Petition for Oral Argument at the Ninth Circuit Court of

Petition for Oral Argument at the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal Petition Petition for Oral Argument at the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal Petition http:// http:// Petition for Oral Argument at the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal View Current Signatures - Sign the Petition To: U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal Dr. Yue, a pro se litigant, requests the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal to grant ORAL ARGUMENT in his case against two large corporations and individual defendants. At the federal district court, the judge told Dr. Yue to "cease and desist" from filing papers. The following was the exchange afterwards (transcript): DR. YUE: WHAT'S THE COURT'S LEGAL RATIONALE FOR THAT? THE COURT: THAT IS THE RATIONALE, AND THAT'S THE STATEMENT. DR. YUE: FOLLOWING RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE (interrupted) THE COURT: MR. YUE, I AM GOING TO HAVE YOU TAKEN OUT IF YOU DON'T BE QUIET. After Dr. Yue sued Sun Microsystems and StorageTek for stealing his software, the judge quickly dismissed his case without leave to amend and before defendants filed any responsive pleading. Dr. Yue now appeals to the Ninth Circuit (Case Number 08-15927). Dr. Yue believes that oral argument should be held because he was denied in his day in the federal district court and he should be given the opportunity to argue his cause before the judges of the court of appeal. Please grant Dr. Yue's Request for Oral Argument. Sincerely, The Undersigned View Current Signatures The Petition for Oral Argument at the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal Petition to U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal was created by American-Justice.org and written by Dr. D. Yue (dxyue@yahoo.com). This petition is hosted here at www.petitiononline.com as a public service. There is no endorsement of this petition, express or implied, by Artifice, Inc. or our sponsors. For technical support please use our simple Petition Help form. tags: copyright court due Federal pro process se

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 1 of 9 1 Chungchi Che Che8888@Dr. Yue should have more time to express. 2 Kristi Devine Dear Judge: All that we ask is a chance to be heard in the pursuit of justice. Please grant us that opportunity and help make justice accessible to all and not just something that devinekr can only be attained with money. The world will be a far better place when those that do wrong face consequences. The courts are needed to be accessible to all for such. 3 Timothy Enos Dr. Yue should be granted his day in court (i.e. He should be treated with as much (if not more) dignity as would be any duly licensed lawyer). Pro se litigants, including Dr. Yue, should (even MUST) be allowed to present cases before ANY court in the land (there's nothing special about the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal). 4 Steve McDonough daddyozz The right to be heard is a fundamental right, see Mullane v. 5 Yong Li Cent. Hanover Bank & Trust Co., 339 U.S. 306, 314 (1950) "Many controversies have raged about the cryptic and abstract words of the Due Process Clause but there can be no doubt that at a minimum they require that deprivation of life, liberty or property by adjudication be preceded by notice and opportunity for hearing appropriate to the nature of the case." 7 Carol Shi If the Ninth Circuit Court has its' desire to correct the wrongdoing made by the District Court, Dr. Yue's petition for Oral Argument should be granted. 8 Steven Li I read Dr. Yue's case from the internet and knew that the District Court failed to find the truth from the fact. The Judge just has a prejudice against Dr. Yue- Pro se. 9 bill butler 10 Amy R I support Dr. Yue 11 Bo L I support Mr. Yue and Discrimination against any minority unacceptable. 12 Daniel F. Andre 13 Steve Liu 14 Jason Sun Dr. Yue should be allowed to present his case in the court 15 Fang Shih Support Dr. Yue and support justice. 16 Qing Xiao 17 Chao Deng 18 Flavia Benitez I support your petition for oral argument 19 Mike DiRubio miked59@

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 2 of 9 20 David Chen 21 FRANCIS KNIZE 22 Chen, Chang Jing 23 Zhang, Yu Zheng 24 Annie Luo 25 yong lu 26 Jinyan Wang I just completed a legal malpractice against CA lawyer Philip R. Green, in federal court in San Francisco. I was fortunate that Judge Zimmerman was of the highest quality and strove to be absolutely impartial. I know this is 27 Gloria Grening Wolkggwolk@Vunusual, when a non-lawyer is pro se, which is why I am writing a guide book for pro se litigants whose cases are in the category of "complex civil." Dr. Yue's experiences, hopefully with more justice than he has had to date, will be part of the book. As the Founder of P.U.L.S.E. (People United for Legal 28 Joseph Delgado System Equality), I support your quest to have your rights as a Pro Se Litigant completely honored and respected. I believe pro se litigation is a constitutionally-protected right. Hopefully, your supporters will view and sign my PLEDGE OF SOLIDARITY (located at pulse-fo http://www.gopetition.com/online/11773.html). The American right to self-litigation will never be fully honored until the People organize peacefully in support thereof. Until then, the legal system will continue to be run by lawyers for the benefit of lawyers and those who rely on them for representation. 29 Tage Lejon tl@wippiplease show respect and honor, NOW 30 Ke Zhan kezhan@g 31 Cheryl Kennedy 32 weize xie Dr. Yue should be allowed for oral argument 33 Hesty Liu Although Dr. Yue's uphill fighting with the two big incorporations seems "Mission Impossible", he should be granted the chance to speak up. It is a basic right he is entitled to. 34 Teng Ge It is Dr Yue's undeniable right to be heard at the court. 35 Shenghong Wang

