RESULTS OF VOTES ANNEX Abbreviations and symbols + adopted - rejected lapsed W withdrawn (...,...,...) roll-call vote (for, against, abstentions) EV (...,...,...) electronic vote (for, against, abstentions) split split vote sep separate vote am amendment CA compromise amendment CP corresponding part D deleting amendment = identical amendments paragraph art article rec recital MOT motion for resolution JT MOT joint motion for a resolution SEC secret ballot P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 1 PE 629.327
1. Import of cultural goods ***I Report: Alessia Maria Mosca, Daniel Dalton (A8-0308/2018) Subject /EV remarks single vote + 513, 57, 33 2. Protection of the EU s financial interests - Recovery of money and assets from third-countries in fraud cases Report: Cătălin Sorin Ivan (A8-0298/2018) Subject /EV remarks single vote + 502, 70, 45 3. Unfair trading practices in business-to-business relationships in the food supply chain ***I Report: Paolo De Castro (A8-0309/2018) Subject /EV remarks : decision to enter into interinstitutional negotiations + 428, 170, 18 Requests for roll-call votes S&D Miscellaneous was requested pursuant to Rule 69c by the Verts/ALE Group and the following Members: Caspary, Mann, Gräßle, Collin-Langen, Radtke, Langen, Ferber, Kuhn, Florenz, Zeller, Schwab, Voss, Koch, Brok, Gieseke, Gehrold, Verheyen, Liese, Wieland, Gahler, Müller, Huitema, van Baalen, Nagtegaal, Klinz, Selimovic, McAllister, Ehler, Schulze, Winkler Iuliu, Hirsch, Meissner, Gericke, Quisthoudt-Rowohl, Štefanec, Corazza Bildt, Niedermayer, Virkkunen, Winkler Hermann, Mureşan, Kariņš, Sommer, Girling, Ashworth, Fjellner, Sellström, Hökmark and Lange. Tom Vandenkendelaere had withdrawn his signature from the request. 4. Authorisation and supervision of medicinal products for human and veterinary use ***I Report: Claudiu Ciprian Tănăsescu (A8-0035/2016) P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 2 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author Provisional agreement /EV remarks Provisional agreement 36 committee + 563, 48, 10 5. Veterinary medicinal products ***I Report: Françoise Grossetête (A8-0046/2016) Subject Am No Author Provisional agreement /EV remarks Provisional agreement 324 committee + 583, 16, 20 6. Manufacture, placing on the market and use of medicated feed ***I Report: Clara Eugenia Aguilera García (A8-0075/2016) Subject Am No Author Provisional agreement /EV remarks Provisional agreement 94 committee + 583, 31, 6 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 3 PE 629.327
7. Charging of heavy goods vehicles for the use of certain infrastructures ***I Report: Christine Revault d'allonnes Bonnefoy (A8-0202/2018) Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Proposal to reject the Commission proposal Proposal to reject the Commission proposal 132 EFDD - Amendments by the committee responsible put to the vote collectively 1-4 6-7 10 12-15 17-18 20-25 27-29 31 33-35 37-41 43 48 50-51 53-59 61-62 65-68 70 75-77 79-80 82 84-86 93 96-97 99-110 115-123 125-130 Draft legislative act committee + Amendments by the committee responsible - separate vote 9 committee sep/ev - 303, 307, 11 11 committee sep/ev + 325, 285, 7 19 committee sep/ev - 268, 331, 8 26 committee sep - 32 committee sep/ev + 304, 303, 9 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 4 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 44 committee sep/ev + 329, 284, 4 45 committee sep/ev - 299, 304, 7 46 committee split 2/EV - 269, 340, 10 52 committee sep + 69 committee sep + 81 committee sep/ev + 315, 297, 6 92 committee sep/ev + 318, 271, 23 Article 1, 1, point 1 Title Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 1, after 3 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 2, after point c Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 6 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 8 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, after point 12 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 15 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 16 133 Verts/ALE - 150 ENF - 132, 479, 7 172 38+ MEPs - 233, 374, 11 16, 124 committee + 134 Verts/ALE EV - 301, 307, 9 42 committee + 151 ENF 135 Verts/ALE - 244, 361, 13 136 Verts/ALE - 137 Verts/ALE - 233, 361, 26 152 ENF - 108, 495, 12 153 ENF - 85, 500, 30 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 5 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 18 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 19 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 20 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 21 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 22 Article 1, 1, point 2 Article 2, 1, point 24 Article 1, 1, point 3 Article 7, 7 154D ENF - 155D ENF - 47 committee + 156D ENF - 157D ENF - 158D ENF - 49 committee + 159 ENF - 86, 500, 28 160D ENF - 60 committee - 293, 299, 28 original text split Article 1, 1, point 4 Article 7a, 3 Article 1, 1, point 4 Article 7a, 4 Article 1, 1, point 5 Article 7c, 3 Article 1, 1, point 6 Article 7da 161D ENF - 100, 512, 7 63 committee + 162D ENF - 64 committee + 138D