NYS Common Core ELA & Literacy Curriculum D R A F T Grade 12 Module 2 Unit 1 Lesson 2

Similar documents
NYS Common Core ELA & Literacy Curriculum D R A F T Grade 12 Module 2 Unit 1 Lesson 7

NYS Common Core ELA & Literacy Curriculum D R A F T Grade 12 Module 2 Unit 2 Lesson 1

CJS 220. The Court System. Version 2 08/06/07 CJS 220

Activities: Teacher lecture (background information and lecture outline provided); class participation activity.

California Common Core Content Standards: Writing Grade 11/12

Guardianship & Conservatorship In Virginia

Multi-Agency Guidance (Non Police)

Refugee Council response to the 21 st Century Welfare consultation

1. Humanities-oriented academic essays are typically both analytical and argumentative.

The Genuine Temporary Entrant (GTE) Requirement (Recommendations 1 and 2)

3. Recruit at least one other person to help you with registration and other tasks on Caucus night.

If at all possible, it is strongly recommended that you get advice from a lawyer to help you with this application.

Measuring Public Opinion

Dear Mr./Ms. President... Stephen Arbogast, The National Cathedral School, Washington, DC

Unit #2: American Political Ideologies and Beliefs AP US Government & Politics Mr. Coia

Steps to Organize a CNU Chapter Congress for the New Urbanism

Role Play Magistrate Court Hearings Teacher information

CALL FOR PAPERS TWO DAY S NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON MAINSTREAMING TRIBAL AREAS IN KHYBER PAKHTUNKHWA: PROSPECTS AND CHALLENGES.

Social Studies 30-1 Related Issue Review. Related Issue 1: To what extent should ideology be the foundation of identity?

Ch nook Aboriginal Management Certificate Program (AMP) 2015 Application Form

- Problems with e-filing, especially for people from lower-income backgrounds. - Receiving memos / communication from one side and not the other

CBA Response to Private Prosecuting Association Consultation entitled. Private Prosecutions Consultation. 6 th March 2019

EUROPEAN REFUGEE CRISIS

OXON CHURCH OF ENGLAND PRIMARY SCHOOL COMPLAINTS POLICY

Tropical Forest Alliance 2020 Overview and Frequently Asked Questions

2012 CORE COURSE PROPOSAL REVIEW APPENDIX A AMERICAN HISTORY COMPONENT

DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY I $5,461 - $7,410/Month

PRE-ELECTION NATIONAL SURVEY KEY FINDINGS, INDONESIA

A Strategic Approach to Canada s Settlement Programming: Pre- and Post-Arrival Corinne Prince St-Amand Citizenship and Immigration Canada November

INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND CLIMATE CHANGE

FDP MEETING REPORT/SUMMARY. Session Info. Activities/Outcomes/ The newly established steering committee was formulated and has been Progress to Date

DESCRIPTIVE CLASSIFICATIONS OF MIGRATION. Fabio Baggio

Recording Secretary Participant Workbook Facilitators: Colin Treanor (UConn 2014) Jake Lueck (Kansas 2017)

Media & Democracy. Course Introduction Week 1

February 6, Interview with WILLIAM J. BAROODY,.JR. William A. Syers Political Scientist and Deputy Director House Republican Policy Committee

due date: Monday, August 31 (first day of school) estimated time: 3 hours (for planning purposes only; work until you finish)

Adjourning Licensing Hearings

Refugees and asylum seekers: developing local services and responses. Karen Mellanby Director of Networks and Communities Mind

CAR. Message. efforts to. is carried. It provides. Fifth Tradition. o o. out the group. o o o o. or to make a

CAMPAIGN REGISTRATION STATEMENT STATE OF WISCONSIN ETHCF-1

WATERLOO REGION LOCAL IMMIGRATION PARTNERSHIP COUNCIL (LIPC)

GENERAL ORDER PORT WASHINGTON POLICE DEPARTMENT

Supervised Legal Practice Guidelines (Legal Profession Act 2008)

REGISTERED STUDENT ORGANIZATION LEADERSHIP TEAM Drafted on: April 25, 2013

Protecting Access to Reproductive Health Care and Abortion As An Electoral Priority

