uu c c SOAH Docket No Docket No Cities' 16th, Q. # 16-5e Attachment Sub Part e Page 46 of 75

Similar documents
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA AT RICHMOND, FEBRUARY 21, 2018 FINAL ORDER. On July 13, 2017, Reynolds Group Holdings Inc. ("Reynolds") filed with the State

STAATSKOERANT, 3 APRIL 2012 GOVERNMENT NOTICE DEPARTMENT OF POLICE SECOND-HAND GOODS ACT, 2009 REGULATIONS FOR DEALERS AND RECYCLERS

The Economic and Scientific Context of Quality Improvement and Six Sigma

Sabrina Oliver Chapel Hill Town Clerk Town of Chapel Hill, N.C. Sabrina:

Charles H. Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management Cornell University, Ithaca, New York USA

FINAL PROJECT REPORT. University of Delaware Disaster Research Center. # 10 ENVIRONMENTAL CRISES Russell R. Dynes and Dennis E.

Migrants Movement. Introduction to Trade Unions for Migant Workers. February 24th-25th 2011

Virginia State Corporation Commission efiling CASE Document Cover Sheet

Minnesota. State Register. (Published every Monday (Tuesday when Monday is a holiday.)

Classification and Regression Approaches to Predicting United States Senate Elections. Rohan Sampath, Yue Teng

MEMORANDUM OF INCORPORATION OF COMENSA NPC REGISTRATION NUMBER 2005/017895/08

6.3.4 Discretionary Service Agreement WR CIAC Tracking 29760

COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA. AT RICHMOND, JUNE 12,2018 Se'G- CLERK'S twrce 1 PETITION OF ORDER ADOPTING REGULATIONS

Control Number : Item Number : 10. Addendum StartPage : 0. ii..

D 0 ST S. SCHELL A'fl'oiiSKYs Al- LAW. m o m rn o. June 25, VfA HAND DELIVERY

Pennsylvania Residential and Small Commercial Contract Summary and Terms of Service

Maimarktgelände Mannheim. 20th 22nd July 2018

FORM A: BID (See B9)

INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLETING PETITION FOR GUARDIANSHIP OF THE PERSON AND/OR PROPERTY OF AN ALLEGED DISABLED PERSON (CC-GN-002)

EEOC v. Presrite Corporation

% a 3. 9?a ia jv-[ a a. ,,r^b VC^I IIII. VjvA' aa. # a,!

McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC

OUR ELECTRICITY AGREEMENT Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. P.O. Box 4911, Houston, TX 77210

HQPE and the journal literature in the history of economic thought

Global Production Sharing and Rising Inequality: A Survey of Trade and Wages*

Spark Energy, LLC RESIDENTIAL AND SMALL COMMERCIAL CUSTOMER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

Pennsylvania Residential Contract Summary and Terms of Service - ELECTRIC

Welfare-Consistent Global Poverty Measures

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS SARPY COUNTY, NEBRASKA

ATTORNEYS AT LAW IOO PINE STREET P. O. BOX 1166 HARRISBURG, PA TELEPHONE ( FAX http ://www. m wn.

Massachusetts Residential and Small Commercial Terms of Service

Bounds on Welfare-Consistent Global Poverty Measures

Utility Regulation in the District of Columbia

The Commission met on Tuesday, December 21, 2010, with Chair Boyd and Commissioners O Brien, Pugh, Reha, and Wergin present. TELECOMMUNICATIONS AGENDA

Geographical Indications and The Trade Related Intellectual Property Rights Agreement (TRIPS): A Case Study of Basmati Rice Exports

TEL (503) FAX (503) Suite S.W. Taylor Portland, OR November 8, 2007

EXHIBIT L FORM OF VIOLATIONS PROCESSING SERVICES AGREEMENT

Gas Compliance Reporting Manual. Energy Coordination Act 1994

2 Gender, Poverty, and Wealth

European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions

DeGolyer and MacNaughton 5001 Spring Valley Road Suite 800 East Dallas, Texas 75244

DOES AUSTRALIAN LAW RECOGNISE PUBLIC LITIGATION?

11. Labour Market Discrimination

The executive director has declared the above referenced application received on September 9, 2009, administratively complete on?.

