Eastern European Politics POLI 359/INTL390 College of Charleston Political Science/International Studies Spring Course Description

Similar documents
Democratization Fall 2017

Democracy and Democratization INTL Cross-regional studies College of Charleston, Spring 2019

Political Science 2331

College of Charleston Primavera 2017

FALL OF COMMUNISM IN EUROPE

Teaching methodology: lectures and discussions. Upon successful completion of this course, student should be able to:

Political Science 552 Communist and Post-Communist Politics State University of New York at Albany Fall 2015

Introduction to Europe-Spring 2019 Dr. Kovalov

Introduction to Political Thought POLS (CRN 21155), Spring 2019 MW 2:00-3: Maybank Hall Instructor: David Hinton

Fall 2016, Hellems 229, MWF 10-10:50 am

SCOPE AND OBJECTIVES IMPORTANT DATES

Dr. Douglas Friedman Politics of Latin America 9 Glebe St., Rm. 100 SPRING 2017 Tel.# POLITICS OF LATIN AMERICA

History : European History Since 1600: Empire, Revolution and Global War: Spring 2017, 10:00-10:50 am, Humanities 125 Dr N Vavra

Cold War in Europe EUH 4282 Spring Term, 2010 T/R, 5-6,6 University of Florida

Spring 2016, 10:00-10:50 am, Humanities 125 Dr. N Vavra

Political Science 552 Communist and Post-Communist Politics State University of New York at Albany Spring 2012

INTRODUCTION TO COMPARATIVE POLITICS Political Science 21 Spring Semester 2011 Monday and Wednesday, 10:30-11:45

GOVERNMENT 334: RUSSIAN/POST-SOVIET POLITICS

History : Western Civilization II Spring 2014, 9:00-9:50 am, EDUC 220 Dr. Nancy Vavra

The College of Charleston. Spring POLI American Government. Tu-Th 9:25-10:40. Maybank 207. Tuesdays 3:00-4 P.M. and by appointment

IR 169 INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS OF RUSSIA AND EASTERN EUROPE Spring 2014 Mondays and Wednesdays, 2:35-3:50 LI 404

Refugees, Migrants, and Citizenship

INTERNATIONAL STUDIES 205: INTRODUCTION TO EUROPEAN STUDIES

CET Syllabus of Record

The Evolution of Western Ideas and Institutions Since the Seventeenth Century History 102 Spring T, Th, 1:00pm-2:15pm Professor Suzanne Kaufman

Political Science 552 Communist and Post-Communist Politics State University of New York at Albany Spring 2010

Revolutions and Political Violence

Russian and Post-Soviet Politics

History : War & Society: Russia in the Twentieth Century Fall 2015, 4:00-4:50 pm, Hellems 237 Dr Nancy Vavra

History : Western Civilization II Fall 2013, 4:00-4:50 pm, Hellems 201 Dr. Nancy Vavra

UNDIVIDED EUROPE DEMOCRATIZATION AND INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS AFTER COMMUNISM

INTL NATIONALISM AND CITIZENSHIP IN EUROPE

Political Science 552 Communist and Post-Communist Politics State University of New York at Albany Fall 2008

Rise and Fall of Communism in the 20th Century GVPT 459 R TYD 1114 Tu and Th: 11am 12:15pm University of Maryland Spring 2018

In Love with Power: Non Democratic Regimes in Central and Eastern Europe After 1945

A. Russia and Poland Compared (Dr Harald Wydra) MT 2018

Prague, Czech Republic Study Center. Course Syllabus

GEORGIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY Sam Nunn School of International Affairs. Ethics in International Affairs INTA 2030 Spring Dr.

Course Syllabus: Political Science 327 POLITICAL PARTIES Fall 2013

CIEE Study Center St. Petersburg

History 272 Latin America in the Modern Era

Latin America-US Relations POLS Mon/Wed, 2:10 pm - 3:25 pm Office- McGannon Hall #149

CIEE in Prague, Czech Republic

Study Center in Budapest, Hungary

CPO 2001 Introduction to Comparative Politics (Honors)

PPT: Post WWII Tensions

Yale University Department of Political Science

YORK UNIVERSITY Department of Political Science POLS A POST COMMUNIST TRANSFORMATIONS: CAN EAST BECOME WEST? Fall 2014

Comparative Political Systems (GOVT_ 040) July 6 th -Aug. 7 th, 2015

The History of Western Civilization II

Prague, Czech Republic Study Center. Course Syllabus

University of Wisconsin-Madison Department of History Semester I,

PO102, R: Introduction to Comparative Politics Dwight R. Hahn, Ph.D.

