Lowenberg v Krause 2015 NY Slip Op 31856(U) October 1, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /14 Judge: Donna M.

Similar documents
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/15/ :35 PM INDEX NO /2014 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 26 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/15/2015

Rodriguez v City of New York 2014 NY Slip Op 33650(U) October 16, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2011 Judge: Kathryn E.

Harding v Cowing 2015 NY Slip Op 30701(U) April 30, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /14 Judge: Donna M. Mills Cases posted

Paiba v FJC Sec., Inc NY Slip Op 30383(U) February 24, 2015 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Mary Ann Brigantti

Halvatzis v Jamaica Hosp. Med. Ctr NY Slip Op 30511(U) March 28, 2016 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: 7605/2014 Judge: Denis J.

Lonardo v Common Ground Community IV Hous. Dev. Fund Corp NY Slip Op 30086(U) January 10, 2019 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number:

Meier v Douglas Elliman Realty LLC 2013 NY Slip Op 33433(U) November 19, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /09 Judge: Paul

DeJesus v West Side Marquis LLC 2017 NY Slip Op 32364(U) November 13, 2017 Supreme Court, New York Docket Number: /2017 Judge: Erika M.

Sullivan v Warner Bros. Tel NY Slip Op 32620(U) October 17, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /12 Judge: Paul Wooten

Colorado v YMCA of Greater N.Y NY Slip Op 30987(U) May 10, 2017 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2014 Judge: Erika M.

S&H Nadlan, LLC v MLK Assoc. LLC 2016 NY Slip Op 30523(U) March 7, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2015 Judge: Donna M.

McCulloch Orthopedic Surgical Servs., PLLC v Group Health Ins. Inc. (GHI) (Patient R.F.) 2016 NY Slip Op 31061(U) June 8, 2016 Supreme Court, New

Cathy Daniels, Ltd. v Weingast 2017 NY Slip Op 30510(U) March 13, 2017 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2009 Judge: Robert R.

HSBC Bank USA v Brisk 2013 NY Slip Op 33501(U) December 31, 2013 Supreme Court, Kings County Docket Number: /09 Judge: Noach Dear Cases posted

Kahlon v Creative Pool and Spa Inc NY Slip Op 30075(U) January 6, 2014 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /12 Judge: Paul Wooten

Tillage Commodities Fund, L.P. v SS&C Tech., Inc NY Slip Op 32586(U) December 22, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number:

Briare Tile, Inc. v Town & Country Flooring, Inc NY Slip Op 31520(U) May 24, 2011 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2010

Meyers v Amano 2017 NY Slip Op 30858(U) April 17, 2017 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2010 Judge: Margaret A.

Empire, LLC v Armin A. Meizlik Co., Inc NY Slip Op 30012(U) January 4, 2019 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2017 Judge:

Onilude v City of New York 2015 NY Slip Op 32176(U) October 8, 2015 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: /2009 Judge: Wilma Guzman Cases

Roza 14W LLC v ATB Holding Co., LLC 2014 NY Slip Op 32162(U) August 6, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Ellen M.

Suazo v City of New York 2018 NY Slip Op 32869(U) September 28, 2018 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: /2015 Judge: Ernest F.

Tammany v Demetrius 2014 NY Slip Op 33513(U) June 3, 2014 Supreme Court, Rockland County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Margaret Garvey Cases

Graciano Corp. v Lanmark Group, Inc NY Slip Op 33388(U) December 28, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /14 Judge: Eileen

Guertler v Pursino 2013 NY Slip Op 31507(U) July 10, 2013 Sup Ct, Queens County Docket Number: 2926/2013 Judge: Orin R. Kitzes Republished from New

Perez v Refinery NYC Mgmt LLC 2018 NY Slip Op 32545(U) October 5, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2014 Judge: Nancy M.

New York City Tr. Auth. v 4761 Broadway Assoc., LLC 2017 NY Slip Op 32718(U) December 21, 2017 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number:

Ramirez v Genovese 2010 NY Slip Op 33926(U) October 15, 2010 Sup Ct, Westchester County Docket Number: 26231/08 Judge: Lester B. Adler Cases posted

M. Slavin & Sons, LTD v Penny Port, LLC 2013 NY Slip Op 32054(U) August 29, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2012 Judge:

310 W. 115 St. LLC v Greenpoint Mtge. Funding, Inc NY Slip Op 31644(U) August 27, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number:

Board of Directors of the 340 E. 93 St. Corp v Acevedo 2019 NY Slip Op 30023(U) January 4, 2019 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number:

Valenta v Spring St. Natural 2017 NY Slip Op 30589(U) March 27, 2017 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /14 Judge: Robert D.

