Global Politics Review Journal of International Studies Volume 1, Issue 1, October 2015 ISSN 2464-9929 Copyright 2015 Global Politics Review - Associazione per la Ricerca, Innovazione e Scienze Sociali - All rights reserved. This journal may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, including illustrations, in any form (beyond that copying permitted by the Italian Law No. 633 of April 22, 1941, on the Protection of Copyright and Neighboring Rights - as amended up to Law No. 2 of January 9, 2008), whitout written permission from the publishers. --- For information on subscriptions, visit www.globalpoliticsreview.com or contact us at subscriptions@globalpoliticsreview.com. Articles from Global Politics Review are discoverable through EBSCOhost research databases. --- Published by the Associazione per la Ricerca, Innovazione e Scienze Sociali [Association for Research, Innovation and Social Science] Tax Code (CF): 97748700016 Address: Via Cernaia 14, 10122, Turin, Italy. E-mail: staff@globalpoliticsreview.com Fax: (+39) 011 0371950
2 Global Politics Review, Vol. 1, No. 1. Content 4 Letter from the Editor 6 Editorial Team 7 About the Journal PAPERS 8 Transnational Theory, Global World: Theory Matters, Not Geography Phoebe Gardner 18 The Hungarian Connection: the 1956 Hungarian Revolution and its Impact on Mao Zedong s Domestic Policies in the late 1950s David Tibor Teszar 35 Big Frog in a Small Pond or a Giant of Asia? Understanding the Political Leadership Style of Lee Kuan Yew H.M.S. Amanda Herath 53 The Asian Gold Rush: a Critique of the Win-Win Chinese Strategy Towards Africa Camilla Crovella 63 Convergence or Divergence in Future? Comparative Analysis between the WTO SCM Agreement and the Agreement on Agriculture Minju Kim ESSAYS 83 The Power of Cinema on the Korean Peninsula Samyel Lee
Global Politics Review 3 95 Aspects of Israeli Deterrence With a View to South Korean Applicability Daniel Foulkes
4 Global Politics Review, Vol. 1, No. 1. Letter from the Editor Global Politics Review s first issue, titled Perspectives on non-western IR Theories, is dedicated to opening up a cross-cultural comparative dialogue about International Relations (IR) by presenting non-western IR theories and case studies on Asia, Africa, and the Middle East. The field of study of International Relations is to date enjoying a period of theoretical peace where the debate among scholars is no longer shaped by theoretical paradigms, but instead focuses on finding new theoretical tools of analysis that better explain international affairs. In this collective effort, Global Politics Review (GPR) looks at the most recent non-western scholarship to find out some of the latest methodological and theoretical innovations in IR. The first paper in this issue, written by Phoebe Gardner, represents a comprehensive investigation in the field of International Relations Theory (IRT) that pragmatically underlies trends, biases and limitations in the study of IR. The reader will find her critiques of non-western IRT particularly interesting and, most notably, her suggestions on the future developments of IRT. Moving away from IRT, David Tibor Teszar offers meticulous historical research set to expose a hidden historical connection. Teszar s paper links the 1956 Hungarian revolution to the People s Republic of China and assesses the impact of the Revolution on Mao s domestic policies in the late 1950s. Teszar s study greatly contributes to academia and it is of particular value to any sinologist and historian of IR. The third paper, written by H.M.S. Amanda Herath, analyses leadership and identity in Singapore. Herath uses existing theoretical models to analyse and categorize the leadership style of Lee Kuan Yew, in the effort of finding generalizations that could be applied to other leaders. Herath s paper contributes to the field of leadership studies as well as to regional studies of South East Asia by offering a different perspective on Singapore s governance. The fourth paper, written by Camilla Crovella, addresses the role of the People s Republic of China on the African continent. Crovella surveys the recent scholarship on the topic and assesses the means and scope of Chinese cooperation with African countries. The paper s multidisciplinary approach touches on themes in the sphere of economics, law, development and IR. Crovella s work is an interesting piece that adds concepts and interpretations to the existing debate among scholars over the role of China in Africa. The last paper, authored by Minju Kim, does in-depth research on the regulation of agreements on subsidies in international law. The study is set to explain the rationales for a legal inconsistency in the asymmetric ruling of the WTO subsidies regime between