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 3 of 9 It's hugely unfair to decline Dr. Yue's appeal. The law 36 Xiaohua Zhou should provide a fair chance for every good citizen to state zhouxiao theircase. The law is not a garbage can for the bad companies to sweep their dirty work. 37 Wenle Wang 38 Jack Chang 39 Joe Hou 40 Z Li 41 Dr. Chris Rong 42 Jacky.He 43 zhans 44 Hansen Li I fully support Dr Yue's petition, and request the Court to give full careful consideration. Injustice, discrimination and unfair judgements in US courts are becoming more and more popular. It is dagerous to USA as a legal country. I do not understand WHY it is so difficult to apply for a "Oral Argument" for his/her case in a US court as a US citizen? Does a US citizen has any legal rights? 45 Dong Zhuang although useless, support anyway! 46 Y. Jiang Support Dr. Yue 47 Fengjie Huang fhuang3@a very strong case that warrants further review. 48 Jason Tao 49 Jia Li 50 Yao Li 51 steven guo support you 52 souping yan 53 Shewen Liu 54 zou rong 55 Yansheng Luo Please give him a chance 56 W. Hu 57 Zhian Guo zhianguo 58 Jim Liu 59 Zhong Chen 60 Edward Cheng Please let me trust the THE COURT 61 Chenzhong Wang chenzhondon't let money prevail over justice or civil rights again 62 Ming Wei 63 Hong Zhao hongzhao 64 J Xu 65 Simon JOE 66 Bin Lu

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 4 of 9 67 Kenneth Xu 68 Xiaogang Gao xgao@tuflet's see what is a real impartial 69 John Ye 70 J.D.Li talk@raijustice as fairness 71 Yi Jiang 72 Sam Xu 73 Xingyu Wang 74 ping wang 75 linda eveybody should have equal chance and be treated fair 76 Haidong Liao haidonglyou should have a chance to exhibit your evidence. 77 Rong Hu 78 Xu Liyu xuliyu@ndon't give up! 79 Yi Hua Chang 80 HUANG 81 Kingso 82 wei hung 83 Caiwen Shen 84 Kun Ru 85 Jing Liu Keep the US law be effective 86 Henry 87 Yimeng Zhang 88 Henry PAN henrypan 89 Jeff Yue If courts of this country only protect big and powerfull, not average citizen, it will damage the foundation of this Jeff_Yuecountry gravely. You will hardly see Apple or Microsoft type of companies growing up, and will see more parasites in the future. 90 Dr. Weier Lu weierlu@ 91 Dejing Fu 92 raymond zhang ufenn@msn.com 93 Michael Zhou I fully support you 100\%, Dr Yue. Often times our country is not ruled by the law, but by these very judges who sit in their high chairs and interpret law at their own discretion. Often times, judges can just tell you "white is black" and what can you really do about that? They can do rmzebay@ whatever they want. There is no so called "checks and balances" for average people, you don't have the means (money and time) to fight it. When your skin color is shown, you are already discriminated, without a doubt. It just makes me puke.

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 5 of 9 94 Wenqing Li liwenqindiffult to seek justtice in the system of money(=)power 95 Stan Li Please grant him the chance. 96 John Zhu I want and need to see the proof of " USA is the land of 97 Chong Yu Nie cyniemid law" and "Money can not buy justice". 98 Simon Wang Support 99 jie zhu we need truth 100 Fei Xing Support Please allow Dr. Yue the chance to present his case. The 101 Xin Shi fact agreed upon by both side is that these companies did bwca_mn@ not pay for all the licenses for Dr Yue's software 102 SAMUEL SUN PowerRPC. 103 lishuang Su 104 Tom Wang Please give him a chance to present his case. 105 david bei Keep fighting for your right 106 Yilei Qian This seems unfair. Please give Dr. Yue a chance to argue for his case. 107 Liqi Tong 108 Xiaojie Li Please prove that everybody is equal in the face of law. 109 Xiangbin Meng we need justice 110 Ping Sun 111 zibin yang 112 Helen Yu 113 Yuan Tu wuan98@ygo! Go! Go! 114 Ye Lilly yelilly@ 115 Yanming Xiao yanming_fight for yourself and fight for us. 116 bendi Gong defend by yourself 117 Michael Lee 118 Yiwei Jiang 119 jiayi chen 120 Qiang Song, Ph.D qsong@so 121 Yonghua Dong dongyhua 122 YU ZHENG Please give Dr. Yue an opportunity 123 xiaoling bao 124 Peter Brown 125 Shi kao support Dr. Yue 126 Lu Yin Support Dr. Yue 127 M Ruan please give him a full justice 128 jin hu should have a chance for oral argument