Verts/ALE - 163D ENF - 143, 456, 10 71 committee EV - 278, 327, 11 72 committee + P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 6 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 73 committee EV - 303, 304, 4 74 committee - Article 1, 1, point 7 Article 7f, 1a 78D= 164D= committee, ENF + Article 1, 1, point 7 Article 7g, 4, sub 1 Article 1, 1, point 7 Article 7g, 4, after sub 2 Article 1, 1, point 8 Article 7ga Article 1, 1, point 10 Article 7i, 2, points b and c and 3 Article 1, 1, point 11 Article 7j, 4, first sentence Article 1, 1, point 14, sub-point b Article 9, 3 Article 1, 1, point 18 Article 11, 2, point e Article 1, 1, point 18 Article 11, 2, point i Article 1, 1, point 18 Article 11, 3, point c 139 Verts/ALE - 83 committee + 140 Verts/ALE - 227, 362, 25 165D ENF - 110, 486, 7 87, 88, 89, 90, 91 committee + 141D Verts/ALE - 94, 95, 98 committee + 166D ENF - 120, 486, 5 167D ENF - 111, 112, 113, 114 committee EV + 343, 253, 11 168D ENF - 169D ENF - 170D ENF - P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 7 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Annex I, point 2 Annex V 171D ENF - 136, 441, 10 131 committee + Recital 2 142 ENF - 92, 488, 24 Recital 3 143D ENF - 121, 473, 7 5 committee split 2/EV - 285, 314, 5 Recital 4 144D ENF - 105, 489, 6 8 committee + Recital 11 145D ENF - Recital 13 146D ENF - 129, 472, 5 30 committee EV + 378, 222, 5 Recital 14 147D ENF - Recital 19 36 committee + 148 ENF Recital 20 149D ENF - : Commission proposal + 398, 179, 32 Requests for roll-call votes Verts/ALE: amendments 135, 137, 140 ENF: amendments 142, 143, 144, 146, 148, 150, 151, 152, 153, 159, 161, 163, 165, 166, 171 PPE amendment 172 S&D: amendment 60 Requests for separate votes PPE: amendments 9, 11, 19, 26, 30, 32, 44, 45, 52, 71, 72, 73, 74, 81, 92 S&D: amendments 60, 69 Requests for split votes PPE: amendment 5 Text as a whole excluding the words: and motorcycles those words P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 8 PE 629.327
amendment 46 light vehicle means a light duty vehicle, a passenger car or a motorcycle Article 1, 1, point 3,, Article 7, 7 Text as a whole excluding the words: duty and User charges introduced before that date shall be phased out by 31 December 2027 those words P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 9 PE 629.327
8. Promotion of clean and energy-efficient road transport vehicles ***I Report: Andrzej Grzyb (A8-0321/2018) Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Amendments by the committee responsible put to the vote collectively 1-3 6-14 16-39 41-48 50-52 54-59 62-71 73-74 86 committee + Amendments by the committee responsible - separate vote 4 committee sep + 5 committee sep/ev + 312, 261, 23 40 committee + 439, 146, 9 49 committee sep + 53 committee + 439, 147, 8 60 committee + 434, 142, 8 61 committee + 478, 96, 12 72 committee sep/ev + 309, 264, 21 Article 1, 1, point 5 Directive 2009/33/EC Article 5, after 1 Article 1, 1, point 5 Directive 2009/33/EC Article 5, after 2 Article 1, 1, point 9, sub-point b Directive 2009/33/EC Article 10, after 5 Annex I Directive 2009/33/EC Annex, table 4 and footnote - 1 [targets] 82 PPE - 284, 303, 8 80 ECR - 252, 336, 5 77 S&D EV - 282, 302, 6 78 Verts/ALE - 286, 290, 14 75cp committee + Annex I Directive 85 PPE + P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 10 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author 2009/33/EC Annex, table 4, footnote 1 75cp committee /EV remarks Annex I Directive 2009/33/EC Annex, table 5 79 Verts/ALE + 301, 269, 18 76 committee Recital 9 83 PPE EV - 232, 354, 8 original text + 320, 264, 6 Recital 10 84 PPE - 15 committee EV + 312, 265, 9 : Commission proposal + 400, 76, 112 Requests for roll-call votes PPE: amendment 82 Verts/ALE: amendments 40, 53, 60, 61, 78, 79, 80 ENF: Recital 9 Requests for separate votes PPE: amendments 4, 5, 15, 72 Verts/ALE: amendments 40, 53, 60, 61 EFDD: amendment 49 Miscellaneous Amendment 81 had been cancelled. Erratum (amendment 86): all language versions P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 11 PE 629.327
9. Multiannual plan for fish stocks in the Western Waters and adjacent waters, and for fisheries exploiting those stocks ***I Report: Alain Cadec (A8-0310/2018) Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Amendments by the committee responsible put to the vote collectively 1-6 8-15 17 19-20 24 29-41 43 45-48 52-56 58-60 64-67 69-75 78-84 86 88 committee + Amendments by the committee responsible - separate vote 7 committee split 2/EV - 245, 294, 35 16 committee sep/ev + 417, 103, 51 18 committee split 21 committee sep/ev - 201, 359, 5 22 committee sep + 23 committee split 2/EV - 231, 325, 8 26 committee sep + 27 committee sep + 28 committee sep + P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 12 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author 44 committee split /EV remarks 3/EV - 240, 312, 7 51 committee sep + 57 committee sep - 61 committee sep/ev + 429, 106, 28 63 committee - 228, 301, 25 68 committee sep/ev + 349, 185, 19 76 committee sep + 85 committee sep + 87 committee sep/ev - 247, 273, 30 