CARL Backgrounder on the New Citizenship Act (formerly Bill C-24) INTRODUCTION

The Judicial Branch. I. The Structure of the Judicial Branch: *U.S. Supreme Court

Deferred Action for Parental Accountability (DAPA) Frequently Asked Questions December 4, 2014

Gun Owners Action League. Massachusetts Candidate Questionnaire. Name: Election Date: Office Sought: District: Mailing Address: Party Affiliation:

Subjective intent is too slippery:

7.0 Eagle/Cloverdale Alignment

Sociology (Master) Content Skills Learning Targets Assessment Resources & Technology. Sociology. Sociology Key What is sociology

LEGAL THEORY / JURISPRUDENCE SUMMARY

THE NEW YORK BAR FOUNDATION

Giving in Europe. The state of research on giving in 20 European countries. Barry Hoolwerf and Theo Schuyt (eds.)

ORGANIZING A LEGAL DISCUSSION (IRAC, CRAC, ETC.)

2017 NSBE DC Professionals Executive Board Candidate s Handbook

TOBACCO FREE JEFFERSON PARTNERSHIP

2018 APPLICATION FOR APPOINTMENT TO NEW ALBANY CITY COUNCIL

Mrs. Newgard. Lesson Plans POD. Grade 11 and 12

COMPILATION OF SECRETARY-GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS ON WOMEN, PEACE AND SECURITY RELEVANT TO PEACE OPERATIONS ( )

PENNSYLVANIA CONFLICT OF LAWS PROFESSOR KEVIN P. OATES DREXEL UNIVERSITY THOMAS R. KLINE SCHOOL OF LAW

Loyola University Chicago School of Law Application for Certificate in Advocacy for J.D. Students

CHAPTER 2: ECONOMIC SYSTEMS AND DECISION MAKING. Lesson 3: The Global Transition to Capitalism

Attending the Coroner s Court as a witness and how to give evidence

Sociology (Master) Content Skills Learning Targets Assessment Resources & Technology Course Essential Questions

Supporting Documentation Requirements for Renewal of Pa.C.P. Credential

Section 1 Section 2 Section 3 Section 4 Section 5

Global Community Leadership Program

Election Violence Education and Resolution. (EVER) in Timor-Leste

Findings from the Federal, State, and Tribal Response to Violence Against Women in Indian Country Studies

Multicultural Youth Advocacy Network (MYAN) Federal Election Policy Platform 2013

SALSA CLUB CONSTITUTION. Constitution of the "Salsa Club"

MICHIGAN CONTRACTS & SALES DISTINCTIONS PROFESSOR ANNE LAWTON MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF LAW

BRANDEIS UNIVERSITY FACULTY SENATE MEETING

ti' ; ~ ~djj 2 December 2016 Excellency,

Promoting Remittance for Development Finance

Understanding Innovative Potential of Central Europe: The Region s Economic, Political, and Cultural Environment

Become a Successful Bureaucrat / Judiciary

Child migration (subclass 101, 102, 445 and 117)

SUBSTITUTED JUDGMENT AND EXTRAORDINARY TREATMENT. Substituted Judgment--Overview

COMPETITIVE INTELLIGENCE IN LARGE COMPANIES GLOBAL STUDY

GUIDELINES FOR GRANT APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY RELOCATION

Review of Ofcom list of major political parties for elections taking place on 7 May 2015 Statement

What are the tools and techniques introduced to the company and the order of implementation?

AP US Government Chapter 12

WITH RECENT CHANGES ISSUED BY THE CFPB, FINAL REMITTANCE TRANSFER REGULATIONS TO BECOME EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 7, 2013

PEER INTERVIEW. Conduct a 15-minute face-to-face interview with a colleague

DATA REQUEST GUIDELINES

Paul Tacon Social Affairs Officer, Social Development Division, United Nations ESCAP

RESOURCES FOR IMMIGRANT AND REFUGEE PROFESSIONALS

Migrant children: what rights at 18?