Canon Fin. Servs., Inc. v Meyers Assoc., LP 2014 NY Slip Op 32519(U) September 26, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013

Fhima v Erensel 2018 NY Slip Op 32663(U) October 17, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2016 Judge: Debra A.

Parra v Trinity Church Corp NY Slip Op 34122(U) June 13, 2011 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /08 Judge: Doris Ling-Cohan Cases

Sengbusch v Les Bateaux De N.Y., Inc NY Slip Op 31983(U) July 11, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /12 Judge: Nancy M.

Progressive Specialty Ins. Co. v Lombardi 2013 NY Slip Op 32476(U) October 17, 2013 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: 22338/2012 Judge:

80P2L LLC v U.S. Bank Trust, N.A NY Slip Op 33339(U) December 20, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2015 Judge: Kathryn

Rothman v RNK Capital, LLC 2015 NY Slip Op 31640(U) August 26, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /15 Judge: Barbara Jaffe

Porto v Golden Seahorse LLC 2019 NY Slip Op 30014(U) January 2, 2019 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2015 Judge: Kathryn E.

Dearborn Inv., Inc. v Jamron 2014 NY Slip Op 30937(U) April 10, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /13 Judge: Joan A.

Time Warner Cable N.Y. City, LLC v Fidelity Invs. Inst.Servs. Co., Inc NY Slip Op 32860(U) October 31, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County

Stevenson v City of New York 2016 NY Slip Op 30674(U) March 8, 2016 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: /2010 Judge: Mary Ann Brigantti

Orloff v English 2016 NY Slip Op 31974(U) October 14, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /15 Judge: Nancy M.

Quinones v City of New York 2011 NY Slip Op 33846(U) July 6, 2011 Sup Ct, Bronx County Docket Number: 6924/2007 Judge: Nelida Malave-Gonzalez Cases

Pascarella v Zarrella 2010 NY Slip Op 30378(U) February 19, 2010 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /08 Judge: Doris Ling-Cohan

Greystone Bldg. & Dev. Corp. v Makro Gen. Contrs., Inc NY Slip Op 33172(U) December 4, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number:

Starlite Media LLC v Pope 2014 NY Slip Op 30984(U) April 11, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2010 Judge: Eileen Bransten

Jin Hai Liu v Forever Beauty Day Spa Inc NY Slip Op 32701(U) October 11, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2017 Judge:

Fayenson v Freidman 2010 NY Slip Op 30726(U) April 5, 2010 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2009 Judge: Paul Wooten Republished

VanHanehan v St. Thomas 2018 NY Slip Op 32971(U) November 30, 2018 Supreme Court, Wayne County Docket Number: Judge: John B.

Barak v Jaff 2013 NY Slip Op 32389(U) October 7, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /2011 Judge: Joan A. Madden Cases posted with a

Life Sourcing Co. Ltd. v Shoez, Inc NY Slip Op 33353(U) December 21, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2016 Judge:

Rosenthal v Quadriga Art, Inc NY Slip Op 33413(U) December 21, 2011 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2006 Judge: Barbara R.

DaSilva v Haks Engineers 2013 NY Slip Op 30217(U) January 29, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /11 Judge: Donna M.

Allaggio v City of New York 2014 NY Slip Op 32294(U) August 25, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Anil C.

Seitz v Mira Light. & Elec. Serv., Inc NY Slip Op 33631(U) June 13, 2011 Sup Ct, Suffolk County Docket Number: 33025/2009 Judge: William B.

Principis Capital LLC v B2 Hospitality Servs. LLC 2016 NY Slip Op 31132(U) June 15, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2012

Rodriguez v Judge 2014 NY Slip Op 30546(U) January 27, 2014 Sup Ct, Queens County Docket Number: /2011 Judge: Denis J. Butler Cases posted with

Verizon N.Y., Inc. v National Grid USA Serv. Co NY Slip Op 30088(U) January 8, 2019 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2014

Vera v Tishman Interiors Corp NY Slip Op 31724(U) September 16, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2015 Judge: Robert D.

Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v Barquero 2015 NY Slip Op 32417(U) December 14, 2015 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: /2014 Judge:

Brandenburg v St. Michael's Cemetery 2010 NY Slip Op 33996(U) April 12, 2010 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: Judge: Frederick

Aber v Ashkenazi 2016 NY Slip Op 30640(U) March 14, 2016 Supreme Court, Kings County Docket Number: /14 Judge: Johnny Lee Baynes Cases posted

Berihuete v 565 W. 139th St. L.P NY Slip Op 32129(U) August 27, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Kelly A.

Gliklad v Kessler 2016 NY Slip Op 31301(U) July 7, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2014 Judge: Anil C. Singh Cases posted

Howard v New York City Tr. Auth NY Slip Op 30876(U) February 28, 2017 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: 21344/14E Judge: Ben R.

Lopez v Royal Charter Props., Inc NY Slip Op 32146(U) October 21, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Cynthia

In Line One Corp. v Long Is. Indoor Lax League, Inc NY Slip Op 32141(U) July 8, 2010 Supreme Court, Suffolk County Docket Number:

Fifty E. Forty-Second Co. LLC v Ildiko Pekar Inc NY Slip Op 30164(U) January 16, 2019 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2017

Choi v Korowitz 2013 NY Slip Op 33944(U) August 15, 2013 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: /11 Judge: Bernice D. Siegal Cases posted

Halsey v Isidore 46 Realty Corp NY Slip Op 32411(U) November 24, 2015 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: /13 Judge: Janice A.

Safka Holdings, LLC v 220 W. 57th St. Ltd Partnership 2014 NY Slip Op 31224(U) May 5, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013

Page-Smith v Goumas 2019 NY Slip Op 30165(U) January 17, 2019 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2018 Judge: Adam Silvera Cases

Jurgens v Jallow 2018 NY Slip Op 32772(U) October 26, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Adam Silvera Cases posted

Tesoro v Metropolitan Swimming, Inc NY Slip Op 32769(U) October 25, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2017 Judge:

Fruchtman v Tishman Speyer Props NY Slip Op 30468(U) February 28, 2012 Sup Ct, NY County Docket Number: /10 Judge: Joan M.

American Express Bank, FSB v Knobel 2016 NY Slip Op 31774(U) September 23, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2014 Judge:

Doran v City of New York 2013 NY Slip Op 32858(U) March 21, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /2008 Judge: Manuel J.

PH-105 Realty Corp. v Elayaan 2017 NY Slip Op 30952(U) May 3, 2017 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2016 Judge: Gerald Lebovits

Lenihan v Solicito & Sons Contr. Corp NY Slip Op 32475(U) November 2, 2016 Supreme Court, Rockland County Docket Number: /2015 Judge:

Seleman v Barnes & Noble, Inc NY Slip Op 30319(U) February 11, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2011 Judge: Saliann

In House Constr. Servs., Inc. v Kaufman Org NY Slip Op 30772(U) June 7, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /05 Judge:

Karp v L'Oreal USA, Inc NY Slip Op 32048(U) July 16, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Doris Ling-Cohan

Out/Med Transcription Servs., Inc. v Breitner Transcription Servs., Inc NY Slip Op 30079(U) January 12, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County

Mack-Cali Realty Corp. v NGM Ins. Co NY Slip Op 33719(U) January 16, 2013 Sup Ct, Westchester County Docket Number: 50233/2012 Judge: Sam D.

Black Swan Consulting LLC v Featherstone Inv. Group 2015 NY Slip Op 30298(U) March 3, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2014

Allaire v Mover 2014 NY Slip Op 32507(U) September 29, 2014 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /09 Judge: Marcy S. Friedman Cases posted

221 E. 50th St. Owners, Inc. v Efficient Combustion & Cooling Corp NY Slip Op 33160(U) December 10, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket

Byrne v Etos LLC 2014 NY Slip Op 31713(U) July 2, 2014 Supeme Court, New York County Docket Number: Judge: George J. Silver Cases posted

Patapova v Duncan Interiors, Inc NY Slip Op 33013(U) November 27, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /2010 Judge: Joan A.

Cooper v Eli's Leasing, Inc NY Slip Op 33471(U) December 23, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2009 Judge: Arlene P.