Determinants of Unemployment in the Philippines 1

SEP 3 Q P.S.C. W.VA. M.C. FORMNO. 6 (M.C. Rule 9.1.h.) FILING FEE: $ PHONE: TRUX FAX: (304) (For PSC use only)

Ethnic Disparities in the Graduate Labour Market

Complaint Handling Process

2 No PROVINCIAL GAETTE, 18 JUNE 2018

TEL (503) FAX (503) Suite SW Taylor Portland, OR April 24, 2008

Factor Content of Intra-European Trade Flows

Audiencia Publica. Si necesita ayuda para comprender esta informacion, por favor /lame Historic Design Review Case No.

CITY OF TIMMINS BY- LAW BEING A BY- LAW for licensing, regulating and governing taxi and limousine owners, brokers and drivers in

TARIFF FOR WHOLESALE TRANSMISSION SERVICE. CenterPoint Energy Houston Electric, LLC 1111 LOUISIANA P. O. BOX 1700 HOUSTON, TEXAS 77251

CONSOLIDATED TRANSMISSION OWNERS AGREEMENT. RATE SCHEDULE FERC No. 42

New York Residential Fixed Electricity Terms and Conditions

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVAN

#complainthandlingpolicy

May 16, 2006 ADVICE 2002-E (U 338-E) PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ENERGY DIVISION

8.130, 8.201, 8.235, 8.310, and 8.315, relating to General Applicability and Standards; Definitions;

1%(5:25.,1*3$3(56(5,(6 */2%$/352'8&7,216+$5,1*$1'5,6,1*,1(48$/,7< $6859(<2)75$'($1':$*(6 5REHUW&)HHQVWUD *RUGRQ++DQVRQ

Telecommunications Complaint Handling Process

Service om mission. f West Virginia. October 23,201 8

Ambit Northeast, LLC Illinois ComEd Service Area

CARRIER-TO-CARRIER AGREEMENT CHECKLIST

STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA

Complaint Handling Process

Immigration Policy and Counterterrorism

Calendar Year 2014 PacifiCorp News Feed OASIS Postings

Agreement for Net Metering and Interconnection Services (Level 1, 2 and 3 Interconnection)

IEEE POWER ENGINEERING SOCIETY TECHNICAL COUNCIL ORGANIZATION AND PROCEDURES MANUAL. Revision: July 2003

Oracle FLEXCUBE Bills User Manual Release Part No E

COMPETITIVE ENERGY SUPPLIER SERVICE AGREEMENT

BHOPAL MEMORIAL HOSPITAL & RESEARCH CENTRE

CLERK OF COURT PROCEDURES & FILES POLICY

Ambit Northeast, LLC Pennsylvania National Fuel Gas - PA Service Area Residential Disclosure Statement and Terms of Service

Control Number : Item Number : 1. Addendum StartPage : 0

July 5, PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., Docket No. ER17- Amendment to Service Agreement No. 4597; Queue No. AB2-048

IPONZ Information for Clients Issue 34: 30 December 2004

AGENDA MEETING OF THE CITY OF CAPE CORAL AUDIT COMMITTEE

Analysis of Gender Wage Differential in China s Urban Labor Market

ACCESS TO PORT PUBLIC RECORDS

HOLMES & GRAVEN CHARTERED. 470 Pllbbury Center, Minneapolis, Minnemta (612) Facsimile (612) WRITER'S DIRECT DIAL

California Independent System Operator Corporation Fifth Replacement Tariff. Appendix B.8 Utility Distribution Company Operating Agreement (UDCOA)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA LEVEL 1 INTERCONNECTION APPLICATION & AGREEMENT

Control Number : Item Number : 5. Addendum StartPage : 0

Southern California Edison Original Cal. PUC Sheet No E Rosemead, California (U 338-E) Cancelling Revised Cal. PUC Sheet No.

STATE OF TEXAS COUNTIES OF DENTON AND TARRANT. Kevin R. Carr Greg Wilson Jim Hase Jim Thomas Bill Rose

STATE OF ILLINOIS ILLINOIS COMMERCE COMMISSION

BEFORE THE OREGON PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION

This manual represents a print version of the Online Filing Help.