DURING WWII THE US AND THE SOVIET UNION HAD JOINED

Social Change and Political Transformation in Eastern Europe. Plan of the Course

Winter 2006 Political Science 2004: Politics and Violence in the Middle East University of Missouri at Columbia

Introduction to Comparative Politics

CPO 2001 Introduction to Comparative Politics

WESTERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

American Political Thought POLI (CRN 11887) Fall 2017 MWF 2-2:50, Maybank 307 Instructor: David Hinton

The Cold War ( )

WESTERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

Collapse of European Communism

MIGRATION & GLOBALIZATION SOSC. 105 (1) FALL

PA 372 Comparative and International Administration

Origins of the Cold War,

PLSC 104 AMERICAN GOVERNMENT CREDITS: 3.0

IR 222: Politics of New Europe

AAST433/GVPT368C (section 0101) Asian American Politics Monday/Wednesdays 2-3:15 TAWES 0234 Course website on ELMS

Introduction to Comparative Politics

American Government I GOVT 2301 Collin College, Spring Creek

POL SCI Congressional Politics. Fall 2018 Mon & Wed 11:00AM 12:15PM Location TBA

Revolutions and Political Violence PSCI 3062 Fall 2015

231 INTRODUCTION TO COMPARATIVE POLITICS Fall 2008 Department of Political Science Muskingum College POLS MWF: 3:00 3:50 pm 15 Cambridge Hall

Politics 115 Post-Soviet Politics. Spring 2010 Stephen Crowley MWF 3:30-4:20 King 123

History of American Immigration. History 21:512:230, Professor Michael Pekarofski. Tuesdays, 2:30 5:20 p.m., LSC 103

WESTERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

CIEE Warsaw, Poland. Course name: Polish Society & Politics Course number:

Comparative Elections (CPO 4072) Spring 2017

CIEE in St. Petersburg, Russia. Russian History: Perestroikas in Russia from the 9th to 20th Century Course number:

Fall 2017 McGill University. Dr. Mark A. Wolfgram Office: TBD Phone: TBD Office Hours: MW 11:15-12:15pm

Learning Outcomes/ Standards Having followed the history course at the higher or standard level, students will be expected to:

Preface to Cold War. Preface

Contemporary Issues in Law: Law and Human Rights in Central Europe Syllabus Spring 2011

COLGATE UNIVERSITY. POSC 153A: INTRODUCTION TO COMPARATIVE POLITICS (Spring 2017)

WESTERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE. Professor Gregory Baldi Morgan Hall g Telephone: (309)

THE EASTERN EUROPE AND THE USSR

Two 1 20 sessions per week (Tuesdays & Thursdays, 2:20-3:35 p.m.)

CIEE Global Institute Berlin

Optional Course Text: Eric Foner, Give Me Liberty! (New York: W.W. Norton) Any edition works.

Russian and Post-Soviet Politics

Social Movements, Contentious Politics, and Democracy

PSC 305: Judicial Politics

GOVT 133 INTRODUCTION TO COMPARATIVE POLITICS George Mason University FALL 2017 TTH 1:30 2:45 p.m. Lecture Hall 1

UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO Fall 2010 POL 414 H 1 F / H 1 F POLITICS OF INDEPENDENT UKRAINE. Instructor: Olga Kesarchuk

CIEE in Prague, Czech Republic

Democracy and Markets in Developing Countries 790:395:10

PSC 306, Fall 2013 Prof. James E. Campbell. 14 Knox Hall :00 8:50pm Wednesdays

COURSE PROGRAM I. IDENTIFICATION

DICTATORSHIPS IN THE FORMER SOVIET UNION: TRANSITIONAL MISHAP OR INTENTIONAL DESIGN?

