Knowledge is Power: Measuring the Competitiveness of Global April 2013 Contents Global Competitiveness Index P.1 Knowledge-intensive industries P.5 Highly-skilled occupations P.7 Workers qualifications P.10 Workers income P.11 Future releases P.12 as a Global City A direct impact of contemporary globalisation on is its rise as a global city. As Australia s foremost global city, is home to the country s highest number of head offices for international institutions and foreign banks. It is an important cog in the national and international economy, linking Australia with the world through business transactions, knowledge sharing, and people movement. These links allow Australia to compete in an integrated world economy through and its other global cities. s status as a global city is reflected by its high concentration of knowledge-intensive industries, its skilled workforce, and capacity to innovate. Such attributes define the competitiveness of global cities, and determine s positioning in the global city hierarchy. Global Competitiveness Index (GCI) Researchers from the ANZSOG Institute for Governance at the University of Canberra, and the Commonwealth Department of Immigration and Citizenship (DIAC), are embarking on a range of projects to better understand the competitiveness of Australian cities in the context of globalisation. One of these is the creation of a Global Competitiveness Index (GCI) for. The GCI results are based on Census data from and. They show where industries and occupations of high importance to global cities are concentrated within the region, as well as changes in workers qualification levels and income. This has been done by comparing results in each of the region s 43 local council areas. How the GCI is measured The GCI is a weighted index that considers the following indicators based on place of work: Workers in knowledge-intensive industries; Workers in highly-skilled occupations; Workers with a university qualification; and Workers income. A research collaboration between the University of Canberra and the Commonwealth Department of Immigration and Citizenship
GCI findings: s economic movers and shakers City of was by far the highest ranking local council in both and. North ranked a clear second in both and. Scores for City of and North reflect the high concentration of knowledge-intensive industries and highlyskilled occupations within central areas of global cities. High-ranking council areas are generally close to s Global Arc (see below).,, and Lane Cove made up the rest of the top five areas in the GCI. Ku-ring-gai, Canada Bay and were also in the top ten. Lower-ranking councils are mostly on s urban fringe. Wyong ranked the lowest in both and, preceded by Camden, Wollondilly, Hawkesbury, and Fairfield. experienced the highest increase between and. Canada Bay, Auburn, and City of also had considerable increases. Some council areas recorded noticeable decreases between and including Lane Cove, Burwood, Mosman and. Please note: The Leichhardt council area was geographically smaller in than in, due to some of its land being transferred to the City of council in 2003. results for City of also include the former South council area. The City of and South councils amalgamated in 2004. s Global Arc s Global Arc is an economic corridor of jobs and major infrastructure stretching from Macquarie Park to Port Botany through Chatswood, St Leonards, North, the CBD and Airport. The Global Arc has been built on the benefits that businesses involved in industries such as finance, legal services, information technology, engineering and marketing have gained from being close to each other and to s transport infrastructure. This has seen the Global Arc emerge as a critical feature of and Australia's economy. From the NSW Government s City of Cities Metropolitan Strategy (2005) rank Council name GCI GCI 1 3.02 3.25 2 North 2.59 2.51 3 0.81 1.40 4 1.22 1.05 5 Lane Cove 1.52 0.96 6 Ku-ring-gai 0.72 0.62 7 Canada Bay 0.14 0.59 8 Woollahra 0.52 0.51 9 0.45 0.41 10 Randwick 0.35 0.41 11 Kogarah 0.35 0.35 12 Mosman 0.51 0.31 13 Leichhardt 0.36 0.28 14 Hunters Hill 0.28 0.21 15 Manly 0.03 0.18 16 Burwood 0.41 0.14 17 Waverley 0.12 0.12 18 Auburn -0.20 0.08 19 The Hills Shire -0.12 0.02 20 Ashfield -0.09 0.01 21 Warringah -0.17-0.10 22 Hornsby -0.07-0.14 23 Pittwater -0.30-0.21 24 Botany Bay -0.18-0.25 25 Marrickville -0.39-0.28 26 Strathfield -0.29-0.36 27 Hurstville -0.46-0.43 28 Sutherland Shire -0.52-0.52 29 Liverpool -0.51-0.56 30 Bankstown -0.57-0.57 31 Blue Mountains -0.65-0.63 32 Rockdale -0.59-0.63 33-0.59-0.64 34 Canterbury -0.64-0.67 35 Gosford -0.69-0.67 36 Penrith -0.66-0.70 37 Campbelltown -0.73-0.76 38 Holroyd -0.73-0.81 39 Fairfield -0.74-0.82 40 Hawkesbury -0.75-0.85 41 Wollondilly -0.88-0.91 42 Camden -0.90-0.94 43 Wyong -0.95-0.94 Table 1: GCI results, and 2