TRANSBAY JOINT POWERS AUTHORITY BOARD OF DIRECTORS MINUTES. Thursday, January 11, Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 416 San Francisco, CA

IEEE Standards Association (IEEE) Policies and Procedures for: PES Electric Machinery Committee Working Groups (Revision 7)

America s Historical Landmarks

M E M O R A N D U M. NFPA 99 Second Draft Technical Committee FINAL Ballot Results (A2017 Cycle)

Improving the Accuracy of the Trademark Register: Request for Comments on Possible

Privacy Impact Assessment. April 25, 2006

P and V(p w,y) V(p,y) for at least one-half the measure of

DTE Energy Company One Energy Plaza, 688 WCB Detroit, MI October 21, 2016

BRICKWORK APARTMENTS BODY CORPORATE

Transcription:

F F a l 2 2 uu c c SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 46 of 75 5

zz zz 2% 29 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Cities' 16th, Q. ## 16-5e Attachent Sub Part e Page 47 of 75 3 E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O O O O O O O O O O O O O O db9tetewteb?teb?b?b?teb+~teteb?b?"... 51

g c SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 48 of 75 a 22 c uu 52

U I a 5!

I 1

55 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 51 of 75

SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 52 of 75

SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 53 of 75 l----l I c

SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 54 of 75 IC1.lc c c c uuuu C K C C uuuu

Exaples of why AEP invoices are failing TX SET Validation @ ED1 Per 8 1-2 TX SET, The SAC8 ultiplied by the SAC1 ust always equal the SAC5. 1. Invoice # 94X32677 12232923 1 ($o,sw+~~ SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Cities 16th, Q. # 16-5e Attachent Sub Part e Page 55 of 75 You can se that 229.91 * 1 does not equal 1229.91 (the decial is iplied in the SACOS) 2. Invoice# 94x222 14 1649 1976 $1,982.97 Here s a snapshot the transaction: 2882821 4g4X28221 4881 648919Q769483278~~28213284924131986 PA88 AI 3Texas Set Val i dati an error P5 I 8327~9487981381 8s CETRAL POWER & LIGHT 1 887924772 SJ RELIAT EERGY SOLUTIOS 1 616498114 2882321 1 SVEL C3RAT WH 857 158288281 15 151 2882821 2 1 A C C C C C C C C C C C EUBAS883 EUEAS881 EUD IS881 E U R R R 8 8 8 EURRROB6 EURRRBOI E U M S C 8 2 4 E U M S C 8 2 2 EUT AOBI EURRR888 EURRR886 e98 257 111442-1 638-6698 - 8793 391 5 78864 31 156-453 -1853 8.98 2.57 3.27-16.38-66.98 -,258.888662 2.85588.97-4.53-18.53 EA1 ERI K1348. El EA1 EA1 KH341 KH5Y1 36 KH341 K1321.2 EA1 EA1

Let s focus on charge code RRROO1: SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Cities 16th, Q. # 16-5e Attachent Sub Part e Page 56 of 75 -.258 * 341 does not equal -87.93 6

Matthew L Gerick 12/24/23 751 AM To : cc: Subject: Jeffery S Stracener/AEPI@AEPI Cities 16-5(e) Reliant Rejects... Matt Gerick, PE, CEM C R R Account Engineer Aerican Electric Power Copetitive Retailer Relations P.O. Box 2121 Corpus Christi, TX 7843 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 57 of 75 Corpus Office: 361-693-255 Corpus Fax: 361-881 -577 Victoria Office: 361-574-2252 Victoria Fax: 361-574-2292 Eail: lgerick@aep.co http:llwww.aep.co "---- Forwarded by Matthew L GericklAEPl on 12/24/23 7:5 AM ----- Matthew L Gerick 1/8/23 1 :37 PM To: cc: Subject: "Pond, Ji" cjpond@reliant.co> Re: FW: AEP unpaid files Ji, Here is a status report of the 144 rejects for Reliant, but we still have soe work to do to finish out the ones highlighted in yellow. I a working with Ji Purdy to investigate your dispute list so we can eliinate the back log of probles. 61

a P 5. 7... I

i I 1 a ala a: a E'K,a: 9 sisi$ I I, I, IS i2 2 r I $ $ $'$,S i 1 1. /Po S $,$ 2 S' $ $/1!p $ o '?????????????e??? cn o o o!o. o, 1 ' lcn'ffl v) v): cn v)!alw,w w w w w w w u UII- I- I- i- I- I- I- I- F I= jf 3 f f 5'3'5 f 2,.KaKKKa:Ka:n 9lv) (I) v)icnjv) v) Iv)Iv) v) v) v)/ v) v) v)jv)'v)iu JIW w w,w w w w w w w w w w w w w w up -'i- I- i- I- I- i- I-!I- I- I- i- I-[+ I- I- I- I-!- 5 f f 3,f 3 3 513 1 3lf@i3 I f f I, f f f! c a K K a:ie LY a K a a K K a: E'K'LY a n

