REGULAR MEETING PALOMINO VALLEY GENERAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT PO BOX 615, SPARKS, NV 89432-0615 Thursday, July 21, 2016 MINUTES Larry Johnson called the regular meeting of the Palomino Valley General Improvement District (PVGID or GID) to order at 5:35 p.m. Thursday, July 21, 2016 at 21555 Pyramid Highway, Reno, Nevada. 1. Roll Call: Present were Marty Breitmeyer, Mitch Gerlinger, Peter Schmalzer and Larry Johnson. Dennis Magers was absent. Also present were Jim Hicks, Operations Manager; Maureen Sidley, Assistant to the Secretary; Cathy Glatthar, Assistant to the Board; and Louie Test, Legal Counsel. 2. Public Comment: Larry Johnson asked if there were any public comments? Hearing no requests, he moved to the next agenda item. 3. Approval of Minutes June 16, 2016 (Closed and Open Sessions) and June 27, 2016 (Special Meeting): Marty Breitmeyer made a motion to approve all three sets of minutes as written, and Peter Schmalzer seconded the motion. Hearing no opposition, the motion passed. 4. Financial Reports and Payment of Bills: a. Financial Reports: Maureen Sidley said there were quite a few bills this month, but there s still money in the bank for operating expenses. Larry Johnson explained that we deliberately held back money in order to remain solvent. Larry Johnson commented that Cathy Glatthar s report shows $14,000 remaining for capital improvements. Larry said, for the sake of the audience, this Board has adopted the philosophy of not stockpiling money, but to spend the money to improve roadways. b. Payment of Bills: Larry Johnson explained there was a special meeting held on June 27th to review the bids for this year s Road Rehabilitation Program. He said Sierra Nevada Construction (SNC) was the lowest bidder and the Board authorized up to $230,000 for the project. He explained the final bill was just a bit over budget at $231,939.60. He said quantities were reviewed and some additional work was done by SNC at no cost, because the road surface was not as rough as they had anticipated when they determined their bid price. He said there was an allowance for extra material, which he put towards patching on Right Hand Canyon Road. Mitch Gerlinger asked if the payment to Washoe County was for the water rights? Cathy Glatthar said it was and that this is for an annual administration fee. Mitch Gerlinger made a motion to pay the bills. Marty Breitmeyer seconded the motion, and hearing no opposition, the motion passed. 5. Road Discussions: a. Status of 2016 Road Rehabilitation Program: Larry Johnson said he was pleased to report the project has been completed on schedule and was performed in a professional manner. He explained there was good traffic control and minimal
amount of conflicts. He said we all had Jim Hicks to thank for all the patching work done before the micro-surfacing went down. Jim Hicks said the micro-surfacing went very well and that Larry should be thanked. Larry said everything came together. He said he hoped to get four years of performance out of this surfacing. He explained it s about one half inch thick and now we have about one inch of surfacing with the two layers. Larry read two Yelp reviews on SNC: The first was complimentary, but the second one from Sherry P. was not. Sherry P s comments were as follows: They need a negative star rating for this company. In May 2014 I wrote: Road is falling apart on the first mile of Ironwood Road in Palomino Valley. A year ago it started falling apart within months of being laid down; potholes and a foot on the edge of both sides of the road is crumbling. This road looks horrible and is quite literally falling apart. Updated in June 2015. The first mile of Ironwood Road is disintegrating. There are several holes where the road is gone - dirt, no asphalt. Nothing has been done. OK, they threw some patch on it a year ago but that lasted about a month. They got their dollars from the GID and me and that was it. Awful work in my opinion. I m sure other residents who won t take the time to post their comments feel the same. Larry said ignorance! He said apparently this individual doesn t understand this is 3/8ths of an inch of black coating put on dirt. He explained that no professional would ever recommend this ever be done, but we did it in an attempt to keep people from having to drive through axle-deep mud in the winter and not have billowing dust in the summer. He said this is the type of reviews we get and it turns his stomach. Cathy Glatthar thanked Larry for all he did on this project; all the miles he walked to determine what needed to be done. Many others agreed. Larry said he has the expertise and with Peter s help, they were able to put this plan together. He said that saves the GID many thousands of dollars in engineering costs. Peter Schmalzer explained there are pluses and minuses for each of these products, and the plus for this product is less disturbance. b. Axe Handle and Curnow Canyon Roads: Larry explained on Axe Handle Road the existing surface had to be resurfaced in order