City of Chattanooga, TN. v. Mark Thomas Robards Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Stephen M. Bevil Judge Charles D. Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Susano E2003-01340-SC-R11-CV A4022 & A4023 Affirmed and Bobby MacBryan Green v. Johnson City Regional Planning Washington County Chancery Court Chancellor G. Richard Johnson Judge David Michael Swiney Civil Denying Petition to Rehear Rule 11 Commision 34902 E2003-02509-SC-R11-CV Gibraltar Taft Highway Limited Partnership, through Hamilton County Chancery Chancellor Howell N. Judge Charles D. Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 its general partner The Raines Group, Inc. vs. The Court Peoples Susano Town Of Walden and Its Board Of Aldermen E2003-02523-SC-R11-CV 02-1030 State of Tennessee v. George A. Johnson Sevier County Circuit Court Judge Rex H. Ogle Judge Alan E. Glenn Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 E2003-02881-SC-R11-CD 9359 Affirmed Matthew Lawson, by next friend, Shirley Lawson, and Sevier County Circuit Court Judge Ben W. Hooper, II Judge Charles D. Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Shirley Lawson, Individually v. Edgewater Hotels, Inc. Susano and Stokely Hospitality Properties, Inc. E2003-03093-SC-R11-CV 2000-594-I Affirmed in Part, Vacated in Part, and Calvin Sneed v. State of Tennessee Rhea County Circuit Court Judge J. Curtis Smith Judge David H. Welles Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 E2004-00051-SC-R11-PC 13385 Affirmed and 1
Laconia Lamar Bowers vs. State of Tennessee Knox County Criminal Court Judge Richard R. Judge Jerry Smith Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 Baumgartner E2004-00347-SC-R11-PC 74942 Affirmed State of Tennessee v. Robbie Fields Bradley County Circuit Court Judge Carroll L. Ross Judge Alan E. Glenn Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 E2004-00716-SC-R11-CD 00-267 Reversed and State of Tennessee v. AaronT. Binkley Knox County Criminal Court Judge Mary B. Leibowitz Judge J. C. McLin Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 E2004-00739-SC-R11-CD 78096 Affirmed Becky Bridges vs. Mickey Bridges Anderson County Chancery Chancellor William Everett Judge Sharon G. Lee Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Court Lantrip E2004-00879-SC-R11-CV 00CH0407 Affirmed and Charles Edward Overby v. State of Tennessee Bradley County Circuit Court Judge Carroll L. Ross Judge Norma McGee Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 Ogle E2004-00962-SC-R11-PC 01-225 Affirmed Frederick D. Rice v. State of Tennessee Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Stephen M. Bevil Judge David G. Hayes Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 E2004-01135-SC-R11-PC 243119 Jerry Britt v. State of Tennessee Hamblen County Circuit Court Judge James E. Beckner Judge Alan E. Glenn Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 E2004-01276-SC-R11-PC 97CR213 & 97CR207 2
State of Tennessee vs. Ricky Grover Aaron Davidson County Circuit Court Judge Walter C. Kurtz Judge Jerry Smith Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 M2002-02288-SC-R11-CD 99-D-2360 Opinion - Other Sodexho Management, Inc. v. Ruth E. Johnson Davidson County Chancery Chancellor Ellen H. Lyle Judge Frank Clement, Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Court Jr. M2003-00660-SC-R11-CV 98-3318-III Reversed and Phillip Russell Lewis, et al v. James Howard Bowen, et Rutherford County Circuit Court Judge Don R. Ash Judge Patricia J. Cottrell Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 al M2003-00985-SC-R11-CV 41585 Affirmed and Bowdoin Grayson Smith v. Ginger Lee Marenchin Smith Smith County Chancery Court Chancellor Charles K. Judge David Michael Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Smith Swiney M2003-01218-SC-R11-CV 5800 Opinion - Other Sylvester Young v. Bank One, N.A. Davidson County Circuit Court Hamilton V. Gayden, Jr. Hershcel P. Franks Civil Denying Petition to Rehear Rule 11 M2003-01359-SC-R11-CV 02GT10918 Affirmed In RE: S.C.H. Wilson County Juvenile Court Judge Robert P. Hamilton Judge Patricia J. Cottrell Juvenile Denying TRAP Rule 11 Daniel Wayne Briggs v. Erin Anne Johnson M2003-01382-SC-R11-JV 02JWC-057 Vacated and In Re: Estate of Curtis Marshall Selle, Deceased Maury County Chancery Court Judge Jim T. Hamilton Judge Herschel P. Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Patricia B. Selle v. Jacquelyn Teal Selle, administratrix Franks of the Estate of Curtis Marshall Selle, deceased M2003-01633-SC-R11-CV P-061-03 3