B :. r SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 61 of 75 P c P

Jeffery S Stracener 12l24l23 2:2 PM To: cc: Subject: David L Hooper/AEPI@AEPI Cities 16-5(e) Calpine Rejects Jeff Stracener Supervisor Custoer Service (361) 881-5739 ----- Forwarded by Jeffery S StracenerlAEPl on 12/24/23 2:2 PM ----- Matthew L Gerick 12/24/23 759 AM To: Jeffery S Stracener/AEPI@AEPI cc: Subject: Cities 16-5(e) Calpine Rejects Matt Gerick, PE, CEM CRR Account Engineer ADS rejected the following invoices because they said didn't receive the 814-2. Our records indicated we did send the 814-2.... Aerican Electric Power Copetitive Retailer Relations P.O. Box 2121 Corpus Christi, TX 7843 Corpus Office: 361-693-255 Corpus Fax: 36 1-881 -577 Victoria Office: 361-574-2252 Victoria Fax: 361-574-2292 Eail: lgerick@aep.co http:llwww. aep.co SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 62 of 75 ----- Forwarded by Matthew L GericklAEPl on 12/24/23 753 AM ----- Matthew L Gerick 8/28/23 8:45 AM To : cc: Subject: Wanda.Gtice@alldata.net Unpaid invoices Wanda, We have sent the 814-2 transaction to process these invoices, but they are still showing up as unpaid. Could you let e know of a status report on these? L Matt Gerick, PE, CEM Custoer Service Engineer Aerican Electric Power P.O. Box 2121 Corpus Christi, TX 7843 Corpus Office: 361-693-255 Corpus Fax: 361-881 -577 Victoria Office: 361-574-2252 Victoria Fax: 361-574-2292 Ernail: lgerick@aep.co h ttp: llwww. ae p. co rn 66

d) D ii SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 63 of 75 C 2 d 67

68 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 64 of 75

"Keeler, Krista" ckkeeler@firstchoicepow To: "'rnlgerick@aep.co'" lgerick@aep.corn> er.co> cc: "Spooner, Gary" <GSpooner@tnpe.co>, "Gerdes, Ti" 4/1/23 6:12 PM Subject: <TGerdes@FirstChoicePower.co> AEP Invoice Reject Analysis Matt, I wanted to see where AEP is with the analysis of the rejected invoices by FCP? I have attached FCP's coents, which is the sae eail that we discussed a couple of weeks ago with Dee fro FCP. Thanks, Krista Krista Keeler First Choice Pozoe~ 41 lriternational Plaza Fort Worth, TX 7619 Phoiie: (817) 737-1331 Fax: (817) 737-1384 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 65 of 75 Matthew L Gerick 4/3/23 8:2 AM To: cc: Subject: "Keeler, Krista" <KKeeler@FirstChoicePower.co> Re: AEP Invoice Reject Analysis I believe we need to speak to Dee about these because in our syste your switch request processed and we show FCP as being the ROR. Apparently, your syste shows soething a little different which caused these rejected invoices. Do you have Dee nuber so I can get Ji to call her?... Matt Gerick, PE, CEM Custoer Service Engineer Aerican Electric Power P.O. Box 2121 Corpus Christi, TX 7843 -,...I 69

z 4 7 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 '. Docketo. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e.- Page66.of75 Z 3 (u I f I I f L P L al v) C.- + 1 *- C - 3 $ B c C.- c) f I :.' E 4-2s.2 z I f s p p p p rrrrr aaaa aaaa t n Y I v ) Y I I u I u I u P ) *>>> EEEEE a a a a a 2$22$ 88888 88888 flf6l EEEEE ZZZZs! O 8 8 8 8 8 5555 8 8 8 8 P 2 w 8 8 444: bbbls P P P P b b c; c; b h bbbb wwwg Z 5 Z s! Z Z Z Z ( W VI IC 6 IC 6 s! 3 W 8 W P s b In ul 2 2 i- VI W VI 7 r 3 $ 3 - - 28;;;; h b VIVI 332% V I V I W W 228s: O O - r K K S S 3 3 3 3

SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 67 of 75 hl L P v) C.- 1 E u 4 x h t._ 2 9 Y v) >" 2 W p. $! 2 R 2 r.?? r- (D 2 f IC 2 s 9 v) r r r 5? 1 8 5 > =: 8 3 W R r f Is 8 2 R i% x

SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 68 of 75 c P,.- F? 2 2 P P 8 % I 2 P z!? F P v ) 8 8 " u? h r. r - h $ t h h - 2 B E - B M r r 7 ::4 P v ) g 8 P P v) r. h IC 2 v) ln 7 h v) r ca 8 d >d 72

Matthew L Gerick 1/8/23 352 PM To: cc: Subject: "Keeler, Krista" <KKeeler@FirstChoicePower.co> Re: FW: AEP Invoices Krista, We cancelled the invoice with SUM and rebilled, but FCP took the cancel without taking the original into their syste. I a unsure how to clear these unless FCP can soe how pull these in and do soe anual intervention to get the loaded.... Matt Gerick, PE, CEM CRR Account Engineer SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 7 of 75 73

-----Original Message----- Fro: Keeler, Krista Sent: Friday, October 3, 23 5:13 PM To: Sheppard, Kristie; Black, Cathy; Spooner, Gary; Gerdes, Ti; Swening, Linda Subject: AEP Invoices I have established a new process for onitoring and organizing the Unpaid Invoices that FCP receives weekly fro the TDSP's. Please find the process docuent attached. Kristie, please investigate the invoices highlighted in green. Gary, please release all others for payent. I welcoe your feedback and questions. Thanks, Krista Krista Keeler First Choice Power 41 Lnturttntiorzal Plaza Fort Worth, 2'X 7619 Plione: (817) 737-1331 Cell: (517) 37-986 (LX: (83 7) 737-1 384 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 69 of 75 -----Original Message----- Fro: Spooner, Gary Sent: Wednesday, October 8, 23 8:33 AM To: Keeler, Krista; Sith, Lori Subject: RE: AEP Invoices Krista - The two 81 Invoices with Reject Code SUM - the TDSP needs to balance the 81 Invoice and resend. Most of these 81 Invoices were released 1/3/3 and brought into AP on 1/6/3 for payent. Others were released and paid earlier. Lori - Could you check on the A76 reject codes to validate y results? Thanks for the help. "Keeler, Krista" ckkeeler@firstchoicepower.cor To: "'lgerick@aep.co'" <lgerick@aep.co> 118/23 3:25 PM cc: Subject: FW: AEP Invoices Matt, Can you please resend the 81's with the SUM error corrected? Thanks, Krista 74

5 z 2 SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 71 of 75 a (I,. w -7 W ly...... r % a w I

> >>>>>>> > >. > >> >> SOAH Docket o 473-4-133 Docket o 2884 Cities' 16th, Q # 16-51? Attachent Sub Part e Page 72 of 75 o o OOCU arzc!a c!?cckc! cor- c! 2. u)

Jeffery S Stracener 12124123 2:2 PM To: Hooper/AEPI@AEPI cc: Subject: SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Cities' 16th, Q. ## 16-5e Attachent Sub Part e Page 73 of 75 David L Cities 16-5(e) Entergy (2) Jeff Stracener Supervisor Custoer Service (361) 881-5739 ----- Forwarded by Jeffery S StracenerlAEPl on 12/24/23 2:2 PM ----- Matthew L Gerick 12/24/23 8:12 AM To: Stracener/AEPI@AEPI cc: Subject: Jeffery S Cities 16-5(e) Entergy (2) Matt Gerick, PE, CEM CRR Account Engineer Aerican Electric Power Copetitive Retailer Relations P.O. Box 2121 Corpus Christi, TX 7843 Corpus Office: 361-693-255 Corpus Fax: 361-881-577 Victoria Office: 361-574-2252 Victoria Fax: 361-574-2292 Eail: lgerick@aep.co http:llwww.aep.co ----- Forwarded by Matthew L GericklAEPl on 12/24/23 8:ll AM ----- "VOGLER, REE A" <RVOGLER@entergy.co> To: "'lgerick@aep.co'" clgerick@aep.co>, 12/3/23 12:12 PM "WEAVER, STEVE" SWEAVEI @entergy.co>, "CAO-CO, LA" <Icao@entergy.co>, "PARET, LARRY C" <LPARET@entergy.co> cc: Subject: RE: Entergy's Rejects.._..-. I have ADS looking at the list to try and find soe issues and coon probles other than the standard reject reasons. Working with other TDSP's, it did not see to be just date issues. I will get with ADS and see if we can escalate the proble. Once they develop their inforation, we ay need to work directly with your 824linvoice person(s) for resolution. 77