89 committee sep - Article 1, 1, point 4 97D 38+ MEPs - 25 committee + Article 1, 1, point 17 98 38+ MEPs - Article 2, 1, after point 9 Article 4, 5, introduction 91 Verts/ALE EV + 318, 231, 9 42 committee original text + 433, 91, 26 Article 4, 5, point a 49 committee split 1/ + 417, 122, 8 2/ + 362, 167, 6 original text Article 4, 5, point b original text + 272, 233, 42 Article 4, 5, point c 50 committee sep + P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 13 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks original text Article 7, after 2 96 Article 9, 3 92 Verts/ALE - 62 committee + Article 12, 1 93 Verts/ALE - Article 13, after 2 90 ALDE + Article 14, 1 77 committee sep - 94 Verts/ALE - After recital 16 95-161, 370, 26 : Commission proposal + 437, 103, 11 Requests for roll-call votes : amendments 49, 63, 95, 96; Article 4 5 Requests for separate votes 38+ MEPs amendments 16, 25, 61 ALDE: amendments 21, 57, 63, 89 Verts/ALE: amendments 26, 27, 28, 57, 63, 50, 51, 68, 85, 87 : amendments 23, 49, 51, 57, 63, 77; Article 4 5 S&D: amendments 21, 22, 50, 57, 63, 76, 77, 85, 87, 89 Requests for split votes Verts/ALE: amendment 7 Text as a whole excluding the words: in particular this word amendment 18 S&D: amendment 23 Text as a whole excluding the words: It should also be specified that the landing obligation does not apply to recreational fishing. those words Text as a whole excluding the words: for seven years those words ALDE, Verts/ALE: amendment 44 Text as a whole excluding the words: including by the use of innovative selective fishing gear and techniques and as far as possible including by the use of innovative selective fishing gear and techniques P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 14 PE 629.327
Third part amendment 49 as far as possible Text as a whole excluding the words: fisheries, in particular to limit the induced socio-economic constraints on those words 10. Location of the seat of the European Banking Authority ***I Report: Othmar Karas, Pervenche Berès (A8-0153/2018) Subject Am No Author Provisional agreement /EV remarks Provisional agreement 2 committee + 462, 48, 40 Council statement 3 committee + 11. Relocation of the European Medicines Agency ***I Report: Giovanni La Via (A8-0063/2018) Subject Am No Author Provisional agreement /EV remarks Provisional agreement 16 committee + 425, 71, 56 Council statement 17 committee + P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 15 PE 629.327
12. Rise of neo-fascist violence in Europe Motions for resolutions: B8-0481/2018, B8-0482/2018, B8-0483/2018, B8-0486/2018, B8-0488/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0481/2018 (PPE, S&D, ALDE, ) 12 original text + 481, 30, 22 17 original text + 405, 76, 47 18 original text sep + 25 original text sep + Recital E original text sep + Recital G original text split 3 + Recital L original text sep + Recital M original text sep + Recital N original text sep + Recital O original text sep/ev + 310, 159, 46 Recital P original text sep + Recital Q original text sep/ev + 275, 195, 47 after Recital Q 1 S&D, 2 S&D, 3 S&D, + 216, 206, 52 + 233, 224, 62 + 247, 221, 49 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 16 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 4 S&D, 5 S&D, 6 S&D, 7 S&D, 8 S&D, 9 S&D, 10 S&D, 11 S&D, 12 S&D, 13 S&D, 14 S&D, 15 S&D, + 238, 208, 56 + 248, 211, 53 + 246, 208, 47 + 249, 213, 52 + 246, 202, 51 + 231, 208, 67 + 223, 206, 65 + 253, 209, 51 + 247, 206, 53 + 249, 209, 52-230, 232, 32-225, 232, 39 : resolution (text as a whole) + 355, 90, 39 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 17 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Motion for a resolution B8-0481/2018 (PPE) 3 17 S&D, After 3 18 S&D, 19 S&D, 20 S&D, 21 S&D, 22 S&D, 23 S&D, 24 S&D, After 9 25 S&D, 26 S&D, 11 27 S&D, After 11 28 S&D, P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 18 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks After 16 29 S&D, 30 S&D, After recital D 1 S&D, After Recital J 2 S&D, 3 S&D, 4 S&D, 5 S&D, 6 S&D, 7 S&D, 8 S&D, 9 S&D, 10 S&D, 11 S&D, P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 19 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 12 S&D, 13 S&D, 14 S&D, 15 S&D, 16 S&D, : resolution (text as a whole) Motion for a resolution B8-0482/2018 (S&D, ) : resolution (text as a whole) Motion for a resolution B8-0483/2018 (ALDE) 3 14 S&D, After 3 15 S&D, 16 S&D, 17 S&D, 18 S&D, P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 20 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 19 S&D, 20 S&D, 21 S&D, After 9 22 S&D, 23 S&D, 15 24 S&D, After 15 25 S&D, Recital K 1 S&D, After recital K 2 S&D, Recital N 3 S&D, After recital N 4 S&D, 5 S&D, 6 S&D, P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 21 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 7 S&D, 8 S&D, After recital P 9 S&D, 10 S&D, 11 S&D, 12 S&D, 13 S&D, : resolution (text as a whole) Motions for resolutions by political groups B8-0486/2018 ECR B8-0488/2018 ENF RC-B8-0481/2018 Requests for roll-call votes S&D: amendments 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, final vote ECR 12, 17, final vote PPE: final vote Requests for separate votes ECR 12, 17, 18, 25, recitals E, M PPE: recitals L, M, N, O, P, Q Requests for split votes PPE: Recital G P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 22 PE 629.327
