ANNOUNCEMENTS COLORADO COURT OF APPEALS February 9, 2006 Slip opinions are the opinions as filed by the judges with the clerk. Slip opinions are subject to modification, rehearing, withdrawal, or clerical corrections. A link to any modifications to previously posted opinions will appear in the Petition for Rehearing section of the announcement document the day the changes are announced. Click on the case number to view the opinion in Word format. P U B L I S H E D O P I N I O N S Court of Appeals No.: 03CA1907 City and County of Denver District Court No. 01CR2356 Honorable Martin F. Egelhoff, Judge Joseph Finley, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED, SENTENCE VACATED, AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Taubman and Loeb, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0425 Weld County District Court No. 02CR1216 Honorable Daniel S. Maus, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (1 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Conrad Clayton Rossman, Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROTHENBERG Graham and Kirshbaum*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1618 Arapahoe County District Court Nos. 99CR2132 & 00CR83 Honorable James F. Macrum, Jr., Judge Plaintiff-Appellant, Brian J. Hummel, Defendant-Appellee. Division III Opinion by: JUDGE LOEB Taubman and Roy, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1731 City and County of Denver District Court No. 00CV1347 Honorable Larry J. Naves, Judge Nicholas Wallbank and Mindilee Wallbank, individually and as parents of Emily Wallbank, a minor, Plaintiffs-Appellants, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (2 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Steven S. Rothenberg, M.D., Defendant-Appellee. Division III Opinion by: JUDGE TAUBMAN Roy and Loeb, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1985 La Plata County District Court No. 96CV269 Honorable David L. Dickinson, Judge Jamie L. Ross, et al., Plaintiffs-Appellees, Old Republic Insurance Company, Garnishee-Appellant. JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division I Opinion by: JUDGE ROMÁN Dailey and Ney*, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2682 Douglas County District Court No. 01DR336 Honorable Richard D. Turelli, Judge In re the Marriage of Rebekah G. McSoud, Appellant, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (3 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
and Joseph McSoud, Appellee. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, ORDERS AFFIRMED, AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division V Opinion by: JUDGE WEBB Russel and Hawthorne, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 05CA0278 Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado WC No. 4-537-010 Subsequent Injury Fund, Petitioner, Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado, Carole S. Trudeau, and Donovan N. Trudeau, Respondents. Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE CARPARELLI Roy and Metzger*, JJ., concur _ U N P U B L I S H E D O P I N I O N S Court of Appeals No.: 03CA1819 Douglas County District Court No. 02CR249 Honorable Thomas J. Curry, Judge file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (4 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Christian R. Hoschouer, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROTHENBERG Graham and Carparelli, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 03CA1906 Otero County District Court No. 02CR94 Honorable M. Jon Kolomitz, Judge Myron Boyd, JUDGMENT AND SENTENCE AFFIRMED IN PART AND VACATED IN PART Division V Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Dailey and Criswell*, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 03CA2279 City and County of Denver District Court No. 02CR4253 file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (5 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Honorable Morris B. Hoffman, Judge Honorable H. Jeffrey Bayless, Judge Victor Vallieres, JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Taubman and Loeb, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0197 El Paso County District Court No. 91CR3196 Honorable David L. Shakes, Judge Christopher Stephen Kemp, Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROTHENBERG Graham and Carparelli, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (6 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0641 El Paso County District Court No. 98CR2604 Honorable David L. Shakes, Judge David Wayne Keith, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division I Opinion by: JUDGE CARPARELLI Marquez and Kapelke*, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0968 Douglas County District Court No. 00CR390 Honorable Thomas J. Curry, Judge Jimmie Ray Schumacher, Division II Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Rothenberg and Carparelli, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (7 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
_ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0991 Arapahoe County District Court Nos. 90CV247 & 02CV1748 Honorable J. Mark Hannen, Judge Emmett Johnson, Jean Johnson, and James W. Burneson, Plaintiffs-Appellants, Dam East Homeowners Association, a Colorado non-profit corporation, Defendant-Appellee. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division IV Opinion by: JUSTICE ROVIRA* Davidson, C.J., and Vogt., J., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1063 Larimer County District Court No. 99CR763 Honorable James H. Hiatt, Judge Edwin G. Smith, CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Taubman and Loeb, JJ., concur file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (8 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1199 La Plata County District Court No. 03CV11 Honorable Jeffrey R. Wilson, Judge Rancho Durango, Ltd., a California limited partnership, and Gorton Family Partnership LLLP, a Colorado limited liability partnership, Intervenor-Appellee, Randy Morine Heritage Properties, Inc., JUDGMENT AFFIRMED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division IV Opinion by: CHIEF JUDGE DAVIDSON Vogt and Rovira*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1410 City and County of Denver Probate Court No. 03PR415 Honorable C. Jean Stewart, Judge In the Matter of the Estate of Margaret Rodda, a/k/a Margaret W. Rodda, Deceased. Grace Klein, Appellant, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (9 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Del Samac-Townsend and Cathy Black, Appellees. Division IV Opinion by: CHIEF JUDGE DAVIDSON Vogt and Rovira*, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1661 Crowley County District Court No. 03CV72 Honorable Michael Schiferl, Judge Ronald Cordova, Plaintiff-Appellant, Sgt. J. Jones, Sgt. J. Hensen, and Nurse M. Muniz, Defendants-Appellees. ORDERS AFFIRMED Division I Opinion by: JUDGE ROMÁN Marquez and Dailey, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1698 Jefferson County District Court No. 03CV1942 Honorable Thomas Woodford, Judge Roger D. Schlesselman and Sheila Schlesselman, Plaintiffs-Appellees, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (10 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