to save it. Connie Paullo, in the audience, said it looks beautiful. Larry asked Jim Hicks how much patch material was put down? Jim replied this month they put just over 30 tons down and about 9 tons this week. Larry said for next year, he will recommend upper Axe Handle above this year s project as first priority since it is the worst piece of existing pavement in the entire system. Larry said next year his plan is to surface with chip seal and slurry seal (the combination is called a Cape seal) probably the remainder of Axe Handle, the rest of Whiskey Springs, and the half mile of Right Hand Canyon. He cautioned that there might not be enough money to do it all. He said if there is not enough money, there are sections of Whiskey Springs that may last another year. He said his recommendation to the Board will be to spend what money is available after holding out a prudent reserve. Connie Paullo said she has neighbors calling her and they think this is new asphalt. Larry said it s micro-surfacing, not pavement. Ms. Paullo then asked what was put down on the section of Axe Handle above the mailboxes? Peter Schmalzer said it is called Otta seal. He added that three sections have been done with Otta seal; two sections on Ironwood and the one on Axe Handle. Larry said we probably won t do Otta seal again. Peter explained that the first Otta seal section on Ironwood has held up quite well, but the second section was a bit of a disaster, this product costs more and it is difficult to put down. Palomino Valley General Improvement District Regular Meeting July 21, 2016 2
Larry reiterated that we brought in some temporary grader operators to do the preparation work, because Jim was busy doing the patching work. c. Right Hand Canyon Road (RHCR): Larry explained he was able to have six areas and two edge strips of RHCR patched. Bud Lehmkuhl, in the audience, thanked the Board for the work that was done. Larry invited everyone to work with us in the springtime when we ll be working on next year s road improvement plans. d. Operations Manager's Report: Jim Hicks reported that for the next two weeks they will be grading exclusively because Dan will be going on vacation. Larry said one of the road maintenance requests was for patching on upper Whiskey Springs. Jim said that was done. Cathy Glatthar said we received a thank you email from the resident who made the request. Connie Paullo asked when Curnow Canyon would be graded? Jim said as soon as they can. 6. Old Business: a. Review Updated List of Residences Per Road and Discuss Possible Changes to Level of Maintenance: Larry Johnson mentioned the old resolution for seasonal roads and that the GID currently grades more often than that. Pam Willmore, in the audience, said she read that in the May minutes and said RHCR is used by more people than what those seasonal road standards would imply. Larry said that s true, but what we do with the entire road system is to keep all roads serviceable (he retold the stories of what was done for upper Quaking Aspen and Curnow Canyon Roads). Ms. Willmore asked if they were going to update the resolution to reflect what is being done now? Larry explained that is what they are doing with this agenda item. He said it s not as simple as how many residences are served by a particular road. He said some of these roads require more intense maintenance efforts because of the soil types. He said we try to weigh all of those factors when making these decisions. Larry said we try to answer road maintenance requests that come to us through our email request process in a timely manner. Peter Schmalzer explained we have a list of roads and their assigned level of maintenance. He said that report was last updated in 2009. He said the definitions for level of maintenance would not change, but wanted to know if the purpose of this agenda item was to consider changing some roads from a 2 to a 3, or from a 3 to a 2? Larry said no, we have 95 miles of roads and he said he wants everyone to look at the list and bring back input at the next meeting. He said then we can decide if we want to consider modifying these levels of maintenance. He said since 2011 there were only ten new houses built. Mitch Gerlinger said six of those new houses are in the new subdivision. Cathy Glatthar said she completed the summary and reviewed it as follows: Number of Residences using PVGID Maintained Roads 2011 = 487 2016 = 497 a change of 10 residences Cathy explained she made some corrections to the 2011 numbers because there were duplicates, and some outbuildings were counted as residences. She also stated she made a change in how Range Land was counted. She said the first time this was done, all residences were counted as using Range Land to access Pyramid Highway. She said that is not the case, and she split it up and all residences east of and including Rebel Cause were assumed to use Range Land to access Pyramid Highway, and the those residences on Range Land west of Rebel Cause were assumed to use Winnemucca Ranch Road to access Pyramid Highway. Palomino Valley General Improvement District Regular Meeting July 21, 2016 3