I will get back with you. Ree Ann -----Original Message----- Fro: lgerick@aep.co [ailto:lgerick@aep.co] Sent: Wednesday, Deceber 3,23 12:7 PM TO: WEAVER, STEVE; CAO-CO, LA; VOGLER, REE A; PARET, LARRY C Subject: Entergy's Rejects SA.H Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 74 of 75 Ree Ann, We are receiving rejects everyday fro Entergy and want to get these to you, but there is nothing on our side we feel we can correct. I sent you a list a week or two ago and just wanted to know what we can do to ove these invoices to you. Here are soe ore exaples that we have received. Matt here is one you ay want to visit with Entergy about. (See attached file: Invoice Rejectsxls) 84 to work 11/17/3 and we copleted 11/25/3.... (See attached file: Invoice Rejects.xls) MVI for other REP 1/2/3 confired for 1/2/3. Final for Entergy 9/9/3 to 1/3/3. o corrective action required.... Everything our end is correct. There was a switch order sent back unexecutable. So Entergy is still the REP of Record. (See attached file: Invoice Rejectsxls)... (Ebedded iage oved to file: pic41.pcx) MVI sent by other REP cancelled but forced disconnect worked. Will need a new order sent for previous custoer - fni is valid. (Ebedded iage oved to file: pic1 8467.pcx) On cycle switch for other REP 11/13/3 - fnl 1/15/3 to 11/12/3.... (Ebedded iage oved to file: pic6334.p~~) ETRGY took over service 7/14/3 scheduled drop for 11/3/3 but sent back unexecutable because no access. Invoice 1/14/3 to 1111 1/3. 78

(Ebedded iage oved to file: pic265oo.p~~) SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Attachent Sub Part e Page 75 of 75 Related to a BSFEE & EDIV - ETRGY MVI 1113/3 to wk 1/17/3 coplete 1/27/3 - MSi 11/11/3... There is nothing wrong with our invoice so, no corrective action will be ade. Looks like one of there business rules is causing these to reject. (Ebedded iage oved to file: pic19169.pcx)(ebedded iage oved to file: picl 5724.pcx)(Ebedded iage oved to file: picl 1478.pcx) (Ebedded iage oved to file: pic29358.p~~) ESI 13278949339841 - received this invoice out of order but invoice is correct ESI 1327894898 - I81 5 date change fro 111 to 111 3, invoice is correct ESI 132789472943121 - received MVO/MVI fro other REP 1/8/3 to wk 111 /3 MVI Entergy 1/9 to wk 111 13 date altered to 111 3/3, invoice is correct.... *** Matt Gerick, PE, CEM C R R Account Engineer Aerican Electric Power Copetitive Retailer Relations P.O. Box 2121 Corpus Christi, TX 7843 Corpus Office: 361-693-255 Corpus Fax: 361-881 -577 Victoria Office: 361-574-2252 Victoria Fax: 361-574-2292 Eail: lgerick@aep.co http://www.aep.co 79

ED1824 82 Reject - Invoice Correction - Manual Process 1) oral Process MACSS produces invoice and usage essages (original and/or cancel-rebills) MACSS sends invoice data to DIPR AEP sends out invoice and usage essages to the MDCH MDCH translates into ED1 transactions - ED18 1 and ED1867 CR receives the invoice transaction fro AEP/MDCH ERCOT receives the usage transaction fro AEP/MDCH CR receives the usage transaction fro ERCOT SOAH Docket o, 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 Cities 16th, Q. # 76-3 Attachent Sub Part f Page 1 of 3 i 1 2) Invoice Reiect CR deterines rejection required of invoice transaction CR sends rejection transaction - ED1824 referencing the invoice nuber, reject reason code, and if appropriate, additional text 3) Reports MDCH creates a reject report daily - TX 824 Detail Report and sends it to a specific distribution list CCO-IT adds it to the folder - Reject Inforation - Usage and Invoice MACSS - Bill Output creates a weekly report - 68 Reject Report and sends it to a specific distribution list CCO-IT adds it to the folder - Reject Inforation - Usage and Invoice 4) Review and Analysis of Reiect CCO-IT and MACSS Bill Output reviews the weekly report to deterine corrective action on backlog Deterinations are ade for any scenarios that are occurring and can be reedied with a progra change CRR support is required: o To help clarify rejection reason fro CR o If questions/answers need to be addressed to the CR to agree upon a correction path o Business rules are ipacting the rejection and or correction path i 8 1