K2 Promotions, LLC v New York Marine & Gen. Ins. Co NY Slip Op 31036(U) June 15, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /14

Fernandez v Ean Holdings, LLC 2014 NY Slip Op 33106(U) August 1, 2014 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: 6907/12 Judge: Darrell L.

Padilla v Skanska USA Bldg., Inc NY Slip Op 32536(U) July 23, 2015 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: Judge: Duane A.

Gotham Massage Therapy, P.C. v Allstate Ins. Co NY Slip Op 32140(U) October 13, 2017 Civil Court of the City of New York, Bronx County Docket

Baity v Burke 2019 NY Slip Op 30702(U) March 20, 2019 Supreme Court, Kings County Docket Number: /2017 Judge: Debra Silber Cases posted with a

Lopresti v Bamundo, Zwal & Schermerhorn, LLP 2010 NY Slip Op 33436(U) December 14, 2010 Sup Ct, NY County Docket Number: /09 Judge: Martin

Head v Emblem Health 2016 NY Slip Op 31887(U) October 4, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2014 Judge: Joan B.

Private Capital Funding Co., LLC v 513 Cent. Park LLC 2014 NY Slip Op 32004(U) July 29, 2014 Sup Ct, NY County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Anil

Transcription:

Lowenberg v Krause 2015 NY Slip Op 31856(U) October 1, 2015 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 158587/14 Judge: Donna M. Mills Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip Op 30001(U), are republished from various state and local government websites. These include the New York State Unified Court System's E-Courts Service, and the Bronx County Clerk's office. This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official publication.

[* 1] SUPREME COURT OF THE ST ATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK: IAS PART 58 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ )( TERRENCE LOWENBERG, - against- Plaintiff, Index No. 158587/14 STEVEN KRAUSE, FURKAN UZUNSAC sued incorrectly herein as MAHMET UZANCS, BENJAMIN KRAUSE and SANDRA KRAUSE, Defendants. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ )( DONNA MILLS, J.: Defendants Steven Krause, Benjamin Krause, and Sandra Krause (the Krauses) move for an order dismissing plaintiff Terrence Lowenburg's (plaintiff) claims for punitive damages. The Krauses do not set forth whether their motion is one based upon CPLR 3211 (failure to state a cause of action), or for summary judgment (no triable issue of material fact). Plaintiff cross-moves for an order: pursuant to CPLR 3124 compelling the Krauses to respond to plaintiffs outstanding demands for discovery and inspection and demand for an examination before trial, or, in the alternative; pursuant to CPLR 3101 precluding the Krauses from introducing into evidence any testimony and any items of discovery as set forth in the demands of plaintiff; pursuant to CPLR 3211 dismissing any and all counterclaims and cross claims and dismissing defenses; pursuant to CPLR 3126 prohibiting Krause from supporting or opposing designated claims or defenses; and precluding Krause from introducing into evidence any of the items of discovery as set forth in the demands for discovery. 1 /

[* 2] This is an action to recover damages for loss of consortium, and the injuries suffered by plaintiffs dog (loss of the left eye) when, in the course of being walked by a nonparty dog walker, plaintiffs dog was bitten by the Krause's dog. The Krause's dog was being walked by another dog walker, defendant Furkan Uzunsac. The complaint sets forth causes of action for strict liability (first, third, and fifth), and for punitive damages (second, fourth, and sixth). The third and fourth causes of action are against Furkan U zunsac, and are not a part of the motion. Therefore, the motion to dismiss concerns only the second and sixth causes of action against the Krauses for punitive damages. In support of their motion to dismiss the claims for punitive damages, the Krauses argue that a claim for punitive damages does not constitute a separate cause of action, and that there is no allegation that the Krauses acted intentionally so as to support a demand for punitive damages. In opposition to the motion to dismiss the punitive damages claims, plaintiff argues that the Krauses knew of their dog's prior attack on a child, and knew that their dog had a vicious propensity. On a motion to dismiss a complaint for legal insufficiency, the court accepts the facts alleged as true and determines simply whether the facts alleged fit within any cognizable legal theory (Mandarin Trading Ltd. v Wildenstein, 16 NY3d 173, 178 [2011]). The pleading is to be liberally construed, according the allegations the benefit of every possible favorable inference (Ovitz v Bloomberg L.P., 18 NY3d 753, 758 [2012]). "[T]he proponent of a summary judgment motion must make a prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, tendering sufficient evidence" to eliminate any 2