Third part whereas, as reported by Europol, the EU Security Commissioner Sir Julian King, speaking at an event on 22 March 2017 to commemorate the 2016 Brussels attacks, highlighted the growing menace of right-wing violent extremism, stating that he was not aware of a single EU Member State that is not affected by the phenomenon in some way, specifically citing the 2011 Norway attacks, the assassination of British MP Jo Cox, and attacks on asylum centres and mosques across Europe to highlight what he warned was a less reported threat to security; whereas neo-fascist and neo-nazi groups manifest themselves in a variety of forms; whereas most of these groups exclude certain individuals or groups from society; whereas these organisations often use aggressive language towards minority groups and seek to justify their doing so by invoking the principle of freedom of speech; whereas the right to freedom of speech is not absolute; Requests for roll-call votes B8-0481/2018 S&D: amendments 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, final vote B8-0482/2018 S&D: final vote B8-0483/2018 S&D: amendments 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, final vote Miscellaneous Paloma López Bermejo and Marina Albiol Guzmán ( Group) had also signed joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0481/2018. Bodil Valero and Jordi Solé (Verts/ALE Group) had also signed joint motion for a resolution RC- B8-0481/2018. Kateřina Konečná ( Group) had also signed Amendments 8 15. Jordi Solé (Verts/ALE Group) had also signed Amendments 1 15. 13. Animal welfare, antimicrobial use and the environmental impact of industrial broiler farming Motions for resolutions: B8-0484/2018, B8-0485/2018, B8-0487/2018, B8-0489/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0484/2018 (PPE, S&D, ECR, ALDE,, EFDD) After 5 13 ENF - 44, 376, 10 14 2, Verts/ALE - 131, 316, 3 After 14 14 ENF - P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 23 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 15 original text + 423, 25, 0 After 15 3, Verts/ALE - 141, 291, 18 16 original text + 427, 16, 1 After 16 4, Verts/ALE - 156, 280, 3 17 original text + 397, 32, 9 After citation 11 5 ENF - 6 ENF - Recital A 7 ENF - Recital E 8 ENF - After recital E 9 ENF - 10 ENF - 11 ENF - 58, 366, 10 After recital G 12 ENF - After recital L 1, Verts/ALE - original text + 411, 7, 15 : resolution (text as a whole) + 409, 19, 2 Motions for resolutions by political groups B8-0484/2018, S&D, EFDD B8-0485/2018 PPE B8-0487/2018 ECR B8-0489/2018 ALDE Requests for roll-call votes ENF: amendments 11, 13, 15, 16, 17, recital L : amendments 2, 3, 4, final vote P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 24 PE 629.327
Miscellaneous Pavel Poc and Maria Noichl (S&D Group) had also signed joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0484/2018. Isabella Adinolfi (EFDD Group) had also signed joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0484/2018. 14. 2018 UN Climate Change Conference in Katowice, Poland (COP24) Motion for a resolution: B8-0477/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Motion for a resolution B8-0477/2018 (ENVI committee) 6 original text split 3 + 9 2 ECR - 82, 329, 14 original text split 12 1 PPE + original text split 15 original text split 26 original text split 29 original text split 1/ + 341, 67, 14 2/ + 223, 169, 14 1 2 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 25 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 30 original text sep + 34 original text split 3/EV + 258, 125, 12 4 + 38 original text sep + 39 original text split 1/EV + 377, 23, 4 44 original text sep + 62 original text split 69 original text split 71 original text sep/ev - 192, 207, 4 Recital C original text split 3/EV + 223, 181, 3 Recital D original text split P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 26 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Recital R original text split 1/EV - 194, 203, 11 2/EV - 170, 232, 3 : resolution (text as a whole) EV + 239, 145, 23 Requests for separate votes PPE: 30, 71, recital R Verts/ALE: amendment 2, 9 : 38, 44 Requests for split votes PPE: 9 Stresses the importance of an ambitious climate policy for the EU to act as a credible and reliable partner globally, of maintaining the EU s global climate leadership, and of adherence to the Paris Agreement; welcomes the agreement by the European Parliament and the Council to raise the targets for renewables and energy efficiency to 32 % and 32.5 % respectively by 2030, which will result in GHG emission reductions of over 45 % by 2030; welcomes, therefore, the Commission s comments on updating the EU s NDC to take this higher ambition into account and increase its 2030 emissions reduction target; calls on the Commission to prepare, by the end of 2018, an ambitious mid-century zero emissions strategy for the