5) Invoice Correction Corrective action is cancelhebill - either BAO or TCCT would process cancel/rebills; this is the ore prevalent resolution due to current syste liitations; cancel(s) and rebill(s) flow to the CR and to DIPR Corrective action is a essage fix - EW - an IT Proposal has been approved to write a progra to allow for specific corrections (case by case basis) known as the 'FIX-IT' progra; the correction invoices will flow out to the CR and notification will be sent to DIPR to apply anual datafix. o action is needed by AEP - soe CR's have business validation that creates a reject to us and there is nothing to correct on the invoice1 1/3/3 3:37 PM11/3/3 3:38 PM 6) Copletion of Reiect Message Cancelhebill solution will autoatically coplete the rejected essage that atches the reject invoice nuber A weekly job (ipleentation 11/21/3) that atches DIPR paid invoices with rejected invoices will coplete the reject essage Manually, using EMSG, set the flag to 'C' for case by case copletion SOAH Docket o. 473-4-133 Docket o. 2884 1 ' Cities' 16th, Q. # 16-5f Attachent Sub Part f I Page2of3, Prepared by: Carole Root 1 1/3/3 81 2

SOAH Docket o. 473-4-1 33 Docket o. 2884 Cities' 16th, Q. # 16-5f Attachent Sub Part f Page 3 of 3.- a, >.- C U c ffl u E u) c Q 8 a -, 'T' C 82

SOAH DOCKET O. 473-4-133 PUC DOCKET O. 2884 APPLICATIO OF AEP TEXAS 8 BEFORE THE STATE OFFICE CETRAL COMPAY FOR OF AUTHORITY TO CHAGE RATES 5 ADMIISTRATIVE HEARIGS AEP TEXAS CETRAL COMPAY S RESPOSE TO CITIES SIXTEETH REQUEST FOR IFORMATIO Question o. 15: Follow up to Response to Cities 2-65. a. Explain fully how each of the three ethods Retail Custoers ay use to report outages, interruptions and irregularities to TCC do or do not ake their way into the Trouble Entry Reporting Syste. b. Provide all docuents, definitions and guidelines TCC uses to identify or decide whether the Retail Custoer call report is (1) an outage, (2) an interruption or (3) an irregularity. c. For each kind of report, outage, interruption and irregularity, explain fully whether the event does or does not ake its way into any reporting syste and, d. If classified as an outage, identify every TCC report, whether developed for internal TCC or AEP use or for external use by a public or non-profit agency for which the outage data is an upstrea (but not necessarily direct) input. Include the nae, purpose of and intended audience or uses for each report. e. If classified as an interruption, identify every TCC report, whether developed for internal TCC or AEP use or for external use by a public or non-profit agency for which the outage data is an upstrea (but not <. necessarily direct) input. Include the nae, purpose of and intended audience or uses for each report. f. If classified as an irregularity, identify every TCC report, whether developed for internal TCC or AEP use or for external use by a public or non-profit agency for which the outage data is an upstrea (but not necessarily direct) input. Include the nae, purpose of and intended audience or uses for each report. 1 83