MEMBER PROTECTION POLICY

Key YWCA USA. What Women Want 2012: A YWCA USA National Survey of Priorities and Concerns. Summary of Findings from a Survey among Adult Women

LEGAL BRIEF SMALL CLAIMS COURT JANUARY 2016

Dautrich/Yalof/Bejarano, The Enduring Democracy, Fifth Edition ACGM

USF Sarasota-Manatee Student Government Association Legislative Branch 05/13/16

CAPIC Submission on Part 16: Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR)

Greater Sudbury Local Immigration Partnership Presentation Part 2

Into the Future: Confirming Our Common Vision

Transcription:

12.2.1 Lessn 2 Intrductin In this lessn, students cntinue their analysis f Benazir Bhutt s speech, Ideas Live On, paying particular attentin t hw Bhutt develps a cmplex set f ideas in paragraphs 11 23 (frm What kind f future we the peple f Pakistan build t and 25% ($3.4 Billin) t civilian gvernments ver 19 years ). In this excerpt, Bhutt describes the plitical, judiciary, and ecnmic cnditins f Pakistan. Befre participating in a whle-class discussin, students wrk in small grups t analyze Bhutt s claims and hw she supprts them. Student learning is assessed via a Quick Write at the end f the lessn: Hw d the ideas and events Bhutt discusses in paragraphs 11 23 develp a central idea frm paragraphs 1 3? The clsing f the lessn includes an ptin t intrduce students t the practice f Accuntable Independent Writing (AIW) in preparatin fr an alternative End-f-Unit Assessment prmpt fcusing n the cncept f citizenship. Fr hmewrk, students cntinue reading their Accuntable Independent Reading (AIR) texts thrugh the lens f a fcus standard f their chice. Als fr hmewrk, students select a central idea frm paragraphs 1 3 ther than the ne they wrte abut in class and explain hw Bhutt develps this idea in paragraphs 11 23. http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 1

Standards Assessed Standard(s) RI.11-12.2 Determine tw r mre central ideas f a text and analyze their develpment ver the curse f the text, including hw they interact and build n ne anther t prvide a cmplex analysis; prvide an bjective summary f the text. Addressed Standard(s) W. 11-12.9.b L. 11-12.4.a Draw evidence frm literary r infrmatinal texts t supprt analysis, reflectin, and research. b. Apply grades 11 12 Reading standards t literary nnfictin (e.g., Delineate and evaluate the reasning in seminal U.S. texts, including the applicatin f cnstitutinal principles and use f legal reasning [e.g., in U.S. Supreme Curt Case majrity pinins and dissents] and the premises, purpses, and arguments in wrks f public advcacy [e.g., The Federalist, presidential addresses] ). Determine r clarify the meaning f unknwn and multiple-meaning wrds and phrases based n grades 11 12 reading and cntent, chsing flexibly frm a range f strategies. a. Use cntext (e.g., the verall meaning f a sentence, paragraph, r text; a wrd s psitin r functin in a sentence) as a clue t the meaning f a wrd r phrase. Assessment http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 2

Assessment(s) Student learning is assessed via a Quick Write at the end f the lessn. Students respnd t the fllwing prmpt, citing textual evidence t supprt analysis and inferences drawn frm the text. Hw d the ideas and events Bhutt discusses in paragraphs 11 23 develp a central idea frm paragraphs 1 3? High Perfrmance Respnse(s) A High Perfrmance Respnse shuld: Identify a central idea frm paragraphs 1 3 (e.g., the exercise f pwer; the relatinship between the individual and the state). Explain hw ideas r events Bhutt presents in paragraphs 11 23 develp this central idea (e.g., In paragraphs 11 23, Bhutt develps her ideas abut the exercise f pwer by demnstrating the negative effects n Pakistan that have resulted frm it nt making the shift frm exercising pwer thrugh the military t exercising pwer thrugh intellectual strength. She explains that the future f Pakistan depends n the nature f ur plitical system, the strength f ur judiciary and the use f ur ecnmic resurces (par. 11) and ges n t describe hw military rule has damaged each f these systems. Bhutt states that the military rulers have little incentive t build peace restre security r allw the empwerment f the peple (par. 18). She says that justice has systematically been undermined by the military rule (par. 16) and that the military rule has resulted in an ecnmic system addicted t aid (par. 21). Bhutt s examples shw that the exercise f pwer thrugh military strength has damaged Pakistan and that the cuntry shuld shift t the exercise f pwer thrugh the strength f the intellect (par. 2).). Vcabulary http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 3