In the Matter of Estate of Lizzie Tomlin Daughrity Marshall County Chancery Chancellor J. B. Cox Judge Alan E. Highers Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Court M2003-02244-SC-R11-CV 12506 Reversed and Albert Bender v. Saletta Holloway Davidson County Chancery Chancellor Irvin H. Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Court Kilcrease, Jr. M2003-02318-SC-R11-CV 03-753-I Dorothy L. Davis v. J. Douglas Davis and Julie Ann Davidson County Probate Court Judge Frank Clement, Jr. Judge David R. Farmer Civil Denying Petition to Rehear Davis Griffing, Co-executors under the Last Will and Testament of J.D. Davis, deceased M2003-02614-SC-R11-CV 02P-859 Reversed and James David Alder vs. State of Tennessee Franklin County Circuit Court Judge Buddy D. Perry Judge Jerry Smith Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 M2003-02767-SC-R11-PC 12714 Affirmed Orlando Crenshaw vs. State of Tennessee Lawrence County Circuit Court Judge Stella L. Hargrove Judge Gary R. Wade Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 M2004-00045-SC-R11-PC 23646 Reversed and State of Tennessee vs. Freddie William Lewis Sumner County Criminal Court Judge Jane W. Wheatcraft Judge Jerry Smith Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 M2004-00210-SC-R11-CD 778-2003 State of Tennessee vs. Douglas V. Killins Montgomery County Circuit Judge Michael R. Jones Judge David H. Welles Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 Court 4
M2004-00341-SC-R11-CD 40200141 Affirmed Ali Alvdu Mohammad vs. State of Tennessee Davidson County Criminal Court Judge Cheryl A. Blackburn Judge Gary R. Wade Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 M2004-00493-SC-R11-PC 2002-B-935 Cecil Moss vs. State of Tennessee Montgomery County Circuit Judge Michael R. Jones Judge Robert W. Criminal: Habeas Corpus Denying TRAP Rule 11 Court Wedemeyer M2004-00787-SC-R11-HC 40400225 Kynaston L. Scott vs. State of Tennessee Davidson County Criminal Court Judge Seth W. Norman Judge John Everett Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 Williams M2004-00809-SC-R11-PC 2000-0-2256 Joe Clark Mitchell v. Corrections Corporation of Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Stella L. Hargrove Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 America, et al M2004-01048-SC-R11-CV 3937 Corey Harrison vs. Kevin Myers, Warden Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Jim T. Hamilton Judge Robert W. Criminal: Habeas Corpus Denying TRAP Rule 11 Wedemeyer M2004-01249-SC-R11-HC 13339 Affirmed & - CCA Rule 20 In the Matter of: Matthew Ranker Putnam County Circuit Court Judge John J. Maddux, Jr. Judge Frank Clement, Juvenile Denying TRAP Rule 11 State of Tennessee, Department of Human Services v. Jr. 5
Melissa Potts and Timothy Ranker M2004-01692-SC-R11-JV 03N0451 Affirmed and State of Tennessee Department of Children's Services Putnam County Juvenile Court Judge John P. Hudson Judge Frank Clement, Parental Termination Denying TRAP Rule 11 v. Melissa Potts and Timothy Ranker Jr. M2004-01976-SC-R11-PT 686-DCS Michael Brown vs. Kevin Myers, Warden Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Robert L. Jones Judge Thomas T. Criminal: Habeas Corpus Denying TRAP Rule 11 Woodall M2004-02001-SC-R11-HC 13469 Affirmed & - CCA Rule 20 Brian Cox, et al v. Harbhajan Singh Dhillon, et al Davidson County Chancery Chancellor