1 23.5-18.5 Sri Lanka 54 41.2 31.1-1.8 Armenia 52 36 44.4-34.0 Source: ILO calculations based on the data from National Statistical Offices
YOUTH EMPLOYMENT IN HOTELS AND RESTAURANTS SECTOR AS A PERCENTAGE OF TOTAL EMPLOYMENT IN HOTELS AND RESTAURANTS SECTOR, 2012 60.0 50.0 48.5 40.0 30.0 20.0 20.0 10.0 9.0 0.0 Source: ILO calculations based on the data from Eurostat
CORRELATION: UNEMPLOYMENT AND YOUTH EMPLOYMENT IN HOTELS AND RESTAURANTS SECTOR Source: ILO calculations based on the data from Eurostat
Unemployed persons previosly employed in hotels and restaurants sector 120 Share in total unemployment was higher in 2012 2008 = 2012 Share in total unemployment waslower in 2012 20 18 100 16 14 80 12 Thousands 60 40 20 10 8 % 6 4 2 0 Cyprus Macau, China Israel Iceland Bulgaria Greece Denmark Germany Finland Russian Federation Portugal Ireland Croatia Hungary Spain if share is higher in 2012 and the value is higher in 2012, then unemployment by previous sector (hotels and restaurants) is increasing more rapidly than general unemployment if share is lower in 2012 and the value is lower in 2012, then unemployment by previous sector (hotels and restaurants) is decreasing more rapidly than general level of unemployment if share is higher in 2012 and the value is lower in 2012, then general level of unemployment is decreasing more rapidly than unemploymentby previous sector (hotels and restaurants) if share is lower in 2012 and the value is higher in 2012, then general level of unemployment is increasing more rapidly than unemployment by previous sector (hotels and restaurants) if share is equal and the value is higher, then the levels of unemployment by previous sector (hotels and restaurants) is increasing in line with general unemployment if share is equal and the value is lower, then the level of unemployment by previous sector (hotels and restaurants) is decreasing in line with general unemployment Estonia Austria Slovenia value 2012 value 2008 % 2012 % 2008 United Kingdom Malta Romania Poland Netherlands France Moldova, Slovakia Latvia Luxembourg Lithuania Italy Czech Republic 0
Decent Work A four pillar approach
Topicsfor future development Decent work indicators for tourism industries Jobs and persons employed in tourism industries Gender aspect Youth Skills mismatch in tourism industries Establishment surveys on number and quality of jobs Persons with secondary jobs in tourism industries Occupations within the industry Tourism cooperatives Etc.
Thankyoufor attention! For additional information please contact: Wolfgang Weinz(weinz@ilo.org) Valeria Nesterenko(nesterenko@ilo.org) And refer to: «Toolkit on Poverty Reduction through Tourism»