The European Elections The Public Opinion Context
Joe Twyman Head of Political & Social Research EMEA Jane Carn Director Qualitative Research
Fruitcakes, Loonies, Closest Racists & Winners? Europe, the European Elections and the rise of Ukip
Sticks & Stones Ukip is sort of a bunch of... fruit cakes and loonies and closet racists mostly David Cameron, 4 th April 06
Three key themes approaching the European Elections The rise of Ukip Britain s membership of the European Union Wider attitudes towards the EU 5
The rise of Ukip
The Rise of Ukip: The Westminster Context (04 13) Source: YouGov for BES Continuous Monitoring survey Sample: c1,000 British adults per month 25 Percentage Westminster Voting Intention 15 5 0 April 04 December 13-5
The Rise of Ukip: The Westminster Context (04-13) Source: YouGov Daily Polling for News UK Sample: c1,500 British adults per day 25 Percentage Westminster Voting Intention 15 5 0 R² = 0.71 3 rd Jan 12 9 th May 14 8
The Rise of Ukip: The Westminster Context (04 13) Source: House of Commons Library 25 Percentage Westminster MPs 15 5 0 April 04 May 14 9
The Rise of Ukip: the European Election Context European Election Result (May 09) Seats Conservative 28% 27 UKIP 17% 13 Labour 16% 13 Liberal Democrat 14% 11 Green 8% 2 BNP 6% 2 SNP / Plaid 3% 3
The Rise of Ukip: the European Election Context Source: YouGov fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,933 British adults European Election Result (May 09) European Election Voting Intention (May 14) Conservative 28% 23% UKIP 17% 31% Labour 16% 25% Liberal Democrat 14% 9% Green 8% 8% BNP 6% 1% SNP / Plaid 3% 3% 11
The Ukip vote: Winning here? Source: YouGov Daily Polling Fieldwork: 31 March 30 April 14 Sample: 8,894 British adults Voted Con in Aged 60+ C2DE South excl. London 40-59 Men North Midlands / Wales All Women London ABC 1 Voted Lib Dem in Voted Lab in Under 40 Scotland 13 15 15 24 24 26 34 33 32 31 30 30 29 36 42 0 5 15 25 30 35 40 45 Percentage Voting Ukip in 14 European Elections 12
Most important issues facing the country Source: YouGov for New UK Fieldwork: 7-8 April 14 Sample: 2,144 British adults The economy Immigration & Asylum Health Welfare benefits Housing Europe Education Pensions Crime The environment Tax Family life & childcare Transport Don t know None of these 1 2 3 7 18 17 15 14 12 11 28 34 51 57 0 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 Percentage of All Voters 13
Most important issues facing the country Source: YouGov for New UK Fieldwork: 7-8 April 14 Sample: 2,144 British adults The economy Immigration & Asylum Health Welfare benefits Housing Europe Education Pensions Crime The environment Tax Family life & childcare Transport Don t know None of these 5 4 6 3 2 0 1 12 13 25 28 45 49 85 0 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 Percentage of Ukip Voters 14
Support for Europe Source: YouGov for BES Continuous Monitoring Survey Sample: c1,000 British adults per month 70 60 50 Percentage 40 30 Approve of Brit Membership of EU 0 April 04 December 13 15
Support for Europe vs Support for Ukip Source: YouGov for BES Continuous Monitoring Survey Sample: c1,000 British adults per month 70 60 50 Percentage 40 30 UKIP Support Approve of Brit Membership of EU 0 April 04 December 13 16
The importance of Europe as an issue Source: YouGov for BES Continuous Monitoring Survey Sample: c1,000 British adults per month 70 60 50 Percentage 40 30 UKIP Support Approve of Brit Membership of EU 0 April 04 December 13 17
The Three D s Dissatisfied Distrusting Disapproving 18
Most British politicians are personally corrput Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults Percentage 0 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 3 4 7 7 4 11 4 8 22 23 38 33 31 29 31 28 31 29 1 2 8 25 47 0 19 16 16 8 9 2 4 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree Don't know 19
In general, how much do you trust leading politicians from the main parties in Britain to tell the truth? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults 0 90 2 6 4 1 9 18 80 36 37 Percentage 70 60 50 40 36 40 39 35 67 30 36 34 28 18 0 2 4 2 2 4 0 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP Trust a great deal Trust to some extent Do not trust much Do not trust at all Don t know
On balance, do you think Britain is better or worse place in which to grow up than it was thirty or forty years ago? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults 0 90 8 5 6 6 1 Percentage 80 70 60 50 40 55 45 23 55 36 19 82 30 19 0 38 26 18 19 11 6 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP It is better today than 30-40 years ago Neither better nor worse It is worse today Don t know 21
From what you have heard, how safe do you think the MMR vaccination is? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 7-8 April 14 Sample: 1,765 British adults 0 90 80 6 6 01 3 12 12 3 0 28 70 Percentage 60 50 40 88 99 85 84 72 30 0 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP Safe (All) Unsafe (All) Don t know 22
From what you have heard, how safe do you think the MMR vaccination is? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 7-8 April 14 Sample: 1,765 British adults 0 90 80 70 Percentage 60 50 40 30 0 1 0 0 0 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP Dangerous 13 23