Transcription:

Eastern European Politics POLI 359/INTL390 College of Charleston Political Science/International Studies Spring 2015 Instructor: Dr. Max Kovalov E-mail: kovalovm@cofc.edu Class time: TR 12:15 pm 1:30 pm Office: 26 Coming St., Political Science Annex, Room 301 Office hours: TR 1:45 pm-2:45 and by appointment Classroom: Maybank Hall 316 Course Description The course examines the developments of contemporary politics across Eastern and Central European countries. These states have undergone a dramatic transformation since World War II - politically, economically, and socially. In order to understand these developments, this course looks at how East Central European states came under the dominance of the Soviet Union, how the rebellious societies contested and resisted the communist regimes, and finally, how those regimes collapsed in the late 1980s. We will also examine the most recent transformations the integration with the western world through memberships in NATO and the European Union, the color revolutions of the early 21 st century, and recent tensions in relations between Russia and the West. The goal of the course is to introduce students to the major themes of totalitarianism, the spheres of influence, democratic transitions and its challenges, path dependence and importance of historical legacies in analyzing the post-communist regimes. Expectations I expect students to attend classes and participate in discussions. Each student's participation in this class is essential for its success, and good participation requires good preparation. All students are expected to read the assigned material prior to each class. Reading quizzes will be administered weekly to keep students accountable for the reading material. Course materials All the reading material is available through OAKS. Grading 1) Active participation in class discussions (15%). 2) Country reports + keeping up with current events in the country of choice (5%). 3) Reading quizzes (20%). 4) Paper proposal + annotated bibliography (5%). Due on March 12 in class + electronic copy should be uploaded to Dropbox. 5) Research paper (15%). Paper topics must be discussed and approved by the instructor. Due on April 16 in class. The paper should also be uploaded to Dropbox through OAKS. 6) Midterm exam (20%). 7) Final exam (20%). May 5, 12pm-3pm. 1

Grade scale A =94-100; A-= 90-93; B+=87-89; B=83-86; B-=80-82; C+=77-79; C=73-76; C-=70-72; D+=67-69; D=63-66; D-=60-62; F<60. Assignments 1) Participation in class discussions The success of this class depends on your active participation. Students are expected to read the assigned material prior to each class and be ready for active participation in discussions. 2) Country reports + current events discussions During the first week of the semester each student will select one Eastern European and will follow current events in this country throughout the semester. Once every few weeks students will give a 5-7 minute presentation on current events in the selected country. You may report on political, economic, social developments or relations with other countries. You will be expected to have an in-depth knowledge of a recent event or phenomena rather than just a reporting a headline, so be prepared to describe and explain what happened and why (remember 5-Ws: who, where, when, what, and why). Be ready for questions from other students. 3) Reading quizzes Reading quizzes will be offered periodically throughout the semester. 4) Research paper You need to pick a topic of interest and examine a particular issue in a country of Eastern Europe in a 6-8-page paper. You may develop a research topic as you read the weekly assignments. The topic of your interest does not have to include the most recent developments in your countries of choice. For example, you may choose to examine the choice of institutional arrangements in Eastern European states (presidential or parliamentary system design) or compare two similar (in most aspects) countries in order to explain differences in economic development, civic engagement, political outcomes, etc. Paper topics must be discussed with and approved by the instructor. You can find the paper guidelines in OAKS under Content. 5) Paper proposal + annotated bibliography A 1-page description of the research topic must be submitted by March 12 in class and uploaded to Dropbox via OAKS. This description should clearly state: a. Your research question or puzzle; b. The cases (countries) you examine; c. The importance of the research question. d. An annotated bibliography. See an example in OAKS under Content. Course/University Policies Students with Disabilities: The College will make reasonable accommodations for persons with documented disabilities. Students with disabilities must be registered with the Center for Disability Services / SNAP, located on the first floor of the Lightsey Center, Suite 104 prior to receiving accommodations in this course. Any student in this course who has a disability that may prevent them from fully demonstrating their abilities should contact the instructor personally as soon as possible to discuss accommodations necessary to ensure full participation and facilitate their educational opportunities. Academic Integrity: Lying, cheating, attempted cheating, and plagiarism are violations of our Honor Code that, when identified, are investigated. Each incident will be examined to determine the degree 2