EU, providing a cost-efficient pathway towards reaching the net-zero emissions goal adopted in the Paris Agreement and a net-zero carbon economy in the Union by 2050 at the latest, in line with a Union fair share of the remaining global carbon budget; supports an update of the Union s NDC with an economy-wide target of 55 % domestic GHG emission reductions by 2030 compared with 1990 levels; 69 Underlines the importance of climate-informed decision-making and of supporting this through the improvement of climate services of special relevance to developing countries; calls for this to be made a significant objective of EU-funded research and for strong EU efforts to facilitate technology transfer to developing countries; calls for a WTO declaration on intellectual property rights and climate change, comparable to that on the TRIPS agreement and public health adopted in Doha in 2001; ECR 6 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 27 PE 629.327
Text as a whole excluding the words: including the one submitted by the Union and its Member States and and update their NDCs by 2020 including the one submitted by the Union and its Member States Third part and update their NDCs by 2020 12 15 26 Insists that, in particular after President Trump s announcement, it is important to have appropriate provisions in place against carbon leakage; asks the Commission to examine the effectiveness and legality of additional measures to protect industries at risk of carbon leakage, for example a carbon border tax adjustment and consumption charge, in particular in respect of products coming from countries that do not fulfil their commitments under the Paris Agreement; Underlines that the pre-2020 implementation and ambition were a key point during the COP23 negotiations; welcomes the decision to hold two stocktaking exercises during the COPs in 2018 and 2019; calls on the Commission and the Member States to prepare contributions on emissions reductions up to 2020 to be presented at the pre-2020 stocktake at COP24; considers these as important steps towards the goal of increasing ambition for the post-2020 period by all Parties, and thus looks forward to the outcome of the first stocktaking exercise in Katowice, which should take the form of a COP Decision reconfirming the commitment to increase the ambition of the Parties 2030 NDCs by 2020 in order to align them with the long-term goals of the Paris Agreement; Text as a whole excluding the words: to mainstream the gender perspective into climate policies, and those words P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 28 PE 629.327
29 Stresses that the EU s budget should be consistent with its international commitments on sustainable development and with its mid- and long-term climate and energy targets, and should not be counterproductive to these targets or hamper their implementation; notes with concern that the target of 20 % of total EU spending dedicated to climate action is likely to be missed and calls therefore for corrective action; underlines further that climate and energy targets should be at the heart of the political discussions on the post-2020 Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) from the outset in order to ensure that the resources required to achieve them will be in place; recalls its position to increase current climate-related spending from 20 % to 30 % as soon as possible and at the latest by 2027; considers that all remaining MFF spending should be Paris-compliant and not counterproductive to climate efforts; 39 Regrets that transport is the only sector in which emissions have grown since 1990; stresses that this is not compatible with long-term sustainable development, which instead requires reductions in emissions from all sectors of society at a greater and faster rate; recalls that the transport sector will need to be fully decarbonised by 2050; 62 Recital R PPE, ECR: 34 Third part Fourth part Recital C Text as a whole excluding the word: environmentally those words whereas the technologies necessary for safe and efficient carbon capture and storage (CCS) remain unproven and, in particular, the geo-engineering involved in the creation of artificial carbon sinks is associated with risks of an unknown scale; whereas CCS cannot therefore be counted upon as part of any mitigation solution and should be prevented from clouding the urgency of radically stepping up climate action through the use of existing technologies and feasible changes in systems and lifestyles; Encourages the Commission to lay down concrete greenhouse gas emission reduction targets for 2050 for all sectors in its proposal for the EU long-term midcentury net-zero emission strategy, and to set out a clear path how to reach these targets, including concrete milestones for 2035, 2040 and 2045; calls on the Commission to include proposals on how to enhance removals by sinks in line with the Paris Agreement, so as to achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions within the EU by 2050 at the latest, and to go into negative emissions soon thereafter; calls for this strategy to ensure a fair distribution of effort between sectors, to include a mechanism to incorporate the results of the five-yearly global stocktake, and to take into account the findings of the upcoming IPCC Special Report, the recommendations and positions of the European Parliament, and the views of nonstate actors such as local and regional authorities, civil society and the private sector; whereas the commitments made so far by the signatories to the Paris Agreement will not be sufficient to achieve the common goal; P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 29 PE 629.327