She referred to the following table, and said the percentages really didn t change much. She said Ironwood Road gained a small percentage because of the six new residences that use Ironwood Road. Residences Served Percentage 2011 2016 2011 2016 Ironwood Road 153 163 31% 33% Whiskey Springs Road 149 149 31% 30% Axe Handle Road 77 79 16% 16% Range Land Rd (East of Rebel Cause Rd) 29 27 6% 5% Miscellaneous Local Roads 79 79 16% 16% 487 497 100% 100% Larry said it reinforces our previous conclusions that Ironwood services the most residences, Whiskey Springs is second, Axe Handle is third, and Range Land is a distant fourth. Larry said he was surprised that there were so few new residences built in the past five years. 7. New Business: None 8. Judicial/Government Affairs: Louie Test said he had nothing to report. 9. Calendar Review: Cathy Glatthar reviewed the upcoming items: The Indebtedness Report is due on or before August 1st. Maureen Sidley said it has been completed. The Proof of Publication of the Annual Fiscal Reports must be sent to the Department of Taxation by August 14th. Maureen said it hasn t come in yet, but she will submit it. The Quarterly Economic Survey is due by August 15th. Maureen said that is done. Cathy wanted to discuss the timeline for the vacancy notice. She said an idea would be to prepare the notice in September, mail it on October 1st, and make the appointments in November. She said the new appointees terms would start in January 2017. She said they can do just a postcard mailing or have the vacancy notice combined with a newsletter. Larry suggested to keep it simple and do a postcard. Peter Schmalzer said there was a question about whether the resignation had to come before the notice of a vacancy; he wanted to know if that had been resolved? Cathy said it had been resolved and the vacancy notice can go out since these will be end of term vacancies and not interim resignations. Larry Johnson said he had asked Cathy to research if someone joined the Board who was an equipment operator, could they be hired on a temporary basis by the District. He said Cathy s opinion was yes they could, and he said he would like Louie Test to look at that. Cathy said she would get the information to Louie for his review. Louie said the law may say one thing, but the perception may not good. Palomino Valley General Improvement District Regular Meeting July 21, 2016 4
10. Correspondence: Cathy Glatthar reported the County is switching from the Permits Plus license/permit database to the Accela license/permit database on August 22nd. She said a course needs to be taken on how to use Accela, and Larry has asked her to take the training. She added that Larry asked her to make sure the GID was a sign off for building permits, planning, special use permits, etc. She said she sent an email to Community Services and received a response from Don Jeppson, Director of Building and Safety. She said Mr. Jeppson said the GID is not part of the building permit review process, and that they do not have a system set up for the GID and other outside agencies to have sign offs on building permits. She said they are developing an MOU (Memorandum of Understanding) for outside agencies but that will take until the end of the year to be up and running. She read a portion of the email from Mr. Jeppson: If the GID just wants to be notified when the County receives an application or final a permit, then perhaps that can be taken care of in a different manner. Larry said we could start there and just be notified. 11. Public Comment: Larry Johnson asked if there were any public comments? Hearing no requests, he moved to the next agenda item. 12. Board Member and Staff Items: Larry Johnson said he would not be able to attend the August 18th meeting. He asked if Thursday, August 11th would work for the rest of the Board? Marty Breitmeyer and Peter Schmalzer said the 11th would work for them. Mitch Gerlinger said he wasn t sure if he could make it on the 11th. Cathy said she would check to be sure the classroom is available and get the notice out three days in advance. Louie Test said he would not be able to attend on the 11th. 13. Adjournment: Mitch Gerlinger made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Marty Breitmeyer seconded the motion. Hearing no opposition, the meeting adjourned at 6:31 p.m. Palomino Valley General Improvement District Regular Meeting July 21, 2016 5
PVGID OPERATIONS REPORT Reporting Period: 06-13-2016 to 07-14-2016 ATTACHMENT: 07/21/16 Meeting Agenda Item 5. d. ROADS GRADED: Roadrunner Bacon Rind (N) Grass Valley (W) Pasture View (S) Pasture View (N) OTHER ROAD WORK: Patch (Axe Handle) 6.57 tons Patch (Ironwood) 1.83 tons Patch (Range Land) 13.92 tons Patch (Whiskey Springs) 5.34 tons Patch (Right Hand Canyon) 2.83 tons Range Land - fill front from cattleguard to Pyramid OTHER: None EQUIPMENT: International Water Truck - Remove & Replace Spray Head International Water Truck - Remove & Replace Spray Pump