TEXT: Torts, Cases and Materials, Prosser, Wade and Schwartz, 13 th Edition, 2015, Foundation Press Torts Fall 2015 Professor Ray READING ASSIGNMENTS (Assignments include notes following cases) INTENTIONAL TORTS Introduction 1 4 Battery Cole v. Turner 31 Wallace v. Rosen 32 Fisher v. Carrousel 37 Talmage v. Smith 29 McGuire v. Almy 26 Garrat v. Dailey 17 Wagner v. State 20 Restatement 35 Assault I DE S v. W DE S 39 Western Union Tel. Co. v. Hill 39 Intentional Infliction of Mental Distress Slocum v. Food Fair 58 State Rubbish Coll. v. Siliznoff 53 Harris v. Jones 61 Taylor v. Vallelunga 69 False Imprisonment Casebook (5 cases) 42-53 Trespass to Land Casebook (3 cases) 72-79 Trespass to Chattels Casebook (2 cases) 79-86 Ranson v. Kitner 25 Conversion Casebook (text and 1 case) 86-96 Regular class attendance, preparation and participation are required. The right to adjust final examination grades for poor attendance, preparation or participation is reserved. Reading assignments include notes following assigned cases. For each class, please read and prepare to discuss six cases. For each class, you should read and prepare for discussion of six (6) cases. 1
PRIVILEGES Consent O Brien v. Cunard 97 Mohr v. Williams 100 Hackbart v. Cincinnati Bengals 98 DeMay v. Roberts 106 Hart v. Geysel 109, Note 8 Self Defense Casebook 110-113 Defense of Others Casebook 113 Defense of Property Katko v. Briney 114 Recovery of Property Hodgeden v. Hubbard 120 Bonkowski v. Arlan s 122 Necessity Surocco v. Geary 126 Vincent v. Lake Erie Transp. 129 Authority of Law Casebook 132-134 Discipline Casebook (text) 134-135 Justification Sindle v. NYC Transit Authority 135 NEGLIGENCE Introduction Hulle v. Orynge 4 Weaver v. Ward 5 Brown v. Kendall 6 Note 139-141 Lubitz v Wells 141 Gulf Refining v. Williams 144, Note 4 Pipher v. Parsell 144 U.S. v. Carroll Towing 151 Davison v. Snohomish County 149 2
NEGLIGENCE (cont d) Standard of Care Vaughn v. Menlove 155 Delair v. McAdoo 158 Trimarco v. Klein 161 Roberts v. State of Louisiana 169 Robinson v. Lindsay 172 Cohen v. Petty 9 Breunig v. Amer. Family Ins. 176 Standard of Care: Professionals Text (6 cases) 180-210 Categories of Negligence Note (skim) 211-214 Violation of Rule of Law Pokora v. Wabash Ry. 215 Violation of Statute Text (6 cases) 218-243 Failure to Act Text (5 cases) 437-457 PROOF OF NEGLIGENCE AND CAUSATION Circumstantial Evidence Text (6 cases) 243-250 Res lpsa Loquitur Byrne v. Boadle 251 Mc Dougald v. Perry 253 Larson v. St. Francis Hotel 260 Cruz v. Daimler Chrysler 262 James v. Wormuth 265 Sullivan v. Crabtree 268 Sine Qua Non Perkins v. Texas & N.O. Ry. 273 Proof of Causation Reynolds v. Texas & Pacific Ry. 277 Kramer Service v. Wilkins 282 Gentry v. Ranch 278 Herskovits v. Group Health 285 Daubert v. Merrell Dow 290 3
PROOF OF NEGLIGENCE AND CAUSATION (Cont d) Concurrent Causes Hill v. Edmonds 299 Anderson v. Minneapolis St. Paul R.R. 300 Liability Where Several Potential Tortfeasors Bierczynski v. Rogers 385 Summers v. Tice 295 Ybarra v. Spangard 267, note 1 Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories 297 PROXIMATE CAUSE Unforeseeable Consequences In Re Arbitration between Polemis, etc. 320 Overseas Tankship (UK), Ltd., etc. No. 1 323 Overseas Tankship, etc. No. 2 327 Palsgraf v. Long Island R.R. Co. 329 Ryan v. N.Y. Central R.R. 315 Bartolone v. Jeckovich 317 Yun v. Ford Motor Co. 339 Intervening Causes Text (4 cases) 344-366 Negligent Infliction of Mental Distress Text (2 cases) 469-484 Public Policy Text (2 cases) 366-383 Shifting Responsibility Note 383 4
DEFENSES Contributory Negligence Text (2 cases) 619-625 Comparative Negligence McIntyre v. Balentine 626 Coney v. J.L.G. Industries 388 Bartlett v. New Mexico Welding 390 Assumption of Risk Text (3 cases) 637-652 Statute of Limitations Text (1 case) 652-660 5
Class Guidelines 1. Please arrive in class on time to avoid disrupting classmates work and concentration. If you must be late, enter with as little disruption as possible and note your time of arrival on the attendance sheet when you sign it after class. If you need to leave the room during class for health or other reasons, you are welcome to return but, again, please do so as discreetly as possible. 2. Please do not bring food into the classroom. Some people have severe food allergies, including allergies to peanuts, so even eating a candy bar in the room could cause someone a problem. 3. Be prepared for each class, even at times when you have major assignments in other courses. You need to be prepared to get the most out of the class. I reserve the right to adjust grades downward for any student who is often not prepared. 4. I will circulate an attendance list each class. It is an Honor Code violation to sign in for a classmate. The American Bar Association s rules and our rules do not permit us to give you credit for the course if you miss more than 20% of classes. Save your absences for unpredictable things like family or personal illness, car trouble, traffic jams, etc. 5. Please take handwritten notes and do not use laptops in class (unless you have a problem requiring accommodation). Please turn off cell phones and refrain from smartphone and ipad use during class. Later in the semester, laptops may be permitted. 6