Fair Labour Market Integration of Refugees Workshop 6.17, Everest 2 Doritt Komitowski (IQ Competence Center on Immigration, Berlin) Stephan Schiele (Tür an Tür / MigraNet - IQ Landesnetzwerk Bayern) INTERNATIONAL METROPOLIS CONFERENCE 2017 The Hague, 21 September
Draft Agenda Welcome and introduction 16:00 Speaker statements: 16:05 Labour market integration of refugees in Germany: framework, challenges, initiative Fair Integration (Doritt Komitowski, IQ Competence Centre on Immigration and Stephan Schiele, Tür an Tür/MigraNet IQ Bavaria) Labour market integration of refugees in Sweden (Bernd Parusel, Swedish Migration Agency) Labour market integration of refugees: Different approaches in Europe (Klára Fóti, Eurofund) Discussion with the presenters and audience 16:40 Conclusion and end of workshop 17:25 2
Labour Market Integration of Refugees in Germany Doritt Komitowski (IQ Competence Center on Immigration, Berlin) Stephan Schiele (Tür an Tür / MigraNet - IQ Landesnetzwerk Bayern)
Summary 1. Immigration to Germany 2. Legal framework for the access to the labour market of refugees and asylum seekers 3. Labour market integration: current situation and main challenges 4. Policy strategies aiming at fair labour market integration Das Förderprogramm Integration durch Qualifizierung (IQ) wird durch das Bundesministerium für Arbeit und Soziales gefördert. In Kooperation mit:
1. Immigration to Germany By the end of 2016 1.5 million refugees lived in Germany: recognised refugees, asylum seekers, non-returnable refused asylum seekers (the so-called tolerated persons ) and persons with a residence permit based on humanitarian reasons (humanitarian residence permit) Current migration dynamics: 2015: 1,091,894 EASY-Registrations approximately 890,000 incoming refugees (Federal Ministry of the Interior) 2016: 321,371 EASY-registrations approximately 280,000 incoming refugees (Federal Ministry of the Interior) 2017 (January to July): 106,604 (new Asylum Application Statistics) 5
1.a. Asylum applications in Germany: countries of origin 2016 Syria 268.866 Afghanistan 127.892 Iraq 97.162 Iran Eritrea Albania Pakistan Undetermined Nigeria Russian Federation 26.872 19.103 17.236 15.528 14.922 12.916 12.234 0 50.000 100.000 150.000 200.000 250.000 300.000 Number of asylum applications in Germany by country of origin in 2016 (Source: Federal Office for Migration and Refugees 2017) Minor 6
1.b. Asylum applications in Germany: countries of origin 2017 Syria 24.148 Iraq Afghanistan 10.572 10.286 Eritrea Iran Somalia Nigeria Turkey Russian Federation Guinea 6.386 4.951 3.725 3.720 3.206 3.182 2.401 0 5.000 10.000 15.000 20.000 25.000 30.000 Number of asylum applications in Germany by country of origin in the 1 st half of 2017 (Source: Federal Office for Migration and Refugees 2017) Minor 7
1.c. Asylum applicants: decisions of the Federal Office 2015 48,5% 0,6% 0,7% 32,4% 17,8% 2016 36,8% 22,1% 3,5% 25,0% 12,6% January to June 2017 20,9% 17,1% 6,7% 39,1% 16,1% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Refugee protection / entitlement to asylum Prohibition of deportation Other procedures Subsidiary protection Rejection of the application Decisions of the Federal Office on asylum applications in 2015, 2016 and 2017 (Source: Federal Office for Migration and Refugees 2017) Minor 8
1.d. Asylum applicants: age and gender 100 % 2,3 3,8 9,4 75 % 20,6 Over 54 50 % 26,4 45 to 54 35 to 44 25 to 34 16 to 24 Under 16 Female 38,0 % Male 62,0 % 25 % 37,5 0 % Age of asylum applicants 2017(1st half) (Source: Federal Office for Migration and Refugees 2017) Minor Gender of asylum applicants 2017(1st half) (Source: Federal Office for Migration and Refugees 2017) Minor 9
2.a. Legal framework for access to the labour market Refugees have unlimited access to the labour market Historically, asylum seekers were barred from the labour market; later on they could access it after four years of residence in Germany Recent developments: various laws and regulations gradually opened up the labour market to asylum seekers and non-returnable refused asylum seekers (the so-called tolerated persons) Asylum seekers and tolerated persons can start working or begin vocational education or an apprenticeship after three months of registered residence Asylum seekers and tolerated persons can participate in the professional education system from the first day of registered residence Asylum seekers and tolerated persons from the so-called safe countries of origin* are still barred from the labour market *Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Ghana, Kosovo, Macedonia, Montenegro, Senegal and Serbia 12
2.b. Policy for access to the labour market of asylum seekers Early access to integration courses, vocational language courses and financial support as instruments of labour market integration But: Many of the early-access measures are limited to the group of asylum seekers who are said to have a long-term perspective to stay in Germany (Syria, Iran, Iraq, Somalia and Eritrea) Identification and recognition of job qualifications acquired in the country of origin New since August 2016: Guaranteed residence permit limited to the duration of the apprenticeship for tolerated persons ( non-returnable refused asylum seekers) 13
