China s Economic Reform Douglas J. Young January, 2010
Main Point Good Government Policy is crucial for Economic Development
Ancient China Domesticated Rice and Millet (ca. 8,000 BC) Pioneered Irrigation, Animal Fertilizers, Crop Rotation Invented Cast Iron Moldboard Plow Invented Printing and Paper Invented Compass, Gunpowder Invented Stern Post Rudder
7 th 14 th Century Dominant Civilization of East Asia Culture spread to Japan, Korea, Tibet, Vietnam Standard of Living = to Europe
Ships: Zheng He and Columbus
But: No Enlightenment China Closed Itself Off from Western Ideas and Technology circa
Corrupt, Ineffective, Feudal Regime Domestic Insurrections Dominated by Technologically Superior Western Powers 19 th Century
20 th Century: First Half Last Emperor Falls 1911 Civil War: Nationalists v. Communists Occupation by Japan 1932-45 1949: Communists Win; Nationalists Flee to Taiwan
Initial Communist Policy Land Redistribution Literacy Campaign Barefoot Doctors
Survival to Age 5
Heavy Industry State Owned Enterprises Expanded Rapidly Large Collective Farms Central Planning
Central Planning (2) State Assigned People to Jobs State Fixed Wages and Prices Consumption of Food, Clothing, etc. Rationed State Owned all Housing => Few Economic Choices
Central Planning (3) Rewards Based on Meeting (Exceeding) Production Quotas Little Reward for Innovation or Quality Improvement
The 100 Flowers Campaign Mao Feared that Communist Party Members were Losing Revolutionary Fervor; Becoming Bureaucrats Mao Encouraged Criticism of the Party and its Policies Mao Purged his Critics Few Criticized Mao Again
Great Leap Forward (1958) "Take steel as the key link, leap forward in all fields. Millions of Peasants and City Workers Made Steel in Backyard Furnaces Results Steel Production > England Massive Economic Dislocation Denude Hillsides of Trees, Burn Furniture, Doors for Fuel Melt Down (Steel) Cooking Pots & Ag Implements to Make (Steel) Quota
People s Communes All Land & Equipment Owned by Collectives Massive Planting of Grains 1958: Huge Wheat Crop Waste: Unharvested (No Labor) No Storage/Transport Report to Mao: Everything is Going Well
Famine: 1958-61 Adverse Weather Government Required Communes to Provide Grain to the Cities 30 Million People Starved to Death in Rural Areas China Continued to Export Grain, as Mao Sought to Maintain Face
Life Expectancy: China 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 WDI, 2003 1960 1980 2000
Amartya Sen Nobel Laureate in Economics no substantial famine has ever occurred in any independent and democratic country with a relatively free press it is precisely this lack of challenge that allowed the deeply defective policies to continue even though they were killing millions each year. Democracy as a Universal Value, J. of Democracy, 1999
The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution: 1966-76 "Shatter the old world / Establish a new world." Red art from the early Cultural Revolution. A worker (or Red Guard) crushes the crucifix, Buddha and classical Chinese texts with his hammer; 1967
Cultural Revolution 1966-76 Mao s Power Threatened by Great Leap Backward Closed Schools; Sent Teachers to Countryside to Learn from Peasants Unleashed Youth: Red Brigades Social Chaos: 500,000 Died Near Economic Collapse
End of An Era Mao Dies: 1976 Gang of Four Tried for Crimes Deng Xiaoping New Leader Visits Poor Taiwan, HK Reform and Opening
Real GDP/Capita 1870 2004 Growth Germany $2,215 $28,160 1.9% Japan $1,053 $29,531 2.5% United Kingdom $4,447 $30,842 1.4% United States $3,828 $39,618 1.7% 1977 2004 Growth China $728 $5,495 7.8%
China s Progress 1985 2001/2002 Housing (m 2 /capita) 10.0 22.8 Motorcycles/100hh s 0.95 28 Cars/100hh s (urban) 0.2 (1995) 0.9 TV sets/hh (urban) 0.2 1.3 Univ. students/1000 pop 1.6 7.0
China s Growth Since 1978 Income/Capita Increased 6 Fold World s 2 nd Largest Economy (PPP) 4 th Largest Trading Nation (Exports) Largest Recipient of FDI in the Developing World Never Before in History Have So Many Millions of People Been Lifted Out of Poverty in Such a Short Time
Pinkovskiy and Sala-i-Martin (2009)
Explaining China s Growth 1. High Saving and Investment (Harrod-Domar Model) China s saving rate 40% of income US saving rate 20% of (large) income But: China had mobilized saving during the 1950s, without achieving dramatic growth: Inefficient Invest
Explaining China s Growth 2. Structural Change (Lewis Model) Massive migration to cities, development of manufacturing, while traditional ag still exists in rural areas
Explaining China s Growth 3. International Dependence? Dominated by US/Europe in 19 th Cent Occupied by Japan from 1932-45 But China s experience in 1950s-1960s illustrates failure of SOEs, central planning, and autarky
Explaining China s Growth 4. Neoclassical Counterrevolution: Free Markets? Sort of, but definitely not exactly China currently ranks 82 out of 141 countries in Economic Freedom In 1997 China received a grade of F for Economic (un)freedom http://www.freetheworld.com/index.html
Household Responsibility System Farmers allocated individual plots of land to work (but not ownership) Farmers decide what, how to plant Sell quota to state; keep/sell the rest => Incentives to increase output and reduce costs Output and Rural incomes increased Generated surplus (> subsistence) to finance Investment
Township & Village Enterprises Local Governments/Cooperatives Produce for Market Local Decision-Making Local Finance Keep (Most of) the Profits Before: State Takes All Profits After: State Taxes Profits
Special Economic Zones Encourage Foreign Investment Capital Inflows Technology Knowledge of Rest of World (Chinese Diaspora) Encourage Production for Export Contrast with Autarky
It s Glorious to be Rich
Lessons Saving, Investment, and Technology are Important: Harrod-Domar Economic Institutions Create Incentives (or Disincentives) for: Savings, Investment, and Innovation Work, Output, Productivity Efficient Resource Utilization
Lessons - II China s Development is Founded on: Gov t Policy to Increase Health and Literacy Market Institutions (Incentives) Stable Political & Legal Framework Various Public-Private Combinations Deng: Black Cat White Cat
Drying Wheat
China is Still a Developing Country Lower K/L than West Lower Education than West => China has Comparative Advantage in Products that Intensively Utilize Low-Skill Labor (e.g. Textiles, Plastic Cups)
China s Growth Will Slow as Western Income Levels are Approached Currently Catching Up in Capital, Technology, Education Grown so Fast because: So Poor to Begin With Policies were so Bad To China s Credit: Many still Stagnate
Is China an Economic Threat to the US? Is Germany a Threat? Most of the Benefits and Costs of Development Are Domestic Increases in Chinese Productivity Mainly Benefit China Increases in Chinese Productivity do NOT Make US any Less Productive
Secondary Impacts Chinese Export Inexpensive Goods Benefit US Consumers Harm US Competitors Net Benefit to US Chinese Compete for Raw Materials Chinese Supply Capital Inflows Chinese Develop New Technology?