of deception involved. Incidents where the instructor determines whether the student s actions are related more to a misunderstanding will be handled by the instructor. A written intervention designed to help prevent the student from repeating the error will be given to the student. The intervention, submitted by form and signed both by the instructor and the student, will be forwarded to the Dean of Students and placed in the student s file. Cases of suspected academic dishonesty will be reported directly by the instructor and/or others having knowledge of the incident to the Dean of Students. A student found responsible by the Honor Board for academic dishonesty will receive a XF in the course, indicating failure of the course due to academic dishonesty. This grade will appear on the student s transcript for two years after which the student may petition for the X to be expunged. The F is permanent. The student may also be placed on disciplinary probation, suspended (temporary removal) or expelled (permanent removal) from the College by the Honor Board. Students should be aware that unauthorized collaboration--working together without permission-- is a form of cheating. Unless the instructor specifies that students can work together on an assignment, quiz and/or test, no collaboration during the completion of the assignment is permitted. Other forms of cheating include possessing or using an unauthorized study aid (which could include accessing information via a cell phone or computer), copying from others exams, fabricating data, and giving unauthorized assistance. Research conducted and/or papers written for other classes cannot be used in whole or in part for any assignment in this class without obtaining prior permission from the instructor. Students can find the complete Honor Code and all related processes in the Student Handbook at http://studentaffairs.cofc.edu/honor-system/studenthandbook/index.php Avoiding Plagiarism Plagiarism falls into two categories: using someone else s words or using someone else s ideas as if they were your own. You must be scrupulous in avoiding both categories of plagiarism in your writing. Properly cite all quotations, paraphrases, and summaries of information from other sources. The only exception to this rule is common knowledge, or information commonly known and accessible to your audience If you are unsure whether certain information constitutes common knowledge, document it. Collusion, a form of plagiarism, occurs when two or more people agree to devise a piece of writing that will be attributed to only one of them For any individual writing assignment, the idea and the organization of ideas in your paper must be your own You can incorporate into your writing ideas that have arisen from class discussion [and] lectures You may revise and edit your writing with other people but you should not have others do your writing or revising for you. 1 Laptop and digital device policy I request that students not use laptops or other digital devices in class, unless I ask students to bring a laptop. If you absolutely have to take notes using your laptop, talk to me after class. Changes to syllabus I reserve the right to make minor changes to the syllabus during the semester. Any changes will be announced in class and via email. 1 Frank O Hare and Edward A. Kline, The Modern Writer s Handbook, Fourth Edition, Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 1996, pp. 447-450. 3

Class Schedule and Reading Assignments Week 1 January 13. Introduction, structure of the course January 15. Cold War 2.0 and the Revival of Spheres of Influence The Economist. Diplomacy and Security after Crimea: The New World Order. March 22, 2014. Mcfaul, Michael A. 2014. Confronting Putin s Russia. The New York Times. March 23, 2014. Mearsheimer, John. 2014. How the West Caused the Ukraine Crisis. Foreign Affairs 93(5): 77-89. Recommended The Economist. Putin s Inferno. February 22, 2014. Dunn, Elizabeth Cullen, and Michael S. Bobick. 2014. The Empire Strikes Back: War without War and Occupation without Occupation in the Russian Sphere of Influence. American Ethnologist 41(3): 405 13. _ Week 2 January 20. Eastern European Democracies 20 years after Communism Rupnik, Jacques, and Jan Zielonka. 2013. Introduction: The State of Democracy 20 Years on. Domestic and External Factors. East European Politics & Societies 27(1): 3 25. January 22. History and background Stokes, Gale. 1998. Eastern Europe s Defining Fault Lines. In Eastern Europe: Politics, Culture, and Society Since 1939, Indiana University Press, 15 34. Verdery, Katherine. 1996. What Was Socialism, and Why Did It Fall? In The Revolutions of 1989, Oxford University Press: 63-88. Recommended: Gregory, Paul R. 1990. The Stalinist Command Economy. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science: 18 25. Janos, Andrew C. 1996. What Was Communism: A Retrospective in Comparative Analysis. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 29(1): 1 24. Week 3 January 27. World War II and its effects Yalta, in Stokes, G. 1996. From Stalinism to Pluralism: A Documentary History of E. Europe since 1945: 12-27 Gross, Jan T. 1989. Social Consequences of War: Preliminaries to the Study of Imposition of Communist Regimes in East Central Europe. East European Politics & Societies 3(2): 198 214. Watch film on OAKS: Comrades 1917-1945 (from CNN Cold War series) 4