Global Politics Review 5 agricultural and non-agricultural products. The paper goes beyond its jurisprudential nature and has implications in the field of international cooperation and development, as it seeks to explain why developed countries have been entitled with rights to distribute more subsidies to their farmers than those of developing countries. The first essay, written by Samyel Lee, is a thought-provoking multidisciplinary study on the role of cinema in South Korean society. The essay discusses the role of native cinematographic productions in shaping public opinion and it shows how cinema has evolved into an interpretative medium that redefines and reinterprets Korean history and foreign policy. Lee s article is a refreshing post-positivist study that, thanks to its methodology and findings, contributes to the fields of IR and Korean studies. The second essay, written by Daniel Foulkes, tests South Korea s applicability of Israeli deterrence measures in relation to North Korea and provides insight on how nuclear powers substantiate their threats. Foulkes essay is comparative in its nature and should be read by any IR scholar interested in non-proliferation studies and East Asian security. I want to express my deepest gratitude, on behalf of the Editorial Board, to the authors that have contributed with their writings to this first issue. It is thanks to their quality research and in-depth studies that GPR is worth reading. I also want to thank our advisers for their generous support and guidance during the preparation of this first volume. I also would like to extend special thanks to Pietro Raviola and Maximillian Ernst for their hard work as members of the Association for Research, Innovation and Social Science, which made the publishing of GPR possible. I sincerely hope the readers will find our articles interesting and useful for their studies. Cesare M. Scartozzi Editor in Chief
6 Global Politics Review, Vol. 1, No. 1. Editorial Team Editor in Chief: Managing Editor: Staff Editors: Cesare M. Scartozzi Max Ernst Guidogiorgio Bodrato Master s candidate at ECARES, SBS-EM, Universitè Libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Belgium. Jordan DeWeger Pietro Raviola Master s candidate at University of Torino and at Collegio Carlo Alberto, Italy. Ceinwen Thomas Davide Zoppolato Master s candidate at University of Torino, Italy. Advisors: Professor John Delury Chair of Common Curriculum (Global Studies) and Associate Professor of Chinese Studies at Yonsei University, South Korea. E-mail: jdelury@yonsei.ac.kr Professor Tao Xie Professor and Associate Dean at the School of English and International Studies, Beijing Foreign Studies University. E-mail: taoxiebfsu@126.com Dr. Jin Kai Author for The Diplomat, and research fellow and lecturer at the Center for International Studies (CIS) at Yonsei University in South Korea. E-mail: jinkai@yonsei.ac.kr Dr. Antonio Fiori Associate Professor of History and Institutions of Asia at University of Bologna, Italy. E-mail: antonio.fiori@unibo.it Dr. Matthias M. Maass Associate Professor at Yonsei University Graduate School of International Studies (GSIS), South Korea. Co-President of KISA (Korean International Studies Association). E-mail:mm@mmaass.net
Global Politics Review 7 About the Journal Global Politics Review (GPR) is a peer-reviewed journal of international studies published twice a year by the Association for Research, Innovation and Social Science (ARISS). The Journal was founded in 2015 by the Association through a sponsorship of the University of Turin. GPR publishes high quality research papers, interviews and essays that survey new contributions to the field on international studies, with a focus on alternative and non-western theories of international relations. The Journal aspires to achieve a two-pronged goal: to provide the opportunity for distinguished scholars and graduate students to publish unconventional and innovative researches, and to be a vehicle for introducing new ideas while encouraging debate among the academic community. Global Politics Review aims to make a distinctive contribution to the field of international studies and serve the academic community as a whole. --- Contact Information Associazione per la Ricerca, Innovazione e Scienze Sociali. [Association for Reaserch, Innovation and Social Sciences] Web: www.globalpoliticsreview.com Address: Via Cernaia 14, 10122, Torino, Italy. E-mail: staff @ globalpoliticsreview.com Fax: (+39) 011 0371950