Vcabulary t prvide directly (will nt include extended instructin) judiciary (n.) the system f curts f justice in a cuntry elusive (adj.) hard t find empwerment (n.) the giving f an ability; enablement r permissin subjugating (v.) defeating and gaining cntrl f (smene r smething) by the use f frce Imams (n.) Muslim religius leaders madrassas (n.) Muslim schls, clleges, r universities that are ften part f a msque Vcabulary t teach (may include direct wrd wrk and/r questins) Nne. Additinal vcabulary t supprt English Language Learners (t prvide directly) incentive (n.) smething that encurages a persn t d smething r t wrk harder Lessn Agenda/Overview Student-Facing Agenda Standards & Text: Standards: RI.11-12.2, W.11-12.9.b, L.11-12.4.a Text: Ideas Live On by Benazir Bhutt, paragraphs 11 23 % f Lessn Learning Sequence: 1. Intrductin f Lessn Agenda 2. Hmewrk Accuntability 3. Reading and Discussin 4. Quick Write 5. Clsing 1. 10% 2. 10% 3. 60% 4. 10% 5. 10% Materials Student cpies f the Shrt Respnse Rubric and Checklist (refer t 12.2.1 Lessn 1) (ptinal) http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 4

Learning Sequence Hw t Use the Learning Sequence Symb l Type f Text & Interpretatin f the Symbl 10% Percentage indicates the percentage f lessn time each activity shuld take. n symbl Plain text indicates teacher actin. Bld text indicates questins fr the teacher t ask students. Italicized text indicates a vcabulary wrd.! Indicates student actin(s). " Indicates pssible student respnse(s) t teacher questins. # Indicates instructinal ntes fr the teacher. Activity 1: Intrductin f Lessn Agenda 10% Begin by reviewing the agenda and the assessed standard fr this lessn: RI.11-12.2. In this lessn, students read and analyze paragraphs 11 23 (frm What kind f future we the peple f Pakistan build t and 25% ($3.4 Billin) t civilian gvernments ver 19 years ), paying particular attentin t Bhutt s claims and hw she supprts them. Students wrk in grups and participate in a whle-class discussin. The lessn cncludes with a Quick Write. Students lk at the agenda. Activity 2: Hmewrk Accuntability 10% Instruct students t talk in pairs abut hw they applied a fcus standard t their AIR texts. Lead a brief share ut n the previus lessn s AIR hmewrk assignment. Select several students (r student pairs) t explain hw they applied a fcus standard t their AIR texts. Students (r student pairs) discuss and share hw they applied a fcus standard t their AIR texts frm the previus lessn s hmewrk. Althugh AIR remains an expectatin f students thrughut the year, accuntability check-ins ccur less frequently in Mdule 12.2 as students assume greater respnsibility fr their wn reading. http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 5

Instruct students t take ut their respnses t the previus lessn s hmewrk assignment. (Cnduct a brief search int Benazir Bhutt and Pakistan and select three significant facts that deepen yur understanding f Bhutt s speech t share with the class.) Instruct students t talk in pairs abut the facts they fund abut Bhutt and Pakistan and their ideas abut hw these facts prvide cntext fr Bhutt s speech. Student respnses may include: Pakistan has the wrld s secnd largest Muslim ppulatin (after Indnesia) and Bhutt herself is Muslim, s Bhutt s appeals t Islamic values will be imprtant t her audience s sense f what is right and wrng. Bhutt cmes frm a plitical family in Pakistan: Her father was executed as a result f a military cup and she herself served twice as prime minister f Pakistan, s she is a respected plitical figure. In 1999, Pervez Musharraf led a bldless cup and became head f state frm 1999 t 2008, s Bhutt was nt in pwer at the time f this speech. Pakistan cntinued t suffer frm plitical unrest and Benazir Bhutt was assassinated in a military cup in December 2007 during a campaign tur. Bhutt s cncerns abut the rle f the military in Pakistan therefre seem justified. Pakistan has been cnsidered a partner in the U.S. gvernment s war n terrr; Bhutt s references t the war n terrr may als reflect her cncerns abut the cuntry s relatinship with the United States. Lead a brief whle-class discussin f student respnses. Activity 3: Reading and Discussin 60% Instruct students t frm small grups. Pst r prject each set f questins belw fr students t discuss. Instruct students t cntinue t anntate the text as they read and discuss (W.11-12.9.b). If necessary t supprt cmprehensin and fluency, cnsider using a masterful reading f the fcus excerpt fr the lessn. Differentiatin Cnsideratin: Cnsider psting r prjecting the fllwing guiding questin t supprt students in their reading thrughut this lessn: http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 6