January 29. Communists in Power: The Two Camps and Spheres of Influence Rothschild (2000) The Communists Come to Power (from Rothschild, Joseph. 2000. Return to Diversity: A Political History of East Central Europe Since World War II. Oxford University Press, 75-103. Bohlen "Poland at the Teheran Conference" in Stokes (28-30) Churchill "The Percentages Agreement" in Stokes (30-31) Truman "The Truman Doctrine" in Stokes (33-37) Zhdanov "The Two-Camp Policy" in Stokes (38-42) Berman "The Case for Stalinism" in Stokes (44-50) Watch film on OAKS: Iron Curtain (1945-47) Week 4 February 3. Communists in Power-2 Rothschild (2000) The Communists Come to Power (from Rothschild, Joseph. 2000. Return to Diversity: A Political History of East Central Europe Since World War II. Oxford University Press, pp. 103-125 Film: Eastern Europe & Marshall Plan - watch the first 30 minutes February 5. State Against Society: Early Revolutions Valenta, Jiri. 1984. Revolutionary Change, Soviet Intervention, and Normalization in East-Central Europe. Comparative Politics 16(2): 127 51. Demands of the Hungarian Students in 1956. From Report of the Special Committee on the Problem of Hungary, UN General Assembly Brezhnev "The Brezhnev Doctrine" in Stokes (131-134) Watch film on OAKS: Hungarian Revolution and Prague Spring Week 5 February 10. Polish Solidarity Readings TBD Watch film on OAKS: A Force More Powerful Series. Poland: "We've Caught God by the Arm" February 12. The Communist Collapse: Revolutions of 1989 Gorbachev "A Common European Home" in Stokes (265-267) Chirot, Daniel. 1990. What Happened in Eastern Europe in 1989? PRAXIS International : 278 305. Watch film on OAKS: The Wall Comes Down (1989) Week 6 February 17-19. The Politics of Economic Reform: Gradualism vs Shock Therapy Aslund, Anders. 2002. Strategic Policy Choices. In Building Capitalism: The Transformation of the Former Soviet Bloc, Cambridge University Press, 70 112. Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2003. Who Lost Russia. In Globalization and Its Discontents, W. W. Norton & Company, 133 65. Film: Commanding Heights: The Agony of Reform Recommended Sharon Fisher, Re-Creating the Market, in Wolchik and Curry, eds., pp. 53-81. Elizabeth Dunn, Privatizing Poland: baby food, big business, and the remaking of labor, Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2004, pp. 28-57, 64. 5

February 24. Midterm exam Week 7 February 26. Working with library resources Bring your laptop computers. March 1-8 Spring Break Week 8 March 10. Disintegration of Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia, and the Soviet Union Ulc, Otto. 1996. Czechoslovakia s Velvet Divorce. East European Quarterly 30(3): 331-352. Shevtsova, Lilia. 1992. The August Coup and the Soviet Collapse. Survival 34(1). March 12. Bunce, Valerie. 1999. Peaceful versus Violent State Dismemberment: A Comparison of the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, and Czechoslovakia. Politics & Society 27(2): 217 37. Recommended: Sharon Wolchik, The Czech and Slovak Republics: Two Paths to the Same Destination, in Wolchik and Curry, eds., pp. 187-209. Zsuzsa Cserg Ethnicity, Nationalism, and the Expansion of Democracy, in Wolchik and Curry, top 91; bottom 96-99. Gale Stokes, The Devil s Finger: The Disintegration of Yugoslavia, in The Walls Came Tumbling Down: The Collapse of Communism in Eastern Europe, New York: Oxford University Press, 1993, pp. 218-232 March 12: 1-page research proposals+ annotated bibliographies are due. Bring hard copies of proposals to class on March 13 and upload an electronic version to Dropbox. Week 9 March 17. Ethnicity and Nationalism Brown, James F. 2001. The Grooves of Change: Eastern Europe at the Turn of the Millennium. Duke University Press, 162-200. Barany, Zoltan D. 1994. Living on the Edge: The East European Roma in Postcommunist Politics and Societies. Slavic Review 53(2): 321 44 March 19. The Politics of Gender Marilyn Rueschemeyer, Women s Participation in Postcommunist Politics, in Wolchik and Curry, eds., pp. 109-121. Gülçür, Leyla, and Pınar İlkkaracan. 2002. The Natasha Experience: Migrant Sex Workers from the Former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe in Turkey. Women s Studies International Forum 25(4): 411 21. Recommended: Hughes, Donna. 2014. Supplying Women for the Sex Industry: Trafficking from the Russian Federation In Sexuality and Gender in Postcommunist Eastern Europe and Russia, eds. Edmond J. Coleman and Theo Sandfort. Routledge. 6