3.a. Labour force participation German nationals 66,9 Significant differences between immigrant groups Foreign workers 45,6 Different prerequisites and conditions From the European Union 54,8 Highest employment rate: EU citizens (free movement) From Non-EU Balkan states From Asian and African countries considered volatile 15,1 48,5 Lowest employment rate: nationals from Asian and African countries of origin, considered volatile Reversed figures for unemployment rate 0 % 20 % 40 % 60 % 80 % Labour force participation rate of German and Non-German citizens 2016 (Source: Federal Employment Agency, Institute for Employment Research 2016) Minor 14
3.b. Level of skills utilised in the work place German nationals 17,0 58,5 12,4 12,1 Foreign workers 39,4 46,3 5,8 8,5 from the European Union 39,3 46,1 6,2 8,4 GIPS 33,4 51,6 6,6 8,4 EU-8 46,8 44,0 4,1 5,1 EU-2 54,6 38,7 2,5 4,1 from Non-EU Western Balkan states 42,4 49,8 3,9 3,8 from Asian and African countries considered volatile 48,8 40,2 3,4 7,6 0 % 25 % 50 % 75 % 100 % Low-level Medium-level Specialized workers Expert workers Skill-level requirement of German and Non-German workers as of December 31 st 2016 (Source: Federal Employment Agency 2017) Minor 15
3.c Push and pull factors of successful labor market integration 73,8 % younger than 30 Years 59,7 % younger than 25 Years 36,2 % younger than 18 Years School education of over 18-year-old 19% said they had not attended any school or only elementary school 36% have attended an intermediate or technical school, 25% completed this 37% visited a secondary school, 32% had completed this In the Group of under 18-year old the number of refugees who had not completed school is much higher 16
3.d Push and pull factors of successful labor market integration Push-factors: Formal recognition through Recognition law (included 14 BQFG) Volunteer-networks many programs for the target group refugees (employers involved) positive attitude towards refugees 17
3.e Push and pull factors of successful labor market integration Pull-factors: Lack of knowledge of education and training system lack of knowledge about labour law and wage agreement Non-formal and informal skills will not be validated Language learning opportunities are not adapted to the individual needs Programs provide false incentives for education providers 18
3.f Recommendations for a successful labor market integration Recommendations: use existing qualifications if there are none, bring refugees into job training If some refugees are too old for job training, use company training, partial qualification or on the job training 19
3.f Recommendations for a successful labor market integration Recommendations: Educational background must be connection capability: Individual educational advice School-system must be able to integrate also older students (16 +) and should be able to refer to the right types of school Formal conditions are in many cases still a big problem Validation of non-formal and informal skills Successful way: professional recognition recognized by law 20
3.f Recommendations for a successful labor market integration Recommendations: Provide information on education and training system Support structures for employers must be available Individual offers of extra occupational qualifications must be offered Language courses adapt to individual needs (language course advice) 21
4. Policy strategies aming at fair labour market integration Numerous programmes, policy measures, initiatives and projects conducted by the federal and local government(s), municipalities, NGOs and volunteers New initiative Fair Integration of Refugees starts in 2018: Part of the funding programme Integration through Qualification Provision of nationwide consulting services for refugees and asylum seekers concerning:» Basic employee rights and labour standards» Forwarding to the trade unions if enforcement of labour rights is necessary» Counselling services and structures» Recognition of foreign qualifications and professional education» Labour market participation 22
Thank you for your attention! Competence Centre on Immigration fe@minor-kontor.de www.minor-kontor.de Tür an Tür / MigraNet stephan.schiele@tuerantuer.de http://www.migranet.org/ Das Netzwerk IQ wird gefördert durch das Bundesministerium für Arbeit und Soziales, das Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung und die Bundesagentur für Arbeit. 23
Bibliography and further information Federal Agency for Civic Education (Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung/bpb): Numbers of refugees and asylum seekers, 2017. https://www.bpb.de/politik/innenpolitik/flucht/218788/zahlen-zu-asyl-indeutschland#registrierungen Federal Employment Agency, Institute for Employment Research, 2016. Federal Office for Migration and Refugees, 2017: Migration monitoring: Migration to Germany 2016. http://www.bamf.de/shareddocs/anlagen/de/publikationen/broschueren/wanderungsmonitoring- 2016.html?nn=2204264 Federal Office for Migration and Refugees, 2017: Statistical data 2016. http://www.bamf.de/shareddocs/anlagen/de/downloads/infothek/statistik/asyl/201612-statistikanlage-asyl-geschaeftsbericht.pdf? blob=publicationfile Federal Statistical Office, 2016: Bevölkerung und Erwerbstätigkeit. Vorläufige Wanderungsergebnisse. https://www.destatis.de/de/publikationen/thematisch/bevoelkerung/wanderungen/vorlaeufigewande rungen5127101157004.pdf? blob=publicationfile IAB-BAMF-SOEP-Refugee Survey displacement, arrival in Germany and first steps towards integration, 2016. http://www.bamf.de/shareddocs/anlagen/en/publikationen/kurzanalysen/kurzanalyse5_iabbamf-soep-befragung-gefluechtete.html 24