What imprtant ideas des Bhutt discuss in these paragraphs? Instruct student pairs t read paragraphs 11 23 f Ideas Live On (frm What kind f future we the peple f Pakistan build t and 25% ($3.4 Billin) t civilian gvernments ver 19 years ) and answer the fllwing questins befre sharing ut with the class. Prvide students with the definitins f judiciary, elusive, empwerment, subjugating, Imams, and madrassas. Students may be familiar with sme f these wrds. Cnsider asking students t vlunteer definitins befre prviding them t the grup. Students write the definitins f judiciary, elusive, empwerment, subjugating, Imams, and madrassas n their cpies f the text r in a vcabulary jurnal. Differentiatin Cnsideratin: Cnsider prviding students with the definitin f incentive. Students write the definitin f incentive n their cpies f the text r in a vcabulary jurnal. Differentiatin Cnsideratin: Cnsider identifying Pakistan and Afghanistan n a map r glbe t familiarize students with the cuntries lcatins. Identify an idea that is cmmn t bth paragraphs 3 and 11. Bth paragraphs 3 and 11 suggest that the rle f the gvernment is critical in prviding citizens with the tls and resurces they need t succeed in mdern sciety. Fr example, in paragraph 3, Bhutt claims that the the quality f ur sciety and the future f ur peple depends n the investment in an individual, thrugh educatin and health, suggesting that Pakistan s gvernment shuld supprt health and educatin services fr its citizens. In paragraph 11, Bhutt claims, What kind f future we... build depends n the nature f ur plitical system, the strength f ur judiciary and the use f ur ecnmic resurces. This claim suggests that Pakistan shuld imprve its gvernment structures t imprve the lives f its citizens. Which areas des Bhutt identify as key t Pakistan s future in paragraph 11? Bhutt claims that the plitical, judiciary, and ecnmic systems are key t Pakistan s future. She says, What kind f future we build depends n the nature f ur plitical system, the strength f ur judiciary and the use f ur ecnmic resurces. Hw des Bhutt supprt her criticism f the military in paragraphs 12 23? Student respnses shuld include: http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 7

In paragraphs 12 23, Bhutt demnstrates hw the military has failed each f the systems she named in paragraph 11: plitical, judiciary, and ecnmic. In paragraphs 12 14, Bhutt suggests that Pakistan must use the upcming electins t chse a frm f gvernment ther than the military dictatrship in rder t invest in individuals, arguing in paragraph 14 that many f Pakistan s prblems are directly related t the prlnged perid f military dminatin f ur sciety. In paragraphs 15 and 16, Bhutt explains hw the military has interfered with Pakistan s judiciary system, claiming that justice in ur cuntry is elusive (par. 15) and that justice has systematically been undermined by the military rule (par. 16). Bhutt pints t the way in which military rule has influenced the curt system by remving Chief Justices, including the remval f the Chief Justice Yaqub in 1977 and anther remval f a Chief Justice in 2007 (par. 16). In paragraphs 17 23, Bhutt explains hw the military gvernment has mismanaged the ecnmy by relying n external aid in return fr Western supprt fr military rulers (par. 17). This, accrding t Bhutt, has created a sciety addicted t aid (par. 21), nting, hwever, that the mney has nt imprved the lives r ur peple (par. 22). In paragraph 22, Bhutt uses statistics, reprting that the military gvernment received nearly $5 Billin in aid ver the last six years and that [a]n extra $100 Millin are given mnthly in calitin funds (par. 22). She als reprts, in paragraph 23, that nly 25% ($3.4 Billin) f the aid that the U.S. gave t Pakistan between 1954 and 2002 went t civilian gvernments ver 19 years; the rest went t military rulers. Differentiatin Cnsideratin: If students struggle, cnsider psing the fllwing scafflding questins: Hw des Bhutt develp her criticism f the plitical system in paragraph 14? Bhutt claims Pakistan s plitical system is manipulated by the military gvernment. Bhutt says military rule is respnsible fr many f the prblems in Pakistan. She ntes that Pakistan has been under military rule fr 30 years and says military rule is t blame fr the prblems f terrrism, sectarianism, militancy, extremism, intlerance and increase in pverty. What criticism des Bhutt make f military rule in relatin t the justice system? Bhutt says military rule has made justice elusive (par. 15) because the military gvernment cntrls the judges. She says justice has systematically been undermined and pints t hw military rule has influenced the curt system by http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 8