Third part Recital D whereas the current Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) submitted by the EU and its Member States is also not in line with the goals set out in the Paris Agreement and needs therefore to be revised; whereas essential elements of EU legislation contributing to fulfilling the EU NDC, in particular the Renewable Energy Directive and the Energy Efficiency Directive, have been concluded with an increased level of ambition, bringing the EU to a GHG emissions reduction target of at least 45 % by 2030; whereas a 45 % reduction in the EU by 2030 does not yet make a sufficient contribution to attaining the goals of the Paris Agreement and the mid-century goal of net-zero emissions; 15. 14th meeting of the Convention on Biological Diversity (COP14) Motion for a resolution: B8-0478/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Motion for a resolution B8-0478/2018 (ENVI committee) After 7 1 Verts/ALE - 160, 223, 12 10 original text split 11 2 ALDE + Recital A original text split 2/EV + 228, 159, 1 2-3 + : resolution (text as a whole) + Requests for roll-call votes Verts/ALE: amendment 1 Requests for split votes PPE: 10 Text as a whole excluding the words: quantitative, measurable those words P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 30 PE 629.327
Recital A whereas the mission statement of the Strategic Plan for Biodiversity 2011-2020, adopted by the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) in 2010, is to take effective and urgent action to halt the loss of biodiversity (the extraordinary variety of ecosystems, species and genetic resources that surround us) much of which is a result of increasing intensity in agriculture and the sector s accompanying global over-reliance on genetically modified seeds and destructive pesticides Third part in order to ensure that by 2020 ecosystems are resilient and continue to provide essential services, thereby securing the planet s variety of life, and contributing to human well-being and poverty eradication; 16. Employment and social policies in the euro area Report: Krzysztof Hetman (A8-0329/2018) Subject /EV remarks : resolution (text as a whole) + 282, 71, 39 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 31 PE 629.327
17. The use of Facebook users data by Cambridge Analytica and the impact on data protection Motion for a resolution: B8-0480/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Motion for a resolution B8-0480/2018 (LIBE committee) 9 original text split 2/EV + 154, 154, 64 After 11 4 EFDD - 30, 320, 4 15 original text split 16 original text split 17 original text split 18 original text split 3/EV + 208, 119, 31 20 original text + amended orally 2 PPE 1 S&D 22 original text split P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 32 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 29 original text + 201, 150, 10 30 original text split 2/EV + 203, 148, 2 3 + 31 original text split 32 original text split 3 + After 32 3 ALDE + 35 original text sep + Recital G original text split Recital J original text split Recital AE original text split : resolution (text as a whole) + P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 33 PE 629.327
Requests for roll-call votes PPE: 29 EFDD: amendment 4 ECR 29 Requests for separate votes PPE: 29, 35 Requests for split votes PPE: 15 Stresses that social media platforms are not only passive platforms that simply group user-generated content, but highlights that technological developments have widened the scope and role of such companies by introducing algorithm-based advertising and content publication; concludes that this new role should be reflected in the regulatory field; 16 17 Third part 30 Third part Notes with regret that Facebook was not willing to send staff members with the appropriate technical qualifications and level of corporate responsibility to the hearings, and points out that such an approach is detrimental to the trust European citizens have in social platforms; regrets that Mark Zuckerberg did not wish to attend a public hearing with Members; Finds that Facebook not only breached the trust of EU citizens, but also EU law, and recalls that during the hearings, a Facebook representative confirmed that Facebook was aware that the terms and conditions of the This is your digital life application stated that the data the application collected could be sent to third parties; concludes that Facebook knowingly entered into a contract with an application developer that openly announced that they reserved the right to disclose