Net rise in total support for the single largest nationalist and Eurosceptic parties in Europe since last European elections Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country 18 16 Net Percentage Increase 14 12 8 6 4 14 18 15 2 6 5 0 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland 24
25 Membership of the European Union
Would you support or oppose holding a referendum on Britain s relationship with Europe within the next few years? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: -21 May 13 Sample: 948 British adults 0 90 17 1 12 6 17 14 80 12 70 24 34 Percentage 60 50 40 77 41 93 30 58 42 52 0 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP Support Oppose Don't know
Would you support or oppose holding a referendum on Britain s participation in the Eurovision Song Contest within the next few years? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: -21 May 13 Sample: 966 British adults 0 90 80 24 19 18 22 27 70 Percentage 60 50 40 44 46 45 56 33 30 32 34 36 22 39 0 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP Support Oppose Don't know 27
If there was a referendum on Britain s membership of the European Union, how would you vote? (excluding WNV / DK) Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults 0 90 21 80 70 49 58 35 Percentage 60 50 40 79 96 30 51 42 65 0 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP I would vote to remain a member of the European Union I would vote to leave the European Union 4 28
If there was a referendum on[country] s membership of the European Union, how would you vote? (Excluding WNV/DK) Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country 0 90 80 70 49 49 29 35 44 38 Percentage 60 50 40 30 51 51 71 65 56 62 0 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland I would vote to remain a member of the European Union I would vote to leave the European Union 29
30 Attitudes to Europe
Best things about the European Union Souce: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults It has helped free trade between European countries 38% It has given people the freedom to move to and live in other European countries 27% It has ensured peace and stability in Europe 21% It has allowed co-operation on issues like the environment and terrorism 19% It has led to more cultural understanding and friendship between European countries 13% Has given Europe a stronger voice in the world 19% It has helped develop democracy in the countries of Eastern Europe % It has protected human rights and freedoms in Europe 15% It has made Europe richer and more prosperous 6% Other 1% None of these - there is nothing good about the European Union 17% Don't know 12%
Best things about the European Union Souce: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults It has interfered too much in how member countries run their affairs 45% It has allowed too many immigrants from Eastern Europe to come to countries like Britain It costs too much money 38% It has lead to too much bureaucracy and regulation for businesses 27% The single currency has made the economic crisis worse 23% It has allowed fraud and corruption % It has not been democratic enough or listened to European people's views 13% It has been too protectionist, putting up trade barriers against developing countries It has stopped Britain building relationships with emerging countries 4% Other 1% None of these - there is nothing bad about the European Union 2% Don't know 12% 43% 5%
[COUNTRY] will be a member of the European Union years from now Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: -27 February 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country Percentage 0 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 22 6 16 18 6 3 6 26 45 18 7 9 22 32 12 6 15 43 17 7 9 13 39 13 9 16 18 35 32 0 14 13 14 14 11 6 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree Don't know 33
I understand why the European Union exists Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: -27 February 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country Percentage 0 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 6 3 6 4 3 4 3 3 3 6 5 9 9 9 7 6 12 19 19 19 16 16 14 49 52 48 53 51 41 0 17 18 12 13 14 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree Don't know 34
[COUNTRY] gets a good deal from being a member of the European Union Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: -27 February 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country Percentage 0 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 0 4 11 7 8 5 5 7 11 15 15 17 19 18 22 26 28 25 19 29 25 23 31 36 36 26 29 22 11 4 5 5 6 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree Don't know 35
All things considered, the European Union is a good thing Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: -27 February 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country 0 90 80 70 9 9 21 3 5 5 3 4 7 15 12 15 15 19 19 19 Percentage 60 50 40 22 26 23 23 22 23 30 31 39 31 39 35 35 0 7 7 8 8 9 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree Don't know 36