remving Chief Justices, including the remval f the Chief Justice Yaqub in 1977 and anther remval f a Chief Justice in 2007 (par. 16). What criticisms des Bhutt make f the military dictatrship s ecnmic apprach in paragraphs 18 23? Student respnses shuld include: Bhutt criticizes the military gvernment s ecnmic apprach because the gvernment relies n rent[ing] ut the army s services fr freign causes, including cmmunism and terrrism (par. 18). Bhutt criticizes the military gvernment s ecnmic apprach because the gvernment gets cvert funds and military and ecnmic assistance fr supprting plicies that prmte cnflict. She says, Since a crisis r a threat brings with it plitical pwer fr the Generals there is little incentive t build peace in place f cnflict, restre security in place f crisis r allw the empwerment f the peple in place f subjugating them thrugh militias r abuse f state pwer (par. 18). Bhutt criticizes the military gvernment s ecnmic apprach because it has resulted in Pakistan s becming addicted t aid, in the wrds f a frmer Pakistan Air Frce Chief (par. 21). Bhutt claims that the gvernment depends n mney frm freign gvernments in exchange fr supprt frm the military and that this has becme the main surce f incme fr the cuntry. Bhutt criticizes the military gvernment s ecnmic apprach by citing statistics t demnstrate that the military gvernment, nt the peple, benefit frm the large amunt f mney Pakistan receives in freign aid. She says f the $12.6 Billin Washingtn prvided in ecnmic and military aid ver the last 25 years, 75% ($9.19 Billin) went t military rulers while nly 25% ($3.4 Billin) [went] t civilian gvernments (par. 23). In paragraph 18, hw des Bhutt suggest that the military gvernment maintains its psitin? Student respnses shuld include: The gvernment maintains its psitin by accepting mney in exchange fr supprting freign military effrts. Bhutt states that Pakistan rents the army s services fr fighting varius causes like Cmmunism r Terrrism. The gvernment maintains its psitin by cntrlling the peple with military strength and an unfair plitical system. Bhutt claims the gvernment refuses t http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 9

allw the empwerment f the peple in place f subjugating them thrugh militias r abuse f state pwer. Explain that the term exercise f pwer refers t the means by which an individual r institutin cntrls thers. In paragraph 18, what kind f relatinship des Bhutt suggest that the military gvernment has with its citizens? Bhutt suggests that the military has a negative relatinship with its citizens, and represses individuals rather than develping them. She claims that the gvernment prevents empwerment f the peple and instead subjugate[s] them thrugh militias r abuse f state pwer. Accrding t Bhutt, the military gvernment makes plicy decisins designed t benefit the leadership rather than the peple, because expliting a crisis r a threat brings with it plitical pwer fr the Generals with the result that the military gvernment des nt build peace restre security r allw the empwerment f the peple. Cnsider explaining t students that the phrase the relatinship between the individual and the state expresses the cmplex links between a gvernment and its citizens, including the respnsibilities a gvernment has tward its citizens and the respnsibilities a citizen has tward his r her gvernment. Differentiatin Cnsideratin: If students struggle, cnsider psing the fllwing scafflding questin: What can yu infer abut the meaning f the wrd state frm Bhutt s criticism f the gvernment s abuse f state pwer in paragraph 18? (L.11-12.4.a) The phrase abuse f state pwer refers t the gvernment s misuse f its pwer. This suggests that the wrd state means a gvernment r plitically rganized sciety having a particular character. Hw des Bhutt's criticism f military rule develp a central idea? Student respnses may include: Bhutt s criticism f military rule develps the central idea f the relatinship between the individual and the state. Bhutt s bservatin that Pakistan s military gvernment brings plitical pwer fr the Generals suggests that Pakistan s plicies disregard the gd f the peple in rder t benefit the military leaders (par. 18). These plicies cntrast with the ideals Bhutt set frth in paragraphs 1 3, where Bhutt explains the need t invest in an individual, thrugh educatin and health (par. 3) in rder t prvide a secure future. Bhutt s criticism f http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 10