3 Figure 1: GCI,
4 Figure 2: Change in GCI, -
North The Hills Shire Sutherland Shire Auburn Warringah Canada Bay Ku-ring-gai Gosford Hornsby Bankstown Lane Cove Penrith Leichhardt Liverpool Randwick Woollahra Waverley Wyong Botany Bay Pittwater Hurstville Campbelltown Fairfield Marrickville Kogarah Manly Burwood Strathfield Rockdale Blue Mountains Canterbury Mosman Holroyd Hawkesbury Camden Ashfield Wollondilly Hunters Hill Knowledge-intensive industries Number of people employed in knowledge-intensive industries Using the Australian and New Zealand Standard Industrial Classification (ANZSIC), the following divisions were chosen to denote knowledge-intensive industries: Information Media and Telecommunications; Financial and Insurance Services; Rental, Hiring and Real Estate Services; and Professional, Scientific and Technical Services. 200,000 180,000 160,000 140,000 120,000 100,000 80,000 60,000 40,000 20,000 0 Figure 3: Numbers of workers in knowledge-intensive industries, - Workers in knowledge-intensive industries are heavily concentrated in Central. Numbers in City of were much higher than in any other council area in both and, while North was a distant second. Together, City of and North hosted more workers in knowledge-intensive industries in than all other 41 council areas in the region combined. 5
North Lane Cove Canada Bay Mosman Woollahra Ku-ring-gai Manly Leichhardt Waverley The Hills Shire Pittwater Auburn Kogarah Hurstville Hunters Hill Warringah Burwood Ashfield Sutherland Shire Hornsby Marrickville Blue Mountains Gosford Strathfield Rockdale Camden Randwick Wyong Bankstown Canterbury Hawkesbury Wollondilly Penrith Botany Bay Campbelltown Liverpool Fairfield Holroyd All other councils 32% 45% The Hills Shire 3% 3% 4% 5% North 8% Figure 4: Workers in knowledge-intensive industries, Other leading locations for knowledge-intensive industries include,,, and The Hills Shire, all of which had between 10,000 and 20,000 workers in such industries in. Areas with lower numbers of knowledge industry workers were generally very small councils close to central, or on s urban-rural fringe. Hunters Hill geographically the smallest council area in the region, ranked the lowest with only 605 workers in knowledge-intensive industries in. Wollondilly, Ashfield, Camden and Hawkesbury had the next lowest numbers of workers in these industries. Aside from City of, which attracted almost 30,000 extra knowledge industry workers between and, the largest increases were found in (up by 7,700 workers to 19,000), Auburn, Canada Bay, and The Hills Shire. had the largest reduction in knowledge-intensive industry workers (down by 4,500 to 16,700), followed by, and Burwood. Proportion of workers employed in knowledge-intensive industries North has the region s highest proportion of workers in knowledge-intensive industries. Almost 51 per cent of people working in the North council area were employed in knowledge industries in. 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Figure 5: Proportion of workers in knowledge-intensive industries, - 6
North The Hills Shire Sutherland Shire Randwick Warringah Liverpool Bankstown Auburn Penrith Gosford Hornsby Botany Bay Ku-ring-gai Fairfield Canada Bay Campbelltown Wyong Marrickville Leichhardt Waverley Lane Cove Canterbury Holroyd Woollahra Kogarah Pittwater Hurstville Hawkesbury Strathfield Rockdale Burwood Blue Mountains Manly Camden Ashfield Mosman Wollondilly Hunters Hill City of was second, with almost 47 per cent in., Lane Cove and had the next highest percentages of workers in knowledge-intensive industries. Areas with the lowest percentages of workers in knowledge industries were generally in s west and southwest. was the lowest-ranking council area, with less than 6 per cent of its workers in knowledge industries. Holroyd, Fairfield, Liverpool and Campbelltown had the next lowest percentages. The largest increases in percentage between and were in similar areas to the largest numerical increases. had the largest increase, rising by 5.7 percentage points to 27.4 per cent. Auburn, Canada Bay, Marrickville and City of all had increases of between 1.5 and 3.5 percentage points. Burwood had the largest proportional decrease, falling by 15.4 percentage points. It was followed by Strathfield,, and. Highly-skilled occupations Number of workers in highly-skilled occupations Using the Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO), the following occupation groups were selected as highly-skilled occupations: Managers; and Professionals. 250,000 225,000 200,000 175,000 150,000 125,000 100,000 75,000 50,000 25,000 0 Figure 6: Numbers of workers in highly-skilled occupations, - 7