Life in [COUNTRY] would be better if it was NOT a member of the European Union Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: -27 February 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country 0 90 80 12 13 6 9 9 8 8 15 16 18 16 15 Percentage 70 60 50 40 22 17 27 25 27 17 22 21 29 30 26 18 24 19 22 18 0 9 12 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree Don't know 37
The way the European Union works needs significant reform Source: YouGov Eurotrack Fieldwork: -27 February 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country 0 90 80 70 1 4 16 4 1 6 8 7 6 5 3 1 1 5 4 1 4 6 14 21 19 25 Percentage 60 50 40 38 43 44 41 45 41 30 31 28 29 26 23 21 0 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree Don't know 38
Which of these options would you prefer? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults A more integrated European Union, with more decisions being taken by the EU 3% Keeping broadly the current balance of powers between the EU and individual member states 18% A less integrated European Union, with a number of powers being returned to member states 42% Britain leaving the European Union altogether 24% Don t know 13% 39
Which of these options would you prefer? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: 1,805 British adults 0 90 80 70 Percentage 60 50 40 30 69 0 24 27 17 9 GB Adults Con Lab Lib Dem UKIP Britain leaving the European Union altogether 40
Which of these options would you prefer? Source: YouGov Fieldwork: 28 April 6 May 14 Sample: >1,000 adults per country 0 90 80 70 Percentage 60 50 40 30 0 24 25 19 12 13 15 Britain Germany France Denmark Sweden Finland [COUNTRY] leaving the European Union altogether 41
14 European Elections in Context The rise of Ukip is on a different scale to previous occasions and is not just about Europe Part of a wider scepticism across many parts of Europe EU failing to win big narrative battles with reform the preferred option European Elections have major implications for 15 General Election 42
Email: Joe.Twyman@yougov.com Twitter: @JoeTwyman 43
European Election the qualitative study
We ran online focus groups across four European countries Moderated locally by our qualitative teams in UK, France, Sweden and Germany YouGov panel members 8- participants in each country Mix of ages, gender and political affiliation Mix of those planning/not planning to vote in the EU elections 45
How European do you think you are? Least I identify myself strongly as a European, but not only as that. I probably have more affinity to northern Europe when it comes to values. Most I see myself as being from Derbyshire, the East Midlands, then British. "I can t identify myself as European. Europe, as it is now is not united, it's every man for himself." I identify myself as a person who lives in Germany and I am happy about the strong cooperation in Europe on the political level 46
How do the countries perceive their role in the EU? The passenger End of the affair The eco warrior The money lender 47
The rise of Euro scepticism in Britain and France UKIP is shaping the agenda and UKIP supporters are placing much more emphasis on Europe within the agenda Immigration has become a topical issue dividing opinion BUT: many feel that Britain has lost its way in Europe want to be part of it, but don t know how We don t know what our role is or what input we really have in Europe lack of clarity and certainty We are more open to reform than leaving In France problems in the French economy are overshadowing perceptions of the EU Feeling that France s influence is fast diminishing and economic issues compounding this Although they believe that without Europe, the French economy would be even worse, they want a number of powers to be returned to the states and for Europe to be less integrated Euro crisis has created negativity every man for himself 48
In Germany and Sweden there is a stronger sense of place in the EU While those in Germany recognise that Germany is setting the EU agenda, this does always lead on to positive feelings about EU membership. Many feel that whilst Germany is strong and influential in Europe and in the world generally we are the second most influential country after the US Many criticized the money lender role that they feel Germany has been forced to adopt in the Euro crisis However, they tend to still be happy with things the way they are when it comes to the level of integration in Europe. In Sweden many value the co-operation that the EU allows and recognizes it gives Sweden a more prominent voice. They accept that Sweden may not set the agenda but it does allow them the platform to make their voice heard on issues such as animal rights, welfare and the environment 49
Love or Loathe? High media interest and everyone has an opinion on the EU elections in the UK 50
Everyone is talking about Europe The prominence of UKIP The referendum debate The 15 general election UKIP were felt to be more prominent than ever before and there was high levels of awareness of the UKIP campaign and anti-eu anti-immigration stance. Voters are now seeing the elections as an in/out vote on Europe rather than a vote to elect a an MEP to the European Parliament The 15 general election is also shaping the EU election this year some are voting for the party they expect to vote for next year to show support. I think UKIP have woken people up and all sides of the debate. The in/out syndrome makes it different this year. 51