[* 3] material issue of fact from the case (Smalls vaji Indus., Inc., IO NY3d 733, 735 [2008] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]). The "[f]ailure to make such showing requires denial of the motion, regardless of the sufficiency of the opposing papers" (Winegrad v New York Univ. Med. Ctr., 64 NY2d 851, 853 [ 1985]). Once this showing has been made, however, the burden shifts to the party opposing the motion for summary judgment to produce evidentiary proof in admissible form sufficient to establish the existence of material issues of fact which require a trial of the action. "[M]ere conclusions, expressions of hope or unsubstantiated allegations or assertions are insufficient" for this purpose (Zuckerman v City of New York, 49 NY2d 557, 562 [1980]). "It is not the function of a court deciding a summary judgment motion to make credibility determinations or findings of fact, but rather to identify material triable issues of fact (or point to the lack thereof)" (Vega v Restani Constr. Corp., 18 NY3d 499, 505 [2012]). that: Conduct justifying an award of punitive damages must manifest: "spite or malice, or a fraudulent or evil motive on the part of the defendant, or such a conscious and deliberate disregard of the interests of others that the conduct may be called wilful or wanton" [internal quotation marks and citation omitted] (Dupree v Giug/iano, 20 NY3d 921, 924 [2012]). In Gamiel v Curtis. & Riess-Curtis, P. C., (16 AD3d 140 [1st Dept 2005]), the Court held "To sustain a claim for punitive damages in tort, one of the following must be shown: intentional or deliberate wrongdoing, aggravating or outrageous circumstances, a fraudulent or evil motive, or a conscious act that willfully and wantonly disregards the rights of another" The allegations in the second and sixth causes of action satisfy these criteria. Generally, the owner of a domestic animal who either knows, or should know that the animal has a vicious disposition or vicious propensity, is strictly liable for an injury caused by the animal (Petrone v 3

[* 4] Fernandez, 12 NY3d 546, 550 [2009]). Contrary to the Krauses' contention, in a dog-on-dog bite case, under appropriate circumstances, punitive damages are recoverable. For example, in Nardi v Gonzalez (165 Misc 2d 336 [Yonkers City Court 1995]), a dog named Ace, bit another dog. Punitive damages were found to be: "needed to deter other dog owners from failing to protect humans and other animals from vicious and dangerous dogs. Further, such damages will encourage defendant to take appropriate measures in the future to protect her neighbors from Ace or similar like minded dogs. The court awards plaintiffs punitive damages of $1,000." (id. at 340) Here, it cannot be said as a matter of law that a punitive damages claim is unwarranted. The complaint sets forth an allegation that includes a prior attack, and a proclivity to act in a way that puts others at risk of harm (Hodgson-Romain v Hunter, 72 AD3d 741, 741 [2d Dept 2010]). Plaintiffs allegations support a possible award of punitive damages. Although punitive damages do not constitute a separate cause of action (APS Food Systems, Inc. v Ward Foods, 70 AD2d 483 [l st Dept 1979]), the court will not dismiss the second and sixth causes of action. The allegations; accepted as true, accorded the benefit of every possible favorable inference, and evaluated only as to whether they fit within any cognizable legal theory, sufficiently state plaintiffs strict liability claims. "Whether to award punitive damages in a particular case, as well as the amount of such damages, if any, are primarily questions which reside in the sound discretion of the original trier of the facts" (Swersky v Dreyer & Traub, 219 AD2d 321, 328 [1st Dept 1996] [citations omitted]). Once the complaint is sustained as a strict liability complaint, I see no particular economy to anyone in considering whether the causes of action demanding punitive damages, based upon the same facts, are sufficient. 4

[* 5] On plaintiffs discovery cross motion, defendants have made a discovery response. Accordingly, it is ORDERED that the motion to dismiss is denied; and it is further ORDERED that the cross motion for discovery, is also denied; and it is further ORDERED that counsel are directed to appear for a status conference in Room 574 at 111 Centre St., on JkN. '6"frl., 20 lb, at ~.m. Dated: {() /, / r5 I I ENTER: OONNA ~~~ius... ~. 5