SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK -------------------------------------------------------x Index No. 152830/2015 SENECA INSURANCE COMPANY, INC. a/s/o IBRAHIM KARKENNY, MALKO KARKENNY and MALKO KARKENNY BROTHERS, INC., LEADING ORDER WITH INSURANCE GROUP INSURANCE CO., LTD., now NOTICE OF ENTRY known as KOOKMIN BEST INSURANCE CO., LTD., AS SUBROGEE OF ORIENTAL PASTRY 5 GROCERY, INC., and ALLSTATE INDEMNITY COMPANY as subrogee of MARILYN MANSOUR and EMILY CEREZO, Plaintiffs, -against- -ag a inst- HADRAMOUT RESTAURANT INC., TRANSWORLD INC., MAKBOULEH MOUSTAPHA, MUYASSAR MOUSTAPHA, ANAS MOUSTAPHA and RIHAB ALSAWAH a/k/a RIHAB MOUSTAPHA, ORIENTAL PASTRY & GROCERY, INC., AMERICAN FIRE PREVENTION SERVICES INCORPORATED, NEW YORK BUSINESS FIRE SYSTEM, INC. and FIRE COMMAND CO. INC., Defendants. -------------------------------------------------------X PLEASE TAKE NOTICE, that the annexed is a true copy of an Order of this Court duly entered in the Office of the Clerk of this Court on June 1, 2017. Dated: New York, New York March 19, 2018 Yours, ERIC S. FENY S LAW OFFICES OF MICHAEL E. PRESSMAN 1 of 7
Attorneys for Defendants MAKBOULEH MOUSTAPHA, MUYASSAR MOUSTAPHA, ANAS MOUSTAPHA, RIHAB ALSAWAH a/k/a RIHAB MOUSTAPHA and ORIENTAL PASTRY 5 GROCERY, INC. and Plaintiff LEADING INSURANCE GROUP INSURANCE CO., LTD., now known as KOOKMIN BEST INSURANCE CO., LTD., as subrogee of ORIENTAL PASTRY & GROCERY, INC. 125 Maiden Lane, 17th Floor New York, New York 10038 (212) 480-3030 Our File No: LIG 15046A/jef/829728 TO: KAHN & GOLDBERG, LLP Eric Goldberg, Esq. Attorneys for Plaintiff SENECA INSURANCE COMPANY,INC. a/s/o IBRAHIM KARKENNY, MALKO KARKENNY and MALKO KARKENNY BROTHERS, INC. 19th 708 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017 (212) 687-5066 eq@kahnqoldberq.com.com Floor LAW OFFICES OF KAREN L. LAWRENCE Attorneys for Plaintiff ALLSTATE INDEMNITY COMPANY AS SUBROGEE OF MARILYN MANSOUR and EMILY CEREZO 4 Metrotech Center, Suite 2000 Brooklyn, New York 11201 (718) 451-7106 2 of 7
WEINER, MILLO, MORGAN & BONANNO, LLC Attorneys for Defendant AMERICAN FIRE PREVENTION SERVICES INCORPORATED 10th 220 Fifth Avenue, Floor New York, NY 10001 (212) 213-1220 WMMB File No.: 398-228 knezowitz@wmmblawfirm.com BRIEF CARMEN 5 KLEIMAN, LLP Attorneys for Defendant NEW YORK BUSINESS FIRE SYSTEM INC. 12th 805 Third Avenue, FlOOr New York, NY 10022 (212) 758-6160 PILLINGER MILLER TARALLO LLP Attorneys for Defendant FIRE COMMAND CO. INC. 570 Taxter Road, 2nd Floor Elmsford, NY 10523 (914) 703-6300 HADRAMOUT RESTAURANT INC. Defendant c/o Transworld Inc. 172 Atlantic Avenue Brooklyn, NY 11201 TRANSWORLD INC. Defendant 172 Atlantic Avenue Brooklyn, NY 11201 CLERK OF SUPREME COURT, NEW YORK COUNTY 60 Centre Street New York, NY 10007 CLERK OF SUPREME COURT, KINGS COUNTY 360 Adams Street Brooklyn, NY 11201 3 of 7
No. 719311 Certification STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF NEW YORK, SS: I, Milton Adair Tingling, County Clerk and Clerk of Supreme Court New York County, do hereby certify that on March 19, 2018 I have compared the document attached hereto, Decision & Order on Motion 003 page(s) 3 with the originals filed in my office and the same is a correct transcript therefrom and of the whole of such original in witness whereto I have affixed my signature and seal. /ik ~~<' V<Ig >.X~7a X.r'y / MILTON ADAIR TINGLING NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 4 of 7
ILED : NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06 /01/2 o 017 03 : 02 PM INDEX NO.0 15 2 8 30 ~ / 2 0 15 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 97 RECEIVED ' NYSCEF: 06/01/2017 e -' SUPREME ~ COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK NEW YORK COUNTY i index Number : 152830/2015 SENECA INSURANCE COMPANY, 'e PART -) vs HADRAMOUTRESTAURANTINC. ~ INC. 1NDEX NO I Sequence Number : 003 MOTION DATE CONSOLIDATION/JOINT TRIAL MOTION SEQ. NO. ~ I I C.E% The following papers, numbered 1 to _,1_, were read on this motion ~ to/for~ ~ M \ C C \.4 Notice of Motion/Order I ~ to Show ~ Cause - Affidavits - Exhibits ) No(s). Answering Affidavits ~ - Exhibits INo(s). Replying Affidavits I No(s). Upon the ' foregoing papers,. it is ordered that this motion is. ~.. ' Defendants Makbouleh Moustapha, Muyassa Moustapha, Anas Moustapha, Rihab Alsawah.. a/k/a. Rihab.. ~ Moustapha and.. Oriental.. ~. Pasty & Grocery, Int's motion to transfer and consolidate is granted per U2 U attached decision/order. 0 O0 O Z Q0 Z Ko' NI cfi CO ~ o g Z uj 0 I- :E u. Dated: Ö\, J.S.C. HON. -RIKA M. EDWARDS 1. CHECK ONE:... O CASE DISPOSED NON-FINAL DISPOSITION 2. CHECK AS APPROPRIATE:...MOTION IS: g RANTED O DENIED O GRANTED IN PART OTHER 3. CHECK IF APPROPRIATE:... SETTLE ORDER SUBMIT ORDER DO NOT POST O FIDUCIARY APPOINTMENT D REFERENCE j.1 of 3 5 of 7