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 6 of 9 129 zhexing wang 130 COLIN HUANG 131 Yi Chang mr_yic@ydo justice to Dr. Yue 132 Zhi Chen Please give Mr. Yue a chance to present his case in the 133 Jian Liang Court. Mr. Yue should have a chance to present his case in the 134 Robert Deng dengaag@ Court. 135 Dai Zhao 136 tenny 137 Xin Chen 138 Bin Peng 139 Guo Chen 140 chi tu I am not satisfied with the results. 141 fan tu 142 Yihua Mai 143 Bob Ren bob.ren@ 144 Shi Ya Support Justice 145 Mike liu support Yue dongxiao 146 Yang Ging Do you think that American is very bad? yes, because the judges are all bad. 147 Gai wen There is no justice for Chinese, india, black, etc,. only for White. We need to unite together and fight for our rights. 148 Peter Z Tan zhimin16support you to stand for yourself 149 Kangguo Cheng 150 tu di Give him a chance 151 Lemon Jiang 152 Jay Chiu Support Dr. Yue 153 liuyucong 154 wujianxun 155 Frank Wang 156 Walter Huang 157 Ming chen Support Mr. Yue's right 158 Howard Mao 159 Gregory Fan 160 Yan Zhu 161 David Shu 162 wangyunhai 163 Youlu Zheng 164 Zhongkui Wang zwang15@go for fairness! 165 carey he

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 7 of 9 166 Linda Hong 167 MIN HU 168 Tao Zhang 169 Alex Xiao Go! Go! 170 yangshu Bai yang_shusupport Yue, give him chance to appeal 171 Eddie L All people's legal rights and their due process should be given and respected. 172 Yongping Zhou I support Dr. Yue 173 Daniel 174 Allan Lai 175 Jerry McLain 176 Fiona Xu Human rights, are equal 177 Can Zhou I can't believe it! 178 yanjun yan 179 Shiliyang Xu xusly01@support Dr. Yue firmly. 180 Ye Jin 181 Chen Gao 182 Angus Jing lvdouwa@ 183 NINGXI ZHANG 184 Manxia Zhang 185 David Liu 186 Weian Liu 187 Gang Chen 188 Chang 189 Cheng-Jun Li 190 frank zhao 191 Grant S grant_soi support Dr. Yue 192 Jin Zhou jzjz@roc 193 Sean Xin 194 joseph chan 195 Daniel Cheng 196 yuan shuai Dr. D. Yue is a good man 197 xinkai chen I can't bilieve it! I support Dr. Yue (from France) 198 hxly 199 Richard Bergeon 200 stanly Lu stanlylu 201 roger z tsai rogercaii support you! 202 liubenshan 203 wang yonghong try your best.

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 8 of 9 204 zhang zhisong 205 johnsun 206 JUN XU find help from: laws --forum --reporter etc 207 Nathan Zhao Give him the right to speak!!! 208 ZHENJIANG GUO 209 Guanglu Zhai abaw997@ 210 xiaokun xiao007k 211 leexueyong 212 huiming li I know it is U.S, where laws are s*h*i*t to lihmg@yabig companies. But I still show my support Dr. Yue. 213 Jeffrey Gu Justice for Dr. Yue! 214 zhangfenqing 215 liuhua 216 anrui 217 meina 218 xuyujie 219 chenlihua 220 yuejumei 221 M. Canarelli BOTH SIDES SHOULD BE HEARD. PLEASE LET HIM SPEAK. THESE LAWS MUST BE CHANGED TO PROTECT PRO SE TRYING TO FIGHT FOR THEMSELVES. 222 Weidian Ma weidian_i strongly support Dr. Yue. 223 carol Sh The Court Should Grant Dr. Yue's Request for 224 Steven liu 225 Harrington, Sean esoxluci 226 ping xiao tieq@tom 227 dina padilla 228 Dr. Charles Heckman Oral Argument Why not, Here is America. He should be given the opportunity to argue his cause before the judges of the court of appeal. In suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury, shall be otherwise reexamined in any court of the United States, than according to the rules of the common law. - Amendment VII, U.S. Constitution 229 Jeff Guan Give the man his day in court, isn't that what 230 Darell A Hott caliente you are being paid for?

Petition to the Ninth Circuit Signatures Page 9 of 9 The real danger of this from a public policy standpoint is twofold: 1) It will kill creativity. The vast majority of innovation and creativity comes from individuals, and as it 231 J. LeFave jtlefavegradually becomes known among the population that the have no equality before the law, they will stop inventing. This will accelerate the decline of the USA as the leading technology giant of the world. 232 Gene Meinen genemein