personal data to third parties; concludes, furthermore, that Facebook is the controller of the personal data and is therefore legally responsible when entering into a contract with a processor that breaches EU data protection law; Notes that the misuse of personal data affects the fundamental rights of billions of people around the globe; considers that the GDPR and the e-privacy Directive provide the highest standards of protection; regrets that Facebook decided to move 1.5 billion non-eu users out of the reach of the protection of the GDPR and the e- Privacy Directive; questions the legality of such a move; urges all online platforms to apply the GDPR (and e-privacy) standards to all of their services, regardless of where they are offered, as a high standard of protection of personal data is increasingly seen as a major competitive advantage; 31 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 34 PE 629.327
32 Third part Recital G Recital J Recital AE Calls on the Commission to upgrade competition rules to reflect the digital reality and to look into the business model of social media platforms and their possible monopoly situation, taking due account of the fact that such a monopoly could be present as a result of the specificity of the brand and the quantity of personal data that is held rather than it being a traditional monopoly situation, and to take the necessary measures to remedy this; calls on the Commission to propose amendments to the European Electronic Communications Code that also require over-the-top communications providers to interconnect with others, in order to overcome the lock-in effect for their users; Requests that the European Parliament, the Commission, the Council and all other European Union institutions, agencies and bodies verify that the social media pages and the analytical and marketing tools used on their respective websites do not by any means put the personal data of citizens at risk; suggests that they evaluate their current communication policies from that perspective, which may result in them considering closing their Facebook accounts as a necessary condition of protecting the personal data of every individual contacting them; instructs its own communications department to strictly adhere to the EDPS Guidelines on the protection of personal data processed through web services provided by EU institutions; whereas the initial reaction by the companies concerned did not meet the expected standards and did not enable a full and independent investigation and audit by the authorities concerned either at national or European level; whereas Facebook refused to delegate staff members with the appropriate level of responsibility and in possession of the necessary technical expertise and knowledge requested by the Committee Chairs concerned, sending public policy team members to all three hearings instead; whereas the information provided by the Facebook representatives during the hearings lacked precision on the concrete and specific measures taken to ensure full compliance with EU data protection law and was of a more general nature; whereas algorithmic accountability and transparency is essential to ensure that individuals have proper information about and a clear understanding of the processing of their personal data; whereas it should mean implementing technical and operational measures that ensure transparency, and non-discrimination through automated decision-making, and that ban the calculating of probabilities of individual behaviour; whereas transparency should give individuals meaningful information about the logic involved, the significance and the envisaged consequences; whereas this should include information about the data used for training big data analytics and allow individuals to understand and monitor the decisions affecting them; ECR 9 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 35 PE 629.327
18 22 Believes that profiling for political and electoral purposes and profiling based on online behaviour that may reveal political preferences, such as interaction with political content, in so far as, pursuant to EU data protection law, it refers to political or philosophical opinions, should be prohibited, and is of the opinion that social media platforms should monitor and actively inform the authorities if such behaviour occurs; also believes that profiling based on other data, such as socio-economic or demographic factors, for political and electoral purposes, should be prohibited; calls on political parties and other actors involved in elections to refrain from using profiling for political and electoral purposes; calls on political parties to be transparent as to their use of online platforms and data; Takes note of the privacy improvements that Facebook has undertaken after the Facebook/Cambridge Analytica scandal, but recalls that Facebook promised to hold a full internal audit of which the European Parliament has not yet been informed, and recommends that Facebook make substantial modifications to its platform to ensure its compliance with EU data protection law; Calls on all online platforms