[FILED : NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/01/2017 03: 02 PM) INDEX NO. 152830/2015 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 97 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/01/2017 SUPREME COURT OF THE $TATE OF NEW YOR.K COUNTY OF NEW YORK: PART 47...--- ----------... X SENECA INSURANCE COMPANY, INC, a/s/o IBRAHIM KARKENNY, MALKO K.ARKENNY and Index No.: 152830/15 MALKO KARKENNY BROTHERS, INC., LEADING INSURANCE GROUP INSURANCE CO., Motion Seq. 003 LTD., now known as KOOKMIN BEST INSURANCE SUBROGEF.' CO., LTD., AS SUBROGEE OF QRIENTAI, PASTRY & GROCERY, INC.,. Plaintiff, DECISION/ORDER -against- HADRAMOUT RESTUARANT INC., TRANSWGRLD INC., MAKBOULEH MOUSTAPHA, MUYASSAR MOUSTAPHA, ANAS MOUSTAPHA and RIHAB ALSAWAH a/k/a RIHAB MOUSTAPHA, ORIENTAL PASTRY & GROCERY, INC., AMERICAN FIRE PREVENTION SERVICES INCORPORATED, NEW YQRK BUSINESS FIRE SYSTEM, INC. and FIRE COMMAND CO. INC., Defendants. -------------------------------------------------------------------X Recitation, as required by CPLR 2219(a), of the papers considered in the review of this motion: Papers Numbered Notice of Motion and Affidavits/Affirmations/ Exhibits Annexed 1 ERIKA M. EDWARDS, J.: It is hereby ORDERED that Defendants Makbouleh Moustapha, MuyassaR Moustapha, Anas Moustapha, Rihab Alsawah a/k/a Rihab Moustapha and Oriental Pastry & Grocery, Inc's motion to transfer a Kings County action to New York County and consolidate it with the abovereferenced action is granted without opposition. ORDERED that the above-captioned action is consolidated in this court with Allstate indemnity Company as subrogee of Marilyn Mansour and Emily Cerezo vs. Oriental Pastry and Grocery, Inc., Hadramout Restaurant, Inc., Transworld, Inc., New York Business Fire System, Inc. and Fire Command Co., Inc., Index No. 514954/16 (Kings county) under New York Index 152830/15 and the consolidated action shall bear the following caption: 2 of 3 6 of 7
INDEX NO. 152830/2015 FILED : NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/01/2017 03: 02 PM) NYSCEE' NYSCEÈ DOC. NO. 97 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/01/2017 -----..----.. ---------------------------------X -X SENECA INSURANCE COMPANY, INC. a/s/o IBRAHIM KARKENNY, MALKO KARKENNY and MALKO KARKENNY BROTHERS, INC., LEADING INSURANCE GROUP INSURANCE CO., LTD., now known as KOOKMIN BEST INSURANCE CO., LTD., AS SUBROGEE OF ORIENTAL PASTRY & GROCERY, INC., and ALLSTATE INDEMNITY COMPANY as subrogee of MARILYN MANSOUR and EMILY CEREZO Plaintiff, -against- HADRAMOUT RESTUARANT INC., TRANSWORLD INC., MAKBOULEH MOUSTAPHA, MUYASSAR MOUSTAPHA, ANAS MOUSTAPHA and RIHAB ALSAWAH a/k/a RIHAB MOUSTAPHA, ORIENTAL PASTRY & GROCERY, INC., AMERICAN FIRE PREVENTION SERVICES INCORPORATED, NEW YORK BUSINESS FIRE SYSTEM, INC. and FIRE COMMAND CO. INC., --------------------------------------------X Defendants. X And it is further ORDERED that the Clerk of Kings County Supreme Court, shall transfer the papers on file under Index No. 514954/16 to the Clerk of this court upon service of a certified copy of this order and payment of the appropriate fee, if any, and it is further ORDERED that the movant is directed to e-file a 'Notice to County Clerk' Form (Form EF-22) attached to a copy of this order for the County Clerk who shall consolidate the papers in the actions hereby consolidated and shall mark the records to reflect the consolidation; and it is further ORDERED that counsel is directed to appear for a compliance conference on July 20, 2017, at 9:30 a.m. in Part 47, Room 320, located at 80 Centre Street, New York, NY 10013. This constitutes the Decision and Order of the Court. Date: June 1, 2017.. EDWARDS 3 of 3 7 of 7