H National Quali cations SPECIMEN ONLY SQ38/H/01 Politics Date Not applicable Duration 2 hours and 15 minutes Total marks 60 SECTION 1 POLITICAL THEORY 20 marks Attempt EITHER Question 1(a) OR Question 1(b). SECTION 2 POLITICAL SYSTEMS 20 marks Attempt ALL questions. Question 2 contains a choice. SECTION 3 POLITICAL PARTIES AND ELECTIONS 20 marks Attempt ALL questions. Question 2 contains a choice. Write your answers clearly in the answer booklet provided. In the answer booklet you must clearly identify the question number you are attempting. Use blue or black ink. Before leaving the examination room you must give your answer booklet to the Invigilator; if you do not you may lose all the marks for this paper. *SQ32H01*
SECTION 1 POLITICAL THEORY 20 marks Attempt EITHER Question 1(a) OR Question 1(b). 1. (a) Legitimacy is crucial to an understanding of the distinction between Power and Authority. Discuss with reference to the ideas of Lukes and Weber. 20 OR (b) To what extent are the key features of political ideologies different? You should refer to two political ideologies and make reference to the ideas of relevant theorists. 20 Page two
SECTION 2 POLITICAL SYSTEMS 20 marks Attempt ALL questions. Question 2 contains a choice. 1. Study Sources A and B below and opposite then answer the question that follows. SOURCE A US Congressional Committees Membership of US committees, especially Senate committees, has always had high status. Congressional committees are often referred to as little legislatures because of the influence they have. In a nation which prides itself on the separation of powers, Congressional committees also provide an invaluable service to the nation by investigating the Executive s work. Congressional committees have significant budgets to carry out detailed investigations and can rely on a large staff of investigators. In recent times, US committees have become very politically divided with members taking positions on bills according to party lines. Although this partisanship has impacted on members willingness to scrutinise government as Republican and Democrat members adopt opposite positions, Congressional committees are often controlled by the opponents to the President. For example, during the 1990s Congressional committees controlled by the Republicans carried out a number of investigations into the Democratic President, Bill Clinton, over alleged scandals in office. Senate committee meetings, especially, can often be lively and combative. UK MP George Galloway famously made a flamboyant appearance at the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs committee in 2005. There have been calls to improve the workings of committees. Many in the USA feel that the influence of professional lobbyists should be reduced. Information could be shared much better with the public so voters can be empowered to make more informed decisions about whether to keep or replace the elected officials who are acting as their representatives. However, Congressional committees do have some significant powers such as the ability to compel witnesses to attend hearings and to acquire information under oath. Indeed, lying under oath and failure to disclose information has resulted in imprisonment in the past. Page three
1. (continued) SOURCE B Parliamentary Committees in the United Kingdom House of Commons committees hold inquiries to produce reports on a range of matters, from the conduct of government to specialist subject areas. Membership of Parliamentary committees hasn t always been as valued as it could be. But in recent years their profile has risen following investigations and public hearings into the conduct of British banks and phone hacking allegations against a number of newspapers. However, critics have long argued that Parliamentary committees are limited by a lack of staff and resources to carry out detailed scrutiny of the executive branch. While MPs can belong to committees in the Commons and peers belong to committees in the Lords, there are also some joint committees where members from the two Houses of Parliament work together. Despite being, in theory, independent from the government, the balance on House of Commons committees reflects party support in the House. As a result, committees usually have a majority controlled by the governing party. For a long time, party whips had too much power and committees were accused of editing reports critical of the government as a result of the influence of government whips. Even now, sometimes hearings can be dull and MPs are not always able to get key information from witnesses. Witnesses are able to talk about irrelevant issues knowing that in a few minutes they will be free to leave. Many people feel that Parliamentary committees could be improved in order to make them more effective. The practice of giving each committee member five or 10 minutes to question witnesses can be counter-productive. While the vast majority of those called to attend committees do so, Parliament does not have any real effective power to fine or imprison people who refuse to attend or who mislead it. Using only the information in Sources A and B opposite and above: compare the effectiveness of US Congressional committees and UK Parliamentary committees in scrutinising the actions of government. In your answer you must make three points of comparison and reach an overall conclusion. 8 Page four
2. Attempt EITHER Question 2(a) OR Question 2(b). (a) Compare the role of the Executive in making policy in two political systems. 12 OR (b) Compare the role of the Judiciary in protecting rights in two political systems. 12 Page five
SECTION 3 POLITICAL PARTIES AND ELECTIONS 20 marks Attempt ALL questions. Question 2 contains a choice. 1. Study Sources A, B and C below and opposite then answer the question that follows. SOURCE A Scottish local government results for 2007 and 2012 Party 2007 results 2012 results Change in Number % of Number % of number of seats of seats seats of seats seats 2007 to 2012 SNP 363 29 7% 425 34 8% +62 Labour 348 28 4% 394 32 2% +46 Conservative 143 11 7% 115 9 4% 28 Liberal Democrat 166 13 6% 71 5 8% 95 Green 8 0 7% 14 2 3% +6 Other 194 15 7% 204 16 7% +10 SOURCE B Control of selected elected local authorities: 2007 and 2012 Local Authority 2007 2012 Control of council by party Control of council by party Aberdeen City SNP/Lib Dem coalition Labour/Conservative coalition Dundee City SNP minority SNP majority Fife SNP/Lib Dem coalition Labour minority Midlothian Labour SNP/Independent coalition Perth and Kinross Lib Dem/SNP coalition SNP minority Stirling SNP minority Labour/Conservative coalition Page six
1. (continued) SOURCE C Candidates in council elections by gender Party Candidates in 2012 % Female candidates Female Male Total 2007 2012 Labour 138 359 497 19 3% 27 7% SNP 149 465 614 21 5% 24 3% Liberal Democrat 69 178 247 30 9% 27 9% Conservative 95 267 362 24 6% 26 2% Green 35 51 86 N/A 40 7% Independent/ Other 105 586 691 20 8% 15 2% Total 591 1906 2497 22 5% 23 6% Using only the information in Sources A, B and C opposite and above. The Scottish local government elections of 2012 resulted in few changes when compared to the 2007 election. However, there was a significant increase in 2012 in the number of female candidates standing for election. To what extent does the information in Sources A, B and C support this viewpoint? 8 Page seven
2. Attempt EITHER Question 2(a) OR Question 2(b). (a) Evaluate the success of media strategies used by political parties during election campaigns. 12 OR (b) Evaluate the impact of the dominant ideas of a political party on its electoral performance. 12 [END OF SPECIMEN QUESTION PAPER] Page eight