BUT in the rest of Europe what elections? 52
Mixed Interest in France Voters feel it is important to vote at the EU elections the lack of media coverage and information means their interest is mixed Limited media coverage Lack of information and transparency Voters do not feel that the media is covering in enough detail and find the debates on TV/radio sterile. They also feel that there is a lack of information from the parties and question the role of French MEP s at the EU. But despite this French participants are planning to vote and most had decided who they are going vote for. "The media speak little about it but I m interested in this election as it represents an important choice" "I am very interested in these elections, but there is too little explanation" 53
Business as usual in Sweden While those in Sweden feel it is their duty to vote, there is limited interest in the EU elections this year it is business as usual in Sweden. 14 general election Single issue parties The EU elections have been overshadowed by the general election in Sweden and the campaign messages have not combined. "Will vote the same as in the general elections. I am interested, but not enough too go looking for information." Many felt that the smaller parties would will have a bigger impact this year than previously, but there are an array of small single issue parties rather than dominated by one party. I think the smaller parties have a bigger chance to get confidence of the voters as they seem to have stronger people. 54
No party or issue is dominating the agenda There is no special topic and no special political party dominating the campaign. Angela Merkel will benefit most. Low interest Angela Merkel Most intended to vote but had not yet decided who to vote for. They were not aware of any key issues this year apart from the role of Martin Schulz as candidate of the European Commission as so-called rescuer of the EU. I saw the discussion if Martin Schulz is able to recover the EU With no party or issues dominating the debate, Angela Merkel was seen as the figure who would benefit most from the Elections because she can present herself as the face of Germany in the world/eu. Merkel will benefit the most although she is not eligible. The other political figures are not that present 55
What s the verdict? "Participants show a real interest in the European elections, although they feel they are not sufficiently informed about the elections and criticize the media about this. The key issues of European elections in France are primarily employment and economic situation. The majority of them already know who they will vote for in the European elections. The balance of power in the focus group was in line with the results of the EuroTrack : the Front National leader, followed by the UMP. According to respondents, the Parti socialiste will suffer another defeat, after Municipal elections in March." 56
What s the verdict? In Sweden it is a big election year this year with the upcoming national election in September. This explains why people are not as interested in the EU election to some extent, as the general election is demanding media attention - the current government is up for a fight after 8 years in power. Voters are confused about which is which debate but many believe it will be the single-question parties who will get more votes than normal in the European elections. They feel more free to choose parties they normally don't vote for as the EU election is not as important! 57
What s the verdict Those we spoke to weren t very interested in the European Elections. Most of them don t know who to vote for and they are still in the process of collecting information about the key issues/debate. Most don t know the top candidates of the parties. Only Martin Schulz from the Socialdemocratic Party (SPD) is well known because he wants to become president of the European Commission. This means that many feel they will rely on previous voting habits or try and collect more information in the next weeks up to the Elections. 58
What s the verdict The media interest in the EU elections has certainly had an impact, with most of our focus group respondents certain they will turn out to vote on May 22 nd this year it s serious business However, very few of them are actually focusing on the issues of Europe itself they are seeing this election as a chance to show how they feel about the political situation in the UK and demonstrate their feelings about the main political parties. Whilst there has been a clear rise in anti-euro UKIP, many of our respondents remain confused or undecided about the future of Britain in the EU and are reluctant to see us leave it behind 59
Overall Divergent opinions Uncertainty about the future EU plays a valuable role but where is it going? How is it changing and adapting How does the EU fit into the global picture 60
61 Email: Jane.Carn@yougov.com
Questions