military rule suggests that a state in which the individual is nt imprtant will benefit nly the military leadership, nt the rdinary citizens f a natin. Bhutt s criticism f military rule develps the central idea f the exercise f pwer by demnstrating the dangers f exercising pwer thrugh military strength. In paragraph 2, Bhutt claims that [w]hile military strength cntinued t be imprtant, it was n lnger critical in defining the greatness f a natin at the beginning f the 21st century. Bhutt s criticism f military rule develps this idea by shwing that the military gvernment is respnsible fr the prblems f terrrism, sectarianism, militancy, extremism, intlerance and increase in pverty (par. 14) and that [i]t has nt imprved the lives f ur peple (par. 22). Bhutt s criticism suggests that Pakistan shuld chse a gvernment that exercises pwer by investing in individuals rather than in the military. Based n Bhutt s statement in paragraph 13, what can yu infer abut the purpse f her speech? In paragraph 13, Bhutt says that Pakistan is heading twards parliamentary and pssibly presidential electins, s her purpse fr this speech may be t gain supprt fr a campaign in these electins. Lead a brief whle-class discussin f student respnses. Activity 4: Quick Write 10% Instruct students t respnd briefly in writing t the fllwing prmpt: Hw d the ideas and events Bhutt discusses in paragraphs 11 23 develp a central idea frm paragraphs 1 3? Instruct students t lk at their anntatins t find evidence. Ask students t use this lessn s vcabulary wherever pssible in their written respnses. Students listen and read the Quick Write prmpt. Display the prmpt fr students t see, r prvide the prmpt in hard cpy. Transitin t the independent Quick Write. Students independently answer the prmpt using evidence frm the text. See the High Perfrmance Respnse at the beginning f this lessn. http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 11

Cnsider using the Shrt Respnse Rubric t assess students writing. Students may use the Shrt Respnse Rubric and Checklist t guide their written respnses. Activity 5: Clsing 10% Display and distribute the hmewrk assignment. Fr hmewrk, students shuld cntinue t read their AIR texts thrugh the lens f a fcus standard f their chice and prepare fr a 3 5 minute discussin f their texts based n that standard. Remind students that they shuld cntinue reading their AIR texts thrughut the year, even thugh accuntability check-ins ccur less frequently. Als fr hmewrk, instruct students t identify a central idea frm paragraphs 1 3 ther than the ne they wrte abut in class and explain hw Bhutt develps this idea in paragraphs 11 23. Explain that in 12.2.1, students cntinue t build n the writing skills they develped in Mdule 12.1. In this unit, written respnses t AIW prmpts prepare students fr an alternative End-f-Unit assessment prmpt fcusing n the cncept f citizenship. Cnsider intrducing the fllwing alternative End-f-Unit Assessment prmpt: Hw des the wrk f Bhutt and Threau shape yur understanding f what it means t be a citizen? Explain that students will have pprtunities thrughut 12.2.1 t cnsider varius aspects f this questin in AIW assignments and that their respnses t these writing assignments can be used as resurces fr the alternative End-f-Unit Assessment. Instruct students t write a brief respnse t the fllwing questin: Hw des Bhutt s statement, We are witnessing a new divide between the advantaged glbal citizen and the disadvantaged lcal citizen (par. 5) shape yur understanding f what it means t be a citizen? Students fllw alng. Hmewrk Cntinue reading yur Accuntable Independent Reading text thrugh the lens f a fcus standard f yur chice and prepare fr a 3 5 minute discussin f yur text based n that standard. http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 12

In additin, select a central idea frm paragraphs 1 3 ther than the ne yu wrte abut in class, and explain hw Bhutt develps this idea in paragraphs 11 23. http://creativecmmns.rg/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/! 13