ETC Enterprises, L.L.C., a Colorado limited liability company, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division IV Opinion by: JUSTICE ROVIRA* Davidson, C.J., and Vogt, J., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1790 Jefferson County District Court No. 00CR19 Honorable Jack W. Berryhill, Judge Justin S. Goshorn, JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division III Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Taubman and Loeb, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1880 El Paso County District Court No. 03CV1 Honorable David A. Gilbert, Judge Jeffrey I. Tompkins, Appellant, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (11 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
CPR Title, Defendant-Appellee, and Ameriquest Mortgage, Defendant. APPEAL DISMISSED IN PART, ORDER REVERSED, AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE TAUBMAN Roy and Loeb, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1883 Colorado State Board of Assessment Appeals Nos. 42459 & 42460 El Davis Trust, Petitioner-Appellant, Elbert County Board of Equalization, Respondent-Appellee, and Colorado State Board of Assessment Appeals, Appellee. Division II file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (12 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Opinion by: JUDGE ROTHENBERG Graham and Carparelli, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1987 City and County of Denver District Court No. 04CV420 Honorable Morris B. Hoffman, Judge Leon T. May, Plaintiff-Appellant, Robert J. Pletcher, Defendant-Appellee. Division A Opinion by: JUDGE KAPELKE* Davidson, C.J., and Nieto*, J., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2165 El Paso County District Court No. 04CV1140 Honorable David A. Gilbert, Judge Jesse Vigil, Plaintiff-Appellant, M. Michael Cooke, Executive Director of the Colorado Department of Revenue, Motor Vehicle Division, Defendant-Appellee. file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (13 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Division II Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Rothenberg and Carparelli, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2178 Pueblo County District Court No. 03CV1071 Honorable Dennis Maes, Judge Philip D. Heathcock, Plaintiff-Appellant, Colorado Department of Transportation, Defendant-Appellee. JUDGMENT REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division IV Opinion by: CHIEF JUDGE DAVIDSON Vogt and Rovira*, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2202 Douglas County District Court No. 01CV411 Honorable Paul A. King, Judge Donald J. Avsec and Sandra L. Avsec, Plaintiffs-Appellants, Carefree Recycled Products, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (14 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Defendant-Appellee. IN PART, REVERSED IN PART, AND CASE REMANDED WITH DIRECTIONS Division III Opinion by: JUDGE ROY Taubman and Loeb, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1140 Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado DD No. 484-2005 Constance A. Luoto, Petitioner, Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado and University of Colorado, Boulder Campus, Respondents. Division II Opinion by: JUDGE ROTHENBERG Graham and Carparelli, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1401 El Paso County District Court No. 03JV1670 Honorable Theresa M. Cisneros, Judge In the Interest of C.G., T.W., G.W. and S.G., Children, Upon the Petition of the El Paso County Department of Human Services, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (15 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Petitioner-Appellee, and Concerning E.W., Respondent-Appellant. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE RUSSEL Webb and Hawthorne, JJ., concur Court of Appeals No.: 05CA1629 Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado DD No. 2728-2004 Robert A. Vite, Petitioner, Industrial Claim Appeals Office of the State of Colorado and Olan Mills Inc., Respondents. Division II Opinion by: JUDGE GRAHAM Rothenberg and Carparelli, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2201 City and County of Denver Juvenile Court No. 04JV2965 Honorable Gaspar F. Perricone, Judge In the Interest of A.L.G.S., a Child, file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (16 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Upon the Petition of the Denver Department of Human Services, Petitioner-Appellee, and Concerning R.A.S. and E.A.G, Respondents-Appellants. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE HAWTHORNE Webb and Russel, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2232 El Paso County District Court No. 04JV800 Honorable Theresa M. Cisneros, Judge In the Interest of J.R.C., P.C., and J.C., Children, Upon the Petition of the El Paso County Department of Human Services, Petitioner-Appellee, and Concerning J.M.C., Respondent-Appellant. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division V Opinion by: JUDGE WEBB Russel and Hawthorne, JJ., concur _ Court of Appeals No.: 05CA2324 Jefferson County District Court No. 04JV356 file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (17 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Honorable Margie L. Enquist, Judge Petitioner-Appellee, In the Interest of J.W., a Child, and Concerning L.W., Respondent-Appellant. JUDGMENT AFFIRMED Division IV Opinion by: JUDGE VOGT Furman and Kapelke*, JJ., concur P E T I T I O N S F O R R E H E A R I N G Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0710 In re the Marriage of Sherrie Anthony Nunn, Appellee, and Steven J. Foster, Appellant. Petition for Rehearing DENIED file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (18 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Court of Appeals No.: 04CA0932 Kenneth A. McKee, by his duly appointed guardian, conservator Ann McKee, and Ann McKee, individually, Plaintiff-Appellants and Cross-Appellees, and Pinnacol Assurance, Plaintiff-Appellant and Cross-Appellee, and Intervenor Aardvark Sign Company, LLC, d/b/a Quicksign, Defendant-Appellee and Cross-Appellant. Petition for Rehearing DENIED _ Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1036 Thomas W. Reuter, Petition for Rehearing DENIED Court of Appeals No.: 04CA2157 file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (19 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Willard Leroy Arthur, Petition for Rehearing DENIED Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1509 Javier Salazar, Petition for Rehearing DENIED Court of Appeals No.: 04CA1530 John M. Price, Plaintiff-Appellant, Joe Silver, Defendant-Appellee. file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (20 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]
Petition for Rehearing DENIED *Sitting by assignment of the Chief Justice under provisions of Colo. Const. art. VI, 5 (3), and 24-51-1105, C.R.S. 2005. file:///c /Users/b888cac/Documents/Temp/coa/2006/2006q1/02-09-06.htm (21 of 21) [8/19/2008 5:40:20 PM]