Claudia Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Court Bonnyman M2004-02416-SC-R11-CV 04-76-I Robert Mitchell vs. State of Tennessee Williamson County Circuit Court Judge Donald P. Harris Criminal: Other Denying TRAP Rule 11 M2004-03050-SC-R11-CO J-86133 Michael Sims v. Brenda Williams White County Circuit Court Judge Sammie E. Benningfield, Jr. Civil Denying Rule 10 M2004-02532-SC-R11-CV 16073 Kaitlyn Calaway ex rel. Kathleen Calaway v. Jodi Schuker, M.D. U. S. District Court, Western Dist Rule 23 Accepted Certifcation accepted 1 M2004-02856-SC-R23-CQ 02-2715-B 1 (1) Does a minor child have a personal claim for medical expenses arising from an injury caused by the fault of another when the claim of the child s parent for such medical expenses is barred by a statute of limitation or repose? (2) Does a minor child who is injured have a personal claim for medical expenses accruing after the age of majority? (3) Is the three year statute of repose for medical malpractice in Tennessee Code Annotated section 29-26-116, which contains no exception for minority, tolled during a Plaintiff s minority? (4) Is a physician Defendant denied equal protection of the law wherein an exception to the statute of repose contained in Tennessee Code Annotated section 29-26-116 is created for minority and medical malpractice cases, while no similar exception exists in products liability and construction cases? 6
Tommy D. Lanius v. Nashville Electric Service Sumner Chancery Chancellor Tom E. Gray Rule 9 Granted of Nashville Electric M2005-00441-SC-R9-CV 2004C-96 Stephanie Dubois v. Radwan Haykal, M.D., Robert Shelby County Circuit Court Judge John R. McCarroll, Judge Alan E. Highers Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Sauter, M.D., and Walgreen Co., an Illinois Corporation Jr. W2003-01549-SC-R11-CV 92035-1 T.D. Reversed and R.L. Love v. American Federation of State, County and Shelby County Circuit Court Judge John R. McCarroll, Judge Holly M. Kirby Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Municipal Employees Local 1733 and Willie Joe Jr. Alexander W2003-01554-SC-R11-CV 300277-1 T.D. Affirmed in Part and Reversed in Part Mary Allene Story v. Malcolm Eugene Lanier Lake County Chancery Court Chancellor J. Steven Judge Alan E. Highers Civil Denying TRAP Rule 11 Stafford W2003-02194-SC-R11-CV 4703 Affirmed State of Tennessee vs Darius Jones Shelby County Criminal Court Judge John P. Colton, Jr. Judge Gary R. Wade Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 W2003-02225-SC-R11-CD 01-04380-4, 7-9; 01-04390-1 Affirmed in Part, in Part Anthony Lee Randaul vs State of Tennessee Dyer County Circuit Court Judge R. Lee Moore, Jr. Judge Joseph M. Tipton Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 W2003-02280-SC-R11-PC C01-382, C01-383 Affirmed State of Tennessee vs. Jimmy Albert Warren Tipton County Circuit Court Judge Joe H. Walker, III Judge Gary R. Wade Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 W2004-00107-SC-R11-CD 4697 Miko T. Burl vs State of Tennessee Shelby County Criminal Court Judge Bernie Weinman Judge Robert W. Criminal: Post-Conviction Denying TRAP Rule 11 Wedemeyer W2004-00327-SC-R11-PC P-27215 State of Tennessee vs Romelus Caraway Shelby County Criminal Court Judge Chris Craft Judge Robert W. Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 Wedemeyer W2004-00462-SC-R11-CD 03-01611 7
State of Tennessee vs Anthony Williamson Shelby County Criminal Court Judge Chris Craft Judge David H. Welles Criminal: Direct Denying TRAP Rule 11 W2004-01251-SC-R11-CD 00-13070 Richard Anthony v Tony Parker, Warden Lake County Circuit Court Judge R. Lee Moore, Jr. Judge Alan E. Glenn Criminal: Habeas Corpus Denying TRAP Rule 11 W2004-01443-SC-R11-HC 04-CR-8566 Affirmed & - CCA Rule 20 David Wayne Britt vs State of Tennessee Hardeman County Circuit Court Judge Jon K. Blackwood Judge Robert W. Criminal: Habeas Corpus Denying TRAP Rule 11 Wedemeyer W2004-01524-SC-R11-HC 5242 Affirmed 8