Highly-skilled occupations are heavily concentrated in Central. In City of had more than 140,000 people working as managers and professionals. This was more than four times the number of such workers in North, which was the second-ranked council area at 32,000. This concentration had increased in the ten years to, resulting in City of having more than five times North s number of workers in highlyskilled occupations. and had the next highest numbers in, followed by and. Together, the top six council areas contained more than half of the region s managerial and professional jobs in. All other councils 49.7% 29.0% North 5.3% 4.9% 3.1% 4.8% 3.2% Figure 7: Workers in highly-skilled occupations, Council areas with lower numbers of managerial and professional workers were generally small and close to the centre of, or in the region s outer southwest. Hunters Hill had the least in both and, despite an increase from 1,300 to 1,600. Wollondilly had the next lowest numbers in both years, with a considerable rise from 1,600 in to 2,500 in. Mosman, Ashfield, Camden and Manly were the next lowest, with less than 5,000 managers and professionals in. The largest growth in the number of highly-skilled occupations was in City of, which increased by almost 80,000 between and. This was more than a third of all additional managerial and professional jobs in the region. had the next largest growth at 16,500, followed by The Hills, and North. The largest proportional growth was in Canada Bay, which more than doubled from 6,000 in to 12,300 in. In all, 41 of the region s 43 council areas experienced growth in their numbers of managerial and professional jobs. The two exceptions were Lane Cove (down by 1,160) and Leichhardt (down by 325). 8
North Lane Cove Ku-ring-gai Randwick Kogarah Woollahra Canada Bay Hunters Hill Leichhardt Manly Mosman Waverley Burwood The Hills Shire Ashfield Hornsby Warringah Pittwater Marrickville Auburn Blue Mountains Hurstville Sutherland Shire Gosford Strathfield Liverpool Canterbury Bankstown Botany Bay Penrith Campbelltown Hawkesbury Rockdale Fairfield Wyong Camden Wollondilly Holroyd Proportion of workers in highly-skilled occupations North edged out City of to have the highest percentage of workers in highly-skilled occupations. North had more than 60 per cent of its workers employed in managerial and professional roles in, up from more than 51 per cent in. City of jumped from 40 per cent in to 55 per cent in. Other top-ranking areas in were predominantly in s north including,, Lane Cove and Ku-ring-gai. Most areas with lower percentages were in s outer suburbs Holroyd was the lowest in both and, while Wollondilly, Camden, Wyong and Fairfield had the next lowest percentages in. 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Figure 8: Proportion of workers in highly-skilled occupations, - The proportion of workers in highly-skilled occupations increased in all council areas across the region between and. Areas experiencing the greatest increases were generally close to the centre of. City of had the greatest increase up by 15 percentage points between and., Canada Bay, Woollahra, Manly, and North also experienced growth of more than ten percentage points. The lowest increase was in Lane Cove at 1.6%, preceded by the outlying councils of Hawkesbury, Camden and Wollondilly. 9
North Ku-ring-gai Randwick Lane Cove Hunters Hill Woollahra Kogarah Canada Bay Waverley Burwood Ashfield Mosman Leichhardt Manly Hornsby Marrickville Auburn The Hills Shire Warringah Pittwater Hurstville Strathfield Canterbury Botany Bay Blue Mountains Rockdale Bankstown Liverpool Sutherland Shire Penrith Campbelltown Gosford Fairfield Holroyd Hawkesbury Wyong Camden Wollondilly Workers qualifications The GCI also considers workers within who have obtained a university qualification. Using the Australian Standard Classification of Education (ASCED), a university qualification includes the following educational levels: Postgraduate degree; Graduate diploma and graduate certificate; and Bachelor s degree. 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Figure 9: Proportion of workers with a university qualification, - North had the highest percentage of workers holding a university qualification in both and. This jumped from 40 per cent in to more than 54 per cent in. City of was also above 50 per cent in, having jumped from 37 per cent in. Other areas with high proportions of university-educated workers were mostly in s north including, Ku-ring-gai, and. Areas in s south-west and urban fringe tended to have the lowest percentages of workers with a university qualification. Wollondilly had the lowest readings, at 11 per cent in and 14 per cent in. Camden, Wyong, Hawkesbury, Holroyd and Fairfield were the next lowest, with less than 20 per cent of workers holding a university qualification in. The proportion of workers with a university qualification increased in all 43 council areas across the region between and, with the most notable rises along or close to s Global Arc. s proportion of university-educated workers increased the most up by 16 percentage points to 47 per cent. City of (15 percentage points) was closely behind, followed by Canada Bay, North and. The outlying areas of Camden, Hawkesbury and Wollondilly had the lowest increases, by a little over 3 percentage points. 10