to urgently roll out planned transparency features in relation to political advertising, which should include consultation and evaluation of these tools by national authorities in charge of electoral observation and control; insists that such political and electoral advertising should not be done on the basis of individual user profiles; Miscellaneous Claude Moraes moved an oral amendment to 20, which then read as follows: Highlights the urgency of countering any attempt to manipulate EU elections and of reinforcing rules applicable to online platforms regarding the disruption of advertising revenues of accounts and websites that spread disinformation; Welcomes the individual roadmaps setting out concrete actions to fight disinformation in all EU Member States which online platforms and the advertising industry presented to the Commission on 16 October 2018; urges online platforms to label content shared by bots by applying transparent rules, to speed up the removal of fake accounts, to comply with court orders to provide details of those creating illegal content, and to work with independent fact-checkers and academia to inform users about disinformation with significant reach and to offer corrections whenever available; 18. The killing of journalist Jamal Khashoggi in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul Motions for resolutions: B8-0498/2018, B8-0499/2018, B8-0500/2018, B8-0501/2018, B8-0503/2018, B8-0505/2018, B8-0508/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0498/2018 (PPE, S&D, ECR, ALDE,, EFDD) 11 original text + 291, 34, 19 14 original text + 242, 23, 78 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 36 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks : resolution (text as a whole) + 325, 1, 19 Motions for resolutions by political groups B8-0498/2018 S&D B8-0499/2018 ECR B8-0500/2018 Verts/ALE B8-0501/2018 B8-0503/2018 ALDE B8-0505/2018 EFDD B8-0508/2018 PPE Requests for roll-call votes : 14 ENF: 11 Verts/ALE: 14 and final vote PPE: final vote Requests for separate votes ECR 14 : 11 Miscellaneous Javier Couso Permuy ( Group) had also signed joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0498/2018. P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 37 PE 629.327
19. Situation in the Sea of Azov Motions for resolutions: B8-0493/2018, B8-0494/2018, B8-0495/2018, B8-0496/2018, B8-0497/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0493/2018 (PPE, S&D, ECR, ALDE, Verts/ALE) : resolution (text as a whole) + Motions for resolutions by political groups B8-0493/2018 PPE B8-0494/2018 Verts/ALE B8-0495/2018 S&D B8-0496/2018 ECR B8-0497/2018 ALDE 20. Situation in Venezuela Motions for resolutions: B8-0351/2018, B8-0502/2018, B8-0504/2018, B8-0506/2018, B8-0507/2018, B8-0509/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Joint motion for a resolution RC-B8-0351/2018 (PPE, ECR, ALDE) 6 original text + 183, 112, 19 Recital E original text sep + Recital M original text split 2/EV + 167, 131, 18 : resolution (text as a whole) + 268, 25, 26 Motions for resolutions by political groups B8-0351/2018 PPE P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 38 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author /EV remarks B8-0502/2018 S&D B8-0504/2018 ECR B8-0506/2018 ALDE B8-0507/2018 Verts/ALE B8-0509/2018 Requests for roll-call votes PPE: 6 and final vote : final vote S&D: 6 Requests for separate votes S&D: 6 Verts/ALE: Recital E Requests for split votes Verts/ALE: Recital M whereas two attempts to build a national dialogue between the government and the opposition facilitated by the Vatican and international mediators with a view to finding a way out of the crisis failed on account of the lack of seriousness of the Venezuelan authorities, who exclusively focused on trying to gain time and international recognition; Miscellaneous Neoklis Sylikiotis ( Group) had also signed motion for a resolution B8-0509/2018. 21. Promoting automatic mutual recognition of diplomas Motion for a resolution: B8-0492/2018 Subject Am No Author /EV remarks Motion for a resolution B8-0492/2018 (CULT committee) After 1 8 - After 2 9 - After 3 10 - After 4 11 - P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 39 PE 629.327
Subject Am No Author 6 original text split /EV remarks 7 3D ENF - 1/ + 282, 24, 1 2/ + 241, 51, 8 After recital A 1 ENF - 24, 274, 8 Recital C 2D ENF - After recital H 4-5 - 6-7 - : resolution (text as a whole) + Requests for roll-call votes ENF: amendment 1, 6 Requests for split votes ENF: 6 Text as a whole excluding the words: refugees and migrants those words 22. Deployment of infrastructure for alternative fuels in the European Union: time to act! Report: Ismail Ertug (A8-0297/2018) Subject /EV remarks : resolution (text as a whole) + 215, 47, 36 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 40 PE 629.327
23. Harnessing globalisation: trade aspects Report: Joachim Schuster (A8-0319/2018) Subject Am No Author /EV remarks 47 1 76+ MEPs - 134, 147, 7 : resolution (text as a whole) + 115, 42, 131 Requests for roll-call votes S&D: amendment 1 P8_PV(2018)10-25(VOT)_EN.docx 41 PE 629.327