Week 10 March 24. Incomplete Democratization and Problems with Transitions Levitsky, Steven and Lucan Way. 2002. The Rise of Competitive Authoritarianism. Journal of Democracy 13(2): 51 65. Recommended Diamond, Larry Jay. 2002. Thinking About Hybrid Regimes. Journal of Democracy 13(2): 21 35. March 26. Derailed Democracy or Successful Competitive Authoritarianism in Russia Hanson, Stephen E. 2011. Plebiscitarian Patrimonialism in Putin s Russia Legitimating Authoritarianism in a Postideological Era. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 636(1): 32 48. Kotz, David. 2015. Plummeting Oil Prices Could Bring Radical Change to Russia. What Comes Next? The Nation. January 5, 2015. Week 11 March 31-April 2. Color Revolutions D Anieri, P. 2006. Explaining the Success and Failure of Post-Communist Revolutions. Communist and post-communist studies 39(3): 331 50. Way, Lucan. 2008. The Real Causes of the Color Revolutions. Journal of Democracy 19(3): 55 69. Week 12 April 7-9. Georgia, Euromaidan, Crimea, and Ukraine-Russia conflict King, Charles. 2008. The Five-Day War: Managing Moscow After the Georgia Crisis. Foreign Affairs 87(6): 2 11. Onuch, Olga. 2014. Who Were the Protesters? Journal of Democracy 25(3): 44 51. Leshchenko, Sergii. 2014. The Media s Role. Journal of Democracy 25(3): 52 57. Kudelia, Sergiy. 2014. Ukraine in Context: What Happens When Authoritarians Fall. Foreign Affairs, February 27, 2014 Recommended Kudelia, Serhiy. The House That Yanukovych Built. Journal of Democracy 25(3): 19 34. Putin, Vladimir. 1999. Why We Must Act. The New York Times. November 14, 1999. Week 13 April 14. Civil Society Howard, Marc M. 2003. The Weakness of Civil Society in Post-Communist Europe. Cambridge University Press. (Chapters 2 and 3) April 14. Howard. The Weakness of Civil Society in Post-Communist Europe. (Chapter 6) April 16. Research Papers due. Bring hard copies of papers to class and upload an electronic version of the paper to Dropbox. 7

Week 14 April 21-23. Integration with the West: NATO and EU memberships Barany, Zoltan D. 2004. NATO s Peaceful Advance. Journal of Democracy 15(1): 63 76. Zielonka, Jan. 2004. Challenges of EU Enlargement. Journal of Democracy 15(1): 22 35. May 5, 12 pm-3pm. Final exam 1 Citation 2 Topic 3 Research question 4 Countries 5 Findings (brief description) Annotated Bibliography Template Notes: 1. Full bibliographic reference using a standard style such as APSA, APA, MLA, etc. 2. Use just two or three words. Examples: transition from authoritarianism, economic liberalization, political economy, political parties, etc. 3. State briefly the central research question of the book chapter/article 4. List the countries studied. Examples: Russia, Poland, Czech Republic, Hungary Slovakia and the Czech Republic. 5. Write a short (3-5 sentences) summary of the most important findings of the research. What was learned from this study? 8