PUC Docket o. 2884 Cities' 16th, Q. #15 Page 2 of 4 g. When easuring the duration of any outage, interruption or irregularity event, for each of the three ethods a Retail Custoer ay use to initiate a report, explain fully how TCC/AEP treats and easures for copliance reporting purposes: (1) the initial Retail Custoer call; (2) any delay between the initial Retail custoer call and TDSP receipt of callhotice; (3) TDSP receipt of callhotice. h. Provide all docuents analyzing the efficiency of REP or Retail Custoer notice and reporting of outage, interruption and irregularity events inforation to TCC. 1. What actions, if any, has TCC undertaken if any to increase the tieliness and accuracy of Retail Custoer and REP reporting of outage, interruption and irregularity events? Response o. 15: a. The Trouble Entry Reporting Syste (TERS) is a software progra utilized by TCC for the ain purpose of electronically capturing inforation associated with custoer service outageshnterruptions. Unique TERS entries are ade for each custoer call. When considering the response to this request, it is iportant to understand that the "three ethods that Retail Custoers ay usell to report outages are not left to the discretion of the custoer, but are decided by each Copetitive Retailer (CR). Each CR is responsible for inforing its retail custoers how to report outages using one of the three options. The three reporting options and associated entry into TERS are as follows: 1. Report taken solely by CR via telephone and electronically transitted to TCC -- electronic essage would be received by AEP and autoatically directed into TERS 2. Report taken by CR via telephone and call forwarded to AEP -- AEP Custoer Solutions Center Agent creates TERS entry 3. Report taken directly by AEP -- AEP Custoer Solutions Center Agent creates TERS entry if via phone conversation; TERS entry perfored autoatically through custoer inputs if via IVR (interactive voice response) phone call or via aepcustoer.co website visit Other service "irregularities" are responded to in a different anner, by creation of a field investigation order. These other service "irregularities" are captured and classified by the Custoer Solutions Center Agent based upon the custoer's description as "PART OUT", "DIM LIGHT", "FLICKERIG" and "BRIGHT- DIM". 84

PUC Docket o. 2884 Cities' 16th, Q. #15 Page 3 of 4 b. TCC uses IEEE Standard 1366, which is available fro IEEE's website at http://www.ieee.org as the guideline for classifying a Retail Custoer call report as a sustained outage/interruption. Other service irregularities are identified based on the custoer's description using classifications of "PART OUT", "DIM LIGHT", "FLICKERIG" and "BRIGHT-DIM". If there is not an outagehnterruption, then an "irregularity" can also be entered per custoer's description in the "O-TRBL" field. c. See response to a., above. d. TCC treats the ters "outage" and "interruption" as synonyous and does not separate custoer reports into an outage vs. interruption classification. TCC reports are developed to coply with PUCT Quality of Service reporting requireents and include annual outage indices/perforance easures as follows: Report ae Syste SAIFI Report Syste SAIDI Report Distribution Feeder 1 Indices - SAIFI Distribution Feeder Indices - SAIDI Purpose Meet PUCT Quality of Service reporting requireents Gauge syste perforance relative to regulatory requireents Meet PUCT Quality of Service reporting requireents Gauge syste perforance relative to regulatory requireents Meet PUCT Quality of Service reporting requireents. Identify highest (worst) 1% feeders Meet PUCT Quality of Service reporting requireents * Identify highest (worst) 1% feeders Intended Audience PUCT TCC Manageent PUCT TCC Manageent PUCT TCC Manageent PUCT TCC Manageent e. See response to d., above. f. TCC does not use an "irregularity" classification. on-outagehnterruption custoer reports are classified according to the custoer's description and 85

PUC Docket o. 2884 Cities' 16th, Q. #15 Page 4 of 4 forwarded to the field operations for follow-up. TCC has no such reports as requested. g. (1) - (3) The duration of an outage/interruption is easured fro the tie of the first notification to AEP to when field crews restore electric service. A service "irregularity" (PART OUT, DIM LIGHT, FLICKERIG and BRIGHT-DIM) duration is not easured. h. TCC is not aware of any such docuents. i. In addition to the iproveents identified in response to Cities' Second Request for Inforation, Question o. 65, there have been enhanceents to the processing of outage reports to expedite the restoration of service. Specifically, the Custoer Solutions Centers have installed enhanced IVR systes to autoatically enter outage data into TERS, ipleented upgraded high volue call answering systes to iprove custoer access for outage reporting and installed advanced call routing systes to transfer calls to agents across the AEP syste and suppleental outsourced call centers during ajor stors. Additionally, AEP recently enabled a web-based outage reporting syste to provide custoers with flirther options. Prepared By: David M. Gordon Jeffry L. Laine Sponsored By: Jeffry L. Laine Harry R. Gordon Title: Manager, Asset Perforance Title: Director, Custoer Choice Operations Title: Director, Custoer Choice Operations VP, Distribution Region Operations 86