North Lane Cove Botany Bay Auburn Randwick Canada Bay Woollahra Kogarah Strathfield Leichhardt Ku-ring-gai Burwood Mosman Warringah Hunters Hill The Hills Shire Holroyd Liverpool Manly Bankstown Wollondilly Ashfield Pittwater Rockdale Waverley Marrickville Penrith Hornsby Campbelltown Fairfield Hawkesbury Sutherland Shire Camden Hurstville Canterbury Gosford Wyong Blue Mountains Workers income Workers median income was measured in the GCI to reflect the concentration of knowledge-intensive industries, highly-skilled occupations, and higher education qualifications, which are important indicators of a location s competitiveness in attracting business and talented workers. $1,600 $1,400 $1,200 $1,000 $800 $600 $400 $200 $0 Figure 10: Median income (nominal dollars), - North had the highest median incomes for both and, jumping sharply in nominal terms from $940 in to $1420 in. City of was second in both years, having also grown considerably from around $870 in to $1,340 in., Lane Cove and Botany Bay were the other council areas with a median income above $1,100 in. Council areas with lower median incomes were geographically spread. The Blue Mountains had the lowest median income in both and, while Wyong, Gosford, Canterbury and Hurstville recorded the next lowest median incomes in. Median incomes increased in all council areas across the region between and, with the largest increases occurring mostly in areas east of. s change in median income was the greatest, up by $500 to $1,240. North and City of also recorded income growth of more than $450, while median incomes in, Randwick and Canada Bay all increased by around $350. The smallest rise, of just under $200, was in the Blue Mountains. Canterbury, Hurstville and Fairfield had the next smallest increases in median income, of between $200 and $215. 11
Globalisation and Cities Research Program ANZSOG Institute for Governance Building 23, Level B University of Canberra ACT 2601 www.globalisationandcities.com Contact Shaun Allen T: (02) 6206 8632 E: shaun.allen@canberra.edu.au Future releases The Global Competitiveness Index is part of a research cluster investigating Global Cities and Migration. Future releases to come include: Connecting Australia with Asia This involves the use of passenger flight data to map people movement and Australia s increasing engagement with Asia. Focusing on the Global Cities of and Shanghai, we will be able to see patterns and trends of Australia s network with the world, through the flows of people movement. This includes the major reasons for travel between major centres, how long people stay, and the social and economic impacts on sending and receiving cities. Global Mobility (GloMo) Index The GloMo Index will show the concentrations of residents across the region, who have relocated from other parts of Australia and overseas. About the Globalisation and Cities ANZSOG Participants: Richard Hu Shaun Allen Lucas Carmody Michael Cusack Research Program This program is investigating the social, economic, political, and cultural changes of major cities in the context of globalisation. It aims to unravel the complexities of globalisation and urbanisation, their contributory and resultant factors, and their associated challenges for policy and planning. Key research issues include global cities, urban competitiveness, urban planning and governance, migration, and space of flows in cities. This program is particularly interested in capturing the positioning of Australian cities in a global urban network or hierarchy, and the way Australia integrates with the world through its key urban centres. It attempts to uncover the interrelationships between Australian cities and their counterparts in the Asia- DIAC Participants: Anita Davis Richard Manderson William McClure Dan Payne Pacific, the internal and external dynamics of such interrelationships, and the resulting priorities for urban planning and policy. Understanding Australian cities in this global context will inform strategies and decision-making at global, national, regional, and local levels. It will also help effectively address globalised challenges, such as competitiveness, innovation, migration, sustainability, liveability, and social cohesion.